Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs K Venkatesh Dutt on 14 October, 2008
Bench: K.Sreedhar Rao, C.R.Kumaraswamy
(aawoonpv 'eqImInuV'a's we oBa'M"1'c1 rzmsirls K8)
-sfesddv 99.1111 321:;
{[9 H; :m:;puod$sa-- :;.:o[va3t_::;:'a'g«' » A'
9.50.13 peog umumg "{--I.'i)[\§-_ V'
ma I1s2>1I=-'>1Hé.mi. .
(aresonpv 'B{gqQ3qsai{S* f--,'w
sfewdv cam 91;; =
s3m3.{.{9'5dV' 83033333:
. 13°0ti«"¢=IIé¢~=*:¢>.'3%¥¥t>trn61'é1-'C; z-ézvira t9JIif3;)""XE*L'~'m00Hi J0 .muo§99kmwzo;i>.,1trass:s$v arm, -3 . 'V¢19.;(O[l33HI3fi ._ ' 1. P993: séta:«2iiCi""3t1'E?I¥I1a'z;1'3 " 3'£31_:vi£_)_O"£7£{V}'Lt}. Iauqjssymmog 91;; '1 . . ' . 'I ' :.i;:E:': ' _ A €o0a%d6%S%?6i0N'V"L'I A ...___"__'.'__..?37.l'5' gm c:%,»z:'o.n1's.m'1 8G9.Z___.:_{O Li7Z'ON'V'.L'I A 'j;x:zs;v,~s§S*:Ia§f'y's:{1>1'z1':) CEIC)i.LSf'lf"2:IW :a'1aw0H am, . _ « . GNU 'Qva 1avH::1:3m1s'}1 :e1:)1,1snr'Hw Manon (»]I~LL .LN{EIS'HE§cI '7.' , $3693 aaaomo 30 AVU Hm: 33.1. SEHJ. (]iH.LV{]
-- "'3éj;o';v9Nva J.v v>Iv1.vMav>I do 3.351011: HSXH am. NI /%:> 'MEI pure 102; go suogsaub Iegmgs fitzgzygonug 'sanmd 3II[':':}$'9I{1 0'3, Ixyeuad IIo}t:;:)9{q()-ssojg} 913;; pm; spaadde sang; 3S9I{'L~. _:
Lflfiflflflflf i3u1m0I{03'"9In« p9»i:2?n§1'=?1-5 9:*_ 'inn-his avnsaazis '£8? Sm 3H.£m9t:{' 10; U0 3'17».'A1"?'_°:1°'~ $'§?.LI 9$ ~'5'3a'J. 2 "
'a.;:c)[B3ueg 'g; :;{;1r_¢~;3 Ianusg 39 '1rIms:ssv 911:; 30 «$91360 am 8008'?)-?.8I~}i331BP I095/fives/oI'o.M II0:1:>=a§'q(s«. ?s's_<?-2):) ;}>!¥2"*%v--L'Q<j;6a,»/finesisgévn VJJ 13:; axogefinug '{efI:tzq§;1'L " tag --'.i';..gv:,i':>:)tI1 sq; Alq passed 191110 sq; ap§s2 ;;:s 01::Bt{§:}[§)'J'.)£s .jf['95g_ fiav X95, swoon] am .10 V095 T10§139S Jail?" saga 5.8 é:s~:«»z'o§i 'V1L'I Sm.L *;1Io{e3;r.eg "A ':$<1§.;{,.;1tfioor11_;o .I9{IO§SS];"£}}'[IIOQ 1IIms!ssV 9&1} .19 ié'i'>::a.._:évs*; 01 we €00E'2'Z'8I pan?-9 I005 /3383 I 6*<}m'- PUB 000% /3'~"1'38/ ZSSEVON vi; tr; axofefitiaggé X334 amootq sq; Kq passed xgaiéib am apfisujas 01 Strpgaas 3951 'my mg, ataoctxg sq; 395 '€093 "u<$§1i#*és i-mun "£«"V-V'-;"I'f '3¥ 9005 .10 owoxxx 'V'.L'I 81% A {am-flag 'X8; amoom jto .I9tI0;$s;mu1o;) 3'I91$!séxi..