Karnataka High Court
Prasanna vs Karnataka Power Transmission Corp. ... on 3 April, 2012
Author: B.Manohar
Bench: B.Manohar
EEEGEE {E15 C§E{{'i7E3§'E' §%E§E'€CE'E ESE' f_§?E§LBA§?;CE:3% :::g3:§§:s "E'§§'iS TEE 3%} SE' ;:%Rm 2332 "
§§E;?@RE THE §§@:*~§"5m: :asiR§ {EEESEECE 7Z%LAE'$/§;5:E'>£S'§£;%;§§ ' V 'x?«.i:em' £>§§;':':@:%; N0$,8@é72§A8€}{$5§%'f_2%§3V_EE = E*§"%fEEN:
W ?:asa:3:2a, E3 5 {in ?§aiha,d:*__3L'€g 1}s7é?:jpAa;;::5;;af - .. Age 28 :a:"€E§E'S§§ @€<::Uz:erfi'§§::xj;<3:if';--.V } E?;,fo.H EEG, E EM£'2EjigE£%g §§'g%:§:E+;:3}::s:l<:%:a-:';~. " VV ;}az::a§a Csgieragz, _{;%;:.1'§3:fg2:§ ' - _' 7 Ar:/1 nkzgfiaag-é "S T , V'§%a.:£-Li; ' ' ' figé 2% jg-s3,rs:.., {§C€f.§{}§%i*{fl§§?3:;T§€§';: } R/' {In §;:§}'%i§" §Ea}75:;' V V ;§3'§0Ei §\§@2.E}§._ 'i{é;é:;%:::*:§._§'§«2:ga.:';'"T?§§€:>3.:"_' 223.2': '-E3/*;»:;*:E€;:>f;:>i5g.;«:(3::
{}':aj';3a:jg:5é §;m;f J '" ~;§:::VE§;§€:
' T 'S5 iT}<é::i€'§::%3V:z1§3E:}§:fe:i E V ?§;3:»§§:fz.:::":éi ;"€&g:;z:' §§i§§,, % §«:::--,:+:,'::gf::i:;.g:;, §a?:_:55é;'i%:2:'§'<'3§ Eimg E2322 2.
% : g: a;
'V §€2:éh'::£<:§*§3Er€:§a f§:e:?z:;::V§ia;§2:::;.5:j§22§> Eizgéiizzzrzg 2&3:
<:;~§:*i f'<«§§é%.§f£%,, T 'I%{%:';<:s.E:;:1:*%:% ?x?;::*s3::::i%§2: Se::§:@<>; _ ' W 58E3E& V. V§T>%$é:{3s:.A:Es:;;*::*g.i;§:2é.é N ,, yd §§;2;S2:w2a,:*;%;1 s;§:::;iZ§%:i:fz:3§"2:::ra§2a:§? as E'§C%E:«»§§"§é":?:§% E L figgé 38 Sits: Ej;3§::z§E@}?$d§ ESE}: E\E@.,{%§ Sr; S%:a::22.:§ 'L':«"£23;:";§%:§ ?:°;§:3i3ze €i.:é<>:::§,«: IQ?<%;:2{:»G: €:ui't»a:ga ~-- 585 ¢) §vE2::l§§§:a§§u12 =:>aS%:§Vapué:*ap§a Babkid, figgge 25%» '%,7€€tfE%,, §:3{fCZUfi€§':j{;§§€)'%,7§3C§§ E?f;;'s:>§Bab§g:d% At P{:2a::Sv}aa§j§ {B}, ?£;:{§}§Siii €}u'J::sa:'g'a~i%8§ 1232' T. :%E1V:'s»-'ash§a:: 3j0.{}iu:*u::ath BE:§'P:;;f§:%, :2? :»;€a3':«;, $::::%:§j:*z€::x;3Ee::s}f€§fz._ ' :+::;g;~2 §~;zg§"@~5$?x?::;_;=._ ' @ {§§pi§€'''~:'§ flsizapéea Dfivé E'€3§;;;/':::,_ Aézmé RG35? €}2::i§&rg?a~E?:;8_§ E11'? "' ;%2:fias'::§2a 5 <>3._;§a/§é;iELE:;z:';:i--a Saégéigi * 3% fgsafs, i"}.é::a':EV:{j';1€:*::;§:_§{3§i%3a:?".§ ' ' E3./::3.g§21m§g;a §§3}';., E:
