Kumar S/O Siddappa Chalawadi vs The State Of Karnataka on 27 October, 2010

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Kumar S/O Siddappa Chalawadi vs The State Of Karnataka on 27 October, 2010

Bench: H.G.Ramesh

CrE.,A$'£'x3«e.530.€}? & 8-45.U?Ad0C

cage had aiready j'§i:m::é as; ans: 0'? the £:p§€=fiz?=.m'.s in
Crémmai ﬁppeazi. E\Icu84:'i,f'2Q{}?, §,Ef:€ c§isr1<2i:§s;e:iE of {ha
érzdepanacisim azppeaﬂ ﬁééd by him far' FEGEE-CGi'IEp§§E§.F.-?_§3f3 «:35
rc:~fﬁ<i:&% :;}bjec§%<>:t2s has no effect. on the app<:=.a1_i 
alsmg with {whey a<:::us;r"3z:i in  
?\E<}18<§~5;'2{}G'?I  ' '
2) Bricﬂj; mated the {gage ;§'*7__'p:*é§;v;2@;;é;i:<>:i 

under:

E§CCiJéS€C§ ?*%<>.2 'S:':'iE'".1,f_"E1"if£1>S':%V"1;"Eai.':"J..:§ ' {§'E'.f1:$ Saiié;h""wh.a had

been arrayed as a_<:cus€d 'fir; ':h;é"::f§:=s€_'_.ar;d 21 guveziﬂtz

on the! re§c5'v£:ﬁ:: éi.a€C.g'a_.f:=: E}/>16 song of acsused 1"€9.§..
A{:CL:s€é:£_ ?\E§&;§4§»_ *i.@ '<f> '[21:féA--.,f:'1*";5: ?€%1ai:i.v€$ (sf Accumzi 1'~E{>fi§,

€}§"1e,>: 2'%sh{}é<L'_s%f<} 3%agmib§J;?§"_fC§'2a§;a21?;aé§i had. been. aweigread 32$

Ac::u,;3éd_. Naif» ._é1*i tide czzssz {>115 Sm%"Ha§12m'1as;va3

v.8-§':§:§§av£?L:z éi':."%;_{§ Réaiavﬁxaz am E§iS/€,€31"$. PW~E€3 Ssgabapipa

A~§§,ra-;%:':;:_;.§a:rj"i§"~*':E7§:siir brgihsr. Saceaaeﬁ E~i:;§:§1a;m'pa., E3'%JEf.3~

Szriétﬁxzasv.§%§§§7vé:ra§?a'p;}e2 éﬁémdzzi zmsé P§?\f,2E~BaE21§<risE'2r:2:

Eaaaziégzgizié  :§'::;= ::;<m5~:; a>i_"E€_g::mgm::::r'1ra, 3.7%'LZ§}§Z£§{§'£'é3'é3
..:""§'%§"'£cE?V(A':E%§,f§'i'rE?§" <3?" {§€<:€:éiS§3?{§ §%"§a3§":.::2g%..};)'§}z?:, is: $33.53 wéifs es}? E%">"§%5'«-§.{E¢

--  §3"3FK!~ ENE. ':<'<::f:":':§'i.z-2:3   3f§Ef§.§§E&?E.:§}§}&£%  's:§":.s;*, :+;;<:m {sf E3"s}~J«E{}.

 

wvswmmmmwmwmm'WWWWMmw......,W.......... . . .



L,l%.:"\b,i\H2.3..'>_§'J.Us' ii E3'-¥Z'5.Ui°AGQC

Seized {:rn.€: swszwd Qialawar} u:1de§ par.2Cha::z1.m.a E:«:.?.6§
from 'aha 31:32:56 sf Accazseﬁ Na. 3. as; pm" §'sf{'C)f?'. ﬁg abeuz E
p,m,, the injured Pionnappa Sazccumbeci is the §E'1§IL'ifi€S.

On recézipt. 35 {he deaéh memo frem the hespitai,"c§ff&:i§'<:je

2,1 S 303 EPC wgzs added 'E6 the case and inver§ii'g2:3;:i§:':§'wéés "

pmceeéeé furﬁwar. ?W--2:% c::m§ :,i2'{:%;':2d émﬁqzgééiiv 0x?Vr52v:f:]~EEfi::e&

deacé E3e3d;»; ﬁr; {E18 f12{}E'"E'LJ.Ei1"j§,«" €§fE1VE€.:'}'}(§E;§f££3;£1iaE su§:>j:{€:~:§%V{E_._

th€ deaé baéy ta peat-me1<.1;_é'"m» e>§.a.:né::afi:%Qr§'.:Vw'Fi:£'th€:'V

imvestigatien was hamiad sv'é;"= $31} I?W--25W;i'i}e:ya}«:urr:ar

Bésrzaiﬁ, Pgiice imspéctéifﬁ.;'K$5g--§<{€,>2a'3g:§.:;:TrM--,,A"'§éi.':uEf>2i. wha ﬂaring

m§un.:2iry _ ;'§'£V<':V1%€i*'7,T."--€?'§_€:V§7E"{E§;<.'V' '["7.f§{i{§'s5€§"'€& 'W€&p{}ETzS 2:236 aka
I"€€()1'§;€G%"E§"}'iE' SEaf;er%:§€~=:"15%;'.:;..__éf""1witz1€sses and su'::2_3?€<:§ac§ 'Q16

se§z€d__ &1?{§1fE€_S $.41":  '}f'0f$1'E8iC axaminatiaﬂ zmé aftsé"

 ;::";::1§:~:§*.;:;;*1::a_g iiha r3é5'<:.5:s;_:;a2'y €§éii€£,'3;§."2'1€f.'£i§.'s ans? aftey Campieting

 §:'°::f§'€$'éﬁig;.;i'%ii.€32'i_léiid {ha ezzharga sheet aga.:£n::-»;'€ 3:C{:':.2S{'fi:§ Nag.

E ~§;{§..'.?;  '}::j'_v~§"E*«;}§3'i,1€'EéCii": sf azcsusﬁd. N93; ET, 2  3; :13: 6», €;.%:<€f;2-'

*~;;é:6:'é"*--$u.§.§§€{:£é{§ is juciisiaé <.:"::S:<>::€§; 2m€i_ $262}; ::.:::":':"[:?:2u.eaT. $3

 .§"'§ifE'§1€?L§jY?:.'i§_vL§'::';§'i,é£§i€§§i§ Caaiaciy 'SEE. {ha <:<>z1{:E:§_:=§é:}:3 £3? %;.E";:% iirégzi

 éjijré ::{::':é%;:téz:'é%{rm, :%=:.t:;:¢:"{E€é{£ E37: ?if"2.<-3 €_.:""_§aE €.'€f3LE'§"i'.;, §%<::m "i:h<":*~



€.;r!,As.NaKb;':G.G? & 845'Cr7=€2¥OC
: ES :

date of ms §Lldg1"lT}E'11.'{, r;fh,e}:' have': 'meet: s3e'r<;én§>,; the
E§z:'i1TT€fZ"X':§";'«'53', ;'%.C£'u3€:d. N053 since W213 found jL1.*'~;:3r1.§I€ as; an
the reisx-*a:1'<.: <:ia:e§, Séparate chezrge sixes: <:amé3 to E;r:';?__f7{i€d
agamg: him before {hrs }'LZI'iE§d§C'€i{}1"1»E11 <:m':r:,, 
Cemrnittal Eviagistrata, gérzce ;%<:<:1_,1s&d Na'?  
fer ssometime, {he case: again::s{'A" '§:ém 
Hewesver, before the trial   
the Gear? anti the Case    
:6 the mar': of Sess§;Q;2?::<; : Baéfh" ifE';e§VVV'"€g;Ase$" "'§i?V€'1q\\«%§'L§bb€é.

Befsre the leameé g'-Eessicsﬁs §E::¢_:ig§<:*:}_.AAzf~5i;'c:«?':f:;;$5__e3E 3303.1, 2 and

:hem zeirzd --::§ai.r::csi'-..*§¥:>A §b4é'.Tf§f'i€5i' '§'s brmg heme $216 guﬁt 0%"
the azccuseé' §>€"E°S€}1f:%fS,  ii§F:.?::--.;;:3 1*0S<§<:':,1'{:011 €Xé1E§1iI:€§ PWs~E. ii}

25 a.:j;:r§ S0%.,E.g§':"3L_ {€}w}i:,"§3.€Z;'é?' héiianca gm &§c:,:rz:em_T:2arj; €i»'i{2§€ﬁC€

par '§EZ;:>'<;';'§'3';E_ is 44 as age rnaiariai <,>bje<:ts

  }.."f:.g;°E_:i'E¢ E1¥ur'iz1g {Em ceurge of <":E'GSS4€X§ii'I}§E'}&i."E§{}:F} <2?'

P1f%;'§§'~3; Vi'i_. ';;1:.st:V§E E2,' 3&6 {iaafezzgéé gm :':':a2'§{;@{% €xs.D§_ Sc; 4%?

a:'2{?"E"}»§.=..E 22:'£€§ aisé: SQEEEEE phczétagrazphs as; p63" E§;:>:$g.§'},5 Ea

 E}:-:£"éz3§§ izfrzasséz" sr5>:2::3'11?:2a%_%{:;:*1 ufsé;  {.":z'.§3.{L t.E1.e:%

 ":;25::::r.;: ';3z:3:'§'e;:>::*;_:»'s dzézéésisé 253$}  i:":<:;§*imé:"::&'§;§§2



C.rE.A3.f\3G.53O.€3? Eia 84E.O7.d0::

:1}:

c§rc:.zmst2:.I1c€ss azppézariizg ezgairmi: theitm in {E16 evidarncii Gf
ﬁle pmsecuiign wimesseg, '%"'h<3 a.::cL:S::d chi? mat chésage
ta Eead any ﬁefencess evidence. The éefézmcss of :.E".::~,= a§:i:--.:::s:':d
was {heat A<:cuSe:E. I'\='{:LT£ is; {mt 'ihe 
iaeighbaasaréng p:"ap::»rt}=' 0:" §3K-'s;"~§{}; that, 
by PW-'~EG was £1': acésupatian 9? 
gistez" sf PWMEQ v.:.=»-me P'xA;--:0  ;1§Gr;;;ér;V._x5;i.'£FA§ %'z:?;§»;.b'.<:E;3§.§'d:*a:%§:.!'§%$;%§3'2.
resiaﬁrzg in G053, HC%'iiVE,"J€I"5  wa_$;=, 
E0 vacaie "ihﬁ said h0'L1§§:~..bat«"§i§tf'ié;g§ \fe.{;:s€§{G $05 In
ifzat regaréﬁ PEXEW Rf}  .7E"::'s br®Eh<3r--i.n~

lav; nameéy EE§:é"::}ﬁjppé_. a.mi{ a';c<:ér':£'§z3_g§32 on 3E.O?.2GG~'~%

ﬁeseaaéﬁ ._ T§~¥~;§:T:':a7»--:a_§p5p;;"~__:a.§.Qs:g with his S'L'ip}:3{}f'{€1"S
r2'um%3€réé:';$>r 'a.be:;f; V35} ?:é'».é?'G' arm::d with daadlv wea ans;
<2? % . ,_  V 9

<:a::1€_?::.ea.:* %i§'.i.€._§":5§'}1,§'3'.3<i' é5'..,{"2;§ Erieé ta ferxrcibéjg ﬁésgaagegg {E29

 «..gaic§./Eﬁhgg-arzzvé. ané ZF'::S"';€é_mi§y E':'E€3Y"{}b§3§°S fmm ihss hetzse, 5-"ii

Ehéét .5;}:T§.':".¥.;<T4iV,""5§'i.E!.'V§.w'<::":E§%CIT Shyam, big §a_méij; members 233$ hég

$ué§";:::§;«r'Eé§%é;'v_v.§§r,E::;ﬁé'arr: :"s:~:si.den%::=: «:2? 1316 3211236 §<;<:8};§t§%' j;:»$E*{:3:;i

s':9§z§%:£~3, =.:§E:."1:.iI.",§{ péaaﬁs sic», at: 'ihﬁ mzfa and airavéé 2?}E'.§':'iE

 Véziafzﬁg ?§':ri;:».:¢ﬁ Eéae zfzasg 'mi ithéigéﬁﬁ' éhcrré 2;: }§I{} Baéézixaa §;'§{}'€.%'i.
V n  . 0- 2::

5 2-?

