Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Manoj Prabhakar Shinde vs M/O Defence on 7 November, 2019
i OA No. 764/2018, 2435/2019 to
2530/2019, 3235/2019, 8326/2019,
* 366/2019, 436/2019 to 439/2019,
4497/2019 to 4354/2019,
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
MUMBAI BENCH, MUMBAI
ORIGINAL APPLICATION Nos.
7164/2018, 2453/2019
246/2019, 247/2019, 248/2019, 249/2019,
250/2019, 323/2019, 326/2019, 366/2019,
436/2019, 437/2019, 438/2019, 439/2019,
449/2019, 450/2019, 451/2019, 452/2019,
453/2019, 454/2019
Bate of decision: O7,113.2013
CORAM:~ R. VIGAYRUMAR, MEMBER (A).
R.N. SINGH, MEMBER (0).
Mes. Punam Kumari
Ex-MTS, PA No. oS? 71-6,
widow of Late Rai Koshore
Singh, age-32 years, Occ, Service,
Presently residing at SMO P-134/3,
Air Force Station, Devlali Camp,
Nashik 422401, Mahareshtra.
, Applicant in OA No.764/2018,
Pandbarinath Sukd
ey Gawance
EX-MTS, PA No. 63767-B,
Son of Shri Gawands Sukdeo Kalu,
Age-44 years, Occ. Service, presently -
residing at H.No. 305, Shingwe
Bahula, Deviali Camp, Naskhik-42Z2401,
Maharashtra. |
Applicant in OA No.245/2019.
Santosh Digambar Kshirsagar
Eu-MTS, PA No. 6S7S8-A,
Son of Shri Digambar Kshirsagar,
Age-28 years, Occ.Service, presently
residing at A/6é, NE, Panchjyoti Society,
Deviali Gane Nashik-422401,
Maharashtr
3 OA No. 7864/2018, 2459/2019 to 7
2350/2019, 323/2019, 326/2019, '
366/2019, 436/2019 to 439/2019,
449/201 to 4584/2019,
.. Applicant in OA No.246/2019.
GQ)
gp
its
yp
rs
t4
ar
bey §
aa
583)
"wo
rey
a
cfr
Go
f--5
do
£4
"
it
Sq
tH
iy
ie
oe ry
Oo
oy
fas
mad
es
oy
}
}
wi Trambak Patole,
<
rm
wise 4
sha 4,
Age~ sears, Occ, Service
Presently residing at Village
Shingawe Bahula, Deviali Camp,
Nashil-422401,
Maharashtra.
.. Applicant in OA No.247/2019.
Shankar Bhagwan Pale
EX~MTD, PA No.45825-8, Son of
Shri Bhagwan K. Palde,
Age~40 vear Occ. Service,
resel Ld a
Ambad Ganvathan, Village-
PO-Lahavit, Na asnik-422502,
Maharashtra,
-» Applicant in OA No.248/2019.
Pravin Shivaii Gsawali
EX-MYs, PA No.63760-S, _
Son of Shir Shivaji Sawali,
Age 29 years, Occ. service,
Presently residing at jaily
Market, Shivaji Chowk, Lahavit,
Dist. Nashik-422502,
Maharashtra.
.. Applicant in OA No. 249/2019.
Vinod Kumar,
EX~-MTS (PH}, PA No. 63770-5,
eon of Shri Late Hazgari Lal,
Age~39 vears, Ccc.Service,
Resident of 145, Idra Colony,
Ratnada, AF Area, PO-Residency
Defence Lab, Dist-dJodhpur,
Rajasthan-S34ecil.
.. Applicant in OA No.250/2019.
Sachin Govind Adka
RAN < mr wo Ea " :
Ex-NTs, PA No, 63759-P,
OA No. 764/201 8, 2435/2019 to
-- £80/2019, 3235/2019, 3262019,
366/2019, 436/2019 to 4539/2019,
44/2019 to 4354/2019.
Son of Shri Gavind Adke,
Age-28 years, Occ, Service,
Presently residing at H. No.703,
Rarkhana Road, Post-Nanegaon,
Nashik-422502,
Maharashtra.
.» Applicant in OA No.323/2019.
Namdev Bhausaheb Jaras
Ex-Cook, PA No. 45824-N,
Son of Shri Bhausaheb Jaras,
Age028 years, Occ. Service,
Presentiy residing at H. N.1054
Lahavit, Malwadi, District-Nashik
422502, Maharashtra.
Yogesh Pand
... Applicant in OA No.326/2019.,
hurang Ch
o me
EX-MTS, PA No. 63764-L,
S/o Pandurang Chavanke,
Age-24 years, Occ. Service,
Presently residing at Village & BO
Shivade, Taluka-Sinnar, Mandir
Gali Nashik, Dist.Nashik-4225902,
Maharashtra
aS
'
©
1
ntiy x
PA
Shri
~ @
"h
Oo
i
Oo
©
i
ad
tH ow
©
fhe
@
cto
i OG fe
oD Set My
$b
th ho fe tm fd
MM
Mm }-
Manes
MANO
cate
EX-MTS,
3
present
Maruti Gali
District-Nashik-
jesh Bhikarl
No. 63
years,
Sy
resi
*
.. Applicant in GA No.366/2019.
cn be
b
j
Bhika
Occ.
esiding a
25 ED
Nashik-4
™
i.