'§ei:;: §>i&;s%::: ijigi-bgizfga ' 3 :2} €:2d%'21;*f{;€%:%:"é;§.3. X? :3; ;§?;':;:f::§:.i«§g;:E<;§;T{i§2a:*::§% 26 §;€'e:*:<;~:; {}:iéi:Ué::fi:i§;E{;§:e{i §:;,se,:;§ :;~;5;:>m: 12:9;
%?&:"2z'§g::§é'%3ié:--§%;§:2§9i, E'£s:w Eigaggéza:<J€::{E:";:
' mg ' - é €_3;;.'§E£?;§EE'2%:{'§ %§::§:2:§::£§ 532%? §€;g.i;.¢
-. , ' 'G ? §?€§«'?Ef§:;'_::{j{E$Z "2§§:£:§:::§Es;§;é3£%,. we _'§fE¥:3}§€"§/«:'§:§;§E?i ?§a;:s ?"%§{E;§f:i§g €Zi%:2::":§§:i2fi:2:%;:%t;;s: %§m;§;;:,§ ;.;E'%Ji€:'?:f§F§i §1¥::§§{2::}«2 xi} ~ 33::
Wm V..."339
H21:":§2":a::':E:§aj 3 f {>g:'%yaL::§:;:§ Agéj 2% ysafgg {}:::{'i:E§§€m§§@};e§1, %;'@,Nf:ay 8 Tfirézgéfi Eféghaararafigra, Eiézzzba §E§b§iS§:"é'{§?., E§7E§:}?3.§E Nagaiz, :'F>.':3a,§12::b:1:§; - T2289 '§'::;:€h§§;'*;:a§3u§ Eigi: €I3:£'b2zV:i;§21. SE:ara:1aba:~:~a.ppa. S;'Q.Ha:2mar:i;h§ Age 3% fgésasa O§:<::Uz1€:"::§E$j{s:§;, §{;'<:xP§{}: E\?<>, iii iiéaziésh Eéiéayew Ud23;}? ;§€warg§ Rsazi 'T ' C:::Ebarga~:'§E%i5 EG2;
Jzinzzrdhag; 3;'@,E§€e§a:af:é%';§aC»%§ ' giagé 28 §F€éiE'& €C'»{:Cii§::€::étf;:§;é>§;6é.fg-, j.
R/{LAE ?@s*{;:?er:::ha§aE;E§,§j?'{3§I:f?§ __ . '§'<1:€%1§?;:{?:§1@§: §;:g§:fi}a:§Qarg21V.{; §E:8«;'§;e>32LIi'i» §hi%;'9;.::5::1§. <ié;«§;:i:a jfipg sj ' 32 Ersgzysa, {I}? "°{§I::€§§:i§}':.{}:{é'{§';' 'E3./' ::m%: .§*<,;:9i£:§€.:§§E;:"@E2/ :f:?'€.;_:;s"'a§22z3£i E}is{.:G::ibam§§é:'-?e i§.8V:3.3€;?2Z'~..._ % S§%21:'a:33§e§Vsa7=a* 3 féi} 5 '::'§;.€§'::§Q:'{€;/\'i,f;%;:'?-;§é'€%.;,;( §':g3;::* BS jgsariz.' {;E$s:'i§::«:é:§:*:g3'E{3j;:3<,i Ea; ::;,?;?EsE2w2>;§:2:é;¢;?:V_ Eigm agé S"§'§§i S§§g3~:€,{3;»*n§%€a'§€ B:::z:i;::% ::§;g:g:E§;;§8é§ 2.2.2'); 'E'i§:§,£:r:g$2:gu:"
R :§E:.§:::?' ' {}gi;1:;_§2;€§';%:22:*%' jg Eiéghaiérzza §$V%sV%é:,E>g2::::§;.%,iVEi ,;%§;:%'3 €223? j%;;ié:3:';~:g €fE§:{::§§:@€:z:§;k>j;€§., L_ '-»»§€;a§~§" Ei:=:§;d§:: 3 'i'€§::'?~$E8$ ,. f €;a:'iE} ayga Gag;
' 'E/:.'f§_2ém*g;3;~:3%%5 /f ;W...:
mum} E53) N3 ymaaxk ' 'mmi ?*~§2E§£E;E"21j ;'a>f2E'::€§ug>aV%§§%:;s§§a E'*22'a%::2§gi, Age 2% }§€&§'S&, {}<:C:{§::€:§;§:%;@y€é§ 'E13,? {);§€§:':éEE;2; §:®§€}E}:./1 §:?€XE'8. §E§gQ%L%E"' '§'z:§:E€::1i::hz2:'. Efiégii: §§2;:§{i:h:,:?»:'§8aé EZES.
