Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Aditya Kumar vs M/O Finance on 11 October, 2019
) LV& .
igial).
< MA.859/2016 in QA. 7882016 Member (Administrat in O.R.210/00788/2016 roe MUMBAT.
Versus 4, MUMBAT BENCH, -
M.A. 8589/2016ry EY a CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, Dr. Bhagwan Saha Ravinder Kaur, Member (Gfud Aish Mix a Dated this Friday the 11° day of October, 2019 i By Advocate Shri Rajeev Kumar }.
Coram a yd a Sa tet aed ae) Lee 3 cd mM 4 Dek New 7% o£ ¢ 2 TCOGMNS A '. 2 ged iY 2 0 at g fra Wy Kao aNE $40 20> & fia FD C3 w. SE ts my oD iy ont wc * XY » 03 BoE Shetty }).
{ By Advocate Shri R.R. +e = OR 43 4 me. 4.
wy "3 bd & 44 a ft hd wy ge fe ia yn 8B 8 i 4 £3 Se @ Mw. yo My rt +4 M mt u fe ws i am ow ft ; *s i ved :
® et ;
; a G ml o 2 4 wy "s s es as te hed Ne "
"s ey ee ~ - oy ty S se BO is o et a % mx Es OG BK fea. Wg 8] . Re 3 a cp 4) ot ef wn ig G3 we ran fea 3 fs m we . ry «sed a3 -- * wed E> od + es mf red i 5 3 ary Dp to ~ Ss oH ky 5 "ed Aa as 1 eo cn : AQ os 183) o vm, Set ws si G a os vt ee ah co . © ¢ - WP he ron "ea G Si "fs 4 Qn) uy f 4 et Ne a ; ry . oe : © va os we YY i : we Cy ed re a ' Co vf G hy . hte MG ¥ x bet Boss a *4 wa orp 8 2 § @ mat i : A ms wee pe CD co ' . : tt " Mee ft 3 he } os 3 ca : Ba a im ey & oe iS ha 4 vu « te G w bs 3 a 8 & v 0 fos c 5 8 ¢ 8 8 8B 8 0S 2 3 a rel ri Nd , a te on ID 5 : £ } 'i : "GB F wee iy 4 yt 2 a4 iv 3 tt ws 5 + Hy , '<i as a Nt A 42 hy ra oy CG ap hed Pat ry ga "x * " ' . im Xs H ws ce " epee} a iy iD f aes rerg pe} an n ; +4 are} wy ww weed ao ua oO % ord wv 3 a OP 4 wi a ke ety ver} Ning i 3 CF 0, a veg a Cc Ba 3 z "1 et ' $ t apt pana} rio og Ms c oS we we , g ™ i 0 o ; a al a. a cs a Boy os y @ a ™ Ee ce : ref 8 td cy ; @ 44 v3 s Oo th B My > bi) @ 4 #4 ard 4A ved ex oO D C3 tet £3 o C Bp rh ao a a as os a2 * oe B us 'S - Gy AF ved G oi eg pe eS a x @ . 8 BO" 3 2 1.3 . es wl ey ae ~ 4 ced ial &s OO oo H d oS » § 8 A a GD o i oe oO g, Os we 44 t '4 a w ea < 43 54 3 vot o red } } ged Og % dob i bt Bs se} . rd D eg ¥ apd "3 $4 ha a) 4 re] % ke vt erst ie) ° to ws . we w 3 mn bas ce a 4 GC es ct 24 3 " 7 5 Cay 44 3 4 '6 Be te w © ® ht p t ; ; a £ ha ra hi 3 a s ft ' s 2g ng ; ca A 8 bs co] a " Und 4 2 9 ;
oa £3 . Ss " % a § G x f . 83 a "a8 ° GQ t 8 4 at ie ty ioe 40 vot @ ey bea al oi e 2 fF B @ 6 8 2 BE ais by ae 7 a g fas Bei Py On by o A ie GB +04 o ae, ye i "es red a " Fg 'a ot Me ved & * £4 3 Od a 4 . va 4 * ard oA 42 a o " Op t os i Gio a « WB 2B oo OB SG GC Sg Dt rm ul oD % ae ws BO os moo @ 8 © BM gg 2 6 U & it & x ce ded vg ed BS 3 "cl si es 43 > rt e a g ~ a Bo Se Es i O tome ae HS a wo i « 6 iG ¢ we OS a } ® tn 4 3% ai Bo & Th oO ed op & 2 ey 43 6 Bonk o a 6 8 # ' Oo me 7 OS es eo o Ho BO OG on my eg & Dp 5 GS ej 8 mw 1 oed ® w es w D ie 2 a Q 2 mf ih o 'e 4 z O ry ene, s ry ord 3 fet in ¥ = 4 { 54 ee. ao 4 GB oped u} " 44 wm Cy oS , ved w , "rt 4 : g - foot Uhl UOTE 4 a #8 rR Go td } ae a 2 O 8 i a os ved "a "a of roa 4 ee) th - Bf oe ; QO eo 3 oS 2 rd ¢ is C8 ef © wd 2 ws Do g © goo mt ou {6 ny.
