Karnataka High Court
St Anthony Institute vs Smt Rita D Souza on 1 February, 2012
VEV 'IN THE HIGH COURT SF KARNKYAKA AT BANG§;LC_}E%E DA"i'ED '£'HIS TEE '£53'? 1393 SF 'FEBRUARY, : .G*~:i,« BEFGRE '£'HE HOBPBLE MR.JUsTIc§;"H;B1L§g;§§€;§j_ \?&%"RY£' PETETEON BETWEEN: V 1 V V' S'g.A::tho:1y IY1Sf.iU,1'i€., , V_ A Reiigigus and Chariiabie'*}{.r§'st;ii¢ut:;§;;f1Q A 3€§pu, Mangalsre - 555 003. s Représented by its . if Directer present i;?3<fE'E'}. '§'i3€f;_§, 1:
Rev F':',Denies M-::1r.as1:';E3_:f--abvh:1_, _ Aged about 69 ijzraa;-"S, S/<:>aLate Jegpu, Majf1gaiOr£%{._ _ Pgtitiansr (By EVE/s.{3_y :'i1 Pragarfi $_.%.'T§1;<§'§0§:iatesa§} AND: ' _ 'V '~ . 'D.,fG;§§§::§;6E'@_Q'Seu:e:a, 'fjE€é;::* }\Z:;p§':tft1.;:§:§Q Eiigh ;'§(E§'i®{}L ~ E¥}ia}1ga1i:é_:*.€, ' ~ 1; ' ' ' 2; T L§§d'§':%ba§a§ ?vEa:1§'aEQ:*s§ *. §v'§anTg;»3_ET?:,:r€ §}§3'§:"§<*::, ., 'E}:3§§;s}:§:":a §{a2"3:2a.:E::L :..;%%e$p<:}:':d&%z:{s ;:AS:7Vi'; SA§L22&;%:§«:§E:s::.§§§:;::m"::5:é§.; ESQ? fiat RE "'ii§::s_{;é;{%%: is RE is €,1;iS§€3f§Sf3€§ Wiéhé WWW E This writ pé3§i§i{>;1 is fikaéi L/EI'1{i€',1' Arféities 226 the Ca:m8ti'éL1i§<>r1 {>5 Efidia przzjyizzg iii: quasi? i'iE,€"'<.§'?;f{§§3--Sx{§ié?;i:€?§ V' 1:1L,Q3.i988 passésd by the Lanéi 'Fri!i::::n:«3_2 V' Ne:>.13ES,f E98485 and fur¥:,her d<:::1a%:%; thgzé azld 'mid zmd paaseéid wréfhezgzi: ;"::,:*§;3dic:iC::."-ihe §:<§;g;y'::§' :ééf%:aiic?:
has been hérswizfi preduced at A.fi'aéX1;re - ;'k:_a1:3:i'.=€tié,, This Petiivisn COH1iI1§.§__{}I1 f0rV_fj3rgi:'E:3:_rs--,. this ":i--9y, Q16 Saurég made the fofiowing:
The Eearngfi is §i:'e<:iesd :9 éaké z::)*:££:€ fer %:}:.veV.re_Spg_if:€%-::;::¢ NT®§ig_<=~5éo the first rc3Spend<sn£ is d§sp€Lns€<iv..:x.r:E:E:.. V' * 25 ,é§ €2}.rd V ::.'§1e~E€:a;9:%ss§ itguxizseizi fer {E38 pééiiisfiér arzé;
:~3§So'"I;-ha V'§L$2::*€€{><?: "GQv€§:1I:1{::":€ Pisader. :3'- H §€%;i%{:{m Lméer ,Ar€i<:§es 225 ané 22'? 9?