Eanmamhapgaé S;;§§.§'J1aE"i§'ia};'}?&9 28 jgeafra QCCZ§fi€§Ep§;®:g'1'3d; §?..;"<1K,PT€E. C=<::§@E:aj; Esfiayy Raadfi $h:2*gfg;:pp;':~S83 E21 Ahmad Efiagéaa 3 ?<>.i'€ade3s::E3 S;i>;_b;---._ Age 227 gsaara, ®e:§::Uf;€;n'§ie:;€§;.VV"'M §::§j!8§*§L2$%«Ei§fi§ A2aVm.§ S:;f;rg:;a Rz:::s;2z{§;~v.__ igiéizz, Riiuégezt "§'q:L§:1gs_u"§2;:".,_" ' §}is'{:R3;':::E:z::*--§8r§ 225; " ' L E'§€::§:}1:::a:é§ J :2, E$;E<.::..:::§$ S'§1a?;?a::a¢;%:«:%;»V:"}7:::
3% §;e33,zsj__Gcg Q§:;e:%:2§E~:>':;'e&'; §'{,s"<;:":U'?~ Vxffiaéfé, 'i_£E:<;}i3.: ?sf§s;::' %<Z;:dEagjL ?g:1;%§;:.<r§ :33 'fvE{>E:d;, :3;::i§<§;--i :;«._s;f.§} g '£i%;éax,;a§.aaa§%Q Eggs 3%} fgsazsg €}'$i::"§;?:":1€r:';;:i§;é_3_?€<i, R;%:s§~§ E'i§Q';»--?1:%~ 2 gzgéa ' Eff: éfimfiagaggv-."§':1§_ §?'§'ai:::_:3jj Eiiésé §~?i7."=2%;'<§,G§;£%;:2:"ga~§$§ T%§'2::;;;3::§ E axgézyifirzzzmé Eiaszziagfi if E. {}c:s:: §,}"?§3.€Ei"§§E€2fg'€§i:
={§%Z;":é.£S;'E'E?;"§ 58% iiygsgéa gag ghgihaiggsaeggg 229 M3 ~ Q?
Li:
53é}.§E'i{}S§CE sf@(S?§:iva:2:§;§2:pp3. Eiazgnzzgx jgsezra, ®<:<::E§:2é5::2g3éei2j}H:ei Eif {}.;'%'{L 9:35':/:Sa;:sV2:§g§ {BL 'i'{;:§}§5*i;:*$uib::1rg:jzz~58$ E82, Chaznd§ak.a:§éi 3;'C:.'"§uE:app;: §~§€s1:3§:;i;§ figii 22 }f§€if'S§ @C€j:{§E:€§n§E.G}?€d, E%;.,»":>=A: P@sT1:?§§ag0§ 'E'Qi:E}§:s::
Bizézssf - E83 4&3"
'§::';>iar::m§ s§k:2f*£€€:a§pa E®S':%f§€s!;?f"§i§ Exggs 2?} :J€£%§"S., C%::a::EJ§€m§':a}?€:%.;.VV §.;'@.A'§; ?a&;:i:E%§a§§@§* 33:3: §}é2»;é: " 8§da:°~58§ 4583? V __ Bagazvarag 3,5<>3\EarSapp;;_§§§_ne;':§g 25 :gfi'§3CfS§ Q::C.§J§2£:;§:i;:§Q§i§;:§, .
