Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Rt Rev Dr Peter Machado vs Brig C.K. Ramesh on 20 September, 2011

Author: Manjula Chellur

Bench: Manjula Chellur

EN TFHE, HECEH C{}§%'§' {EV 
CE RCUET §:?$i?§E\'{,7?%  3" §,}VE*'V§§V€':.»"»*'Iv»'"\T.§7.';?

DATED THES THE gasw 1f}:'--'~J':' {§?%' :;;:c§>'é*;:2:»zi3   

PRESEN? jW'K . . .
THE HONBLE :wR:%,JU:%:'z*:<;:;: :31 <.;1f:;§E:':,zE{iJ 
ME') I  '  " "  

THE HONEBLE MI~?.JUE%'%'IC?.E?: §"::.:_é;£*e: :v>:%:%,1 :3;;<3 

 "La W W

 

BETWEEN:

I. Rt.Rex';Q1",'?_§3V%";¥" :"§ffz<sV<;§}"7;f;:'%:%<'>';.   V

Age: 58 {,}C'C' _: 1
The    
{Cvatb 0  6:731 :7': 1.5: 1 - _, V "
Bi sin 0 PE 0 L Q} 7 {L L 
Bexgaum  '

  

2 . R65 V. U._§> F1 :6; 'v'\}'i. E E :2; rs":  
 (';»§  éjf}%;'«;? : §%"§<:é
»~'5.Pa1*is'1 Prié" /V__;'\'_:fAIvgV§§§'{;T2?i§'1 i,L'?m1*z:V:i"V:.V
&    £\?Eaz'jy €:ff"§LiE"=:f§":$ L V
V' " ..   - V,'(hm;3§::e2é:32~:n

  

Sm aih E'v'£a:*ie<:i, z£%{I§V'{f}{;T&{iE,€;?j§

  

if: A  *B1":ig, C;K.R3.mesh,

'Stazéan C€>mm&r::§am;,
Belgauzrs Czznéenmsm?
Beigazrzm » 590 {;%€f}}'



 Csou

',cXact1§{a%.i:e:%:: zhe {§§§"%3C7E,iif}EEE§ <2?" %:E3z":~s:. iiimfl aa"h§st;::E"2

«(E {rs

Shri i'3':"2s:m¢<:=g3 Eéumzaaz".
Defence S€:';'CE'{'?{é;2§'§' flzsg'
Union Of §:'§«:i:'a:g

M in i  %:irj~.' <2 i" 5} <7 3% :3 ('an

E\E<5=\a' Delhi  E E3 {E0 3.

 

[By Shri :'v'IrL1Eh_\»'Lmjzij\'a FE';-71112»: BE:U'"E_if.?;';-;,~f:'i.§i'\?(f§£,;€':i'{€§§' "

This CCC  ?£§:?::%  "

  

Constiiutism of inciiia »
Contempt ef C<t;L:z"i.<; :='x<'i.:
contempt }3YOC€€{'§§E"§§§S 5335,? _ _
violatiflg the <;:*::i@:' §f?\£¢.\'<E~§:+%3<:'<§ -3*?&i "*'Vi
<;=e:é

. - )
 §%'é><f:%<;%;E~-3 3.2

   
 
 

 

4

E

Vk/.P,Nc>.2i8E32/'2Gs{}9 V  3':§:;:
AHI1€XU.E"€'*A' H 

" <*);":' §3;;::7_{;»~:f'<%:f:":4: 3:?/2&3; ciefsjg Zéfafijzéiéz

  

 f':;%Eé';_<.Vi'%2':§:V' *7 '

L:€a1"12_¢*€f§ v::<7.;:E':s:?'E«._§=::;.:j_ zfhzg <;%<i>z":':§f}Esai:22s;z':§:~;  'waeéi gas

re span d <5 :1 is .21 :"<:>'-h <V%a :*-3  '*--

_ E/'6  §E'a:'<}::;:é': i; §'":{F i.'Z>I"<T[§€.,"§"':'~} <52' zi*:§:~;

L»

' §§§i:i§:e:é%<;m:, <E:;.:,:<1*{'%. §:3f12A2§}E {Lia

n,,>

ft in «':'rs{%» pmbéic in E €f['£'"C 3;?

