Central Administrative Tribunal - Delhi
Rama Devi vs Govt. Of Nctd on 10 January, 2020
1
Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench, New Delhi
O.A. No.2866/2017
M.A.No.3765/2019
M.A. No.4127/2018
With
O.A. No.694/2019
M.A. No.1436/2019
M.A. No.2358/2019
With
O.A. No.939/2018
M.A. No.3760/2019
With
O.A. No.1759/2019
M.A. No.1923/2019
With
O.A. No.2335/2018
M.A. No.2615/2018
M.A. No.3751/2019
With
O.A. No.2789/2017
M.A.No.4118/2018
With
O.A. No.2808/2017
M.A. No.2950/2017
M.A. No.4119/2018
C.P.No.446/2018
C.P.No.645/2017
With
O.A. No.3284/2018
M.A. No.1558/2019
With
O.A. No.3298/2018
M.A. No.1571/2019
With
O.A. No.3396/2018
M.A. No.3762/2019
With
O.A. No.3461/2018
M.A. No.1566/2019
M.A. No.3757/2019
M.A. No.3873/2018
With
O.A. No.3508/2019
M.A. No.3844/2019
With
O.A. No.3792/2017
M.A. No.3753/2019
2
M.A. No.3994/2017
C.P.No.445/2018
With
O.A. No.3855/2018
M.A. No.1434/2019
With
O.A. No.4134/2017
M.A. No.3750/2019
M.A. No.4339/2017
M.A. No.4340/2017
With
O.A. No.4317/2017
M.A. No.4898/2018
With
O.A. No.4408/2018
M.A. No.3752/2019
Order reserved on 5th December, 2019
Order pronounced on 10th January, 2020
Hon'ble Mr. Justice L. Narasimha Reddy, Chairman
Hon'ble Mr. Mohd. Jamshed, Member (A)
OA No. 2866/2017
1. Rama Devi
W/o Sh. Ram Babu
R/o S-82-299A, Jagdamb Camp
Khirki Ext, Malviya Nagar,
South Delhi- 110017
Aged about 41 Years
2. Chandrapal
S/o Sh. Pyare Lal
R/o Mamura, Sector-66, Noida
Gautam Budh Nagar,
UP- 201301
Aged about 37 years
Group „C‟
(Sweeper Cum Chokidar)
.........Applicants
Versus
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
Through its Chief Secretary,
A Wing, 5th Floor, Delhi Secretariat,
I.P Estate, New Delhi
3
2. Directorate General of Health Services
(GNCT of Delhi)
Through its Director General,
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F- 17, Karkardooma, Delhi- 110032
3. Chief Medical Officer (Care Taking Branch)
Directorate General of Health Services,
(GNCT of Delhi)
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F- 17, Karkardooma, Delhi- 110032
4. The Secretary
(Health & Family Welfare)
(GNCT of Delhi)
9th Level, A-Wing, IP Estate,
Delhi Secretariat, Delhi- 110002
............Respondents
2. O.A. No. 694/2019
1. Indar
S/o Sukar Chand
R/o 488, A/2, Bhola Nath Nagar,
Gali No. 12, Shahdara, Delhi
Aged about 29 years
Sweeper-cum-chowkidar
(Group „C‟)
2. Shanti Devi
W/o Sh. Mahender Kumar Sheel
R/o 16/7, Kalyan Puri, Block-16,
Delhi- 110091
Aged about 42 years
Sweeper-cum-chowkidar
(Group „C‟)
3. Munesh Devi
W/o Sanjeev Kumar
R/o 1/4026, Street No. 4, Ram Nagar
Shahdara, Shahdara East, Delhi- 110032
Aged about 41 years
Sweeper-cum-chowkidar
(Group „C‟)
4. Narender Kumar
S/o Bhajan Lal Yadav
R/o E-73/A-565, Sanjay Colony,
4
Gokal Puri, North East Delhi-94
Aged about 21years
Sweeper-cum-chowkidar
(Group „C‟)
5. Ashu Parcha
S/o Shri Phool Kumar
R/o 120, Village Ghondli Krishna Nagar,
Delhi
Aged about 23 years
Sweeper-cum-chowkidar
(Group „C‟)
6. Geeta Rajput
W/o Late Sh. Naresh Rajput
R/o C-199, Gali No. 7, Samai Pur,
Mukundpur, Delhi- 110042
Aged about 40 years
Sweeper-cum-chowkidar
(Group „C‟)
7. Sarita
W/o Shri Jitender
R/o H.No. 4/1615 A, Mahaveer Block
Gali No. 6, Bhola Nath Nagar,
Shahdara, Delhi- 110032
Aged about 40 years
Sweeper-cum-chowkidar
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees -Sweepers-Cum-Chowkidars)
...Applicants
Versus
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
Through its Chief Secretary,
A-Wing, 5th Floor, Delhi Secretariat,
I.P. Estate, New Delhi
2. Directorate General of Health Services
(GNCT of Delhi)
Through its Director General,
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F-17, Karkardooma, Delhi - 110032
3. Chief Medical Officer (Care Taking Branch)
Directorate General of Health Services,
(GNCT of Delhi)
5
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F-17, Karkardooma, Delhi - 110032
4. The Secretary
(Health & Family Welfare),
(GNCT of Delhi),
9th Level, A-Wing, IP Estate,
Delhi Secretariat, Delhi - 110002
...Respondents
3. O.A. No. 939/2018
1. Santu Mondal, Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar,
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 23 years,
S/o Sh. Manoranjan Mondal
R/o H.No. 62R/P, Basant Nagar,
Vasant Vihar-I, New Delhi-110057
2. Ashwani Kumar, Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar,
