Karnataka High Court
National Insurance Co. Ltd. vs Mr.Umesh on 19 January, 2012
Author: Jawad Rahim
Bench: Jawad Rahim
152 THE §~§1§§*§ CQQRT G? §<.fi.R§\§éJTA§<§ CIRCUS" EE§%C%'i AT §%*%§R'xi'2ft3\§ mcrga "ms THE :97" ms; Q? JANUARY, 29:1': 5 _ BEFORE "SHE HONBLE MRJLESTICE éAw:A§%f:;{A5i'M 3 MEA. Ne, 2a3es'a;,~i%:%0:a'L'<ir\4&&:§ = AA . BETWEEN:
NATIONAL INSURANCE CQ:"LTfi%_. " ' A"
I FLOOR SUJATHA COMPLEX; A P, B. ROAD, HUBLL.
REP BY ASST. MA'§\§£§C'~;ER§;
SR1 v. C. SHI.N(3\fA;f§l'f\j_g3.'»il§Pf,€ APPELLANT (av SR1 cgp\{:fPx:1Q:\:;a;;§::%;;_p&V'rz;:3«--S:$}¥:3;R,, Am/5,} AND E. MRA:M'»E}SH
333. BASALINQ;-.fiPPA %':'L3€vEBAR {.%%iEEs':SEiF gags As %?:%'a iL;§%v:E»SH & S¥E'8--?§S as Swag);
1 =.g§E;z§ .'§§,éRS; ass SUSINESS % T§;;£>;%%.§;x::;a?;<:%§{sRAM ;SAU§'xf§AT'§E . "5>?g%L§:'*髧:;~;f%f§"'?§'°"§'Q§ 8EL§;iUiv'§ 3:53: V' x «TQ. '$A:;?~s§,a;T'?L 9:3'? gEL§;am%, E. §"x£",fl}S.'é:'§?§A} A§=:§éa??A C?%ACHA§E §§'E éaezggag, R53 Ei*;§AR§§i, R.ES?%§'sj§§§':ET$ {8':'' SEE : GURBRAE $3., §'iE§%,?I'ié§;I§. ASKEL FQQ §:§; SR? T §;»a§a§*§"§§:~% fig mLA@@i;m§, ,é$a;: ma R2} Km) "§§-{IS E'=:€.§:A, ES EZLEE LEZSEC, §;?3(3;:: GE "§"?'§E MQEGR VEHICLES ACE} i§88; AGAENS"? THE JUEGMENT A-?€.iD AWARE SATED 1?.G4,2SG§ EASSEB EN 517725302 ON THE FILE SF YHE ABEL M.;.ég;£gT;;;~ 3 SAUNDATTE, AWARDING THE COMPENSAT_§'i§N ~ RS,3,8Q,OQOf- WITH INTEREST AT THE RATE ..QE'~--5%.A_1'P,A. FROM THE SATE SF FETETI@v§'s§*""~T.F'LL.'_4 ;5E;A;*§'L§ "'63?
REAia$IZATIfl%<3 THIS §'v'LF.A. CGMING ow .:=:"2.R ;:®'§v2:Es1';;:Q:\%V}?:*A:--g3}$;%% :aAfs,'E'E THE CQURT DELIVERED THE FQLL,jQK'.'.\€ENG.: V ....'_Q¢...,...=......._......