}3aArV8~'gY21§3?é'}§'9f_:'3"'.3 ;ms:'§ 3: 2;::*:V> 5s:i>§<:*<:;m:  asz2<E<%:V's':2V»:v%:c:i a:»;:':22:

?@&d as



 575;?" Size ;;s:2;z;<.2:4;<:?s; :;jf' :+;a><>ss:'!3§g. §;{éZé,'i[>'

has-*6? z':ss2<er;5 é:s5;§'<':E§<2:'§ or: $525»? {iV;§;2zs§<fVVe5:2saVVs ;';{3<f,}§,éa'4'?\ 

5:530  Z%?5z::?e:> {K/>:s2:s:<f~ 55:25:55; zfffizs



 :9/2Aé€:s:m:e:.3 ;"E,::7EE,9rE? <zf.:~::<;: is

Q2

?

f%3<';>(ze:€, ?}'2€?!'=€> 35; <: 2'<»:V>zr<;fz2;?;{; </;'('§!i*_ {'<;sz:~:<>5;zs<:s*za s.:;;2<;:z

 

IP26? (!<»?:1s'z' av

€ '<)!...f,S.£§}2(z2s{5:;:'§ Ergzx <'5<';'}'e1'<'%:'§ .441: %1:'>§,):"€'§(':'fmz

 

2195/><;§z2z'z2V(; <;c'z§<»3 ()3; 3.312 {E/';.%ze~scs'z; 56512255 _--z'2}:§?>._é:'z "

 

z*e?gu€:i1z¢' gate. H5? %'e(s:; {sf:~'~;<) {'€§'ji'€"€*{§f' {'}"zz:_7- ":'?a::a _;,{;z<15*;»§ *

;,.r::a'z'z(;3:2s; i€z;z(:e/K

xx

/, K I

z'r"zsI(zZ?e?(1 OF? 

m

 

€55';

  
    
 

   

'...=§{é'i";EV}'§ 352

the (fizzy §Vz<;zzr<<>z2(4>sV', {'38 5:23'?  

zl:>(:i< (fie: 5§(2.'?i'E{? ,f"<>:1{g;s.s; i'é¥>:';% ;\;(;i§] -.9:

 

._.¢"zIz; <f§z$E2}é<"!{sj

 

3/'/mi? Eyes ;;=<;>5;:{z'<'2z2<>€:' 

  

1
:

(}zzm'(z'(s} <32;z._§fzs2jz;  _!:z'z<z:»<'s- ;'<"":.{:~;i':* " 'z'§:<> ;2ié>gj{:e"';

 

K0 the Zocfxf " .';5<f <};2_<:*':'2€~';5:--.95' ?;3Ef"{'(* fT}{,é'fE'§$.

  
  

/31:'7(?€:+:;s:' zw7E.iV E  ;'%V2z%'s:<:«::::zf(§

f}?:f€_fi  ->.<*z:> z;~; 

%W'<{z;<.;z:'<::2, or 5:5; f'E/":;iZ'{i§{'?'f'£:"){'g

 

1r;.:'{)c:*P5;_s {(,);7:_;v 

§!:»:=> €f"f@;'§s§z'szi;

 

 E22515 iz'2z<i3z:<'2'§ T?§'3§?{é§'?A?'g:%f'.%;' 

{77'8:z2ézs3z'g;.v.

 

5:2 i}s<>' :':'<a<;s'.%"a:%

 

335133;. :'2=CC<es:: }m::,+; ijmesg s:;<a'(§:> an/*a':é€{z§;§;s 55:2 Sizaie

 

"<~;;s'z}:;:z: (1/,f??'?'E §~*f<?'°?"f/i, s/2:255 ::;:"Zsr<<'";sz<V:s'z:% s;a:»>:::z.g::%:g;

  

ear; ;2a:=;*'s;§§?5:--%{§ 55; E96» §:;s§«;e:%z':?