  {}r:,_::{i;:.::':.':;;z_:. <2?  ;;}é%I£E§3iz§; ac}; .;;<;* a€:e:3:":<=::; emaé §:>z"§<:'§<' '§3§€;':{?é?§_~}

 



CrEJ5kS.§'\3£:>.§3G.G? 8; B4;5$Q?'(dO{\:

:12:

PW:s--3_3 4; §§<m:'1ap;_:>a and athem E§LEf'§?E"éii"1€:Ed injzsrieg ami

whiis w%€:§d:':':.g_f the xwapeng ?:€:>E& by them, i;h<::}=' aiset}

gustaizwd i2":_;'u:~é€s,

4} Aftsr héariimg bath skies and an A
area} as we}: as éczscumentarjg; ex.«'§«&e§1C e3__ :'§;;¢v  
Sessécmg Judgczz by the judgmezmlhﬁgzéiér. 2%'§:p*eAe;}.:_.:ﬁQ;3,§fi'%f§§é«
acsused N03» 2, 2 and 4 is €>».?;40Ed1§'v1'€3:;A.;€'i--2.é.t 
has prayed 'she guiit 0f t}*1€S€"V"'é;%Eé:CE1iS€3€.Ci p;%1;fS{%§:1S' L%f: V £12 the V
chargeg Eeveiiﬁﬂ again§":'=.:}1e:':;§§:§=:;;V;£§'~.;aaS<%>vf§é1i§v§e éaubt.
§G'i'=£€vz31", in "326 Eigh}   0? m.at€:n'aE

wiEmeS:§€s z%€Z*m _E":a{°i;',' bj§'«..§?:e:r:.S€Eves exoneyated 2::::::'§,:s@d
I'ée:>.§Z {§'":1f': EC"381'?r":€*';{'i§ 'fgéfagéc-.€:S'.s}"udge acqzzitteé accusézd $239,?

sf aH;.é:§<:e Ch31'ﬂES~§3€'»'€§E€rE§ a aims: him. Aftmr hearémr ihﬁ
: --. ':7. C'

'"a*;r;€i;':"$eé;"L.%;énti.¢their Eﬁarnsd C§}'%..,3.'F§S€L ths Eearnéé Séissiena

E-,?é,1<iTgeT'0ré_ers regamiimg ssnmnce. Being

;zgg:"-§;{,~"ve_§E'bf§}' {$16 §'L*£<ﬁ§:;§}'§i€f}'°Z? sf mrzwizsfgisn and {§§"C§€:" eff

 é;:=:;:i€%:_";c';-:=.--?" a<:::uSed N98: 1, 2 313d 4 K3» 6} am in ajgspeai

" . '?;3-§3f€j}f-é;' firzég cszzrtﬁ C§"§.,_f§,?\3{}J§3{};j2§{}7 £3 by écauaeﬁ ?*aEs.:¢.~<%«

' " -i2:--§*'::7Ee {"§:"§....+":,%"\§s_:ué§=-%;*"'§§2{}%i}'?'* £2 sf; ;%<":£2.;:~;e@{§  2? 3% Ema:

«s

6. :'§§'£?i§€f ix :'1<:;: 5:'i§§gI"';.€?'~;,-'*€ai§  i:§':::=r 2:a{:£§:3§?;.:'aE :2? 2'5::<:<::.;s9;s_-éé §"%§@$?



CrE.As.f'-ie,53G.S? & 8%-5,eZ}?.d0:;

:33:

ass mg .z1pf§3a>.22E ééezg been filed against. {'2/15:': part cf the

j'1,2dgm€~r:i:.

,....-

:3} We Ezave h€3a;1f::E Sriﬁaxri  
C::>Lm.s&§ arzé Sri.V,E'¢§.Sh.ee}.vanth  
appearing far {he appe§1a.nts;'a:'<Etf{:S€«ri 
agpeaig aad alga} Sf§..;5x'R.P§1tiTL  
S:'1?,Ravi B'Na§.I:«:, during 'f}'}V{3"V""'*¢".'Zf:§"L.i'£"S€v. é:';f _t§1.%%.= 
wauié urge as; under: .   ' <

31} that the  ES perverse

&r::i.z1§ieg:aE ;_:m<:'§  £1336 §j.=ia;f'n:;€d_ Eéezssiong Judgs has

1j"€C~€34:'<§A;§d.'_ e*§;f9:1€§;i2$_«* 'fi:.f:;.vr;?i11g that ¥:§1.e*se accuﬁed

__péés-if;:?2v§:V'Va?€#  'g_.1;i§tf§f sf chargeg, ihzmagh thé
 esx-%£.d.?e3:;.ti:§L:V'V0'f§"-.§%é'¢<i§rd 60 :10': agtabﬁsh iaéjqonﬁ.
:'='@aSe:f;:5;--.'@§€._ Eiaiubt the guiit af $2.6 a.<:<::;;s@d
p€r'sdr:.3___§E:«>§v a:"':3:* 01? 'ihﬁ chargas Eewﬁiied agaizfzsi

A %'i'i*:'ﬁm;

 '*§é} V A  -"{§f1.é§:"ihe manna? in which the Eaarnazd Sesgémfzsa
H ';}"%;:d;g€ has; a;:spre<:£a'{eé Ehﬁ svédsnes amé hag
cangidereéi {ha ssiefezzce f§'173Cé§,'jJ is CGE€'iiiI"a.I":;' is

ihe 'i%J'€i=§§ geizleai p§"iE1£'i"§3§€;'$ cf Ezzw aajzai ibis has;

§'6:§::§i.&i§ £72": €:':*<>:2:3<::,:s;ju€§§.;:::":{§:2I:;



1:1)

iv)

= iest§'r;t§;'n§'  Féigiiiy i:nz'€£éa'::vi:3:

{.;rl.As.N0.bji}.Uf & 84';>.i}.?.<:3eC

é:Ei:e:!: 'she Eeamed Se:~':$3i<:»:1:-3 &L:dge has 1391:
pmgeriy appreciated the fact Ehai {here has
been inorciiaate ané unexpiainezd deiay in
Esciging the C0mp§::1i:*1£ and that the corrzﬁaéni

Exﬁié E133 mat COI'.1':rf;' into €.X§S{'€'1'EiT:§3 ~~&§'E1 'it_S

§i23:'pGI"?;€€E time in View of the fact_.*:}§éi'£{ .
rea::h=3& the jurisdictionai MagiS§.'§§itV€"-éﬁiz  
am. an 81.98.2004.  '§IA' %ié'1"3.fG«re,-: «  :g:,ga*med.

Sassiaﬁg thggdge e'ug1_1{".:o:'-.§:%§ve };§E:;i_

cerrzﬁiaint has b€?:I%.""?$.I:ts--é:v§me<i;   

thazi the iﬁﬁffflﬁd""E§'§";$S§;§';i1.S Jué:i'ge~"}:as 3203
taken mic: I"::j;13§ai*£ets\::i<fé':i"% 3.;a;:é0L:.s infirmities
and %.mprababi§i*§i€3 in " i:}:é'* l§::%id€::"1<:e sf the

";1d.s'5'§?';e:"ié;E"wiiﬂé-$se§"'which has rsndereﬁ their

Thé kzzzrtrzed.

« S@s:»;%{2--r1§ failéci to mate {hat there is

C€>2'::2'§§.Eei:€3 xzarianee wiifn rxisgard 3:3 ihe manna'

2117; *¢»-'?::ic'E1*'*:""i;1Itf*:Ve ézzciﬁent aiieged 'ie have Gzztfsurred

.._aiS® ﬁne exact piace Q? 0cc::%;:.2*r€3;:':<:s as;

'V '  in ﬁe c<:>mp}a.:E§:zﬁ; E:a<:P.6 arzd {E36 césuéar

' -€';?«'§}'E;&€EEC$ Q? {E28 '{£':£:ii€§."§8.§ "wiizzemas and this

£r:C{}r1S§s3:£:i:c_§.? émng znaégﬁriésé {me 531$ 22330 hag
ihe <>;Ff:3<:2'*, <3? Shifiing 'aha z1<:t:,:21§. Séiﬁfiééi 0?

{)CCU:Z"E'£*f§C{i°. éisseijf} G'L;Z§';h'?; ii} $133275? been

:::<:sz":§;*§{§£r6d -§§<:>:ri.<::u$.§.}; amt? gr: é%38;'i. %}5as;i.;:<::5 {E28

E€e7s2:"'2*.::;%::§ E%§{&ss:a;és:>:§,.:'~.: s.E:;:c%;g;;e ::;~2,3gEf:%; ':9 ha:2;*z5 §:":s:-'zézi

 



Cr§ﬁ.:saFJc=.§3Eé.G? & 8»4S(i}?'.do{;

:13):

'aha': ihé E€'S{§1";"1{)1'§}7 GE the'-:36 E-'Ji{Z'}€SS€3°S is hélghijg

L2rm:~3.1iabE€:.

that the Eearned S€:Ssia§"1S Judg::""h_.%ag;§ __L'§§§1f§{3~.

failed to notice that the ev:£dence""r_3:f §55'E?'»?g'--:%,'  V'

Ema'; 'EC? as to the fa:cm:/H sf tvhé-I.de{::aasé'&_

Hanna 3 ssca 21116 "A;frc-_'r:;f 51%: '-%ii;£é1:"LL~--..ai;i.:§
13? 2:; . . _ _ A

gumpéng :0 the 3;1e'ighb@Li"1'n;Z:.:g ccmpécjfjgjd :>a§fﬁI1€V:'& '*

ha was said is héQ%;*~:f bs3en 2is3;é:"L:l.§ed57}'.$H?1'£g§'1Ejg
imprababiegnd a;EV:3'{2 '-%iI':}"'§}'I¢:V$'ES_S}'_b}é' h'awinfg mgard
to {he ﬁes<::*';%§i:5:3§r:':15;;-- :15 Cimtairzeé in
the aE<etch',..r:.'{ag:<E<e§iA :,as'.A"'E:i§1VVEf;~"f prepared by
?W'E3 j»   {he Eearmed

;Sfes§ s;§v0 'm"S'..__J2;2§Egg;é'*--.hZ';a$"V.:<:empie:e§3.r grained to

T'c<;{§:.;;sid'éff"'f;39:'£s;"-as;;ééC'E 0f the mafia: in ihs

'--€I"s:vfi:£é*€ij-»E}.é§;:i':-:§1'§'?; 'ufzder appeaé a.:r:& 'ihuss; the

=. E&:-,1::f:"1£3-d"' S«3:§E~si0§."1s Judge has amitteé {C2

r:€:s::s;i{%<e:* 233.-zxtéééai exsécﬁenca an resrcsrd wiaéch if

had E%<':::*:*{ ::0nsi&e1"ed, in $53 preps:

VC;;e@«é?':«:.;.>eQ%;i.are, ﬁns finding w<::u1d bzwé bait}.