Lat i M2016 in OA788/2 83 fA "
M £) is rd yd ty] iG hed rl m2 1h 2 :
i / M.A.2493 N ne 3 cA G3 ig an hy oe Ed 44 ae ti hed ty me Ls bad gties, ow od 4g Ks OF AS ia aD 4.3 4 ab?
any th . a bt ea, 8 a oa . re) be x a oS oe oP m re) a "rd es ios S eet & 0) @ Re se $4 43 o bf tO y eet c iD 2 A ra we ot 33) ts wy orf ord md i ta: Ma wy et 44 5x4 } oi peed a "8 ee , ' bed o oe mF Ba "er 4 of ccd © i i tS G t ry en CF t in .
£4 es ud qQ seh a fo See Gh «rf ey hg a es Q 43 asponse < an 4 * a vt Pod int 3 qh al v £3 iy w s a co) . ton Bt wD % ft 3 $3 i eg < ng ro Oo x ra $4 " so be @ Q C ts et wt ve Bn . 43 « gS QO o 2 a 44 8 5 Ea ft o oO . a arf mS D % A 43 a) "x eyed "ed vost aa 4 oy 2 ke at LA 4 63 ro . we oe 8 Oo re id n "s Meg .
Ge c eo fF ba & a + 5 a yD Sn 9 gy o S ® oo re "ed a mm oy 4 os a i y G @ 4 el ia ie ps ee " : O o 5 re) oo iG oe re} og "a 4, ted ty in Ad CF os mw a O 53 a 1 mh, 7 vt . sed is) " r > oo Sec a3 S a CF rref oy * 42 + bea ct - 10s x Oo Ly a Q % ' ao Ue MB 3 tis 4 on " a ey ee * 5 os . ad we yD my ' 5 ao sed "rk 'f w a a £3 Ms ff 2 cA 2 w qQ te in md } wo oS Q a 3 om ON bt A re p 4 wm 8 ee wea a Set & 4 2 bt ii 'G beg ji xed i 0 & 4 + "
ie oy " " "
sod ty A io Ad ts et Dy ved r & .
43 £e my a ae set 1s a < oy Bo BR ' 4 o & t ; rs , » £3 x 1S mm ¥ rs wh 4 yk tong 2, / Sos. ak . £3 eo 7 qa 3D ey iy : ue i w w i 6G 4 rt we 2 wh 3 i" "ye ny ie is a ae @ Md DB he kava cE ky 3 4 wo" o @ a w goo Bk M9 & = 4d my s xa hea pet > C4 Fa 9) 4.4 "2 ry Sf. wed eg ~ is an ons thd eo 4 t " peony 4 are§ Do we O * cd oe he bi uo ° Cd fe , "4 Mo "ng Cy 3 '. he 6h hee Be %, ed te tS 4 : Y ord 4 3 ot iD iL uy . a ven +4 as i re g i ci Xe va Ls 5 $4 yy . ' by a 43 . , is Ai wy Ls pa cS xo 6 4 ny y "rf 0 i 6 te bea e Cc 4 as a et OH 4b 'yt " BS op ~ bY 6 on 4 ke * oO 2
- cS t 4 . ef er $03 vf 4 wo ay roan) oy o oy ved ri iL? oS wo 4 w b.4 Ko . is V xed we ts sr Bw bt oget 43 B i "3 7 hs , CS) -
=a Ce "~ "at « t ae .
ta ie QS 3s ad at .
Ne beat aX bl ik oat Ser ele wr Me Q wt oe > a * iy yf gerd Mn . -
ee aed Es e x a we eae :
Be ene aa ' ak ye bel ee aw Ak tat ve o¥! Ye . an ot Ba he ' * es Red OR ~ 3 Oo wy G pp © e e a i = = 3 tt MR fn X. ae = 3 1 "a & 4 xX 2 ; er sy 4.3 ' * ; £ has ot co ry 4 a 4 4 oy Cy 1.3 a4 a n £) cs ae iss Ct oe aNg ce u y cod u 7 G aed C3 fH oo ean s aper:
s a b4 ® " "e rd 3 ' 43 ¢ er a _ 4A aH 6 Bs hy bt mS a & * j 3 ut a @ a 43 es 4 w , ' i" 63 $4 bay ' mS 44 Ma Ct @ " Qt Q 4 we E ved aed ' ve ° g Ww
-
oH , = aa & n Ce So a ay = .