Lahy
2019,
tt
;
~
45/2019 to
23/2019, 3526/2019,
2019 to 4309/2019,
z
4
ao
4992019 to 454)
OA No. 437/2019,
2019.3
(2019, 43
e
OA No. 764/2018,
S0F
6
2n
2
36
4
.« Applicant
oO a oO
ret wd rt
< a ©
™ mM Ol
Pn nm wn
<0 ra) oy
cy ow xf
"<i "ft 'sft
6 Oo Qo
a a wa
et eh a;
»
G 13 oO 6 o
Oy w Me
& mem & is thc §
4.3 "ot OG
43 a) Be (Fost 9 43
~ 3 te G BO th a
"G 6 Oo tH » ee rey el af) g « A
ng Le oe tr ha 163 SE ev} t wm bf end
* oO ord of rt 1 of = OF BP og | ~ ES Wb Lt
@ ~ OG re wm BO TS ct WEN fy St rf eo be as
ha mit Q, OOO NW -4t td Oy f 4 i hy } CR Fy ky
ow oy MOM OUP § Gp ie ei CO ED Dy pw oy OSS OO fy
~ T « Bs) ee a0 oo red ri NS eet an oy eh Sort
Pa EG rd hu Thy * WM 42 45 ty ba ey as) * Td TS 2d OO yd > "Oho 4.3
@ i OR om min. ' tt O ef $4 =f P ny cf oy cy . Mu £5 ad ie
beh TY (tf mye + oe hy a * serge s gy mm * es ft {
SO + OE 44 Gomer Gy CJ YO WW ary ae tg tp E
aot CF LY ct ry S$ O @ a bh Ay OO ed gy cep ag rE OM O
HO) GD ved aw ap OL. UF BEE ned UF apy ed et Se nt OE ® O ad
GIO HOH ty ay "4 DB tS QS m4 © B41 Dy ah £5 oy eg
» Mh "e$ 1G SP WS . G6 Om OO "MH i BM at 6 set
SO Ch. wy tn 4 OL OM on iM ord Of: om . a oct Sm ww
Th mM MO a + oO m4 Moog ahs } @ SF i + wy A De
Hort bd be og 43 ot 43 Oy Be be ay ~ G8 OF wow Go weed by Sy
Hel he @ mo Wo cpt 9 © Mo ah ky Wo hed eed eG ot bag
@ fa OG Sayeed ach a Kor CO WG a ST mre yD Coa te te OP gy Goi st ah mp,
Q Hb Pay eed 1 4 ct SP Mbyte Ut og a WO Ea kp a5 oe YE BQ ed
= 43 a Owe Dorf OB rh WH a a) we ow ay fe
350) 4408 Ge ok og Sty + by te st MON GO emery ad Mobb ed os
MH ON GD 0 sd 4y 4 OS OD SM a he <0 $4 ky wird OO GH
a f Wy ws ha oo AS UGA fb 6 ood oes Ch Png ered 4 ay AD fay ee
wot Se Oe A i MO 4d ry be oct OP em De oy id T4 op a
oO Or a wg OM GO Get ay ied OM OO 4 a4 Gg MA OA by
09 fa] 0 eG Os oy oy Wht Oi 3 O Bt oe Gh WO be Oy et Gl wo a 9,
.. Applicant in OA No.450/2019.
3 OA No. 764/2018, 2458/2019 to
SoU/20TS, 3235/2079, 3236/2019
| 366/2019, 4936/2019 to 430/2019
, 4490/2019 to 4354/2019.
Dinkar Ashok Patole
Ex-MTS, >A No. 63765
Son of Ashek KR PB
ve y
Ag
"
fa-Z6 years, Occ. Service,
esently residing at
oashingve, Post Shenit,
strict Nashik 422502,
faharashtra.
me SS rg et
foe
.. Applicant in OA No.451/2019.
Shubham Laxman Weghchaure
Ex-MTS, PA No. 63887-F,
Son of Shri Laxman Waghchure,
Age 22 years, Occ. Service,
presently residing at Qtr. No.
94/05, Driver Otr. 25 ED,
AF Station Devlali (Seuth},
Nashik 422 501,
Maharashtra.
.. Applicant in OA No. 452/2019.
Bhausaheb Kacharu Jundre
Rx-Fireman, BA No. 45826-A,
Son of Shri Kecharu dundre,
Age-38 years, Occ Farmer,
peresentiy residing at Shraddha
Apartment, Bshind Suman Hospital,
Jai Bhavani Read, Nashik,
Nistrict-Nashik 422401,
Maharashtra.
.. Applicant in OA No.453/2019.
ayur Subhash
Sonawane
Bx-MTS, PA No. 63757-S8,
Son of Shri Subhash Sonawane,
Age-24 years, Occ. Service,
Presently residign at 96,
Subhash Road, Bhagur,
Nashik 422502,
Maharashtra.
...Applicant in OA Ne. 454/2019.
