Karnataka High Court
Dr Anand Patil vs Esi-Post Graduate Institute Of Medical ... on 30 May, 2012
Author: Ashok B.Hinchigeri
Bench: Ashok B.Hinchigeri
N THE HIGH (OURI OF V 3 TNGALORE
DATED IHJ5 THE 30 DA lAY, 2012
BEFORE
THE HONBLE MR 1H"mTICF AR-
4 'k F, HINCHIGEPI
'PJPJTPET1TICrJ Nosii146ii2i1:2ui2JDN:AD
0
BE FA/FEN,
A
LirRna O r'clLjI,
So Mahadevagotda Paul,
Aqed 29 years.
255. V B Man Road, Shvanagar
Pa al n a a a r.
Bangalore 5b0 niH
2 Dr. Archana B H,
D,'o Hanumanthappa B
ed 36 years.
23 Main 2 Cc
F yout
ore 63 0
aLM
esh
d
rr,
4 B
a
I qr
oW 130 7-3
29yar
C ro,
1 A )t[1(IE I
F H ci , ,
c'r Jr '
'
g
1
1314, Main, Marenahalli,
Vijayanagar,
Bangalore 560 040.
-
6. Dr.Bheemaraya, 5/0 Hanumanthappa Devaramani, Aged 27 years, 990/D, 13 th Main, 11 th Cross, Kallappa Block, Srinagar, Bangalore 560 050.
--
7. Dr.Charusheela Y.Ankushkar, D/o Yallappa, Aged 35 years, 232, gth Main, 4 th Cross, nd Stage, 2 BCC Layout, Beside Chandra Layout, Bangalore.
8. Dr.Chetan.B.L Sb Lakshmlkantha.B.C, Aged 31 years, g 1 No.3, Floor, No.87, th 5 Cross, 8 th Main, Brindavannagar, SBM Colony Mathikere, Bangalore 560 004.
-
9. Dr.Dilipkumar S Sb Shamrao C, Aged 31 years, 12/1, 27 th Cross, 5 th Main, Bhuvaneshwari Nagar, Magadi Road, Bangalore 560 023.
-
10. Dr.Divyasree R.N, D/o Renugopal B.N. Aged 28 years, No.425, 14 th Main, 1 St Block rd 3 Stage, Basaveshwara Nagar, Bangalore 560 079.
--
1-I
-
I 1 - wJ p
'a;
(L
I,
a.
3 7
a. - ti
I
3
4
54,Smihka
2 Main, 7 Cross, Shivanagar. Rajajinagar. Bangalore 560 010
-
17 D.KiranC.I. Sf0 Dr.Hanumanthappa.C.S. Aged 34 years, 1$ l4talCns Ba galoe 560085. 18 Dr.Lakshml, D/o Parthiba K A d 4yers, 12/44, 1 g Cross.
New Kalappa Block, Okalipt am Bar gal e 21.
19. Dr.LakshmlS, D/o Srlnivas'rajL S AgeS el' 10o4, Behind 581' APMC Yard B anc'h, M.G.Raod, Chikkaballapur 562 101.
--
"
D 31 en 5/0 Mu syappa T K. Aged 33 years, L 28, 2 'd Main. i' Cross, K sk Lout B avenwo Na r,. Ph €, Barigalore 560 079
-
IL 0 4ad JSL nan R S Raaro Aged 31 years, 101, 1 g Cross. (adiyur h ana ir C BI ck, Ba ' Dr.Manaboel Basno.S.k.
c, EIar S K 5 Aged 28 years, 215/16, K.N.M.Complex, th 28 Cross, 2 nd Block, Rajajinagar, Bangalore 560 010.
--
23. Dr.Manjunath.B.K, Sb Basavaraj.B.K, Aged 34 xears 263/n, 6 C Main, RPC Layout, Hampi nag a r, Bangalore 560 040.
-
24. DhManjunath.T, Sb Brahmänanada T, Aged 30 years, 988, F Cross, 4 th M Block, Rajajinagar, Bangalore 560 010.
--
25. Dr.Manjuvani, D/o Venkatappa, Aged 28 years, 14, 15 th Main, J.C.Nagar, Kurubara Halli, Bangalore 560 080.
-
26. Dr.Mohammed Hussain, Sb Sikandar.M, Aged 28 years, 202, Deepthi Residency, 3 A Cross, Rathan Slngh Layout, Kavalbal rasandra, R.T.Nagar, Bangalore 560 032.
--
27. Dr.Nagatanooj, S/o S Krishna Murthy, Aged 30 years, 90, 14 th Cross, Muneshwaranagar, Ullal Main Road, Bangalore 560 056.