.
RN ace r 3 Sete AE ee XY ct Sao a = + f us : $3 7 acd > 2 v : tm Gy end oy rat he = 5 oe a s 4 ™ Parms " sy ' ) 4h ee ae G UO ts . ut i a O ged ay eh bd f G "4 4 a 5 o wt 3 3 "od a we ri 2 14 a a XO Prt % @ O se Ty ® eo 6 4) 2 cu + iy x, 4 x et ek Pad ?
ke.
' ¢ thes La : : » bd n 3 i | ae nt 2 } - my 43 r The, A ATE MIN Bes ny le Xe at ae ehh nt x ~ OTE me Lf .
whe ~ Me ~ te ae a * Me ty ed ~ gh, Pg D> w ty beg et a a ?
xs @ ned a 4 g 3 r cS nt 5 6 5 r = 8 3 @ Se Ww x S NR.
HK oe a on YG oe te $4 & ot se} . i wl if jf .
2 $3 CG G 2 4 {) cs i i Oh a o 2) 1G ' mf 3 Q Rae 83 oO a its m3 D oO 3 q ha * Sa Sit ie ma ra ' eg w od & $a Q oy 4 ez ca he eg ait Be - Dy wo if = We wd vey ved ha rf Q $4 iS 43 i Fae ay ; z LG yb ee Me 6 ' ¢ ny ha " * Pe 4 ra 5 4 wy on & a a & , . i Oo is i a WA * ot 28 sf f H me w vl 54 = @ ce @ me * a , iy : we " oh te, - th, wy ct mo p21 / iy o™ : On '2 tf Hi a avd = @ y tt C a ba 7 6 i Se, Ds 45 % i AS Y AS ea, $ fa G6 : Ob ~ Ho 4 : MoD m ® rt So s G u " Ont acd ge 'a % @ @) : a y) o a4 ed ry -- tg > *e ' s oe ont 44 a ha + mS '¢ : cS ? or bi "wo mf ' oO is +} 4 ba o rf 0 ds a 3 wh Tg o 8 ne Bog i * GO wel oa 8 a m4 » © 68 % a, (one a) a ot | ee ee es & Boo Fb oY 3 « a st Ga if og 8 Qs dA ~ Bae HO 'be a Os G a cy ty e xy . a a j ts xt g y iD O & i a 4 % iP v @ "3 , @ 3 c is : th. o a . u if cd Ae * i { i o vi 3 cs @ © i } mG s . g & z me i y oO mc oS GO c a « « yet G By P i me * "4 on 0 a ved o bel ved i A + a i o a GO o up "ret KE i iD ne i ed , a * wl 13 ved nae > g ou 6 33 ies "FS x ond ms DP - G th ® ce a w 4s G KR ort m4 e 4 of im a 4% gt 9 a is c i 7s ret @ Co a " by, 2 vo wD f 3, - oe TS. t G om werd e cK of AS G& Ke * : ; Ly f3 « % a on G <2 5 EE Wi ; ti ft thes " 3 44 " a oo 43 CO: 4 & et o . " 5 +h veal wd a e * we o & G rt 4 gy ' oI o a a o 4 mw oO | m4 3 , in i ui o be Goo gy Be 5 mS eo 8 8 Sod Boo i a & EF 8 g 2 el me ret Sa get (3 vt ws rt c oS '4 bel i3 a he " ey Bo HM mo vel mR U " 43 i mn ch . « Oo Boe * id a a . g cs > g 4 a g 4 aD Py ad D & ws i = i ae @ ; £3 % a ay $f 4 a es My 40 4y O ved 43 oO & a ¥ ted g vet oy x ed a "e at es os wed Ch Go g , G we x 3 a a fa o> (c a s i es B 03 pe ' wm cd Ye CS os 43 be 4 s .