(By Advocate Shri Yogendra Pratap Singh)
3
x
(201 9 to
2019, 3826/2019,
S6/2D19, 436/2019 to 4390/2019,
wy
xt
ra
8,
--
0
oy
ke
64
250/2019, 32:
ms
QANo,
20] 9.
za
en
as
x
sf
¢
S tod
cal
ma
e
449/201
RL
4.
?
ine-c
x
2
a
a
OUce
Lg
ryt
ee
gos
4
x
¢
x
OnmMa nd
ix
x
¢
Deviali
t
Lab
mh
3
Versus
-
he fF
OMMan
o
Newt
ou
we
Xe
R. VIGAYKUMAR, MEMBER {a}
in-e¢)
&
-&
"
ae
os
oan
*
*
5
3
ORDER (ORAL)
fA we Naw she ae Fic O .
Pex ee = Lpmant Depo o SAL 7 > 373 station, ote ~ Lnbenan Qo is ir fa ® HO Ber (By Advocate Shri R. R. Shetty} 63 sed SS td cs me is) sed end f;
kg Q oA $5 oS red ned the 6 "4 he fr bet cs act % sy}
19. } 2019, os i i 9 A 2 2019 to 4 y 2 y 6 019, 323/2019, 3246/2019, 43 :
ay 9, f 2 if 3 366
4) oa cr £5 TW hy Ke oD ws . d he i a omy) , , a rt @ ov mn mee y gl SB we Ee $3 fy Ry A a 3 ty a sw oF @ rs So ye 4 py @B y ce} t 4D G3 4.00 Een ce wm ¢ 0 Pay 4 < ad 33 2 : my nt foe f cot Ge A rpg Cy 43 Pat at 4 gen 1 eg { HO Ce ON Et GG 3 : my ey ok} Cb and 5 GY et ra Cy 4s uct Ec 42 @ ap xt oed Hr OSA Le he i bs ty ey tte TY «OP HE 43 seh od can "ch Ad oS Ee ay a A ci) a ® Oy m peel Oo 4 o Shes ra tn ol . ha a © eS Be 4 Bo SNe 2 Be Ho a $462 OO BS ' Ge et On dS 3 Pri Gm B @ A, oo : ed gh ws m4 z a BS 2,61 Uy ort op oy CL MG iy 3] Uy S » ae ty 3 Ma a . Cy & G3 att OG t Fog $3 ww fx, oo ey G4, O wm OY t ny OS ts, 3 hs te oe Bap gy # st os oS Go oom mM oS Gos DO & oe. €o "OR ge w ot om Hy BO ge Bc EN Qe HE GD gy ory tit, "ko ge tt 2 S « OH & 44 oo 4 ae hy OD ry Pa qa tt Nor} oS rt QO wm ga O oe ba te $a ty KS Boe Oo om 4 2 * o TS FE oy pa ky ag Dy W 43 py a oy O sa ES Big t. fey os on 2s 5 Sos Gog nel Rea g nS PES Bae Yay Bis a s @ ty Sh if ey, a ag TH ES EG A te 43 a fy me GF a tha a & 4G Pr age ms = 4 c iy 43 m5 o Qo © £3 ss Cy ay Gs a4 re Ay 2g o 3 ro a " a ot it a hy ' cc oY Bh Eid Oy Co G8 BP Bm em A a t~ Abs By % Up os ton Mort GH Sp ag he BP yy tag a G % t B me, Sey BO ty oy ty C3 Soy & i. us cs % cy Op ty cy Le) re ae & : ard . a OX ' GE w 7 4 : wy 3, 5 | So gene Ge PMT eB se 2" oo bo TA o Ue A Re g ei O, UN 43 -- 8g R&S ep BBP Ry "BEHESEAD "
es yo, 2 zy ay oe OS cee ao 6 fb oe et ang Ee OS gh OG 3 CO ge85 § BES™ oe HOE em iy Gs a rs St ay 8% Gos, "4 i 3 o ro thf 3 EP act "ss, SS #3 TA ny oy 4 Os vet e US Cp ty te myo ts ee 4 x to, Bry rg 8 oy De TH i, Bi an oy a ' a = watS the 4 BE LE, Ad ee ay sey 0 Xs ESE a Ak im) ' "ry es *¢ Soy 3 i A KE & & 4 & i 's ao 3 £3, 6 ° e @ ma 5 an Ba 3G ee «a try 4 % " W vt H G word 4 a ED Naot th On ep AD Og eS A Bay cy O ny #4 4 Ey A ny O ED Ay Pe A bp b Geprhe gop we oy «fh te wy e 3 4 fy HY oy ~ W kp a Pe ry s ro} gn ho. ky mote & 3 "et gal * ® 2 aod = ry i ay «© kp apt. of ty Ron, we ww ey g 4 wed @ Gam ts on ty cy MS oan se Oo - & , f 31 @ +t ow Oe Bas a Ge Beppe 8G rs a, a Ua et @ a 28 Oa Ye _ ge + en os on, a "eM ee NS , ee at " tea "4 *e Aga "4 ord @ a re} "a seh OND ED ey % &, Gy SED OE Oy ord % mn o% @ o 4.3 ts ce 9 ct re "DY. 4G ey ts wt a sed ret "a 2M MS beds ey Oo 3 Sf % Fe OO} Eb ay tA Ab eho my "ree Y ~, ; it . % 3 tt ? 3 by RY os x S q w f F ka t tw mt XS Ss He OD Oy "HO oO ON S aon eG ee ong HY ah oy Q " : os Sg ky as a % é. . a "yo Ee ; "5 ar: St ive 4 s i "ted 1B %. oor Ob. ry BA YY tf ' Ae bs Ot Bw ag To) Ob +ee Oe Ee Ss Grote ng oO G t C8 be EE ey op i EO e ey OS ay fey ue w ard "4 Go vr et O19-ta i f 2 245;
§ O18, 9 & OA No. 764 2S0/2019, 3232019, 326 2019, O19, 2 Zz O19 to 439/ 4492019 to 454, 2 7 4 x T3 O19, i oh tf my r| xed a ies 44 4 ay hy g ters S43 <3 Ls by ne fe j 3 ey he 43 o} 3 wo vied tf tt hes fet 1s bf ie GS red peng oof "rd wer G
i) @ Oo nd, ed O "4 5A > id oh, wo Ct a +f 3-3 "sd ot ea.