Insurer is in appeai iai§a'i'né%:--.i;fn}'e j_:§§£§%<;;*:1§5en.t and award in M,V,Cg Na; S:3;?;!,:<2}_:G2 i§:A;u¢>$i;<3r1§Er€[gfE"_::?f§ev' Quvrantum as age entitiemem: bf _:."iIr1:7ei'""-..§es;:§§2;1c'--e_ri5:"<_§Ea§mant ta receive Sam pensV3ti%jr;'; E. ii;
2; Apfagai is i;>--=r3s;'Tta:=;;§,.fG--sf§émis$§e§2g .V j€.).,} f.' 'fiaaség 'A as gees; {ha resggfifisni: ifinzegh SG:i§§"5Z éa3_r%§E¥3;gEé1$é*:';~ai_§§ saw': 9% §\3$f:?,§?§;S§G,»"- regaréiag Seaih V . cf Eééze £;.%%~;»'"b:*§':h§? Asmi §§§§§i§3:§§@$§ Kumbar ii"? a %;?ieZ%:1§§Ee §£C§§§§E'C 5?: §S;i2,§2§i':: §¥E\iQE'a5§§E§ Kmgtic E %%§<':;€é!ai'!a5 mag: aycie bearing §a:$,§<;:':a 24;'TE~§2?;i we the fieaf ", E 'é L. mmw;mmmmmammmmmmmw.._'w_ ., , wéflé he wag siéing 3:; a ggiiééan wiih éééisgb iaéafiav ém ?%£?€§' 9? '£516 meta? ve€':::Ee3 asazés éegh am :":eg§%ge::*:, 3 'fine aggeiiani: hereéa wag <:en:§:$tEr:g_-'§é§;:é5é:.{§é':1:'... it resfied the ciaim; an '-'ghé greuri-id; ;as:<'a 'i;':2_§*r:2~i:%i%e;e*' waisid Rs: 23%: entétisefi is £655 §f'%fi_e;>§2nde%':v.r:;r 5:n3",gé:.:gn.:fi:V1>y;; the izséema 59$ sf the de<:€a_;s é:::i_ was .i"3LE':.__§§"Q:§3€F§y indicated 5; $3 Ci;".>fi';1'i:":~IS*£§§ _i:_%1e~: :;f§'£::?fT's .._«-;;é::%i%0;§W wag géégwefiff gramting %2_§{zf} i":?>.;%":';s%:~?;§§sVa:§;;§r>_ 'é::"a___suV:€'2 :3? Rs§3§.8G§,{}S§,f-3, with :;vb§cEi:_ he '§gfl;:a§"V!E'§i'V'$'\aVt%L-:':f:連§E' "§he respcadgnt aiaémant g:2:*'e€e§':*e:€ we Cam': Seeking _a::§"2.a§':;;f.a_§%;"2éé:n:*f*::,, ggié a;3§€:&E,, ihe agseééaésiwag PNWCQ ';;%_,§r':3s_ a.%':a3g..Vag a §'€'S§i?«O§"!é%§a"?i' 553$ wag giajfig :*e§:f%:~:§::>:_;":%:é's:;§«A '_§:>.2;%'~§§é%§7e::§ Aéxfeiaie efig&§e$ by E; "fie ajisgeaé"E'zas"--.§:;es:3':;é ?'§€é§'§ aad féaaiigz $339335 3'? {ER me??? '$32' Gsieé 2219332828 sfiisfzzésgéfig ihe agegseaé 3:.' E338 ._§f:ésg%:;r;é'é::?'é§2: s;:§a%r:":§e"2%: i*%'1?1§§":C€E"§'E%3?"%?: fifid aféérméag téze :2? R§.3,8G,,$€}$;-., V'».§§"E%§€ éigwséag if 'me sgma:
mwmmm.mWmmmmm.W_"'.m__ .,, ibis Cczurt {3i}§€.?"€€§§ iinai ihazsgfz She gram: aégpegrs is 'fie mare am {$36 §'E§§?1€€' séézazg. ii was éacimeg is %§:te.:*€§%-s5: ~..v wééh it ag 'aha éngzgrer wag not if': agsiseai §:"n:§":é3éia"i':%¥?%;-- A ""
