Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Suresh Dagadu Chaure vs M/O Defence on 7 November, 2019
i OA No. 764/2018, 2435/2019 to
2530/2019, 3235/2019, 8326/2019,
* 366/2019, 436/2019 to 439/2019,
4497/2019 to 4354/2019,
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
MUMBAI BENCH, MUMBAI
ORIGINAL APPLICATION Nos.
7164/2018, 2485/2019
246/2019, 247/2019, 248/2019, 249/2019,
250/2019, 323/2019, 326/2019, 366/2019,
436/2019, 437/2019, 438/2019, 439/2019,
449/2019, 450/2019, 451/2019, 452/2019,
453/2019, 454/2019
Bate of decision: O7,11.20183
CORAM:~ R. VIGAYRUMAR, MEMBER (A).
R.N. SINGH, MEMBER (0).
Mrs. Punam Kumari
Ex-MTS, PA No. oS? 71-6,
widow of Late Rai Koshore
Singh, age-32 years, Occ, Service,
Presently residing at SMO P-134/3,
Air Force Station, Devlali Camp,
Nashik 422401, Mahareshtra.
, Applicant in OA No.764/2018,
Pandhari neath Sukdev Gawande
EX-MTS, PA No.63767
Son of Shri Gawands
y en xy
Suxdeo Kalu,
Age-44 years, Occ, Service, presently >
ses Ae ¢ ah Pe TE
residing at H.No. 305, Shingwe
ct
Bahula, Deviali Camp, Nash
Maharasntra. |
Applicant in OA No.245/2019.
Santosh Digambar Kshirsagar
Eu-MTS, PA No. 6S7S8-A,
Son of Shri Digambar Kshirsagar,
Age-28 years, Occ.Service, presently
residing at A/6é, NE, Panchjyoti Society,
Deviali Gane Nashik-422401,
Maharashtr
3 OA No. 7864/2018, 2452019 to 7
2350/2019, 323/2019, 326/2019, '
366/2019, 436/2019 to 439/2019,
449/201 to 4842019,
.. Applicant in OA No.246/2019.
GQ)
gp
its
yp
rs
t4
ar
bey §
aa
583)
"wo
rey
a
cfr
Go
f--5
do
£4
"
it
Sq
tH
iy
ie
oe ry
Oo
oy
fas
mad
es
oy
}
}
iwi Trambak Patole,
<
rm
wise 4
sha 4,
Age~ sears, Occ, Service
Presently residing at Village
Shingawe Bahula, Deviali Camp,
Nashil-422401,
Maharashtra.
.. Applicant in OA No.247/2019.
Shankar Bhagwan Pale
EX~MTD, PA No.45825-8, Son of
Shri Bhagwan K. Palde,
Age~-40 vear Occ. Service,
resel Ld a
Ambad Ganvathan, Village-
PO-Lahavit, Na asnik-422502,
Maharashtra,
-» Applicant in OA No.248/2019.
Pravin Shivaii Gsawali
EX-MYs, PA No.63760-S, _
Son of Shir Shivaji Sawali,
Age 29 years, Occ. service,
Presently residing at jaily
Market, Shivaji Chowk, Lahavit,
Dist. Nashik-422502,
Maharashtra.
.. Applicant in OA No. 2499/2019.
Vinod Kumar,
EX-MTS (PH}, PA No. 63770-5,
eon of Shri Late Hazgari Lal,
Age~39 vears, Gcc.Service,
Resident of 145, Idra Colony,
Ratnada, AF Area, PO-Residency
Defence Lab, Dist-dJodhpur,
Rajasthan-34ecil.
.. Applicant in OA No.250/2019.
Sachin Govind Adka
RAN < mr wo Ea " :
Ex-NTs, PA No, 63759-P,
OA No. 764/201 8, 2435/2019 to
-- £80/2019, 3235/2019, 326/019,
366/2019, 436/2019 to 4539/2019,
44/2019 to 4354/2019.
Son of Shri Gavind Adke,
Age-28 years, Occ, Service,
Presently residing at H. No.703,
Rarkhana Road, Post-Nanegaon,
Nashik-422502,
Maharashtra.
.» Applicant in OA No.323/2019.
Namdev Bhausaheb Jaras
Ex-Cook, PA No. 45824-N,
Son of Shri Bhausaheb Jaras,
Age028 years, Occ. Service,
Presentiy residing at H. N.1054
Lahavit, Malwadi, District-Nashik
422502, Maharashtra.
Yogesh Pand
... Applicant in OA No.326/2019.
hurang Ch
o me
EX-MTS, PA No. 63764-L,
S/o Pandurang Chavanke,
Age-24 years, Occ. Service,
Presently residing at Village & BO
Shivade, Taluka-Sinnar, Mandir
Gali Nashik, Dist.Nashik-422502,
Maharashtra
*
.. Applicant in GA No.366/2019.
Rajesh Bhikari Pardhe
Ex-MTS, PA No. o3761-A,
Son of Shri Bhikari FPardhe,
Age~3l years, Occ. Service,
Presentiy residing at NP-95/01
Six Chawal, 25 ED AF Station,
Devieali {8S}, Nashik-422501,
Maharasntra.