oO an eq net s term Ne ae ee fe @ £ § cy ita) ir .
wef a 43 O19, O19.
#2 "
?
2019, 2019 to 439/ fe :
O19 to 454, 2 , z ;
23/2019, 326 23 & 449, B4/207T8, 2459/2019 to *~ 3 Of W2019 & \ OAN 2 66/2019, 4 _% 2 Wipes © wy A © » a "fy DH ow Gk oD OG Uh mm © "Ot cf O Ba & OO tH OF g % @ Ay LT "ed 3 AE Des 4h oO act Gg ip TO ft Ebert ay Gh O OG ch OS) to a 3 4 m4 ay "ef rH & Wor 4s Ror a RY 4) ts S228 Qo Bd tg ors a» mt ms ses tH Uy 43) 4h Gi ty ge = Oo, 3 4 plo a mai a ea ont 1 8 me BS St & Bes 4 el ge ge ie) 4 } OM CES Uo Mom ® ef OQ bb DS House 34. al af Sh a) sao Bp pes h sg a a ® a ss » Bay AC) they 3 be LO' he GS, Ay Be ee @ co vd ans 4, Be HW gb oe BO BO Ew Big, 8 Meal & a oe a ® Pe a goth Tk guy he & ea Ss 8h oes os gs i ° mh ord ty & % owed meng 3 83 wf = "G rg 4 ot > 4 ba "rb _ €s 4B 2 a a ; & HIG a aw a 'a i Hg Gc a fe be "ef "4 al, aww Ss ky om 2 ~h ss fi ey ag RH og. Edy Aa Ey ery tot % f " a} aad % 4 "ow o "eh Se 46 By HE ty 2 +3 i gi = a 8 43 Sn ny oo mi i Sa Ge af" Gly, UB wpe o wry ae "CS a Oy Loot Eg gy BP oe Mee RG nape bz, tHe tal q v S9Gu5 So " a Stk CH bays Se 3 - ae j is + 4 S a3 a b a tt A Sy ay B, wy Bs ® bi lS G wm RE * re) " 4g ty % 4 ra Hl ig ss ' By ep "ef dah ry BS bap A ced mia 4H oo 4 E Dp st Gh ed OL mS) af BE gl 3 Gn @ cS do 3 POS Oc 4 2 "Be Wa' BP on gle ce A Ba | oe o Ts Ot aM oe 4rd 1. oe i ACE +t Bo, 4 re aie 5 t SMG Ops wpe 4 BS Sg 1 i iy a am ES ail ¢ oid ma Get es | a 4 by yy D ral kd Faye 4 ans: 5 4b oy % O} ua. 3 Gg As CBE eH OSE ES ty by A BOS A . © PE AY toy fs rol OS 2 TG e. gt E 4 Him oad feed cl a ol |S wl Gl wo & H HAG Oe tr B™ GR la & Sod oe ea CH rd ES PN iS) Wh AH ie BW Ho 8 eB es wy fel 0) ha of & te Bed td we) fa} Oy Bt OF Bi 43) 42 ty CG GS 4b ord hy » # y Raped ret Sa se EO i C3 Uy TH tet OL Git OG, 4 ky GW Go @ Ga w ' ro 2 + i . % om Pe OO by EY Mp ky Oh tal sop pe ay Cy ky --~ HOU Gem de OE & oO «sO 6 Pps 2) GO co ap gh OF eh @i co iy CH Ag Gy Oy GPG kp ay O £2 ow ey mG a eG ee oS es Woe Ie 2 aoe , : : 4 Pe Y 3 " . ' . a eg oe a Fipo> DL 8G OC Gh tap Ups pve» £4 Ey Ay "- Ty Hp Oo, om Fe Gm OD Re se bs Oa he Wy EO Crd in & O aed rd Q 4 2019, i i 4 3 O18, 2435/2019 to 2019 to 4 oe 4 wn {Se é 2
449. OA No. 764 19
uh ai 3 bea 1 .
