Santosh Ramchandra Made vs M/O Communications on 23 September, 2020

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai

Santosh Ramchandra Made vs M/O Communications on 23 September, 2020

 

CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL ,

MUMBAI BENCH, MUMBAI.

O.R.2@h

gfo0184/2017

Mazch, 2020.

y of

a

ysdoler the ay™Ga

ished

Dated th

   

Or. Bhagwan Sah
Ravinder Raur,

ai, Member (Administrative)

Member (Judicial) -

«
*

Coram:

 

Pe

Cry
ts

4d

«3

in
3
wed

g

S
{Xe

Yersus

 

ip
34
ia
OD
3
wn
3
os
w
®
IX
tn
Q
od
(3
A
op
vt
i
he
us
Bs
aos
gek ged
CP AE
HB cams
mw
Cy acd
qy y
a4
rf i
ef
$4 bd
co
oh4
Ad
wy red
O..&
ta

( By Advocate Shri V.5. Masurkar }.

.
»

27.11.2019

 

Order reserved on

o. 2020.

a a

+
s

Order deliverad on

 

ORDER

Per : Dre. Bhagwan Sahai, Member {A}.

od is 44 i} Bus iy Yanara ail Sa bb 5} ore if rs hy im itt te @ @) t ts 20 gt ed (rs is wey cn xv} C$ G a 6 wo sod a4 iN} 8] aed ey & a Ke "Ct om 3 yet Ks no "os a Gy a cs) o reek « ry Wy Go e 2 y & ho o Ci & A O ee tes "5 i 3B $4 SS DB 4s Mea

8) oo 43 Oo gy

i) vy a $4 tS 1G oO 3 3 M ws ad ct ba aa we 33 tS u

- 4 .#] bt ote wy ie 43 ay sn ha "$

4. * $4 a En ord th a 4a cs wm Fa de: sy @ Set oe ht i ed ee) $3 ns ae c ae @ as ay 30 "4 a 4 od ne o vO Mo Go @ gt "3 ot 6 43 3.3 co KS ei) 3 Cx 4 id " Me aD aes a) ag bed x a 4 4 ct 4 ony BY ad 4 £ LD ee "3 ro aed t~ w oo. ° 3 r on in ced rt i es " bet @ ; a) " G4 tig ir} oy fh 3 wo . i es ag coy "+ - { 4 ayeg Oo ' ed rs Oo "h co xt wes, a a4 as is SS Os "4 i , 3 ged Ch "> '4 3 ht Ci a) Fe 5B 43 mG w a4 o> + ° o " es ie % yO a rad in x5 > ase pa - "oa 2 ~ Od a "

: i $4 th 5 Bias ay Ct . UNE C3 . s ES $3 €

"4 ons . Oh ; a ; Pa is id 6 wt Gi B et oO rt ot i thea ry Os me a % ta *s C4 pd es ot mo ' a wv , od tet 'a fi "4 5 it 3 5 O wed " ro " © to Ned sy <3 B} on b 6 "C3 vet A "3 cs e3 4 BD aed a * Q ot A cs » oe 8 r % y og ; ! "eh Bs is 5 bet a rm . uD , 4 i in vl 8 . Ass a @ QO bd wed $4 rs wy 'rd we y 7 ts ce) ® A i : + C 4 9 v 8) G cH ee et ae ma th os ' 5 a al o ©. a i ® fy ' 4 ry ea ; 3 a gt . ay " ws y w + 4 i § "4 Q i ip oe ved " o> i $e a me Q a wo Mo ke @ i . Oo te Fe 8 me we Bo To mM & Oo b&b oH wy 5S oh p, E » G6 @ § om £ Go © 6 Q oo3 8 By O a 3 4 ip oA nd 2 4 a 4 : «8 5 4 it © w "4 , ot Mi : Ma ted | 4. ey ce 3 4 } 4 ke & G be ' a # oy o 4d 8 a i B bs G Q "> mw OO ~ 8 2 B Be OC £ h% m 8 wi f ay Pu ant we a) 4 4 cs T "3 " is? 4 x) oe 44 4 cs ce ort ® ; gy OC % ia ha eo ve rm ' oe ¢ ; ve u ry 4 (3 a . ss é ae ' a a my G wn 624 ho ed aU x & its C fw Ph ey oa a oh co Ace : hy cat 3 seed 3 y i ¢ cS tO fy is hes * ed es Lt 3 a iw i aa! + ua wy . a " a G a + ip : * "3 t i 44 as y $ :

wed wD ee) ved = bys & i 4 is 4 B mn ns * AS "4 x ms om oH . # m yw. 8 f & By 5 Cw PB a Qe oR ' a ef , SM me BD Moe My lm GBH. G es ts 9 ts . "rt "4 3 Aa od ot . "4 sar 3 Ce 4 a {2 iG oh usd Goo M4 ® a ¢ oe a. Gi ed aa mC GO 04 ry Y in UO t oD fia} 44 : © Ly 4 } bey 3 tee : Nn, (} 4 Ns not 4 44 ix iD rea) Q G 3 15 a a 4 3 cy de qs ot * c te c i fe i f : Z : i vod ~ BR ' : a : oo ae) oh Ay 23 io * % ed o a ia a 4 i @ . $3 4 2 OB, bs 7 2 nt , "§ 2 ob oD Fi oc @ ans} Go ® me ah a" mo . o eh Mg Oy G 3 & eed 2 4 a oy es {i ip Ad Fs Q aa a h a # res} Gj as 7 3B week vas "4 a EP ii ee oa oi oe4 ye a *) As i 4h ES nS CO € § 8B mw 3 eek ee Tg et Bo ge ws wh vif 2 v i & 4 a od oa rye ved Bs e "4 wed Ax 2 me os ard i Font $3 Cs : ¥ a ad e3 on, 43 a ha ha Ae wg xt ~ a £4 3 ~ 4d ' oF io) os wt i q PD go o go 2 Ge FG a 4 2 O 2 mp et i} a % * Y th tha 3 cS Dy 5 * a 4 ~ 4 ~ ch om ® 3 in i wv 6) QO tt 3 bd . re 3 43 ws rt " " os "rt 4 i, @ ' ef 4 g @ ai <f i 33 a s SB As Q3 se ae get ip mS vet $4 os a or QD: hy 6 ur 6 oo bs Sf 6 % red $$ * & vd ta UG D, 2 vod h in ot . G o . cad ord ag ay & A x & os "3 is a ra BA g gt b G a w ved a a] ca wee ih % aS us im & me 43 2 oo 6 O fo ei het "4 ard ts M% a ua iy ney gS el a © ae H '3 tS i ed o @ 1 Qo es za wh w is Re} | a © G 3 $4 @ @ & ics fea oD i sed sre a @ "3 "s ri 6 a 6 2B cs ts ey Be & as 4 a 6 & £ » & ed ogy mp wn Ls @ Co i ie hed wo iD { a 6 A qs we wt cH ret rv} "nf i oe oe 0 ed i ts ved oe oh a 2 ih o rt Sg cs at B o eo 6 AG @ sy 13 oo i7 @ tn mg cc in « a a 2 C 4 3 4 aw Leo ' & 0 w sy 0G rt i "$ ™M , Oo 8 w i oo Ut ba ip mE ced i.

a b . ys a3 . cy oa % oa o we i} oy Aa % ms Mu i Th et, 4g gt C65 £D> a wy é. xs m5 ced 43 A? #) ae a3 ae ae, ' 4 is (33 * Y sa a © os a WW as 4 iw sa & $4 " a7 ed ~~ ys 3, 43 3 - Q 02s / Fa 5 uo 3 . mi Y ba - W at wD Sea 13 ard 8 . wd rh KE is & 0 3] BT vs a " fh it o -$ ~ a Ee fe c + 43 6 D 4 a apd co " ry a 8 a . *. x3 aa "4% i) 3 $e + » ch oa m oo » "s oh wo 4 G ort 8 uo fF a " Seed gt a 2, a | OM ho 4 " gq Ya © is Q ved 13 a io ' neo a 4 wy 43 tro oe ht "

i " r ' 6 " ve fs as CO oO at 7h] 4d oO ad "

ae ve "{ q 8) a fa ' - 4 , 4 ve vet G u ib ay 43 ud a "d o ie on " e ks 9} et @ z Q ot 4 4 : wy oo wa 3 ; of o ed cos of -- " % "74 ® aS eo a a " 4 i eo A . C6 D o GC os i AS C Cy : j I ow! $ ie iD fap oe Q . a , Bog nm Yo " "

1 5 ' i ws wD Uh bs x "$4 a w a4 nt S & cs BY agin ~ ~ 6 GS 4 o © are s i 0 = c & y te a ed ee a i ¢3 "el ® "s 44 " G e y Oo v red 0} : Cy ord SS a Wy ca . 4) it % ie Ba : 3 a} oe a a uy # re Q ol buf Q ed ng m th 4 2 @ a Oo G 4 . oD va " % 2 C 43 g te 43 4 4 =3n 5 & 5 a .