.. Applicant in OA No.436/2013.
Mano? Prabhakar Shinde
Ex-MTS, BA No.63763-H,
son of Prabhakar Shinde,
Age-25 years, Gcc. Labourer,
presently residing at 124,
Maruti Gali Lahvit, Nashik,
Bistrict-Nashik-42250¢2,
45/2019 to
23/2019, 3526/2019,
2019 to 4390/2019,
z
4
ao
OA No. 4337/2019,
2019.3
(2019, 43
e
OA No. 764/2018,
S0F
6
2n
2
36
4
.« Applicant
a a 92)
vot et rt
<> a co
is is] Ol
mm ny Mine
Ext oO ry
cy ow xf
"f "e =f
© Oo Oo
vA a wa
et fh oH
wb
G 13 oO 6 o
>} w Me
& mem & is thc §
wr 43 "ot GO
i Moa 4 (Fost 9 43
~ G te g "Oth gt
aS) i @ ty at reed af) a = bd
ea t} ma TQ kd G md 0D wm bf enh
™ O ox} vc crt i om ms OY EF ag vl ~ ES Wb Lt
q} ~ rq wm Red LOE By ry SD NE. Sa 5 rf ed th 8a gg
id nt O, OO 5 Nord it Dy fj i 2, $B CS ky
$A OY oy MOM OUP § Gp ie ei CO 1 Dy pow Oy OSS OO fy
~ T « Bs) ee a0 oo red ri NS eed an oy eh Sort
PQ SL ed 4 Gy, * M 43 4a fo kp cet aD * TS TS 4b Oo ey > Cho ong. Was
@ i Orwoam mH. a 20 O rt $4 <f a a cl tu cy . Mu £5 ad ie
beh TY (tf mye + oe hy a * serge s gy mm * es ft {
re MO SS Oe Ad Go set © y @D i wy ae tg tp E
ot TF Ly ct my S$ O @ a bh Ay OO ed @ cep a rE Om O
ASO GU ed cp WS AR BE GF wed ES ed 2 th he a ft OE ® O ad
OO MO tt uy ct ad D BE o@ ok pp 4 cc6) B44, aM a) fs Oo
* 1S teed OS SP OE CS ~ 6G 8 O te aoe DM eed rn 4] rt
So Cl 6 om tH HOM oF @ ard Of: om . a oct Sm ww
TE MW DM © ag + 'OO Dy Mo ah « (3 © 6 th + Wy m Ot
Hed bb ke Be ed ot 4 ed 4d Oy dy ke ag » © OF a we Qo ward My Sy
Heh Le GB ch Mt Momrm SO th by Wo Sh ned ee eG ot bag
© fe TO Sayeed Kor CO WG a ST mre yD Coa te te OP gy Goi st ah mp,
a Lo Pare' 2 CY uct fbr kt ep ct od x WM Ee kp op 43 a YOR BY ey
ae 43 3 a Oe Bort OH or ai we oO w @ 44
Sw Ho Oo oR fay $5 oh, + Ba oe rel tS MON GO emery ad MOE ed cs
MH ON GD 0 sd 4y 4 OS OGD SM a he ef $4 ky wird OO GH
we f Wy a br oat SOUP hs 8b wm ep og Eny td QO 42 bey 1) a4
tot SP a Qe O 4 is a ee OP De omy Oi op @
oO Or a wt Gg MM ah oc O Bed Wa OM OO 4 4 Gg BM OTR 4G
WS Tel 2 eG On 0 i st Wht Oi 3 O Bt oe 2 Gh 09 >. be oy et Me ik wu gt 9,
.. Applicant in OA No.450/2019.
3 OA No. 764/2018, 2458/2019 to
SoU/20TS, 3823/2079, 3326/2019
| 36G/2019, 4936/2019 to 430/2019
, 4490/2019 to 4354/2019.
Dinkar Ashok Patole
Ex-MTS, >A No. 63765
Son of Ashek KR PB
ve y
Ag
"
fa-Z6 years, Occ. Service,
esently residing at
oashingve, Post Shenit,
strict Nashik 422502,
faharashtra.
me SS rg et
fe
.. Applicant in OA No.451/2019.
Shubham Laxman Waghchaur
Ex-MTS, PA No. 63887-F,
Son of Shri Laxman Waghchure,
Age 22 years, Occ. Service,
presently residing at Qtr. No.
94/05, Driver Otr. 25 ED,
AF Station Devlali (Seuth},
Nashik 422 501,
Maharashtra.
.. Applicant in OA No. 452/2019.
Bhausaheb Kacharu Jundre
Rx-FPireman, PA No. 45826-A,
Son of Shri Kecharu dundre,
Age-38 years, Occ Farmer,
peresentiy residing at Shraddha
Apartment, Bshind Suman Hospital,
Jai Bhavani Read, Nashik,
Nistrict-Nashik 422401,
Maharashtra.