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 23 years,
S/o Sh. Suresh Chandra,
R/o RZC-6, Gali No. 3, Dabri Palam Road,
Tamil Enclave, New Delhi-110045
3. Ajeet Kumar, Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar,
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 24 years,
S/o Sh. Matlu Das,
R/o RZC-118, Gali No. 9, Madhu Vihar,
New Delhi-110059
4. Naveen, Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar,
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 23 years,
S/o Sh. Ram Niwas,
R/o M-125, Prem Nagar-2,
Kiran Suleman Nagar, Nithari,
Sultanpuri, Delhi
5. Sagar, Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar,
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 23 years,
6
S/o Sh. Bhagwan,
R/o Kirari Suleman Nagar,
Prem Nagar-II, New Delhi
6. Priyanka Sinha, Nursing Orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Age about 27 years,
W/o Sh. Gulshan Kharbanda,
R/o 49-A, Tyagi Vihar, Nangloi,
Delhi-110041
7. Vinod Kumar, Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar,
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 35 years,
S/o Sh. Raj Kumar,
R/o D.S. 100E, D-Block, Qutab Vihar,
Phase-I, Goyla Dairy, New Delhi-110071
8. Sarita Devi, Nursing Orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 43 years,
W/o Sh. Umesh Verma,
R/o B2-V7A, Nanda Block
Mahavir Enclave, New Delhi-110045
9. Mukesh, Nursing Orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 28 years,
S/o Sh. Soraj Singh
R/o RZ-31, Gali No. 1, Durga Park,
New Delhi-110045
10. Ruma Devi, Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar,
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 35 years,
W/o Sh. Jaya Prakash
R/o RZC/7, Tamil Enclave,
Dabri Palam Road,
New Delhi-110045 ....Applicants
Versus
7
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
Through its Chief Secretary,
New Secretariat,
I.P. Estate, New Delhi
2. The Principal Secretary,
Department of Health,
Govt. of NCT Of Delhi
New Secretariat,
I.P. Estate, New Delhi
3. Directorate of Health Services
Through its Director,
Govt. of NCT of Delhi,
DGB Building, Karkardooma,
Delhi-110092
...Respondents
4. O.A. No.1759/2019
1. Suresh Kumar
S/o Shri Murari Lal
R/o Brahmpuri Gali,
6-ex, 152/40, Delhi-110053
Aged about 48 years
Sweeper-cum-chowkidar
(Group „D‟)
2. Mahesh Kumar
S/o Shri Vir Singh
R/o F-14, Gali-1, Shubhash Vihar,
Delhi-110053
Aged about 37 years
Sweeper-cum-chowkidar
(Group „D‟)
3. Deepak
S/o Shri Ramdayal
R/o W-13, Welcome Seelampur,
Delhi-110053
Aged about 30 years
Sweeper-cum-chowkidar
(Group „D‟)
4. Sandeep Kumar
S/o Shri Ramdayal
R/o W-13, Welcome Seelampur,
8
Delhi- 110053
Aged about 27 years
(Group „D‟)
(Temporary employees Sweepers-Cum-Chowkidars)
...Applicants
Versus
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
Through its Chief Secretary,
A-Wing, 5th Floor, Delhi Secretariat,
I.P. Estate, New Delhi
2. Directorate General of Health Services
(GNCT of Delhi)
Through its Director General,
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F-17, Karkardooma, Delhi - 110032
3. Chief Medical Officer (Care Taking Branch)
Directorate General of Health Services,
(GNCT of Delhi)
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F-17, Karkardooma, Delhi - 110032
4. The Secretary
(Health & Family Welfare),
(GNCT of Delhi),
9th Level, A-Wing, IP Estate,
Delhi Secretariat, Delhi - 110002
5. Chief District-Medical Officer
(North-East District)
Directorate of Health Services,
GNCT of Delhi,
A-14, G-1, DDA Flats,
Dilshad Garden, Delhi-110095
...Respondents
5. O.A. No.2335/2018
1. Arun, Nursing Orderly, Group „C‟
Aged about 31 years,
S/o Sh. Kamal Pal,
R/o H. No. 63, Type-I, PWD Flat,
Dwarka, Sec-3, New Delhi.
9
2. Anita Pal, Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar, Group „C‟
Aged about 47 Years,
W/o Sh. Kamal Pal,
R/o H. No. 63, Type- 1, PWD Flat,
Dwarka, Sec-3, New Delhi
3. Jaya Gaur, Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar, Group „C‟
Aged about 48 Years,
W/o Sh. Hoshiyare lal Gaur,
R/o H. No. D-176, Dada Dev Colony,
Sec-7, Dwarka, New Delhi
4. Sukhdev, Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar, Group „C‟
Aged about 22 Years,
S/o Sh. Om Prakash,
R/o H. No. 317, G-Block,
Dakshin Puri, Delhi
5. Roshan, Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar, Group „C‟
Aged about 25 Years,
S/o Sh. Om Prakash,
R/o H. No. 317, G-Block,
Dakshin Puri, Delhi.