%«9"?~ 35910 am M93100 or: we eoozsrsz vamp /3u'ea~»!Vt*;_ -ow tronsefqo ssoxs we 0008/3398 /17<.39'0N «.11.: kjéxotéfiuv-8 'teIm<:iI~AL swnaddv mm amooul 91:': fiq xsfizo 91:33 apgsta 399 01 SzI_L)2[9:3s 1951 'my XE; atxroom 9q1 % 7f';-ofgregaz Houses Japan Dan} S: 9003 .10 z.W;'01~I 'V'J.'I Sm. alopq sfeadde sazq; pafg seq pmeumx _;o 19910 sq; Aq paaapzfifie 'EBUHQ?-'J. 311 JJEQS Q[{\L 'IIO§1E3.I9§}§SHOO I{S9.I_} .10} .:ar;1em 91;} [;}€3§}'{IB'l'.II3.I 'QUE Sq], JO .I9p.I0 Sm QIIQSB 19$ X].§.IOI{}I1E 'V 91'", *QL[{)) X81, swoon; _;o .I9{I{)§SS§I[H]IOQ 91;; 01 Ieaddgféué.' A' sssssssv '.£.8~986I W95 9&1 10.: -/OO0'()0'€O'I'SEI."9$S:¥§§SSE 3 sin 30 smooztg sq; p9SS:--.3SSt:".* AZ:gg.1oq1m{ 8u_:§ss«QS$v'1 'A -'agssgssé _ A' sq; Kc; paonpmd mu mam s11:x9u;rn_;)o(1 _é'1I.t:').1:'g;:¥{1pé>.;A). 'V 91;; Ayusnf on, s1u;;m'n;:roAp éégéfiége am uodn panes (Irv) &:V;£x9amnfJ%%'3u§$séfssv éfictianpap zrpauao pauxpafa peq aassassv *st;_r;I'ni';::J;:'.1:i9§[._s?<,>;".3 ':1; pauoguaux SB -/000'00*0€'v9$."'%§';?33" Se 9m03'I¥ Sm fimimoqs z.8;§>.36:' 10; mnam 1'-9S¥A9~I *3 Paul sassassy 'p9:zf.,zs aJLa.§§i 3t1'§.1'eII§{II§.I;)tI"§Z amos 'sums gig; ago sq}; " no ptm pgm pmoupuoa fitqm éfifisfifitaiérl .fi'A6;£§*'8;£?6I pm $33-1.351 'L8-986?'. s1e9£'1u9mssmss"e 91:1 '@911 (-mm-sfqo ssoao) sssssssv - nun 9813:) mg; JG 8103} '.I9{).IO IIOIIIHIOD V" pm; sagued sq; reaq '.I9q3,:;3o; mam .I9'{)'_(S'{.I0;) am aauan /'>0 'meant 3q 0.] T.I0'{I;O3fq€) SSQIO 9111 TQII} IQAQMOII QQSSQSSB' sq'; Kzpomny Sugssassv sq} suopq aassmsse 912;; 1SI.I§B38 Apamsx S1; ans.mcI pinoqs znms 91:13 1131;: D1333 um1aIpq1§m. E.2q oz; '{)9].}.fI1I.I3d sq Alem ptretuax 3:0 .mp.Io sq; ';St.t_t83B ~ mm mm reunqw, 91:8 910190: vammqns same 9§1;L.%:i-auieéiif ' L syq 313 as}; am pm: mzrg sq; 3:0 amoofiyatfjg '*£Io:1:j;.\1 Jaoggo Emgssasse 90;; 1BE;[1 pm; areafi 93.IlS'{§:_'é:'£"{_";n[[B .ia;. 