.. Applicant in OA No.453/2019.
ayur Subhash
Sonawane
Bx-MTS, PA No. 63757-S8,
Son of Shri Subhash Sonawane,
Age-24 years, Occ. Service,
Presently residign at 96,
Subhash Road, Bhagur,
Nashik 422502,
Maharashtra.
... Applicant in OA Ne. 454/2019.
(By Advocate Shri Yogendra Pratap Singh)
3
x
(201 9 to
2019, 3826/2019,
S6/2D19, 436/2019 to 4390/2019,
wy
xt
ra
8,
--
0
oy
ke
64
250/2019, 32:
ms
QANo,
20] 9.
za
en
as
x
sf
¢
S tod
cal
ma
e
449/201
RL
4.
?
ine-c
x
2
a
a
OUcer
Lg
ryt
ee
gos
4
x
¢
x
OnmMa nc
ix
x
¢
Deviali
t
Lab
e
mh
Versus
-
he fF
OMMan
o
Newt
ou
we
Xe
R. VIGAYKUMAR, MEMBER {a}
in-e¢)
&
-&
"
ae
os
oan
*
*
5
3
ORDER (ORAL)
fA we Naw she nmbenan tric O .
Pex = Lpmant Depo o SAL 7 > 373 station, Qo ~ is ir fai ® HO Ber (By Advocate Shri R. R. Shetty} 63 sed SS td cs me is) sed end f;
kg Q oA $5 oS red ned the 6 "4 he fr bet cs act % sy-f
19. } 2019, os i fo 9 A 2 2019 to 4 ?
y 6 019, 323/2019, 326/2019, 43 19, ' a f 2 y 25 366 © ne cp 4 OH MO Mx Tos km co Gy wy Go ka Ry he Wee Se BB f OD vetord ey St gg PO bred bt ot OQ MO AER weg ed BOF Oe Gy o mE OS A ey GO OO Us Romy 4 Om Ky ea gt oS © ie ts, HON ey Enorg 0) «Of 1 de seg Ld 3 ped ha OY et © tet "4 a Cn ne rr tom te ee Wo BOD a ee O, Ha Oy St OO a, - Be ey 2 3 ra fa ay ety Me io Port Ory try 8 Oy ef En a ye ws Om OR oN fy Ue ey By UN Be OS ay 1 n uy . GO f 1 GG ~ OOM me oy ORR Sra S wo op bo wg Bae % HO OR yd Bog TS ON Bog @ % aoe § ERR QOS fon PS .a6 Ge on ye f i 4 p 3 age Bo 64 OF GQ cep ot yD Me 5 3
- am UG BS Gg Om yO Boy ie 5 £0 6 2 Oy & ct ha he Ao RP Os, 0 ge és rt Ure Ey ow ¢ Bg Ww 43 yO a BS BO ¢ ay gq Bl by G wn " GS SEM oy Soe Ses ® iO, 2 6 2 ® iy GO GS qj is SF Bee Ae ey Bg me Ha a cy oy G A a S Sha gay ee © w % a Baa 43 no a G pp my ye ke eG BRU, so ; ay we "S& & G 88. Been i, Ge BU Pam & ae DHS ooh wing 9) & Mom Oh aa PA ay PECOS B 5 FDS wg pees bbe See MES Bow ogo BS oe :
uh DA Om Oo wp a, WoO cH oe fn oy ® OG h @ a O e . Ad xy 10 "a 4 GO Gag @ ha NI Bm "MP i SB yet « g@ . & Uma Oo gy hh SRG rH DBS or i OO EN gy & o te Uy Boy 2 ty OE By Eg OT Of, ee he ty Ao pe gy (8 ot ot 3 GO Bey 43 got 1 No Mag WoO Et ow BEN BN DS m3 Li a bm Bm ay ght wg a os "Kg Bert OO WB Og Bo et oy a BAD th oy By a ma Ma a UP Bye cts Eb 5 og Bigg oy GR SL ic Ge Sy in BS ri P BB ROM OR WOR gg Sm em gL f-4 Hs oy ty MG med a Sa 4 Lp uy oh 35 7 AE ed ON wt Sy 8 Oo Me ad tye Ys wy © Sa bb OEY wy OO & th Ap T «Af ue wed ed mr Gof ky BN Yy or «by : i) o @ 5s 8Sy my Bg gm fe 3 ooo ey BeBe SR ga At BH g 2 vom G.GRSS Gy ge eSka ose FhoawissSak SHR Xs Bs g iS we} rt oe "A * ee a . oe eee + m4 2 ve 4 -£ * 3 ws 5 ad + "ps 7 as be £3 rd @ @ oT Mea N Ee B 2, Un m4) Oy ord "TY OF OG SB Ey oe 53 6. x -"O Me 8 kG WOO BP wy QE mh ort TW my oy rete Hg ed SHO Yb) at by © iy a PF 2S She oo (uO DOORN Spon ro Ga a Ya Cac Sa Ge a @ Ms kt bs 7 OO Bag w Go Oy oF te SO OU © OO OY SOM Ae DO ENO myo wy «rf "4B S ie "4 4 O19-ta i f 2 245;
§ O18, 9 & OA No. 764 2S0/2019, 3232019, 326 2019, O19, 2 Zz O19 to 439/ 4492019 to 454, 2 7 O19, i oh tf my r| xed a ies 44 4 ay hy cs ters S43 <3 Ls by ne fe j 3 ey he 43 o} 3 wo vied tf tt hes fet 1s bf ie GS red peng oof "rd wer a 3 G
i) @ Oo nd, ed O "4 5A > id oh, wo Ct a +f 3-3 "sd ot ea.
oO an eq net s term Ne ae ee fe @ £ § cy ita) 43 ir .
wef a 43 ?
