Central Administrative Tribunal - Jabalpur
Sabnam Bano vs Archaeological Survey Of India on 10 May, 2024
1 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
Reserved
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, JABALPUR BENCH
JABALPUR
Original Applications Nos.200/600/2017, 200/1089/2017,
200/1090/2017, 200/1091/2017, 200/734/2018, 200/1054/2018,
200/40/2019, 200/369/2019, 200/398/2019 & 200/427/2022
Jabalpur, this Friday the 10th day of May, 2024
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AKHIL KUMAR SRIVASTAVA, JUDICIAL MEMBER
HON'BLE MR. KUMAR RAJESH CHANDRA, ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER
1. ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.200/600/2017
1. Archeological Survey of India Workers Union through its Secretary
Deepak Raikwar, S/o Phool Chand Raikwar, aged about 35 years, Head
Office at Jantar Mantar, Sansad Marg, New Delhi - 110001, Branch Bhopal
Circle, Bhopal M.P. 4620001, Mb. No.7000984227.
2. Nathuram Kushwaha, S/o Bandi Kushwaha, aged about 42 years, Casual
Labour, Khajuraho, R/o Tehsil Rajnagar Khajuraho, District Chattarpur.
-Applicants
(By Advocate - Shri Vipin Yadav and Shri Arun Patel)
Versus
1. Union of India Department of Archeological Survey of India through its
Director General, Janpath, New Delhi - 110011.
2. Deputy Director (Administration), Government of India, Archeological
Survey of India, Janpath, New Delhi - 110011.
3. Superintendent, Department of Archeological Survey of India, GTB
Complex, B Block TT Nagar, New Market, Bhopal M.P. 462003.
-Respondents
Page 1 of 53
2 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
(By Advocate - Shri K.N. Pethia)
2. ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.200/1089/2017
1. Vasanta Bodade, S/o Ramdas, aged about 51 years, Occupation Service -
Daily Wager Group D - Post, R/o Aahu Khana, District Burhanpur (M.P.) -
450331.
2. Heeralal, S/o Bansilal, aged about 47 years, Occupation Service - Daily
Wager, Group D - Post, R/o Village Asirgarh Shiv Mandir, District
Burhanpur (M.P.) 450331.
3. Asshish Vishvash, S/o Aanant Vishvash, aged about 42 years,
Occupation Service - Daily Wager, Group D - post R/o Village Asirgarh
Dulkot, District Burhanpur (M.P.) - 450331.
4. Mahesh, S/o Ghanshyam Kori, aged about 30 years, Occupation Service
- Daily Wager, Group D - Post, R/o Village Asirgarh Dulkot, District
Burhanpur (M.P.) 450331.
5. Moh. Zaheer, S/o Moh. Gulam, aged about 46 years, Occupation Service
- Daily Wager, Group D - Post, R/o Village Asirgarh Dulkot, District
Burhanpur (M.P.) 450331.
6. Joeb S/o Naim, aged about 32 years, Occupation Service - Daily wager
Group D - Post R/o Village Asirgarh Dulkot, District Burhanpur (M.P.)
450331.
7. Vijay Patil, S/o Bhagwat, aged about 45 years, Occupation Service -
Daily Wager Group D - Post R/o Mahalgulara District Burhanpur (M.P.)
450331.
8. Gopal, S/o Rodu, aged about 45 years, Occupation Service - Daily
Wager Group D - Post R/o Village Chhapri Mohalla, District Burhanpur
(M.P.) 450331.
Page 2 of 53
3 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
9. Shaikh Zafar, S/o Shaikh Gafur, aged about 51 years, Occupation Service
- Daily wager Group D- Post, R/o Fatehnagar Ward No.17, District
Burhanpur (M.P.) 450331.
10. Mukesh Bodade, S/o Vasanta, aged about 28 years, Occupation Service
- Daily Wager Group D - Post R/o Aahukhana, Post Jenabad, District
Burhanpur (M.P.) 450331.
11. Vahid Kuraisi, S/o Safee Kurasi, aged about 47 years, Occupation
Service - Daily Wager, Group D - Post R/o Ward No.11, Kaaj Bajar,
District Burhanpur (M.P.) 450331.
12. Mohan Vaniwala, S/o Kalu Singh Vaniwala, aged about 31 years,
Occupation Service - Daily Wager, Group D - Post R/o Ward No.20,
Aahukhana Post Jenabad District Burhanpur (M.P. - 450331.
13. Rakesh, S/o Sharad Chand, aged about 48 years, Occupation Service -
Daily Wager, Group D - Post R/o Hunuman Nagar, Burhanpur (M.P.)
450331.
14. Vinod Katare, S/o Shri Ram Katare, aged about 32 years, Occupation
Service - Daily Wager Service Daily wager Group D Post R/o ward no.5
Omkareshwar District Khandwa (M.P.) Pin Code No. 450554.
15. Rejesh Keer S/o Gulab Keer aged about 36 years Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D Post R/o Omkareshwar District Khandwa (M.P.) Pin
Code No. 450554.
16. Mahendra Singh S/o Kalyan Singh aged about 39 years Occupation
Service -Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 5 Omkareshwar District
Khandwa (M.P.) Pin Code No. 450554.
17. Lokesh Pawar S/o Ram Singh aged about 29 years Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No.6 Omkareshwar District Khandwa
450554 (M.P.) Pin Code No.
Page 3 of 53
4 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
18. Satya Narayan S/o Gopal aged about 25 years Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o R/o Village Sidhwarku.t Omkareshwar
District Khandwa (M.P.) Pin Code No. 450554.
19. Dinesh Kewat S/o Mohanial aged about 39 years Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D Post R/o R/o Ward No.13 Omkareshwar District
Khandwa (M.P.) Pin Code No. 450554.
20. Budheshwar S/o Baleshwar Paswan aged about 42 years Occupation
Service -Daily wager Group D- Post R/o R/o Gram Sidhwarkut
Omkareshwar District Khandwa (M.P.) Pin Code No.450554.
21. Nehru Verma S/o Nathu verma aged about 50 years Occupation Service
-Daily wager Group D- Post R/o R/o Village Rawerkhedi District
Khanrgone (M.P.) Pin Code No. 45119.
22. Yashwant Bhargav S/0 Punamchand Bhargav aged about 31 years
Occupation Service -Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ward NO.4 District
Khanrgone (M.P.) Pin Code No. 451115.
23. Bhaiyalal S/o Nehru Verma aged about 28 years Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Village Rawerkhedi District Khanrgone
(M.P.) Pin Code No. 45119.
24. Maksud S/o Hameed aged about 29 years Occupation Service -Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Ward 10 District Burhanpur (M.P.) Pin Code No.
450331.
25. Vaibhav S/o Ravendra aged about 23 years Occupation Service -Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Ward NO.15 District Burhanpur (M.P.) Pin Code
No. 450331.
26. Jeetu S/o Vasanta aged about 30 years Occupation Service -Daily wager
Group D- Aahukhana District Post R/o Burhanpur (M.P.) Pin Code No.
450331.
Page 4 of 53
5 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
27. Dinesh S/o Ramkumar aged about 35 years Occupation Service -Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No.14 Omkareshwar District Khandwa
(M.P.) Pin Code No. 450554.
28. Manoj S/o Dhundupant aged about 31 years Occupation Service -Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Sai Kela District Burhanpur (M.P.) Pin Code No.
450331.
29 Harish S/o Ramlal aged about 32 years Occupation Service -Daily wager
Group D Post Sai Kela District Burhanpur (M.P.) Pin Code No. 450331.
30. Manohar S/o Sampat aged about 46 years Occupation Service -Daily
wager Group D Post R/o ward no.9 District Burhanpur (M.P.) Pin Code No.
450331.
31. Jagannath S/o Govind aged about 29 R/o Occupation Service -Daily
wager Group D- Post ward no.7 District Burhanpur (M.P.) Pin Code No.
450331.
32. Ganesh S/o Aanant Guruji aged about 45 years Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D- Post ward no.7 District Burhanpur (М.Р.).
33. Jagdeesh S/o Tulsidas aged about 30 years Occupation Service -Daily
wager Group D- Post Aahukhana District Burhanpur (M.P.) Pin Code No.
450331.
34. Rakesh S/o Ramesh aged about 27 years Occupation Service -Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o ward no.5 Omkareshwar District Khandwa (M.P.)
Pin Code No. 450554.
35. Sandeep S/o Pratap Singh aged about 30 years Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o ward no.16 District Burhanpur (M.P.) Pin
Code No. 450331.
36. Sujaant Singh S/o Vikram singh aged about 43 years Occupation
Service -Daily wager Group D- Post R/o ward no.10 Omkareshwar District
Khandwa (M.P.) Pin Code No. 450554.
Page 5 of 53
6 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
37. Kashiram S/o Terala aged about 40 years Occupation Service Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Hasanpura main road Asirgarh District Burhanpur
(M.P.) Pin Code No. 450331.
(By Advocate - Shri Subodh Tamrakar)
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Culture Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi 110001.
2. Archaeological Survey of India through its Director General, Janpad,
New Delhi 110001.
3. Regional Director (Central Zone) Archaeological Survey of India, T.T.
Nagar, Bhopal (M.P.) 462001.