ce As AR 2 = Pp : ed . Ps W) 'S a is £ vd 3 Bs ¢ ua . * ar Fa, wed © 3 a 0 "4 £2 Os % vot a ; hs C th on ' we gh iv ' , in be EA el ve @ at @ dy a Bs . " Ol © te | oh ay Co ved . £2 mm yg ip Hey "ed vd ont ms us ay 4) ts oA fa ee a w q i | Oo vet C4 £2 4:1 D G on tq &! Md He 43 o ; 3 red a $4 co . c ok cs ie a 5 need Gh vee @ $2 ae os ae th) reed re ot ia . t hes oes nel ot #4 ae © f S "i u3 - ' o ba He Gd 5 de ® 3 S| ved god ot td f se os & « 0 2 « oe oO 4+ ie ed 4 a ty iD oe | arf / is i wa am ve wo Bort BO Bt Pm Po ey ; Set oe aU m4 O® WD art eo i @ SS wm ££ FG @ $4 : 43 es be a 33 ba eg ; Or Ra a 0 6 ) 43 Wo , re 6 i in 0 ree wa af th 3 rot td na o vet wv & "& tf 5 Bh gD % y oS is a TS 5 ea 4 wn in en m 93 £3 +o 23 ba 4 nr 3 : ts i 4 a) ed . is - a wD ay wu £3 uM i 4 fi GB 3 ~ seb deg Go OQ 2» m 4 ay © GM » Gg i QB Chs YD 48 a cs Q OG ad bed 3 kd AS 9 a oe Q a ord Q ed a of ) tS @ i if fi ee o oO bel s a1 "rd it 2. uy ew) « Sd aw nef ' ved SS al o &t oO ted sed o 3 owt 8 ort Ye eal ee ya oe) in thes % BA i) 33 +4 ot or a 5) ES x3 '3 43 & a rot g oy SY o ty a ' 2017 ?

a4 OAl bel i oe cd SPRL oat od ord be, a?

Mt @ oy raat a z wae wai he wey, 2 ae of % x ia = 5 ba 3 evs 5 ah Be eet oe ceed bed 42 ge a up Ba 43 set sey ox a ae tty eo or a o 3 ie @3 Ms vet vod seed 3 a pret bd eK ff} &.

¥ ng fia tha 3 QAI ry os) § 43 ia rss 63 3 £4 Os tS oe See a g eee en R = ey nae?

Gi mt pet i> "05 By eS $3 ae weed oF 3B

i) 3 aft ant 3.3 Se $a tat G © ved £2 q} $4 5 Be?

tid Qo @ 4 ed © 8 B (3 v3 red 4a DH Sa 4.4 wed teat tf 2 ray fA Be BY oe rer} 5 G3 reoh ry 'et

2) 43 ¥ to ee ~ aed ee i » bo Q OS o ty 42 42 on 0 9 8 8 3 0 3 ' 6 O 8 " Oe ® re) - td oa * Sa (3 wd ne = 3 4a ¥ gd @ Ga 4 oA + *: ; #2 C3 5 ° c ¢ 8 re 2B iy 8S e 54 rd 3 a i % 42 4 a "3 , Bi @ a Sed tt = ue 13 43 cs nyt + me ve 4 ty) a3 raed "04 ar Se A - 3 & ER, % a wa A mf 4p . 1 + a 2 ¥ G fh 's) a4 oe % oa wy Q Shep 7 Q ad 4 «6 ry vt i * s 4 aed a oO qe 63, Q | ; at @ 3 a 3 & t Gi tn Nea] veo} - re " 3a 6 a 4 : eed . a fi i yp 3 ay in vet "a iy 4 xt

a) a 0 SE + D ie wy ce ' ; ? i 3 ie 43 Q "4 4d 43 oH i 4 iD : 2 fs we 3 . si Ch tgg Shek «3 ¢ Ky Se uh i a o> "sh - 3 ' 43 4A eh C % Cy ie) iw B g A fed is 44 red g f % 2) iB 3 : vd o : oy ° 5 A BB 5 o ed ° as 4 eG zi fn 7 es ra 2 fa ay a" f : ta $4 4 _ 0, « wed A te gerd age4 re % . 3 { * " : ; om « ' iu a ir wd ® a eh @ ' 4A " i a a Es 6 oy TA AE gy ort a : ot 5 i So «rd ye 3 : © " i 4A 6 o 5-4 4 r by 5 ' io] @ ha Us wd 54 Cc ee in ie meq m O "4 : a) rd a 4 a 3 «ry a $4 nd a a moO a rp «eB fw a o . > °& oO ty m5 a ia a ts gq cd c mM 0 es 5 . 4} S @ oh oO AG So oS C Oo 4 Shs a a cs ny fi . & "rt ord he orf Ea us io grt o sre$ bs apd K bs gs et w aa cs Bes tt ie " 4 zs a o as a it Ube Q es 3 i oy a B g td Sy ord OS % to « cf % Cl a B © rt 44 hed ry ' C aS 3 ova a es) 4 rs td i r Se pet mee C3 co f2 eee 43 ws dy 1591 Sate 3 3 LP " 7 42 : 4 th: 43 ba , aye by 0) te } a4 Cz Sy ey panes 5 . a Ae i: v i) i ae c a 4 te % 4 ! xn os as ' q wa so Nb ee e Q o " i oa mo ¢ %S "4 ns a '6 3 ~ o Pa o Pe Be w 3 mk Be 5 - 5 6 a Cha Bs mm =O '4 ty G Ci od . G "4 ® aC ) w 3) 6 a@ 4 "3 wed oe " Le " GO iD $3 ty D> wy 2 4 we 4 ca 'o iD tey vid a ah ® £ te. ® wt eat q) - Sa "8 a

- 4 cy neh Cy 4 ah its £ € be at {> 4 Ay & bed '. 2 i os f ty te * i) " '. ' @ % a) i A ; ted Ag 2 Bs re 4 $4 -~ "4 A a3 6 i $2, w ae) a ay re re fs : - a] i) red 43 kg £ "es nia w nd "4 i @ vy et iy :

ae ko i Sy de da en u3 oad Aet Bed 2 4G) :

fx] A a © ve ma okt ae ek B fest reed i cord te bs a os & ~ 4 be, we ar 4 3 hs wend «3 bea id b4 3E oe nt a cs A Ad

1) wy a 1 \ as a 32 us ea % (3 " oer 4 ig co Sa f At a wy oy et tr ved ao os me nh nd, 4 oN EX cn vend gi :

ve "~ y, a os, Sod Q «e4 rl ay 4 8 wt iss) art rh wend "~ AR 0 as fs 4 oO t toad De or us fas "et $4 A a a B2 whet 78] ut Ou tt ort ry vot w,, wt wed Bek

3) Ast ka a u-4 oy iy =) yee?

th oO trey eek aS wd sod red 4 > art ¥e et ocd 63 tod ya ss +4 ha:

Bre % % cn 74 ing ot ted O us 3 P ¢?

peed, ed te ©) as re " yeh me t hs beet oa Beg ced aot £2 a hed uy tim sag?

oe ved m vod ord 10 «v4 ies) vert hs 44 ok reek rd ay ® 74 Ad of Q et cst

i) 3 ard et £ i mek Ne et my &° Ne } o ae uh 1 ea aed ) 6h, oO frent Ets UU oO ied Oo 6 aot Bo ~ har a t Ty wt ord SS 6 ard 3 od "3 44 w oe 45 Wey MSy x ' t Nee 8 cord 2a iy Mi yay tt % 94 4 4 v "th f ei Aes o 4 Ak aged oe we » eee 4 4 ; 1 - ro g d a 4 w ' Oo a v 4 a oe i a S 9 O a a fo wd o wd 93 ad Pe i val 4 ® "a, te o "4 wy 2 ot i 4 as cr BS A ed Sa Sa a a i e 4 a ea be "a me es 3 s ud xs oO "ed rm os 43 oO M4 tt i 43 = = Cok © c Hy vee om a cS Ma g) fu oN & vs be Bed ;