2019, :
2019, (2019.34
019 to 4 (2019 to 43977 23/2019, 326 23 & 449, 3 B4/207T8, 2459/2019 to "2019
& \ OA NO 2 66/2019, 4 _% 2 Wp. GD yy wy OF uy "fy SHPO 4 oo ok 2 © TH @ © "Ou cf O Bm & OO tH OF g % @ ty LT "ey 3 AE Dey 4h oO act Go i> TO fb Ebert ay Gk, O Gch SO of & 3 4 mA ay "ef rH & Wer 43 Ror we at ey 4) ts S228 Qo Bd tg ors a mt my e 43 4 WY 431 4 43, GH iy ce ie 2, Sf 4 no 'G ag 8 8] % a Ba a bs ag od ® fou 5 el ge ge a 4 } OM CES Uo Mom ® ef OQ bb DS Hose Jee alo aa a "ag Ge as 9B ay rt A ad 28 ® aes iy I te rho jg, HOS kya ct el an | 2 rd ay Uy Lg 4 Ok, He ws 8 Hy BS try Ao 8 ag oy ape ce Ms BOG OR gO = % ' : 5 SY ES xt of wy Ert © UE 4 wrt 2 83 be "GH x Ho Bloc ba wr by om, EE 4 2 a a ; & HIG a a a a a i Hg Gc a fe be "ef "4 al, aww Ss ky om 2 ~h ss fi ey ag RH og. Edy Aa Ey ery tot % f " a} aad 3 4 "oR o "eh Se 46 By HE ty 2 +3 i gi = a 8 43 Sn ny oo mo i Moa Gk OO al Gly, B ws 5 wy alo ,, OH dt EB mg BO DF " a Stk CH bays Se 3 - ae j is + Hoa Sos a | tb oH 3 Sg ay a on™. o D> a) So Gm] . we Occ a ® 4 3 Al 6g tg ' By oh * ~ ned dagt TE op is Me "et ) mia, 4H OS ot a E Dp a Gl | OF B mS el BE ot a6 3 1 gS do 3 POS Oc 8 2 "Be Wa' BP on ele ce A Ba | oe ea es 1S an & yd ree a SH a dE Ot Gy HE aie 8 t SMG Os wu Pe 4 BS Sg 1 Ly fy a mE SAE gs ail ¢ oid ma Get es Bee Ey eat te My ans) i ab % O} ua. 3 Gg As CBE eH OSE ES ty by A BOS a ; x ny ay chy Peng & nee 3 et 4 QB a ; xi Te ae ™ A foe) dS wal Ol al fc He GduN™ wm B™ BH uw & Sod oe ea CH rd ES PN iS) Wh AH oe GOW bo eB es wy fel 0) ha ea Oot SS BE ced Lor @ m4 GH tol BA ta wy CG TG 4h ord ba + © Ripert red Se oe A OE OP iy Cy CH C3} ret OG wy Oe te OG et Oo Bet wy 2 ks 2 + i . y o™ PS O UO kp Ep Mb Lab Oh tal sop ee yg ky --~ OF OD Gow Ge GF Hb a DO Phe 2) Gc cap al OF ah @i cH iy CH Ag Gy Oy GPG kp ay O £2 wm ey mG a eG OG a Sp mM te ag Mee I ky Me he, 4 me . . : M6 ga 4 " > . ' : _ eg po ws Rio Of UO CY Gp ap Gp | -edf oy ey "- Ty Hp Oo, mw eG mH OD Re ~e fe OC, a iy wy EG Ca 4s nm z O wd rv o 4 2019, i i 4 3 O18, 2435/2019 to 2019 to 4 oe 4 wn {Se é 2
449. OA No. 764 19 un 5 C by , i mG 5 -f Bi a «3 cS TG ct a t "ig = eZ ye 2 i O OM a. a et ty yg » ' . s y os "tt i yp aeee$dgmy aa g 3 e cd 3 UP Ay Ma 4s ks CET ch a a oa ey ty tea ro O B Go try fe daa on a ry, "- ho md sed ted £2 LY ted ed By eed ved BPD G5 rt ns 43 a 4 £3 a O hog a a UE 43 et Sek rd tts hy a 43 o coat $4 6 wg $4 th ws 4 o é & Si red 2 ee 8 Pty pe 03 ag Q ot Ww cpl oO eas Gu Og Se DBO Be a ys Bs wy ed hw o age DUE Sy oy : ke Qe ' hk "rt | a 4 th 3 # eq hd 2 & > z. a < oy oo wef a oa 3g tied &., es , A ae Pao Rot. gk apy OF 83 Ca w i 8) a Ou "ey mr Our bbl 4 & G rue ae Te & BA EG fn cel oa PO Ss 6m" + iL a ee G wat ? mt 1 yy wy SOM RO e @ gq , 7 O Pg 2 ® . & 2 A 8 ty ty BM it 8 4 ae u BG a Gy, sm Ou BRA MOON