4. Superintendent Archaeological Survey of India, Bhopal Zone, Bhopal
(M.P.) 462001 -Respondents
(By Advocate - Shri K.N. Pethia)
3. ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.200/1090/2017
1. Rajesh Yadav, S/o Mohan Lal Yadav, aged about 35 year Occupation-
service daily wager Group D- Post R/o Madan Mahal Jabalpur Pin Code
No.482001.
2. Vibhash Kumar Patel S/o Late D.L. Patel aged about 39 years
Occupation service daily wager Group D- Post R/o Madan Mahan Jabalpur
Pin Code No. 8482001.
3. Rajendra Dolas S/o Salikram Dolas aged about 43 years Occupation-
service daily wager Group D- Post R/o Lanji Tahsil and District Balaghat
(M.P.). Pin Code No. 481122.
Page 6 of 53
7 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
4. Ritesh Bhagh S/o Neelkhanth Rao Bhagh ageda about 33 years.
Occupation- service daily wager Group D- Post R/o Lanji Tahsil and
District Balaghat (M.P.) Pin Code No. 481122.
5. Rajendra Asatkar S/o Deenaji Asatkar aged about 43 years Occupation-
service daily wager Group D- Post R/o Lanji Tahsil and District Balaghat
(M.P.) Pin Code No. 481122.
6. Yuvraj Borikar S/o Jathuram Borikar aged about 30 years Occupation
service daily wager Group D- Post R/o Village Devgarh Tahsil and District
Chhindwara (M.P.) Pin Code No. 480107.
7. Manoj Borikar S/o Mathu Borikar aged about 27 years Occupation-
service daily wager Group D- Post R/o Village Devgarh Tahsil and District
Chhindwara (M.P.) Pin Code No.480107.
8. Sunil Kumar Yadav S/o Ghamandi Yadav aged about 30 years
Occupation- service daily wager Group D- Post R/o Village Badgaw Distt.
Katni (M.P.) Pin Code No. 483990.
9. Bharat Kumar Raikwar S/o Lakhan Raikwar aged about 28 years
Occupation- service daily wager Group D- Post R/o Badgaw Distt. Katni
(M.P.) Pin Code No. 483990.
10 Rajanikant Patel S/o Jagdish Patel aged about 27 years Occupation-
service daily wager Group D- Post R/o Badgaw Distt. Katni (M.P.) Pin
Code No. 483990.
11. Ramsujan Patel S/o Komal Patel age about 30 years Occupation- service
daily wager Group D- Post R/o Badgaw Distt. Katni (M.P.) Pin Code No.
483990.
12. Suresh Patel S/o Komal aged about 28 years Occupation- service daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Badgaw Distt. Katni (M.P.) Pin Code No.
483990.
Page 7 of 53
8 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
13. Ashish Kumar Dubey S/o Balaprasad Dubey aged about 27 year
Occupation- service daily wager Group D- Post R/o Village Billahari Distt.
Katni (M.P.) Pin Code No. 483501.
14. Komal Prasad Rajak S/o Narayan Prasad Rajak ageda about 26 years
Occupation- service daily wager Group D- Post R/o Village Billahari Distt.
Katni (M.P.) Pin Code No. 483501.
15. Rampal Verman S/o Kishori Lal aged about 35 years Occupation-
service daily wager Group D- Post R/o Panagar District Jabalpur (M.P.) Pin
Code No. 483220.
16. Santosh Kumar Prajapati S/o Deeraj Prajapati aged about 36 years
Occupation- service daily wager Group D- Post R/o Panagar District
Jabalpur (M.P.) Pin Code No. 483220.
17. Salman Khan S/o Aleem Khan aged about 30 years Occupation- service
daily wager Group D- Post R/o Baihar District Balaghat (M.P.) Pin Code
No. 481111.
18. Suraj Singh Dhurvey S/o Khusiyal Singh aged about 40 years
Occupation- service daily wager Group D- Post R/o Garhi Baihar District
Balaghat (M.P.) Pin Code No. 481111.
19. Ashish Kumar Gupta S/o Ashok Kumar Gupta aged about 25 years
Occupation- service daily wager Group D- Post R/o Bedaghat District
Jabalpur (M.P.) Pin Code No. 483053.
20. Sanjay Yadav S/o Shivnath yadav aged about 30 years R/o Bedaghat
District Jabalpur (M.P.) Pin Code No. 483053.
21.Bhavichand Kirar S/o Heera Kirar aged about 32 years Occupation-
service daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ghansure Distt. Seoni (M.P.) Pin
Code No. 480997.
Page 8 of 53
9 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
22. Partap Kirar S/o Dabbu Kirar aged about 38 years Occupation- service
daily wager Group D Post R/o Ghansure Distt. Seoni (M.P.) Pin Code No.
480997.
23. Rajaram Nanda S/o Harinanda aged about 48 years Occupation- service
daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ghansure Distt. Seoni (M.P.) Pin Code No.
480997.
24. Ashok Kumar Kachwaha S/o Radhelal Kachwaha aged about 49 years
Occupation- service daily wager Group D- Post R/o Mandla Distt. Mandla
(M.P.) Pin Code No. 481661.
25. Modu Vishwakarma S/o Gendalal Vishwakarma aged about 38 years
Occupation- service daily wager Group D - Post R/o Mandla Distt. Mandla
(M.P.) 481661.
26. Jitendra S/o Harichand, aged about 35 years, Occupation - Service
Daily Wager, Group D- post, R/o Ashta District Sehore (M.P.) 466116.
27. Maniram Bhartiya, S/o Bhammulal Bhartiya, aged about 30 years,
Occupation - Service Daily Wager, Group D- Post R/o Ashta District
Sehore (M.P.) 466116.
28. Charan Singh, S/o Chetram, aged about 28 years, Occupation - Service,
Daily Wager, Group D - Post R/o Begam Mahal Distt. Mandla (M.P.) Pin
Code No.481661.
(By Advocate - Shri Subodh Tamrakar)
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Culture Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi - 110001.
2. Archaeological Survey of India through its Director Genreral, Janpad,
New Delhi 110001.
3. Regional Director (Central Zone), Archaeological Survey of India, T.T.
Nagar, Bhopal (M.P.) - 462001.
Page 9 of 53
10 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
4. Superintendent Archaeologist Survey of India, Bhopal Zone, Bhopal
(M.P.) 462001 -Respondents
(By Advocate - Shri K.N. Pethia)
4. ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.200/1091/2017
1. Ramesh S/o Keshar Singh aged about 41 years Occupation- service daily
wager Group D- Post.
2. Smt. Prem bai D/o Shri Gulab Singh aged about 35 years Occupation-
service daily wager Group D- Post.
3. Rajendra Kumar S/o Nandlal Rao aged about 26 years Occupation-
service daily wager Group D- Post.
4. Veeran Singh S/o Shri Karan Singh Aged about 41 years Occupation-
service daily wager Group D- Post.
5. Gokul Singh S/o Mangu Singh aged about 40 years Occupation- service
daily wager Group D- Post.
6. Bhadrilal S/o Bhona Singh aged about 39 years Occupation- service daily
wager Group D- Post.
7. Shobharam S/o Girdharilal aged about 39 years Occupation- service daily
wager Group D- Post.
8. Motilal S/o Shrii Puralal aged about 49 years.
9. Raju S/o Gopal aged about 29 ycars Occupation- wager Group D-Post
service daily wager Group D - Post.
10. Anil S/o Mangilal aged about 32 years Occupation service daily wager
Group D- Post.
Page 10 of 53
11 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
11. Mangal Kumar S/o Nandlal Rao aged about 49 years Occupation-
service daily wager Group D- Post.
12. Deleted.
13. Ramesh Chandra S/o Kanihilal aged about 41 years Occupatior- service
daily wager Group D- Post.
14. Kanihilal S/o Bagdiram aged about 55 years. Occupation- service daily
wager Group D- Post.
15. Deleted.
16. Bhawani Shankar S/o Ramlal aged about 34 years Occupation- service
daily wager Group D- Post.
17. Deleted.
18. Deleted.
19. Deleted.
20. Arjun S/o Dayaram, aged about 22 years, Occupation - service daily
wager Group D - Post.
21. Deleted.
22. Kalyan, S/o Nandram, aged about 53 years, Occupation - service daily
wager Group D- Post.
23. Deleted.
24. Deleted.
25. Deleted.
Page 11 of 53
12 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
26. Dinesh S/o Mohanlal, aged about 44 years, Occupation - service daily
wager Group D - Post.
27. Sandeep S/o Bhawani Prasad, aged about 43 years, Occupation -
service daily wager Group D - Post.
28. Jagdish, S/o Keshar Singh, aged about 43 years, Occupation - service
daily wager Group D - Post.
29. Rajesh Singh, S/o Hazarilal, aged about 28 years, Occupation - service
daily wager, Group D - Post.
30. Daulat Singh, S/o Nannu Singh, aged about 29 years, Occupation -
service daily wager Group - D Post.
31. Jeewan Kumar, S/o Kanihilal, aged about 36 years, Occupation -
service daily wager, Group D - Post.
32. Omkar Singh, S/o Puran Singh, aged about 29 years, Occupation -
service daily wager Group D - Post.
33. Gopal, S/o Kachhari Ji, aged about 42 years, Occupation - service daily
wager, Group D - Post.
34. Satish Kumar, S/o Rajkishore Sharma, aged about 41 years, Occupation
- service daily wager, Group D - Post.
All applicants residence Village Chandra Basa Tahsil Shyamgarh, District
Mandsour (M.P.) Pin Code No.458002.
