Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Ashok Kumar Jha vs M/O Communications on 2 April, 2019
1 QA PI4/2017CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,. MUMBAT. BENCH, MUMBAT.
O.A.210/00714/2017 Dated this Tuesday the 2° day of April, 2019. Coram: Dr.Bhagwan Sahai, Member (Administrative).
Shri Ashok Kumar Jha, Working &s General Manager en & A ngapect ions BSNL Murbad . Rest ing at:
( By Advocate Shri $.V. Marne ).
Versus
1. Union of India, Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd., fs through Chief General Manager, GA A insp, firobe, BENE Sanchar Vikas Bhawan, Cams DRY oho mt ES | At a
a) mB oO tA 3 e ee ~ 5 & Inspection Cirele), 4 t Say me, ~ mochar Vikas Bhawan, Hi os whe o Re be oh, oo & moO tect 1 4 fe OO oH Kx Od ae) o pod Ss KROCOGURTS Office of {QA & Ins Jaynagar, .
{ By Advocate Shri V.S. Masurkar ).
Order reserved on : 26.02.2015 Order delivered on : 02.04.2019 OR PER Sexy ak Wires 3 The worki sae {enersal Shiri Ashak Kumar dha working as Gener as fe oun on 3 5 RE a ee wa cate ys "Te y Manager {QA & Inspection), jarrah Sanchar Nigam FI4?2017 ot OA 2M 2 2 ee uf 4 m 4d Ned 33 i oy a c : a ;
D> 5 O te € rm OR : " d ; aS Oo C a a O uss O oa a we oa hd 3 @ aon vert vet GB Co st od ort e @ ed ct Q ba Fa ~ OM & . ae » xs bea wn od aed cae Q Dy YD G rd . i oy Pie! xt oF D $3 vot a $3 " 4 G DQ. 2 cH be Pd 2 "3 2 ' on ' ' Ret i ny ip rf aff ib Ch ye GQ 3 es et a na 9 ny = mn Sf & 8 Oo 1 1 c VF ¥ Gg x B : Shug 3 + 3 : 2 ral ft od » o mn ed # 8
- ay 8 As b iB 4 M4 ge. « £5 wr oN sad 'l a ud ch ce, wy } a a w 6 aed Bod % j ret sot ies GC 6 eed 7 Ee w a "4 ® "2 a nt - c pas o z ms red i & th $4 wh ea 4 ei BS 5 e a 3 be wo, ; i " od "sd a + G "et a © 49 nn re v4 ra an in ey : -* "ed *K G ge « eg Aed Ae ns es 3 oo a 4d at ed od tt 43 ia Gey as 5 i * wd ; Oy mn £4 ' cH aw ceed om 3) os ct os i ot ga % ost " 4 44 4 a Fa Sh eS ~ 2 © 2 Gg rg BS Q iD a Oo ee os CO wt gt Ss a an a rr :
1 w w us co D & Lied i : e a Q @ ce i wy wy " i. 4d wee Ba te) ot " oa 9) ion ca) ® 3 a
- ; fa 4a eo 3 ' : ' Ag < ny 4 na .
ha u} et 3 vs os ' 42 my 4 CG on ; ne ot . x a4 £1 : o 5 a) n cs des x c ! o hey @ 4 ee oy & 3 es 3 x an fo ry mn OO i m th tee ted me o 2 e at a 43 cs i 6 ee fs o oO fo os ® FI i GQ 4 Cy fe bea set 3 Sc wef ms mB a2 . % i a " oy sh oO 2 . teed ides ci re) Ey Ae) © ee 4 oh ; " i 4 ur ae Os . io fon Au 3 ~ ° é a rs es 2 i w + ; is iG ish es . 5 sj moe 8 6s o , # @ 8 & Mw a eo fo 9 & 8B en: > 3 ae o ' Oo eS ' . ™ 3 Se 1 & "<p rook at a T mt ~ ' a a we om Ys on fons 7 n > . oe am : My AG 5 Qt mn a Se = eed oy cc Aa ry ta 45 oO © Ao oe 4 B e 4 a 2 aed © Pet « $e o os ~ Go 4 Cort TE a te Bo %) i cy a sy z ot ' "rf a G cs & Cy ce S23 he a * at C ' es my ; a Set , isd $41 we Se ~ ca. 6 met te 'het Co » 4 ra "3 at 1 fe ay 42 4 G m a us 4 o a 3 oo 42 . > i } a) ; a OY oR i E Pay ni an S yD : , 08 ® sh bef ved 3 by Oo ™ os (2 od wos \ a § > Oo fag wy tp ww 4 3 a ay a 4 ce iS rt " a ed 4 a fis) i i My oO > @ Sf * is c 52a a e~ & eed 4 ed £ a £ w . Ox oD - 4 3 ® ~ © mM G rl Ca a > > (3 £3 i) wy rf wt {3 ro a G 43 % Ch wy 4 A ' ne f~ ra ils By *% cess c iw a x i hd ne ' ~ a ef 9 Oy wy oy wy wd wd a ce) bei w hed in he bd oS Ea He vt ay td oh Q JS 3 wi os a as 4 itt ct 2 ' be w nm ei 4 Th re at m4 Led t
- 4 S&S 8 8 & 9 fg HY FP ¢ ™ mA : wd A \ in me i. ms a Set fos + G a "4 =. & be 43 er} w ° & ie fed ad i ) , wf oS om < cs % ) #3 ~ 4 iB a 4, 4 s e 44 . a 3 a is rot . ha os Cy 1D nf a * LA ¢ a Q Sey * a ood ; * oi ' 43. . oh ; 7 wD = a 4 Sof ei 4 @ io a b Yel AS , "3 re oy oy 5 as A BE @ ° hs G 0 a Pu bef i ted + as a . & oo o Pa rs Le aC eG es 3 3 oj : o o YF & oy @ i sts ig eo " * wy o cee a Me * Pea i va Ba Ne, os, : 3 , #2 ne ar Goa 3 a ey 5 7 2 8 BS S$ 6s " Ss % Bo od aS wen re) by wn eS tad ty bed ye ' OD os c O i % ms G " a 6 Re 2 O { Pa 23 a ted " Cc oy * 4 rhs 3 5 aw v 4 a 7 e i es ot i CG co th ' a4 +4 be mM cs a Q OG 4 i iv & "3 ct " 4d ye ao 7 SP eg 6 % 8 . ' 4 Ol ~ 3 vd 2 me v5) c w 43 Q ° mo a a of fo a i a a fa ' we eet "en uy Ms fh; te - ny 44 . . thy 'a " oD @) gs oo wd AS o a) a o ~ * ee O, i " ' i so ce om @ ori ad ya Pa Go 'pb Ge o & es Q fe A a td Kok 43 Mb "g 3 2 iS So et 04 ts ed {9 a ts o gC " we a G c Q 1 3 i wo as 6 mA ® a o ni ne nt r nb "A tf ct ka os. 44 ex Oh Fad, 43 Q y a it ye de Ld