2 bt oe 2s $e 6 . « a red AX a « wD ot Gs , cS sel . Sheg sa d bel we ia 4 Pe i a ry 4 A a ws thy 4} a wo ed Ry ve O vad a m wh Me 2 a ot "4 ed of ' wd w «a vA 43 & o; orf 3 e a = a wp, oO ah 3 3 re oh ra 3 43 my o aia fs e ee om Ss o, a 4 \ i ¢ 3 ba i Xn "3 iS ot 5 QD ie O Q ) aa a @ haa O "4 4 " 8 3 vot sb i B * es Sek 4.4 4 TP © D & 5 a6) mod a Aes he 2 " 4 J " oh a o a on 6 BO BP & OG eA Og BO Tt a we Dm i . i? wn us thek ard ; uy Ce : ay 8} Cs «6 od As Wo ned a Che A 13 ht co e / 44 o 4 } bt et oS 4 ty oe D 6 Gb " is aH ft 13 " te '3 me rn ne Bo , * ef pes Gags ao 8 wn QS . ' ory bea @ bs Gr a 3 3 . th ip seed Sa go ro o 8 Fw 8 8 ¢ 8 & 9 8 9 BS BB 8 a ord A ni " a $4 vee 4 Ab Q D m 3 ie 5 ts hheg mi ia "4 Sod 5 4. oe O3 "4 @ 6 { 5 ved wy 4d iS wh y 6 org DB Ba G ae oA ti gy . & ts A sa 3 w aed 54 i a w ed . omnes "ed & a % 0) % a - o 5 y a wh x Os ep ne $4 6 '4 Go oo 4A hed me t hs t3 eo ee ae a o 54 : oO a i Q ee ed bona Set a ma wh rat wee ; 4 ~ " ae, a

- SE wt 8 et " mo og Hm Fe a Be Bg oe " ° thy om * GE @ 44 a a rel rs i et y & % S g chy 4 @ a) perl C3 4 we g) tS a "x MM cn a Be a 5 "eh a ng i " o4 & ° 6 4d Q i D a» os B 16 43 med t3 ty

- Se gD @ £3 ft H * oo a' ® be % } os "4 @ "4

- ° co Sy "4 ed 9 QO mE * a i ne wp © ¢ 3 ref oy "4 3 ited yp be co ra Bw) % 3 : - Ba "3 2) sf : 4 Ld Che @ a 9 4a 44 43 ® ce] be i wn AJ iW 3 a e + © > 4 u . 4 o aw Og 3 BS uy 2» 8 a & Oo A AB 2. 4» 6 B eB Bow Mf Rob si @ ts a 9 6 OO ~~ og 8 G 5 a es a © Q Ms : % % @ a rt 4d a ra] ie "4 a es rp : 3 wt 4 ~ . 3 5 3 "

So gf mn mas 7 , ££ GO 8 & "24 fj 2 GON rt DA i) é a * rr) , . & fre " 43 ri i bel ™ oe a oS ok a ks ® na ao oO a3 aD ort od By eo ca oe ke "S aa ba Ad Bed ~ B x 4d w@ rod os Ad thd wd é od a 2p é ed @ « ie oO i. ae zg re Ad "8 wed 'et ° Mo eT OQ Pr om SY ty ~ 3, " Pp 8 OQ rn rs , Sa te 0 eB kd @ of @ iy a "es 4 us a i y Th 1G wo oy 43 a} a ~

a) v as ; c . ct Ss 3s i ? "3 az be ered > ne "

te CB yD Gs om bt Q y es a wy o W sae we SE od ; B Hs go P 8 sy SG £ vw Oo 9 @ FB B FG 2 6 BG e G OB Fn i} '¢ 4 } , oe e cs 'BD 4 £2 ig $4 g © ord ot me ea 4 G os a 4 "s war HS eet @ ts 2 = ue : -- a . % i s if % a) i % {i Oe Bm OB MH bs ; , ae mM oA rood $3 $4 Or ip 3 rt ud end ce pnd ort oe hea bed ib Ds oe sy 1 a3 ot £ MA eed a.

it oN Aa Me ke x a S

----~ Sea Re Le .

Oh SAS ed Os hs em 43 Ad w).

vd % ths t wey $44 So LETT Sat RR he en x qt we YY ahh the. 4 9} Ls weed tpg oe B® SB ae a o nw 9 oo 8 ®@ Y to He Mo Soe ot 3 is <3 4.§ QO yD 4 ca a o "4 "4 13 ' i EA sy ut ! : « ) ee 6 "aA rs Ss ; " aha hs : i Son b & ) ae Xn «5 ae oo it 1 a Hoa @ 4 Oo ~ ¥ 2 " i i Hed dt 43 veh 1 Pe a) 4 , ae et ER tA rn M4 ne ne " oy m cy ~ 6 @ a td Soh Ww £35 ing "th at ont he g " eho of at ; :

ey 43 i Shed 4 2D iy a} wn 3 a) te they 43 a Cs 4 ra Pa 3 fe ct 8} SH is33 i Aad ® or el n ran oy sot 3 o ay ar C3 ' Ay thd Ch fe a see ods Ce 1 nt a i} os os - mt 5 Sea ay - 5.4 o oa > ms . ; 55 "yO! oO es 4 2 a a 4 : a ' "~ e fi ved fe gy os Be ned os we 2 vw Sed o es 4 : mf be ays i o 43 » " cA ry Bhs "ed ~ 4 ha i a 5 4 fa ad yes ea On ay a ot tS ad 33 DB yp 7 an 0 #4 hed «3 Ct #5 > 3 rd ed oA ° py 3 Yd ee es , a Br it a » " ia ha vd Bow om 8 Gm t ans a , fu fa "t we 4 5 . . 2 po of be ny 0 8 Lf ud 13 ord w As bs rel a) a g i ia <4 E = O '4 3 ue » a i a C3 a © $4 " a) 44 ts 8 he "

Ke , 5 up mn . ka $4 vd 4 i 74 a a * KE w rs) 6 i £2 wed G wt, a 3 ° 4 3 a Ge '4 it Oh red a tS " vcd it ved i re) coe 3) . "s i D3 © Oh wr % a é wt 4 he o 43 4 Sa "3 "a var ° ' a a " -

a Th a z I 8) i. oe r mo ' ce rw ay woe a a i vc Ss © " & § © & fj no 3 go 8 0° is & is i iy cE iS Th ard ed xs foot tr a at ek, Go co wy rd as ~ 2 a bd a S 0D ye ths oa Fs "ty * ay he a) * ; , te cat "A a i oe 3S 6 : teed 3 " a py ms yet A 8 © 3 a 4s " q c o 3 43 a3 o « M4 4 3 1 . a G ti oe a : 4 G3 a gy ? @ - 44 «a oe a a 3. w cs 4 ; : uy ct 43 is ; a - s 4 i Lt a4 3 p Soa $y wha 3 63 wR 3 ; 3 4.3 5 ref Mel 3 44 ; ay a oh 4 q ea ro 2 A ib C Ae Os fs 5 8 &, we F "4 ty rh mo 8 a B cia os od aS (3 " oe aa Cs 4 "5 id vg 43 ted

- a of 3s ~ 3 . wed :

tH a @ B 4 G o ca Shs 3 xs $2 Sid ig cs $4 i C3

- Ro t © OO 5 Ul OQ 2 . a ws Boo me * © 4 fh, 4 8 ot 3 " 3 C ka y $3 0 cS 3 von * 43 a 4d 3 . tat "3 2% a ey * cs O 43 0 oe ®

4 Q Os © oa ° y ba 'i 2 " fe ~ ee fe vee mF ws My a ° wh o te om " a ed ; . rs * o ra Or 2 et be ee 8 . 44 Pe 8 D M BL, , Fe 4 th f io ad uy 4 fi . fi ¢ f . « gn 8 ™ mE GS i 4 & § w e eo 8 « © {ti "4 oe wt " ved @ ved 4 ee . 5 43 3 4h @ ¢ Db cm hed - ar 44, 3 oa - r< 4 4a ms « os4 wo? "5 "4 3) @ £ 2 , i a ih ot 4 . we a ts * ~ ry 4 bt x "5 7 @ cs 5 uy fhe woe < 4 : a & e wo ne G od te oS sed ed . Ce ' sy ha 5 ad rit fa x we . 4.3 2 ont a ot vt as : ; Q "? ey 43 ie om: 3 4 4) a 7 CS vred a ca G m2 * D 5 za D vy t3 4.4 aa 74 (3 a Cc a wee vs a o (on i 4A ri oe Ct JS . ib rem . a a 7 mh bas e bt 4 4.4 bs 43 % ie 4 o MB 5 44 G & by, G 5 : 4 is oe 5 oe 4 ¥ ht £4 ap "st . o " "3 i va Y «ed gt og iS m % < nage . , } Ct Ad i nm, ba o nm " : C M % rd x ks fy a 4 ff i ike hee QS j P " 43 os ' A ; 9 i m4 ie a OG co i 8 ww OD . @ se o 0 @© 2 MW & Oso . y 4 a c ry pe "s gn gh a at + ® wn a on G ££ G os As wy Lh ot bra + @ 3 Ct 1A wt iS bg a f wb 3 gy Don ms os i a @ a a ' } "3 4 a a wrt Saag s. eo} & vet ts a) ard ved &@ Us on ea o : a fe at a i wD 4 4 ' rt -, cy o oD : ie > EA ; ia) 3 wy te n oe, 2 $4 oe 4 mo os a ah by $4 a "y '7 i be oo {3 * » Se ri ce wD © : . ; qo C3 M4 ws A mg ~ ae 6 2 Go yo ® S mG * : 0 ay , : 4 ;