R ;' ::}}1£l_i ?r:2:§i[: §':§iEE2§ffi'3E§, '§g: E'}§£%f:: " V. "%'€§: E}i$%ii:.;E§§§_az:'» £383 '?;2{:%, V» "
§'iE:§'%3§§3{_E :5 ,5 €,>4;"§'>::E2*:"§:i;::;-_:;::iE/:-. Efiéigzéiéi, ' -,%?%;;'§:;;;.g3:;%:; E§i*::%S:,:E'i;;e:f: :A221:::i f§é'};g3f§f:§§;':"i?§2i§3§é3.., _ 7; § €}c§:::§j:*:_s3m§:£Vé:>;:é::'%g §5,;k>,':.'§>2é;:::§:aé:*' {§:f;{§<;:§:§2 Ei:,:§::23:2:E>;%aaii K §.éa::%;:m;3.b;2;§; §}i:~:~$;.:;%§§i%_&:<: PE"'§7'E'§'E§::$§EE%fS ..% ' «_ éizgééégaméig Mm 1 wt;
Kw 5",./'~39 Eiargaéaka 9% '§:";--m5;:::§s~;:e:@:':
{§<>:*;»:}:*ai3fe:: E;:£§.,i %§21:>€3;'3'_ §fr;:9;ax;2:3., §:éEs::g2:§<;:*€g by 333 Sezéeral Ekéaizageiz _ B:5az"2ga§::é:;€3--56§ $93 .
Ka§§§a':;aE<:a F::;w:5:* "§ra:::9m§s§:Z»@:: {iarperaéiafi Lid" ' Eiavsyi Bh§§.Vi'8;f}, Eéezsgzzéazeg bf): its A . VA Szzperiggéafiéing E:':;:.g§::c<::*;.. E gfikfiéliéfii Rag: CEECCES, ' VA Ba::§33£>§<.E~5§@ CHCEL GuE3ar§;: §§€Cf§f..f§{f"
;§}i§£e{:1'i<:s:' {QENE & Eigfiiéb A ?s.s€21;§:§ Z§"i<>;;':<*§';' '&§i5:>af;};e:»5'{f7,5'- §§}i% §3;;:1g;:E{}%<~7 €'i.§_*{/3,? Sziais;-~ L:
§:}§r§:S{:53§1';§}';'- E35:
""3;-:*«.!§§g E3}? 215%;
1"v§%.,f:éa;::4:~g3 Szzpgfiég {is}, i§:::E;.*/ E. , ' 1: S,%€j?}1i>'§E ER? 2%?/:3 E':/L¥5z§195'f::2é§ §}§§€{f'§éZ}§, . V ,. , V; E5 ..%:?:'%:§2::*:;.%,:§:{%; ,€s::'§"
'W x ;§é.:§;:Cég:
'= ' ';?:i:*a%:::%::s::
2
£5 5;' ' V (fir.