-Applicants
(By Advocate - Shri Subodh Tamrakar)
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Culture, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi 110001.
Page 12 of 53
13 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
2. Archaeological Survey of India through its Director General, Janpad,
New Delhi 110001.
3. Regional Director (Central Zone) Archaeological Survey of India, T.T.
Nagar, Bhopal (M.P.) Pin Code No.462001.
4. Superintendent Archaeologist Survey of India, Bhopal Zone, Bhopal
(M.P.) 462001.
-Respondents
(By Advocate - Shri K.N. Pethia)
5. ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.200/734/2018
1. Mohan Singh S/o Naval Singh aged about 46 years Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Kanhakheda Kal Sachi District Raisen
(M.P.) Pin code No. 464661.
2. Lakshman Khare S/o Chhotelal Khare aged about 42 years Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 04 Kanhakheda Kala
Sachi District Raisen (Μ.Ρ.) Pin code No. 4646613.
3. Prem Narayan S/o Pannalal aged about 46 years Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o ward No. 9 Stup Road Sachi Kanhakheda
Kala Sachi District Raisen (Μ.Ρ.) Pin code No. 4646613.
4. Sumer Singh S/o Chatar Singh aged 48 year Occupation Service Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o ward No. 9 Stup Road Sachi Kanhakheda Kala
Sachi District Raisen (M.P.) Pin Code No.4646613.
5. Dharmendra Singh S/o Khilan Singh aged about 38 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o ward No. 9 Stup Road Sachi
Kanhakheda Kala Sachi District Raisen (M.P.) Pin code No. 4646613.
6. Lalaram S/o Somrath Singh aged about 38 years, R/o Ward No. 12
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Stup Road Sachi
Kanhakheda Kala Sachi District Raisen (M.P.) Pin code No. 4646613.
Page 13 of 53
14 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
7. Sanman Singh S/o Lal Singh aged about 32 years, R/o Ward No. 12
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Stup Road Sachi
Kanhakheda Kala Sachi District Raisen (M.P.) Pin code No. 4646613.
8. Vinod S/o Narayan aged about 30 R/o Ward No. 12 Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Stup Road Sachi Kanhakheda Kala Sachi
District Raisen (M.P.) Pin Code No.4646613.
9. Sunil Sharma S/o Gautam Sharma 44 years, R/o Mukharji Nagar, Vidisha
pin No. 464001.
10. Charan Singh S/o Tikam Singh 46 years, R/o Ward No. 10 Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Stup Road Sachi Kanhakheda Kala
Sachi District Raisen (Μ.Ρ.) Pin code No.4646613.
11. Deleted.
12. Mukesh S/o Ramesh Kumar aged about 40 R/o Ward No. 12
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Stup Road Sachi
Kanhakheda Kala Sachi District Raisen (M.P.) Pin code No. 4646613.
13. Aavid S/o Shekhakhat Ali aged about 38 years Ward No. 13 Hedegwar
Colony Sachi District Raisen.
14. Aakash S/o Omprakash aged about 32 years Ward No. 6 R/o Ward No.
12 Occupation Service Daily wager Group D Post R/o Stup Road Sachi
Kanhakheda Kala Sachi District Raisen (M.P.) Pin code No. 4646613.
15. Naval Singh S/o Vadam Singh aged about 40 years, Ward No. 10 R/o
Ward No. 12 Occupation Service Daily wager Group D Post R/o Stup Road
Sachi Kanhakheda Kala Sachi District Raisen (M.P.) Pin code No.
4646613.
16. Ramesh S/o Devichandra aged about 46 years, ward No. 7
Motiyakuwan R/o Ward No. 12 Occupation Service Daily wager Group D-
Page 14 of 53
15 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
Post R/o Stup Road Sachi Kanhakheda Kala Sachi District Raisen (M.P.)
Pin code No. 4646613.
17. Shyam Singh S/o Tikam Singh aged about 44 ward No. 10 R/o Ward
No. 12 Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Stup Road
Sachi Kanhakheda Kala Sachi District Raisen (M.P.) Pin code No.
4646613.
18. Himmat Singh S/o Bhagwan Singh aged abut 47 years, Gadersedi,
Murlikhedi Salamatpur R/o Ward No. 12 Occupation Service Daily wager
Group D- Post R/o Stup Road Sachi Kanhakheda Kala Sachi District Raisen
(M.P.) Pin code No. 4646613.
19. Anees S/o Babu Khan aged about 34 Yeren Gulgaon R/o Ward No. 12
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Stup Road Sachi
Kanhakheda Kala Sachi District Raisen (M.P.) Pin code No. 4646613.
20. Deleted.
21. Lakhan S/o Har Bhajan aged about years Yeren Gulgaon R/o Ward
No.12, Occupation Service - Daily Wager Group D - Post R/o Stup Road
Sachi Kanhakheda Kala Sachi, District Raisen (M.P.) Pin code
No.46446613.
22. Manoj S/o Somat Singh, aged about 34 years, ward no. 10 R/o Ward
No.12, Occupation Service - Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Stup Road
Sachi Kanhakheda Kala Sachi District Raisen (M.P.) Pin code No.4646613.
- Applicants
(By Advocate - Shri Subodh Tamrakar)
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Culture Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi 110001.
2. Archaeological Survey of India through its Director General, Janpad,
New Delhi 110001.
Page 15 of 53
16 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
3. Regional Director (Central Zone) Archaeological Survey of India, T.T.
Nagar, Bhopal (M.P.) Pin 462001.
4. Superintendent Archaeologist Survey of India, Bhopal Zone, Bhopal
(M.P.) Pin 462001 -Respondents
(By Advocate - Shri K.N. Pethia)
6. ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.200/1054/2018
1. Sohan Yadav S/o Udal Yadav aged about 38 years Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) Pin code No
47001.
2 Shri Yadav S/o Bhaiyalal Yadav aged about 35 ycars Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) Pin code No
47001.
3. Malkhan Yadav S/o Gorelal Yadav aged about 36 years Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) Pin
code No 47001.
4. Tejram Kori S/o Chaturbhuj Kori aged 48 year Occupation Service Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) Pin code No 47001.
5 Balram S/o Tejram aged about 45 years, Occupation Service Daily wager
Group D- Post R/o Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) Pin code No 47001.
6. Bhimna Patel S/o Nathuram aged about 35 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) Pin code No
47001.
7. Dharmraj Patel S/o Ramsiromani Patel aged about 38 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) Pin
code No 47001.
Page 16 of 53
17 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
8. Mukesh Pandey S/o Lallan Pandey aged about 36 Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) Pin code No
47001.
9. Karan Singh Rajpoot S/o Tejsingh Rajpoor 27 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) Pin code No
47001.
10. Moveen Khan S/o Basir Khan 40 years, Occupation Service Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) Pin code No.47001.
11. Hariom Raghuvansi S/o Giriwar Singh Raghuvanshi aged about 39
years, Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Sagar, District
Sagar (M.P.) Pin code No 47001.
12. Dashrath Pal S/o Rabude Pal aged about 28 years Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) Pin code
No.47001.
13. Makhan Pal S/o Prabhulal Pal aged about 35 years Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) Pin code
No.47001.
14. Rajendra Singh Rajpoot S/o Poolsingh Rajpoot aged about 45 years
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Sagar, District Sagar
(M.P.) Pin code No 47001.
15. Rama S/o Kashiram aged about 42 years, Occupation Service Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) Pin code No 47001.
16. Keshavlal S/o Rajaram aged about 35 years, Occupation Service Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Sagar, 47001. District Sagar (M.P.) Pin code No
47001.
17. Ramchandra Pandey S/o Shital Prasad Pandey aged about 35 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D Post R/o Sagar, District Sagar
(M.P.) Pin code No 47001.
Page 17 of 53
18 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
18. Mathura Sen S/o Shramcharan Sen aged about 38 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) Pin
code No 47001.
19. Ballu Patel S/o Sadhu Patel aged about 40 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) Pin code No
47001.
20. Suresh Soni S/o Ramkrishan Soni aged about 37 Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) Pin code No
47001.
21. Chandrapal Yadav S/o Sahab Singh aged about 38 years Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) Pin
code No 47001.
22. Gulab Singh Mogia S/o Bhawarlal ageed about 32 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Raisen, District Raisen (M.P.) Pin
code No 464551.
23. Rajkumar S/o Himmat Singh Aged about 34 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Raisen, District Raisen (M.P.) Pin code No
464551.
24 Kailash Singh S/o Phool years, Occupation Service Singh aged about 36
Daily wager Group D Post R/o Raisen, District Raisen (M. P.) Pin code No
464551.
25 Rakesh S/o Deni Prasad Aged about 39 years, Occupation Service Daily
wager Group D. Post R/o Raisen, District Raisen (M.P.) Pin code No
464551.
26. Devi Prasad S/o Panna Lal aged about 35 years. Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Raisen, District Raisen (M.P.) Pin code No
464551.
Page 18 of 53
19 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
27. Basim Kha S/o Sahid Kha aged about 38 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Raisen, District Raisen (M.P.) Pin code No
464551.
28. Neelen Gir S/o Prem Gir aged about 30 years, Occupation Service Daily
wager Group D Post R/o Gyarashpur District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin code No
464377.
29. Shivprasad S/o Chhuttulal aged about 48 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Gyarashpur District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin
code No 464377.