a1 £ A a) s me 3 An x 4 c wd "4 A : vot +e D 4, ey 5 @ 44 os 0 mv wy j ' a eet * " ct ras i $3 4D Ga > , 0 G os a wn c a ws " a G 8 8 8 of S te "ow & & egy 4 % So 3 & 6 ¢ * BS wif " ® So £ 8 | 8 a 8 ow Ce Ue UuM Be 3 i > © OO G sy g NN «e ® OG @ % iB t4 vet @ UG ' ° na in i . Aa " o g cc ww 14 : 44 oy Sed w rd : ; eg "ch rea} ~ @ @ . th * cy 4g 33 st % ved os oD a 4 3 o a 2 . 4 wr ny Be @ 4 qi ° " re wy mo ca An @ ot a os wy ved nd 3 a bea cs a Es a i ' "rf 3 al 4 a4 a Es 8 ae Pic i hy ct @ a mG Pm od Be, ey t " ® es 2 6 Yo om oA og Hy 4 a ig « ad he G 43 me G3 a i Sh | be . a 4 ie) mw "gee 4 40 " ig Cy aM re a ed 1 * wt w ne a a 1 G8 sD (oe 8 oF «a oe $$ Bb m tH 0 cmd SX a G t 5 tm wn a my & u ae ms db » £3 q Gu ft o 4 £3 " cm C w * % st aad obs 9 i a a] KB mR ts a g aa is & © rr > . . thet tf & Bd OQ "Bg ow Be 8 oot Com £ g ws s 4 B& EB % a sed ia i" a 6 3 5, C ard 4 vee wm a el m BC 6 Go B HOD 5 P «og 8 4 eo @ oR Gb ot @ a ti} wy 3 . .
5 gb & is OD x :
-- 2 a G « d fe O sr CG b4 oo < .s oi s i+ i ad bed i a £3 0 i) % roe a G Ch as wv 3 35 a 0 ne fe y ° " fs £3 me w us Go -
a9 "ef @ w i Aj re) ; a ie ces eed " ca C . % te ro os g a rea 6 £3 : iM 43 ja " ne Co i 3 #} C3 é 4 Y Y en ony . 5 cp ted bo 5 ge 4 35 a a "Ss aa ct 32 : Co z w + co a 6% é ot ( 4 a bra re) ' 2 O tt to, fy ce 2 3 "4 reed ra te oO MA te oO § Bs ih Bowe a . Cp gO ~ g t bby shes st i "en nt : cH 3 ib va 38) pet _ % 2 = ° rd i a} ® " a b © a 3 + es) B ° > "ee > a ins oe 4 head Sd 8 Me ibs a ct w eG oo 4 e syed Cs = rt md {3 " > yet G a 4 5 it ts et eho £ Kz "5 r * oe rod $4 ved a a) ° wed bes o ih, aA 43 ard A w% a ol a3 et u Sk at, GC 3 er ee KH om i} g ce ie a 4 A st a we RA a 4d "3 2 rod G e 2 : » os He © i me ha "4 fe Ss Ai a oi mAs ~ "a fae i oY ao) a ia mn ws be cf i 8 qe 8 = 2 © eo & 9 = ge ® Som oF gq = G me @ Bog ~ G g Do a gE
- " or * KG } & 3 o4 ry x3 x " 4 & co gO iy wy oe 8 - 4 Do 3 wd ws we a ad G bet 3 . 43 w Ba Th 4 3 3) et wed $d so 5 ae 13 :
. : x hy DY : 83 he a 4 4. $33 @ . £3, a * QD A a8) ' a ony ed 4 mi G eds bs Fea 6 i. tl 3 a 3 » 9 % ' * oe 0 OF is at id § JS . on ff iD td we id @ oy x oa se , PS Mp @ ty th owt @ 43 ford © ua o> if 74 us Eo? $4 a another State of Bihar and others Vs Ory, "
© wy "WO 3 a ted ae wy ved fe 'é ;
& ge 8 8 a g 8. ' » 2 2 mere o <p 9 Pe - @ voy of 5 ts vied Ci rh " "4 .. na ? tq os be
8) 7 Sy : o G Be oa ip Q & ful wy oe «Of o OC rd p 0 ; ' " ved od te gg QO cy 43 ti . ; hay . AS a DD c 4 ut 4 fet i oO oP Q ved - ao. 3B ° 44 44 G trol ' 5 a 5S or Gg Rm OG S$ g € & oy se : ew go te pa 4 gy Ad im et no . C3 by 4 in ity fe cs > A 5 it eg aed oe 1} wm - ae G od ved zi a CO pw & & Boe ~ 8 Tf RR a gO a 8 on +t 3 " , weed & o a Bi od a Be a ag Da son - 4d 4 od aw ae co $3 wt t ay) x . eed rhea ' gt seq et AS © 5 wd * 45 a fs a cd ~ 4 "3 ay Good cee 4g 0 © a sy 4 et f oo se] B C a ay iB on ' sed B C « oa eg wha at iy ' ee Cy "To 4 yet tr "4 4 'i 1 "i Q 4 = f° " Oo " - Oo 4 B 42 & pt ad f. : wd bean * " wy ww w = rs £4 if @ o =~ gy 8 x nM rt te :