4) cad x Th m 0 w Q aed we. Mo oe 4 "4 ing iD ta td « a S © a z is 0) "4 ! ; . i © et ved th vied me: o ; Ct - o " - ty o rae ib Ser a a Fe f; a p o mg i . " 2 nO Oo a a oS @ g 8 goon ® eo a 2 Ud % wn ce e Se a & t i "s int ss, 4 wi ed 5.4 ay Ke ra no ¥ aw he vgs $4 bog wy mi Ct st se "4 ot nm @ 8 Ho Be ° " OM ga Feats _ @ eo > OU 1 gO wm igh wD tha ; 4.3 Fd a : ad "E i} sed hey th o ces G a a mS Si a ' hte eg, ; vet 4 eS Boe 8 'he o a 8 & Dp oo 8 f © jp hs Qu os * vt hood" <= @ coy OM A rt wet eS << 3 tet 5 5 Ri @ et a * oe el ee & Ps i a D wt 4 i a it D . a * el y e y . a 4 ri v5 5 bt road "3 wine a5 Cp ed " ord Jd a w qt Tau 4 the vt a 43 ed yer @ ts wt q) gt vd a @ a Ss n fo : o Got a6 OU si a es uv is $4 a bee as , @ w on we $c oy : - x mS a Pei ts "a gc a O i s so arf & mK wee arf 'A t-4 "4 + Ks or ee hs 4 a 0 mS i ie e a ted Y ag @ ; ; kt oO o a ate is 44 . a C3 3s mi e mi wy ~ Oo C4 a '4 bt vet vo a in = : a Ma + ch ¢ 8 4S : a re ih oi v sw] Yet te + n =x Q id a Oy fy he a 5 os ab w ; @ id yo u Z° C4 my . 3g a) a we B Yet p = Oy, ' o q A) wd , oN nt "i " , 8 : : » Fo 8 B x Go oe eG Ms ak com ba M yo At 5 Uw!lUlUB UO BR oo og z a fa o rt 0 -. ele (i "ed s rot "tS ie ths wh « = 4 'ha Q ef 4 So of BT @ fom GM © es ee en 0 a
- oo RR a gi "ed Y ot Med ee) ry 3) @ G * ee wi ts vl ' #3 ' wo be at OG a4 rt H 9 & Nes ant O . | i "agp . bs a} g Ad me, Y rae oe 6 ord Fe n G at ms oy i a ce oS & : 4 . ws "53 4 oC ; as ED :
wy 2 A 8 eo ip 8 i 8 SD bk a og "¢ * a m yo eg a * * eo 8 5» & § @ & oH so fo 8 8 ag 3 ee Boon G4 fda fas} QD Pan a o cS a 3 ca} ka an e a ms fe i on os ae) ith " mw co aad " che wy fs C _ sed , : . a } * hall fe u oo a OO Oh a hg a wee, " hd < S Eat of et * 3 § © : "4 tet wT oy ee fy te ww @ a m= "4 on 3 we ™ ~ a ob N An Ba rod nA 9 ond "7 ht fed fh Ra hee oo a * a w Cd se 2 Os @ CG 4 yp QL?
f2 OOA7E4.
"4 Lo 44 m3 ra ae co i bd ical wy ped
-
-
IT), h E u t 2 im reo "nf "a 2 5, Pog ks = i é ttt v4 ah c i .
i i G 43 rl a - ca 7 i a i a j t yy , ed o on oe s ;
wo % Bt © 3 za ~ oS @ y ved ry oH 5 2 x th eed ba ws La .
da £fA oGM ) h a da ¢ G o 8 re Go ™ i re ee er "i ey ne os - ce) thi oO us ee ns Soa { a ba 2 "6 ch; ed - - é gh a oO iw fo 4 mn 44 Lt ord am weed gi we ~ 2 i bea md a3 4 43 i) = , wt aa ue 43 © eet a ma, x j x3 ei, 43 3 a oe a { va] aq . cs iG 5 tom if « yO 7 Cy S ied M3 Se 8 «a a es Om 3 2 ay io) c 4 3 Dg @ © 2 ok os es '3 ort oy + wn a a a iD. rod i : mo. OR Ea i aa me G t am tt rod ce A g ai @ vid a 2 @ . mn, aw me seed re ad Je + fest crf } Mw GS tel Q ¢ ry ~ a i sa * LF th 2% , &} f+ xf B Q c 3 . . "= $3 NS ry ws ca 6 63 G4 43 " i ; RG thy okt eh Qs oe eG 1a 7 re TS 2 o C5 a 4, a ~ # 6 8 fas a we 2 5 2 py to a :
ert ° 3 ie = E Lac LS OF ve ie fr wl.
fo~ e ra % + R in Be © 0 M4 Y ra) ) = ol , oe oy a if a a a to eS oa) a ™ Fh id 3 4 te e My Fat 4) a ce cre 3 cs be eA ae 1G ' fay det
3) wn m Mh et a x O i mt tet a 2 O ; Ci 0 bef eg Bs 4 ea ork c 22 4 ME a ' 0 By am fy G "A ch, o> fied on esed £ o + xy 4-1 A 4d by tht rr cd 4 og 3.2 a " So ire) iG CO ao a a Sed wy o O Med m4 6 ag ae tn a oe a er © - ' f a wre L ie : i i bs " w fe end ved : , ce) oO vot KE ce . £ ay ~ st ke 4g Aa a 7 oe t v4 7" : ot wee on, th. a * " £ ed 5, Cy Sy at a a a iy 5 5 ao bs oka ort Et " og CO Q oR , ort 1 cs Ss H Bas & .
a @ 4 vgs > D A 4 on cS 5 gs % ms fe .