30. Kallu S/o Kanchhedi lal aged about 35 years, Occupation Service Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Gyarashpur District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin code No
464377.
31. Vikash Gir S/o Late Shri Munna Gir aged about 29 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Gyarashpur, District Vidisha
(M.P.) Pin code No.464377.
32. Chandan Singh, S/o Suraj Singh, aged about 35 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Gyarashpur, District Vidisha
(M.P.) 464377.
33. Lakhan Singh, S/o Udam Singh, aged about 32 years, Occupation
Service - Daily Wager Group D - Post R/o Gyarashpur, District Vidisha
(M.P.) Pin code No.464377.
34. Bharat Singh, S/o Tikaram, Occupation Service - Daily wager Group D
- Post R/o Gyarashpur District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin code No.464377.
35. Narmada Prasad, S/o Dhannalal, aged about 36 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Gyarashpur, District Vidisha
(M.P.) Pin code No.464377.
Page 19 of 53
20 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
36. Kailash Singh, S/o Khelan Singh, aged about 38 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Gyarashpur, District Vidisha
(M.P.) Pin code No.464377.
37. Bhuramal S/o Daulta Singh, aged about 38 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Gyarashpur, District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin
code No.464377.
38. Vijay Singh, S/o Komal Singh, aged about 38 years, Occupation Service
- Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin
Code No.464001.
39. Rajkumar S/o Raghuvir Singh aged about 30 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (MP) Pin code No
464001.
40 Rakesh Rajak S/o Kuvar Lal aged about 35 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin code
No 464001.
41. Guman Singh S/o Khopa Singh aged about 36 ycars, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin
code No 464001.
42. Ajay S/o Ramdayal aged about 33 years, Occupation Service - Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin code No
464001.
43. Pramod S/o Babulal aged about 36 years, Occupation Service Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin code No
464001.
44. Dinesh S/o Ram Singh aged about 38 years, Occupation Service Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin code No
464001.
Page 20 of 53
21 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
45. Bhagirath S/o Ramprasad aged about 33 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Pos R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin code No
464001.
46. Kailash S/o Ganeshram aged about 43 years, Occupation Service Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin code No
464001.
47. Pritam 5/0 Bihari aged about 35 years, Occupation Service Daily wager
Group D Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin code No 464001.
48. Rajesh S/o Khop Singh aged about 34 years. Occupation Service Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin code No
464001.
49. Dinesh Kumar S/o Rambabu Tiwari, aged about 38 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin
code No 464001.
50. Kamlesh Ahirwar S/o Mohar Singh, aged about 35 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin
code No 464001.
51. Govind Raikwar S/o late Shri Balkisan, aged about 36 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District
Vidisha (M.P.) Pin code No 464001.
52. Makhan Singh S/o Biharilal, aged about 37 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin code
No 464001.
53. Dhanraj Ahirwar S/o Narayan Singh, aged about 32 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin
code No 464001.
Page 21 of 53
22 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
54. Dhansingh Kushwaha S/o Narayan singh, aged about 32 years,
Occupation Service - Daily wager Group D - Post R/o Vidisha, District
Vidisha (M.P.) Pin Code No.464001.
55. Chotelal Raikwar S/o Khuman Singh, aged about 34 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.)
Pin code No.464001.
56. Dharmendra Kushwaha S/o Kisanlal, aged about 32 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.)
Pin code No 464001.
57. Vishanu Kushwaha S/o Malkhan Singh, aged about 34 years,
Occupation Service - Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District
Vidisha (M.Ρ.) Pin code No 464001.
58. Chandrashekar Sahu S/o Jairam Sahu, aged about 34 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin
code No 464001.
59. Shivraj Sahu S/o Jairam Sahu aged about 36 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin code
No 464001.
60. Ranjit Singh S/o Phateh Singh, aged about 36 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin code
No 464001.
61. Mohan Jat S/o Ramsingh Jat, aged about 35 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin code
No 464001.
62. Lakhan Singh S/o Pratap Singh Mogia, aged about 38 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin
code No 464001.
Page 22 of 53
23 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
63. Haphij Kha S/o Habib Kha aged about 29 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Vidisha District Vidisha (M.P.) Pin code
No 464001.
64. Adhar Singh Yadav S/o Siyaram Yadav, aged about 36 years,
Occupation Service - Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Chanderi District
Alirajpur (M.P.) Pin code No 473446.
65. Sher Singh Lodhi S/o Sag Lodhi, aged about 35 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Chanderi District Alirajpur (M.P.)
Pin code No 473446.
66. Rajesh Pal S/o Santosh Pal, aged about 35 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Chanderi District Alirajpur (M.P.) Pin code
No 473446.
67. Mansingh Pal S/o Guman Singh, aged about 36 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Chanderi District Alirajpur (M.P.)
Pin code No 473446.
68. Narayan Singh S/o Prem Kachhi, aged about 40 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Chanderi District Alirajpur (M.P.)
Pin code No 473446.
69. Phaiyaj Kha S/o Nasir Kha, aged about 35 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Chanderi District Alirajpur (MP) Pin code
No 473446.
70. Govind Pal S/o Balchand Pal, aged about 35 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Chanderi District Alirajpur (M.P.) Pin code
No 473446.
71. Kadeen Kha S/o Kadeer Kha, aged about 35 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D Post R/o Chanderi District Alirajpur (M.P.) Pin code
No 473446.
Page 23 of 53
24 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
72. Shovran Singh S/o Harnath Singh, aged about 35 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Chanderi District Alirajpur (M.P.)
Pin code No 473446.
73. Kripal Singh S/o Madan Singh Rajpoot, aged about 35 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Chanderi District
Alirajpur (M.P.) Pin code No 473446.
74. Mannulal Kewat S/o Amarchandra Kewat, aged about 40 years,
Occupation Service - Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Chanderi District
Alirajpur (M.P.) Pin code No 473446.
75. Manju S/o Shivcharan, aged about 32 years, Occupation Service Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Chanderi District Alirajpur (M.P.) Pin code No
473446.
76. Sunil Kewat S/o Mannulal, aged about 32 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Chanderi District Alirajpur (M.P.) Pin code
No 473446.
77. Dinesh Kushwaha s/o Puran Singh Kushwaha, aged about 35 years,
Occupation Service - Daily wager Group D Post R/o Chanderi District
Alirajpur (M.P.) Pin code No 473446.
78. Manoj Jatav 8/o Khuman Singh Jatav, aged about 35 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D. Post R/o Chanderi District Alirajpur (M.P.)
Pin code No 473446.
79. Mukesh Jatav S/o Ramcharan Jatav, aged about 34 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D. Post R/o Chanderi District Alirajpur (M.P.)
Pin code No 473446.
80. Sujan Singh Kushwaha S/o Harparsad Kushwaha, aged about 36 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D Post R/o Chanderi District
Alirajpur (M.P.) Pin code No 473446.
Page 24 of 53
25 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
81. Singh Ram Pal S/o Hariram, aged about 40 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Chanderi District Alirajpur (M.P.) Pin code
No 473446.
82. Naval Singh Rajpoot S/o Motilal, aged about 40 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Bhopal District Bhopal (M.P.) Pin
code No 462001.
83. Mahesh S/o Kashiram, aged about 34 years, Occupation Service Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Bhopal District Bhopal (M.P.) Pin code No
462001.
84. Deepak Raikwar S/o Late Shir Phoolchandra Raikwar, aged about 35
years, Occupation Service - Daily wager Group D. Post R/o Bhopal District
Bhopal (MP) Pin code No 462001.
85. Shekhar Kumar Patel S/o Gaurishankar Patel, aged about 32 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D. Post R/o Bhopal District Bhopal
(MP) Pin code No 462001.
86. Pradeep Sahu S/o Omprakash Sahu, aged about 25 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D. Post R/o Bhopal District Bhopal (M.P.) Pin
code No 462001.
87. Lakhan Singh S/o Kisan Lal, aged about 43 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Bhopal District Bhopal (M.P.) Pin code No
462001.
88. Ganpati S/o Gopal Singh, aged about 26 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Bhopal District Bhopal (M.P.) Pin code No
462001.
89. Sanjay Dwivedi S/o Late Shri Krishanawatar, aged about 35 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil
Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
Page 25 of 53
26 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
90. Dharmendra Shukla S/o Jageswar aged about 36 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
91. Kailash Dwivedi S/o Ramswaroop Dwivedi aged about 35 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil
Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
92. Mukesh S/o Sangam lal, aged about 34 years, Occupation Service Daily
wager Group D Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur
(M.P.) Pin code No.471625.
93 Brajraj S/o Shri Halke, aged about 46 years, Occupation Service Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur
(M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
94. Ranmat Singh Yadav S/o Shri Mavadeen Yadav, aged about 28 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil
Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
95. Anand Kumar S/o Bikku Yadav, aged about 38 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
96. Surendra Raiwar S/o Rajju Raikwar, aged about 35 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
97. Nathuram Kushwaha S/o Shir Bandi Kushwaha, aged about 42 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil
Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
98. Prem Raikwar S/o Nandram Raikwar, aged about 34 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
Page 26 of 53
27 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
99. Mangal Singh S/o Buddhe, aged about 38 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar, District
Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
100. Rameshwar Raikwar S/o Late Shri Kittai Prasad Raikwar, aged about
37 years, Occupation Service Daily wager Group D Post R/o Khajuraho,
Tehsil Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
101. Manish Kumar Singh S/o Umashankar Singh Group D Post R/o
Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar. District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No
471625.