6. Asha Devi, Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar, Group „C‟
Aged about 33 Years,
W/o Sh. Ramji Prajapati,
R/o H. No. 15/16, Factory Road,
Samalka Village, Delhi
7. Mahendri, Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar, Group „C‟
Aged about 52 Years,
S/o Sh. Roop Chand,
R/o H. No. 257, Shastri Market,
South Moti Bagh, Chanakya Puri,
New Delhi
....Applicants
Versus
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
Through its Chief Secretary
New Secretariat
I.P. Estate, New Delhi
2. The Principal Secretary
Department of Health,
Govt. of NCT of Delhi
New Secretariat
I.P Estate, New Delhi
10
3. Directorate of Health Services,
Through its Director,
Govt. of NCT of Delhi,
DGD Building, Karkardooma,
Delhi- 110092
...Respondents
6. O.A. No.2789/2017
1. Mamta, Nursing Orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 40 years,
W/o Sh. Ashok Kumar Sabharwal
R/o Roshan Vihar, Ph-2, Najafgarh,
New Delhi-110043
2. Sudesh Sharma, Nursing Orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 27 years,
W/o Sh. Dinesh Kumar,
R/o H.No. 65-B, Sainik Enclave,
Post-2, Jharoda Kalan,
New Delhi-110072
3. Daramveer, Nursing Orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 28 years,
S/o Late Sh. Jagdish
R/o H.No. 82, Village Munthlee Khurd,
Post of Ujwa, New Delhi-110073
4. Hitender Singh, Nursing Orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 40 years,
S/o Sh. Umed Singh,
R/o H.No. 659, Farwan Pana,
Jharoda Kalan, New Delhi-110072
5. Sandeep Kumar, Nursing Orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 39 years,
S/o Sh. Khushi Ram,
R/o H.No. 90, Farwan Pana,
11
Jharoda Kalan,
New Delhi-110072
6. Suresh Kumari, Nursing Orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 29 years,
S/o Late Sh. Rajesh Kumar,
R/o H.No. 152, Post of Ujwa,
Samay Pur Khalsa,
New Delhi-110073
7. Dinesh Kumar, Nursing Orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 32 years,
S/o Sh. Dalip Singh
R/o RZ-29, Vinoba Enclave, CRPF Colony,
Jharoda Kalan,
New Delhi-110072
8. Sharmila, Nursing Orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 32 years,
S/o Late Sh. Rajbir,
R/o Post of Ujwa, Samay Pur Khalsa,
New Delhi-110073
9. Suman, Nursing Orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 28 years,
S/o Sh. Vedpal Dabas,
R/o Village & Post Office Ujwa,
New Delhi-110073
10. Yogesh, Sweeper-cum-Chokwidar,
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 24 years,
S/o Late Sh. Purshottam Kumar,
R/o H.No. 1010,
VPO Tikari Kalan
New Delhi-110041
11. Karam Pal, Sweeper-cum-Chokwidar,
Group „D‟/D.W
12
Aged about 36 years,
S/o Sh. Ramesh Kumar,
R/o H.No. 38, Nangli Sakrawati,
New Delhi-110043
12.Soni, Sweeper-cum-chowkidar,
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 27 years,
W/o SH. Mukesh,
R/o H.No. 98 A, Bamnoli,
New Delhi-110077
13.Seema Devi, Nursing Orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 42 years,
W/o Sh. Jagat Singh,
R/o H.No. 470, Gali No. 17, Qutub Vihar,
Phase-II, Goyla Dairy,
New Delhi-110071
14.Manjeet, Nursing Orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 32 years,
S/o Late Sh. Randhir Singh,
R/o Village Bamndi, P.O Dulsaras,
New Delhi-110077
15. Deepak, Nursing Orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 22 years,
S/o Sh. Randhir Singh,
R/o H.No. RZG-3, Prem Nagar,
Najafgarh, New Delhi-110043
16.Kavita, Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 34 years,
D/o Sh. Anil Kumar,
R/o B-38, East Krishna VIhar,
Gopal Nagar, Najafgarh,
New Delhi-110043
13
17. Pawan Kumar, Sweeper-cum-chowkidar
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 38 years,
S/o Sh. Hari Ram,
R/o H.No. 481, Village Bamnoli,
P.O. Dulsaras, New Delhi-110077
18. Devki Rani, Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 35 years,
W/o Sh. Sunil Kumar,
R/o Jauhari Nagar, Line Par,
H.No. 33/6, Bahadurgarh,
Haryana
....Applicants
Versus
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
Through its Chief Secretary,
New Secretariat,
I.P. Estate, New Delhi
2. The Principal Secretary,
Department of Health,