é:>§:é:;%i::;€::.*::<:y fez S'§;%£::ii€;?§E€§§§ V:v3:<:2 *> mi mééé. {:§'ii='3§ §e2?§"§3i;2:§y ;%€<:§'é:t23£j§ gzzgé Prizzitigai S§3<iiEi"'€f'§,$3d'fg'1 g'7:n€§g'y §@pa§*§,§::€%§':€.; {}0:?%; <3? E{ar:@a¥;aE»,«:;:; Efékaga Sezéfihzag >7 §2mg21E@§e« E 5 K64 'R;'%E:S?%3:\EE} .V ' {?'§§; 352:": R S ?22£:é§, Aiiwz far §§_EH R2 zmfi RLE Sm RE%£7§£E§if£i %€c:'§f5;: Ada»: €35 Rii $32 Gé_>u:z"is~3E2 S %{2:s;E.j;zm§a::: Adv: §«:>:f"§€5;;* . Efiziifiiéfiljjl/EEE S%8§§'i%§§fc3.§§ EECG? 3 WEE: §§':ii:e:>r:g am f':{€§ §~f!:éd€3§" :%.:*i:<1§<3:'~:'22,§E..;;:'3<§_V§2'.Z'? _ §"~ (:2? 31%;? Czszzsé/ii1:.§;i{§:: <35 Enfiéga psajgi 1 ' fig §Liéi?5g§\}"'§'§§_%? énzgéélggyaséaé 'E%j}j{,§§§{'iéEfi§{}%fi A:mé::<:L:f:'€:--E; Céaztxssd §J?.___2;:f3}'?:,_§; ?<:f&2:.:"i:':§_i'\F{}.E'*i:?'2?'1%"3E¥«E§_?'%§% / Wu 5 T 1€§f?962§2é'}{?§»E€3 :':a:&s::;€:<':£'__'b§«% :'§:s5j;g*{§;:<:5£Z-331:: §§e§§'2::?d§I:g 9533:
U: " % ' "
F"
§é:3eI:3a:":§ 933$ €*;<:m
5.73
€ {E3556
';E":":6:sa=: %.:fz*iI:/ §€€ff§§:::r:s éiézgéé:
C:::a;::'é_i :21:-gda 'aids §"<>§_§{t;x%g ' g@:Ra>.;E;1§' E2'; aifzfii--«§é%'§n:é<?;V:é:r§f iihéf: ;::<3*:i'i%e:ms:;~*::"e:a 223553 <7§i:2:i§,és::1Vé;j;i:2;T:
'ii 22:19 /§--"E€!:§§,'r§§'%é:L:E:'§;>§/g€:}VE:'§{ §:«2§,s:?<§ §j'§'§é zgsjsfzsé. 2;2;%*:2§:f2:éj;<i:;* Q? 331$: §3s%:,§*;,§e:::§":§::*se §3§":3Z;§ é;E':§% s:;:§ 4,, .;"é:§§;::§%53:V;Ea:2i's. 33:3 g::§{:::?i3--;éa:%§: :':'::%a<i<1% géféi"
"» 2"; / t.
W rm, X' if??? K "\4 §<3s?';i.Vé:;i§ A§:»;§§;':a:2% ";2:.:;.= "Eégés 5:-géméiggsf ':':::€/§'iTE.z'%.e€::s::':
athziéésifigsd if: 'K? :'a&§i§§§ 2:,:::di M gm LN' M ézééeaarsé ':?5§'i'£, g}<::§é;3k:>§;$ smzi igsgigézsaé 'fags ::m':<:%:zd€:§§ §'i?§i§fi{7§2§:"{§.{3I"ig. 'E'n@ <:%§<=::";»1i;§:?s:~ §3<>§é§::;:': <2? '%;:E3§u §::;»>:~es.~;a;%{i 2:': 'i;E=;s Said wzézi §::2<3":§§i::;:2ss is 222% 2/:.:":d6:': ' E} '%5J:::3:/ gaiiéisgas are haérfiby a1E{}f§y§§d¢ 3%} '§'h<:= §::':§u§;a<i;fi gmezzééfi E%§§:":§s><;:;§<3~L daééid 1'?,%8.2€}§.® §:~:£?%_s::1f:::V_7:>js,x* C§{,:_v;:E;«hefi[V 'i'§:€ Eifiggfzzéaaeng 32$ 3: $:1<><:%i_";;r§:3r §f,.{} ':33: a§::€?@dm€'::z§ fESEG§€§. " " " * "
EEK; E 23 éésziéiars :h;::__%'=§;ha *<i}:rfié;§E§:2:°§@ ':*:1<:=§§€:i<5 E'%*::>§n $3526 "§"€$'p€}':"id€fi§ §::5E:"§':i§--':_€=1-é:§*é"€§i;§§%;;§€ 3;/<> .:s§§§y £92' 23:16 §{}S'i sf .§;SS§i§:${EZi peg" 33:6: 2/:s;éé§i<::a'ai{:a:: $31.?-€{":.v.. E 2. 3:2 g. ;~<3;;:i:._::z3:%;2:.fé?%~E*vE;
WWW EX? 2%.: %':'-:39' f_---3f_£é';%_s:¢ :"9_,:;":";aE€ (7€iEE5§d2i§f3~E~Eé §'§§~v::23_§:.s9;'° am zzégw ;:2<::se%;<3::§s3i:'":_;*;--V.E; ' ' A ~2:;:%i:>§; :":":s:"-§;1<>:s's":55 ;§'§E%§3:§§€:§éi§}§i §,iE¥;*E§'§EaE'E 32:9 §}%i€i§:'- n:}__%i;§*fi:::;»z--:.,.%;:a:2;' 2,29 3 E , £1';r::3€:z:%,::*<3--§:/'1?