in ex r ¢ = a ie Fi id 4 on ar My wan Xr te ke tr com, : et Shed ord " 6 oe ¢ "sy a eh, me - ad i foe w i i Y in o Fi ed Oo % oo , a ie Feed * the e ord o a i. go anf cae * * a i wen & ae 3 «es Q ea 7 " . 4 red Shed aad a) 5 Ci A 4 a ) Qi £5 tA tg 8 rea oy gs ao ere {3 Se ot tS ot i eget ae Ed ee Cy S od
4) ot Ht get @ C Ce BB . G 2 GS GG Wo et g 3 } Aa 3 Ca Cy = a sie 6h cy Cl ~ 4a ws raed ord bd 43 Oo aed x 3 <P vm ois kda GS " + (j iy c a # mc be XS 3 os, ~ ~ we ac hs an ; "4 ea '© wo "4 a4 . 3 6 a @ x fre ed Co ny itt ee o 4 a) sS 4 G3 as wy ey ~~ Go C2, Bot G " * . G a mS ro . . ea u 3 vod oot uy S) @ Q Seek at ay sy rm a) 6 #3 i ay oe wo igs wu o iD ae ~~ oO id oe &G N nant ws = es iN uy x CH 3 Md {3 Ny Ong wv } .
Qo Om @ Go oy | Q eS " & € 4 Woot gg . eh s wai es, v4 ed va ) "mm ea rs : i rood ch sy to Lat en on. s . KD a cant a tp 4 ~ tA Ad ent Et 44 ce rm 7 : 63 @ é ba = "4 4 i wi fi an aoa my oS , in bee 15 ; & w@ ot we a hed uy 4 A ay iv wd , 8 reat oo 8 oa no tpg ® A MH $i a " ie ao ws ran © uy 4 4 ce ; 5 ay sex} ey or vy ig sed : ta sot ry : 4 ts « et % so a C2, fos ot bat i res i} a : S "oF a Bie, say coat 3 b, ia B . who s xs a te a o ari see int a Ci iy g: hed $4 Aes @ Ci xe Bp ahh : it (6 vot om iL, : be a or ded G B 4 & C8 bet wd =~ ae ha 6 wo a fed oo wed G 3 so Oh cs a i, a O "3 a a Pr 3 AB bd on aS o 2. a3) Mi a - w 3 a La Q TG S i i, wn & in o ne) Seed ped ont + ; "Bo 4) a oa eg © Ss ' af i aa am N . ea re co a ' " 44 Ah ots © G hed ; et we ny Cy en , en mo kB * . eae srt ti * Joe . ee 4 cot ea xt 1p rp a ved get 4 9 fe m4 ie a se 43 i ES fro & t os @ B a : i 3 oS e 2 Soe og & cn ar a 3 & o 5 & § 4 y 2 8 3 8 6 ®% 5 » ag 3 B 4 &€ 5 9 6g 6 & mY Ses wf © "e % og m~¢ a a & % ran eo Ea gs Q rt 5 _ w a oa Fs} 4a " % 4) * Cj : 2 t 4 % 4 e 5 2 a is 4 p rt 4 ay Ci 5 9 4d 5 w. Ct 5.4 i we " Cy % re a wo} mA, Pf ts ; a @ "4 rf Q co % G a 4g a a @ a Fs od & rt oe) uw nf A O C3 heen wT i ms aod 43 re et Q Qo 4 C3 vend " i i 3B ~ 2 roe 2 : ; 2 ry et a ' wht n ws . ae mS a : ba Thy f 44 iy so "4 on a a os o £3 uy & $4 o oO we C oUF G 2 © Cis * GC GC Nos ry & Ra ~ c a 3 3 o wy 2 I 7 = QD a oa od " 6 3 O Fe ae = a 2 & Go BD cn o © Bo ; G o . fF @ ct ay oR ed he Ly eet * » wt G} wf cs ; eed 4 " my cer} i : $3 " a @ © m we) bi a ~ bed cod C i oO | eal 6 it) ry ae © 43 eo @ ' wy tt > te ct eo : fot &. ' " mm haf reel Saad ral ot gt t ra] ae ei CD @ a4 at f 3s of £i 3 nm MN im & o " Fe
- pet . ~ : a aed c i" rc Me aye . y rd o a re © " @ ? ed ~ Mon { Pa 4 e £m oa O & ee o Go os <3 1 "n Aa a a Bs a0 ne 83 Oo " 5 DB c wy OS Et Cs} s a os . ce ; . e a an t - 3 G Uy SA HS hed mG ce y & e E ae oO ty, ra a4 4 oi wh 8 5 $3 2 Y ord Fed my co om, a reg Se " ved 4-4 ce, on ™ a %3 Shed a 4 4 mo ont os Ry I & 4b co e : : 4 2 a i me * ~ ' i 4 * . Dye oe ot BP S OG & OF = ' mow | is "
2 4 a o ren " *) c es . me 3 + ° "4 44 G wes
- _ ue Ci 'ses! ws ta e 4 2 @ t oY ' < ie) 3 ery € a oe if « 1 131 Xs wt Be sa es a a ro oo i a 5 a a4 ~ bd @ im fs hd re a oO @ @ b co g & oo Ma 3 (3 4 oo i cy if we vere a Mea ey o i 3 a o
- a $4 ee ' bh iy Ge 44 Ce wn . & : ° 7 ff t ee : 3 ae x, ued oy ay ™ a " oN weed «3 . fat DB wont ~
0. ay eee ha om a a a : -
On s we & a fd = per tite theg oS oe a so . ? et ay AF OQ I ek a a - Lg i ce . yd . : o Qo Ct set ot a a ba ; Bs 'J Pa : vs B38 s © € g 8 ; po B ge Boa 7g Ps a te Boas Gq} cD 4 a it a 3 th ny 'e rf ode, 7s 5 re v4 5 A ea & rh oO oy w wd G © © oO < CG te rp @ eh, % @ % 4 a oD "a 3 a + @ a Od 4 é Cc @ Q3 cm os G a 2 *: Inn od, -- ee! Le 4 4 = ama, 44 a bed a 5 QB $4 hk QD Bi od es * * , & eo re BOF ' | e 4 4 : " « c t * , @ - " ? * = So & & v 2 a ci r , 0 ® es Pm £3 og hy 7 2 RS % "% i, i 2) a ran 7 H im : : 3 Oo ' ca KG % Z on ry at Ae x3 Gh 7 ~ 4 rs tH ° " 2 ™ a a ms % & od . a xo a7 Cc 6 | OA.714/2017
- he, bon Fae a cath gin whe en te t % wey fe eyes ree sae of informed by the rescondent No.3 that recovery would sy 9 AN OP A yt 3 Pee eS at 3 oN WR a 4 3Q2.20,2017 thah mo decuction should be made from his recovery after 5 years defies all general sense and he @lso mentioned two decisions of Delhi High Court in Radhacharan Shakiya (Director/SE) and others Vs. W Union of India and others <({(W.P.(C) 3445/201 decided on 03.09.2014, and Union of India & another Vs. 38 Sharma and others (WP(C) 5555/2013) decided on 04.09.2013 and Amex Court decision in Syed Abdul Qadir & Others Vs. State of Bihar & Others (Civil Appeal Nos .3351-3354/2003) decided on 16.12.2008.