_s:;<s (ms? w.P:Ve2z2 i"6?{gE»E?(?"s?{§. :g?"£,E.s.Ea' 5/zéeezzfistsearj. E535? §L}%"(T§Z;:f5??"

zzz%::<;s_s2 £2"; 32262 :23:~;_2Tm2? ssr:'s§ ;;2<«>::'3.%':;3z2 E235; ;'E}i{*}{1'?,f,J;;fZs':7:'?§j
:~;:5sfi:<,:j§c<><§, Zk"fisz~> z}*z5~:I:tsszf Es='i';5€ ;;:<=:z§;k;>;2  :s<w:' <>z*(f:ézgigfgtgg

a1§?IS;}G:§€é'§ z;;§;'i "

<'~'.'xjJ,-*é'::.\.<"{s ix}/;' ziigflx 5: ms? 2,

if;  : a2z<E§:2 m' I; 54> my-::>;<»>2z5 <;:s,f"



gait; 8. S32 §é§'«-pEei1<:<;?d hr" iéxgé ;2:,Vz:";';<>;~;::: <2? iéifié {j{):V::  :*%':<:

. diffiC"uE€;"--:E'iér€f<}z"s%, Eiéaifx 2.:'.2::m.i 222%' {mi}; 2,§3<::> m'=:iV-:%:1é'::;g§ <2;

3. Afz;«:*r g;§<>in;;: iizzmzzfgfis ;3;;:':;a;3;:*:2g;h  esmé 
so aEss<> the zA"e:E<?'v;m:V ;;>Em:<>;;::*;:;,:%:ss mu; 2:':E"{' s\;::§*V,:s::::§~:_: %;:«<;§'=5;

boih '£336 sédeis, x\'<;:> ;*;<j>é<:> *a?i;«:£ 

 

to mach Cemetery an ;::<3i:"z: §\'z:>" E ~j§;A»:1';.S4s§E'2<'m'zé "§'E~',tj§'§";Vi;,._€,g%&3§'sV

     

at page No.37'. Thif' c?<>z'n;}E;1% zaazzrk:.:é'4;z;3:;_}:*%'§;

 

in the pubiic in'L'€1'£%SE' E*;'a:§3;;=:
proposed to put up   ,;=:'i  j,{f>"<~;:é::%;,<; <:>'1';» :~§':<:> z"{'sa2€i§>:;

 
 

 :2 {E if as In 2"? 3 <1' 

 

51 E 31} \7 ff

 

Court, C€?i§@};$"~  ;'

sL.zgg€sif:t>%é 'é1$.::fC;L,I€}"ii:$VV{X§ :V*:4:;;g_:'3:*':gé%1 :"\5<;.I?:.

4.  T536 'r;f<}:*;é;f>§:«:é'}"2§,  'z§':;:i 131:? ggzaiz? gm:  3::

CE'1'2'Tzt;§'{ii"i'1.f §%Zos;r;j:§., 3   9212:? zs.§'::é:' <f:"z:}5sis§?3,i3; 'iE3ar

pr0'C€V$$Vi';:wé_'s;.' i;7E:;:"<:s2,:2:;E1 tiriéses    emf §,}:§€;,'f{3§3'3§§E;?;'

=»:h<:*g;_aié,' but aissg r€:z'2@aV*i:¢2g;; <2? :.%:<:=; ms: §i}€'3,«*'ii3i"3{'§ :iE'2<;? gggaaisg'

~  <3Af;:  C€F:'E€*;€E'}»' §?£>2:s.§%,.

' -:§j:'és;§ 

 \x'§=V':{*z?:__ {hat "zj:>§;-g3£j5:"3'<§:=:1{es V



'./z

5. The <7<;m<%m;:z1  m,>:E2:I:3;; iJ;>z:E x'i<>§;=:Eé::m 42:" she?

mder sf}? the C{3%.2E'T: é:2<§:§a:*21atén;N{ <§§s;:'<>:»;;><e<:;*é So 333:? i}E"~€V§'.:I"i".$~§"~f{}§'

" .2

1:316 C<m:*€; C¢;::z1i:>m;:2: is as. ma:::z:'§' '%V;:.%s1:::><,V=:V":  

 

and the Court. The <:ii_i)I'fl§:%§2I§§3;

   

n«:>1;1'<:€ of the COLIN £320 84; <>:i:ii<[>ii  L'

1

".3 1'3?  {:' Q %;-'.a :1': 'L; *:k;:_{.