--
8 ara
N
op
/ lycdS
34/a, 2 Moo Sampige Layout 4 Main, Vavanagari Ports Bargaicre 56o 0/9.
2Q Dr Panka N 0 eshmane S Madhu ri r Des i I Ia 1, ssI cit al B aveshwe gar, Bargaore 560 079 90 Dr PrashantI S/u BABora!ngaiah.
Ag d 30 yea
6 Mar 2 Sta
ay N a Me
j aagr Baigalc 600
1. Dr ratnbha.
Do frIargowrIa. Aged 33 years, 181, r F1oo 7 Crrs B iaqar Siork ci ft.
3n v' B Anr28ta 5erahru:aona 5.
Pear JHv'Irrnaç.oa i F' jtta
F Kn rflF't
a
'to
) 3W -ec
) -D
t -
m
3 pWJ
0;
- 3
C
31)
0)
0
S
C/ic! MR!Ramaiah, Aced 30 years, 149, Chowdeshwari Nava. 1O Cross. Vidyanagar, urnkur
40. Dr!Sandhya, D/o Late RRamudu, Aged 31 years, 99, Srikrishna, 12" Main, Binny Layout, 2nd Stage, Vijayanagar, Bangalore -560 040.
41! Dr!Sanjay Biradar, 5/0 Changouda Biradar, Aged 30 years, 206, 4 th Main, 15t Cross, 2 nd Link, Industria Town, Rajajinagar, Bangalore 560 044.
42. Dr!Santoshkurnar P!Uppinal, S/c Parashuram F!Uppin&, Aged 28 years, 72/a, Stage, 6 th Phase, West of Chord Road, Mahaganapathi Nagar. Banqaore.
43. f3rSyeca C4cywsia Aznar, D/o Sved aLd,,I Wajid, Age'd 32 years, Crcss KHBccar K B Sandra Extension, S ['Jjcir, Eangaiore 32.
44. DrOhivakiran, Pamoapathi,
--L -
Ra.macha ad ra aura, 9 Vidyaranpura Post, Bangalore 560 097.
--
45. Dr.Shlvakumar D, Aged 28 years, Sb Danappa B, 304, 3 rd Main, 4 th Cross, Kirloskar Layout, Hesaraghatta Main Road, Bangalore 560 073.
-
46. Dr.Shivakumar.A.M, Sb Late A.M.Mahadeva Murthy, Aged 32 years, 46, 2 Cross,BHEL Layout, Kenchenahalli, R.R.Nagar, Bangalore 560 098.
-
47. Dr.Shobha Rani K.N, D/o Narayana K.N, Aged 29 years, 88, 22 nd Main, PES College Road, Nagendra Block, Bangalore 560 050.
--
48. Dr.Sreeja, D/o M V Kumar, Aged 32 years, No.118, Mahaveer Rich Apartment, AGBG Layout, Hesaragatta Main Road, Bangalore 560 090.
-
49. Dr.Shruthi Das Shetty, D/o Dr. B.G.Shetty, Aged 29 years, 2543, 7 th Main, RPC Layout, Vljayanagar 2 nd Stage, Bangalore 560 040.
-
l0
50. Dr.Shyam Sundar Nayaka G.S, Sb Late G.C.Shivanna, Aged 37 years, 3ac, 903 Shobha, gth A Main, 1 Block, Kalyan Nagar, Bangalore 560 043.--
51. Dr.Sindhu, D/o Siddaramegowda, Aged 28 years, 6/1, 8 Main, 6 m Cross, Saraswathipuram, Mysore 9.
-
52. Dr.Sowmya.T, D/o Thirumala Giridasa, Aged 29 years, 1518, Panduranga Nivasa, Ramanagaram 571 511.--
53. Dr.Suresh.B.N, Sb Nataraj B, Aged 28 years, Kyasinakere Post, Honnali Taluk, Davanagere (Dist) -- 577 224.
54. Dr.Sujit Betagerl, Sb Vishwanath P.Betageri, Aged 30 years, No.112/a, 10 th Main, 38 th Cross, nd 2 Rajajinagar Block, Bangalore 560 010.
-
55. Dr.Swamy Vivekananda Harwal, 5/0 Girimallappa Harwal, Aged 29 years, Lig-112, KHB Colony, MSK Mill Road, Shantinagar, Gulbarga 585 103.
--
cM ci
C
C Lfl
H
U cM
- C C C
c ci .
L. ci
..
U U.