uo 8 Oo « o & a oa cS Ty (3 a t "ig = eZ ye Oo TG Oa wg cua ¢ . \ . id te = rh fe ap geo cmy 6a g 3 Re nil pie SEER bas ty ky ce ey gy OG 0 Bb ed Wore 4d Ls 2 bs anion ce CE Bae wet OO EO GF Q@ gy 8 @ O hog a a UM 43 Oke rd tts hy a 43 o coat $4 6 wg $y th ws 4 o é & Si red 2 ee 8 Pty pe 03 ag Q ot Ww cpl oO CD as Goa sa mel A 2 OU © se eg wy BB Poy S85 A mt toy BG 4 by OT EE Cy GH a fg WE hg ? ae Le t iG 2 fet 2, a hg ong a rl ay eS me ; w oy o "4 " a 3g tied &., es , We Pan Rot. gk apy OF 83 Ca w i 8) a Ou "ey mr Our bbl 4 & G rue ae Te & BA EG fn cel oa PO Ss 6m" + eg Bp EF seg og Bs teh 7 rt Bo wy Boh e @ a) 5G OPO Leg al Hap wat SP ge Bo wg a G4, k a . 3 i] - ee a . um | uo) * m OL a n 'ct eG .G gy Sy % iy iL 5 Oo 1.3 S G5 "YAS BD gy @ Oe & Sy ie Bet od DO he By Ho * oN a 4 @ AE OG pi ON BI mee gy gy ORE ag Be 44 eri gg fo Fath wy ; ay & Bd ty as x, 4 a ak ads 5 is © cs Hoo, Bas od wo qo Om yw me og § eG 'i , « 2 4 * ' f ¢ 1 Me . oe js o ms one 2 " . ape Bese Sou" BR Uso Bea GY wet a, © SB 8 & yO oe by 4 oO ve uy ge 8 e 3-2: £3 tS RI FE wed 0 hg Etat eq C} £3 wt got as AL SS a ot ij ko Bi ny _ i 0 4 Ad ge 43 i ® 3 Aa & a é bu eg aPo GU | HAG oT 6G OE Ro BS tha ow & G6 « 8 G AE ~ A : 3" oy my DO oe t A : eet GR ay . * tao. » : * & > > 7 i SP aS sO wy te BB & EG gia <p 8 mo Ok G Boom OP ti Zp og G ® " 2 wg Fe py ie byt a ret if sot ¥ $3 gs 1H SS x my Gs rg CO BY AQ , @ ap g O ha G Ay N@ ee yt Poop Be Mls Gag 8 Hg Sw YO Be th a ne i x fa ty 4 4, 8 cs) a 6 te UG et wy 9 BS bas a 4 a } 23 tS os a ¥. , hot ae nd - . ie wet ray 7 i Me. M, es red Bog Ss se gm a i & Oy Bo Ago OG e ag mee n rei es " i wy ty @ a sry os eH Q 4.3 an 4a ay EP Oe 433 co w ' 63 2 w my ty Bae OY Q of SS gg ROE Bw oy Se a a ed " &% OF ovet 9 Hay i Bye ow OCG w ts a is > © ty OP" Ore Par g & fel yf oS dS we r "6 8 & i ae a = Gy eat ag OR Wo OO ty a 48 t Bet us a OG my a O | Hi ® Gm a o Fe OE RE org ie w @ 8 8 @ Rod ge «GB Bg BSS we Be Oo ey 7,8 6g a ok Bs ae gp Os te ts og 8 aq uy " Ao wy gS eS ada thcrt fe Cogs su B co} 0 45 4 uy G 4a OR OD OG neh CS bis * Bb a on i io u Qos &4 AS bd ond fet ay ve e 44 £5 4, mg ber. . a ' a A BI AD OF 0h 4D spd re ct Ay a my ee! ' mr ' . , hag el Nh Theag * my kT m HE tre 4 1 most vee one « = GO Ge ts OO "HE GH bay kOe 2B o, a e iy * 8 tos fe be 6 7 =<) ae . it ct ™, 4 af beg a . Dp > ord me q rel i = . ny J .