zZ{g). Phereatter am amount of ks.64,815/- was educted fram his salary of Octeber, 2017, and © "3 : 2.69 pode te a meg eng - Lo amount of Es.3,88,887/- was also scughkt to he t ¥F > recovered. He claims that although he was paid TA & Rs. 7OO00+DA From August, 2013, the respondents are Seeking to recover the TA right from March, 2013. Thereafter tise applicant submitted Ewo more reoresentations dated O28 .T1.2017 ani OO LL. S017 'Annex-Ald} for immediate refund of amount of ¥ of oO: ? SF ya mts . a ¢ " "
Rse.64,81S/- deducted From salary of October, 2017.
wid OA FL4/2017 M, + : ano
3. Contentions of the 1} + es ~ Saat oa = _ The applicant contends tnaat - te ete yet . x ' 3i{a}. the action of the respondents in seeking 2 © ce eae ra Kad
73) if 54 4 ou et on ct S a gs eB 5553 sad vd 1 we He fat 7 nm Pa + nae v me % rR &.
@ ry f+ % w rt a3 53 £3 as ee take cr o @ my ox 3 wt 7] rd o ni ity G fe f J o Zz @ 3 ok ow @ ra 3 ry Cy + tr f--$ 7 % oS rh 3b) .. as held by the i Prey a oO % mK 3 ©) {2 rr rt eda a ch a
8) oS ran] mH Q O Fae 63 State of Punjab Vs. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) ete in CA WNo.11527/2014 (Arising out of SLP (C) No.11684/2012), and as per the DOrT OM dated 016, leopy at Annex-A-15, page 47 of the OA), the applicant is fully covered by Direction No.{v} oe iin t oe y 4 f arn T os ae DOPE OM dated 06.02.2014 {Annex-A-i6)}. [Pssuance Of oats a + y een -; . 5 Dk ge mere ds . DRS SMoOoOwe red TO Sena OIrGopIsat Ese Woe byer recovery in deserving cases, Dut ~~ Pai ) 2 fe i P OA.7 14 .
mittee my Management Ca tet ED @ re oe ae <2 y as ae;
oY ead hes oS ea Gh ut 6 coe "A commit in for ss Par arh & the dence, resid x oO required toa 8S a Fy Fat tie od @3 x NaMced, en! ho x Py + id pt rink 48 'gt CS.
Gh:
sed 7.02.2 i "y the we Me t.
aul' o ied oO 4 n ay cm Q the 43 4, 5 ° BS 43 * £3 @ en i) *, 'a, ip wn wn SCAR 2 OD Sho. 6 BE Ch op Mw G is eq: 9 ye mh ote wh Lk 7 ou ;
bd ao i 44 "4 44 mS KA a o 2 Sn cS ei 4 z ved oA i 6 @ iS aS 42 4 @ v4 G v4 Be ef i , ef 4.
-- 2 UY Be oC 6 eo tO GC 8 a Rg A e iB S c 3 a & aed 1p ? wn it oR iw? ct Y aE, 4b > Sea au 3 '3 o o & g ee) wm b "ri @ et : * fe <> 3 3 8 3 . A e Bor x ri . go 0 Y = aw ae i 2 Shel i - 6 ee fo oo S Ei 5S , a "eh or aw rm & a 9] eset aA see] cy _ week 'iD orf G AS ay q £ "
¢ "et a4} ': pew. '4 3 im Ss a" J ah e " er hd hi An Basec ec & er a 3 Sf Ry a u A fT f &
3. a 5-2 rok i i rh Oy Go rea] ws oS oy G aS ® C ood <3 oy "ef 43 set wed } ; * Y zc ae . B Th o G a 4 ua " a ved c ved oe 3 . , % 5 eid he ry +3 o4 ree em , + , as w Fu, @ x ce 2 wb 44 » ay 4 it 2 a A M4 hs.
3) bl a fa = oy wi ge ord or ww ' . a @ sot "| x a BF pg p S 4) on 4 Pa id QO ~ 4 : i be @ a ' 4 Co J whe ae 4 a go - on 7 44 Lg ; ai s ay ti 4 y o ot G es! Me ns oS . ® as 5 Aad ca wg te } '4 : C thd ren 44 i. pos tm > oe . ' oH Ko 4+ oS aa @ re x fi, G4 G w oa Cu i 0 wt Es to * G : ' © M4 i . u ed . be eh -- G4 % i ei Fe & o 6 My 4 os 3 " wv iG 'oe cS cS a bed ard cm Fey ' £5 oO oe me .
ns 4 ¢ a bon c oO wed ue a rt aoe cms 4 :
U ~ se € wep tet ae w : fe f ') x cm ORL a C J 4 Bd i] 'hee, - Q wD ¢ ' ; << } 4 t 4 ot behets oe cst t oss e3 bee ey . . "
a) . ty ' g , "3 ee, gy 0 bea > cged wd £3 & c15) ee a a roe as iD 3 G end a 4 @ w bet od " i 33 ie r A} : Cy Gi / , . oD , ; . ed itp pe het 4 ;
a ¢ ins 4.4 hed a @ aged 2 a ae i a uy 13 ig be 4 . oa ha c 2 G OD @ a 4s Q v 6 @ Q fu o @ » QD ci o XS Bs M4 a3 Ma ae n cf 4 a r An ae) 4 4 " ard 43 rr4, " ped fe cs a Gy cX ad A it Mo eg Ms Be ¢ 5 y : 0G oF oe i O : a wot og pat pes G £3 ao : in 3 in ret ook wd a The z wees kes y tid te ged ea o xo dy os vy <3 , i : ' 43 a : : "> AS oF a ced w is <4 o) sed ha = it ee + ne z ey wf AS ge j G rt om "3 ka kes > iG ind 2 ie ae a . m7 we , cs : wv he oe * ef we G G @ GB ® o 2 4 BB @ 8 . & cB i | - @ 8 a2 8 9 8 Be oop ee 8B g FB 3 oe v 3 and E = b gy TO t ¥ fay sf La oa at _ ~ te ' ° ; sy, 4 ¢ a S a oO Une 2 w Ct ct g {eof 5 Ge ted x 4 fy ' Oo we ay & ded i 43 oO Aes ve ef . "ed ro 43 , "4 O 8 m4 aa G At a @ sent & 4 e } od & "
a my OS w o rm) QO go wi ws gc 2 6 ty ed . .