" .ji,he Cs3r':Si,i.i§§:%a>£i Sf indiza §/33$ geiizéazier itaékad; in f 'é:§§:és}fé:::*sf;ri;"~.:i":€ srdgez" daééd F/~1~'i33.E€~§8§§ pzzsgad *3}; I333 Lgmci V. " '7F_:"%;'?;§"a,: g 9/;':§3;g:,E<}:"€ £3: {.'.E%,:':%*6 ?€:;s;,L§.%2.'§§3i%j E§8é§--a_;Eg §?:T%_§% Est:
Ii Q V ' E3Q.3;;" i§E:%4~--E%§ ::*;d{3 A:113:s:>;:,2:*e ~-- 2%. 3 4}. E}; {has impugned Qfdeiz the Lsszé T :'§?:2;_1:2a1§ %'3a1',3.§3}.€}i"'€ hag gmnisd aec1,zp3.z1£§; zrighis in f3;%%"QZ}_:' C+§:'£i'::£§ "§i'S;i zagpsfzésni ix"; 3"€3S§€€"§ sf Sy.E'~%'@.§§ :2? Maréii V 5; aenis, Siifi §'s3"§,2§.
5.V zfiggrieveé by that i}3$TVp§iiii9Vi:s%_:f" has > paiiitian.
6. The petiiisnsr garner sf Sy.1\§a.§5 sf Maraii s:ite 1'%E0,2Q' The petitiener e;.':4.:€:-.""*§":Vc§ ;_"'- xzariih the first réspafindsizi r€3;':'.f1':'%t5:Vi;:i %:1*1€ Iazzé fer residentiai ;3urp{>s§ 3:: Ths fiysi wrespanéegf: was is';
gessessisz; .3_V,r3c1 $i:§:§¥§?2::.€::1;i"'s§f iazzé. in ihfii year }.§$»r1»~85;. $14}-%}E% I§}Zf$§: :%§$}'.}%i3§1'£i§§§'}'iV §;i1é§ f§1"§T: 1333,29; siaiming §:;::":.1;3ar:$3z r:g%3*:%s.'§:1_T.é*1:5:*:;%;§§::::"£ é3f§§E§§;.§e.55 af Mamii 2:iI§3.gsg mfiasuriizg é :2:§<;':":':s3 sits:-':§_V§§§',§s53';; '§':*:ib1;,;'::g§ %3§3 fig Qztiay éaiecé Z%.%3g $86 ' " __;g:*:;jz::aé.{:§i&z2§3»::{:y fighis ix: fafiaezzr af ihs firs: rssgygzzéezzi
- _E:": ':v;*:$§§%:::?: .§$}z:§f'sE'z:.§§ gf E%§3.:*s§:% zzziiiage, zszaasurirzg 5% z::e:=:::i:.$, siéa j % % E 7?'. Aggrieved by that the p€%:i--'i'i'€>::-53:" E€_4a$_f§§<;V%§ € 12is',v:":<:1tV péstfitioixg that the: ::::::p::g:1::>d arcéfér qéaxzznei He aEs;(> submitted "shat the :'iV§;..V_nW3't_h<>:1Vi: A jgzrisdictiori and ihereférs, {:amf1G'{ bfg E'ur'€he:* he submitiaci that a tenant under thra Lané granting occupancy righés in is éilégaé and sazmat be sus*:air;edV V V. % W '
9. _ A3 Léiiga§'::$V$'V-.tZ?: ;s,V'{ha isarzzeé Gevernmsni; Pieafier ,$J:.:;2§s>rg:e.€E V.impu'gr;'€*:§'V@rd€r and submitififi ihat: fizers 323 i§§:éi::;g§.;:: ';j1ea:*§§; 2?' ysars in agproashirzggi ibis Cguré '2..s.E}:fiC§ :%:'a3_:*é§Qr::_:3;é;§91_€"w;*ii p<3i:%i:i=:>§1 cazzgeé $36 er:€L:eri.ai:1:::é. ES. " Viv Aéisave carefuiijg :é{ms;§é€:::'ed tiia S1§C)Z"3:1§SS§{:ri"§;'E=3 mafie Eé;ég«:°n§§ itsmrzgsi E231; E215 §E§{,§§§()§3€§' and QEESG ihéi? Eearrasfi .€ij;7<_';'v%:;"z:::"::3::'£ ?}€€i§fj%1 8: Thfi 1e:».1:'::§e::% <::;::::ss:§9§s'i:s_r ':Eé£1;._pé:%i:§%:i{}T:=:éz3:fAe;:;3:1::§;::§$d .