C C --
cz
-
-- ci crc
20
Co
LU C 0
Z&t .
c dS 0 od
0 (32 ci C - 0
cc .10>0 (t) C C) H j5U 0
U
-- r cc -- r
C ccc
$nuDUcfl :5
cMCCo oCroc_C - C-CoCo
.
t C) H
.
ccl C Qi
LI
U C (1) G) (LI r Ci C C
cc>--Ci rL>_roCj coc>zct C
? ---- cvC)L >Ln rCN C Co
3ff Co t0 ico
0
- ccsQDt C aD÷o tu)Cir LU
--
C' L-Co
(o
H
t ->'• CCflrflCci
t--n ç()--cc tccflJjC
nj cc
ccLr%cc oc0CoF: rr)o
(V
r
q
0 )(Ø(
tic t3%DECM -. ci -r .. ci -ci. ç ciCci>o
:-°°
flC(Utc)ciniCC <ocuinci <$cuco oaUflciccC oocc)
ciu--'cc --,--ccc ofOrO occc --cc
ee<>s.ci C<<cxci .eC<(nc1( Cccicin :CD<y)IC>.10 Lfl$10.
cc
10 10
•
12
62. Dr.Vinay Kumar Haddannavar, Sb Bhimappa Haddannavar, Aged 30 years, 111, 2 d Phase, 5 th Main, Manjunath Nagar, Rajajinagar, Bangalore 560 010.
--
63. Dr.Vinutha L, D/o Lakshman, Aged 27 years, 7/la, Uma Nilaya, 3 rd Main, gth Cross, Adarshnagar, Chamarajpet, Bangalore 560 018.
- -
64. Dr.Yashavanthi.H.S, D/o Siddegowda, Aged 28 years, th 0 j Main, 2 Block, Rajajinagar, Bangalore 560 010.
-
65. Dr. Ravlshankar.M, S/o Mahallngappa.B.V, Aged about 28 years, Door No.830, 2nd Floor, th 15 nd 42 Main, Cross, Rajajinagar 3 Block, Bangalore 560 010.
--
66. Dr.Soumya.R, D/o Nagaraj.B, Aged 28 years, No.262, 18 th Main, 4 th Block, Nandinl Layout, Bangalore 560 096.
-- Petitioners (By Sri Ravivarma Kumar, Sr.Counsel for Sri Ravlvarma Kumar Associates) 13 AND:
1. ESI Post Graduate Institute of
--
Medical Science & Research (ESI-PGIMSR), Rajajinagar II Block, Bangalore 560 010.
-
Represented by Its Dean.
2. Employee's State Insurance Corporation, Panchdeep Bhawan, C.I.G, Marg, New Delhi 110 002.
-
Represented by its Director Genaral.
3. Government of India, Represented by Director of DGHS (Medical Examination Cell) Ministry of Health and Family Welfare Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi, Represented by its Director.
4. State of Karnataka, Represented by Secretary Department of Health and Family Welfare (Medical Education) rd Room No.341, 3 Floor, Vidhan Soudha Bangalore 560
- 001.
5. Medical Council of India, Pocket-14, Sector- 8, Dwarka Phase-i, New Delhi 110 077,
-
Represented by its President.
6. Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences, t1i 4 'T' Block, Jayanagar, Bangalore 560 041.
--
Represented by its Registrar. ... Respondents (By Smt.M.P.Geethadevi, Advocate for R-i and R-2;
Sri S.R.Khamroz Khan, Advocate for R-3; Sri K.M.Nataraj, MG and Sri R.Omkumar, AGA for R-4;
Sri Noorulla Khetty, Advocate for R-5; Sri N.K.Ramesh, Advocate for R-6) t s C, i -- a - t or st•tu .on U Tnl,a p a,'r.ç, to .tnki .g dnwn the def.nit.on it in-service tand;dates .r Rule 2;G ot Vie Karnataka tonduct Of F ntr3nc-' Test Fe' eIPr'.or. Arci tdi. s;c,n To ost t jdt' e V c. r e r sc tar as exc iie. ES dc tor wo king r ..w 3tdtt- of Karnatalca and e'c.
S r t. S r 0 or t ' 1 t S d ti o ii le efoowi r KVNaa he 'ar J lit al 1" t en submits, or. instructions that the EmAovees' State Insurarire t 03 r a o. ar n j oa t i er e candidates fr the purDose jf adrn.sston to OG Medical ourses f t iu f 1 • u r • I deric!"r on the 'cci'e vc"ki he taken fr the r,e4 ye'r 1 Pt rd ji s.i iissn. iIsG' It )ep U rc as'rg I)a.) f 1 lC '3r tts't..' a- , 4j, rr._ ii s i :p r )) ti' I d 1(1. I F I 4,j 'r,' • I . f . • • r.. - •I.• ',?,• C • •I ' a C in t a