V _ .,r.3:":En§;'=';*"<,ara;5&%;

v.?§} '

 $2233: ms appmaizh adagted '$3; {ﬁg Eéazrmeé

$€*-E?~§§i:'_3§.1§-} Jzzdge in zijecting the d.€f€1'3{',fi &§":€{}rj;
52:: *:.i§::;% grit-'L§§E{§ 'E§":3..*:. ?§Eé;? siefergce @5233 net'. "p§.e::_:€é
gm}; <z2;é{§s3:':::e :5: smbsigzzetiszés iii; cézzéiéémééé ﬁg

C{}}7":§§E'sE"i§":;£ 32;;  zaseéi S::';*'§'§'.é{?{'§ ;'3*{é:";s:7§§>§e:--; 2:3? E231-as

 



Cri.As¢N0.E33G,G? & 8éZS.Cé7,doc

"'71:

;:_..

itseif ceznnei be as gmunéi to 1*:-"ﬁe? the
averwﬁéssimizig '€.€S'£.'i}""f'10}'1}-' cirzf Pi1§s.3, 6%  E6}
213 impreiseabie emd {big {szniggigazz §}'§.f1_"4'?;i'§%€<.:":;:¢"5{E"§
Sf P'i?v'.E§ has is be? C{}I1Si.d.€3"€'€§. assfea  V'
amission amﬁ HG cr€d¢;r;c_<f3 €o_iz;i1l£:i"

ii} {.136 said £216: {:13 :!;*:;e. 2jig'}':sTt 1   Gm}

=ffV"id€F':C€ Gf {he ma1:€ria1.V.wi£nesS%:S'; . A' "

vii} that {here £3 :10 CE'I:'€';3"£;%%}'15%§.Et1'1%IE" t'ué i::3d:i}:ate that
tbs scene {Ii}']LV.Léi':3'»'.bf3€'I'éV';§E"ié§'i€3C§ from
'she from 05  IQ: the hate} and
as3';3_'ﬁ;1i§1g ithét  céiscréspancjg
 e*_gi.4i€'"§' ev%ia;:V1¢"é;izd the cements 0?
.§f:'seEf  :j;9;:?:.n0'E be 3; grcnmd to

 %£?':;:g7e %VE1l::<'3ie  6f the prese<:'L;2'Ei{m as
"  hthe: canienig of EXP6, ihe
.i'_§,:"1"{:'§,ﬁéV}'.}._'E. ' fZ)C€%%;i'i"}%'°€i'{§ 5:1: the hQ?;eE arm? the
 V" beézég :*':;:sé.'E{: '*~:i§Ee:.g<~::°:<3, 'ihgir
SEa€€m«é%i%1Sv Carma? be *«;::'ewé3§ §}6fiC¥iiS1:y'  this

_ 
§;%}'*f'*.._'§7::':§:V:*'ef92"€:, he :'--;:>i.:g§**:€ 'f{:>:" <:Ei3m%.:a5«;:-33. {:75 {he

::pp%<3.a§:'-;,_v" {Si Sugperz of big submiéaieng the Eééazrzaaci

 ~.._*ﬁ::i£éi%:i{§;:g_E ﬁiéiéiif Pz;bi:'_{:t ?m$<~:c::;ie:>:' §;m;z§%*:z :51: §:I=§E~§{"T{*,

 ._ "r:;%ij§a:*%;;:aEs  sa€a¢*%3r22§ z%x3e:é:;:§:'::":s_, EE"Eé§§E"i§:£ at: $2153? ?b:*<>;::{.%



Cr§.A§.N0.530.{}7 & 845.G7,dOC

:25:

that A<::c'2.1s€c?: ET'~§{3.Z; as {}W§1€T (sf ihs zieéghbguring
§r:}p€rE:§;, wag abjactitkg for fi.:<:mg the <.»=s:ind«:}w 
if 3.C€:L1S€°d E\f<},1 was :13: the (}W1'1€§' of 'ihe 
prgpariy, there was met) ocs::a$i.0:'z_Qr__:fea$§':*:
No.1 ta raise 215:5; Qbjectionsk I\/§;:%2<1j€ 
:10: be s'uffi<:.i6nt to pmxfe '£.1f%V;:f:"=:;j3f.?I1.§1i':~:ig1_i1:~.  L
by AC<:L1Sed Na}, mqife sa:>,vAV_f~,-§7uTVr:j';'«:%=;:_1'VV_I_*_V1,LAs: :r3;A;;sV;:3;aI:sd the
Said fact during  0:19 CELYEHOE
expect: Accus€aE f€Q ,E.  fact; it was
:10: difficuéij.    pmduced extras?

fmm the "'p3f<3;§}13rtf§*I:.;:":zg§s;:€>.r f::*6n:'~'i§1e iecal &u'€E':0:"§t§.€s if':

:reSpec€;®f--_€'§1<€%é:3§}g::jE*i.'£':0%:;:.:j?Z::.g'prapeﬁ}? as has beer; d{).'E"§€E
wiéh refér:&:f:»:::5 tie ﬂ"£V§6:..pﬂi*§}§€§"?i}-f of PERJJQ 233% préducing

Exs. EVFIE-3. a:':. a'v-P}'%i4%'} '§'%bi$0§ut5Ey' me aiiempt apgaears ta

' E;f:3.::"é" bséffz. fixadé ta 3e<:'u.m {E7163 sxiract fmm {he ;<}mp&§'"'é},-'

1:<;e?§2:1§;§:::3:'.. :'<3.f"%:?7£<%_.}§'vE:mi<:%Lpa§ ;"3.:.'::§':@:":it}r in :f:':u%p6c:% Q? the

 jgmpcsrz};-* 5.}? P'\%z'.E.@ 'ii: "preﬁx? 'z}?';.afL ﬁcsaigeé

'V§?§:},7§ £3 £216 {}W§E€f° 23f {mes s':;2_<:-h §2:°ap§33:i}; a':3u_%':i.:zg aha

'*;_<§=:§:u;;é';7€§-' £2? P"s§£'.E.f}. E§:£'m:'§;21_:"§.fg,«g ihée §}2"{}S€;'{:i,§5:§{}§.'§ haéa aisgiiz

m '§:<}: ;:»=Ea<:§3:<i £:%,?E}-" {§.{}€:1';?r:z':€§1'§:£:,1"}' £%'a:é{§:%n5r{>, is}  *;.1":z5a%;

1,0}



Crl.,<'3\sKN0,S3G.U? 8: 84§.U7(dOC

: 126 :
PW.}C§ was cGr;.s¥::"u{:ti.r;g 2% ':31,1iidi:'1g in (ITS No.3?Oj4n.

Admit:i:eC§1}>, the pmpfgrigjgf Gwnegi by ?\?'v'.':f} is-3: '2&{iv§.%V;:i.:j ~t_h<3

Eimits of §f§i,ib1§.'r3§'1EiI"iX'"&1d Mumcipai 

Therefors, :10 c.<::s1':$'£:z'é.:::ti<m <:at3_ be «'%:§'ad§é". "'2;'2.~*ii§19=.:'?: '

  

obtaining ﬁ€{Z{"3'E3SEL§'}=' E_:£c€1":Ce and E:£:iEa2'1, A.'z";A~"é;v3-2"§'1 fi;}"'§'e:4"':M'E;i1T§"i""i§:.Zﬂ

ziathorityz pwm in his or2;T:%'e--s;1dm'csr;as 'gdgx:;7:;'«:s--;a:.r,i,;V: that- 

the heuse Gwned by  »1?a§_.£;ﬁAé:1;pV§.§nd  r:V£Q'pE2.exa; :33;
name Shjsam. Sf cv€)'*:;:r.:s.€A,. ,:}1; a.S$€TC€ﬁ in his
€Vid€§'1.C%:"f that v'£'§'1:€ Vs'a:iq::  hOUS€ abzmi
031$ manth€.p';:§'Q§  thereezfier, he
WW. EU}; ""     c0ns'::*:;c:i{>17_ and
ce::z1sé:rﬁ§:€:i0§:_  'i:.0::r:é up is the height mi' &b<}u_f:

E3 :0 6 iégefa. Exé'é§;i; "E:-he oral evidence, {Emma is; T30

acceppiabie 'V*<)1-{"§Gf'€~Z"'iC€7 ii: énciicate that ?\7\§Ii{} was

 ,sor:._$'€'mEcﬁ£j§12g %;?z€-v"'%'1e.':ia$1e. "'§"h<3:'e is me acceptabiz-3 z'-sxrédezzca

 €4:>_V3?:§>:z.;V "£'§'§_E{9;_ i§<:.__€3 ggzéd Shféam had 'zzzazizatéid {E13 Em:>:.1s;e 21:36

%f§v_é3'"3Vgz§€§er '_§?§%?,3;{E gtariﬁd c<:m$"m,:ct:'.<3:.1x in 'ﬂ.";€ a'm::=.:::::€ of
;:,:=;';§,;»..44s:,::::Ev':.a{f'g:tep'i.5:bE€ €%fTE.{§€?§C{f;, we §E"n{3 greegt. §<;s;"a:s:  zhe

x_;:<mEa%:é~~? %e:%.:1 5}? ':Ef:.€: §§f£iTE§i?d :2;:::%::i{>§" s<m:":s;s:E '£'§f:222.'E: Ehé',

L



Crl.z3«s.E\%o.53G.0? 8: 8-45.€}.7.d::3::
t 27 :
§1'°es§:=CL:tiaz1 has, faéiecii to prcve the genesis; sf {he ézfgtécisnt
aﬁegéé, '

13} Acczzrdizig ':0 ihe cage cf the  
irzcident OCCU,E'E*'€'& at abeut: 5.36 p..J1t::i;:.>_§31":  
imzééent \--'%:'{':'I1'E am far about EC? '{o:'»..g :'§  
meanwhile, the police <.,&?er€:V_':i:3.fi0r:"%§évai:V: 
ma peiéce Came there rand    p5_é;~g;o::s to
the hasgitai. As per  and 3539
in reapeci sf mg-.,__3 i.;';,'§:'\.;.'§..¢§'_';§ "£r'"'.:.:::3p3i'{2*;.':, ﬁubiiﬁ
bath of :hg_m   .91? 22:25 p.:".'1":, in

$313. Pé% &_  '"I*::>fé€?..'_.1_. -Siﬁtéd ihat the ing"L2.r€d 'W€?€
bz{3ugh':'--.b}..»-« g;;:3VV.P§::??iS%1};§r9;~;*r:. A:::c<3z'éi1":g ':9 ms: Qrai.

:3v§d€:'";_C€ <23 "§~'?*'s?'=£V,'V:3~§;?!_r,V"*"'E'*s.s'fam_i:az3 ai 1390 pm» an

 @nA é"~ZE?212';as%:uram 's§{::.:g§:§ three §:':juz'ed

 :g¥*fj§'§§{}I§S '%;3_fsi~.t,f:é;v::€ Hazanappa, Sriniarag aim Bagaiingappa

 ;'"?w§'r: {his E': is 6362.1? 2212:: betaareaééé ?.€}{}
az:.::»..?X3C%~ p_,::.;; the i:_";.juz"ed Eiimappa, §'W'w3m Szériiaizass 51:25,.

"PiEzi4§«Bé;.:éa§ingz2§pa. 'W€E'"€ §3§'{}';..Zg§'3§ 36  3/2:}s§péE;a§ by

V"-§?aa:.r_a::"§::2,:2';§:'§3. €92" '§.E."€Z;'f;"i?'§"%'E€'-E"}i.?_, fiiT{i{§~§'€§i'f"§.§_g: in 32:: €:r*§.:§.<:-:.";<:%% 0'?