102. Bablu Kushwaha S/o Shri Brajraj, aged about 49 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
103. Kuldeep Kushwaha S/o Ramswaroop, aged about 31 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
104. Rajkumar Choubey S/o Kamlesh Kumar Choubey, aged about 33
years, Occupation Service - Daily wager Group D Post R/o Khajuraho,
Tehsil Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
105. Krishna Kushwaha S/o Shri Natthu Kushwaha, aged about 35 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil
Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
106. Dharmendra S/o Jagdish aged about 32 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar, District
Chhatarpur (M.P) Pin code No 471625.
107. Anil Balmiki S/o Jamuna Prasad, aged about 35 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
Page 27 of 53
28 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
108. Umashankar S/o Late Shri Bhagwan Das, aged about 33 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil
Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
109. Jitendra Dubey S/o Ashok Kumar, aged about 38 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
110. Kehar Vishwakarma S/o Maniram Vishwakarma, aged about 39 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil
Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
111. Jitendra Tiwari S/o kunj Bihari Tiwari, aged about 33 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil
Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
112. Rajneesh Tiwari S/o Brijkushur Tiwari, aged about 32 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D. Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil
Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
113. Horilal Sen S/o Sangam Lal Sen, aged about 36 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (MP) Pin code No 471625.
114. Pahad Singh Yadav S/o Matadeen yadav,aged about 32 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil
Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
115. Vipul Sarkar S/o Vimal Sarkar, aged about 30 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
116. Umakant Dubey S/o Ashok Dubey, aged about 28 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
Page 28 of 53
29 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
117. Jaiprakash Dubey S/o Sakhi Gopal Dubey, aged about 30 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil
Rajnagar. District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625
118. Ramkant Dubey S/o Dwarika Prasad, aged about 35 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (M.P) Pin code No 471625.
119. Reghuvir Raikwar S/o Narayandas, aged about 37 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (MP.) Pin code No 471625.
120. Deepak Kushwaha S/o Nathuram Kushwaha, aged about 28 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil
Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
121. Thakurdas Patel S/o Ramswaroop Patel, aged about 29 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil
Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
122. Harishankar Dubey S/o Shivratan Dubey, aged about 30 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil
Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
123. Parsu S/o Lallu, aged about 35 years, Occupation Service Daily wager
Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.)
Pin code No 471625.
124. Tidiya Raikwar S/o Kanhaiya, aged about 36 years. Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
125. Satish Tiwari S/o Keshav Prasad Tiwari, aged about 32 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D. Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil
Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
Page 29 of 53
30 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
126. Rajendra Dixit S/o Bhaiyaram, aged about 45 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
127. Vinod Singh Parihar S/o Jivan Singh Parihar, aged about 38 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil
Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
128. Rajesh Kumar Singh S/o Achhelal, aged about 38 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
129. Mohammad Shani S/o Pyar Mohammad, aged 34 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
130. Ramdatta Pandey S/o Santosh Pandey, aged about 42 years,
Occupation Service - Daily wager Group D Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil
Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
131. Parasuram Rajak S/o Rakshi Pasad, aged about 30 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
132. Saddam Hussain S/o Kadeer Khan, aged about 30 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
133. Hashib Ali s/o Sagir Ali aged about 34 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar, District
Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
134. Pushpendra Awashthi S/o Sundarlal Awashthi, aged about 35 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil
Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
Page 30 of 53
31 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
135. Smt. Sunita W/o late Shri Rajendra Chourasiya, aged about 42 years,
Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil
Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
136. Shri Dhaniram Sonakiya S/o Shri Haridas Sonakiya, aged about 45
years, Occupation Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Khajuraho,
Tehsil Rajnagar, District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No.471625.
137. Tripurari, S/o Shri Daya Shankar, aged about 38 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
138. Bhagirath Pal, S/o Shri Khandupal, aged about 30 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D - Post R/o Khajuraho, Tehsil Rajnagar,
District Chhatarpur (M.P.) Pin code No 471625.
-Applicants
(By Advocate - Shri Subodh Tamrakar)
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Culture, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi 110001.
2. Archaeological Survey of India through its Director General, Janpad,
New Delhi 110001.
3. Regional Director (Central Zone), Archaeological Survey of India, T.T.
Nagar, Bhopal (M.P.) 462001.
4. Superintendent Archaeologist Survey of India, Bhopal Zone, Bhopal
(M.P.) 462001.
-Respondents
(By Advocate - Shri K.N. Pethia)
7. ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.200/40/2019
1 to 5 deleted.
Page 31 of 53
32 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
6. Jagdish S/o Shri Kehar Singh aged about 45 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D Post Mandsore, Ward No.2 Gandhi Chouk, District
Mandsore (MP) Pin code No. 458001.
7. Smt. Shyamu Bai W/o, Jagdish aged about 40 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D - R/o Ward No.2 Gandhi Chouk, Mandsore, District
Mandsore (M.P.) Pin code No. 458001.
8. Ravishankar S/o Shri Gendalal, aged about 48, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D - Post R/o Mandsore, Ward No.2, Gandhi Chouk,
District Mandsore (M.P.) 458001.
9. Dev Das, S/o Shri Kailash, aged about 38 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.2, Gandhi Chouk, Mandsore,
District Mandsore (M.P.) 458001.
10. Shivnath, S/o Shri Anokhilal, aged about 40 years, Occupation Service
- Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.2, Gandhi Chouk, Mandsore,
District Mandsore (M.P.) 458001.
11. Lokesh, S/o Shri Shivram, aged about 33 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.2, Gandhi Chouk, Mandsore,
District Mandsore (M.P.) 458001.
12. Sitaram, S/o Shri Bhagirath, aged about 49 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.2, Gandhi Chouk, Mandsore,
District Mandsore (M.P.) 458001.
13. Omprakash, S/o Shri Puniya, aged about 35 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.2, Gandhi Chouk, Mandsore,
District Mandsore (M.P.) 458001.
14. Govind S/o Shri Motiram, aged about 45 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.2, Gandhi Chouk, Mandsore,
District Mandsore (M.P.) 458001.
Page 32 of 53
33 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
15. Sitaram, S/o Shri Kadwaji, aged about 48 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.2, Gandhi Chouk, Mandsore,
District Mandsore (M.P.) 458001.
16. Gangaram S/o Shri Chandar, aged about 36 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D - Post R/o Mandsore, Ward No.2, Gandhi Chouk,
District Mandsore (M.P.) 458001.
17. Shri Ram, S/o Shri Sakharam, aged about 38 years, Occupation Service
- Daily wager Group D - Post R/o Mandsore, Ward No.2, Gandhi Chouk,
District Mandsore (M.P.) 458001.
18. Laxmi Narayan, S/o Shri Gendalal, aged about 47 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D - Post R/o Mandsore, Ward No.2, Gandhi
Chouk, District Mandsore (M.P.) 458001.
19. Tantu, S/o Shri Jangaliya, aged about 48 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D - Post R/o Mandsore, Ward No.2, Gandhi Chouk,
District Mandsore (M.P.) 458001.
20. Kamal, S/o Shri Sitaram, aged about 34 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D - Post R/o Mandsore, Ward No.2, Gandhi Chouk,
District Mandsore (M.P.) 458001.
21. Deleted.
22. Deleted.
23. Bhanwar Lal, S/o Shri Ramlal, aged about 38 years, Occupation Service
- Daily wager Group D - Post R/o Mandsore, Ward No.2, Gandhi Chouk,
District Mandsore (M.P.) 458001.
24. Shruti Pradhan, S/o Shri Sekhar, aged about 38 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager, Group D - Post, R/o near Post Office Ashok
Colony, Bhopal, District Bhopal (M.P.) 482001.
Page 33 of 53
34 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
25. Anil Kushwah, S/o Shri Mardan Singh, aged about 32 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager, Group D - Post, R/o near Post Office Ashok
Colony, Bhopal, District Bhopal (M.P.) 482001.
26. Ranjeet Singh, S/o Shri Ramdayal, aged about 36 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager, Group D - Post, R/o near Post Office Ashok
Colony, Bhopal, District Bhopal (M.P.) 482001.
27. Gopal Singh, S/o Shri Lal Singh, aged about 38 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager, Group D - Post, R/o near Post Office Ashok
Colony, Bhopal, District Bhopal (M.P.) 482001.
28. Arvind S/o Shri Balmukund, aged about 36 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager, Group D - Post, R/o near Post Office Ashok Colony,
Chanderi, District - Alirajpur (M.P.) 463446.
29. Anil Sen, S/o Shri Phoolchand Sen, aged about 34 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager, Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.4, near Mata Mandir,
Chanderi, District Alirajpur (M.P.) 463446.
30. Deepak Tiwari, S/o Shri Kedarnath Tiwari, aged about 33 years,
Occupation Service - Daily wager, Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.4, near
Mata Mandir, Chanderi, District Alirajpur (M.P.) 463446.
31. Ashutosh Sharma, S/o Shri Ashok Sharma, aged about 32 years,
Occupation Service - Daily wager, Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.4, near
Mata Mandir, Chanderi, District Alirajpur (M.P.) 463446.
32. Rajeev S/o Shri Lal Sahab, aged about 45 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager, Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.4, near Mata Mandir, Chanderi,
District Alirajpur (M.P.) 463446.
