Karnataka High Court
The Branch Manager vs Samba Shiva on 31 May, 2010
Author: Mohan Shantanagoudar
Bench: Mohan Shantanagoudar
gamer E'? '§'§'§§« §§{'%§"§ i"fZ{§§.§§§' §§'
-§§§;'§,,%l 'Z 5?? §;;§§€€..§fi§.r'§§E:j~ ggfigfi *§i--§§ ":*?%§ my Egg? Z"-:TZ€}i:§"..§ j' §Ei~;§'{,?s?§§;
WE Efififiifi %§<.a;.§"§§$*°:'§::§ §§'?:§_fi§*§ §:{:.%2::%§;§,aé;:f;§:::--:§ég§ L. aw? §a*§2*§:~:3::§ %§{3§35§é_s:::;§ 2§:%.§3}%§§4.w*§'E}§<%::%'%' - * F} M' §E7-'§"§§§é§}§%:
Tim fizgfifiiz Eéfiazmgaagg &§§$;,§">E:::*e; Eigié $%%§f§..§;i"'%§'§$§§ , §§§.§§§§ 3%», '§":§&:'s.$§i §é:a:m$§:..?;:2:;%,$';§._ .V E§fifiE* §§$§a:sz'% . , "
§$;§'§§g$.3€.':%f§ am Eéi} :;1ai.%;%{"""?'.V__ » _ ¥§é;"'E'E'1'Z§§¥E;E §§i'§ s §%§:%%;, Z';??°$'r»~--
Egg ga??g;ar$§§: §a2.?*':4§;%sé§9r§:'s:.;§%%§§.s¢3__;§ . _' fifiéfi §§§":§%$§;%..§ 5S§§"<;::~. §g:§:fi?a§:%é§;::;;if&§§;a';**:$gg§:«:§ 42$ %'mm§ €§.§$ féfiafifig 3*? éC;f';§.$§9 3; 3}*%,§¥§§§;tg:.; '_ §*§ {%:§'s:g:*:3g{§;éfg i';§'§;;:m§§a§ §;'z*r:§:§ ' iZ§E§ ¥E::ggf§s§§3::a' Eiaiiig ' 'A§§a'.€:g&E;$:*§»~;-- 1:23; RE gafigasmfif Y ' = awit gfifiiiiiéiii :3 $55; mm? fiféégia 123% 3&5 '2:'.~2?";§f fim iaizfiifigziéfi 23%' Eiafiia §:>:*3.§?€mg fig §:,:5;$%: fiw §&s$@ {my '&m 33 fiéfiéfignaé Lafmgzr fifizgfi * _ §8£"2§&§¥}§'& gamfi 2{}fiZ}E§§§,€} Efiéiiifififfiififi? *'¥:§§s§ azzfi am.
N?
?§Ei$ '§%'i:3E:i§§:*: fig mmég at}; fa? §%§§.fi'§;"§.'£§§é?¥ E:$&,ri§*' e. fig ._ $33,353 gm iisszzri fiéfigiifi fizz: €%3:'§::%;-*§:%:w 'E%§;2 awmfi 3:' aka § .§:§§:Ziég::§§"§,a;%%m:? §.fr3,--.]~ §g§i§%'€.:y2;':%§' ii.-.%{1%iI§'?§ '$32: whifih 321$ :%?;;§§aa§s;:f: '%§.:;§& n *& :*e~éz"§'£ga%;é:% wézh cezzfinuitg 3%' gmécg gi§::3gg=:?;?%§:2°:V"'%:s§.r3:.§°:§§ wagag fmm €}§,§3;'§§;'%€f§€Z3? zifgéifg "§§;:£s§§,"{s;?§'js:>§".a*i§;«§2:§a¥a§§;%;&§,;:$z3.§'§ is qafiiéfizzaé £32 Efiiifi asgrzié; §@§%§i§z':;;' * 2% §§::w:_: if; .:Zr:§W §§f'{1§jEj3:{}-§3_gj:g* .. &z::2fi:3..%;...§::'%::fi;€{::;,_E:.?1é:.f%f':f%§§ §:fi?:2.%f1'fi$.$§":'§. Eg a Sfixzzfity
-._€:.:%:a§';;§_1?*$€:--§7:t:é'§'%-' Ea: is 22:2: 3 .- fifi Sfigszvgsfi azzaafi;
wiiézézz iéig fif Earazfifim fig} fif _..'f;;§:f;::% $§é;:'§'i;:;a':::===;;§__£a:% 3%? §3§'E@;§§§§iEE" rfifarrfi %;§',:+..Aa%.§:,.V*:?Z:2:: ;._V;;éT§§:'«;%.,:é§;2:3;:1*:f:;€;=T:": as Eééfi §'$$§'fifi§§fiE'T§E was iifiiilg '%.:1:ie §m%;§§ 3:=?$§$.%.?§;§:'%:g 2% 55-§.3$r'%:§§§;§:3 3%' afizzurvity, TE-Eiifig aé"é%:%:%§.,%*:g.. 31:11:32? fiifi Eiafmégz' §.ff:§:.1z*§. awimiié; 21:3': afié §:r.z%m m°3:£":°%:a:§.§:&a§ aha éfiézgg " ééfigmza.