""--.. "P'*E:§?'.235 E§§:f%2«'21a2:_z:<?:% E333  E{.%s;§3*=:23§:3':::f gsaizm :=;§27:.:i<::I:":?



{:rLA$.NO.S3Q.G? 5;: 845.€3?.éGc

:29:

been Ciuéjgr expiained. Hcswrsrvezf, the cguegtian ES, whéthrer

£Z§<:{P€: has came into €>{1"5;{€1f:c€< at its pu_}:'p0rte§ 

his €§=:ami:1at§<>n--in~C%1i@f? P\Jv".4, the campéaéxzsgfnt ;:"i&;;éj'5:§.A:ié;:*;;A ~
Siam ihe {$131.6 at which his €{}:1'.',.?.'.'é.}f)§";'iE'1"}il_"é<§.f&ii€..§fé¥€.i'°if: V
racordeé. Hawsxém', in {he c%::jss'§'ci'~»ié'1zi'§§1é:';fi'0£L' _"i~': £[$

elicited from him that {ha §$c>_Ié;'s:;:¢ recA:"<,:3'i<_:1¢:dV 

in the haspiiai er: abeuqg  t3':3LA'31 "€§'?--,:?E§}{§:1. i'»1E'L:<:E1
significance cannot §:::a"";a.:{.£?;¢:r:""i3_:%:fi}iV:}isé>ﬂ:'f?:§:.§ifferenc£' in {his
timing as sta':;€;(§;'§;>§,~f  ":.;5;:'.;u~:'..1'}_{:%ii"1:{)(",'Cf Supraﬁ
Pwé» had   §'1€ wag being
traateg  Themfere, he méghé;
:19:  bﬁeﬁ. 9:9 mate the exaci: 't:im%n§;.sn
E2<;.P32 :'.S &E; s3.ﬁ§90jf;§A:;.§§ie§.:.\'~7fF'§R Suhmétted to Ehe Judtéczial

E\;'Eag.€.:§%:f;;:z;a.*L#: aEo§:;3§..'i§f§{h&VEXA.P6v A3 cauid be Seen fmm the

 €r:§§V{§'rse2%%ie§ifLp::1ade er: EXPB2 bf; the ieamezé ?v'§agi.st:*ai:€?

 ;'%?§}7i_T-:°e'a::f£':.;a:%:§ j?:":_;1;5_:: 38: 338 am' 01: @T§,.{}8.2{3E?$'-in 352$ gym'

c@i::;..;:m. V~2.'7"~»;'g";'2';.:--"~sT¥[ §T;?i§}{d} if EX.P32«~E<"iR, 8% case was

 .;eg}§:«;:e2"e?:3i;_ 222$' 833$} 313.112' :22: 3%.{L'%'?.2{}*{}4. As; per ilfgaa

..f<:Q:ii'$i;:f;%s; <2? €a::E2,§_rz':':": §'€{:2,E3 sf  ﬁgs: %'¥§EE 

'*::§ié:;;g323:.%:s::'§2§::*§ 'fraém iéiszir E3<>'E.§_C§-E E%§iTa:'§i<'}:":  E:i:'r,€}{} ;;.mM :32:

 



C€!wAs.F=ée.S3G~G7 :3: 8:'sS'G§'.doc:

:31:

'24) €'};":@.- .a1.r:01;.h&:" Ci:'::ums1;a:':C<~3 p:5>im_e'3:im:}'L:t "t::;.«= {he
§ea.rr:e{§ S*f;',I3.iOI' C-:3LmS<;%} ,-E2': i".§;'}.§E%3 ragezzfd is th£:?,= ~"'safhé§e?
e1."n:%<:n"$ing O1": E:s<:.PE; v;17.2:§: regzird is 
cast; P\?E!W.2I% hzag Eﬁft the s;tat.i{m 
fmrnber b§a_nE<;, This 
c:s:>L,:.réS€-E izzdécaéieg t':.hai   
manipuéaie the 'things;  21$    are-
Saiisfied. that the ci:'C%:§§2é._sta_§§.é;:§§ j':/~§;,:Qé3(,§ E1§Z)'{:v}V"',.'A{§%V;~,%.7('3=Li3d be
sz;g.fff£<:i::m: $0 §'1«:>I<;§  that  }L§':g;§.Vé::v§3e§'e*.rvv;:'"§§';%_.é§X;3i.2iir:€c§ deéay
in FER !'€'aC§1§H2'.':{{g4  an actcxyurzt of

'i;§'1i::a, 1T.'E'; _r53.eV*:.is';§:.i:";3.ab'E.sA:~ 'tr_}°'§3z:;_.'f::*:".' that EZZXPQ "has; mm Cf}I"§'1€f

ims <:§<:is::2.1fz£@ ab iti;s?. p:.2i:=;_;v€}:'t€d iéms ezné f}.'§€:'§"€f€}}"Ff ii ésg

ante' 

(3

 ».?%3_Vi.':..<}ii.c:'-xi. saazpraﬁ P1353.  43 8 :35 ES ware

s'i':{»;g<»9r1 £52 .'E5{> .%__*:é3' L2;*€%e:§. 1-i«'§?_"E'2f:";%$f:'£:">'* ii is :".:.=:;aa:-' 2a;<:§'E~:§:3%;"i'k':{i 2.22%:

  V'-E35; €2i£.€-;.:(":?; ef a:%£%ci$§<:m$ 'a§:..2s.*i: ':%:e €'%J'§{z€§"1€%'3 <35 §:":._;?1.':.;*ea:%i 

 vg*é'*.:3f2_s:*';:§;$€ss. carries;  w€::?.ggE:E2a;§§;c>; a-mrri i"§'IE§}{}E"1'&1§§{ié*: :1's§1{2%.§§€§

V' "':}§f:¥ gggéaimsz Esi} '§§':<: €:*s.~*i¥.:Es:r':<::;': of s«_;:.':<:§3 wi':';:2=fs:;3:;:s<;%s; 'Ear tE':<% :'€:;22:~:{;%:':_

Viézafg ?:'EE?' §}.%:'§§%§};€%.§'2=:.'{:* <5? :".r:;é,3ré<?:s:: G23. °§j:§'}ii".'§3f' _"§}éT'?&§(§'§("§E*§ §:s:,:t':~.: 9.5:.



Kg.»

CrEA$$\§G,S3C3.{3? 8,: 8<Z5.€}?.cjDi:

to
ix)

s?::;~1::i1p sf proof frsjgarcéing their pr"€:~";<3:":<:e 21': £1.63 E§C€"£"i€' sf

<}c<:'ur:*€:::cs3 and Such witrzesgas generaiiy wg32:iVE§_%._:';f1v§3?,
€:~«:<:uEpa':€ the reset} asgsailants by 
persans, §~1'0vvea;er, this pr0posif;éQn__is :i5é't'v"';2;%f:;V}{§sr§§;§Vu&¢ '
{max it is aka W€:'3H-S{*3§EE€d Eaw E133:  
minimal $019 in czimirzai   zffgcaw  are= 
simfiazg therefore, each.caseVjm;iV§":1&1a'&?.g. '§iO..b:iT:'v<?i_.€€,?iEd€§ wiéth
reference {Q the 'factS"4'2:::;ﬁ_:i  of *{E'.;a.': casé:
N€'v'€EI'§}f1EiECi'SS§  éppreciatien sf

evidance @f"'x*;%'.§£ﬁa$$eé"va;1"'i'G':;zs gatagafieg §::33»;e been

YEGW '»7'3¢'*€'?:?1§.'9'S%1:Z"é"ﬂ..VfL','§  'eaiieria {sf 5'€::§si0mS. 'Eh.e evidencss af 2:
wﬁ:*1e3S.._Acan*11:3tV"ivé--.:f'€2;§§r:*':;i%;5;'----0:':'the grmmé than hefshs is
reiazed c;ef=..ir1t€r54'ste£:§.V'é:§r""--§,nimica§, Ej¥marev<.=:;; eviéé.-":r:¢::e sf

such ,:--';--%%;n€$s}.€s has ta"-$35' S<:3.%"%,i¥ZiI1.'§.ZEd. carefuﬁy ant? {.":§GS€§j,~"

 '§:>e;f«:'isv;<°é :s;:;:cé'p%f,%:r1g iiiiém 'ac z":,:i&~m,:E p§s$éb§.§':}; -atsf {$3365

f§§T'£'?2;;_'.">_§.§:'iZ{~?5C'§'?}E."'l;.f§h;.'ﬁ'? i:€$€i§:'1m"z}~" <3? iwgrzessas wéié hazzraa is he

cs§:f;;s€i§;€::"e§£--V }§f:'{:5':1,r: the gztsixszi 0:" EYES? z;m:*i%:é::<3ss gmzi {mm

-- Ehff zi:1gi'l::~'~; aéé:{é';<} wE:§t§n.e:" it izasgéréss c<>:2f§d.e~:";€:;% 3:": tiw zmzaié

 _:§'fl t?*f:_;:% {ZV{':*m:'% {:3 e:zc::::€3pi 2iI"E€f§ $121: QEL.IE','$§§{)§"i: i:-5 :::i*é::£%é'£}§%é*§.j;¢ emcé

" _ .§Z"§V§.V'Eé;2f§§§§TEf§  2:: 1-%:'i_Ez::%:;:§ Eiai; 31$: 33:? da:;:3?€i.€r}: :.::§i§*': ;"§%f€i:"é::=§*:.<:€ '§:s:::

w*w\w_% N

€173 "
:2

\



CrivASDNO'E3ﬁ50? 8: 8£i5.U?,dO{Z

:33:

haw he E1215; {amid in the <:2":3:~;$~<3:>«:.2*::':1:'1"za'{i<::r2 and 21:39 {ha

naturs cf impressien cmatad in tile mind. »:>f t:}(2:%_:i1f_{:%:;11:'"i.

W6 {(55% it 'L:n11€<:e$sar§s [0 refer {Q \:ari:>L1_S d€;-::isi:>§3§L''~--::§It§_+;i' .

on both gides with rfeagard §:0__;:h.e };=r"7@é;:;7£-:'_':p3}?£n¢i§3i<3$KV'

;:egar&.iz1g appreciatian of evidericé.

26} Keeping in r:1ir:ci£T.: *m::v_we§1.4s:2:t'i¢d;p:§:i;ré"::é;::Eé$ 0f* 

law, we shaﬁ praceeé to QAa~:<:éj:'d;ef"--~..L:he éaséz  harxdi
Pe:"L:Sa.I cf the '_§'%,i§gE'f1€'§'I§:t,"1i}Z?_§Ef3V1:':' .:i:0'L11d indicate

that 'aha: Ee:a:'ne;j  SSE':-.€~::3;.5.:Vii's' ?I;E<§Y€E§' referring is

3 EEW.  »

the @v§dem.<;e"a;éf W'i"§r:€:sV$'3s namely? P'iF\f3.3, 4,

ané 8 1:0  €x$§1n_i:é.a:iGn--in.-chief has prgceeﬁsd
{G accep'; the£:~"§3y observing that {hare is

nothing in ""'IIf*_1§c5*'..:::<w::é;3wéxam%:1at§<m 1:0 discredéz iheér

 .':€S'i,§;'"§Ti::§.{§3fEj«,:Z __P€z°':,:'Sa§,...<.:s£'the jL1dgm=.5m uxfzéez' apgseai da 319*':

 :?:a_d§'§'::.ats3_Vthat,éhs learned -Sessieizg Juaﬁge has mazgie an}-*

{:r:=*'i€'£&?a:*'{$1-f°if5':€Ew0z;,;§ ax;-*%:e£%:er in aha Eéghz 9% ihii" variezzs

.V :irci,.i'iz:f;.s*§:vfgf;:":'€:'é}$ ané £3329:-z:>'sa'9§Eités:s bm:;gh€-{>'L2€ on zeztarcé.
   :§E:f;°€3=:f:.C€_§ thaiz §€3§§'i§fE"§€iE'"£:é' is asczzizspiaaksééz B}: E':'§€1"t;'.§j;g'
  333.23: thizfé is zézéihézzgg in tézss ::r<:s§»€:}:E:m%n::a§';Qn E5}
= .~%;§.*i-;s*;<t:':?s*:3:é%_' :%::@2I:* s;e:2;%<:'§:.e:'::;:::, ii: zézgzesg 32:2? a:a.z'3;m-'z;:;":%:'. 321:: ;:::r{>;_Qe::*

(3
Z W y,..

