Karnataka High Court
K Aarmugam S/O Late K Kannan vs State Of Karnataka on 27 July, 2011
Author: Aravind Kumar
Bench: Aravind Kumar
EN THE': §~-EEE {i{}URf'§.' EE EéiA_§{N,E'_§",§a.KA 5:? §3f%E?;'\7'::;f§g>'%1:§.}£}E7{E<Z
mr_:':+:E TE-{E8 'TE-EH 2%" ::>EY =:3'E i_,§§.".'é}'E.':/'i,)E.7. '
EEE<>'EE"'<. «_
'_E'E€§~Z :~E>E EEE Mm: E5-3*:"§'<:f_E "E%2Ex?*§f;'_x§;;}' :§~:m%:,E§¢.~;_;§EE "
E;EEvEEAL EE'1':E*3:iféEE E%3;E31v.Ej';'=E{§.;: :w %
BETWEEN: V V
K.Aarmz1g_§aE:":. - _ .
Son of iata _Ef:,K21:1z-1331;'
Ageci 25 :;eE:;g;.', ' =: A '
"R/0: N_r.)-;E"§5§ C3.{}i<};1}yj .
*
Bzfgngziiezfié, ~ 55%} ,.PE"E"'E"E'EONER {BE $193§a?--.Eg;3§XE:}iH§§'i:?":'FGR SRE.SHE:KA.§{ E K'UE\JEAR ANS EEE2.PEA_Em§EE_.E.EL:MAE, A:3v'@c:Er1«:E;
: * -. _S:.f--}1EE.M<:;§f %§2:r:1:21i.g:Ee:.
" _ E. :1S--§§s'i3lV215i;:fé§:;mfam E>:'}i§:?;e:g A ' -.%3e:r:§_.g:':['§--<22*i:j§;' ».._%§E;3s:: E:g;?éfi.:'§€.E{§ E}:; ELEE §3s§as§'i'.s;: Pizizziiatt ?z'{}Ec;%Em;<>'r*, §fi§i;;:§t:" {'i<>1.::':: Building, AA ' *- .§§2::':g2a§z>r<i<. , , §3{}'i'\EE3 §§£\E'E' b' EERE. B REEEEA §i§BRA?£AN'x}% BE*§.z3:s.'E.X, §"fE{3{}P% "§f§4{iES s;f:EEE:EE:, E>E<Z'E'E_'£'°'§{Z1E"\I ESE E:EE::.; Er«E:E::E E§<:EE-E:}E «%.i"§§ 53%?' '::'EE <::E:.E::f:, EE T}--§§E E§§f}¥'{i}§E2%7.§.'E':
EQE E:--Eé: §3§;'§"§'E'E{}NE%:E€ :>E4s;':E{:; ""§'§~§:"{E' "E-EE E<>E*EEE: {fE<L§UE%?:'§" ?E§_é;%%' EE EE§%:.EEE:3 '§'{} §%2E'€é,-;%E5€{E%: '§'?§§i W / ?ETE'T§QI\§EE?;. SN Bfifi, EN CRf«»k'C¥t}37:,z'2Q§B SF SHESHADREPURM RSW BANQALQRE, FGR '§'HE GFFENCES PUEQESHABLE UNEEER SECTEC¥'E's;' 382 R/W' 3% GP EPC' Y @113 CRLEMENAL PETITEGN C8E\z£_'~,E;i"%E€T';}..'VV'€.«§'};__E:':é:"7 ; §*@R QRBERS mm ms: ma CQUR'}Z'; * q'm*E:«_ FQLLG'&%f§NG:w ._ "
Accused N05} 2 by Seshadripuram Gffenée punmhable u:'1de:'i _.f'_~>"f.F:e::'{i';:<;V:.3.'"':;§V. Sivectian 351; sf {PC now rcfg1$€€r§(i._ 3.;~; is Ssekmg far being "
'-2. gs-rfiseauticn is that on 28.08.2@1@ at a'b:é1.;_fi 41» §.M4V.'A:é'm;§;}ai'nant 'N38 proceefiéng bafere the ":05 é;};'§€E«.,§T§EgC'€3.S€d Ananda Shekhasz' ané at that ' =%E2fA:;':,;:5*Méjvifié-§_ unknmsvn persans hsiéing bags in their 'gééifieé srziry mm the Shep 3? &es:eased Wm: an i;;:::e'::fi_3:§@:; ":0 assazfii and 3: iéiafi: iima cempiainami crzaeé _ $531' E1639 and in the mganwhfia aasguzsfid paraezzs assauéieci Amazzéa Sheéifzazi. ésgteaaeci 'grfiih Eerzgs ané Céliifififii: his; deaih 333$ Spézé away £3: a igéaruiixi 'afar; i?¥§T2§-Ch axras pa:r"'E<;€& s':1§;Si&§ {he shfig Ciémpiamaiffzi hag E?"