'§"§'3§ fifiéffi $'é3f€;':3§f§3§.$$§€=§3 éfi 235;: agmgééfié. §:5$§3§? sf géatgmfizéi £25 agajaatimfi fifégé by 337% gzififiéafir 'mfam \f' 'shfi §g§3iX}?.;?§"' iizgzgfi. is; §:z§*::sé::£%€:{% 3%: éimaixigria =-~ 'E? 3% {Em mfiz giéfifiiz E2': aha ggzaiamgfii 5f §§;§§$°:i5:2§ Eéggfigamaz" E. %,% 325:: fifififi %i§;"Zi£§3'."%§. géiégfi ism? .. 5:;:;-- _ afieaiz fiat "iizg :*%§m3f3§az::i wag éaésrgg &1;%§'%2*f§«i?§$§§'V.V'?;i::'2A°.§{":*k§_ amé {Ema Egg 2% 3'€,E§}$i?§fi§§" £3': $33.3 f miigan fizz} iézé Esifiifiifififli :3? a'§7:_;§'a:f,:%:::f$:<2,V".§:"3§:§;'::::2§: §§aEf%a§..? €:::}'a:*: 3&3; fiéfi ;:_. &:§.&:*'é5.*'t= 332$' -gsfigééziéfififii as a fiéiléfifififi-§%%?;*s 11:'; a§§a:~$;3fié§ §§ any"
matfizfiaé mi; :?::<;:§::a:":§,. §a§€:Es%;:~*a:gE.§:_:*_;' °:*:a'§::m 22;? wgxfia azsfiéégzzsaés, 4}: V. V§_;°'u}§" '€§§E"'$§ Er; flag raggazsfifiézéifi §E§§§§"£,;::2;z:?§ is §_s::«:;m2sa 25: ihfi aa§'§§zr§;'ss5$i€::3'1:::s§ "a%:& ' }:*§§§::§;;{é?fi§£?:*;%§ En m:*§§:* 'Ea pmm fimt fize :**e$§::@:;1*z§m:%;' fig v°§"§'3;%'£ $3 fi%as2.*%mn.:, ?;§E€ Eséazzagsszffifizzt :_v'$'$é"3£%'%..Ei§;..i %m:§:%,:;1::é:i%.... 7&:f€';:*& iézé iaffiaégf ':3%':3i'i. ma :%::§;§g31%§§t:§V::3V_$§%.§;:;$;5" €333: 22% yaggsmfifimt vggg zamtfzgsiafi 523 §:2;é%¢§*Q§a;*;{;;°j§%' %¥;§~s3:rEai:;a;£:§; iimfé. firm i'%§3§i3.€§fii'i§ 'wag :1": E: 'hf?' away weii a-efiéafi fiat 3, " '§';;...,4if*é:2';§: aiaifig 3::
£32? amfkg Eézia éyssifiazimiig 4iTr'§"'7;if§V£"-..§."§"'&gfi§3:fi1'E. af flag aka siaag gamfi aéerisai ' ii: :§;z:§§;'§a:f§ §E$}§?"i Ea Ex Ezéaisfi; Eihsai Em 21.3 Ezmpéajgmi in V' sé $:;§>$:"~§;3:2:j$ $::§:§:2aa::é:§?; &'::::§§ «;<::é:*;e:*::§:%:%a%§jg; if §E?&f§§ zigzag fig $32' $§,a::"é£&E Eggizsgrag iiéw mam 53$: iimé §Qfi1*E%__ %:.:§x?::*=§%Z:%;@:*:§; {ézzéieg gm §.E§2:: s§2,:*:*ie§£ sixzci iswéiifizétaiig $'§ f--._ a gmsaii ;%Tm:::€i::::°: Q? 'gawk ézzazzg wiii 23$:
$§7.i3§%s:s§5§E':§:'?;§ $3 a Qéark 4:23' Yfif ::*E§f::?..§;:':" .; ~f§_:fi%'§_ m.z§&:"1§§§:z:*}* :ta%<::%§.:§ §%*E'%f§ {3} 3%: 2%§::_ ?§'¥§§:§"§§;§% ?§;§°'%§§:§'§ "§£%§§,%f'EET:% *:*§;4§;i"'%;§§:_"2§e§s;%€§g%;§§§%§;%§~v§;a%sé,:§g zbgaré :3 itiw :°:a::;;~=s sf .'s%é*:~:~s.:*§: lvagfiraixzsfizzéfsgzasé faaég 3;:'3;§; £Zf§E"{:1Z:fi'ES'§.&*£.:1€§f$, aha jiiéitififiéi in mmaiézflzifig §';2§"£:}§'&ET§i'_3§_Vi§ 3:; 25a? $3 §E$:','{%:':f:::§ 'i[é§Exa%i*§"' 5e::a:*:»TT£'§:§} ?:§'§:§ flair: {E25 :$=:.E::§:r V §1:;§;s::s;:§ %:§:§§<:: E',"'3fi€.T'§§§'f: 52:" :¥s:§§>§§ §a:%i:a.;a§j%; ;_?.':€3 .__t:..%3§ 'ffi-fiafifianz 2% Ex again §%§E2"& »=.I'4:¥§'.__$3§:§§3;fif £3 23.3%: §?:& i';.3f§:§L$i'§$; :23: 333533 flag " wxm:'=;2.3*é::__ $5 '§eé;"§:*%,7%.3§ an &:f§3.§§§§§%'E:£. %E1§%}w§:* my 3:33': am ~ '$§ZEz;§§§;§f§€::fi " 1 %E':a:'i 1%?'€§:"k§f$§.§'§, Lzfifiar 3:53'; 52% $25: A E}**;§§m'::es#5: $2? is; z'@g':,:§::%§ its fie V% ':%?§:%:__5:%:f;é:§§§a::15 €23 Eiig §%r§.:%'::€:é§:2§§ §""§§§é..f;:§f$ :25 fiiliififi 3.33% VA ~§%~.§§"m%7@31g.. Egg}: flgfififiiigfi Ea :3 'am éatarmézégé V' 'L5'?
wifia E"'§§§f$'§fE£Z;'i% is: ?§'*;s% ffiiiifi azzgiii ségsugagiaézwa is? ggagg magi maiarimig mg rgmzfi gmfi :2}: $5 mm: §w%$i%§fi éigasg' ~ " §E€:%§§:': mgr zaezrgii-=§&<:§g&§ ffifzzzziég. :ssE°:%£:E: fifijfi fiifié" £%;§°;.,:*é:fi gag ms the ffifié mgiurg fif Emizég gzaéifwmai E';ja;' &§3.§§$§;a?¢§:z 3?; $;§'f;;§ Z":%%§§ ms; ya éfisgg $§;é?;a*:1§:§§§;VV§&§é'§ E; "T:
3% &§g: t2§.r%§.E:i§: 23% §a3ii3:'_:é§:%m: A:§§ i;:':z gfiisiififi $33 2:13? §',s§:~§;a,aa E:3.a$ faéifié ifi fgmfizimv mime sf 'w-s;:;§'E§ sf ggagéziégiazzig 5 a?" $352 gfifiiiiiifiiifif -=- Eéazwgagzrgzgfa aafifgzgifii * V§*=:§%i%:: {:5 §:%:& V§;é§.I§m§ %*§§:*i*: gmiiiiefl {$213 agsfii {Em 3&2;-;:"a§ -V Sd/-
JUDGE