ﬁw



§~~

Cr€.A$.N<:>.S3(ZI,8}' 8: 845(G?.dc~c

:34:
appreciatioxz of eviiiemce. "B16 evai:,:e1i:£<m 213:3

appreéziatiezi of Evidence irzciuéw COIQ.Sid€F£i?i{3'I'.;'{3f ~i_§'§€

Stataments made bf; the witnesgea in the <;%:>e;a1r%;é19i1;21*;.5i§;nf--E~r?_..§'.
chief and the C§'OSS--€Z5§£i§i'1§I"£8.'£iO§'i asnalso r%:3'eX"z:..ri;i:'i21.tiC:;";,./if " "
anjy: E31 31% ﬁght of the answers 61J:Cii€f:i'».F;1"1~_§"€VV:C'§'TQVS:S§E

examinaiian sf 3. witnesa, t§'je"£"§ourt"i.<s :'::>:qu£Vrec§ :e}Hreicarcé. L

a ﬁnding as is; whether the__Vy'§tne'3_§3 11$ 'tf:*:.1vt_hfL; } or mat;
xafhether there am a::§5"-i:9n.;>:?r3b3.§:iu§}£t§.[€S9'<:r_ incsngruify in

accepting the _t:3sj:irr10'27*:j;%'*€i¢f 'sliith Vrw'éj:f:€ss€S. Ekiiereéy'

    

"because se'};€:"::e§ 'S _ 'r.:e'$S_5<%_$";Z7g's <:.1?1::%::*z;S agseri 9; {act that by

itssif c.:;::':_':1€3: "br3<g:*::s§.i::r:é 7::i'~vhf0}d that the said fact
a3sertr3§_  _4:h»:>é _ ﬁ.»'§}t'néss$:'s.. §SV.'.f?ue:x

11?; 'E':*:. i:_§*:3 Vcass-._§~~-ffarﬁeey Vs. State af Hargaraa

...,..,ari€35 i'a{z.§iE:$r a:;éipv<3--:'*::€ in AIR 2ﬂ§2 SQ 3$I§,~ She

  iiamrt has; <>b:$€§2:-'$6; §:E:':,::3:»--

.' 5"_%"*%T':<:: fixaeti f0rm1:E.2: C2312 be :»::.d0pte:~:cE; %:?22::.E
';:t: ',€e:s:': SGYIEE 0%" $316 accziged "}€F$i)7f".:$

. . 2
 émgaiiézsziteﬁ Eé}-" €316 a§7e--:..%;:§tr;€s$e$ §'E%°i'€€ §::é3z--3zf:

'{

..:mqu:£i,:':@cé, iherefgre, eiharg mus: gﬁsaa :25:

':3<?:{:<§s;$a>;:*:E},' :;«2c€§u§ii€§ ms?" §",E'Eé?§.'{ *:%?§r:.z§%;:32>":%r '£35? ::}::€

%'Z::<:'€:-2 &_:"::::§ <:.%:*:%;s.2"::s%:a2"z:::3:; <3?" 322.6; €;',%2-$3 ':és:,:%,, érz.



CrI,ﬁXS.N0.S3{},OT" & 84§,G?.dOC

: 36 2
£326 acczgs-vssd abused them in filing' Ear:§g'u.a§;§&% and.
thzéreafter, Accusegf N32 asssauiized ?'&:',8 with 2;
Stick at: his Egg, {En seeing théss, fairing  _
PWs_3, 4, 10 and éecsasad %§an::;;; §>pa ent::1€§<§z_.. v§r§:::i»::i§-ii 
am? dosed the éioor, whiiss PWSS,' 9::23;r;gr?§ 
ran away from the place aréﬂ  E%[;}'c3fg1SEj}.¥"s?iSE'
'@i8;C€$.z Thereafter, the gzccusgggiii  ivfznocking
at the door sf :%.:.5 E3otéy~%§:"eséV:1§%:_Z§V;1'g--ﬁfﬁgjérsans insida is
Qperz the doorflghgz  :0 the how},

Sensing da1f;g:§::,  €:«'»§§'?TE€":7V.Gf._ '%;:ﬁ'C hgﬁéi Qgcrafaeé the @001?

and atwihai_§%{né ??gccé;:$e<§ §\.fés.V='§:;' 5 alang with juizeniis
Acczzsééi N'Ci'.3, 1é:*:f€.§99es:Ev 4 {'§<;_;e "*Tr:o?I:eE and asgauited PWs,3§ =2}
anﬁ E0. }€*;»3:L tfrzai "':%:":*:;:é' E:{$énfi appa in Gféﬁf' to egcape {mm

ihﬁ cE':;:.f:ch:as ' 323%' aié-$a.£Eam;s entered {ha kitchea frag:
---.'_;3:f:s:_"'€§.;a:::=_zf' 23$ %;.*;r'::«nif:___z;»:,*:"E: thm:.,,2g§: ihs hind gigs? €31? {E26
 i«A:é'1':«,'_,E':jve:':_vb'A2<§.2V';;;i$5333: jumped Eta tha :?%:€i§g§fzb{;>':;::*§:":g {:32/r:;::;9z.;m:::§
Ai':'g%:*:§'¢dT1  Ragashakar P. Shanti, i%'§0w€*»:€z*, he
 ﬁgcczzseé ﬂag" E; Q 3:; é azfzxzi as;s:2zu;h:§:{§
' :;§:w~3:9§:tE:j§,2V"'s;:':éVihc kegs? zmaé f}"£h.€°3" pzgis Q? the  51$ 
 {$5 w§':§'€'_._ E33 ;i~§:},$ta§:2:3{§ :=;::*v:;%:s«:=% ézégtgréaég z~::1<§, {EB



CE"|.A5.N0'S3f3.G17 31 8-45,€??.C¥oz:

:37:

h<:*ari:1g the paiészta Siren, the zsccaisaeici wr:'3:r1: avsay fI'(}ff} the

'E)§8«{:€w Thié; etgwrxsistem: €3vé<;iez"1c9 0? P'\.?v'$;I§, 45 

i§':jL1.red e}~=€-w§é:r:es$€:s has beeerz acceptaci ':>}f_.~éV_1':€'

Segsiomg Judge" The: first sand 552:'-€ﬁ:i<.*;"..*':;?é_".zf1ate:*:a§
d.iSc:*€panc}=* and 1-§'1.CC¥I'ESiStEf§1C}/';":4 pf3i.':1';e&?0:;:'r' ' 

referenca 1:8 the <:or;t:sr1€§:$__"'*a:3f t.1ricV ::0_ﬁi}:9£2:;§;*1'*;--.....:>:.P6.=L

Accaréing {£3 Ehﬁ corgﬁerats  §%f§2--éi{1.  these
wi'mes$es were sippi.r: gjA:'»«§f»_:h€ hazel? the
accused pe:"so:'14S 'Ca_:r:1e:"   weaperzs
and fémé:    P\?'v'..4 wen: is
the :*es :;:'u?r3  assaulted 'zhsreafteay,
PWS.   and thereafter, the

accused xv'<.-3331?: aé;-é;-Faf;?.A:";Q.f::. {he place After SGITEEL' time

paiécsf 'Cfiﬂiﬁ éfi:-e:*Ve"3'3:1cEV'sh2§fted ihe §.:f:;?'ured persmzg :0 the

"=:<ms;:s:{a:;;--. '"§"E*';;,:.S, a%il<iib?:*{§§':':g to the cozrztenis :3? £<3mpEsjnt--

V'=E2:a: _ "£.::3¥:i_gg5é:~r§ ::*; the €a3'Ei.e$1: poénﬁ GE ﬁE"E'E{3, the aC%:'2.;:a.E

'i§'1éiﬁi.Q3.'f3i'§i efufg/s§£2a'u.E€ <:>€cL::"°r'€CE ix: {ram of the: Eiatsiiasé. Dsiux.

R€*a.a5§:§,:1g..__"é'§-."E§:«:.?€?> €33 53$}? §:1;.€§é$ate 21$; :0 'azshmher 3.1%;

h"--.é%:$§§E€:%':E:=~--e:§f zaségzzuﬁé: :;z:t::L2:"§:'e<:3 ir::«;%{,§§;% *g.h€ haéesi 2}? in {ha

'  V e':"'§}:T'%_'_%;_§__',3'*(.'}'§..EE'}€f§ sf E3'?-.?. §.£§--~E}z: §'~€.<ié.;E;3:.;<sE2&:§<:.;:f:° P. {}E:2m*:'é.;  ::;;v{3iis:€%:":

 





CrE.AsJ'x%<3.E3G,D? 8: Sé%5.G?,d0z:

14$:

0*: occurrence as stated in §:~:,PE> nameigg the p1,:.bh<:: raarzi
in fmrzt 0'? Hateé Delux was Shified is inside {E19 hate}

and {maids tha cemgszmﬁ of PWCEB, duzéng the {"3'x-i§~;§.if:§'1.C€

before the Cmgrt. 'E'hF:s czamaat be égnared a§_'4::» "t:éfi§1'<;Ar

i:":c0r:sis:er1c}r as wughi :0 'me cezztended 1:1j;"'-1:V§:€~ '§<<»%5L:1*:*;e:r_?{ V'

Additionaé SPF',

20) N6 dﬁtibf, EH6 C0:mp1ai:i:i.. iﬁnot a»'.:s'=A:Abe;ian--:£a1iéB.

pieca Of evééezlcié. §'*Jev:3r€1*:éix:iS's39 it  cra:*i= '§3€ ';s.,:sed to
correbaraie the sage va.é;_f"Vi:£';e ' f}I"¢':S{':3?.§.§_EV1::i€§Zf"§ GE' ':6 éantradict
the maker Gf {he si:a:t€nj:¢:'1tV'£3§%Vi;?:erdéf:::;¢€:. At am: rate,

{:<;:»:"r.:pie{:é.m: §ss5.*_the:"i, fQ:.:'.m_Ciati0n far the C8138 cf the
§:1"®s€cu€;io§:., if;ti*1§'s T:::3.;é§€.,.'1:--§.*ie materiai witzxessw {hiring

their €'<£2'§.€ :£"Zi.C{~3' b<3.fo:~'.s3 "the ceuzi bekéw have given a

 <:<:>z1*?;§:a}{-:'¥;€~ gs V-33;} ihf: Casa as S8? 922% in '{§'1€ sampiaént

iaiigeaﬁ '=;Z*.;é'~sifa.r§i€SE gain? :3? tima This} in aw: v1§€2>a;, is; 3;

':2%:a.:e:f%;2:§ :'::g§:1%ff:'2:7:.s;§§<:'é:ic2r:*: v;="Er:£<;§*: has affeéfiaﬁ 13123» case of £235

p:°€,%,$<V5c2,::%k;:'§1r1'1._ is 9a gféaiﬁf extent" Assunzixig fez" the:

 _"§u::""_;3<>:<5é'«.:}:7 arg;1:m<m.%'; rhea? f:Z':%$ is a z":r.:é2i:.€;:" {:€:*Cu.msta.23::€
..f'«>;a%§%Lii."«.2'i§${> E33; §~;f:E:'i,3"."§E§.§§ ::€z°1:aén marggizia {<33 *£:.§2<: amzirztztig {>5 *i;'h.é:

 éi:='2:é*1§i2E.;>s.:é*:?:?., :23   SE12?-3 ;:;:f§:3{é:,%s':::i§1 :19 <::{:§"1:~.;é:§$*:*  is

3!