Govt. of NCT of Delhi
New Secretariat,
I.P. Estate, New Delhi
3. Directorate of Health Services
Through its Director,
Govt. of NCT of Delhi ,
DGB Building, Karkardooma, Delhi-110092
...Respondents
7. O.A. No. 2808/2017
1. Sushil Kumar
S/o Sh. Hari Krishan
R/o 6671, Nabi Karim Pahar Ganj,
New Delhi - 110055
Aged about 32 years
14
2. Sunny
S/o Sh. Vijay Kumar
R/o H. No. - 7028, Qila Kadam,
Sharif Nabi Karim, Pahar Ganj,
Swami Ram, Tirth Nagar, Delhi
Aged about 31 years
3. Nand Kishore
S/o Sh. Nathu Ram
R/o N- 67/103 Amba Bagh, Kishan Ganj,
Chunna Bhatti, Delhi -110007
Aged about 34 years
4. Indu Parkash
S/o Sh. Ved Parkash
R/o H. No. - 54/4490, Regar Pura,
Karol Bagh, New Delhi
Aged about 32 years
5. Bunty
S/o Sh. Kartar Singh
R/o 10861, Gali Church Wali,
Jhandewalan Road, Delhi - 110055
Aged about 22 years
6. Sanjana
W/o Sh. Anil Kumar
R/o Motiya Khan, Sawan Wali Gali, H. No - 11155
Sadar Thana, Pahar Ganj, Delhi - 110055
Aged about 34 years
7. Ashish
S/o Sh. Sardari Lal
R/o 7028 Valmiki Mandir, Shanker Marg,
Pahar Ganj, New Delhi - 110055
Aged about 23 years
8. Mohit Chauhan
S/o Late Sh. Hari Kishan
R/o 4076, Gali Ahiran Pahari Dhiraj,
Sadar Bazaar, Delhi - 110006
Aged about 22 years
15
9. Rahul
S/o Sh. Om Parkash
R/o 3926, Gali Mandir Wali, Pahari Dhiraj,
Sadar Bazar, Delhi - 110006
Aged about 21 years
10. Deepak Manjhi
S/o Late Sh. Hari Charan Manjhi
R/o H. No. 361 Type - 1 Gulabi Bagh, Delhi - 110007
Aged about 23 years
11. Arun
S/o Sh. Sunder Singh
R/o N- 74/62 Transport Line J. J. Kalaster Bulwar Road,
H.P. Petrol Pump, Delhi - 110054
Aged about 34 years
12. Dinesh Kumar
S/o Sh. Tilak Raj
R/o H. No - 412, Near Ambedkar Park, Delhi - 110036
Aged about 27 years
13. Rakhi
W/o Sh. Shyam Lal
R/o H. No - 712, Near Ambedkar Park, Delhi - 110036
Aged about 24 years
14. Jasbir Singh
S/o Sh. Nand Kishor
R/o H. No. - 31 Bhor Ghar, Jatav Chaupal,
Narela, North West Delhi- 110040
Aged about 30 years
15. Ravi
S/o Sh. Garib Dass
R/o EE 2211,Jahangir Puri, Delhi 110033
Aged about 32 years
16. Manoj Kumar
S/o Sh. Murari Lal
R/o Block No- EE, H. No - 2220,
Jahangir Puri, Delhi - 110033
Aged about 39 years
16
17. Prashant Singh
S/o Sh. Bhagwan Singh
R/o D- 51 J.J Camp Tigri, Delhi 110062
Aged about 25 years
18. Karam Singh
S/o Late Sh. Charan Singh
R/o A/195 B-A Bilaspur Camp Molar Band,
Badarpur, Jaitpur South Delhi - 110044
Aged about 47 years
19. Vikesh Kumar
S/o Sh. Chander Deep Singh
R/o H.No 1188, Rajeev Nagar Sec- 31,
Faridabad, (Haryana) Pin: 121003
Aged about 29 years
20. Mukesh
S/o Sh. Ram Dhan
R/o C-503, Tazpur Pahari Puran Camp,
Badarpur - 110044 Delhi
Aged about 29 years
21. Mukesh
S/o Sh. Murari Lal
R/o H. No - C-36 Gali No. H, Chauhan Colony,
Palla No - 1, Amar Nagar, Faridabad
Aged about 34 years
22. Dharmender
S/o Sh. Babu Lal
R/o G-T261, Sangam Vihar, New Delhi - 110080
Aged about 38 years
23. Arvind
S/o Sh. Bhanvar Kumar
R/o C-14A, Sangam Vihar, New Delhi - 110080
Aged about 21 years
24. Anita W/o Sh. Ram Prasad
R/o H. No - 17/200/26-C Sangam Vihar, Dr. Ambedkar
Nagar, N. D - 62 South Delhi
Aged about 37 years
17
25. Anil Kumar
S/o Sh. Braham Singh
R/o H. No - 406, Village and Post Office Mukhmel Pur,
Delhi - 110036
Aged about 39 years
26. Rohit Kumar
S/o Lt. Sh. Jagdish Prasad
R/o D - 461 Jahangir Puri Delhi - 110033
Aged about 30 years
27. Mala Devi
W/o Sh. Darshan Lal
R/o J-1, 617/17, G. No - 17, Sani Mandir,
Sangam Vihar, Pushpa Bhawan, S.O,
South Delhi - 110062
Aged about 42 years
28. Vikas
S/o Late Sh. Ashok Kumar
R/o H. No. 3223, Gali No. 83, Sant Nagar,
Main Market, Burari, Delhi - 110084
Aged about 30 years
29. Urmila
W/o Sh. Ram Lal
R/o H. No. B - 1209, Metro Vihar, FF II,
Holambi Kalan, Delhi - 110082
Aged about 38 years
30. Sunita
W/o Sh. Dharmender
R/o Sangam Vihar, H - Block, H. No. 398,
Gali No. 17, Mehrouli, South Delhi - 110062
Aged about 29 years
31. Ram Lal
S/o Sh. Mohan Lal
R/o H. No. B - 1209, Metro Vihar, F II,
Holambi Kalan, Delhi - 110082
Aged about 43 years
18
32. Jyoti
W/o Sh. Ravinder
R/o H. No. 6671, Nabi Karim,
Near Neemwala, Pahar Ganj, Delhi