Oo «aw CO 44 ie "4 Os Gord G © Go wo DB OB > 8 mm a Q on ay oS oO ® wd i> u "et uo oe Q co cy a4 44 a a j bes wi ° ° & ord . a £4 oO ard > G 4 Ms * a ica! She o oi o~ aD SA eA of vod o OQ, f> wd oy CG ad on ot J Oo ut G Ch, yg €h, ty qs oi iy i oe w tt 8] " et wt 4 roi %y th i i 1 $04 Y wB Che wt 4 q} * Sa: & a th; AS sa wD 2) ee aes sor} eS ~~ w of G 8) hod het & oy fa Sh v eh i Oo my fo $4 $4 ae a od cs a 43 7} 7 3 a ak OATS 10 rd : # 4 ra) ay ) ng 4 capi GS we 47 (ei whew. ' . iS Bo 8 Ok G 3 " 2Jn Yds in A a m & i a : le eo Ge nb ar yO es @ 4 @ Mo ed m5 "a i ae Q mi - fre O.. Bork a. ce Cj 3 : Set © ch wmf 7 @ +7 iM ti OD ved Bo ert 3 BS gj aa 3 : a my Qe z Me © fe 2 a4 ie we Go ya * . aad & Oo cs ; u 0 > ies z vet wet O 4 Ht pe we it a ae "e s 3 on a ef wet 5 a & 8 GU 4 0 A G3 ® Bo of a RS el cl M4 Ad he L os 4a oO fs wy hat ro ts " eal ot eh Be se) f ® : Yo art z i o « CS bes Med . ~ 0 o i i * * " ay o td cet gt a 0 a a aw ee Gi z con S a pe tet qb ey . Pot nd i e "a4 ; wv ; 55 : SS o ms oF ab M4 ae , "rt is) haf Es} "sot nd oO vd ey oe 4 it ry vy iy fd oO & wn bey G we © " n o ved LE 4d "yy i" s & a | v , wt oS Me eG | OU 3 ® &£ 'i 3 0 ef eS i ay a) Goo Be RG 8 Py Oy ot ' i 2 ey G ga re aed re 65 x a c ae i a : a bs bs ® «4, Oo @ ae a coef rep) "ng a : Q ~ xt U4 f G G Ba § ' $3 os oh £3, Q wt bet ard 4 . i. 0 od i @ Ci S 5 ms CG ms m 433 ae di o "ee "is . Ra G re SS 4 Gy es i rf o i "ee an Hs) oe a : 2) a ua Ch : ie & isa} Es a = ' S xz "nt t Bw fh G@ q@ Bog a e 3 GW og Pt ~ m4 ey as ie: : gor a: a) : - a s " i) ot ces bn EF on Sy, gat ed . a + eid } % foe a 3 MA cra * et iS "rt ont an iz ' S c se as me hea + ww ae » pg 4s # n bo 8 eo Go Pg o a 3 3 "c oe fs] oe Qo srf by oy wn $y at a c Cs, Q 44 'ad as - ~ cs et a - 2 : o C1 oy a cr pe (Ss Cs 9 { a fe wy ~ eS * Oo "4 o fe C . od ne 2 ' wh ke DG yu 2S 2 "4 @ ae bed iD ey 4 a3 C%, tp ws a ord 3 hea i wed be eh oa a mn cA a Dd, o @ "eS & w eh we oy ' 3 "FS . Od oe bef 3) 5f-f mn 3 ry ch $4 cg c w 3 id C3 Cg ot OB OG " ® | US 3 8 3 8 os eo © . 4 O ia w oh: @ is a @ " "rt hee fxs ved 1G Cy oS er od gy Sad ke age 43 Sf ; a ? wet . ps j @ + ~ ue hd a m rm ved . * ty 4 z o x * wD 4 t3 .. Cy ; © m4 oo 4 "4 3 a ; st ' x oy i rn 4 fo ind bod we 43 Ch gr a stb ry do 2 Sed 4 is as fn 3 * Dp a. 6 a é ms Lee ' ae ie rg CO e 3 a a : eg 3) a4 ie "4 t ~ 4} cs es x ae by . c pei cc ac oy oy go xy 2 seo o np: D> Fest a a he apt 2 os OG a Co a ; y © ad im 4 aa 4 ww a4 5 & % i wo @ B on ageq s a8 fmt : = " Ch 905 a a be ( _ = aod " uh i we \ * a ee ct A 3 4 4 Mo m ef, aw 6 = it Pr iS WD "
ut ood ot i> iX% B BS) £-4. op a ai Fa mt os oh iy Yd o a rw ba oe & B i oy ct @ a wa . @ C5 w 5 o ee "4 Q , ' ¢ A x rs ' ae G " as "os « ' Cj ' eed ; zs 2 ' st * i 4. a i * 1 iy ky " Bet G Oo om & fF Ue we ef ; Ce 2:
8 oe GC © my Be" om eo fs j ian i : os beg £ : * * nd L * . Ss 8 » &£ 2 oo # 8S ya » 2 ™ @ "8 2 5 + ee ard gs - ha we * O "e ra) "a . ne ~ G m7 ab f ee) ee -! { & 3 "od om . ; . ¢. ~ . i" é . G read fo ys4 & son 0 4 a a "3 "4 mB ws " . we oH @ Dy 3 og . 6 OG os So 8 & S o 8 & 68 8 g {7S & &® a 8 HN 4 oy 7a) th Q ad 1a x bea @ 3 ws er "et un set a OQ in 3, : "
™ 3 ch hs 3 gy 2k re "et Qo QB re é ¢ Sint o fort G 65) oy ct Px oO wy mA 4 ed ix © DAT EA20T7 uM Ty ub fas ' w 1G x or wa Abate ud orn
-
ae th o£ TROT er 4 BS of very Pece et
1) Od arch, 4 k :
he,"
ng Dm iS & & aI 3 F} ved bed tas ie my AA o QE on SMa L i. ey a 2 = also " a ana o ¢ 4 bo ai wood @ Fis ont ae mt MM gt @ cot: pe gy st tery eed a Sok ra Cy bd tf) mn & wd 3 = G x O Q t ce Wes 1a x that olaim is ut G. 3 (3).
