Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

M/S United India Insurance Co Ltd vs Thimmaraju on 28 February, 2011

Bench: N.K.Patil, H.G.Ramesh

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE I3'2\"I7'£¥IIf} 'I'§ II-S '1'?----I E33 285" Ii)AY (,3? I"FI'§'%RlTl"5"*J'~{'r', 281 :PRESEN'1':

THE HON'13LE MR.J"(}S'I'ICE N.K.?A7§'§L     "' '

AND   ._

THE HoN'BLE__ MR.JU_sff:»cEvv:;.G.:§.A.m1;3s_;§:

M _ A";- 0. iE~€i£'i1;E3 : if {WC} 1% 1.u;c:c%:': :
M,' UI'1i{'€d _1.:1r;1.jV2*;:- .Ei'"1E§'1.£}'Ef§§1_;(f'7€ €'4\'T{',:}.;V'1":i,.a{§:4{flkgvi' B:7z.mc:h Oi:E{'i:(t€:V. M;éiaJ.";za£';(i.i ?.(':()14"114"*n":.,"V '

2 7"! Crc), 21 §.EV_L\2'2,i«3j:1";1 gs: F ".E%'}'3" -- }.%3r.>__c_;k. E3e11'1g£-§fI('>r€%--"E60 C) By its £11_1g._;;211t)f1:"'~§f{(%<3r1T;§{i--- _('}'ffi(',e, U11i.i:<-ad '§1:1c'i§..a }.1'1Ej5"i..}.vIfl'£xYj,€;'.(3%__ ('E0 Ltd ,. Sh a.1'1k211'i121r21y21i'} 21 }i31.'1.i E (i13'.;.'3 g , M.GfR0ad1 B21:1;;'z1ic;§:'c:~560 'C30 'E . V . --. Re'}31*€:s§s:%;';1t.é:r.i_ by its » Ef)'e':--p_1.: £33 M a.«I13 21$-21f.

('E-iv PLRé-1j:1., j5'xdx=-"0<:221E{*.} fkzédz .. "

~ .1 . V S53-xii. 'I'"E'1:mx':12-*:.1'a_j1.1.
'--»."%:'(:}. Sri. i"§E1§"§i1I}1Z£iE"2'{'.}'ZéR}'}§')£Tia ;3;§§:%<.§ :g1be::n.:£. 25 };{>2.;zz'%a E.{€?f€5i.{§§ n g at §S}":ia?:'21'1;-:;;;<-ms:.
CzhiE«;§»<;E*:':a§'1;~.1iEi E"'<':»s'~;i'., .¢..A:;31;)(?11z:1§.i.
§\>)i5§%§'/ at S . ' $S'L.1}T)Sf'.E1}'1i'§E153 iher. saaici s:;'L:b:'11issic>n, he Ems 'i':-aimn us t.Z}}.I'{Z3i,.1§§}'1 the r:-i-:vidcn(;%<=: <5)? ihqr E.)<><~.t;:>1' MPWSZ, zzmd Sm-E;3_T::::'4it:t:'<i<'1 tilmt, PWi2 E1213 the };3er:1'1e1.m%:1%__ .
suffe.1'{:?€i Esy the <31air112:z1'1i, 27:1: 2Q,..,§'.§} 2L§_%'"'{i{:;--. '::h€%= firliaégé bmtiy z21:r1d U'i(':'f1'f;i'.f()I't'.. mes: CznnrlniSS§i{>r':Té:"(;21,ig;;Ejit i:c;V'LL";~:1éfi-'{=} t:a.k<-an the pe'1'Im21:ne;'1t: £iisz1b'i1i't'y_ at 25% f;0_ the, "W}3:vC1C':i%JOCiy"

%11si;ead of 75% ane:i :;1wé1r._ci<:...?."_i.V :fea.;§s<3h'::bI_r:€-- c:oI11pez'1sat;'011 "under 't:.h<;é sa;ic1"I:_ja,é.21cI.¥;_'.1'11ttr'<:i"t::ré'.[i";:::_§3§ibn1.i'm:éci that the :'mp1,1gned5" _';';.;iL"£giimtai;.4"*{f'.:afit}. oitgclcér passed by the C(3I1].IT1iS'S'§{)Y§:€j'f is ' "iii 2:1-b1"e. i'.'<--> be "rticigiifzkici.