Joa oR S 3 & it € ' o @ os $4 cod ~ he by ha « Ad a) me add 8 ee Go @ Wd ne ey fh ty " + "4 cd ot wy t ag O ® a ae Ut 3 'Go v > @ 3 Began 8 ry Ge ne 3 es Me @ OS rd C 6 a w S GQ & 2 anes © SB J BY oS eo 8 =e Gl OS tt DR ES ocd > f 2 sel i i a =z + "2 3 0 3s 38 ae og my Ort gp 2 a o eG ® 4a Qe ee ¢ asa GCG 8 gH G on « 4 Soot yg os f& & , » ; 5 ea m As @ x " e 3 Gi XD co est eo os ns . y) Cr v om ie © a ty & £ fs é | i a " . ~ t a Lo x nd bad =r ! ¥ ee egk 5 " BH 8 @ GF 8 BF Se . @ & 8 og OO x é gf 2 @ Oe "gD , we ie . : $ r ean r yet ad ma vel ar 33 fe Oh eEaD 6 8 FS el OB orn QO 8 fi oo D> + ky t ord @ cd rs) 5 yet w O AS ce @ Q a be ~ oe a A a oO MN Boys GOB beg yo Oa EN SS tn 4 "4 Fed a ts go og Q 4 6 oo % eo ery cf} i C oO > y 3 wt % 34 aa! rm a "y a a ria3 q borq rt aH hy oy * A Bo 4 a y % a te : ry baa ; . ao "3 m of st rio gy oO f os Soy or oe ¢ Qe a mee « 3 ven ar 4 My 4 my ay " m $. a : 3 + it a ¥. £3 i OQ ie aN 4 $y . . @ a @ rg ff Ld G , oo £2 © i a i" S m 7g "4 as FA i 4 x ih ry yD w 4 ae) oS Fi ee a e i thf OWA S iB t) ~ is fe x gs % ret $4 ed ug a . ne moo \o C3, ~ G3 > & g + a3 4 Abed va tot 4 te n,, 5 4 OS ba : 3 3 ns Q ka 3 B 4 i QO s ¢ Py ot G ; @ te; o a ff a za % 5 4a Oo ¢ 6 3 oA ~ 4 wd ord MM e & GQ WM BO gq 8 8 Pp a a . o 6, G oo HG te Ss 8D 6 @6 3 S Ser bg ra) Ci *e a & 13 w 3 ve vo ny oe o as en) Ho 6) OU eto 0 6 a wa so fog he by O ao wy goo z os oO oo a oh 're cai a fa) ny ifs Mi a oO iy we 4 > be 43 ay fa : oe 4 © 3 si g ay 3 8 a i a at ve o 0 ae % mE i ni a g 2 3 ® es ag ' w 1 es o we "3 Fs SA a mn FD HB 8 OG wg GS Ss Be a a @ 4 ge F & a a ~ 5 sn ve RO & @ oO ¢@ OS - « eto a 8 v @ > « 7 ot a 8 so DB
- @ o i rh) G we e fs iy Ge ad os . ot Oy Che G+ ci oh a ai om i ' a i * Bo G a fon $4 by "Th ® ct aed a s Cr 3 Q 2S 8 a : | ox » - ey By) ved a 4 S g Boo i oh » & ££ @ B® 8 % @ YG » B yo ard 33 5 arg f wry 4 ~ ' i - tad he re) ' £ - bs oa oH ef a 4 ae 8 @ , ' rd © v @ : & oa "4 ay 9 C g @ al "5 A Gy my J By ms 6 fb bogs Bf om & i & oS BG op og UU Oe he BB » . ni ss a mn co 0 8 3 ris} 4d 45 mG wt @ > fly ae uM os ror rf vet OQ "et gn ha ie 4 ard ih nm wo eS ks r } ie he nO oF GR oS 8 2 © @ u % GO PY mM 4 Moog OO Y oS ° cs i a s Ld wy vel 8 @ et od "-- e @ eo & . ob Go ge es ee @ a paar ts eC ad ai . ved cm @ ved or is 8.4 44 a a ~ 4 eG eb Bm Hog OS 8 BH Ret & "
w "4 ia & 3 i) arf o @ M3 se} oe ont i % es we wd hi os « Q o " bead ns @ pd 3 oe we ee ved a Qa @ @ $4 $f by tT 4s © . Oe. @ Het & si u i ; ; na 3 De ke XG 3 & B wy . hy a Q ee OQ, ta A&G ey a 3 . t 4 rs os ha ra) Ss 43 be $4 44 w 0, cis} G Eo A its) o 43 O ond : "
A20F9.
a f2019, 326 O19 to 439/2019, § 18, 245/2019 te 3232019, O19 to 4 ZL i ae > 449;
Bei is :
by * 4 ot 3 io 2019, 4 366;
x 12 aw AS be id ¥ COU 0 £ s G g «sed B a seh ay nee SA RAL way te BU y nat ar ion :