Aged about 31 years
33. Sunny
S/o Late Sh. Kartar Singh
R/o 10861, Jhandewalan Road, Ram Nagar,
Pahar Ganj, New Delhi - 110055
Aged about 26 years
34. Ashish
S/o Sh. Kamal Singh
R/o 1897, Gali Ahiran, Malka Ganj,
New Delhi - 110007
Aged about 23 years
35. Rohit
S/o Sh. Naresh
R/o 6234, Gali Gurudwara Wali, Nasi Karim,
Pahar Ganj, New Delhi - 110055
Aged about 27 years
36. Mayank Chauhan
S/o Late Sh. Hari Kishan
R/o 4076, Gali Ahiran, Pahari Dhiraj,
Sadar Bazar, Delhi - 110006
Aged about 24 years
37. Yogesh Kumar
S/o Sh. Prakash
R/o 77C 45/1, Mukesh Nagar, Shamdara,
Delhi - 110032
Aged about 35 years
38. Kuldeep
S/o Sh. Suraj Mal
R/o H. No - 1108, Pana Barshan,
V.P.O Tirki Kalan, Delhi - 110041
Aged about 23 years
19
39. Tapesh Kumar
S/o Sh. Raghubir Singh
R/o H. No- 65, Harewali, Delhi - 39
Aged about 26 years
40. Punit Kumar
S/o Late Sh. Hari Charan Manjhi
R/o H. No 361 Type - 1 Gulabi Bagh, Delhi - 110007
Aged about 22 years
41. Vikash Kumar
S/o Sh. Gaje Singh
R/o 77C 45/1 Gali No: 5 Mukesh Nagar,
Shadharq, East Delhi - 110032
Aged about 27 years
42. Om Prakash
S/o Sh. Hari Singh
R/o 77 C 45/1 Gali No: 5 Mukesh Nagar,
Shadharq, East Delhi - 110032
Aged about 35 years
43. Poonam Rani
W/o Sh. Dheeraj
R/o A-75, Gali No - 1, Part - 2, Pusta-1 A Block,
Soniya Vihar, North East Delhi - 110094
Aged about 44 years
44. Bijender Singh
S/o Sh. Dhram Pal
R/o Vilage Fakharpur, Distt. Baghpat,
Uttar Pradesh - 250101
Aged about 34 years
45. Neeraj Kumar
S/o SH. Mukesh Kumar
R/o H - 61/3, Gali No. 3, Jai Prakash Nagar,
West Ghonda, Delhi - 110053
Aged about 23 years
46. Honey Kanera S/o Sh. Ratan Lalkanera
R/o E 2/40, Shastri Nagar, Gali No - 1, Delhi - 110052
Aged about 26 years
20
47. Rajiv Kumar Gaur
S/o Sh. G.C. Gaur
R/o 23/2730, Beedon Pura, Karol Bagh, Delhi - 110005
Aged about 45 years
48. Anita
W/o Sh. Ajay Anand
R/o D 6/212, Jharoda Mazra, Ext - I Burari,
Delhi - 110084
Aged about 26 years
49. Seema Goswami
W/o Sh. Munesh Kumar
R/o H. No. 448, Gali No-10, Adarsh Mohalla,
Maujpur, Delhi - 110053
Aged about 36 years
50. Beena
W/o Sh. Kamal Singh
R/o B- 85, Gali No 3, Sushila Garden, Delhi - 110093
Aged about 44 years
51. Suman
D/o Sh. Tasveer
R/o H. No -1545 V.P.O Sonipat, Haryana - 131001
Aged about 32 years
52. Kapil Dev
S/o Sh. Rameshwar Dass
R/o 1451/9 Street No - 2, Shiv Colony,
Devru Road, Sonipat
Aged about 32 years
53. Anil
S/o Sh. Ram Chander
R/o H. No -222, Prajapat Chowpal Village,
Holambi Kalan, Delhi - 110082
Aged about 30 years
54. Sudhir Kumar S/o Sh. Bijender Singh
R/o H. No- 336, V.P.O, Darya Pur Kalan,
Delhi - 110039
Aged about 35 years
21
55. Devender Kumar
S/o Sh. Raj Karan
R/o 48, Poothkalan Village, Delhi - 110086
Aged about 39 years
56. Vishal Sharma
S/o Sh. Om Parkash Sharma
R/o 1124, Gali Samosan Farash Khana, Delhi - 110006
Aged about 40 years
57. Umesh Kumar
S/o Late Sh. Dharamveer Singh
R/o H. No - 67-13 G. No- 5, Kundan Nagar,
Bank Enclave, Laxmi Nagar Delhi - 110092
Aged about 29 years
58. Anju Sharma
W/o Sh. Roshan Sharma
R/o A-46 Jitar Nagar, Parvana Road Delhi - 110051
Aged about 43 years
59. Sachin
S/o Sh. Ram Prakash
R/o 135/7 Andrews Ganj, New Delhi - 110049
Aged about 30 years
60. Varun Kumar Kashyab
S/o Late Sh. Ram Chander
R/o 7/135 Andrews Ganj, New Delhi - 110049
Aged about 34 years
61. Pawan Verma
S/o Sh. Om Prakash Verma
R/o H. No - B-225/5-E St. No - 7, Ashok Nagar,
Shahdara, Delhi - 110093
Aged about 36 years
62. Akash Verma
S/o Sh. Om Prakash Verma
R/o H. No - B- 225/5-E St. No - 7, Ashok Nagar,
Shahdara, Delhi - 110093
Aged about 22 years
22
63. Ganesh Prasad
S/o Late Sh. Mohan Lal
R/o 204-Jhuggi, Near Road No - 6, Andrews Ganj
New Delhi - 110049
Aged about 28 years
64. Manoj Kumar
S/o Late Sh. Gopal
R/o D/900, J.J. Colony, Tigri, New Delhi - 110062
Aged about 30 years
65. Pansula Kumari
W/o Late Sh. Pardeep Sahani
R/o D- 17/277, Ambedkar Colony, Chatarpur,
Meharauli, South Delhi - 110074
Aged about 43 years
66. Vandana
W/o Sh. Deepak
R/o H. No - 111, Kh. No - 1151/3 Word No - 2,
Mehrauli, Delhi
Aged about 37 years
67. Bhagat Ram
S/o Sh. Kishan Dutt.