._.::"*.--s VVEig&1§iT1;S'{' '«f£,}'1~§S,' -1<--:a1fr1e<i {:m,11'1sseE for the <:.12zima1':i;;'w«L'i:'1i:<:::¥';24Ii'é-; ac)'i:»fe:3_deci and s1.1bs{.2mt;i3.'t.ed the j11c1g;:2ve;j1t: 2121-r.1"c?;'1*c1ei' pe1:~:;s<-id. by ighe C()I11I]"iiSSiO1]('.;1'.

"=.F11"r--3:.he53:"L,: P3L+..s11?3r11Vi'fi',E§c1 'Ethan. the CC}I1'1IT{1iSE5i0I1CI' z1ff';,er dui-3 '=i'f.(,§'!"3SiCiiffiféif',i'£v},1'§" Qf {E19 {.3131 gmd <10e:',r1.m1é:1"z'£ary fit?'-!I'.(J.i{-::}'}~{.:(./\'§ 'itaé-3..,:1Wé1:"ti»si<1'3r€*21s3<:>1'.1a.k3I<:* <:0:"npe1'1:3af:io:'1 axzd i:hc':1*efb1"e, it {i0€;%'s%» zgmi '(:13 H for iI"ifZ€?1';{"€;'.',fi"€,'.}""§lC':¢E)a "Af"i.e:' h:51vi:'1g§ Em-:2:n':;i ihs: i::?z;::1':m%<:ti. <'%<.)1.zz1:%;:;:E fix" 3f:2<:}*£:h. "' ":E1c°';>;:r€.i£:s%; a'§'i.e*..2' <*,221*<;%f1.:§ ps=;%r:.;.:'-;;;:E {sf £E":_§,% E"I1é%{.ii':§"i£:i§S 2*' ff E') z1Va.iIa1:aEe 01": f1'iE%, i1'1c:1udi.1'1g the ix1'1p1,1gj1'1ec1_j1.adgme:'1{' :»;md <>1':i£:r pzzsaseci 1:3}! iiiw (,T{m'1m.:£ss5i.om:::". that {}1'E1}/'4C§1.E.E?.SE*i()fE i:.hz1i': z1'ri.s:.ees for our Cc;>I"1ss;1ci€.:*21i:ion is:
W het'ht;~é1" the cornpe-rz1saiiV()»:'1 £i\1z*éii"{i€fi',i" .133; , the Cor1"11n.i$$i<')11er i8j':1£5f zémci 3"€:21::s:)1%:<21E3~;Et2'?.__ '-
8. H. the crzzzsg of 1:116:..(:}:é::i:11a;1€'. th%1t..v1f;eVAvfi;iI2as £i.§§E?d about. 25 years, etlefiimeif 'by§'; §)1'C5fifE?:§§i£3I2 zmd €:e1r11iI1g§ 34.000/~ per r1:=.v=:m.th Vern---d. fa1s<~>_ g§et,t:_i';_1g"i?2OO/ ~ be1i':i:a.

Th e Con1n1isiési()f?

'the Clain1.'»i:m: ?V4;'Q€)Ov,i'}«.§)<:1'..--rm)'1'11:il"1 sinc:et this: accidem:

Ems <><;3c'v;11;'1v'1-*.<::éij;<)1'i"*€;Ti';--7.'2Q'@4 zi_i'1L}"ii1 applying the 1:'eieva:1i:
factor "<_)f' @116 Schcduie. How*ev<;=.y, the Co111111issi{§.m3r _h'v;1s;'~-.§2z*r-~é,d in assessiryg" {.119 p<:rzna_11emi. ciiszi-igi1ifIj;' S1]E§T.'é}.§.1.1.Qd' by the claimant, 2:11: ?"5% in the .wh_,01c }:':€)<:!x/A.;'»., as ri fiiiiiv )<)i:1t,eci cyui". bv 1111:: Ie21_rz1e(:i V _ , __ 2% -1 , L"'r:§'i§">'tj:'1'.;'.r»'TAS:;'«.-1 :§'}'i?.,1V" U516-"'Iz1st,1ra%r. The PW2--E)o(:i:o1". has 2183688663 f:h<=§:"~..pc%r:§§a1':&2:1'1i. ciiss2a.13il.ii:}-' st.1i'fe1'<:(i by an-: c:Eain1az:1i at §.:<f;._. {€112 'W'1.}{}1{?b€}(i:g'. E}3z1£: tihez '.I'riii>L.ma§ h_2:s:s z.::=.s$c=:$:'-;c2ci f.'E":e;«::: ..diS21'£'5E§£i"}g at'; 7359»-'€35 wi.£'..'E'§:'>:::'£: E3lSE~§i§,"§3'1§E"§§2; 2-§;:"1y vg1ii.:% 41*' iif:;$f1'*igi1iiEy 3.é§'s,*e--:s'seci the i11C()F}:1{3 of rc2=1s(.>1':s zmci <'t(:>r1i..:"z:u'y 1.0 {$19 e:\fic3I<;:;'1<'%e on 1"ec:c>rc§ z:u'1<i 1h<:a"::f(>1*<2, it. lizjaliyic 10 be $61. a;1sidsr;: X-»'v'c> E-':.tZ'T:€'V..€§._'I§"{'."'.¥';V}1{;'. €\x'iC'1€3'1{'.€? 0f the E.)o<:i"(:>1"-- PVV2 zmci _ pcr'n1a1'3e;'1i" ciisa.%>i1iiT.y s1z_I':I"<~>;"e(i by $10 ct_E~:1}::n::e.2i§2f£. :3.i_ '-23%; to tile 'Wh('.}1.€'f body i:1::ei"e2.1c.i of', '?'E":_% .. ':V2':'£-.'f5i"' {.£'(?¥IVi'f;? C(m1n1issicme:'. :'\C<;:c'%pt_i1*:gg 'ti';-:6'~£§1c:£'.<_)r*o;{' 216:91}:::ppV1Vir%:1ci by. L {fie ("i(3m11_3issi<311<-:73. we rc:,_--c1é2?i.:e.:f"111.1'né'-i§_i?3;g_1-cgmpm1g;;3_t;jo;~1 E H'...
at: 31.30.1457 £2,409/»X121"e3:9%:'"x-%2§5/100) instfrsxaci of 33,90,438}? ~::_;§i'§;v211*€}::::,1"§ '1:wy"'~~t:.h é: Coxmnissiormr €:.I}C1 e1<1c:(3rd1I1"g1'yi_.. T;it "?~:i":.-3 "":41'iv:1rdéti';"" The re'-:duCi:i()1'1 of com;>cS;1s::ai:'1<i:';'1 (l4"J:VI'Tl'; 1.0. 292 / V.
9. u'Fc_)1*the'ff<3i"gc)i:1:g§{Caisson£5, the a.ppe.z1i filed by {her {1}}]Z)¢.'j§.1.12ii.I.'I'E.AE}']S{.ii"!ifI7.'iS atiowcci in part, arlci the in'1pug1'1c:d .,;'é,::1g;'1:4::1"1'.'.. .;;.1f1--d <'21"c%e1." ]iJE?ES."'§E?{i} by H16 C01m'm'ssi<311c1" in ""..;»'i./"€if';{-'x,/1f;3;z;'CR«235/O5 I'1('3I'¢:'.by m<'3ciifieci, 21x>v211'{fiii'1g E§3.{;"*-"={,_'<>';'I§,_;')('- :1s§~:11E..i»c.)1'1 Of ?1,3(},E46/~ with i.I'1£"e3'::s€" ai: .1. 12% p.21"
"21nf'I_::i1* .'3(}..::iayss {"1311} '%'.}':(=* (iz.':'i.e of ac:{:ic.§c1'1i' iii}! im 11:-72-1i§s;21ii<)1'1. _.=T%";<* z::'1'2<.)11;"1t r:ic3p:'>s~3i1<%:'1 by '$110 I:'1sL:;'*e:' @2211} "£32:
.VW:_f2.::1s=»:'::§'i:"<:?:.§ is} %;.E:':<';.: ri.Tf.)'E1£'L':.'§"i'1£'{f§ {'f<.>1':'2:'":':§5:;s~;§c':»:2=:::°, £m§1:¢{;§§;«1.t<éZ§2 2?
/-
/55 " ..
5-?};;:;v;»'é'} wlm in 11,2111. is {ii1'::'£'%;.r:*{1 to 1"e.1"L1.13.<% [ha exmsss zm1<>u:1t.. if zimy, ::'i&"§p(}s:;ii4:=%{.i bf; i'.1F§€?f I1.'1s1,11"e?11 The-3 m2:mnr:*.z" of dissbt.11*5;<3rne1'H' rI'121--.*§{__&"t ' é . Cc>r1m1i:ss;i<)1'1<;-:1" geriis pr<)pm'ii<>r1;1At;;::iiy ax'-:ifi't.1'a:.,.i 1. fit)" , Eziae ° €Xi.e1'1i. c)£'1"€::i;1c%f.i(n'1 made b t,}1.i:§V.Co::i,:'.ri. Y . .
Office to draw the 22.\r'»':11"'L=1.: ;1c(tA<')z"d'1:'2 i:.s1"1,*«