E? :'%::s;;2{§':':ai%';:§;%é*5,.§"--§§E:ézii 3 {§<:>:"§E§§€;%éa7::::i: :?'3::'f:§€><:2i:~:"€4i'z«"E '5::§:s:.;.:3%:%~~--"§ 3:"; {>25 _ 1" %;[s::{.§;:¢:;a §ji~§'§"§}§;§fi;E§I§{}§"EEé Esatsiéz §.E"{/fig A.:;ms/E; %ZiéE:'::éf:§<% étzzzfaééégzéiég 2 ' §;§€3fE"§;i§§€jE%.{E,€E:E§ Ex: figs: :2? §:s§§=;:§;:i¢a::% 1 " is}?
':%§§:Ei:::2$;zi.é:§é;[;; é%;:'§'i:E:: §:LEfi§"{} §§."{}"§'§E §E'§;€ ::i2>£;,::: =:':}§ 2':
:::»:f:°f%;;»2;{%';?:r': '{§.;;"§'E ' \ WM;
" 555:} "?%".E:€ ::::2m{i§::i_ is/as; :a%:s:: Ezavg 2駧%Ei€§}?' ' s 'X, azaié E §%{}§_~'£', a::>§ §%,s+;s:;:sé;,;::<:::V Eéifigségzzazz ::{:¢§ ;::g}é};
'SEE On recészigsi 9? 31:6 8:p§§iC8.'{iO:ES 33 siatfid absve the rsspafiésni ghafi Qaxigéégar 3.33; the a§§Eca_%ie::ag in ascezfiarzce with Ehfi Rsg:,§3.§i@::;§;e', ' ami Law gnd ssémplata 3:6 §;*{>€e$$ of seleaiécté,' Ggfisrgd aceardézigiy." L" '
2. TEE Adxrecais appsaning {gr .3}: ' éiiafi 3351,23 ixzérsévasé in ihess zazrii p&i§*:::;@:':._a:;~1:;--é Séziafié;-r .' E\E«3sj.25:'§9,%2{}E.'Z 8: Oihfif c0:2n$£:€l§§'i}§f;°i: §&ivf?fii:;::3 :'dé§$§:{>;3§«:%; off :33 232,216 E2 E3}; ihe Frégcépgé gasg zeimfiar 9365:: E3 visaxf Qf geiééisns are digpassé Crff in i:€§I*gf:Sg;a¥§..:hs::' /QGEE ané canizecied $%s'fiéV {:32 2E'x,252§'i2 quar3h§1:":g ihss §:k:;:i?I§ij;»ai§'s*:;:" -33' 331%: ;'~§::;':'3$:i'::re~E1, Eris isar:3€<'i~ SS-*»7s5':i::':,c,z'::é;;<2;,:'§'£?1€a£§€:' is pérmiiéed 3:: {$6 r::§:::':@ af ,2:%fp§e.t~1ra§:é1eA ._:%§*i€E1:%:é f€}U;§" xvseksg éifi 5% AV