My





C.?'l,iX5.N0.S3G.07' Si 84§'G7.dDC

: Q2 :
whe§h.er ihfg' evicisnce {if this ma_':€r17.a£ wit2'1€32;e:a. etcézﬁd be

aceepted.

21} As: F1€}1ZiC€*d sazpras accardéng £0 €h€:;"1é'vidf¢-:§.c€;:..v01:7%

P1}? 33, 4 and 8 is E2 whgzx Sway were ;<:=,;11:)}p',£-:<:gf'£si:.2%;'~.:i:3<":«§ro§"£::*V.

Q? Deiuxe E-Iryteh 21.21 {E16 e:':€<:used=.A_<:am«.=g :"[§'1'*Z--"'*,}f;i'-..£§L}'§'l"51.'€.4§i_'V';*ifE}'1

waagans and when Accused" '3_.S$au§téti'._?.W#8_}wi:§?. *

haciiajy sticks? ssnﬁing <fi2:r1ger4L»E?3Wss~.V_3, fsizidvftiséceaséé
Hermappa enterad §h1e. :hQti§§  the dsar from

inside. ﬁesnzexfar, aCC.'.§'S€d;:"§:f;J'.ﬂf";1'€é;§$fi§§f1!g the owner 0f

the hotel by  ﬁif::-->_  tbs E&:.0€eim§"f the 6001* was met

Qgeztesi, g<1»i;"'»..;wh§: d6§Qr'.:1%p.ﬁ%:.;eé,-- 'E'hereaf1';<~3r, A{:<:z,:Sed No.3

rw, :,,.'v-».'§':'" 5

{juvenile Q%"'endw:.r};- j%£':é&.§_$€r;§" Nasﬁ an& E3  entry mm

tha ??2:,>~€$E a.s"%'r:Vf.%d"*-:,a;?§{§f: ' swarsi, émn red anti hackﬁjg -Sticks

' '«.a:::§§. i:§a:;g:;L:§9~.:E"1€ hC»%'€'§;"*ih€§.=" asgauléaé PEﬁ53~3,=i§ and M}. £2:
'%;':;2é;'t..Vii:'::1€,. £i+§i4::e:%a_:e.ed .E%i@irmappa €SC£':%.§€€§ {mm iE*:(:e hiné

%,i::%3r_««:}§." 'égiiéhazg and jumped §_r"1<> the €{}r:2p<>:,:":":a' ef

F*W'¥'«E3 V. "2m.:"§f 9;: that {imam 'EEK: Said 'i*i<:s:1.:<1appa wag

 -».a=:%s3a2z:§§.§_rf% $3}; ;'%c.cL2&;:%£§ ?'~Ea:2:=~:.E; :2? 223:2? $3; '?E2:.,:s;§ 

» '*;%{s:V2é-'iAs;:';:2r':%; E:';8.}" :2"? ?;he zzzateréazé :2;ii;z3i%§;$:?::;  §§2a.%

 

f{:=é2;~3{=,{f:. §F§<:=§m3p§;z?»: ﬁ:<--::i:g:;g:z:::£§. E;.%"':r<>::_;~§;"%: éjhs hé:::€§ ::.§<:é:};" {sf

 



Cr§.A3.?'~3C».S30.87 8; 84S.O?.d<3C

:43:

the kitcherl am? jumped into Eihé? compgund G"? P"\?n:'"~£3. E3:

is the Cam 3? tbs: gmgecutiarz that dmrzfagf imsesgégafgifan,

U"1t':" PVQB autheriiiss wem requested. is végit :Eiié'«:§¢~:3:_*éé :_r3f' 

»:3C<:z;§1.':"'e:n<:€ and pre;3a.z:*e a sketch af S€)€1"1€*v'3:*f:.§'€f,C'i;EE%E"€?T}i;'.§f'; 

Accordingijg, PW-- 5 E1CC{)TI1p&if}§€£§=.__7i)}":-A8 A. §Pcé:}iC€  V'€-3§3'1*:£s§.%E;_a'a;1«:*A

went ':9 this scene of OCCLIE'§'€;f':C§": {:z1"éL§9'§'{i9»2éIJ{)%§ ~?;I;}c§ ,;:":f[:«:?:»1? 

énspsctirzg the spat? he {}2i€."%;:§:'%'E€'%%;§i .215 pa?
EXPAY. ?W--5 in: his   {ha war: has
asserted tfzege fe:<::s,  V$£%Lf'{_$é igﬁfﬁagégericai wwais
{hat the   ,ff~;§§_}e"'ﬁ:1& carrect. Tbs
p:"€3$e{:'L:;iiQ:3:    éither in tbs: <;w*id€r2ce

ef ?W'§}§3 gr'w£ﬁ?:2f-:}.?i::a_4CQ§91':.s:nts 0%' EX,P.'?'. Pemgai {sf
EXQPJ?" ir::'};i:";21::i*93»._£:§iz.--é.i _ﬁ§:«::"'§{ié{:}1er2 Gf Seiaggxa Hc2t«:3:'; &Ge§:

mg'; E333-re a fag? :f§Q:;:".A'-._1ﬁ;{:&:0:"<,'iér1g E0 tbs Sketch at EX.Pf?,

 %;'%1em~:5;;§s ﬁn};-Y a::%E"d;.,§_§;:1 to {ha kéichaza *sx:h.§.::h is érzsgéée the
Ezaigégi. "'§i"';:é4?€«.._vé$ my ejxéi; £081' EQ £126 kiiciﬁsza if the
-f§E:7§_'§éi'§§,_S' {};f  5sf§{a%:<:h Ex.P,'?' is accegtedﬁ the €$£e:%e:'s{:€ af

?*EE:-*'g¥;§3  ézzzaté E2 ihzst d_e<:€as:3=:§_ ﬁesziappa aegeapeé

  EEEEGI' <3?  §~{i§".€§'1.€:*'f':  highéﬁg i:'z:g}r{}E:;2%..E}§:3, E5

.""



CrEK£as.£x§c:z.53O.D?' 8: 84S.G"?.dac

:44:

thsm was :10 exit 6.00? at; 3315 quesiian of H.c::1.':":appa

eacaping {mm {hat dam dig? rm»: arise.
22} Sri. Aﬁﬁaiii, iearnecé Add}, SPF} with regard

' 1/

1'0 thia defect; in Ex.P."'?, gubmitg thai ii o§1§:,: 'T»~"if;ié5.:1g

defectiw' imsasiigatiarrz, in the Eight of 

Subsiantive evidence of materiai.'A§§i€nes;$é's----fﬁafénet £126

/E

rejected Csr ignareé. §\r'1.€1"@§;3-* because :?';i;'*"s.3»,._ :--~:~ _é¥3::1 {i : E~.§{,:F":"£.€._,3

12 have Corgsisientiy $iat:¥vd."'-~.§ha:"'v.?§'onna§§§jAg'»..a5::§£2:§péd--. 

thmugh the hind deg: 0f ti':_¢ %;if;<;§:1_fsr:, su§;h giiaiement

cannet be accepted e:*eéﬁ_~V"if.s5--x;c§;3{ ;ex,5*§~:§t:;i>§'<,-5: iS Shown to be

Eréighiy :v§.m:g?.a'bfaEi:l2=:_.".7§7'\;?..%'{E§...f£s.ax: Engineer who v§.si2'.'€:d tbs:

hetei aE ;:Ef:e* 1'°€<:§L.1Véi~3':?£  <': f'%.ff%.é«.E~:*1vestiga:i:1g Gfficer ané after

i§1_spé:c_%:ing 333.16"3_Q'E§,Ea}§fC§€i:S '€h€E"€, E35 prepazed {he sketch.

 '§7h.e..«.i:3:v§§;€::n<:e iii. Cgmprise 9? igx-we parts :1ame1_'§;"
§*;e*.;ai?*%:a:,?' an_é'«§he primary' évééence. Ceriain facts: Shawn

AL-3:25?» $33/.%;€:.{§" 'based, en the infarmaiiatss given by

'ah:"?:3if§<:{é' ff{j::§r:s%abi€ "»fé?§'1ﬁ acczsmpazziéecé him 'magmas

j 1§':€fc'1.3f':€%f«I?§a';";,.'Vé":$ E,~';CLECE'T:§ ma: '§}EiE."'3_' <22?" {hes €:'3'?;{§$1f'E{?€3 3:26; tbs:

~_ €i{I*§7E--§,€3E}i«E§: cs?  a:;:z.1::m%: E255; raéiﬁaé 222;}-aim zmzi $353.2; Er; Em





CrE.A$,N::».S3D:G? & 845.G7.dOC

:45:

§°€j€?Cf.€d. E-E.@weve:°, {E18 C€}3"1{€:'*I}?IS Qf 'E>=e:jP.'? as; ta She faci.
which PW»»5 saw at 11% 3330: becomes pyimasy awédence

and ii: Camno: be rejectétd mereiy an thﬁ' gmumi :h_.>;2fI_;_ the

mater§;a.§ \ari.':r:es;<s§rS have Said. that Hrzmzsiappa '4--f;ffVf;>'{'.:5c:'z11'§4'vV€':"ﬁ
thraugh the hind door. P'J\:'¥5 bag 1323 teas;-ﬁzfi %::s:._f'it:w§:3f:°_{ 

faisehoad. if accoréing ':6 the gpfi*?o'Js:::r:jz,1':§:::~:j:.,_ i3'§EJ--V5' hs{&:¢

€i.i:h.er deliberately omitteé 12;} meé:I;i{§':j :he Efgir:'€3, '=:i£5:3.f--~é h'~.

the kitchen whiie §r€paring""§§'€~, s§<:e"t<:--h   shy aV

miﬁtaks he has d0r18:'°::*.Q, itsi>§4a'a. 'f9f'-.:hr3 p'1;'léAS€VEC'L1t§Q:".§. :9
i'zaa-[*6 brﬁugiﬁ gut eX§1anaﬁo:r1'=%§*1?f;h_.a{i" QbaH§0a,§sEy,

ths iearned :.?L:?{)§_'%<: §E_'1"0§:3e::..rf'mE<.>1«*'~'.:_'E3§f<:>;Vif'€*: getting EXSPI?