Pot es ey red < x / °° 4 wd 3 ' a et ay " - x > th tf eT , i 8 by 5 4 of A OF oD fg om oS a oO Qo 8 o te 2 ; ", eo Cs a. ot i » Che iy ; A ag id Le Wea el G Be oo Sha a + § Ch 4d 5 . a . @ e Met 2 $4 0 ae . @ a a fh ~ x D iD . ith Fe} cf ~ F : my OD OQ 4 O cet wy iD 4 ai ME @ Os i 3 : Ba se o 0 B A 6 " ay « AS a be: aopeg vd 43 ' we 3 G "B + O v3 43 4 weed | 3 a ay od ved 4 ok 4 ia o "A t? o} os Y vet 5 £ cP 4 rd a bs 3 ts "e C we veh 4 ® a a bt ¢ 3 ad 3.2 Pa . "A 43 os " x yp LD o td a * bei 3 0 4 Us ie & +4 & ra 4! tg a "a|O O ta eS '3 ee poy ny @ » as $4 s a a 7 ord oe 4 13 wy "Cg ys j Oh : ecant oA ve "

sf oo a yg SB Rg 6 CO 1 et 4 543) we 1 % wy Wee 4 Ch rd 44 mS ce pw oe fa gg 0 oy sa ¢ vel ond , uy ae a BB 4 tee 44 {3 cy [ a oe By it tS oH A BS 30 ' @ a 5 "

A 44 ct gy gc ws hed a we ' & ; 5 4 3} e , ' is ' # iy ; 0} ui : ot u on} . Z a i w ea Ba veh ay a} , +4 ' tf um i ts Gy a 4) 43 oS ty ia 7 ; c O nF ut ° cc ao 4 weed 4 5 % ' ¢ TS j w ' i "ey v i Bs os 4 a Q) 3 5 5 43 i +4 fa od os we $2 m4 be a ws 3 wed 4 ris] bee wed Ad At 6) bg ok whee at ud s iz Ho a rs OQ fe ta uw op ¢ s ft es i 53 . Cj ' wy O co ' ts i a 4 o @ 3 Ht o t qf f i 7 4a tet $4 Sy : 1 5 sy i a oo m mes rs > om ie LG Oe / a a ea : 4 3 ' 1) ; Q soa 4 ff oi 'et 3 re AS @ @ £ 4 a fas £3 ad @ w ut g a # 4-1 ged At ag a os 2 ; 5 + 3 on 3 - 4 ay a "i st © to Bo 4 4 4.3 ot ' © . rt " 4 4 a" ak Ud " te « poet e G us Ba a a o iS om a % rk @ Ro Ue z Gat @ a a 3 "

Wy wed ope Xu ya aed (hs tht teh ay = i} 4 be ay ih, oY a ot Si 3 {za).

et raed 4.5 wy ard bel Be 'a 9 eh, § Q a 4.4 yp ae) weed wt me he z Xe aed ga chek Ad had O17 2 a é S134 a Q 16 B53 Sze} .

Feet oF ved ct een

a) "4 & a, et Be;

rood ped TAU 4 tye iy a bs wy {re et at % 43 at Sor fs He ord v5 g cpived > x on 25 cS Pa Lf wed ay ny sa Z entar LM ng ve hed CH % so ed oo ot 4 tha 2 i pot hog m tH i eye ES st 42 4) wD 43 Gg} a 1D Ba @ "4 w% iB He ' ue : Ba 3 i x si u in A Ct AG ard or {5 Ss) GC veo] 7%! aD uy QD Aa ad 3) ay ved mh ca o ah o $3 a5 et tS a oo 43 . i om a $4 @ xa s 3 : e Ha m me ~ 44 eC ree M 44 St & A 2 eG a vd fe " o> 35 6h, rt th 8 oS G 4) " bd a wet mp MD a a a oy & ", a cP a pe © 3 . & a co va 4 4 Q ee x 4 + ceed sn 0 3 oon " ca Q vet u "ea v <> ned Pe a) a 4 "4 "f ved oe 154 4 ba 5 , i) ba a aed c i . ms % Co 8 e 8 Bh 8 G 9 6 wo Gm oy 3 rs 'ik _ bid : ot oe 43 44 ao id £35 . fa a Oo 4 4 Gg GF 8 & MS iB a . em "st ed * el by ia ig a $4 in m uy ord s 3 a & 4a O od i) {2 et cS a % " & "4 4 Co y f re Thy ( 3 Ae ie, os 43 RY ora nt ay oe ce a3 | 9 gS CM 8 & Aho wD

a) | A ct a bed & 3 y a a 3 Sa fs rock U3 net z 3 set 0 ay ie ved Sea i aa Wa £4 a 0 Q 3 . 4 be ts ant oe ' . ~ Le ° ni do, & 'S Sk 1 "tg Bg OY 43 thet 7 . yd 4 rs ¥ 9) - he rind % 3 xe > i"

be or te a " vent . he oF a 4) oO 3 -- Oo a 2 a Be ny uy a} on ~ : 6 ey ' ih reg v gy bs a ie ' clog " G os . we ae : we t wed , cS . i yt a cd 7 it oy ot $4 a ced 3 cs 2 i * ry oO a 3 . eed bf KG rm ref ie ad eyed ta} es 44 "a ee os $4 oa fond as in i ah Sa RS 4G 5 a Go sed 3 iw Ch a . ay 74 nh se B wo OM 5 wg Soe B® 8 a an o ay ot be oO 3 4 13 i i a 6 3 % ch "sy et 3 wo KS gy sock Ae a - ths ad @ arf ts v4 j.3 44 f 3 a wet 3 wt be O) 3 5 nt Fy ot Cs a re "a nm O a Bo OS be Ci 8 Oo Wo * © Ps "

aa Ba © "4 @ "5 x ra) D> # ee a 2 4 ae tn pe a in £3 in 43 XS : - ce iS fa " "3 fos 6 ea ° 4 a Q G O BB OH wh gy Q © 8 bi pd 2 rs) a ge 5 o i sy g m4 } C'S od a rhe k y % 4 ays ny rs ed DB % "4 we Ad ved t} Aa 4 SB a f° iB " 6 my | Ho B rh BD me to «3 mm % Oo si a er a 3 . a Ss fied wed « hs # "a Mo ed, O a at aie rt ae s eo a &a 22 n * % &) e werd £4 we yo. u A eG % oo wi . oa f od seed id © Ly ys 6) eed Ly Dp So O aa) os a @ 'mee z 4 wf a 4 ' 4 33 $4 1 So E hm 43 i oy Oh, O "3 "a uy Os 3 a a3 #} 8 vee iy ih Oo bd Os Sa 3 ia a 3s Cs Cs 0 JS m3 vel vod ~~ to i to i aS as eg if} i co me 64 ie) HA LJ & es co) es mM Et i) . x 2 me Dw i - 3 ~ ; a hey Bey, (1) oo i) % to us 4 ns oA ry GS mB 0 65 ba " et oo 4 oe " re DOA Os a oN 3 o i we vo "a 4 423 4 a Os . ' - fe "4 eS OF OG ° 3 xp : S re -t a " ° + 4 % Ge i rd @ Ms ~ D ¢

a) A ¥ 2 we a é : 2 & & Goo rl . 4 i? 4 ote > ge. nat ' <M 13 ce vet SA be iit of me 4 ao . Ch, % 4 iH a G3 a ad 3 Sh "% is " @ i 4 GF « Gg ra) GY a 4 c o 6 6 ved ee uw Oo wn hi B-4 ~_ An ' ; . ° oe > ify 3 ts pee of a yw ow 8 vip ay , 0 A 5 a , ip f : m 5 rs G , 4 i bt m Bes cd &3 . ver 8 ~ © , fh gy 4 Es Oy ws - 4 o O a 4s ' wn $ é on Go ee Soy ry uh es f a 5 tt w 6 ag *3 Pet P art hy i' 2 > ge & 44 hy e e ag > . vs "2 ' se 5 "8 - oo oS @ pt DO 2 a a w i ai re) - " oe b ie 3 "GS g} 3 é $a vod + = nae, as ?

ry x _--

ed, sS , = Ra 8 rhe V4 a ; GW 8 co a 7% ie 4 43 ih x4 G © 43 ; * c 3 i tds is ie vee Ad O ip fe a a Q oe a 1 8 3 ei x Oo os ' am ot ae Ke) " & Me 1 wn * tc , + oO wt Pe od oe rn a the a me gs ® Q 6 ° "

at . £ BY Jo cd a is y ' "5 Ce © 4 a or s ap veh £ ME Ot yo i . :