wpe it} p $2, . -t » r et "ct . : pe + } Tey in oS se @ a$ Ae a ; net } 7 a a wy a wn ec 4 cs @ ' Y C o a @ BAK FT ee & SO 6S et @ GS 4 9 a 8 8 oy Amst FB "OD DO o @ UR 0 S i oO ms SS ' . Hi a ri ted GB os ag i" 4 oles a C aM # + sed Oo 4 ane o 8 @ Fa oR 3 w@ "t 4-4 iS 23 bg rd rn ce D C4 on Q as m ay oT 4 5 co AO Og 8 @ & oO on ® 2 a go of m% & "4 43 © ~ G ax ok a o " Gg oC of GS ve} re a) ie a oy & 0 iS SA a on 8 a 43 o | wh ed weed red . us ao = " ; ket ui gy 4d Sea 4 mH RE " 4 42 ong og, OB D e e @ Sg ofoas ek D a re ® @ @ @ fs a mo OD fs } SEA GE, ee es hy Oe aD i Q ty Rey be fe ord & Q FOSS Ly a3 4 ca O a mh bs i e 4 aR + oO "oS ue : ars: wen £0 of my B O, Sy Oo Toes % "rf mG wD Pra a ho a 4 a sore s c Sb-3 rye ~ j "eg ML * cid o 7 ORS ra] @ ty < hy G 3 in » , 4 ; $4 . O . | f - " ma eS wD a ah {) Get CO & SN & o ae ¥ 5» s B D " of w a 2 gy a w OS % iv ts, 4 at @ 54 . WS : ty te 4 23S 3 nr ar Bot > 3° ¢@ @ BR 8 2 a Bo a G TF, A ood GQ Oy os ced ws i a Fra © / AG ia o ¢ iS ce ip 43 ° ™ e 03 ol @ ted i iM oe ae & vet bet G 4 £3 ht 4 Fa 43 ved os be 4 st 1 ts, ord 4 a ba 5 &y wv ay $3 °y us ' "rd 3 ® o a) Ba "ee ed a cs 0 co ao ci a o Lh =e am § iy aS S44 ay & . wD ha a ae Ty Go 4 i ot & KS uy iS & 2 a: we 2 a " ms D ve} iv a 3 ot Be » F 4d 1 Sa : , 3 ( £3 = ¢ oe ro ¢ Ae ey 3 ced bs '4 D 3 pO, vei Sa Bi c a % os a gO root ay = "4 be a + ty * vet Qo fy * Me aw AQ vat y TS fa 6) vied a4 t oo Oo vet Sed peel 4 o AG 6 LE 4 or DQ ip reas yg am «S "§ " Ki 44 we wD is 43 Q ri in B 3 4 Bs wd 3 is) 1S at . sy or) oy in Cs bed et , a rad M4 oh Cj 3 «€ ww (ts xe is Pe re ort 0 we 44 bed @ 4 o re BY , 4 a ae io 4 Rat wy £3 a oY oof ah & / e 4 44 o re nas Gs 'th re es @ a 43 43 <a a i & G Gy ws + , G x 3 a or v4 aS '4 3 1 . MS LER a 2 & a 43 ra B © ® © G oo 43 mh do 8 To mw Hy " eoBo on Po. € eg ow 8 Boo os , oo 8 ex hed Ad 4 er i GQ $4 , re 5 y " xg wr @ tf ey rr re ws cet w Wo, G & B c @ wo m £ Ho Goo © £ , g 8 £ fy g o 6 i 3 hd 4 as ny 3 - = al rt sed ua a vite s " 4 of © 5 ra BM wg we «8 fy aan by Sm & wm -P , o rEg eo Fgh Hay OY oy 9] 44 , ic a AR i} a ak aed c " 34 7 m @ | © * , 8 43 + " ¢ © 'g BG So 4 QO © 6 th io 1 B wed a 44 a 44 ix Ww cant C eG 3 eC gs i a wD 4 hed it e 3 e to eS 0 43 B i © " $3 GS a3 i i 2 » ¢ + 3 set tf cS baz c S&S a go t & i 5 CK, w O © " w v eh . o (i 3 vt os Dp A w . uy i 5 a MSS My uM i ow @ i cot a es a mo i Ww sed oo Q 4 2 $4 be © ia os 4 es 65 b te so ed ved a es Sf OG 44 Dp ent wl "hag ih Ag oh ay eo) fs ord ort rt ~ u 45/2019 to > oF764/201 8, ¥ :
a OA so Ket DO uy 4 Oo a ag : ors e Qe es iv 44 BE G a a a os 1b DB Ci 3 ag} 4 iy 1 ty 0 4 "s seed aot aS vol w Ni O jy Lt Po oh B a a G ct "it a ce a ao o SS ogee Es g "4 a Ro ° a & a ee gs bed wee 'es ' a os w Lh weed 7 SR mo 6 Gs Q SG By a nm B - % a «@ is fd Sr ay Gg « 93 a 3 on ® Ms u OH Bo t ' € ' } po im 7 os bet <z
- 9 8 , : Peet yo o fF GS © 8 HF 8 « » wo -* ae = tt io on 4a Ws; e m4 Q a x i : 8 i @ aed on 4 w a3 a @ EG ' } @ 4 "ef Le kg a c wt oS % LE 'a a "4 44 St sy + th & 7 a @ "ed v6 $3 coat : i nt co @ are tc 4 ey ; 44 _ ts + B es Ck @ At 87 H 3 bo e ; @ S hag a ® i a ' is Z pM . ae o AS 's i" x "4 n ft "sed i o ey oN & 7 ad 8 wd % rd a we eS D 2} 2 S 0 3) 84 4] ee 2 2 B aog © BF SB mo Og as 8 © 2 6 & Ne "8 & eh gy on D i o = it oa % 8 3 3 & 0 mG Eg & of Po ey "4 yO 7, ot an eo 9 Ly . a * on At td y 4 a 7s ' o & i wy G 4 a v4 3 4 " ted = i 4 & re ; 4 S O o © wt * op 8 6 ia © @ Oo 4 8 2 oy i a a , "4 be a n , a £3 i a 4 @ (F5 u a @ wt u se 1 be Dp iB vt 7 ra aw o 3 af "s by . A bs "4 a ' "ee a tet pag +4 rhe uh wh ( ved reed 43 eo 8 on fy, ER ' 6, Bo og OB GO oo», Gof GE € 4 i O mat o * Cos 3 Ht a % i OM G a o 3 w ew tes ic " HS 13 s ; vd re 5 .