g rm mh ro beg 2 Ds cs 4 cs is kK $4 ns uy oy 4 % red '4 o C Fa 4d iM mm 3 aa ny C} 2 4 o QO a od , @ of @ a vot Nn, ty oO "od a weed ~, : 3} ° < Shug :
»eibs sig Pl eb be bs o> he 28 2h 22 8 xt ° s Ne & 4 & oS od ry st , bd an sw oe 3 8 8 #€ & o 2 #8 os @ BS eR me OF me DB et Co el " 5 mow Oe Q 44 415 et $4 *v o . os gt ow Le] 0 fe wt "ef ~ Cc s ea 43 iget vas @ s 4 GQ w Led 4 ot o : ', $2 & i '
- wt see 999 5 3 ha 43 oy ot 43 4 QO we - w Ay os Be BZ -- 6 o 3 i co o " a i) . 3 fe 5 6 ® & © % ¢& Ge @ e Go * A OG £5 a Fat % O @ 43 j + 9 "S ord Ad i , . 3 c >
- a weet o, wt > cs a 3 rf 2 £ oO € Mm om REE EEL OED IES I Bn MO TC a @ a a 13 Gy 41 4+ Ga i 13 $3 Bea 4 is i ep a i wp Sa ba a AG ny AN ics) ay 2 ot vet ed B o 3 cw) he wd 43 srt 44 os As $e QD 42 cD o A 19 ved oe , a a ee ; oA . & sc i ee cS vd eA . bf oe and 4 Ld os os O ia a rs G So A ie re wh ia Ui A ral ry os rh ; B roa a 4 a i aa wy mS DB a , ee ve ey CG e pe O ss wel iS & 4 " $3 MM ved i o 5 id O i 4 a a ° » a Mi C : " or C a ' C a 3 os Ml 3 7 rho 5 God CO , i i i Bo u $3 O Ao i "A s "3 % oo oO cd ae @ 4 a re cc oO pa - re) "ct Qh rs eh yh EG Jk 5 ms a 6 . bd i Gs Ff i gs oe] a 2 eo 8 2 8 gp 2 b 4 & 8 f oS (Dp + " " 7 vA, " ; "Fe uy £ as om a a w) i v4 oi 3 a GS S a oy OG esd ri os te es nd on in Fa KS . te a L , 7 "4 a s a ie a Os , o iG i wy o yo fs 4 o Pn e ca oo rt ed Ww a4 sg." oy ra a} " > o $3 . " fa w Eas Oy af 43 G et, < . noe , + ta) we Sey 4 aS my ae Ge '4 * C im : a G om uw Py { a4 te : ved i A rat f oe = 2 a Mi ne md 4 ' 13 ap " & rr: fe ged yd wy Bw ae co é , i : £ _ : \ 3 . y Re "3 Oe te i » & 2 ¢@ BP? BF BE © i ° a 8 Ch co ry Pot we wert 2 va "4 thd C Gy t : 4d ot ) 2 oe a ga a s) o a « ne ray 3 £3 u + fra] es a Ged Q 0 a a ™ ae 2a e oe 4 54 om : " ci t~ ' " id th £2, ES G iG a " 1 & i HR Ct os ind mm a th} ' ot me fr a . 49 <> c i . vd @ o rat hoy qt a oh ied a wn " fh ig } a A ¥ 3. bd o a » Se a wt a ™ " i « eat i" a c. 8 a G 5 om eG, af & Ww ys . > ae w i a w ey ce 03 4 SO 4 i a c c Ww | 0 Ps od # a ~ oD y a " sh % ) "4 O a4 ©. 4 Ob MA gr ne . 3 ao zs Dh et 7 OS Oo 6 a He @ fs O a3 G 9 G "sh wy ve, cy il a » ord * O Cds we £ Be " fe ved ao 4 & x 5 o 'a ~ ie % $4 C O 4, wm ft 13 a ge i v4 os "* bd Sfed 0 oy | - , 6 Re Se 5 BR VF w = be % 4 " wi @ £ 4 ee 0 MoO yt 3b Bal om a G 1 @ € g & & a8 f p : 3 8 & ee © a NAR WA fe 8 om 7 w ' G mm 6 Bh 3 mort BR wD eB we & % , 8 © » @ % "tA od a © ao ® ne 6 . @° GG 8 Bg wy 8 go Soom Oe arf co 0 ty a oS rer} a _ : w : io a En - Gj bs ~ rh BED D> 8 6©PUmOUlUlU,lUB LUG 8 2 ra + Ad 5 Gg @ i xn a Sy at 8 a D5 , Ch et z Gt cm : 4 os + 3 ¢ oLy ey ae srt ved ws apd ts 43 ky :
L 4u a 1 & QO bg on 6. te rok MG BS {2 xt wt % 33 i Oy a ® ies) Os ys KS od iid 4 ce ook red ME ce . Oy m Do 5 a 8 io H i$] Wl g pe ih at 44 a es ig @ be he "S o Qy art 9
10.