'2 fitzsz-;<?r.fiE3<;?d iihagé fa:-::2't4:'::"e-53 af 2;:_E.E '€:.Er1:;é "E:E"::'m% ;i:<;%{'::.,1::s€:c§ §}{".fE"S:§{i}§;'"iS :_:3.m{.E fiisd a. c:s:>mp§ai:1E. E3a~:f:}:'z:: ft::*iss{i§<%§.§<;::*:a;:2 §}£3§}:{,',€? S'i.2li.i€§£"3; {.'§E'1 the 3:213:19: day E332, 28.38.2818 at ezbzméi. 4 P.I'«'I€
3. Hazard §€&1§"1T}€C§ <:e:3z.1n:e;e§ fag" ;§'€%i;§«%:.i;;§:}'ezVé;__ arggi §.ea}:n{-:*.<:§ E-ECG? far' :'<3:&sp<>:1c§e.11L it iséézasf'f<:<1=i::fi&:z:i1E:£:}1i -«:3»? Sri,Jad%1av .a§3pea.riI1g for pe::'ii'.i:;.:1§:f%: 1é;¥t1ai1 "<-:<3t:*:p§zaifi*:'. 133 f'1'.1€££ by Sri¢M'f\r'1ahe:..:dr.;_1n and hes,-.'""}f;;1$._ §:-§_.;3v<--3:1?': fizz :~s€,a;t€:§1"1€.r:t', bi-':'f(}1'€-3 {he k1veS'%:4§g2:t';iI1g:§ Offi<_t€E" eaffter fiaps-3<~3% <3? €:11r{;%i: m():r_1thS i,s:.;*~.c§'n_1._O.€}?f.2'€3§;G":i::1d £11c2>1':.sa§st€:m:ies; i3€~»::We£-rnx i:E.:£~:A.V_ C<s:z1pE&~;Z,:1a.n1. and st.aJ;:€:11§":'n'L is st.1ffi(:1?<:>,n%. r;-':mf;%;zg,>;%z toVé1E§iv€=._;i?;,~.2;; <r<):'1ch.:s~:;i<3:1 iihaiz §i'}€;'.I"€ is :20 _i:1*2.r<§i'%..5€--:";:<':vrr:4 Q5 §;.=:3§.;i1'.§é§I1<;%1f 3:1 'Lib:-5: afferice 2>,1}i_§@g€3{i zxgziiiisi. He "\.>v:};:1£E. a§$(> :t@r1.é:§3:1<i {hat p€;?'i'i§Li{}I}{3I" is not A g§;iE§;§;* .<}§5'«.._Qff€.§1<>e ziilsageai &3.,§:§_EliI"iE§§§ him zmifi; g;>:°ima fa{7f§€;':
'f.I§":€;':-.f1'§f§:"E4i;ifi_.E§'§ 21%/*ic';;}Z§§21'E)§e3s éésess 320$ C1:§s;;::i{;s:*-se:=: :»2.E§i:g&::'E <,)ff€::':<:€; __E-19 as-*'<_>5";j:=;-E7aiT,i €:£2:§,>:3:"2.-uié": hiss; $"a,:'b:n.i$Si:';m Egg {'f{}§T§,€','.EE€§.13§1g {:<.::11'§3§2x_.§2'121:":i Eifhf} E1213; §§§V€£"1 &;'§'a*:::;é§E:§:§";i'. "E32«:=:E"<*;r€-3 p@E1?<7:<3 A *::'§:_;r_ts';i 31:3? i%:::'.::3:w 'éI§'3{E §}€?§§€1.i(};:'E€';EZ' 2m<.§ 22<imi€.€,r;::{§.};}F Eéifi b' :3:25s_n:<? {"§{.}€?:i% :'1<'>§'. §i'§:T:<?§ §;}§2'a::s:=. in §§'§€£:'*. €ff{}§§E§}E%i.§.3'E.§.. 23;':':{:E sez.:cE'1 :%:.§EE:: gm §2':'é¢:::': ::_:.§.:: :1": 35:2 §§'§'}§f}§§{?EE f;'§':<;i gm-3:"E.§:.;'%::>:'2<:3%:"
'*3 §'t<?2._Es§€.*;Ej«g* in "she szzéai he §'2;.1::; §}f;?€?':E'§ ;a::'rz1ég:'z.<1é<i as 5i<?<<:u;<s€rii Ni). "ii {En £3;{3C':€1'i?;..E.I1'£. :13? £;.i:1e$€% im'::<m.;~i§i:e;i»::%m:1§s:=:ses in pr<3$<%<::zj:i;§a>:'1 {','Eli-'rééf E26: <:=<}::*;'a.€r:':«:Es9; 1:hs3n<;> 155 mi) ;>ri;11a fazjiét matsmii against _p€i::§t.i<m<:ar° and E";.€:1'1<'t€-t %'1é;::_' ikgss 'Em %}<3in§3; esifiarggs;-':{E_ on bail 41;. Per <':::}:1§::'22:, Ei¥2iiI'I1{":€i-H*C'::p :)€:é171£:": :>'xf<:»_§:i. ;'§4§€;.2zti,eL« V . .' _ ' " .7) ' .