kee t gt BAL wm ate * rp " Ne: _ rf : i i ug wher A aed 3 qb tS at 4) 4 + 44 "2 43 5 by ry if ay wy y & 3 t w 5 "a u } y 3 iy iy od os G 3 4d Cc ay ri ce ay a a yi . ib } 4 x v t. " po 3. £5 : a Oo me SH Bm et G Hog @G #® &§ © uw @ Oo pb & ss eC 4 - 8 BB 8 8 DB oa 5 f # C J aod ~ or ; _ -? D> aed o t. ved § ' e wn a nS: ct 6 3 fa et t3 ot tpg > " 7 OQ G ' bet . sed 4 a arf ; on r 0h; 4 as + « © rh ee tf © me & m3 Bed in 8 : " no i i Bert eS -4 Ky a 4 ie a od 54 me a ® w ae 4 BO ® aan Hg 8 eG "go gh " f ve: oe be "544 sa ye : = . '5 t wy $4 . 3 w ; * "eh aw rt & mA Me a oF EB @ i eB w a Meg ae 4 4 iD ay ° £ ated ard tf 7 t ont ag r a " Poem rs o ape hd : 3 wed > a ra @ " ka % @ wo oe o @ 4 ' , Gs % rn ee * wea 7. ae x a a i O "+ bd iss " i oD w 3 x "
a Mo : R4 "GO B+ > % @ > & 2 os c og Mo ® so 3 g 8 FY g noo 8 6 9 8 Be a be 3 4 KS "4 ek v4 f ue i f i "4 Oo @ 8 mo B * 7 Db e¢ o &B FB mw 6 ££ @ @ B&B B @ G 8 Bog ' % p ha ® Ay O 4 a wD Mat C 4A C3 mh OG ' mi / oS bed " wa : tS ee "4 ' 4 i " iy " th w « ~ BD 82 om a 6 #2 Bo ep og ae 4 B if & Bb, oN & S us 44 a 3 ¢ 8 a AG Ee od a 4 44 ts ved 6 Q is Ad en} a rheg . y £ ot ¢ E 4 F§) 4 i a v} % 4 % C5 : og hi © x c o f Qt ¢ uy es "4 "4 . ae 4 +) @ mak € ka he be if &, a mS 42 a % cs : . "yf 4 r 3 "ed O Be 4 red rn ' Bp ttt rf nig oh a qi Oy, ch hing ce 3 a wy 8) oF > " i$] ' + , 2 ve 3 4.8 iB wy be im oa Be oS fF s a & £ 8S &@ &# m@ &@ & 68 a & © B BR _ & & . eo he fet Ot ie la a SB Be 4 ay 4.3 o hd 4) rd 26/2019, S/2019 to 5 ae 3 9, 436/2019 ta 439/2019, O19 to 4542019, Z. m~ ee i ' 449 2019, 3235/2019 1 i é 9 Q OA No. 764/201 8, 24 2 "y ij :
"366.
aed a4 At @ a %3 v bed * Q D> @ eo Cy Ad Le 7 @ Co i 7 BY fe 8 ae d he at cy .
aS 4 TSE Gg 5 ba G od cs a & Gs ~~ os by GQ 3 i go Ah ¥G Ct o ort 2 Ss wd 3 mi & z 44 arf wm wy $4 v4 3 i a ky o ay bg a ir a "% a : rg 5 2 » 8 go g 2 3 ;
eo @o & © BO fo . #2 © > 2 As (a o : @ OY in wh, . a 3 oe gM 3 . 'st Sy ft 2 i a o} in G 9 - " " fe "3 ny a My oe 4 2 os 8 3 a oO 3 35 4 © tt ® Qu if '"O & nie} L M4 a = orf i ; by GS "rd n a a ef y te a 54 ae) m 5 + : hs &i 4 % ;
i a 6 as wo Pr £t, $3 2 % oted o $B ; 4 Se 4 Bg a oe & » g © ws ore ard w . aie KS ba 4 sed ™ c Oo 3 ft th of 44 a 5B oS ; at "
4 my a a 4 w ad o y 8 a iG 42 £5 3 @ iD oO AS @ Be ond ws 43 as ct & 2 Oy, on z 3 ar a Oo "Y - & 43 44 # a ed G} Sy 9 rf " mh eG CG ct a ro he , a oe © 5, OU' a GG fy rt A Fa e t Js i © Bo bt et ay tt ee wp x " 3 uj t whed co Foe oy Bo. RY 8 Soe & - . f 3 4 e 4% 2 » @ 8 HR & eg a5 ae SF * SF oS Gp BS fe SS oo B gS ce H cred 5 e ty ed 43 ths . ri Qo w od " " mp "ef en 8 i ; 4 " uw a mn oo a seed 3 ve yard iy . n he a a vy a 1S S 2 mf eh ed $4 ai a © Bi et aE Ss "4 vor a 4 hed @ q CQ @) a O TH @ & & RR OM Mw Oo . :
"$ es x 2 ig a2 rd ed o $4 wy mG ' oy mr is) "4 1G 43 4a a ee G 4 nol oe SSS SATB BIBI aI HH Wt gg gaa de nee deed weneee eee .