maykeéi '£E;:"r3u5_»=;?f;V-«.?1%3r5«._é§p_pears ta hays Hat %0<;§~:'€<d inta

ﬁrm <:<}niezj:.ia:;:>if°' evidence 95 P'a¥sw3 and 4
Wm} had a1:'r:--":s.cE§; gE._v6s:f: éﬁésmce by ézbaé zziazax in $139 Eight

of  éai*'.'§\ri.er:<:;<':-" :--;~3 an& 4, if; wag £>bE1?.ga.':<>:jg«~* am i.:%:&

 3%.' ":%';§1s;3_%'f§;«x;f:}$e:a:':';*:i<:m ':0 haw: bmughé: east expieiraaiéen

 uif acwrdirzg €23 ':h€ p'é"GS€€2L§."E§€}"EL tbs

€:,1'.;rié':'2<:e :}fL:.éf7*%?g.?--;"§ in reE3:f:£.e:3n in 2115: cor:tei§":is3 «:22? ZE,:>e;A?f.?' 'éﬂ-'€i$
ﬁe£«2'i4ﬂ;,:i:=§:?;i:a6?"ii{} tile éjziséi 05 {he '§}"fG§§i3'CLE'Ei{}i'E, ii {:§'::§Zn'§. 'iii:

  §"§§,%§-'ﬁ' é':r':'s.:;é;%;;§:<:§ ?2F».f--E':3 2:3 'n{:&:At.:§Es:3. {E32 {E2255 :::$'§2.e§* hazzsiti, it :3

§



Ll §=:"\'l3.§\iU..)_)\J.Uz' CA E.)"*?.J,U

:46:
asaertsd by time pms;€c2_,1¥::'_0:§ ¥:hr<>L:gh PREV-'--? that the
cerztems of E>;.P."2' are tmze zmd cazrect, Theirs £3
23{i3301'%,z"§[€§j»;' :10 Ciycumsiance to doubt the <:Qr:*:.<3*inj: S Csf

E§e:.P.?' in this regarzig it was 'tbs SLibT§1iSSi8£E 

Patié that Sines ihe eviderzce sf {he maieriéj' 2%.ré§é"iéS;3.éS "

abaut the exisience of hind d0<3:'~é?i "%:h::": 3_~:it{:.h:é::<_n]_'%i:}21s5ﬂr1b€

been Chaﬂerigsd 9:" <:s:>1':1:1f::we1'*'faec§--._A'ir1 .'{3f1©§f'.§;.1£:GS;S'¢._

examinaiéan by the &€fez1ce,"v..gf?£;Vse:1<:éV:3f' SAuV%:h'V"-.r»3{?;io§r in'

EXP? C3.E1Z10{ ba 9; g::E'qunci.AV'*{'o'AV§d7'31ibf£ the""i:€:§€:§"n1Gny 0f
{begs wiinesgeg, 'Ne ﬁné'14$7f£j:"<:;:'~ifé:,§'§*:3;3 subzznissieng

whﬁa the pre;sx3'€:'§,:'i%Qn§;its?e1f'1E':-a§;=§:r2é=Qd:L;::ed 3. subsiazitive

evidenlw £32.. tfézz-"_f--3_:'::<t sf, "E$v:s.<:_,§73'?I; showérzg exisiemca (sf arzijg
0115 diyoijtzj the,fi§é.:e::'L':V€~21""i::v:Side the E/:e:':eE, ihﬁfﬁ wes_s 130

GC{:aS§O3T} {:53 *?{:%*:;_¢ £:':,€f€',r:€:::'::~'1':';e €mss~exam:%r::e aha wéizzesaeg
in 'zéfzgfai :;egar:%...V_ 3%: £3 22380 gssrzineant is EEOEE' 'shear, :h<:»'azgh

"%;I%:s,{;* VL:§}r€;;;-"§€:ci:&:é¢;>a:1 has sxaminéd ﬁxe (223215? 3?' gaici 'srzmai aia

  the :;u_1g:s§h's::*:=: in the hoiei z-33 §9""*E£.EE§?

zfzésﬁéééngg é:~:i'§2f;_E§éét£:5E {mm mam abzmt ﬁns sxéséerzee eff h2f.:'}z.:§

Q ::§:.3::a::' ':9 E<':'.':{th@§:";* 'E'h&rs3f::w:s:3 Eéqcre  as $33392': its ?€_§€<:§

 '%Z:2;,§_3='?f'I ""??é:;s35 '€%:§>: :*.:}m'::5:2":§.:; :5?" E;>e;...§};?' %r::g::"<§'::szrs,'§3éEé2ae::: me:

 

8' -UUL



j gear §E§"%§,i;§:.'V§«ET{}f'§: {}"L;E'i€:§i§.€-T'. Er; thég €€i§_f§a:"{E, $39: :%:>::%;:%;§:$ <>

C{"'.,5lxS(E'~§O.53O.G:'7 8: 845.0?,dC:C

:48:

cism and gazmpirzg into the <:<>mpr:>Lmd {:25 §3V€--§3, if €")}'Ef;"f
visuaiizxzee the scene of accurrence with the heip of skate}:

§:<:.P/3?' anti also {he phoiggraphs ax-"éiiiabla on :'e::0rd_.__ it 11%

ciear {hat pi:::'&;Gn$ stémdéng in front 0f {he h0':*€:"E'

{aegis {Qxvasﬁs Earth WEE 110%: be able H} see a::j§*é:[email protected]¢€;-éziinig 

Gut ¥:hr<3L1gh the hind cioer Of the---§{i1;<:§"1é--:1"2  si:::j:§:=s;;:i"a:i.th'¢

:30u':E1wwe$t@rr1 earner Gf the h9:e§'an'c§ §':_2mp'mg~ .si>r; 

f":,:r\:  :_:;,%:',.,_ %gj;,;{\} «K-X'  ;

ﬁgwww

compoL:nc:E.:$&3c, Therefaré,'-v.7;:§f'*~.is  ':5

balieve thaé: Accused }"E€;s. 1., '.3"':{:L°§/{ii €3'<§:o'uEé 'r'us%1V mwarﬁs

E~£@?1z*:,.appa. fmside ihe é9#r;:pc--3u;ui::£ :r§§_._3 and a.s3aL21'é:

be G'u'§.é; ide'na1??mé:E:3;"??'%?€s;'1"iE and E2 Eaaws not sstaéed in
their evideﬁcée t§:aiq:~:r;§'%¢1»;S4€{i Nosxig 2 and é en seﬁziriag

§~§§n:1:1§}pajii;::p£§:_g 9:}: 35 ms csmpgund ef PWJ3 rzished

' '~.:a:a=végf;§.g_..L}3§.:<:1 2:n{§'2;;3--s:1z;Eied Exirn P"*J%x's~§_1_ and 32 have

151i}: .aAS«--._:s Whether §"E.,:m§i;:::g sf Eésnnappa 1'i::.'i{.a Zhii'

'm:::;;sg.r:%a§.';;§*--.P%:?an:3 was vésiws {mm <:»ué:;:aéd6 zmd '%:%':.+£3

F':

:E:3"eje  a3$a§§i:e::€:s 1121:3633' ﬁatﬁzzgegé ?x?<>s:,"£., i and. £3 ccsuid

.5"
E

  E2/'§:§2:7r:.22:T2:2'2/,1" EZX;.P3i2;E  é%'.':§§.~§%_§fEE'§ti'f$  7éz::':§;s<f;z*i...:>%.:m':z;é.,

 W
$f§Sg;~W"""°"

\


/1



CrI.A$.N:§:§3E}.G? 8a 84S,{§?.d::}<:

: 49 :
A rssadéng 0? Ehé' Csniéimts {if E3:<.P.,212 incéicateg iheit a': the
time af ézhss Spot Mahazar, the Em-*es':é.gat'ing ff)ffi.cer
naticed Mood ;E§{€3;ii'1$ on the tar maci in fmm: $35 

Hem} as 3 désftancié of 12 it {mm the Eéatei

bieaé ségams also an the Vs-"€SE€E'ZE W33} Gf ?:§":€:"« f*:03i§;?.§;.:.V 'ft" 

not Clear as is whézihez" the i?3%3'[{§E)VC{'-'--.3'i"."6';3.-.E'E$i.;<'¥?'~%§"£7°{;?VfG"Ei'I'1{L§

inséée Q1' azgtgide {ha wail" ET\}eve§*:i<2._é1j::&_s5:§ th ij  §j0v:*s£é;':.f:'$~.,@'f

EZx.P.22 éoes :13': indicate a:'a§9""%E31§aé'=g¥:ai:j:':3 §':::s; §€%.e the V

Qsmpound of P\?s.?¥13v . §t.__i$ th'é"':Ci'5§i:1%££.._sa3' 0f"iih'é m.a_i:ez*§;e.§
witrmgseg that Eannappa Vxa.2'?is"'s;¥ev,.3_fie;A§j.Vaf;:sa'u§t£2=d i_:';$i<:E€

'aha c0m§01;n§;'é§ E5'¥V~:§:3.g -VH3 serious bleeding

:Znju:?1§[email protected]:'~;§i ixideéi-»§éE§. 4é'£.%_ éi"sz€' Sggaumcé them. P'a}\/'-13 in his

€'s:i.d.$n::$ E133 _S?.Vé;t€:C'L   he did 21:}: YEQEECS thga biaod

 staérég rlréiséde :h'€-Vcgggjxpcunéﬁ if reaiijg éeceased ﬁomnappa

 Ef.':_a:.lC':..bev%:V:§~a;~:$'a2;§.t@é inside ihe campaund 0:" ?\§v'»»13 and

iﬁﬁ 5:Eao::E;  §5%;:f¥5:VVé:h€ izijagrias had. faiien on $313 g:"<:2u_:z@, Ehs:

 E:n%..?®$i§g'3.§img iéffieﬁé" Qauicé :23': haw: Qrrziziﬁé €63 méseiziéam
v~.} '-;?1é":~:ai& fact in .E;s;.?.2:2 aznﬁ ha augfnz Us 7r":av€ cgééeczeaé

" 'aim §::=§<}{:::;% saiairzssé mm? fmrgrgz ihaé fpE'a..<:<?. E: 11$ zzm the $23};

$2 E3i§if~»;?;4§ aa.»"%m {T{)E'"'£.{§'E..'E§C'{.s*';'£f§  E§:§_}{}§', §¥Ei2%.§":;£2.:r;:r '£32233  

N, _ 4/",
3 ;,¢,/.\«»"



 g

CrE.;i\,S(!'€0.53{}.07 & S=f%S,G7.d0£

: SC} :
tine, blaaﬁ Stamg i.f1Sid€ tha Cz3r:3}:az:>':,m:i 0f PW--1.3 Of that

he coiiected bleed stained mud {mm tha: place, Ne;

doubt, same phoiegraphg have been pm&L1+::ed  the

presecutéan as psi' E3X.P_':;2 ta 1? which d§$€i<3S€~:"-.$§§<3.;9iv:.e

$233533 whsre the blood staixxs xafem §oam.5é,.'=. ':"§e»;§%§ 

phaiagraphs are saiﬁ to haw: béjéfi '1:a§<§:§%; at  iiifnie if

the spat mahazaz; Hewever? theV'p¢%':g:}n saxiéa :§0{)'1<:n

photagragshs has mat beén 'e3:§é;:néne5d'--.§c§::€0%_e <':m:rtV

thaugh he is €'£t€& :?:"'s..V_CW:v:2§;* : N'€;:";e £3f t§'1€"ma.teriaE
urimesges cermect ihescre g§?:0't'§gfrap_E::}?;=;--,§::» :hs piacﬁ wheze

the incident sg§:§.._:{; have ;3<€§:iu§ré'é.;_'~..VB§,9:fé0okéng into these

§3h{}iOg}i7_E1P?iS3V§§§"&)""-=fg8;f}§;i'{3'_§ 'E%8.}"a8 ':0 whether béaoé was
feund if: ~.1'€§ie {:1@€;i1é3.':"1'>3...§f--{}'ﬁi.' Quad. iearneﬁ ACRE}. -SPF
  .A .V  P

*::e="hi§eV._dzaaa~*%::gV Vgxirér ":az':ié.:'1ii0z1 1:0 'aha phaiagreiphs at

  2;»_-{;0:t%.t:3*:1eEéC3;"'ét*;%:aé3.": {he saié phemgraph is in rsiatign

 %;Q. i*:§3.,e E:sE_:§ié,:Q'7..;;:'€a__i;;f;s f@':;:;:':£ is': the <:o:';::pe'u.;i:d {:25 PW~E3. By

aé;§f:?£;_.:fe%i'i« l<3_{>ié:ir':'§ énia E;<;.P.E.2 arm Can 3353 Sﬁffiﬁf iskmci

s*:aé:7_:':; izfzx 1::f*"1§%7~=pa.$&;a§$ amé aisa an €233 magi in {mm Qf %:E':€

*.;}a$$a.§;:<5:,":. _§»_§.<:=¢;%3z.-*:2:; £1: £3 ma": p<::3s"é%:;E:% is 'm':_:§ zmfz EEEE3

..f§»f:§g:éi:§:.._2%§s  rim.  E2 §'{*§£~'2'5C€E% {<3 éiéfzi-3 :::{>m§{}:§:2:§ ii}? Pi?%f7~

 ......