£ ai.
£ Fooy A uy & i 3 4 ie 4a q os a 7g O a Get a a a 3 a sr & if G G ct Ke (a Ls g wy) ted Ma 2 3 Se 1 wy a % & od wt . a ord wD a 43 a wm 43 ve 43 rm cb KS a 43 4d et . re: Ea 4 rt hg = oe i a bey Q Re AG i > es > ras fon ved fea] "3 a G $4 x yp 43 43 rm a 3 ba en Ad "ed a3 @ . oS oO we 1 red "3 cs 3 - fl ate ae wD 3 fs aoe o ™ ci ce $3 4 @ Med a Q @ a oO 13 Aa iD on mS 35 o < boot 3 a i oO "3 as te oe ih i: eos i © o i rt 3h o by Bet QO Boy cs CO wy ot at O «@ 5 eh hd Woo te 3 i 4 ved i -e-d Uy et M w o 4d o o ? ad e ot 3 oe ved ~ "ay wd & a} sr er O 1D S o * x 0, wy es bg } ® 2 a i we Cla fe is a ved Ln Cy ord weet a fad bed * whet bet TP syed > na) ip oy ay a) Ud i 3 et iG b> t, £3, «4 i :
£8 fey DM ' Gy 4.3 pod . rs " ' . ~ 44 on rs 44 rh C ee Ch 4 x 1? a3 Set s td md gt 5 ryy " D ved pe ce iD * in rs x3 a iB et Cy @ a oD i a5 4 a Bo i A aH 5) cs @ x 5 C3 4 aD O wok . 7 43 iF geen 'y x iA 4 By gent $4 " a id Gy y @ -
ie re tM "a a ») C @ Gh tS oO ot BS i% 3 ras ced 13 ved i) tong Ba Fy Hed Cs ved na : * ny 8} a iB e vod hea Fs ? ¥ Cs 4 3 t 13 a oA 4 ms sie (5 nt n, w rf oF 4 ct ey a 3 * oY sg yy i GS rt he {i x on ce , . ee bad ES a Oo ' ae a * a3 a {6 a o fh . "4 ® iJ O rf ry ci a ey cc a "4 & ea '4 3 So Gf Oo @ ~~ " , 4 mo yt Bo ay w % is tt 4 4 nm tS om Q 4 yt 5 4 a Gs CO je gy '4 ry a e "
3 5 > <I wt os ' ya : bat , £ 7 ¢ .
oo" 5 4 @ 1 is a '4 orf ~ 33 eo oo.» % 3 a @ a ' yd x ee + ed 4 2 cH a m4 cs be I wet * CB @ om 7 "¢ tt Ad ae La * > : G 2 "4 % cy GS Oa Fh, hd is) 4 & ved o m i ' " 3 a @ @ / ai GQ so 8 vert Lj a Be . a4 o et 4 mt oe Bo : ad ce «a ud wv ; eS £3 3 wi oe we a * 3 a 44 o Th others Vs. K. Addanki Babu and others,
i) .