fF Ga SOG ay yi Ge gg 8 PD OB e 5 9 "4S @ g uw PR @ oi Bet od DO he By Ho * th M4 @ % cS OD % Mj BI ve 43 Ty Gy uy AS ty od uy Yt fy oN gt iw "Ft it ag tt a is KG seh AY hy j Q; B Og wy aes, 4 ny a 4 . CS 3 i 93 cs BO BP Be SN Oo ol a ote OL om yw me og & eG ' eg 7 Fe '> f r Fn Ly " eel js % roel one 3 ca , ape Bese Sou" BR so Boge Ge et a, © SB 8 & yO oe by 4 oO ve uy ge 8 e 3-2: £3 tS RI FE wed 0 eg Etat eq C} £3 wt got as AL SS a ot ij ko Bi ny _ i 0 4 Ad ge 43 i ® 3 Aa & oH é bu eg aso GU | HAG OT, 6G OE Re BS tha ow & 6 « 8 G EG oH "| pay 3 oy y OS f os mt * tao. » : * & > > 7 i SP aS sO wy te BB & EG gia roars mo Ok G Boom OP ti Zp og G ® " 2 wg Fe py ie byt a ret if sot ¥ $3 gs 1H SS x my Gs rg CO BY AQ , @ ap g O ha G Ay Ye Se t ° pe Us gag a Bg hE ay OD El te i on i Bo, i or ae wm ® + yw Gal GS car 4 OO Bo Ss a "4 a } a tS w
- ¥. , kt ae 4g ; ie . ray 7 i Me. ss oe red Og eB Bos Beri ig I OD GG "e te ab yD Oy @ ae yt g 43 Se ge 43 fs EPO 45 co w ' 5 2 w my ty Bas OY Q of SS gg ROE Bw oy re a a ed 3] o% CS ep ty mH ow sd me Oh re ode ORS oy if 0 CG A OQ rr 90 oa Pein g ® se Sg 8 OS Gm ew © "& 9 & GO Th gy re Gy ee ag OR Wo OO ty a 48 t Reus ey oO UG Bo 6 sxe Ga 8 % om or ie YB a a Bod Ee a yao Be Soe Boe eG eG 5 hs ook Bs ah Meh ng Os te ts og oy uy im do w fos eS ada thcrt fe Cogs su B co} 0 45 4 uy G 4a Oo U O7°O & neg ty B tr; ay a on fs a 4 Qa ky 43 "3 any $4 wD ve e Aas SO cm F tee, , 4 : ' "s CP oS LE $s OS u3. 4p spd re wat het 44 fo Sem ee a ha 6 OF t % Go og Soe a oo hy Boe FY @ EF A +g. aA ' . , the Sa ROME ord ke kG ky on ie Gs 4 re ort ve: oe 4 © eH ab O Oo mw 8 oO Be "HE O eo Ro 2B C, vy e i a % tos fe e © 7 =<) ae . it ct & v4 tt ba Ge ; DB > ord * a ft = . ny J .
"8 , 2 2 & « , 3 o ip € Ee £ 8 Hog OB 4 k hy m a a it a iS mt G we a wv wd Fal i oy Ks o 4 Ss w wa ! is 8) © w thd we ot CO Y ms @ it & HS = gs 4 b or i a G G i @ @ co rd C % a o xa a ts D Amos et MM ord oO ie a eek a Ra a 'S 44 a vl 6 43 6 ae os ao a4 oy rei tng ts set Ws Sd 2 in & % @ "eb r eet ce a aoa Ft a cy wD a on fa Q © eon as hd i rt fi a w soy CD cy @ GC Pe Pa "4 "t3 ft ms ss # end - » Ct W en o 0) 4 43 ag I O rm 4 5 Gag > 2 _ & O fF Oo vi Bs rt a Noe BB 5 o p 8 @ 8 8 5S 8 . * YO a 3 GO So o > @ ge SS oy OS ed a4 ws eo at hs a o a it a "rt a 33 fe Oo, mt Os @ a : - Feb MH GB yy 8 OQ 4 ma fa SS at : or} & ed 3 am eet ee) ey KE a @ OQ ge Me « ca) a OS os OF 4 a 4 i ¥, r ved be Shy 4 in a uot "WS a re} in a3 ee CNY Son OT , 3 ud & bE Ch @ } 4 4 art RY §5 3 Fey om . 