 

{he res.p<:>:m:i€n::a. Tizcn. 2':  ad 

 f.i<> §L:s:'é:i.:;' i<;;__'V:E21r:

whether such C(1m{,e%:"r,:gi.:n. <;>f ,:"E'2;_>. '<LV>:'5%::é:'se <;s:j"'E'E%<%~"{3<V>:,:3": 

 
 
 

commitiesfi 0:" mm. As vvé? ;_§:;sz'c*-.:1£"s;;"z: _j;m ;;L{g,é;*:>:~; é:1:s:1:;§%<%<'§ 03";

the Race C<,}L}?"(§§3

<:>n<;>u;:;h :a3::'*Eai?i_'<:. §'§Vi'"'§:"«.,j_  

 

Road béiiig-',«"». m<i;??;' '§\"i { ?<;?. :':<_é?Li'"V:é";<;~;  'é:"1ssa2;i:EE<:><if

faet gate.¢beca1a,;s6é"<§f~E33322t.é;%.::E2 05 {E29 :'<2:»;i:E zjmd iE"2<>_a' h.:2:x~'<>

  

9330 pm: z.:;:§"~:a Vh{3?j_ ..:1><;%:'~_:;>z:€§ zéaaé 

V'"VEhé"uG'0§if'~.baFEs <;'2j2a2Vé'::'i'g %§';;¥L2:"},' 2:;  §";>£%.§~;?%,{*I'i~;~?if)j€ zim 

 }_1'f<j§*é1_d.V§f_£'E--*:_§>" §":€.:g..e1z°€ 1"{:?E'"E'3€f}'J{',{'§7 3': (',{'}E,Z§{f E9226; {(3 §§"3_;}iEE'§C'f\T :4;

pa bij C WE :~<°_:7zf..*€.} 0% 3" E :4; 5:: E  2%  (4

 As 21 ff'::.iEE{if'.E" <5? §';:::<;:,  ;*:;:V*<::;3<V';s~;:<}£ mas; 2:3

repiace :'e2r=;)}vi:':§g  M13": 2: :"w>>"%:E;:'z:V' ;;;::<;a  g:~;:%*; i'§3=:>

3': " 

 Lzndertakmg ?t::e{<32"<? iiimé C<>:2;":§ :A':c%;<2E:VV:':¢':§;§ ggggaéae is; ':'a'7g3Eaz:<;:g::%<Vl§

with regaiiar §a':<:7= gamzgié :é:<=z*:> is; rm :ém>:~:m §':~:>x%; zmgzséz



vxi<:i?;h @2301':  :<;E'2<;:¢§<§  éém. $1: aséii   

pérmissaicm mass; {(3 iazégc .f'Lz:'><::::z§ §};¥'a')i_,'{"f$$;i'{}§':§%'.<V§'§\~._ §'§.£.§'§;{.'

p1"oc<3ss2"<;>1':s %';:-::w+ <'§V§§'é:<:u'E:}: :4; Jf§in:~'éSf%

L

 

 

Cemetery §'€i'L<ZT', s;~;u<>E1 ;><%:*s:<>:3:e <:';~:::»A~;~:§%~_~;<> 22.51% : h"::--..'' *

(}ymE<:h:%1n22 R<)a{E zmd E"€2:r;<* €L,Z<>LE.2":~;"<> §€':f>_;ic§._ 

 

proccsskm is; 1*": at 13% :7: ::;;m <;,:;;}>":'s<z<> ':§2{x:~:a 332:3  § .:{'?.HE'VI:;zé§"i<§fE"}

gate;

/. In {hair :V*é:7'§2_'V_VéV;§7.V3:535?._r3'§;E'::<.?:'*--,} -*;i'<> awe? of 'mar

é €,)i§W_,'?i'§."%.\'s'/' <3!" ;§?*2<:* 'Cii} £"{:f£,7U{'}§'E8 .:a::'::€

 

opinion then? 1'_ "
no CO1'1'i.C*fT1}:",>'li3 2Is§C;'%:>m:€:'ii«:,<'%A<v%K..' ;»IXfi?éiV¥<L;:Vv::§in §3:"<i2c<_>:;%é§is'2 

dmpp€'«;§.

 .....  

Sd/4 JUDGE : J {,9 S.) Km' LL.' Q " Rsh