" whee r s ci ; % £ cy iy is ' it "E4 ss % , Do kt o te O we fh RB pe BD or m 2 ma e ae i) a 44 43 "4 a s 44 ' . i o { oy 4 vd ' . we Gm - @ 4 i ' Po, a € mo, wo 3 Oo uy cs ct 4 at ag my 4 is) ee Le ey sy LnJ eA eth U4 ng i : a w 4 ord ced HA a EE Oo « j o ed 9 (Cha $4 at "

" seed i. CG wt , ce % .

a > zed *y ra C4 beet f " Ly Q : i ' vod 5 we " Ds a a Me % Q ' Sw ED o , 65 vd i 4 ; z ms ved e ie e gt E 2. ' Ff » bes a y . a sot i ia S $e wt oS ; = es : c ws a) a a es 44 Go nS rm Oh G. fe 6 aH , y a ae 4 Bea hed th Os Che "4 4 an i oO 43 im * «| UC oa a is te oO "2 ~ as "a 5 a <j Bo gt ) ~ , m ot "3 " oo 3 44 os "A @ set we eed hy cof oe @ 4 3 ta ° a > 3 fork ed nD te we 1 Sf wy zs « xs cs sa ha - g o cs y Pa wo Aa iy Fa & F " oa a " Ev A ¢ a tS oO Fe abe oe "4 _ % Ly aw iT i X ~ dod Bo 6 4 n 8 3 wy 36 6D a Oo sf th, A j r =.

es o 3 &

- be O 6 2 ' Bog Fb ® 2 "8 pp Bg om 8 » Bog & HO os 2 8 ;

eG 3 . :

5 Ys i , a ~ m parent Le Po Si ma Lon EL 3h } et is a7 pe a a Et Ss tl B a Nek on BME x a & 4 seed Ad read CA «eed o 3 we bed eg Xa ~ Sa hn xe we a.

~ a D 2 ge oa 4 7 4 ' abe ¥ reed bd a ay " rt 5S 4 é C "3 ed 8} e oP G 52 uy 4 oA 4(b).

Pee, et & vend we chet Sea! iy tye4 igs Fi ed, 4 . Ng oe Soy ted Th a i 44 g ws 'ed 'A a 2B a) % va , 3 is ef, Sf A $a o w 3 4 on SS cy i Sa o Ka x3 G in a : ws rs) 43 a 5 42 in bs + nt fe a y 2 te a ty WR, SA % eq eB 1 6 SY mg c pe DE ho a Dg Pa 8 | bg St | me gh © eh ne G6 6 fg « # oO 8 vd Gt a od ka a " ¢ US 5.4 Boor " ne e a ° 4 C3 i fe rs . we weed rt bk cd & 4 : hae th} woe 0 4a a O 3 ws Aa eo TS & Of Q BN 8 at a . Ps a 3 4 % 4 rd hs 43 wd ont ® ms & < © tos 9, 4 a3 mt ' . ' x rab 3 7 44 wd my fa % ) $4 on @ £ s o uo é Sa Y 4 AA a bs ay woe ig 3 £ % my a "3 We OE . Fs iS wr " x ve ih wt J i M4 4 @ oe 43 oss ns a o 4 ad "ny vd 7s a o od * Y 5 ' ~~ ot G 5, # aot . 'Oo 2 a in oa a As . ra wd ~ on 6 good ed ' w "4 rn. mw i ¢ oe Gt Gy 3 Gg 2 OR BS oe oe F a 8 2 ® > & G8 "i os - is Fy He «s ao 4 a e - mt ' ' 5 ; Go Om & kg & go @& oS " fg tty > Le geet i on a) rs O € 4 3 as " ) , wt fa $4 oo sy e ed we Me vs ved ae . D ts i} i ' os es) 83

- 4 BOB 8 & GO 8 RY ut o OG @ ed as w 2 AS oy w e Ws @ $4 rsp i) ! ri 4 reat Od veg bed a} G mM oo bd 43 Aa ia ob ed 43 beh Ay tft Pa 4 a "3 oged ty Heed 74 a) et a uy " a pla ek ' C 3 tt i :

a = £ f Xe aos S eed i" t . 4 seed , '2 . w pet is $4 G » st . "4 ' hy ¢ ww cal ; a uw for %) ; a a 4 a is , , bed AG . * in A 2 re me «@ is i 8 '4 = ot i ® ee y 3 6 oe me aa c 6 Th fh 2 Goo 34 wm © a4 $4 Ss O . Q 4 = i (3 a q o wa wo thy oS 43 0 w tt rr . \ wk thy 3 43 cs isa ° mo OF ons Hy Ee De 0 pa . a , 4 oN a is 3 Ags 4 a i a wy 4 3 eA ie Bs fe KY hey ot Q * CD is «L Pa y 64 £ ae ne ay a 44 gs "ed Sb iZ he Oo J , ae Ost iF ky : " 43 Fe wt ca os ee # o By 8 e % @ & & 6 8 G 6 @ be ts 8, yrs . " o 4 t a a & 2 fd t " g bp ® ms ad oO 4D He eR S GS ££ 2 2 mG hos ~ ra ej aN ', ns " Chi Ed wet ' ci ra Le syed a Ba] nad B se 15) ad " 3 me , 4 thet ts ce wt th : bd . , oO oy G a ip Gt 4 ; a is OO gp Oy oS BO Bg 6 "4 HD) ' @ t 33 > tt wv ' a co o te the i Ct % oe 4 : ' tht oO De, a an " = iv ug " 4 ® a 2 m @ @) od CY a oe 5.4 os bt * ci ib , @ x a a ea) gy ° "s " a3 a ™ 0p 5 m O in % 43 3 ~ . a i . is 2 M4 o e ed " " ~ es <3 Sef et 163 s ® wed O G ord i a ort sd wt ce rf G3 pts st} wo Ps hed oo Gi wD ed C oo w 43 oa "ws 3 he bd Cay 3 vd % aS A G Aa A O re (2:

4 fe Ud oy FS, o> rD o is; --- Aa 52s &} 83 ee @ nr & 2 Tk a the 2 4 (dd).

he co} & Ment aA a8) co 6 os tt wy ae ord er Lg sy @ tg 6 Gh 3 } . C ths Jed ud @ ny ai ay a ocd im "3 aS fs) as G es ee A B a Ww mo o 2 be o at % fo SE aS © A % £4 43 i a ent mo oe "we m3 & "% eo ue is vt 5 cA tek , ag a 3 si cn ree} ae 0 wD ped . ES ie ou ¢ in Ib e va 4 wed 2 vot vd t % co a i oe o O gen, G 38) a @ aa O be wa £5 5 cS oe 43 be ra 36) te bet o a m2 om O :

{ts fs , > . wy m3 xD : es 4 F Ae i 4 Bo Sa tes 4 7 2 2 YD "rd ' me og

3) 4 4 C * ref nl Do Fad oe) "74 ad (; me wr £4 03 bx Rt & on n ae & . 44 mm is 4 . a wh A " roi an + r4 Oy ro Re ' a4 if) ad eS & 3 ~ ir re rm Qs 6 gh el wed uv nt 0 5 B QP 3 4 * « 74 Aa od we woh ss a G hy a " mo ' $ ' wn at

8) f a beg Ne C35 ot sé x & « t } - a q ae 6 . . ma 2 Ga 4- ~ Sn a ed Pat o 5) @ wD 33 i 3) ay a as ce > a + sre} a £3 a : ht my v4 ch 's a » 23 44 : Da 3 ya . C3 . 4A ord & "e MM os 58 Sf aoc ' "7. } coe 3 C3.