O hed Nn promotlior ed gt weed heed ud got ea) oe 4-3 thy ohed Aet ] WwW Vie Th Kh t A 2 orf Clas che AY ATICS } a aft aged we.
wrt ood qo with respect > a wet mo a bes ra OA TI4R017 ation one a x te i2 po ef « de ein we SS AS = x ' R.&, Loant x ae € appl A ved A Poy id ot the OM and e Sas ¢ ¥ VW wt eae t aM 3(m).
Oo a mer y 4, he t o hE Lt ct EXpPEr Of.
oa BA party Moe BAS be re ¢ B yoo + sath ons F y N the 3 ne = .
he da ke o ce Le of ved od ch. <3 5 4 *, ay : : » G. See tebe | o an w 7 oa . aL ' + el G Cd Ps ws ret 3 '4 # eft kort " D p- A: ce te fe oe RG Ge Gh my as 45 ES ~ + ws 43 G TT 2 mS iD ia) re) ra : -_ PG a &d a $4 a 5 U ES aN e 2) o eg rh a oS oe) "3 . i . ° ° ¢ cj vs , E8 Ca el oh os ers nt 3 4 < wed j © weft 5 bd ia a i a ? o " ne; ne cs G cae Ch ~~ « os wo Pe an oh roa =O O a mo & & 2 Bw aot rh me " + x, ° i oO « be m, coe rani } ns Pe as a Co "3 x4 a 64 fd wi & cH <p "4 3 = oy * ne "a " en a 3 4 wm 4 (> r one 4 ft fa +4 rs th a wD 6 be a of w Qe ns St ' % 2 ao 2B 4 : my ed G ® , bet 2 wy es , se pA eG ay <4 nerd Pw a in n oy & hd os mt ~ a cy i ts co ' ud i be t ; : Ke o Le "ot St 4 Uy oho ye 4-4 4 o As ~ es oo 13 i an . Go O 40 et i md 3 4 o iA ot Ad Ce ae 43 . oa fe 7 hej thd oe > cm oo o 83 reeeal ' red b, < eel Mt bet = A . wD ee a 4 it © « cot 6 aE oC @ Oo & ri BH rs G @w 8 y» G& & ie) p g "4 ; = ns i 4 8 s Dy 'A % a ® o fa sal Q $e H ms , a a on e a @ 4 ¢ 2 8 & vn z ce > eo 2 ma 2 2s v ny me = ra ved ma O o BS ax & 3 bs 2h a bed Qi be oO £G seed Y @ boa 5 Co © yD io beg v4 ~ ie oe eS : CS net af a co 44 o ae o O 3, @ " . 42 oF 7 54: ' cl oi e ' ca Be Bg oa oO Q 7" op os mg a uy; vo Fog SB fg 8 we fg Ss co Boy , ram ot bd 3 wD ved CG 4 od be ny 43 ' a eg ib ~ i oe 4 " - . a oo a ct +e gc . oh ct eet ne he O 4 os 5 ut : a os a ond i at 4 an eed * i 561 $e. nt fla font = @ @ rs $3 A wot « "y <2) fee : : 4 te. ng ma 4 as "
re ved (cs a ~ in ca gy ig rm cs a > d "s gE wd Ae i a : ~ o ip 4 BE a 0 oO t 3 ; et e ved y ot ue % © : 8 ia Ee va ol ' GS . a a oD w a sora. +3 * Ese OQ * an GQ ie] tt of } La "65 'S we Gt 4 ni ce 5 we / . c i] ~ a eed "
"UTE m ed cs me : fe ~ mm Me » or '6 wy ed Set aa u tg G MS. ge c A 5 @ 5 Sh, Q "2 a a i aa & 2 a ta el, ie " § oy . at wed Al o ' e a f : ree st ; : . yp " a we aN oi * 7st fe 4 o oe 3 ot vt os i be a mM me ra } woe % 4 a o Y my te > + o ny "t aes fh oe ph cy 6 "4 wD _ uy a ve "rh 5, $3 oa ¢ 7 3 ~ i 2 Ce o Sed ie ® aed ag uy er 3 mo . 4 es : gad a . $a re et i? AS a4 mn bey @ oY s 3 ~ ~ ' 3 6 " % So cc) ce 4 a £4, a a ( uy ha 3) of : ne + Aa See a 4 ie td ws ct ot x ¢ "A . its] Mt (Gg rh B (ae) 0 ret rs) rane os s hy Ae ih GS go Tp) O s rs ad o c eo rs a wD . 4G a ors eed re 4a " 44 i, bet 43 oct ma ; @ 0 ond >. bs o OY co 44 a : (ry 4 o eed Bo co ct 4 LE Q ; i & ' m 6 ft cd @ w% e oo wy a a eo S bd et G too is hs wo a G ny ° a P ; if m 43 - on v 43 co ' ba os bo G na O o & 3 ds ps © a 4 arf eG rg fh Q oO % 9 ed » © & % . §& B ® 2 8 & S F G+ & He "4 @ pb ood tom | Go oF D ' § = ne ' "§ or « . al hes a 4 xD my Hoe GS ms 8 . o % Ro 6 wi w 3 cg D A om ns os te oS aa 3 CS my . Ss fas he i owe @ i iu GQ cond ro th os wer &s, cng et 6 ie wo 4 ARS bh & S 2 «A G - ot So Ee Ba f20 ' OA TA?14
a oe, fet ' s Bog Sot Ypv mt 5 TS EQ OU UB OB on. GA , 3 8 Me es eg ob OB seg _ ia er me 6 a 45 De ny : Oh 4 , it ors t € on, pe aged bes a4 cs (7 ¢ , i & oo i.4 % "CS " ded ° te, rt My a is: At fh eof oy O 4 3 % ana vet "es < hoe y ao wed SS Co " = t "4 my a = . ' * 43 fi iss BE ©, o wo 8 GM See G "3 & ct 5 tom oo a es wy oO & "i o rd 4H th G ®) eS eed thy £3 7 5 eo ss os ed oy B cd te ipa iG wi a4 Ges S et * te 5S os, oO O 6 ; Ch «} (3 4 b 2 1D ef, hi an si rn a ro ved " ve y 4 in a " a re oS H * a od Med ° a : ' a s Cu apd % 6 wi co a @ Y ae B ' 8h . 2 me 4 el ka age ma : . be 4 ®% vee} Pe yi a og mf ni a 2, " nA ws i 9 & i 5 . © ed St 4 4g 4 4 3 het D By eL, 7 te a Shy by v a et wy re : Oo u © . ws, G MG & ce. iS co Ch o @ Ad on ' » we A. CO ee i S ry had:
cs a ® wa + Si 4 eo »% & M ann o a c 0 od > fis " ard éy o Aa . et a cS » Y vob Sf a om o 8 eo 3% 8 *~ Q 9 Fu & mh On of a ay ~ ™ oe 4 ' a < 43 nH -- a % o th a4 . . « 4 d ' : Ld " te hs vw nd Oo 4 \ © je oo #e , vy $4 hi a. , bod "4 fet %s 4 © 4 ha @ ; j Go w 4 ® " Ong . . iS we 4 o S 33 Sh Ge Ce s ts. i avd y wd 4 af pea q i ia co by et Ve Shuag o oe eo 8 UW v a i , 0 2, vd G wD 3 t et 3. 44 phes ws ' ih pe ot te, GB ea ye "
CB 3, > : a Ao 6 8 Bs a a é f é pe w ; i 7 e a @ 5s # 8 & a 9 GH 43 ' : 4 ee aye hw ; s zs ' m
- + '4 en a Shed on v4 = Dp ry ee cB g wy 3 43 Shot (3 ay cy es 2 as ; ie a 6 ya ; = , 3 t o _ i i te 6 on Aad @ * mt G 3 % ved ir ad "sy j ~rf 4 er "4 aed ; ms 8) fe a ved is) et o oe * M rd - i bat on ae ot od wD = @ y th 5 na ug Gy = : 3 rt uh oa C3 4.3 © a a 3 a ee nd co " @ Q diet & 4 mS a 5 GH a ad Som § oe 6% $9 6 $ 5 " a ok G " ' ; ee: C z x a a w beg ae ae) £E ot qt ns Bs by a i i nd Ws ot : A oe . 3 i 33 ct a @ ~ ¢ bed ii oe ' <> @ a) ol Yy ref see He 2 a © ni Cc ' ge 4 ae oe g PS a ae fo % 8 yw o> 'N a Co ms Ss 3 ka / O *S wy oH mt fed @ @ " eye my eo ' fee , cm aA 4 . Ct ws "4 Q a & if ge BO oO nd s DR if ea i * v vt me eS in a < 43 "
: ae) iw <6) a B i wt ah a et ? % oj ; Cc Set 58] & 5 bea ci f , os g ts & . & 5, 2 & FB 4 i id s od a o i " 2 : a ne i
- BES» 6S 2c g 6G. a & 9 BOF bey . ; hay se 4 a end " 4 5 vt ~~, G3 * rest wD "s @ ing i 4 G hy, GS a i a Ls heed 7 @ 6 2. &@ F 8 Te « wh nw x . ge % ie ae Ag a Se 5 " afd w ved om rs ca . * B Q OG G - we a wo . [oy "H O weer yy ih arf ws ' et * 2 ft " on a Ld . j om i ; gs mE fe weg te Coan 4 & @ 30 8 £2 & & 8B & B eh oO & oma 2 Sng a3 4 fe ene a & ny wa oS mt @ a 5 a ey 3 oO uy ros Ms ved 2 f, it ad oe 2047 it = OAT I as 8} hy o 3.4 os 34 ra seed red "3 Fabs ed 4 Ba 4 Tom
-
y a iLakions Nat MG stir s coming ne 4 and rice OFt to AOS 1 "4 z as qrante reside ~ in " rd 5 G «ed e8 bet bp} a nd, a O12 tn 4.04.2 ~ so t Y ak Frai OFL y dae Mew 3 Jpgre [ \.
Y _ NG }
a) co S i?
wget Sat gs Me pli he apy x
-
fe ies ws om o + bee up te nired aA ke te month Cer reg was 'ance v Tiox QR & the an speart % o* £ elaim rhe mr co Ale).
b veel ved bi 45 nm 44 Gh wr recs ard Shes ard £3 a 4 hi SS wh his DeCHauUse X aed Med arf ble neASO ~ Le o1i ey AP re ~ Roirn > ry 4 fal pay it wD fey Ou c i aa er 1é ce ahd ® <3 LP g ad * a wed ct Nea 9] a m ved ez om vert wo ay Ma 4 oy nit won, ad cg $e @ fed SS 3 <4 tate K oy mS ™ Ww <> (re thd Need 44 a essary {3 a *
-
OL eipt cer rec ad e Howeve ard at % i rif weed it * yt a es c a th e?
a a the:
a9 on Q ( La Sy ites J a «ed hd are c¢I a + 3.3 G ned ae oe a Ad ri eet bt the oft OF ec_s ion a SS oH seed baer thee 43 G es eke 4 "e od Court.
a a gram Oe.
% io FAN ! o ih, a. cs a GS £ & YF & FF Dod a v ho ord ai ar 4 Ca :
~ = ah fe . % Tt a ty Me ord oS ch a A Es uP * "> ont id Se Og 4d arid x os oe me 5 ih rd ny v wy # Sh So + G 6 OC & & op mw 8 8 8 8 ow BOM SG go ¢ @ £-& BOS ao ood a Gy oy e as a ow to ny . "as ri G a oS % ed an fe DD. toc © |OUR Go 6 Hh So % pm we = oy = oO moO © eo , O° ¢ Do HUME « t. is wo . a Aa " * * ©, rd ro o l : & ig waft * i ty wane O i 7s 0 as ° a ted gt a G ify ord % ved fs . WwW 2 we o 2 th Thy cd Cy ah oy ig ct cs ram is D * "rf Oo Mp 16 uy Gg G ra and BY id a "S "2 Q @ e v4 "ed co ek ma tee * fis " cS * 4 a6 2 hts «a ro) weed om G 43 : nt CO ca) ra a i ~m a 3S ez, si Ad cg gy © iyaf LS "4 ny iB co "
" tu as a Za - ra) a co Q) O ie 3 ed x ey cs : 3 co 3 g i we w sa ey 4 pat os " be oF a 3 = a 4 4 3 oo, ao C 2 OG 3 "rh ; 4 4 3 .