R/o 28-Aliganj Kotal, Mubarak Pur, New Delhi - 110003
Aged about 37 years
68. Rekha
W/o Sh. Parshu Ram
R/o 18, Satya Jeevan, Leprosy Camp,
Sri Niwas Puri, New Delhi - 110065
Aged about 34 years
69. Sanju Kumar
S/o Sh. Budh Prakash
R/o G. No - 1, H. No - 14, Jatav Basti, Kamal Pur,
Majra Burari North, Delhi - 110084
Aged about 26 years
70. Arvind Kumar
S/o Sh. Tilak Ram
R/o House No F- 368, Street No - 5,
23
West Karawal Nagar, Delhi - 110094
Aged about 32 years
71. Sangeeta
W/o Sh. Tikam Singh
R/o H. No. 77 C 45/1, Mukesh Nagar,
Shahdara, Delhi - 110032
Aged about 31 years
72. Sunita
W/o Sh. Ved Prakash
R/o Khasra No. 11/B, Ramesh Nagar,
Baana, Delhi - 110039
Aged about 34 years
73. Payal Gupta
W/o Sh. Netrapal Gupta
R/o J - 83, Shri Niwas Puri,
3rd Floor, New Delhi - 110065
Aged about 42 years
74. Rajinder Kaur
W/o Sh. Sukhpal Singh
R/o WZ - 94B, New Shaib Pura,
MBS Nagar, Tilak Nagar,
West Delhi, Delhi - 110018
Aged about 40 years
(Group „D‟)
(SCC/NO)
...Applicants
Versus
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
Through its Chief Secretary,
A-Wing, 5th Floor, Delhi Secretariat,
I.P. Estate, New Delhi
2. Directorate General of Health Services
(GNCT of Delhi)
Through its Director General,
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F-17, Karkardooma, Delhi - 110032
24
3. Chief Medical Officer (Care Taking Branch)
Directorate General of Health Services,
(GNCT of Delhi)
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F-17, Karkardooma, Delhi - 110032
4. The Secretary
(Health & Family Welfare),
(GNCT of Delhi),
9th Level, A-Wing, IP Estate,
Delhi Secretariat, Delhi - 110002
...Respondents
8. O.A. No. 3284/2018
1. Manoj Kumar Paliwal
S/o Sh. J. L. Paliwal
R/o G - 28/Panchsheel Garden, Sarovar Marg,
Shahdra, Delhi - 110032
Aged about 42 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
2. Rahul Sharma
S/o Sh. Nirmal Sharma
R/o Som Bazar, Pushpa Garden, Bahaita
Hajipur, Loni Dehat, Ghaziabad,
Uttar Pradesh - 201102
Aged about 26 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
3. Pushpa
W/o Sh. Ajay
R/o H. No. T - 31, DDA Flats, Sarai Phoos,
Tiz Hazari, Delhi - 110054
Aged about 38 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
25
4. Pooja
W/o Sh. Manoj Kumar
R/o H. No. 143, Type - I,
Gulabi Bagh, Delhi - 110007
Aged about 34 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
5. Kusum
D/o Sh. Babu Lal
R/o Gali No. 07, Pappu Colony, G - 20,
Sahibabad, Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh - 201005
Aged about 32 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
6. Anil Kumar
S/o Sh. Prempal Singh
R/o N 76/4, Om Nagar, Sangam Park, Delhi - 110007
Aged about 25 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
7. Rukmani
W/o Sh. Jugraj
R/o K Back N/18/165, J. J. Colony,
Wazir Pur, Shiv Mandir
Aged about 44 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
8. Rakhi
W/o Sh. Jitender Kumar
R/o 242, Sundar Nagar, I - Block,
Nandnagari, Delhi - 110093
Aged about 25 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
26
9. Satya Prakash Verma
S/o Sh. Gorey Lal
R/o H. No. 79, Block E - 1, Gali No. 2,
Nehru Vihar, Dayalpur, Seelam Pur, Delhi - 110094
Aged about 52 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
10. Ranjan Kumar
S/o Sh. Bej Nath Shah
R/o H. No. N 418/77, Udham Singh Park,
Wazirpur Industrial Area, Delhi - 110052
Aged about 38 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
11. Mohan
S/o Sh. Ganesh
R/o H. No. A 1/246, Sultan Puri, Delhi - 110086
Aged about 39 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
12. Vijay Kumar Shah
S/o Sh. Jai Prakash Shah
R/o A - 87, Udam Singh Park,
Wazirpur, Industrial Area, Delhi - 110052
Aged about 37 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
13. Renu Shah
D/o Sh. Pankaj Shah
R/o 29/A, B/4, Keshav Puram,
Delhi - 110035
Aged about 34 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
27
14. Asha Pal
D/o Sh. Arjun Pal
R/o B - 297 B, Begum Vihar, Near Bharo Mandir,
Begumpur, North West, Delhi - 110086
Aged about 39 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
15. Shyam Lal
D/o Sh. Raghunath Sha
R/o Wazirpur, Industrial Area, B - 201,
Udham Singh Park, Delhi - 10052
Aged about 35 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
16. Mamta Devi
D/o Sh. Shayam Pal
R/o Wazir Pur I A B - 201, Udham Singh Park,
Industrial Area, Delhi - 110052
Aged about 30years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
17. Parveen Kumar
S/o Sh. Kaptan Singh
R/o H - 67, Budhk H, Rajeev Nagar, Extn.,
Begumpur
Aged about 28 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars))
18. Janak Shri
S/o SH. Nitrotam Singh
R/I - 21, Krishan Vihar, Sultan Puri,
C - Block, New Delhi - 110086
Aged about 36 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
28
19. Ravi
S/o Sh. Jagdish
R/o Sultan Pur Dabad, F - 76, Delhi
Aged about 24 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
20. Kapil
S/o Sh. Roshan Lal
R/o H. No. 480, Gaun Badli, Balmiki Mohalla,
Maszid Wali Gali
Aged about 32 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
21. Akash
S/o Sh. Gaiyan Singh
R/o P3/19, Mangol Puri, Delhi - 110083
Aged about 25 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
22. Vikas
S/o Sh. Ashok Kumar
R/o P 3/21, Mangol Puri, Delhi - 110083
Aged about 25 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
23. Seema Sharma
D/o Sh. Ajay Sharma
R/o B - 38/2, Kewal Park, Azad Pur, Delhi - 110033
Aged about 46 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
24. Beena Sharma
D/o Sh. Mahender Kumar Sharma
R/o 48/C, Street No. 01, Shivaji Marg,
100 Foot Road, Jhajjupur, Shahdara,
29
Delhi - 110032
Aged about 26 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