znereaftez an [email protected]@:a me insurer _éiya,3_ rus§f:'é§"':2*é:%'§§i "*::e:Vs.. apgeai in ms Cami, Since then; its a:::ép.<~.:'a%'TT%$ admissian and has came 21$ for'?1ef':a:f§ng,A'v. 1?; The questiar: én ::%:Es. +:£%§§é:La§if;s; '4 "$53139 if¢e,""J'ie;cf§";r2é%¢:z?."£i__ 0?'. ?"r:'5;' Soagrzf s}?a;§;;.;,'r'e;?.s%. 'C{L%§f?%}Ff??"E?€?' ":z'*2'k's Cfléjff, E3 a?no§_:3*z'er '"3g:<%;3é5:i'.'-~&:,}}'2<:7'éar "$565565? 3,73 of ._"'~g.iVfe7§f>;:§,r_ *-.:§£--ef2:'§£E§....v' Ac: W88 ' h _ ' . ?§°:aAa::s%A;er's'§"'in the nggaiiaxe far the {gages}, '£38 "VAg§§:»?:%V%é§:é: ézfi' t?*:';$_ agjgeai was a £Of%i%Si§§'§§ resgsndent we §a::;V;%f'j'223:;T:,%z1;2§:jg fiéeé by me Cigimanis seemg émhgm::ems:?rv;*:i:..V'.i'~1'%*%2e aggéfiaszé: in iéézig a;>;':>e§E §'E§{.'§ mi £3§":§';f (""3 a;::.;:3ea:*a&r:::$; égui asaiegitefi iithe amgaé :»*'\§§";§C§'% 'i:§"*:%3 §Q§€'§§ 'aaségég a';s§a2;<--;€é 3? €G?'§i:§£"%"§"E§;f?§ $28 ";;:§:é.:;;:%:e5:t <3? "fig: Qsmrz €351 §Z.%3:.2§§xi}t Afier §is§§35§ éézsé: a§;2$a%, wig ggpeaé ég féiegf, §'"%§:'"":C€; *{?':%S aggasfi :f'é_§§§ mi: bé £'"%':a§E§i&§i"Ea§§€;
9 Es: $323: as ii mag; ihe apge§i_Va,;3i_was_--'§3':'i;%'_j§:': ':%*;é:».. apaeai as a respméen: 563,2 and ceafd :';;:.%_§'e:~::j ;::*éééL:«:-. €"1TA objectéan appeaé iv: 5:, if E: was:'[_ag:§.;feecjA'§::x; :%aeT'€g::a._:za.:,m--;1 He SE5 net at; go? We a@pe§_i__a_E:':,_ ';»:_:_:d£3:}'i'}"i:£t~::j:3:,ks 3 Cemgamz irécermrated ""=3»:"1€%Ae%fLi}:%j:é""-- ?Z'.§€r:pa:7§€S £5\C€ egagéjgped amtéw. Legs} §e;3'3'§'i:?§'ent.._*€::_ it am we expeéci a :Em.e.Eg}r.. S§A;§§_::--g%2r:;{'ai:;tg§n*:;f;:fy:"m ,f:iie gar? cf 3&5 C£}E"E€E§'I"%5:{§ fig xsésjféf <i\::~,§f: fcbgirV§';*%€z;aV:*2<;é3$, if the awards; are mt agaiaévi it, 55%; '2;§':<;:.:>V-_.i%"z5fcé":<::f£nSage, E: is Qijiifj' sggbvieus éhaé: 'aha <':2§§§£IZ€§"$ <:<:§s:::e::*§'{3<:i"":ié::§€;:;f1s%b§<:3 ifie Camgaawg fave _¥'€Si}§"§I$£_§ §G*.E?2§S 7§§..§éa% aciiim, gerbags becaage 9:' ihé "<:b:'§§é*:5a?:;<>_V{é.m.a}:§<3 ix; iééég Cami: :3 <:ax;e: :%:§~: @3393, éhééé .;QfE:¥.ges"£.%':::%'_s§;:§:'~§S"%:":5fie is {§%Ef§€:§?" §§"%Si£?é%"2C€ §f;%s""s'§§§:f%E€S fzgm jg:-:*§f'aé':§*s":::§ azzy fsévaisug agjsgeaés, Es": itéze
---._g;g;::'f¥14'%3*5?%:"[§g%s:§ E am 39%; Eaiiémed :0 accegi gm: 5:5? tée sj;§T;i:3é;~§3%i'§"Aa.;z§§é $329 a;'2§ea§ §ga;r:$%; ihe émgasgaeé
-g%.,é;€g:%ze:'::, :sx:%1':<:%2 $333 regcfisé 3%:':5§%%:;g by \5§E'?;é.§c'3* <3? jufigmeszfii @363? :2g{}L.?j{}E€} in §'vE.FA. £'%:>,2234§;'2QG§ $3 merit aigo. "§'%:sref:>re; {fie agigeaé is rjismésgecé ._"
maéniaéaabiez if 5% 3% the Campasgfg mtesest %s_-:§Vffé:':é.;;--§..% 'V' the Qamgany £5 a%: iiberiy is ;'e{:o::er_%f: _frQm_--'tééé*--%5§ff§£i{=E£=,. asncemed, \f\:'§'éG are respgmsibie fer thgg §.¢'3"ps*é' 15, We amount de;3Q_:§'§':,_ arderegj :53 BE transmitted 1:3 the "§'ribu::$"§. _ 7 ham' msmmmmm m"mwmmm"mw_. ,