4. Qs thy oa Bb rs hes £ rw) oe] - --~ "3 D i 6 8 a eo Cop 8 om be g wo os . 4 4 ot Ro n° rl : ny at i Y oS 9) a an ce Cy c Db bea ¢ Q wa a a 5 " iia ' e ad @ CO Za # in a m ved 43 @ oe ed we o i ty we eG ss rs Hed : s £3 > 6 Q ie ry " us z a 4A iy ve + 23 '4 44 C as 43 ® " a % Mo hd i As m8 te oa @ ms as wk , . we CG Ds O ae co iv 5 ~ a 4 rs) be uy ad 5 a ao & & «<6 » «© & @ ~ o © 8 pi OS ; 1 a oe i ms % -. eet - | ; a ' iD re v4 "4 e wm ee re ar eS ct . ot be g CR e ha Aa vad a a
- oo oa «& oe 8 9 oH Gog Ns o wd 7 Oe & Ls a ed "1 wy O, iB ' if we Q ; iH ' Pee & ~ mpm o Q ' cs oS . w @ md oh c Sy i Pe sed be go oS a @ ; w 3 4 : ~ ' sae eo co a 3 go % " " a Ss BR cs o % ' : & <4 nm oO 9 : a) g 8] ; eC aN . rs a BO rf . Co o@ H » Db & 8 4 : ed a ty ~ rt oh G 'y @ the At 4 4 e & xt , vy oe 2 a 3 uy a ox ° E G heat aged a 3 on 4a . yp 4D 44 a * u 1 es . i Ea i = " os wed : . , a Si rt ord . "3 : ">. ch ey "
Ps) a Oo 6 B "4 P 44 te Em oO an * y i. . 3 i By dt . %. 3 reg 4 ot 3 wD > Ad $4 uh oe i mm Qo ped n e . : ae ° ' od i 4 " vet wv mA oo M4 43 4 4 we ire vs # e et i 2 Oy a tv] gs Se "GO i « ° ct mA wo it ey o Ms Ch, us . me a reed é 7h in ; a iG : D wy nS ; oh, a , ret = : g Co a a @ a o o 3 Qo # Z . ® @ mm oy OO o ae w ~ " 8 es " °% o SB th & * 9 2 ee BS bo @ % - { re he oy x 4 ba C 54 OE bei @ 4s 4 43 ie mn fa 7 en * wD es ix] 4 Sy © ry iS tpt ra ye Aa 5 tye 4 ort na aa aad w ' b4 C3 "
ey £ a G Ho C > ot ae ° it oD a Sok ° ad 4 Be 2 9 a G he " 5 ha eC Bea Or 4 % om ER o Poo of o its x) fe R "> . 5 a Se saad a ty 43 eh J BD ae ed B C% @ G 8 , 2B 8 es @ © v = © 2 ow Sy Ee Be cs U ps ' sod n 4 i e4 mA " : cs z th ia a" G ws a ms M4 ™ S Fa C n iO Gh . Med te 5 me 4 vol 3 wn " tes : "s od © eA 4A a 5 OS G o od a YD c . @ ca Bo ht "a % Cc moO ® i 3 @ & ot / i Pa Q et e) eed nf whee QO, Ky Q 3 vhs a ot o t me ee seek yt xs 4 & vs ~ rt cd "4 we 43 wy # © C7 a om iat @ Fonl c " t} ws ; roe g ee "a ae 63 ita Ug qd Cb % % rs , al rel Ci és 3 cd Ch o SS, 5 S apd te ord * 4.4 ~ i 2 'agyt Y tk a3 iT Ch a 5 ot Cr 13 . at ee 338 3 ex in He it i 5 % 4 "4 4 wey hao} Cy £55 "~ "4 aI Sai i a - i ord th, ° Bes O, tk 4 c oe OD a tg "ed Ci oO ; a a sed it 3 gq 18 hee Meet nas SErang AAA ad aa Conmsal th rt hod, a iy akly a Xa uF "4 adhacharan Ra officer % Soa LAC x + bec ted £ rita cl iy 3 eéligqib + Ne Ro are go4 AS wtih. SE eS q * Expends me Co Re; 760 noe & licwa A we 4d t Gy G eK.
of heme .
Se od @ 0} mS i srifica C ved KS my St ce! for i a 4 eh ay Ry, ee Ae rt RB ohh NA SF AUS yom fa og * AP a + Ree Apss Court et 6h vol o> on Cat ert nt ay Rey! tee u} ug z 4 vey 4 a. Yo Tin Very ole Ne 4 ~ £e justified.
4% wt 7 rad ood rs iy oY Eo the 2 t a Cause * nip Harass of is wa rs icated OL?
oe ' OATI4 1g a fe bes respon ee) 4 ea refund ld vy ta she 4 aw w yd i, 4a Ca AEE @ ie) sed werk ch aw 6S xo My tS veel C3 J a ms ia % & w i @ x 4 43 % Ry ny =z Ci me oo oO .
be i an Ge) rho wy a o be BS om --
' wy 43 co G 44 Med ord oe wo sed Q ke & on i} Oo. ct rie) ta] sed hy tS wo on , Ad = a red ded Rm 8 ad mt ts * . "s, eh < > TC be 8 i ° mi O as o a, 6 Oo 'ied deb ri 4 oh & a Son wn Gi ce 'UO @ ig x a beg . i 3.3 vt Son B . -
i ted 4 ot wy ; O Fy o 4 Aa oat "a a yy $d 3 rs i Do Bw g vs ct ts o ' a nw D r a i = 6 a ® "a rae a) oe SS on iv be gy ot C3 a ~ w qh _ B i 4d be hg ~ 1G Ci * @ o ae a a he GO g a + 2 n payment a the tg a i "
& 65 ae A aa oO aye] 3 nd Co Q cy x ran ry Mee The tet rel im er ne bet (Dr. Bhagwan Sahai) Member (A).
rept @