es o a . | 2 Qs a y o 4 "4 . wed : et : aw © Bm Gi 8 Sg Foy tO a 6 "3 5 ® 4 vo go Bo a we 3S ¢ cf a : td we GS mm © OG i a wo Ds gs e tied ns: B 3 @ 3 nts o » © 3 a. Gh 63 . wy "es he ' aS as tt] ah te 7 3 uy $3 be " of CG $c vt D a ' aa tH ie "a om Sm m& 6 wig 2 " ed sed @ Po ~ 8 g c $3 sed bd arf os <> _ ® a bs) @ - ceed my a orf ord hd is8) bed eB) pag ta ard G3 @ @ gh "4 cs ee ped bg w C "3 od * 3 dG 4A mm OQ dt 4 q PF aed o 43 G mt As o> BA "4 g sed bd z, ood Hea "4 v4 ae) 2) oo of 4 % 6 rd be a av ws od $4 - & ¥ ip iL . © ® " a o o th, b4 45 red w a ' 0 & ig ef o bi ae Ka roan a rs 4 oe, oJ c & Dp i v Dy i ra G4 vod 5 od £3 hs it QO os aay ts ot ef ~~ '3 wy uy v w ed QO wt ot ar ors ad @ oO '> " , S44 4 ag iQ 2 ns 4 St - a "rf om aH ae nek ns Ba t 4d. cP An a hi 4 43 4 " a uA 4 gt ved ts us perk a rm y 5 4 i sed $4 iB G a wr He ic 8 @ es Gt ~ 8 cS Se se @ OB QO UG 8 x be ot 4s o oh ? " Aa 3 ed "4 oS ke vel vd ® os LD ; :
a Qe wo rae . 3 4 T my RG yd & a 43 oa SB I ca "4 we ; 4 rae 54 Gd 9 La oy ~ 4 : Sag Oo a ng ty oy aa #B o 7% oS oo we 6 mi w ae wo a yd my tty wie oO cy wh Peet ved 55) : #5 be ~ o ve iG DF i a DD ' : ro a) CG ved hea bet 4 $4 Pe t a 4 NM @ 8 B $4 13 a 0D ry ot iy gs 44 % ; ' g © a a : ip © fer ae 4 od 43 Y a a C} ENS i AG eh, es $4 oO ic 5 42 js as ig Set is rr Y rot i nA - * w C3 os * oe ¢ sat :
Booty og e es & fs a ¢@ " § 8 & eo" 8 A . 3 a + or i a weer! oh ok, oy OU eo OC gi «a G @ eo os 4 iS wt Ea od tt on srt 4) tis x} i » sg ~ oats os > SY 'tas gO m ww 6 & fg a 2 . = Bow 8 4 j Ra eg ie ved ny 2, ce i. ' t wt a 42 fe yi i id Pe KR € rd y ww ee oF '3 fs Ae ss ne" i mn 4 a & Regs Beard » 4) ' tm g © ia wi oy Ay od 43 we ° oO ry a 3 é t ¢ 9: 3 a ) , aa o 5 : ts ce > Oy a 5 ft g3 i 4 QB 43 ord Ce eed . or " Pi fh * ca) a Me 4H ha "OG ed Ma 5 @ 43 A O; is Me "ed xe c i A u o 5 by 2 oy 8 6 & HB 8 4 ~ 3 S 8 & o a8 oy ; nh ey nd it & th 4 fad 6 wy > ie wy re a 3 o gs oD 9 G «ho , & , un eos Pa orf ed a d 5 a 3 , G Q 4] rt os G x . hed : % u3 i "4 o a ee . o et os Cy «bs + a @ ad ert wv o a v 44 "rf a] gy ss , vat 5 E uw a oe << a m a3 oi % wed we m . 3 U : he q) UF a tn * 6 2 eg 8 vo a ee es ° 6G BO OH gy Bg ' eh , Bo 4 ® SG «at 6 2 BBG ec » A a & he 4 4) ad GS 4 ne wd a fl 0 4 o a oA ae a a co f . rf is bo - ™ fe) baby Ge a ¢ oe r ved ry t a4 2 @ Oy { ~. a Oy eS % Qt o fs kag +3 _ og ne, ag Et orf on w ie Q wed wed im} ad we a 4 nae G ty.
et a ich ant f noo a E o, Net * we ; 0, a -
XS _ S -- wed iY C wo % 5 3 4 < qh Ad ue 5 % rs) ct is '2 se & cy et eG, a "Eat ro OM it & ay Q a eae ' q At oe eB v uy ort at Sed ® Go 4s ; cod o> ha Fs a rae a on iQ Pp A .