93ssa's -a§'r} 9113,, JO 9'£]10:)I£'§ 9111:; size passasse Haaq fiat; ;3as;%s';:gsVVsa':<;.f"éi"{{:; jo spueq sq; try; (33); sq; pm": {mg sq; ;0--~3.1:;t_to:§t."q;_9I{:; T3;1éI;;.9;h§:sasse 91:3 xiq 'p9pII33|'£;[0() osm SBM Afiegz 1011 saop II.It'tZ},9_{ paspmiéxz sq), 1131;; pm; pmmq amp; se psgoafm 9;§;'g;"s; "sq; 121;; pangmqns 9.I0_;9.z91:[:; 9: 11 p9é'.méa_r'mi:1 5:5i09H¥ SW S9 ifuous 10; 'asxi game; 'magma Btrgfietrew 2 S'_[ fuoqs 33'i:€1«.:'iI'SV§:1%V§13Ui9A'}i 'qomm 330 um dn1s-Ia'rI::.mci 13 (nous ' V' '~....;:o_; 13131 111.11; 911130 swoon; sq; pasopsyp .p?e_qV._'q:;xe9s; _9f;:; 03 1101:1393: agtmtti E' SE' 'aassasse QIZLL 'me; I1; (13: sq 53-9361 xezm". sq), 10; pafg mamssassta p3S'_[AQ.I V" xtéigg fitxgpumum uog:;oa[qQ--sso.1;) psgg assssssta 911,1, 'cg; p(3S?AQ.I 913$ HMOQS EIIIIODEII Qqi}, Z}BI[], IIA5.0"{['S SEA': QQIIES pasymaz 913;), max; agsax .10 3321131 01 pangua S; a3ssasst;.';;;";3LV;§1§fi;;§'--.,,, pII¥C10_; OSF3 [QUE IIO'_Cj,C.)9_[q_O SSOJC) Gm QIIIIETIIIOO " ' '$1913 sq), fiq sfeaddta 9113 go {emmpI;{1'pm---- " sit; pugs; sgvq 'plgaaj no [ey.zs1etIx sq; 30 --.
E0 'fetrnqgu, sq; 'z{1]f.IOE{1nE' Aé}"t{.],__ Véfiéézzsée sq), Kq pag; S3'(1:3111"£130[) a1:[;__ a:)s*pa _ 9;)»$;v)?1{)I.'£'tD'i)' -- .r;;a.n§.§s stp B1 WHO; mtwwnwp 1319?}? é9:é %p"=aI:- #é?1i$:'j',:'*'?¥¥1{ 01 ummd 106 890? P68 CISX WHVQI 2-§I{1';1<> ii!-5%-rad sumw paspmax am II; }o___.-- 19:13, moqs 01 ({3}; pay V31" peq aassassv *9 % asssasse sq; pugq pmoqs 131111191 pasgnaa ;t.v--:I.[;' sq), azogaq psfg EI.I!11Q.I paspsm ;2:{1A_ 0:; V f;t{3!.I...£)kI S"8t[ 993998513 sq; gem uogmafqo séivgzzx ; 9t§; sq; mogaq psnfim 93,313 9111, -Q 3-qt; pattopuoo psaunqpj, *st1o§:);2[qo ssous
-. :E!:;§§:_-5: II; £e{é»9_Abs{e stem 9.I9L{J' °1u9'mss:9sse mfem 01 uopmpsprnf peq feunqpi 9133 321;; pm; arms; nxaptxadapttg H sf} uogoafqo ssmo sq; my pazxfonuy nogssnb 91:13; 1, /10 ~d1o:)stIagL '3J()[!~'.'3IIBE[--S91B"'{30SSV d.I€):).I91II{ J0 Qmootrz 91%: /iIwr:rm_:s 'var mm 9111 01 suganad aurms sq} sva £[:aAp,:39cIsa.: 59-3351 _ mm 88-L86": 'L8-936: S-ma 1U9U1'5S9'-95V 10.1 S38: 0089 we 538: (}8'€8 'S9~10§¥<?,.€}fr'I'Sé$"" f._.