CrE.;1s.§xia:S3D.O? 8: 8~<'%5.07x<:£o€; 1:31:

23; Eicceydirzg ':9 the CO1"l{f3:1'£.&3 sf EXWRZQ, {Em Scene <35 3c<:'urz"€:n{:s: was the public road running east i:<>vV.2r:9,é'1;<:::.V"é:*:

f§:<3:*1"{ czf Deluxe Hate}, 'E'h'1;:S, the absence Of H in thé Cézrmpaurzd {if P'\?v"--§3 3330 beiieﬁ »§;i"--. Pws»33 4? 1: and 12 with Hazanappa inside the compQ'un_§ :3f&ViT3*'_K§'»'?'i33' 1E'v%£' thage émpmbabiﬁiiies, {hare {£3 the era} testimanj; sf wi;{Ah ;"e§§ard to £3516 assault on d.e<:€ase::é...i9j1§'§n%§.§;§;;pL;:2é"E%:§f:":V'é7§é§useé N03}: 2 ané 5. the Wiizmsssss are :20': No dcsubé, it is the éutj; ofivééze ﬁgs graﬁ: from the chaff and :0 s€pafa€V¢'E:fuihV_§":féjA;n:_'€:%j{Se'f;§;oé and ':9 accepfj f}'§€;" Em/:_t§'1. "by" :'e§e;<:%:§.::§;"'£?:é fe;Eg€3%;{:z5{§. 3*; is aim W623 seiiied Eaw 'ihai '_ msrsig' b_éc2,;:;$e3i'§2@.__:€«:s':im@1'3§; 9?' 3, wiizrzess €GIEiEE,§I3S some §'§:S€§'1{){}Gf'.'€3;V§""'§"}_E3.E basis {I36 entirﬁ sviﬁenzxs {:am.";G?; be A2'-€}§<:.1Cf$é§.é:':*::~.V nt':§i:}«§:~.;'2::'§.n<:£.;'3E'r:: cf ' §z:s,€é;zz.:<; in urge, f:z.§s;:La3 5%? amni £:>asS».', é;;:sp§ica§ie ii': §;:1.déa' §"§{}'W€'i-76?, :1': is aim"; _$€';?.§é3€§... E';§.ax.? that éf §;?3.€ i1:*';z€%: 233253 f22;§é;€§f2{>{;{§ is 3;; ' .,E:§'E"{u'f§+;€j§E"'2%;E§§fg' £3 £3 '§§22§§i}f§$§§'}§€? 3:5; Szifgésiraif Cf§4:9&S.?\§C}.33':},Q? 8: 845.07,GQC truth {mm the faistéiietzod, it is; highly haz2z1'dou$ to piaese reliarace on the f:«esti.1':r2c::»r:j.,,-* of such wimesses. E21 V:?i<--*;u%.::.g1$e on hand, having I'¢Ei'g&%I"C§ Ea {he fact {heat t?1€:_.§}é"%;y'1.'dé§:;:--c_"€ -'.~:j_)f' _ PWs«3, 4;? 13 and £2 with regard gt} :§r1:3.--';;>ri:3é:<:3':*:{f:::.:c3--?§théé bind door in the kitchen sand €i€--$€3a_$f§€Zi".VRO'15'if§3*??;§ji%';1 jumping infra {he c@mp0ur€d'«-..Qf Pi'\'}vi'--V13V was--.L assauited £3 highly §m§.rebabV1 %€";:1}1':E.._§ir:<,';é xffsgysiam 33% out 'by P\?v"--4 at the eafI§r;:${_ Ap&oL.i::jt to the manner in which the the piace ef Qccurrerzcg truth 15mm {ha fa¥se?1@Qd{ Acid}. 8?? by drawmg om' a%ten'£:z§<;a:*;«i'aL'?:?:";€: eV"'e;:*'Zc'i'?::V;f:\:é""e;.:>:.?P¥'\f--2-"3, PSE saugiﬁ E5} ztaﬁiéznsi V §.?:a:,:_§v15Va5_€nc€ é'f'PW-23 Carmberaieg $15 §£'§=-"i§€E"}.C€ sf P's}~;f$«« Tia? va';*z4V§».V1:2 zv§€:h regaré its the asssauii imside 'iize E:*i€;*.'té§._:'3ri''§'}''%%'s5--:§'s¥;';"%V':é"»;::*:{:§ 4% gang' mi: ﬂaceasésd E-E.s::z':r:a;3pzz E:'E"§S§§;€

-- {E26 <:'{;;m_*;::A;}z,§:i§d <:;>f PEPJWE3. Eixccerémg $3 ?"é.?i:'¥;2?;'.3, s;a<;en after i L::,E"1AEc':';r:.{:s:';:r: <2? wéreiegg E'{':€SE~3&§€',., E26 {3:£iE"1'.'§.€ "G651? €£hs=3 'E2<";:&*§ av: f:a§:;:{>'%.:: 5.45 p.223. 225253 *i:§1.€§":": EN: :£:'g§:2:"<3<:§, g:§m'S::;1:§ ms-3°E.{%:? %_:f<::':? .§"2.9é<:E "rm:-:i§ {E36 i:.2:~3i£§§2 iéési C-{):"'ﬂ§%ZE%.},E"E€§ GE X'VM,~.

. 'X3 1.

(_,;r§.!3'$.N<.L';3U4£3f 2&1 84b.B'?.€i{3C :53: P"x2V'-- 13 and 2"m.me<:§i2:.t€1:; he shifted {ham :0 the hcsspétai in the paiéce jeeg and p:mé1,1<:ed ihem befrjmz the ducmr. Whahez" this evécience sf PW--2f3 is refiablg. '}'§1<>;:g_Ir-ia___P"§7~f'm 123 states that he received 2: safireiegg rrzssgagsi 5.30 pm: abeut gaiaia tal<;ri.ng piaczzs in V' i: is Bi)? ihe 33;}? sf PWQ3 thafi' Station {ha Hausa Dairy {SHD}:»A:§;1 Qb1%gat0:'j§.r an {I716 part sf "HV;3use'V Gfficer is have ma(,i~;:...V_ent;:.3;:"' a1:;@ui the information Said ':0 have.}beéx27"1'%é¢%::i§--é{}.Vbbgr him '{%:ro'ug.h Cop}; of €156. Sig/.;3 a§_;;':ag$ 'aiéc-..__::5>%' beer: producgd b€'?{3:"€ the aria} semi. "Th§S._C§'E§':Ef'i15§§if:%}fT?}C€ €38_StS éeubt a$ is axzixsther ?'s.?\f--23 had' :"*?f§C€'ﬁ_.'%.«"€€'C§; ".:«::.n§-' wireiesg mssgage 02* he §:*c»{:«:;¥--g::d€{f. 'CG t%:é"--4s<:_¢_:_j:§, {:5 0C€L;EI°I°€3f}C€ an the bagis {sf Such i.f:«fr;_f9i§3T3§:.£§:s;3i.hsugh accazﬁéng {cs PW--23, he pf£'€§d'%i{:@d €s':§:;:5r"€:é§ bsfsré E138 .5/T.E<3*d*;<:':«9j. Gffiear £1"; tbs %2é$j§§§aE,_egéégsfding is the ::@:*2*:e2=1:$ sf E><:$'P.€~§ and 95 S26 '.$2@L::r:.¢:§.. %:é.§r%:.§f%£gaé:e in 1"€S§€€:.i sf ;PE?:fs;~3 zmsj ::'me:.E ;33.§$:> 'x*.E3;{';<i'1C}-?<'ff?f};§"§":§ ta} zhe éfaféééésrzcé 5:? %%*'~%':«? §E:*.§%/§_fa:.:.n.§e:a2: i%§a}:°2%{:E §._ﬂ.3%$.l\!O.b§U.U/ E3 25453.9/.GGC : 56 : and choose' Therefore, ii is; hig§:1.i§;* Lmsafe {.0 place :'e1%.a.:1c€ er: the tegtimanjgz {sf these Witmesggesg in ad.<:%.ii;i=:m ta thig, ail 2:136 materéai i'Ji¥Z§'1€fS&32€'S airs Ciasaiy I"ff3.l'@'€€c§.

PW:-¢;--3 and 4 though have stated ab<>L3.':. the £:hems€1V€s aﬁd alga on deceaaed M mat statad azz}-*thi.:f1g; with reg2§rC§" "£0 "OHI'; deceased Homimppa, ?\?\:'s~8 Vané not stated anything abOLi'EI "t%ﬂér.}:1"1<i:atE.f:.fjr.¢':"_; $:;§V§éa§i;:1% 9n deceaseé Hannaiﬂﬁa ;>;I".'t.§ a::::;i2*:e;i.i?ij'P'»'%§;':As#';?;?A agzd 4» as accsrﬁing :0 PVVSW8 and.' ;'3,3T,"tE9:Le:;§-9:*a3f1¢ ax$a§;'=§'rom tbs place seam after PW$=,"3: '='_"%5 a5mﬁ.«:d€§iéa_jge@ Efiérznagpa e::§:emz;§ '$11.6 begs}. 2 ' 2.3} '=-- AccGfdif:g he ran 'mwards 'ifx/'as': 9:":

_ éhe >§T{§§E':;{'.i".1r,i'§ fr<§:":?_ :::sf the 11036}. ané %':u§':r1€:d 2:0 Sozztéi ané hid,§':if{3:s%:§i",' E§f§th rﬁferezzce ':0 the: $E<ez'.,cE:--.EI;:><;,P?I it is §."i.§7:';:€_?{:'z;;§"é;:;;.*iﬁ: beﬁex--*6 $13: fmm $139 93356 zvhﬁréz P'x?\:C8

--V hid 39:9 cmzéd see as ':0 whai éranspéreﬁ in {mm sf : *Eh3;é' §-':_n{§'{E'§5 "§hi3;'s2f{}:'e, 32:33; gag}-I {hat €326 2233:3366 *;%z;=.rs<:*r:§-:' * 22::{§z':'a '{§7§E"€f£%'£€'ZE§E}§; aha: ,2-§'"T{E€ff' £2? Ehe h{;'I:.{:E :13 a'pE:':'2, '$22': stiazézg u €_Ié:?;.§§E§::}?I. be z2£:<x=:§}ie{E, §.3E?:£C E ~»:::2m*:€:' <2? §:E":<»*: §:_:'>@:s:3E. ;»t:.1'":{.§ §3"zEf.

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court