25. Madan Lal Sharma
S/o Sh. Shrikant Sharma
R/o C - 184, A Gali No. 3/22, Nahear Road,
Gokal Pur Village, Delhi - 110094
Aged about 23 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
26. Sanjay
S/o Sh. Bhoop Singh
R/o H. No. B - 14, Street No. 03,
Near Hotilal Dharmshala, West Nathu Colony,
Shahdara, Delhi - 110093
Aged about 38 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
27. Narendra Kumar Verma
S/o Sh. Chhote Lal Verma
R/o A - 85 - 88, Bhalswa Dairy, Delhi - 110042
Aged about 28 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
28. Yogender Kumar
S/o Sh. Visember Dayal
R/o X - 600, Mangol Puri, Delhi - 110083
Aged about 35 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
29. Saroj
D/o Sh. Surjeet
R/o H. No. 63, Sabbad, Daulat Pur, Delhi - 110042
30
Aged about 43 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
30. Kundan
S/o Sh. Revad Ram
R/o C - 1/149, Sector - 20, Rohini,
Delhi - 110086
Aged about 24 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
31. Mohit
S/o Sh. Surjeet
R/o H. No. 63, Sabbad, Daulat Pur, Delhi - 110042
Aged about 23 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
32. Ravi Kumar
S/o Sh. Hari Singh
R/o H. No. 103, Block - E, Meer Vihar, Madan Pur,
Dabas, Delhi - 110081
Aged about 26 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
33. Deepak Kumar Gupta
S/o Sh. Rakesh Gupta
R/o 1216/537, Amer Colony, East Gokulpur,
Delhi - 110094
Aged about 35 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
34. Harish Kumar
S/o Sh. Devki Nandan
R/o H. No. 91, Block C, Near Shivam Public School,
Pratap Nagar, Delhi - 110093
31
Aged about 26 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
35. Manish Kumar
S/o Sh. Ram Kishor
R/o N 362/ Gali No. 07, Sundar Nagri,
Delhi - 110093
Aged about 26 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
36. Keshav Gupta
S/o Sh. Anil Kumar
R/o H. No. 128, Gali No. 04, Ph - 09,
Karawal Nagar, North East, Delhi - 110094
Aged about 22 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
37. Sumit Kumar Sharma
S/o Sh. Gajender Sharma
R/o Ghudi Chaukhandi, Sector - 68,
Nodia, G B Nagar, UP - 201301
Aged about 31 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
38. Muzahid Ali
S/o Sh. Qumaruddin
R/o H. No. 203, Gali No. 01, C - Block,
Kadi Vihar, Village Kadipur, Delhi - 110036
Aged about 43 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
39. Sudhir Kumar
S/o Sh. Shyam Lal
R/o B - 4701, Gali No. 112, Sant Nagar, Burari
32
Aged about 40 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
40. Lal Singh Rawat
S/o Sh. Mansingh Rawat
R/o H. No. 404C - 918, Agar Nagar, Prem Nagar - III,
Delhi - 110086
Aged about 25 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
41. Nitish
S/o Sh. Girdhari Lal
R/o 2/23, Gali No. 2, Jagjeewan Nagar,
Loni Road, Shahdara, Delhi - 110093
Aged about 22 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
42. Jitender Singh
S/o Sh. Mahesh Singh
R/o 766, Gali No. 09, Sangam Vihar,
Wazirabad, Delhi - 110084
Aged about 30 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
43. Jitender Sharma
S/o Sh. Saroop Singh
R/o H. No. 404, Khera Khurd, Delhi - 110082
Aged about 38 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
44. Sandeep Kumar
S/o Sh. Raj Singh
R/o H .No. B - 13, Pradhan Wali Gali No. 01,
Johari Pur, Delhi - 110094
33
Aged about 31 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
45. Rahul Prasad Sharma
S/o Sh. Kanhaiya Sharma
R/o A - 1/280, Sultanpuri, New Delhi - 110086
Aged about 26 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
46. Rahul
S/o Sh. Ram Kumar
R/o H. No. 295, Shadi Nagar, Azad Puri,
Near by Railway Station, Delhi - 110033
Aged about 25 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
47. Deepak
S/o Sh. Gabbu
R/o H. No. P 6/13, Mangol Puri, Delhi - 110083
Aged about 35 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
48. Rohit
S/o Sh. Mahender Singh
R/o P - 3/123, Mangol Puri, Delhi - 110083
Aged about 28 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
49. Ganesh Chand
S/o Sh. Jeesukh
R/o H. No. 1666, G - Block, Jahangir Puri,
Delhi - 110033
Aged about 28 years
(Group „C‟)
34
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
50. Sunita Kumari
S/o Sh. Jyoti Parsad
R/o 87/3, Subli Mandi, Railway Colony, Delhi - 110007
Aged about 33 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
51. Dharmender Kumar
S/o Sh. Amichand
R/o H. NBo. 1 - 242, Gali No. 04,
Sunder Nagri, North East, Delhi - 110093
Aged about 243 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
52. Rakesh Kumar
S/o Sh. Bhagwan Singh
R/o H. No. 562, Sector No. 12,
E - 1 Block, Near K L V School,
Nehru Vihar, Dabalpur, North Delhi - 110094
Aged about 43 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
53. Vishal Vaid
S/o Sh. Ram Kumar
R/o Khera Hapur, Pilakua Post Office,
Uttar Pradesh - 245304
Aged about 22 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
54. Mehnsha Begum
D/o Sh. Islam Khan
R/o L Block, L - 47, JJ Colony, Wazirpur,
Aged about 35 years
(Group „C‟)
35
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
55. Jai Mala
W/o SH. Roshan Lal
R/o H. No. 337, Type - II, Delhi Admin Flats,
Nimri Colony, Ph - IV, Ashok Vihar,
Delhi - 110052
Aged about 38 years
Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
56. Naresh Kumar
S/o Sh. Shankar Lal
R/o H .No. 2326, Block EE, Jahangir Puri,
Delhi - 110033
Aged about 34 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
57. Sanjay
S/o Sh. Naresh
R/o N - 17C/223, F Block, T Hvts,
JJ Colony, North West, Delhi - 110052
Aged about 36 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
58. Reena Devi
D/o Sh. Vijay Kumar Saha
R/o A - 87, Udham Singh Park, Wajirpur,
Industrial Area.