3 od ee S Bos a od oO rl 6 @8 49 > oF Ce oO 2 aS 3 4 3 4 "ae ns ; 5 © rs m4 3 k mM aes " FA & x 43 a ® oe ha 2 2 oS a an @ rt oa be M ~ oF ro gy os '" © 8 of SR af on og & Q Gb oe ot a3 4 end So Ss "4. ha my odes m ' og : eC . in a st os = os FO 4 ts ae 6 1 @ rg be bd 3 54 we & Oo Qo ft 3 Ci Pt oe a st Ww ke oa ryt ye 3 ¥ as cA 2 iw « a3 Sg ee LSA a. OP is o oe # » GG 2 ts Pop 8 3 mn OD iy te my cs w ; te , S24 r on et * " oe 3 o a & Oh a i> 4 3 a bed ' = re 3 3 ed es i b4 a ty Kee e a rey + wn he ue) a & 0 7 a o a " 4 4 a $4 an oy 4G 43 a 2 Ma wy Q oy Oo ee c $2 03 4 " "ea es ig td os 4.3 , @ £h; 0 hy i xed o 4 os $4 a 3 5 3 <3 Of SP os GeO 42 Mf eh et i a a Be i 4 wy bd oO XS Oo ed o a ug n {3 a i Dae QD £3 oO o he by Om ff oo wy go & os om go @ rh aay g wy cra ny EY Mi @ a] iy iat 7 fo ka a) e * ww ue e v3 4 xy iD re fut yA Ha A it Rt o w) @ Ne ~ ag 4 c oe m 2 <3 6 9 a5 os w 44 es oF Oo ug x» Soe a t {3 43 3 43 is eS G cs 3 Ke ze . g3 $4 "- & ca Go 4 ws : Q 4 oF - j ' as wg . 'Sj 8 bay ort Q i "3 & a ee fa a rs 7 @ 0 QQ 2 Aas Cy Get ci @ (i i oe 55 MM f wn wo G Oo C ba hy 7s rts) i ved W s CO 3 g a 6 a - be y "A ra ' "4 tt or 4a w ard § ay 4 ~ ' i ct rd a GB hi Bg gs eh ® y» 2 8 Bg & og BY : vo 4 nn ns cts Go 8 B® 8 Re 63 et i & oS BG Oo os & KR @®© & 2% Go op & G6 @ 4 GF om @ Mo ® S Ye Gm & a 8 3 6 Os nO OQ ort ay ea ba LE 4d ord iH A w 6 oor wi os <4 40 . Oo 1" CH rs a fat oO 6 wn uy i oO 43 os ie < XE "Ch 2) @ ss x Et "3 bg i) in werd {D a ® ard $3 gree} ee g wv ia ' D> it os oot a te od ha ved dea ad o o i 44 on - 3 ad a3 : vet uy « ved i i" 4 44 ai v8) ~ q C » g far bd m3 x4 "c 3 es ® i a) 2, ved o ES) a "4 a ' 3 Be aye 5 @ Beet at cs we ll bi os we q o a be ved rs a {2 + rt $4 @ i 4) 4 @ mS rj <4 Dy wD @ $4 $4 hy Dm 41 a Ch @ Yes @ cS ic + 0 <4 3 Re EG Bh 34 & B ay . 44 a q3 Hy Q, ia Sa Weg T xa * ing » ' ha RY n 43 43 43 44 a hy ~~ ce) G Eo aa its) °o 4 O or a3 ay my AB oO A20F9.
a 2019, f co 326:
O19 to 439/2019, § 18, 245/2019 to 3232019, O19 to 4 io ae 449;
sy fe 3h:3
io 2019, 4 e 366 x 12 aw AS be id ¥ COU 0 £ s G g «sed B a seh ay nee SA RAL way te BU y nat ar ion :
wpe . -t » r et "ct . : pe + } Tey in oS se @ a$ Ae a ; net } 7 a 0 wy a wn ec 4 cs @ ' Y C o a @ BAK FT ee & SO 6S et @ GS 4 9 a 8 8 te CaS? 6 wo UG 4 a Be "4 43 og OU ms SSS ' . Hi a ri ted GB os ag i" 4 oles a C aM # + sed Oo 4 ane o 8 @ Fa oR 3 w@ "t 4-4 iS 23 bg rd rn ce D ch on Q as m ay oT 4 5 co AO Og 8 @ & oO on ® 2 a go of m% & "4 43 © ~ G Bone g Roe yr OG wh Egy PR, @ 0 4s ® , 43 3 hd i fs % . a a w Be ka we 3 Speed on, a 3 s oo ' Ft a weed reg te & hea 3 a S3 gy 4. OF omy Is . Bee "rr io 43 Ae Ly hd vr. uh 5 a ' oo as a xt «ed » Seats a3 " a } Pad ce 8} by ot ie 721 & So * ba y & ma i ® 3 ie @ & @ a + G at ry oO set oO ba & 3 SEA GE, ee es hy Oe aD i Q ty Rey be fe ord & Q FO BD Med ra O oH aS e bs i @ a Qo, + e ms ae L ' Se OQ oe 2 + ot eS B Oy hy iy wo 4 me = ord ri 4 iB py a of as ' a 4 a sore s c Sb-3 rye ~ j "ye ML * cid o 7 ON Wd @ ay MH és 3 in » , 2 : $2 : O : . f - " ma eS wD a ah {) Get CO ZR o ~ 3 - 8 Pg o pe 8 Ge we 8 Bp og o & OS % iv ts, 4 at @ 54 . WS : ty te 4 <3 & 3 Wig BG & oe ¢@ @ oR 8 2 a Bo ae Os fos red 1%) Oy ei oad ws Ls a tt ay ; on aa « ¢ 4 ec Be 43 ° aS o | oO 7 RUM GC 8 "eR la 4 4 G4 G or fs ae rd Cl be 4 cf ty ca + a bed ; &y w a i of G ' a4 2 wn o Q ba ve od 4 re o cs wD cs O rs he xe i S iy aS S44 ay & . wD ha a ae Ty Go a4 i ot & KS on iS & 2 a: © 2 . " ms wa ved iv Q 3 ea wy . 