33. Deleted.
34. Deleted.
Page 34 of 53
35 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
35. Vikram, S/o Shri Narayan Singh, aged about 38 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager, Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.4, near Mata Mandir,
Chanderi, District Alirajpur (M.P.) 463446.
36. Gopi S/o Shri Kanhiyalal, aged about 42 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager, Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.4, near Mata Mandir, Chanderi,
District Alirajpur (M.P.) 463446.
37. Deleted.
38. Deleted.
39. Deleted.
40. Chandan, S/o Shri Moolchand, aged about 36 years, Occupation Service
- Daily Wager Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.4 Sachi, Raisen, District
Raisen (M.P.) 464551.
41. Abdul Vaseem, S/o Shri Saeed Khan, aged about 35 years, Occupation
Service - Daily Wager, Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.4 Sachi, Raisen,
District Raisen (M.P.) - 464551.
42. Deleted.
43. Pannalal, S/o Shri Ramsewak, aged about 35 years, Occupation Service
- Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o near Buteswar Mandir, Sagar, District
Sagar (M.P.) 470001.
44. Devi Singh, S/o Shri Deendayal, aged about 36 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o near Buteswar Mandir, Sagar,
District Sagar (M.P.) 470001.
45. Ajay Singh Rajbhar, S/o Shri Acchelal, aged about 34 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o near Buteswar Mandir, Sagar,
District Sagar (M.P.) 470001.
Page 35 of 53
36 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
46. Amar Singh, S/o Shri Brijlal, aged about 36 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o near Buteswar Mandir, Sagar, District
Sagar (M.P.) 470001.
47. Mangal Ahirwar, S/o Shri Udal Ahirwar, aged about 38 years,
Occupation Service - Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o near Buteswar
Mandir, Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) 470001.
48. Dwarik Prasad, S/o Shri Kadorill, aged about 38 years,
Occupation Service - Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o near Buteswar
Mandir, Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) 470001.
49. Brijbhan, S/o Shri Umashankar, aged about 35 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o near Buteswar Mandir, Sagar,
District Sagar (M.P.) 470001.
50. Deleted.
51. Dharmendra, S/o Shri Kok Singh, aged about 36 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o near Buteswar Mandir, Sagar,
District Sagar (M.P.) 470001.
52. Shiv Prasad, S/o Shri Naryan Singh, aged about 35 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o near Buteswar Mandir, Sagar,
District Sagar (M.P.) 470001.
53. Raghuraj Singh, S/o Shri Narayan Singh, aged about 38 years,
Occupation Service - Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o near Buteswar
Mandir, Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) 470001.
54. Deleted.
55. Santosh, S/o Shri Tejram, aged about 37 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o near Buteswar Mandir, Sagar, District
Sagar (M.P.) 470001.
Page 36 of 53
37 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
56. Deleted.
57. Deleted.
58. Deleted.
59. Sitaram Sahu, S/o Shri Gaya Prasad Sahu, aged about 36 years,
Occupation Service - Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o near Buteswar
Mandir, Sagar, District Sagar (M.P.) 470001.
60. Deleted.
61. Deleted.
62. Arun Kumar, S/o Shri Sanjay Vishvakarma, aged about 35 years,
Occupation Service - Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.25, Near
Ranital, Jabalpur, District Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001.
63. Ganesh Sen, S/o Shri Tejilal, aged about 35 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.25, Near Ranital, Jabalpur,
District Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001.
64. Ishwar Sahay Shrivastava, S/o Shri Narayan, aged about 45 years,
Occupation Service - Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.25, Near
Ranital, Jabalpur, District Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001.
65. Kamlesh, S/o Shri Kaluram, aged about 36 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.25, Near Ranital, Jabalpur,
District Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001.
66. Rajendra Kader, S/o Shri Harihar, aged about 34 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.25, Near Ranital,
Jabalpur, District Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001.
67. Shivraj Patel, S/o Shri Mahabali, aged about 35 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.25, Near Ranital,
Jabalpur, District Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001.
Page 37 of 53
38 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
68. Suraj Barman, S/o Shri Darbari Barman, aged about 35 years,
Occupation Service - Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.25, Near
Ranital, Jabalpur, District Jabalpur (M.P.) 482001.
69. Fuliya, S/o Shri Badiya, aged about 36 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.5, Mandav, District Dhar (M.P.)
454001.
70. Deleted.
71. Santosh Yadav, S/o Shri R.S. Yadav, aged about 36 years, Occupaton
Service - Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.8, Vidisha, District -
Vidisha (M.P.) 464399.
72. Deleted.
73. Phool Singh, S/o Shri Jagnnath, aged about 38 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D - Post, R/o Ward No.8 Vidisha, District -
Vidisha (M.P.) 464399.
-Applicants
(By Advocate - Shri Subodh Tamrakar)
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary Ministry of Culture, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi 110001.
2. Archaeological Survey of India through its Director General, Janpad,
New Delhi 110001.
3. Regional Director (Central Zone) Archaeological Survey of India, T.T.
Nagar, Bhopal (M.P.) 462001.
4. Superintendent Archaeologist Survey of India, Bhopal Zone, Bhopal
(M.P.) 462001.
-Respondents
Page 38 of 53
39 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
(By Advocate - Shri K.N. Pethia)
8. ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.200/369/2019
1. Rituraj S/o Thakur Prasad, aged about 33 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o H. No. 787, Near T.B. Hospital, Bajpayee
Nagar, Hazur Bhopal (M.P.), Pin code No 462001.
2. Jayantraj S/o Thakur Prasad, aged about 30 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o H. No. 787, Near T.B. Hospital, Bajpayee
Nagar, Hazur Bhopal (M.P.), Pin code No 462001.
3. Jagdish S/o Narayan Singh, aged about 25 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 3, Nemawar, Dewas (M.P.), Pin
code No 455336.
4. Deepak S/o Kamlesh, aged about 28 years, Occupation Service - Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 7, Panchmardhi, District Hoshangabad
(M.P.), Pin code No 461001.
5. Ramesh S/o Sundarlal, aged about 59 years, Occupation Service - Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 11, Nemawar, Dewas (M.P.), Pin code
No 455336.
6. Yogesh S/o Krishna, aged about 28 years, Occupation Service Daily
wager Group D. Post R/o Ward No. 5. Bangali Colony, Hoshangabad (MP),
Pin code No 466001.
7. Badami S/o Punnalal, aged about 47 years, Occupation Service Daily
wager Group D. Post Rio Talpura, District Sehore (M.P.), Pin code No
466001.
8. Rajeshwar S/o Madan, aged 25 years, Occupation Service Daily wager
Group D- Post R/o Village Raipur, District Hoshangabad (M.P.), Pin code
No 461001.
Page 39 of 53
40 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
9. Mukesh S/o Tejilal, aged about 34 years, Occupation Service Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Village Pangurariya, District Sehore (M.P), Pin
code No.466001.
10. Suraj S/o Ramvilash, aged about 22 years, Occupation Service - Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 11, Nemawar, Dewas (M.P.), Pin code
No 455336.
11. Mukesh S/o Ramsingh, aged about 28 years, Occupation Service - Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 10, Nemawar, Dewas (M.P.), Pin code
No 455336.
12. Sachin S/o kallu, aged about 26 years, Occupation Service - Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 8, Nemawar, Dewas (M.P.), Pin code
No 455336.
13. Virendra S/o Rajendra, aged about 28 years, Occupation Service - Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 11. Nemawar. Dewas (M.P.). Pin code
No 455336.
14. Rajesh S/o Kishorilal, aged about 29 years, Occupation Service - Daily
wager Group D. Post R/o H. No. 322/4 Krinagali Nemawar, Dewas (M.P.),
Pin code No 455339.
15. Vinod S/o Shivprasad, aged about 27 years, Occupation Service - Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 3, Nemawar, Dewas (M.P.), Pin code
No 455336.
16. Ashok S/o Hazarilal, aged about 26 years, Occupation Service - Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 12, Nemawar, Dewas (M.P.), Pin code
No 455336.
17. Rahul S/o Suresh, aged about 29 years, Occupation Service - Daily
wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 9, Nemawar, Dewas (M.P.), Pin code
No 455336.
Page 40 of 53
41 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
18. Ramesh S/o Chhannulal, aged about 44 years, Occupation Service -
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 19, Nemawar, Dewas (M.P.), Pin
code No 455336.
19. Satturam yadav, S/o Shri Babu Singh, aged about 48 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 7, Basant Gali, Ashok
Nagar Chanderi, (M.P.), Pin code No 473446.
20. Lalla Parihar S/o Shri Kunjilal, aged about 58 years, Occupation Service
- Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 5. Kadwaha. Ashok Nagar
Chanderi, (M.P.), Pin code No 473446.
21. Rafeek Khan, S/o Khadar Khan, aged about 55 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 7, Basant Gali, Ashok
Nagar Chanderi, (M.P), Pin code No 473446.
22. Aperbal, S/o Gora Goralal, aged about 57 years, Occupation Service
Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. No. 7, Basant Gali, Ashok Nagar
Chanderi, (M.P.), Pin code No 473446.
23. Chenlal Kevat, S/o Shri Viranlal, aged about 30 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 8, Amarkantak (M.P.),
Pin code No 484224.
24. Rattulal Baiga, S/o Chulbuhiya Baiga, aged about 40 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 14, Amarkantak (M.P.),
Pin code No 484224.