J $ Me?
tw "4 tr) ror) = ok "sf Cod Es 1} ob oe } hE ws " ad a uo . & "rt * & j Bi yd eo oe td g i a a a Q 6, Hea ) " is) Do ng 1s) ® hes Ba) = A ts iS O oe o et ed iss es x a 5 aSea n
4) & Energy and others a & & e Q a 2
14. W
-
C Yr ~ a rod Sed ip oh} ® so ' iu ; i ut wn im 4 ~ 4 43 K Q or an o 43 ' a tr i a o w O act M4 mt "s Oo Sy SA be 0 2 } GS of v4 Ss *~ oo) ea ' + ood Tt ay 14 4 . . vd a os " i ont > Cy 43 4 Q a & 3 MW 4 ' f- . , ae] wngt 4 L ws : 2 Go ee) © ss t > ib an gi 9 4 a 2 ae) o B is ba co ag n be ot od x ort g @ . 4 ost 1G or} if}. oy G 4 v st AJ oe . ip ca : z " $ oo : i 2 0 & w) 5 @ re 42. na 3 wel ih Q ey m 8 Gg 8 2 GB gs @ 3 a ~ oR mG 3 " Be 4 oi o SO @ O st oa we o ma M4 @ @ 4 oA 12 4 s Gh ha co x a "€ ms gi 2 g i 6] 0 'n c 2 Oo ne @ z ce ~ . hs Ke Dy 3 : " av " Aon ra) a & MG Ses BOD "3 f £24 eB BS at oy 4 rf) - os wg « 3s a i> a hy aS me ee i) Q 33 tt ef we B Be .
"y ne, yy ws 3 C mm 7 a be, 4 boy a 4 wry on Ad a a ua ° a es bea a o ~ ve ; 43 . % be . : v @ pe 4 ' a ms me eth a 6 ci i we wa al 3 By "e € ©@ 9 FG pp FG 4 ® Ooo 3 ch : BY oo fe + " a) £5 OM ie S$ gg 2 Ew . £€ & & og (8 ag CO BU fF oO a 18 ce x ss By a a) 4 iS w B "0 wel a %y © 4 ne , so " reed ffs ~. a "4 rt A s s * > TH aod Bo 8s * 4 : ¥ ok t "4 oe ' . io - : " id 4 3 gt ey ¥ ug at §4 q ; a ee! { 3 tad i Be 1G mn 3 f a ' , a uy . ia & i 4 ip et @ wd 4 Feed hy «gs w An rd ia '4 5 ££ o © @ mm 8 Bs BS mp Pp oe 2 my Bg me w 6 ef, « us : & bs i 's it Sa ha J : f Q wont @ CF " ea g Af "A be sed es coe} xed bed Sh
- : Co we . i * ~ 1 ~ we < . ed nd Vis sn Es reef C ri " Cs a a5 red fy, a @ o . ' ae: & 5 a 0 4 » 2 a 3 3 = a es Ae "3 o ged 3 oS "a i a as 2 B 3 O° 3 fog A > (OO ~ oy "rt 4 wg He Yow * iF ay : wry og P . Aad pat a a 8 in ze 4 ny she a3 $4 i G 6B ard @ 6 ; h @ rd ' i oO oO , 1g 6 bd 4 aed ct aa {3 4 oF sed 4 . | 4 ard 3 ast re9) tey wa [2 i? nd Q . td . -j go + % ar a ae Ba i "et o ip ms, - a sO QO ' « ' ty ve) red es i A = ay :
ie, fe Re 4&4 et of ay t3 3 $4 red 6 " A 3 42 o 3 . ; re C J 4 5 : +"
5 oF 8 Gg fF BM B 4 w(t ms «to CF ow «4 2 ot 4 ved < . -~ ict ct 4 reed ne ied set 3 bax ort } $5 0 ot ina But ied fy "4 t ef oUt 4 my wd O £ i am OD : mS a 44 S$ at ro OD iB ns M4 i oe m9 : wt of ony 5 5 ey dt $ {3 a iG co o ) o a ' Q wo r we xs 4. i . oat O m4 ls t Bp ie ord % ord 7 iS 44 Co ved au a3 rt u Le a iD 3 Cr vet Sa > "sd o bi 7 bed 9 ord £3 @ 43 ro wy Gg} on Py thi ord & % G, fa Ae! a 2 id "7 33 ey wh rca) ved ard wy. a 3 0, . UR G b tm © it ora rv REALS o at 2p ad ad a os / a Ch, 43 Ad ) @ ct Bb or} ky GS cot SAS "sy A on ' a Neda Le, a fe Se {1987} & 24 (2012) OL State ¥ Gupta Vs. Pp OA T8B/2016 FRE © 2016 és i é $8 414.8 t A i iy co A }
4) w "sed i Es et, "f en Et wy rt oa) ved x AG At ot ed iB we 33 ey a Gh {Dr . Bhagwan Sahai} Member {A}.
{we {Ravinder Kaur) Member 7} yt cay