" $4 ie) C 4 "4 re) Ls hed a cred rs) a C ue cA , 3 @ & ae 1 " f % #3 ' G vet wo 0 a 4 3 83 RS 3 4.3 is 3 of ~ box whet a ® Ad eas) ay ee Cy " > 4.9 "rd @ tS oO it ay "e fr 43 C3 "th ord a3 rf 44 a DN oA ws y roe Aaa \ coed re, ta 4 rh a : e Go : . < i ty pan fa fos ~ fo 43 6 4 reed wh 4 Ss A a 8 4 v 7 3 ort tS reas D 4 a ee 6 a a i # , 3 43 of tt ' rw; ay + 4h : 3 3 crs ha Fea] rt 56) a re at us 0 te " ho 9 wr = ' mt a) Si « BI 4 w a6) oa 5 > ce 1 ved @ i mt wd 6 a 4 c a ot +s td "4 Me et 4 ork By] fo ES cD: "4 be ue he M4 & rs wee Sha * ad ~ " a 43 fa in 6 iy g th ie xi os ~ 3 3 (G ot be. Co Ad t be b4 nn to . "3 A BO " oo] hea ' ig 3 oe f y 4 a * me oe : "4 a ad vd tt 4 i) 3 44 Ths wy Gp gy oO Sm Be fo G Bf @ 3 : t x 40 wa f i! a . < a ' a "4 mow 68 eA OY o & Go om A ts og %) ge doe es mt 2 ay woo. QU * Beg £4 Og Bt mG OQ Do go, oe «6 ete rt ao o) wo Hea fy a OG MM wD 3 m i og b "A @ $4 wv eo B8 on + ao em gt MG a UG rd 4 ved is oh} we ia Oy, MA os a bet hig * a3 s ie Sa « ts o> , at ad , wd a a rt ci Ee Ad ) 7 th 3 a " mow o 3 at "£5 Lt OD, O 3 ¢5; oy 12 wy "id c % ws ts a ay a a 1 "4 oh : moo & © 4 Q m 4s O "y oe mA 43 w a QO "sd cs wed art wg oh, " is) Sek c n ts red » "«s Tha "a , ms hy 4S ed g ci ap S ved ' a eH a oo wy a 43 uy eh o3 oy "y iy o Es oo os 1d CR 43 4 on Q Co g} we g (2. $4 oh o oO Sa wet 3 Q @ reed ote i . ib ¢ vert f- » py @ ie oe $4 1B . £2 ws red St 5 oo «s ved Q oA o @ "od ord oy 3 td 6 4A vod 3 uy tm ifs tsa &G 44 = ted eat the Co Os ke see 43 ou us $25 orf sf Le ~~.

eat Us x x A ones SU. St A ree! ¥ & i OA 154 G im M4 * A S Ma ts a 4 at ® $4 @ cal "4 a3 n in iP et gs c a e G $a r) Ct @ sod aa 0D O SS wo 6 ta in ha am Ch o ba a G et ved thea @ ad ae y 4 4 3 ea 8 be 43 & sf sed 5 ka "ed : yo to. ba "ch 5 ad ard "tS vad if 42 vcd a @ G seh rs) ys so ou lf ° 2 3 ood wf 4 £3 ee a z 4 a: u 8 ind ved 5 es a wp . er fed 8 Ht eH co os > 4 me a . oh 2 3 : 13 bt "my beg i) ; a 43 % a4 oe % ".

AS A ~ ae "

i fs nS = a} xh ») a zx a Q @ ft "4 4 is 3 a 4 a as oe 24 Ry " ~ Z or orf . a Q . oR i SS os OM ay fg mb gg Boe ~ 14 ' a ro Ow 0 6 gg om vB eed " 5 r% a ' beg Sow a bd re sien 6 : et af Le ira rc ad + c 44 "3 4 3 he Q om red a io 2 G uy ved 43 gi a "A fA od a uy od Q 84 Hi "4 4 i> yp oe "S C 2 ay a) SO og mS HW y thd Boo 4 oy Tm ig iD ; £3 a %S ah xe] DB "Ey oa "4 ord a et . ts end v 3 od "rd ha + 4 id & it red G} MY ny Sa 2 u ved " yd w ey G } . o wl eG 2 & 2) e m8 GF kw . QO & Pp wm FH oy a fe a ve < eh gs *3 wl nH & 5 EO oO 2» :

ve » 2 & a go om y 2 oa yo Poo 5 ae) D 4 4 "35 ef ES ay 44 2) rep a an ad B nf mt 3 cy 3 ® M in ad ae . ae, A oe ; "A 5 Mo " o 0 G9 a) @ tO Oo , ot is is Ae th i a oy "e 5) a M4 u wn & a Se ~ no Fs} x4 wi rr as 3 Pa ) , es 4h ros 3 rcs Sk fs 4. ; Gs 5 43 eh "e " sok & 4 cot $4 ay es Os "A aa ha tis 5 oy ont et . oO 4 on 4 4 oO rat od o te a o @ ah ° gt £3, ay 2 ed 5 oA 4.3 se wt ed vet G Ae ise GA ge 4 o a 8 op oe BB gk Gt C3 a i oa ce aed a el wa Sf " a * ht 4 & 7) # uy " : = i op OMe 0 vd ct D G wd B 6 tS fe i wv re) an a a rf rs te 5 ? - ce ree : j 4 ver if : 2 Met es E: "1 oy o 7 $3 yo wo a 2 v 1 w a a yD _ 8 et SG Bo Bt BR ag eg . a yp it weed SO * o @ a = Ma se cs 3 5 oy G ': M4 iu a "e c ; 4 oO o BQ 4 me n th Gi me 4 m oe 6 e cd tt a ° S & e oy ab Bf e 5 % 1S 4g gm © Go O° o £3 "og ee de me a G4 rt x et ord 42 i ° s . 43 up wed BA " - +4 y fo £5 oo ir , we pod a a XS we is ot a © % gs fa a a ond art & : ces ws ha " Go $3 ch Q ¢4 SA 43 0 a a "rf re shed @ es 43 £ wd iy Ae a G} nt oF ) Ka sot Ba Oh, $i £5 ws , td eS , mm & 4a my ard cy EA vd eo DG 2 @ Oot ws @ oy "aif up ord a3 bee ch rad 0 we o ge a "ti uy #4 bt $4 9 tr we th , hf het th a3 ee a GC « Oy se LA pet en ct peek ao ved ct a B ea % wed tt y wt " w Gh = iH Fe wsd i] vec} ee a % bey 4 fe] tnd at % 7 <4 3 4 a «A $2, Q > " ' w QO ort 3 Q . ord Oh Q @ £2; wp rd $3 os iy @ Hed red B rood * pe 2) rod ce to tr ty sere 3 £3 {5 o in a©) 3 a3 sf $3 &S Fee or G5 W red ved si ved eed my oO tha > RQ oO a i} a) re] $3 a QD at o er ca a ey ay "

a mg ES ~ oO Oo £ 9) a '3 0 & SO we i Om fo BL a ui i 4 cA SS. 43 4s Si St # wa "rd i "4 @ me a st 4 BH x UF BR" co D2 8 ce) 3 f Sa bed sd "~ 3 ra G3 my 0 : ts ¢ Ws ry s a= o ae y ha be os 3 Ro i wo t pe ct Sw ic . rt ced , om rr a ve ae as a a o os ral 6 a Ys of 4 42 a & 63 ser} O gy ved Ad £3 ny G 4 post at 0 Ea oo he * "xe ud cf nie & ced va 4 <t fe " g ® oo, a "eS at vg Oo nn oO ~ « wed To oY 4 os Aw G geet 43 nH ; 2 ~, £ < a @ ee: "3 wa "5 oral 4s See wok Re 3 thd iD . oY h O LA 4 ; >4 4 Dy 4 a os wy gr i - ~ . ye "4 3 @ 2 vt Ay a & et ra veg o £3 4 us a my ne ag sed oO Ss 3 ried " & ns 33 a ios 4 é : is 7) 4 + " 44 vent oy OG ae os 8 fhe ot 5.4 4 e od G4 wn on @ 44 a ra oo on 6 G By . » a a a ** un x rt sod re o zn as mo fa 3 C pry ved i Sa os 6 o La 3 . M4 v3 @ oped hd i. 43 be i 45 s 'YS a a Ma to seed is Pe Bh tS ' re o od Cs "ef ne en 44 KS '. 1 43 a q 7 "

a Q ; ; iG 4 4 La od o ' 5 "A 2 bu wy, ed svt en fi % 8 e '4 i ) tS" ; . a Ot Qo a "sD © cd A ond " : os @ ta « 42 a c ° ca i c 4) * ve$ ™ wid oped . Cy wt 53 ¢ at 2 mn . oe uy oY {c4 4 nm mD { fos " iG rod 0 iS 2 bts 6 a 4 oa " pve " & mG Ses oO nm «= 6 2 » vd a