3 Ad i Sa ' 7 } iB t3 a ¢ oe ro ¢ Ae ce o "0k OG PF og 6s NOR § OG QB 8 OS a gO root ay = "4 ws a ty * vet Fea fy . Me aw AQ vat y TS fa 6) vied a4 t oo Oo vet Sed peel 4 o AG 6 LE 4 or DQ ip reas yg am «S "§ " Ki 44 we wD is 43 Q ri in DB 3 4 Bs wd 3 is) 1S at . sy or) oy in Cs bed et , a ra M4 oh C 3 «€ ww (ts xe is Pe re ort 0 we 44 bed @ 4 o re BY , 44 a ae io 4 Rat wy £3 a oY el a Oy fe bg | SG Boe 4 C @ a 43 3 or ay 4-4 ® G ay al + y {3 na Ld wy ay-t wed Ant { 4 3 1 . MS LER a 2 & a 43 ra B © ® © G me Oe +3 ° ne ~ ke gd 8 fF w& A a BoB og Po. gs go yw B Boe Fg p Bon A 2g hed Ad 4 er i GQ $4 , re 5 ty " xg wd a 6 Eo a doa N gon @ | GC om RB og @ 8 rf & Som Bow yo iF 8 GS NB 0 oS +4 3 hd 4 as ny 3 - = al rt sed ua a vite : 4 4 Bs a 5 ca a "4 mo a a tf 3 & by pa is ida o us | 5 ri fe B ' w Fa Bs 44 Med <2) 4 v oy > 44 , ic a AR i} a ak aed c " 34 7 m @ cl a ° . {0 43 = " 6 wS 'y BG So 4 QO © 6 th io 1 B "ed a ie: a bd zt So we Cm © 3 ie gs ee 4 o 7 hed it e 3 e to eS 0 43 B i © " $3 Ga a3 i wn 2 » ¢ + 3 set tf cS baz c S&S a go t & i 5 CK, w O © " w v c us . o (i 3 vt os Dp A w . uy i 5 a MSS My uM i ow @ i cot a es a mo i Ww sed oo Q 4) 2 $4 be © ia os 4 es 65 b te so ed ved a es Sf OG 44 Dp ent wl "hag ih Ag oh ay eo) fs ord ort rt ~ u 45/2019 to > oF764/201 8, ¥ :
a OA so anes eo th 4 i a a : vrs ae 22s & 4 6 oo « © @ & & » 3 gf @ ee ee ec oof mm ri So 4 G ne x! im Be Ear » « Gg gf & 0 aa eG Bg a cS 8 Bo ne oe GB ort ' SR mo 6 Gs Q SG By a nm B - % a «@ is fa ee ay a 4 9) u 6 a n @ Mk v fo eg % ¢ & j -- a ; ns B ~o @ uy . ye u at oe @ % Bf 3 2 a) 3 "
NBs w& goo 44 ws & tf a fbi eh gh pe : i 3 4 @ aed on 4 w a3 my @ EG ' } @ 4 "ef Le kg a c wt eam 3 B "a a ha ds Ss vel + oh x Ao a a ed "5 43 a ° ; ha " a 3 ' 43 a } ij aS * oO Ba G@ FP @ ow GB pgp G 8 & 2 kw Woop i cat oe & ~ as , wt a 4 a Bed ' 8 ey oN & 7 ad 8 wd % rd a we eS D 2} 2 S 0 3) 84 4] ee 2 2 B ao og 6 B FS Oo Og s 8 © 2 @ & "f : mn "set B ce "ed "3 nt a a oe @ koa bey ea o oo ¢ "3 & 0 mG Eg & of fo a os oo « 7 oe as im med B ' os ° > 4.4 ud fe ; vd "4 2 g vi ce i én a 4 sy 4 3 ao & ted ea te 4 & ret a oO oO the 2 a ca ' "3 be Q n , a 3 5 a 4 @ " eR ey Ss , & ® 4 er ee es " , 4 : x hs im - ' an 2 ted of 13 oa s ct ved "eg 43 eo 8 on fy, ER ' 6 Bo og OB O on ' © G "4 e rod ta a oY at 4 us an 4 j i fs iB o | Dp me 3 "og HG « o "3 @ oO, @ Hast ed #8 Med , re 5 i 3 vod " ag mq ig fe 7 hd GC Py tS eM 43 4 . 