;o sggparo at}; spmsxa :l,{O_}8.lZ9I{J, utgqs V ' fitzgssassv sq; '(;moqB V1; med tr; SB) '€10'.31!?19d attxsruamas I1'! p$v:I;'"sI0:1'Hi'r=<iUI00 A no paseq pmndmoa S; " ' V J,ta=::{; £19952: 5; 1; '.I3'{3»IO. iu9msséésy¥:':;rj§L'-maxg (5) '[BQddB 1313110 szaééfl' go 9{IIO()"(I'§ 31'I§3.'3.dIII€)Z). V *§z:§)fL{.: )x;;{"
03, 3; V3; 30 amodigjlhgo 'sfififiéraaogiésgp .I£)t{1G ptre xgqjzgo 'suow£I=m..TSiI-.3u§t:rx:I;>'a:"'sm sq; (ql _ V % . gnoguang Osta ' ,,,gei;' §c::V ssaxdxa sq} 1stI;1-23:3 'u(§§:;taog[dd'e 1t19u1:m3,9-s .I9fi.1'§f9 "9131 max; 01 pspgus sg aossassv (tar) 31B'{{1 [3101] 31k\ S{I0'_{S§Z)9p srn0;I;é;;.. p1iafitzgprxg snoepa .m,o go mam '£11 '91,, 'Q1; qciexfiamd 11:2 13:13.10 angmsdo Sugmouog aIo;a.I9q1 [eunq;;yL sq; *9ass:3ss"e am 0; tI'_re;;.19d 10:1 {]S}{ pm: V31 mp go amoozrg; sq; S; 139; 1:; am S{I.I"tT{19.I uaaq peq [BQGGB spnuzmm sq], usqm amxaxxm sq), liq p3['[_; Ieaddza sq; oi; aassassla sq; Kq pap; <.§uo}1-zyqfqowssoxo am u:_re1.191u9 _ __ '
03. flfl¥13¥PS?~m.[ pm remq!-IJ. min mllstzm . ffii % ~ .10} 93,913 sq; liq pasodaxd SBM mm 30 SH(§;§1SQfi2t§ T. { ésatp.
0:; (2)91 qdmfiered 3122 Japlo 9{\*g:;1a1ad9__a§}jg.;{q ..;jAs9A<,).1_}1331n3AA:;;{%§;s 91% " ;;';>9z¥$éé:13.S £i:e%é:i'.%A2%'?¥4' aassasse go am srmangz" ._A__:§q:_1 91:13; 1:] '(6'§z2.. 333 591 Z) ;LI:5""?éA Ff #11 :é%é!--I1sI1pIII mow ;o IIO'{fS§D9p sq; 3H@:a[i§$ue§ sq mm LIE;/913 'vim <g:69x1:¢:ms Japan xsaxswl <2;
* _ V' 'wastes 91;; Stzgonpax ._ ~1o ' yaauenpw am s1I:9um_Z3.Ie 2 en,§>;n.')C;;9q peadde Hf; pafiuageqa ;1ou 5"p9H?-HA1 sq Irma XIIBIIPIAEPIII fiéwgiéa V. _;o amooug .I(~_)1f;0 Kuv (p) " . V 'SJBQK 99.11;;
2:71; _ ['[e ;to_; QQSSQSSB go aumciamg max; p9pn[.:)x:; ,9'q._ (fife .19:)g;Q Bmsssssv fiq psmdmoa S1'-3 ziaqmog-dxomaguj 'fiequzog-dxooefiayq "g:q[9(] t-/Ps ebpng '.10 3 ;3¥11"E'--. . ffifitgpxoaov '3AF1HULi{{,l'9«::§§$t§;.ri§ uogsrsanb 9103919131' '1{Ii9I¥VI0CIS9«I:':}?T»I1_ my I.I:}1Sl*3} 0; mapuodsm 'W1 J0 9m00'U5§ smaq saggua pyes 9:1'; 3:0 3'f103U! ~4'i"43I;I191{xM"4¥1_Vf5V 0i;Ts9m::t,ua ppas sq; go S1II1.'10(}3B sq; 'aoaag 'prong; no {epzaxem Am;
IIO pgmx sq 01 Jeacidta 101:1 S9013 ?;I?{9p{I0dS3.I V931 _;o a'€£1p0t1§.~3rg§§u§ss9ssB ggqm $99,133; anoqge 913;} go s;1m0o:>'e " LQ'~?:}V mag ~(}'V am 3I}i¥_;11II9AQ.Id feunqgq sq; Aiq 139IiS'$J;v{;Q]§;O9.1'§p B' 'azogalaq; 'uopmapgsuoo .10; paatzpoxd 31951 »d.I(}3.I32{[I[ ptre Xeqmog-droaefiaw 'flfl9(]--dJO3SHB1i Ii