25. Prahlad Mehra, S/o Shri Sheshman Mehra, aged about 29 years,
Occupation Service - Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 8, Tehsil
Rajgarh, District Anoopupur (M.P.), Pin code No 484224.
26. Raghu Prasad, S/o Shri Sarwan, aged about 30 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 13, Amarkantak (M.P.),
Pin code No 484224.
Page 41 of 53
42 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
27. Sudhir Sen S/o Suresh Prasad, aged about 32 years, Occupation Service
- Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 15, Amarkantak (M.P.), Pin
code No 484224.
28. Radhelal Chandravanshi, S/o Shankar, aged about 36 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 14, Amarkantak (M.P.),
Pin code No 484224
29. Bhagwat Prasad, S/o Shri Tularam, aged about 45 years, Occupation
Service Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 17, Amarkantak (M.P.),
Pin code No 484224.
30. Teeharu, S/o Shri Vishal Singh, aged about 55 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 13, Amarkantak (M.P.),
Pin code No 484224.
31. Sabeer Khan, S/o Shri Gafoor Khan, aged about 44 years, Occupation
Service - Daily wager Group D- Post R/o Ward No. 18, Amarkantak (M.P.),
Pin cod No 484224.
-Applicants
(By Advocate - Shri Subodh Tamrakar)
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Culture, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi 110001.
2. Archaeological Survey of India through its Director General, Janpad,
New Delhi 110001.
3. Regional Director (Central Zone) Archaeological Survey of India, T.T.
Nagar, Bhopal (M.P.) 462001.
4. Superintendent Archaeologist Survey of India, Bhopal Zone, Bhopal
(M.P.) 462001.
-Respondents
Page 42 of 53
43 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
(By Advocate - Shri K.N. Pethia)
9. ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.200/398/2019
1. Vipin Kumar Singh S/o Shri Patch Bahadur Singh, Aged 44 years,
Occupation -Service- Daily Wager, Group D Post. R/o, Village Chandreh
Post Gujrer, Tehsil Rampur Nainik, District-Sidhi (M.P.) 486775.
2. Shivnath Yadav S/o, Shri Sukhdev Yadav, Aged 56 years, Occupation-
Service-Daily Wager, Group D Post, R/o Village Chandreh Post Gujrer,
Tehsil Rampur Nainik, District-Sidhi (M.P.) 486775.
3. Jokhai Kol S/o, Shri Tersava Kol Aged 54 years Occupation- Service-
Daily Wager, Group D Post, R/o,Village Chandreh Post Gujrer, Tehsil
Rampur Nainik, District-Sidhi (M.P.) Pin- 486775.
4. Lalu Kol S/o, Shri Ramhit Kol, Aged 48 years Wager, Group D Post,
R/o, Village Chandreh Post Gujrer, Tehsil Rampur Nainik, District-Sidhi
(M.P.) Pin-486775.
5. Kanhaiya S/o, Chhotelal Yadav, Aged 57, Occupation-Service- Daily
Wager, Group D Post R/o, Village Deor Kauthar, Post Katra, Tehsil
Teothar, District Rewa (M.P.) Pin-486117
6. Baboolal S/o, Chhotelal Yadav, Aged 47 years, Occupation- Service-
Daily Wager, Group D Post R/o,Village Deor Kauthar, Post Katra, Tehsil
Teothar, District Rewa (M.P.) Pin-486117.
7. Anil Kumar Patel S/o, Shri Laxman Prasad Patel, Aged 36 years,
Occupation-Service- Daily Wager, Group D Post R/o, H.No.L.I.G.-54,
Housing Board, Chirhula Colony, District-Rewa (M.P.) Pin-486001.
8. Sushil Kumar Pandey S/o, Shri Chhedilal Pandey, Aged 38 years,
Occupation-Service- Daily Wager, Group D Post R/o, Village 501 Mahsav,
Ward No. 11. Post Mahahav. Tehsil. Gush, District-Rewa (M.P.) Pin
486553.
Page 43 of 53
44 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
9. Sudama Prasad Kol S/o, Shri Ramkumar kol, Aged 28 years. Occupation-
Service- Wager, Group Raushar, Near D Daily Post R/o 63 Middle School,
Tehsil Hujur. District Rewa (M.P.) Pin-486001
10 Ram Lakhan Vishwakarma S/o. Swamideen Vishwakarma, Aged 44
years, Occupation-Service Daily Wager, Group D Post R/o Ward No. 8,
Near Government School, Kurmihai Tola, Barhat, Tehsil Uchhera, District-
Satna (M.P.) Pin-485001.
11. Raj Kamlesh Prajapati S/o, Shri Arjun Prajapati, Aged 40 years,
R/o,Occupation-Service- Daily Wager, Group D Post R/o Ward No.14,
Village Barhat, Tehsil Uchhera, District-Satna (M.P.) Pin-485001.
12. Ramdas Kol S/o, Shri Lallan Kol, Aged 44 Occupation-Service-Daily
years, Wager, Group D Post R/o Village Khamariya, Parasmaniya Pahadi,
Bhumra, Tehsil Uchhehra, District-Satna (M.P.) Pin-485551.
13. Neeraj Kumar Garg S/o, Shri Krishna Keshav Garg, Aged 26 years,
Occupation-Service- Daily Wager, Group D Post R/o H.No.18, Village
Khamariya, Post Gudha, Tehsil Uchherha, District-Satna (M.P.) Pin-
485551.
14. Pooran Singh S/o, Shri Balban Singh, Aged about 45 years, Occupation-
Service- Daily Wager, Group D Post R/oVillage Nachne, Post-Ganj, Tehsil
Gunauor, District-Panna (M.P.) Pin-488333.
15. Shyam Lal Kol S/o, Shri Harlal Kol, Aged 38 Occupation-Service-Daily
years, Wager, Group D Post R/o Village Nachne, Post-Ganj, Tehsil
Gunauor, District-Panna (M.P.) Pin-488333.
16. Chutoo Lal Kol, S/o Shri Shyamlal Kol, aged 34 years, Occupatoin -
Service - Daily Wager, Group D Post, R/o Village Nachne, Post -Ganj,
Tehsul Gunauor, District - Panna (M.P.) Pin - 488333.
17. Kunwar Kol, S/o Shri Baliya Kol, aged 33 years, Occupatoin - Service
- Daily Wager, Group D Post, R/o Village Nachne, Post -Ganj, Tehsul
Gunauor, District - Panna (M.P.) Pin - 488333.
Page 44 of 53
45 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
18. Gaya Prasad S/o Mihi Lal Kol, aged 55 years, Occupation - Service -
Daily Wager, Group D Post, R/o Village & Post - Ganj, Tehsil Gunauour,
District - Panna (M.P.) - 488333.
19. Sabbir Khan, S/o Gafoor Khan, aged 45 years, Occupation - Service -
Daily Wager, Group D Post, R/o H.No.1755/1, Nehru Ward No.02, Tehsil 0
Ajaygarh, District - Panna (MP) - 488220.
20. Ajay Kol, S/o Munnu Kol, aged 30 yers, Occupation - Service, Daily
Wager, Group D Post, R/o H.No.190, Malaiya Tola, Village Shilpara 52,
Tehsil - Hujur, District - Rewa (M.P.) - 486001.
21. Kanchhedi @ (Daddu) Dahiya, S/o Bhola Dahiya, aged 56 years,
Occupation - Service - Daily Wager, Group D Post, R/o Village Khamariya
Post Gudha, Tehsil Ucchehra, District - Panna (M.P.) - 485551.
22. Govind Prasad, S/o Shri Gajadhar Ahirwar, aged 33 years, Occupation -
Service - Daily Wager, Group D Post, R/o 51, Ward No.1, Ludhiyana
Mohalla, Tehsil Ajaygarh, District Panna (M.P.) - 488220.
23. Gorelal Kodar, S/o Joraiya Kodar, aged 59 years, Occupation - Service
- Daily Wager, Group D Post, R/o Village Taroni, Post Shindhpur, Tehsil -
Ajaygarh, District - Panna (M.P.) - 488220.
24. Mukund Kori, S/o Mullu Kori, aged 44 years, Occupation - Service -
Daily Wager, Group D Post, R/o H.No.1755/1, Nehru Ward No.02, Tehsil -
Ajaygarh, District - Panna (M.P.) - 488220.
25. Ram Sujan, S/o Shri Ram Sajeevan, Occupation - Service - Daily
Wager Group D Post, R/o Village Khamariya Post Gudha, Tehsil Uchhehra,
District - Panna (M.P.) - 485551.
26. Santosh Kumar Soni, S/o Shri Ram Gopal Soni, aged 43 years,
Occupation - Service - Daily Wager, Group D Post, R/o Ward No.27,
Village Purani Basti, Near Durga Mandir, Tehsil & District - Shahdol
(M.P.) - 484001.
Page 45 of 53
46 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
27. Ramawatar Kol, S/o Shri Ram Nath Kol, aged - 47 years, Occupation -
Service, Daily Wager Group D Post, R/o Village Raushar, Near 63 School,
Tehsil Hujur, District - Rewa (M.P.) - 486001.
28. Rambhan Kol, S/o Shri Ramshiromani Kol, aged 37 years, Occupation -
Service - Daily Wager, Group D Post, R/o Deour Kauthar, Post Katra,
Tehsil Teonthar, District - Rewa (M.P.) - 486117.