4. ! oo "4 tt " % eS > whe ; a i O "4 i) 3 43 a ca So 4 By D ag et a a (3 tt a . ha * ¢ 4 : & z od oO bo a st in 4 : ww c x 2 &@ Bp be me RP GB 6 gon @ woh 3 © - moe eo o @ 2 'rf 0 tha So. Be BY i . £4 A wo a $4 es yoo UR 2 A a m3 om a BD "J , ay a in ae 2 o cd 2 M4 * Gay w & Q ee wp ke " "3 ed "A iD 5) Me 2 ws xs & ot a5 Sa > Ds G o ° us Py C os "Hh fo "4 od vt = CG 4 @ iB w Se Ea fee) % * tek 5. reg eee 4.4 Chy £3 & "3 5 Ae we Ke 13 i " sa uyet " ! sed 4 . 4 5) R . £} Ao rs ad ra ; oo mm ey he tes ped 0 G 44 Xa ma fy vf ry B ig a} Co Fay 0 3 od ryt AS 63 cy ' » 8 AO pM Oy Bo BG My a a3 4 & 1 rr t rd She hed ea) io th ts or ay A os Mm ge i ® 4 i i ay € oe ns! 42 } me 7 OBS wv an i Oa 6 RP Gd mo Go srt me rn ar Gc 8 4 tA rd " 5.4 vd oO yp & . am ord ~ a a & ¥ 4 SB a4 cA 0 Ko 4 ws i i a @ a 4d $2 a 3 in fe aa G p a $3 a Ge 43 G D a rae B ie, ~ ni ba ha 5 wt Oy , } 4 ; x4 + tea : . "gi ae) ¥ . 2 4 ei eg OO wg SG na & a eo SB Bb TS o 2 a rE Bs) a - as i ; 4 , & Oh es 43 ied a3 ; ;

a4 Ht a td rd a 2 Os ' a Os o 4 a wm B my ed tt J 3 o ed oh wy Th @ bee ' te wed es ct 4) 3 tm GB 9 BO sa oa '5 0 ; oo . « i 3 4 2 8 mh 4 BE gee Poet MS ' % , Gf ao OB 8 2 He gO 3 et j ws @ si é 4 © 5 i ct Q i.) "3 "s 6 #3 ie ' ; a 43 a c 6 oO w oS ie) "5 a ed " a Su el ah i i) a) oo 2 2 rant D 4 5 Ty ved Gh ad % i ot he 43 ts 4 Ch cb soe ty '3 Os You oo ed ate i : "

"" +4 tee, '. * vt oq Wy a3 bd wD 3 me = '3 e Qo 4 a e 3 ts a ia i wd ha 4k ce io "4 we " ' cy " 4 " Ma &s iW st . L 4 i 4 og BO OF a 8 4a a di 43 ) c ' os Ss a sed oo ant ea, r ett Net oe = ke ad ~~ Ne i 43 at a mo ws ri a we ~ @ ed ® ye 3 ' 2 % Hs UB we Sha " $ 4.3 on é hs a eee . r ved aot on wD " co 2 g te et uw a4 ue 5 02 cp * apd Be 3 , £ - eed he + a rs a "s 4 A oot aes "3 a ray aan a 2 Ma O x ry wi

1) 4 aed fs 43 3 <s 53 wt xy sy opt ' a g a 0) w , r ng . wo v4 * fe) - "5 "3 ys 3 + $4 6 " sf 3 vf th a v3 cS : £4 ' es i> " . " SS a "5-3 ~ ts be 4 Gj wv A ° . 43 @ ry wa a a "ed aS O ot hs . by ue i + ot . i $4 g yl a ' Et cd 3 C * : ie . . '4 i 5 hy * cr a4 ae . B a3 ed a a 9 43 cy iG » a we aS ot

3) OK; is th BR, eet ea wh 2 r M3 'a c $2 i oy oe ra} an 5 3 La a n 2 4 44 wet ry ie ed 3 * Wh Us os vd "3 ; % a f} im

4 ~ 3 co try i a de " "4 _ eA i : Mt gh 3 EA ( gt oor in . os Oud te on 3 Fe 6 3 cs - cs 10 44 a i Pa 3 ; v oop 8 oo op" 3 rj eB et Ot © B® gs so " 4 o MM ha 9} G = "3 a3 ith Ao ort y ts @ en os ° - ie tf oo * 0 "4 . a 3S om $4 4 ° re os ' o a3 4d 3 CO " en ars) "s u i ; : ee . cA & a he a BB ved 45 ot oo "a 3 i ed & Bo " @ 80 om eg og 8 @ Bs ion OQ 4f A ft ad ee : vy. < oe td Log ved Oh, Ad vs 6 o es A Oo O wo od ies e , . a f "4 ¥ f. . 4 3 + wt et > P- Mee . -§ : aa ced 3 © * se * i oy tog 4 Os bs tS $0 re ; w tS reed ay "74 aed . ay - + gi ey od cs on 43 a S4 . g 2 G3 " a4 a v4 ri s 'o ' 7 ' | ' ved ok. a on oS 4 an © od 44 oC 4 4 Gi yy : 4 a oe Ag Ha) Po oe a te WG ts z Oy ry St Les ved ; ° i. 2 4 | a im ve , - cn i 2 6 2 Ug 8 g 2 ? " ; 2 . ne sed Ma oO ne mt ; " ot ay "ye aS it) = Fass Ae , re} hed % 43 CY @ ge Ge : . od Aa Cy c a4 4 oy $4 She} ond ry c od n ; p mi ae ee ka QO ca os ey ON ee a ' or d wi M4 4 3 *. 4 L me, mM ey t ade ee ? 3 w } " 4 8 TG ' BOR ve Oo ht Gm & « 4.

"Oy RM 4 a z Cs "4 os 4 koe we wm ay ob in : Mi "4 Ps Z o og Bop ON » ato Ts : ss a £3 wg oR @ bs 4 $4 5 reg 7 ug ms 44 isd a - , 4 ia ane mm hg mt 43 4d y a He is o 93 ord "a Db bp & ® a at Ge ' ) : we RS me ord 0 O Gs . 3 - a if wy rh , & + y " a ne i 4 3 6 oe a wd vel ww 4 Nd "Ps a ® a 7 ® v4 Si és me - i : * 2 .

o ih, cs x a oe) "3 wt Set ft oO cA 4 a : ~ -s os ve ¢ p o ub 4 xs 3 uA: 4. san bos in fads 4 ee . W G a £k we '1 - a fet orf ng fg 44 ms rd fw art ae i) © ~ oy ' 4 a4) ss 'Ds "4 Be ce o ne, a es 2 A el kE @ as a O ea rt 4 5 x 3 4d & % 4 Cw 4 O 3 3 a Md " ¢ 45 uv " 4 : wor A & 4 4 veh i £3 its wy is on 3 tt : a) i aS we het ue Ara : reat A wD wt £2 y 3 ~ iis ns 44 ie * cg OS o fy chord DP wet ot a M4 oe cel oe) BA 'es a a ge ee ES ot Sy ag ist « C4 a ; @ va mek aS et i 4 % $n ta @ oj 4 a tA ue gg we MoM & ba 32 a a} ' ont w a, ~. si fs) e ood Loney 0g o ¥ york wa hve ee 4 res 4 et ;

~ as R fs Wo etn = 3 mF 5 ea LS f BBM Oy v) i my ge " 7 EE * * t. 4 C in ehes f' 4 tf ee . rd 4 m ka 5 Be " 4 a oad 23) TC G 3 " a 4 «A Y cya . 2 ie "eo set 4 fs oa a " oeg o fo oy vf is} a ® 4 mA 74 ng 'A f eh, oO, 6 a SA cd 0 a ref wy "s ot th a . Ct ? ort ct Sh aa + @ a i ft Sy a : 4 Shed eG BG 2 gy 5 » £ 8 8 B 9 -. os e i "a . vot ny eo uw, oe ~ n - uy

8) i oO ord iS % od 2) eh 4 g} Aa ay ° * co 33 3 ho 4) ' i in : 2 ws 1 wy wt a ra] are rae fea c ced + & S / Le '

- OC gs 9p ge oo @ , bo « o | OBS 0 2D B® Wow So 8 @ "

"a Gs % . ag « $4 , enh : hs (ss a mt $ od e ¢ 44 ot ri 4 qt k 4 es Cr bt ve need a KS o fle Dp ot ra * be 4 ml 3 a cea] ; be te * + Ea o, o sed ea bs ' a ~ See \:

ea 2 ay s 4 q BR B Bg 'i £ . as wh owt Ave ; » gt st 4 5 3.3 ir * Xa os om : shes of Gh Gp 4 oA '; 4 fh ey 5 seed oor Hy ry . D on od ba & 4 tes ws 2? oe -

TY Ba y 4 w S . . " oS aA Ad ar a £4 La se 'Z os i + y ro o , Sy m Bow aD mM . Se i % i] 4 Ay ard A oh £5 | us 2 3 "A oot 4.

ii ved ss 4 CG . a 3) + + o be 6 we * " «3 O be gs * ty wy yy a an scars 33 ae 2a ag we s « Ox < :

+ x D one wf 5A i ' ~ = ve 5 2 ;

: a ca Prt gt rr: rh EN eg 9 6 mrt "3 . 5 "re 3 + . mc . i "

a © "x4 5 is orf mt ~-- 2 #5 0 md i i A Gort st 6 & ® Crh eh BE O Bo gp iw eH oe OO ts % a te ba er @ we a ry) 4 " ® mu A 'of os pe ae: C wee is ' 2d 7) ag et the ae ioe a Bb Db @ SOE ef HG ae. wm ty ot Et » OO m 6 8 of & oO @ ¢ no ot o 2 Sw 8 Q of My be B w 6 &£ GCG ME s a Qo mi wo oom wa coh GE tet Gr OG GD eet Aca 0 } ' cot ' ' gap