44 "2 43 5 Sy ry if ay wy y & 3 t w 5 "a u a y 3 iy ay A os uy 43 ft cH ts ri eC haf BB wD , " a or rhe * ¢ mn "e ce ae ase t 3 o vw BG # 8 Bw & o i og 8 8 8 ® ww 2 re ae: et ® = = > 5 8 # « 4 5 . oo. , 2 : wed " - -$ : J ' . D © 03 rt 4 BO wm Bop By OM yo fF HY & 6 © ¢ ~ o . seed % ib se4 * od » Oy of vet 2 hs + + & S mod Yo 8 Be gg a a A 8 i, eR ' ent ral fa i rd a kt oh " a a 3 eon 8 Et i @ g wg i G9 ® Hh sg Bo @ g 8 BB cw Y " é ve e ee "#4 v4 i " bind . 44 i. & yey $4 * 4 y 5 ho ? Cy 4d 49 rt o er i hy ae & rs] vet ra wy bef w By s os ww 0 x 3 o iD & ° € ated ard tf 7 i ah ag ¥ ne A Poem = 3 ape oft : 3 ted > a ra @ " ka % @ wo oe o @ 4 ' , Gs % rn oe ' oa : ae xs a % i G 4 1 bs he ty «s N a Mo : R4 o§ 4 G 43 2 oh, G 4 % re 3 hee Cc Sd t % - © B a , OF 4 , cf $4 ri o 3 5 O od . L % 4 ' kG a ined vA '3 ot i f " ond > 3 8S » GF 8 7 SB ee o & FE ss 6 ££ @ @ & B 8 6 8B Be gy ' % p ha ® Ay O 4 a wD Mat C 4A C3 mh OG ' mi / oS bed oa Aa ~ \ tS ii} a4 s 4 i - a "e rrr 44 iy "
~ BD ¢@ om a 6 #2 Bo ep og ae 4 B if & Bb, MY co o te oa 3 % > as + ef 42 44 fy ved G 2 ag + ed wD whee + oe £ ey c F: s a 4 i a v} % 4 % C5 : og hi © x c . : Qs ) tts - 4 / if 3 og @ 7 £ cy + ha te a © a fa 4 ' i 4 ; 3 d : r 3 «st 9 bs 43 rd ti . Fe at 4 Beha uy q £3, oh reg es 3 a wy 8) oF > " i$] ' + , 2 ve 3 4.8 iB wy be im oa Be Oo & ¢ @ FF = 2 8 £ BR MBM 8B BO ww oe om 6m Ul BO :
ewe fe RO Gl Ue lhlUuwal UU et aot whos 4 cy hed ps 4 26/2019, S/2019 to 5 ae 3 9, 436/2019 ta 439/2019, O19 to 4542019, Z. m~ ee i ' 449 2019, 3235/2019 1 i é 9 Q OA No. 764/201 8, 24 2 "y ij :
"366.
aed a4 At @ a %3 v bed * Q D> @ eo Cy Ad Le 7 @ Co i 7 ge 7 2g SS d he at cy .
oS ct 5 34 & ed Cc @ % Cs am ca bs 6 3 oA fs Sa Aa or Ct o ort 2 Ss wd 3 mi o a + we in % bet of 3 \a HM o 3 fig ® Re 0 "% a : mG ar @ YD h4 ws a ot ut ' So @ F & oO fr . 8 ® 2 a (a O : @ o oy uy th; * a rs) bm Ma 7G a G . "st Sy 4 2 i a o} o 6 : m " q '3 nH a eg - 4 Cy " ra 4 Q oO 3 35 4 © tt ® Qu 4 '"O t nan} *. Mi wa Bey or} uF 5 nd i ved mG tea o Pe Ss OU 43 &i a ® id a 6 as s) . r £2, 43 2 % aored o w : 43 Se ot Bo So oH fF 9 6 © on 3 w . wed £E ba + rt rm o o os "h ct ht a w 5B oS ; at ve 4 my G a 4 w ad o B 8 a wi ah gs a oO AS @ Be ond ws 43 as ct & 2 6 4, on z 3 44 oO t ~ C s oo. a / 43 44 # a ed G} Sy 27 at) " my eG ct on ay on $a , fa eo C 7 064" GG ey r ; § . { Js i © Bt ot TY ee wp x " 3 uj t whed co Poe oY 8 8 8 GE ~ . f 3 4 a.
~ He 8 om # BH oe 5 a SF * SF oS Gp SB fe So B a al gt H cred 5 e ty ed 43 ths . ri o 3 ot " : iy "ef ~ ced 8 i ; 4 " uw a n oy cc ord Hs 3 Peed ny . n ht a Jd a mn h oS 2 vel ehh $4 a fs © Bi a aE Ss "3 vor a 4 hed @ q CQ @) 3 O & @ & & RR OM Mw Oo . > 3 cs st s ty 2 ra good GO $4 wy mG * oy pa Q "ed 6 44 4 : ao Q wd ~~ a SSS SATB BIBI aI HH Wt gg gaa de nee deed weneee eee .