wimid s;uE::m.£%i ihai. 21<:{:1;§ed:' N{>.é§ has f§~3.€;'.<;§ ';:_i"'i::i§.:1z1§ petiiiion in Cr1.P.E58l;.'_,2E'§.}:§ and' iféizrt: Iiéis re<:Gr€i€:d a; p1*inza:"§g:<:ie «fiiiciéiigf $:L&§21i31si:'é1c{f'uSe':% 1 to 3 mid as such said £in'di:';;g :i2v<:.z,:T1'{¥; 'f§:§e_;_ b:i11ding am this; c?<:5";;1"i.--_a:3dV 'i;:C"'-«$é.'ekSVv_Eb'1*._:z?s:*:j'e<:tiem of the p@€r:it§0:1. % . Haw i§'1;g.._'..'L'heard {the Ie:3:a:':f:.:;%ci :::<)1.ms;;é;:i§ far '§:et§_i',i<::1f:@:r Aé;1<;.sfi.._'Eziiamtid RC6? and {Elf} g}ez'us:e2.1§. 0?
-ma;ii,§§':*i§-31. A5:-1;_ :*'<=3<:0:*cL it u,r{>u1d <-:m<:é:jgf<3 EE1.a'€. §'}@'iZ¥5Ji'E€§1 é;'fE":§2% 7 €;f{:>':1:pEe:Ej:1f rzizflsi on 28,§,2GE;$ zmié :~;'ii.:-':"*é:em€:::éi'. reitmrfied $3; §E"£'%,Fé"?;'?é"i117§_§£§.E;i§}§: €)fi:"1%<:»«:%r 5:»? i§'1<=é «::<.>2"n;3§:c'a;.§::1am {mg , };:_€}e?.2@'§%'jA 3: :<~;-:§§§_§_E':'§;: d§§s::§epz:1'3<::§; {E0 :><:'<::T1_:f. §'"§{}"éJ'€3%'%Z'F an p:*=::*u$;'-1% {>5 €§1'§'§..'E'{'E 2"::va2fia?:3E€ ma'€:<:=.ria;E an 2"€::{}:r+:.i m{:iz.1<§§:'3;g; :'~3€'.£:ii€:EI":{f.'§'3E' <3?' agar: w§i.§3;_é;:se;;&;e; :*:z2:me:3:E§; ;"?-3:"'}'.,V§?r:1E{:;»'1.3;.a'~':s:e%': wézéazith wa:»*?5 :"é%:i:<'::'§i€:{;i (:23: %§':.é;% 1.-T*a>::'},_.-Y mé>;é, <:%i:a.§,2-* €32'? 'z:E"::;-é <;::<::..13":'<:::'2<é{% (:3? 3;
,*~;, §!'E€',',id€'E"J€I. smai 53:': pa-'::"s".::',~;;';2;.i (sf '£he:% <?.::}§r2.pE2.:.§z2i: vcizigfh zgissg; f§:'1€i;<3 E316: E'1é"::?§1€f of said Srifl-'<a:':k21{:§::9h, it {jf2:E§'iE'E(}§i §::s<:~: heiéi then': at "éhisze ST.E1§;f: ihc=ré;% i:':;; E'Ti{) 33:;f';.:112?: f21<':§€% <é:a::~;e a§_§_"E?;§§1$§", §3€1'iL§'€,1i.(")I"}{"f1'. in mat. xfiexrv 0%" ?;:}"m m:;1i:ie2' 2 am ;f;;{::%'§..:.éizfiiizie6. in s%z1§z1:"g<% ihs? }')€'f"{,§€Z.i€i}§E.€?§' <31": bafi as; §31"a.y€~_<:§'":§'L{>';*.. ' --~ :_. ii: 153% 21150 is be 1':<>:'i»::€<i j;_ha"'£:. §::<fi?civI<'3:':1'i_3i¥;iV. {'gs.;e3:a_:E',i&:;::1 haci {}CE{_3UI'II"€?d on 23;:tt<:m.:m; GE iA;1{,e:"=g:;"<3:ip :'i:?é';E:*3f ::}j:1€iifi, is "
at 'she staga sf r<3C0r'dii":g; ::r{i$a% C:>§21iz1_i_r:;1§:vi.€3.rE--'sf E;E":€;':
Wi1;.n<zssses bei"<3re__ L(>w<3r... {:(3_i,1f.I 2111:? --.1__h§-gyrka is every pos»ssibi1_i4.;,y of g2"c§'§.2'p---Iwzifiry and 21130 me éfhgliliffi, (3Vi" WE-f;fi£3§%S€$'"'*bE%Er1§g §.er1°Qrized <:211:1.11<3t, be ruksd am: i'::;_ §}'};*:§:v'ig__jr{§1s.;":: ii-J21irj}* is; z':§1é: 5:211:39 fax" the §I'£(.'.idfi}T13I. fir: c§:_'a;.e3s-,';':','§€;':'7:'--... «In 3.-'Em-sf of ihfii': §:3éiI."E"§€:, thew is 1:0 m<:1*::Zi: in _:E;r:: iiéiii £031, 5s::1n:1€: £53 h€i'€3b:§,?" re;§€ci:€(§.. @171'? Q» <§".1 9:"
m