4. * /! ad Me he BA OG 5 a a a my r e ay bd cm cf Ae in ce a $A ved tog eed Eo eed at UH go 4a O os W FE 1 OF is 3 O} OS Fe DO "s Bo Ce 4 fh @ , Ee ov @ ba 0 fi} 43°F OO Ca 1 OF Ds aed a . 4 oot etre, one wy ES a es es :

ue ow 2 a ws © i et pd ord £3 Gee i a 1 GE 44 BE CD BES MW Gi OS mm co @ whom Sy SS eG A c ars ef ae £2 wD 33 hoard CP 44 25 33 "ct 43 Sa 43 M4 o ¢ 5A ¢ db red be «ed GA GY it nM " ba 5 Tee te 43 4 i Be at Q Oe cog Be a as S 5 wh vot wD cork fe < pate: my veh 4a 9 Qs ti ba a Y ~ Ly 2S £8 cP org St od OF a 4 GH ag G A 4 Sa bee s AS gv "oy 8 oD vt be L a} 4s Bory a3 BOO Mg 4 ad a, 4 aw 7 5 e Bed et Mg, SE BE a, $0 : 42 3 ue a bed, iss ane 4 a of urd " oO or 4) ip mt a 5 @ a5 4 G Bo @ fs = 3 8 te ed oy 4 2 ne Ke a 5 i ge OM ve Sod ha td " ue 8 Oo be as woe OO @ A O As ut aap gt moe EE ® Ba ea OS Yogi aw BE ge my oh i ie mA > 8 yt ag ot 2 gm 6g OS 4 G f a ye, & ~ ; % Mae ¢°3 a 28 ag "MBH 8 @ 0 8 Ae 0 ee do, ow Oy as = Sy Oo Be gy eB ge GO ut ym Bas © Bey Orme gg ~ )hUDS OG OS a Og ff Aa gs Oy ee eG % oo S 2 $0 G a" 3 ;

+ > . : bdo « 2 "tS Oh, Oy, a] wo yd +3 Med ty mag oy od Ct ; a4 wt 'a 63 4 wo % @ Bm yp & ¢ ih a a fit ry teed gr ' XS 5 ae, 8 ag cs gy Dt gy _ $a 3 a ae] . ard Cy ares . 0 Hy a a et ER by ' a bt Set i et ad WO A sce £ A ay ® 1 Oe © ; i ALM oc Fe a a wo \ be, et ' o> e ae wo Dp Ss 4 moo et & oa ¥e 43 me n bo by 5 OD 6 8 Bw Be 1 4 33 Hoon , OM } hg ek iD a © bes Sage y a Po ® . a 3 ga & vw oy ort # aU 8 S ork DH gM. ) te .

3G a " Ay O gy OD O Oy By wen ; @ i wh (owe Be 4 @ ord 43 a ib < if 2B 5 & Pods fee "eh EN ard Oh ' ' 2 ~ m ret Bowe hs yp hs ms DB Lo a3 g mn a Lo S a & 2 x

u ~ Me S$ on = 3 a Nah = S x Ss cs s we x ty eh = a Ten ee Na Se "sf be Oh ane oy «3 v2 me Moe BO Dm et OA I gen Oo wm oS . Qt og mH 8G OHO OBO KHO UBER AN gee gan, ad 4s 3 4 0) ne weigh TY, CE WA we hg 44 BB dd Bd ae Sp OD OO ao BM Cy pea "

Hy ae - mene * f CF ved wef bd : , ff my G4) MM Sea YO AM ye @ 4) ae ow U4 Oy ke S a3 42 0 £2 : wd wd 5 "tt or a the 3 me rod re4 el i?

od o i @ u a oa = Us 3.5 Ougni 1B it] we

1) 43 $f 45, 4 ' > se ¥ £4 gw $ b-

y ve 4 Ate 4 x 3 iy 6 ao) he . En wy m $4 $3 ha ' t 0 2 @ 64 » "3 . 9 re a va ved £4 ord pea ord 44 "od ved 4 a} in Bi ee 8) ed oO ved Q oat as GS ved oD ee mS tha Ch ay a "3 . wy ® uy ee ted x 43 5 it te : if : ' 3 ae BS 4 cS i a mR ad ot 8 ny fa '3 Ss fu A A a oe ice is i mi Cp i mt aD cei @ hd "A "4 qs mC "3 ed ho % Ct eed ad ot AS a wet 63 i on ved q? '3 Pa G ot ss aed od , 4 3 oe 1D a ; Ct ns £ i, $ Th M SS iH Ma ; te * Sez "ge A 6 ord - r ee Lbs " 4a oo aa a gc in rd ret i ae Ch, ee "it " mo on os a} S34 o AG a ee ay ord xn 's) 3 vet Aa 34 "es Ch ve im a ed Bd & e iy a = be gs y ui 2 12 0 i a 2 fea 3 ' a SO &% : ie wet : ty DB "

a : cS ch we % Q a 54 $a " a ty ip & wf a a i es 84 'G oy OG » ce 2 ng i A w "5 BS wl ce 8 9 2 % gk a Of yo tA sf bs a id va ea eyed bg a ; ¢ 5 £3 ra) a 4 a 6 ; a Sa M kd 7 < - at af. 4 ak or Kad Lt aye! g 1 peat zs oe aE DA Bo 5 he 6B ge CO GG Ww 8 6 ved @ i \ Cha 4 2 be 9 & "4 o 6 ed % ig - a 3 ce) *o a G a sa 4 C on ce

5) ved veg 4 ~ $3 Bes 4 0 'g ad " ' % ; ; & 44 us ' ty ee a peed

4 BD , * ci if m a 5 veh ¢ 6 "sy, mS 4 wed ep Y ue) bel Boe 4 Add . a . S2 ae '% ot it ved ty A a o 9» as wy . Ww ia O o at 3 vet {at y 4g G a o My as aH rad Ct Ged 3 ~ Ad % ™ "ed ea w @ @ eh O we wl rot % rl iS ie y "th rd ed Sa co v4 bd as « i 9} a 4 e w if 3 " Be 0 Co gt ua ci oR oUF cs pal a ti OD i mee i Oe fs g » m 4 td a "3 os 5 wD wo fl on ; ° aa '4 my +e oh ae ta 4 Qo % 8 ehh ag My ba wt gy & nb wha (2 a 44 g Ad 4 as wed es ved ry o oo ae He gs go 4 3 3 @ mS Q wd vd Oo ts "rd fa " © =H '4 G a' a fa a 3 5 3 rc as ci 6 pe o Ps go eB A uy he 5 i os io in mB % gq} oan rn ma yy D 3 4 ee a 12 5 é ed os ot e 6 8 % yw Cl tS Y 1 wn C ' & w 3 o a ( me pp wm 7 ee: 6 oa 8 $3 3 ; - e on of ee I ' ay ci @ ) She Che tO % g x . oS a oH ey 4 i ® 2 an & vd a 8500 or aa ms G as x Oo * OG ty mM x & nm Fo ge mm O Pg os v4 5 QR ota wa ® + a » eh ket Eg a ne ry EQ 43 el od wt "4 Sa - x aa 4 oe 3 " Ch 4 O , ord aa o OD Cg st us # 7 3 . 8 Oa red "4 » © So et 5 0 3 eo 2 oo «& GC 8 & 2 & GS G© Oo F yp EB 4 foe 6G EOD G Tt & Bp OG BB ££ 4 fds wd Sa iy rd bef 62 $4 wy wt '3 A ca Le 3 " 42 ig Cc 3 4d By "a Co ay ay be Ol GQ @ O = 3 3 O $4 st or w@ 3 Sf .

By) 4, Ch GB She a) ee B hey 4 44 @ ent ay 4 uw a Aa 63 g 4a 0 v on 4 be vet if c w th 44 Fe 4 3 kt og a 43 w@ wv Med 44 4d: ie y {> Ha 7 6 ha $4 wD "rd } « "3 wi Gh o a £3 a @ cs bet £3 rod 0 o ba is QO mee bs aa u i ft ; af 4S fh © Gy wu G 2 fa Os vd z a3 Gi f4 3 e as ts 1 Y35 ¢ i a we PO ve $22 eas ort uw 2 Oh f "

, 4 ' & weg 43 ord be ie) hes 4:3 4 aed eX, ved & mh « New cote Mal wet Ke rt Ny Saiet aad Sat: chin 04 tered ala 2 ts ' Ail).

hey 3 + werd noe my Pg wy bed cu the ny 3 ft OAPS42017 ee veoh te, 43 pt Yad a rhnk 4 4d we EK a3 ve uy a wd 3 ed Gg 4 3 ae & Lad wo ra (Or. Bhagwan Sah&%} + (Ravindée Kaur} Member {J}.

Member (7) eget yy

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai

Santosh Ramchandra Made vs M/O Communications on 23 September, 2020