29. Sundar Lal Lodhi, S/o Shri Chamaklal Lodhi, Occupation - Service -
Daily Wager, Group D Post, R/o Village Lanhagi, Tehsil Sihora, Distraict -
Jabalpur (M.P.) 483501.
30. Ramujagar Patel, S/o Shri Shambhoo Dayal Patel, aged 40 years,
Occupation - Service - Daily Wager, Group D Post, R/o Village & Post
Kari Talai, District - Katni (M.P.) - 483990.
31. Shivbhan Patel, S/o Shri Ramawatar Patel, aged 22 years, Occupation -
Service - Daily Wager, Group D Post, R/o Village & Post Kari Talai,
District - Katni (M.P.) - 483990.
32. Harchand S/o Shri Dulichand, aged - 37 years, Occupation - Service,
Daily Wager, Group D Post, R/o Village Aashta, Tehsil Barghat, District -
Seoni (M.P.) - 480997.
33. Achhu Lal Kevat, S/o Shri Radhika Prasad Kevat, aged 36 years,
Occupation - Service - Daily Wager, Group D Post, R/o Village Silchar,
Post Badagaon, District - Rewa (M.P.) - 486117.
-Applicants
(By Advocate - Shri Ram Kishor Patel)
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Culture, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi - 110001.
2. Archeological Survey of India through its Director General Janpath, New
Delhi - 110001.
Page 46 of 53
47 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
3. Regional Director (Central Zone) Archeological Survey of India, T.T.
Nagar, Bhopal M.P. - 462001.
4. Superintendent Archaeologist Archeological Survey of India Bhopal
Zone, Bhopal, M.P. - 462001.
-Respondents
(By Advocate - Shri K.N. Pethia)
10. ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.200/427/2022
1. Sabnam Bano, W/o Shri Atul Jaleel, aged about 35 years, Occupation
Service, Daily Wager, Group D Post, R/o Govt. School Ke Samne, G.D.
wali gali Near R.T.O. Office, Vidisha, District - Vidisha (M.P.) - 464001.
2. Sarvan Sen, S/o Shri Rajaram Sen, aged about 28 years, Occupation
Service, Daily Wager, Group D Post, R/o Govt. School Ke Samne, G.D.
wali gali Near R.T.O. Office, Vidisha, District - Vidisha (M.P.) - 464001.
-Applicants
(By Advocate - Shri Subodh Tamrakar)
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Culture, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi - 110001.
2. Archeological Survey of India through its Director General Janpath, New
Delhi - 110001.
3. Regional Director (Central Zone) Archeological Survey of India, T.T.
Nagar, Bhopal M.P. - 462001.
4. Superintendent Archeological Survey of India Bhopal Zone, Bhopal,
M.P. - 482001.
-Respondents
(By Advocate - Shri K.N. Pethia)
(Date of reserving order : 30.04.2024)
Page 47 of 53
48 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
COMMONORDER
By Akhil Kumar Srivastava, JM.-
Since the issue involved in all these Original Applications is similar in nature, therefore, they are being adjudicated through a common order. For the purpose of this order, the facts are being taken from OA 200/1089/2017 unless specifically mentioned otherwise.
2. The applicants in these cases seeking regularisation under the respondents-Archaeological Survey of India on the ground that they have discharged more than 240 days of service continuously and have also completed the qualification as required for grant of temporary status and regularisation.
3. On 21.12.2017, while issuing notice to the respondents, this Tribunal has granted status quo in respect of the applicants, which is continuing as on date.
4. The matter regarding regularisaion of Casual Labourers working in different state of Archaological Survey of India was also under consideration before the coordinate Bench at Cuttack in O.A. No.340/2013 and while disposing of the Original Application vide order dated 29.04.2016, the Tribunal has directed as under:
Page 48 of 5349 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
"7. Mere running the eye over the order under Annexure-A/12 and the stand taken in counter at paragraph 11, quoted above, it is crystal clear that the Respondents are fair to the applicants as on consideration of their representation in the aforesaid order it was held that all the applicants except the applicant No.4 are entitled to the benefit of 1/30th pay and order to the above extent will be issued in due course. In view of the above, it is not necessary to go into the controversy much and this O.A. is disposed of with the following order:
(i) The Respondents are directed to pay all the applicants 1/30th of pay at the minimum of the relevant pay scale of a Group D plus DA, as has been paid to the counterpart employees of the Applicants, with effect from the date the same was paid to the juniors of the applicants, if not already paid in the meantime, within a period of NINTY days from the date of receipt of a copy of this order;
(ii) Failing to pay the benefits, as directed above, within the stipulated period, the applicants shall be entitled to interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date it became due till the entire amount is actually paid to the applicant."
5. Similarly, the Chandigarh Bench of this Tribunal vide its order dated 17.10.2018 passed in Original Application No.063/00873/2017 has directed to grant the applicants therin pay in similar terms as granted to similarly placed persons i.e. 1/30th of pay at the minimum of relevant pay scale and other related benefits available under the policy. Subsequently, the co- ordinate Bench at Kolkata in O.A. No.350/00936/2019 (Obaidul Islam and others vs. Union of India and others) vide its order dated 11.11.2022 has issued certain guidelines to form a committee to consider the cases of employees working in ASI. In view of such position, learned counsel for the Page 49 of 53 50 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs respondents appearing in Original Application No.477/2017 and other connected OAs filed before this Bench, had conceded that the respondent- department has constituted a committee to examine the case of all workers demanding regularization under ASI in the light of Supreme Court judgment and the rules and regulations vide order dated 20.04.2023. He further averred that the committee constituted has to submit its recommendations to the DG ASI within three months and a policy decision has been taken to grant 1/30th status to all casual labours who were on muster rolls and for regularization a committee has been constituted which was communicated vide letter dated 29.05.2023. In view of the statement made by learned counsel for the respondents in the aforesaid OAs, those Original Applications were disposed of with the following directions:
"2. Learned counsel for the respondents has submitted that the Co- ordinate Kolkata Bench of this Tribunal in O.A. No.350/00936/2019 (Obaidul Islam and others vs. Union of India and others) vide its order dated 11.11.2022 (Annexure R/1) has issued certain guidelines to form a committee to consider the cases of employees working in ASI. In compliance of said order, the respondent-department has constituted a committee to examine the case of all workers demanding regularization under ASI in the light of Supreme Court judgment and the rules and regulations vide order dated 20.04.2023 (AnnexureR/2). Further it is submitted by the respondents that the committee constituted has to submit its recommendations to the DG ASI within three months and a policy decision has been taken to grant 1/30th status to all casual labours who were on muster rolls and for regularization a committee has been constituted which was communicated vide letter dated 29.05.2023 (Annexure R/3).Page 50 of 53 51 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs
3. Learned counsel for the applicants submitted that the applicants will be satisfied if the respondents are directed to consider and decide their case for regularization along with other employees for which committee has already been constituted in a time bound manner.
4. Learned counsel for the respondents submits that he has no objection if the Original Application is disposed of as per law in above manner.
5. In view of the submissions made by learned counsel for the parties, these Original Applications are disposed of at this stage, without commenting on the merits of the case, directing the competent authority of respondents to consider and decide the applicants' case for regularization along with other employees, as per rules, within a period of 90 days from the date of communication of this order. For this purpose, applicants are directed to serve a copy of this order along with a copy of O.A. to respondent-authority."
6. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the pleadings and the documents available on record.
7. The issue regarding regularisation of the casual labourers/dail wagers working in ASI is no longer res integra as the same has already been decided by the Cuttack Bench of this Tribunal in OA No.340/2013 and subsequently by the Chandigarh Bench of this Tribunal in OA No.063/00873/2017, wherein while taking note of the fact that status of 1/30th of the pay has been granted to some similarly situated workers likewise the applicants therein, the Tribunal has directed to grant same status to the applicants. Similarly, when the same issue travelled to this Bench in OA No.477/2017 & other connected OAs, the same were disposed of with the consent of the parties vide order Page 51 of 53 52 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs dated 24.01.2024 to consider and decide the case of the applicants therein, within a period of 90 days from the date of communication of the order. We have not been apprised by either of the sides as to what decision has been taken by the Committee in pursuance of orders passed by us as now the period of three months for compliance is already over and failing to do so shall always be a subject matter of contempt. The applicants have also filed copy of the chart (Annexure A-3 along with OA No.200/40/2019) to show that their engagement was for more than 240 days throughout the years. In any case, the fact of the matter remains that once the ASI has already extended the 1/30th status of similarly situated counterparts of the applicants working in the Circles other than Madhya Pradesh, it is incumbent upon them to grant similar benefits to the present applicants also. Hence, if the applicants are otherwise similarly placed to that who have been granted the status of 1/30th of pay at the minimum of the relevant pay scale of a Group D plus DA, they are also entitled for the same treatment.
8. Accordingly, we dispose of all these Original Applications and direct the respondents to grant the status of 1/30th of pay at the minimum of the relevant pay scale of a Group D plus DA to the applicants, if they are similarly situated to the persons, who have already been extended this status Page 52 of 53 53 OA No.200/600/2017 & other connected OAs pursuance to the orders passed by the different Benches of this Tribunal. This exercise shall be completed within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. No order as to costs.
9. A copy of this order shall also be placed in other connected OAs.
(Kumar Rajesh Chandra) (Akhil Kumar Srivastava)
Administrative Member Judicial Member
am/-
Page 53 of 53