Aged about 32 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
59. Madhubala
D/o Sh.Kishan Pal
R/o D/751 Gali No. 5, Ashok Nagar,
Shahdara, Delhi- 93
Aged about 27 years
36
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
60. Deepmala
D/o Sh. Roshan Lal
R/o D/651, Gali No. 1 Ashok Nagar,
Shahdara, Delhi- 93
Aged about 37 Years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
61. Mamta
D/o Sh. Anil Kumar
R/o E-227 Block -12 MCD,
Flat Nand Nagri, Mandoli,
Sabali North East Delhi- 93
Aged about 38 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
62. Manita Yadav
W/o Sh. Neeraj Yadav
R/o H. No. 292, Ahir Mohalla
Nangloi, Delhi- 41
Aged about 36 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
63. Manisha
W/o Sh. Wazir
R/o D-61, Amar Colony,
Nangloi, Delhi- 41
Aged about 36 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
64. Kamlesh
W/o Sh. Anand Prakash
R/o B-3/138-1389, Sultanpuri, Delhi-86
37
Aged about 36 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
65. Manish Kumar
S/o Sh. Late Sh. Sunil Kumar
R/o D/751 Gali No. 5 Ashok Nagar,
Shahdara, Delhi- 93
Aged about 23 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
66. Prithvi Raj
S/o Sh. Jugraj
R/o N-18/165, T-Huts
K-Bloc, J. J. Colony, Wazirpur, Delhi-52
Aged about 22 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
67. Ved Prakash
S/o Sh. Jagdish Chander
R/o R/Z-49A Rama Public School
Arian Main Dhaka Road, Nazab Ghar
Road, New Delhi-43
Aged about 53 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
68. Ajay Kumar
S/o Sh. Manga Ram
R/o Madanpur Dabas, Delhi- 81
Aged about 27 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
...Applicants
Versus
38
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
Through its Chief Secretary,
A-Wing, 5th Floor, Delhi Secretariat,
I.P. Estate, New Delhi
2. Directorate General of Health Services
(GNCT of Delhi)
Through its Director General,
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F-17, Karkardooma, Delhi - 110032
3. Chief Medical Officer (Care Taking Branch)
Directorate General of Health Services,
(GNCT of Delhi)
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F-17, Karkardooma, Delhi - 110032
4. The Secretary
(Health & Family Welfare),
(GNCT of Delhi),
9th Level, A-Wing, IP Estate,
Delhi Secretariat, Delhi - 110002
...Respondents
9. OA No. 3298/2018
1. Mukesh Kumar
S/o Sh. Sunder Pal
R/o B-31, Street No.-2,
New Seema Puri, Delhi-110095
Aged about 27 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
2. Virender Kumar
S/o Sh. Ram Shabad
R/o H. No. 83, Block -S, Welcome
Seemapur Delhi-53
Aged about 34 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
39
3. Prakash
S/o Sh. Rajjan Singh
R/o Ambedkar Colony, Street No. 2,
Indergarhi, Post Adhyatmik Nagar,
Dasna Dehat, Ghaziabad,
U.P. 201302
Aged about 42 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
4. Krishan Prakash
S/o Sh. Vishanbar Dayal
R/o Rana Vihar, A-15, C-Block
Mohammad Pur Masri, New Delhi-81
Aged about 48 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
5. Ranjeet
S/o Sh. Ramji Lal
R/o 10/162 Khichri Pur, Delhi-91
Aged about 36 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
6. Tinku
S/o Sh. Narayan
R/o B-40, East, Jyoti Nagar,
Shahadara, Delhi93
Aged about 26 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
40
7. Soni
S/o Sh. Hardev
R/o E-5/109, Sultan Puri
New Delhi- 86
Aged about 26 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
8. Sandeep Kumar
S/o Sh. Leeley Singh
R/o C-494, Gali No. 8, Ashok Nagar,
Shahdara, Delhi- 93
Aged about 29 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
...Applicants
Versus
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
Through its Chief Secretary,
A-Wing, 5th Floor, Delhi Secretariat,
I.P. Estate, New Delhi
2. Directorate General of Health Services
(GNCT of Delhi)
Through its Director General,
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F-17, Karkardooma, Delhi - 110032
3. Chief Medical Officer (Care Taking Branch)
Directorate General of Health Services,
(GNCT of Delhi)
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F-17, Karkardooma, Delhi - 110032
4. The Secretary
(Health & Family Welfare),
(GNCT of Delhi),
9th Level, A-Wing, IP Estate,
Delhi Secretariat, Delhi - 110002
...Respondents
41
10. O.A. No. 3396/2018
1. Raj Kumar
S/o Sh. Krishan
R/o J 472 Shakupur, JJ Colony, Delhi- 110034
Aged about 42 years
2. Seema
D/o Sh. Raj Kumar
R/o J 472 Shakurpur, JJ Colony, Dellhi- 110034
Aged about 37 Years
3. Himanshi
D/o Sh. Mukesh Kumar
R/o H. No. 523B, Village Nangloi, Delhi- 110041
Aged about 21 Years
4. Gaurav Kumar
S/o Sh. Sukhvir Singh
R/o R.Z. - 47 Santosh Park, Uttam Nagar,
New Delhi- 110059
Aged about 22 Years
5. Sharvan Kumar
S/o Late Sh. Jagdish Lal
R/o J. 634, Gali No. 9, Sardar Colony, Rohini Sec- 16,
New Delhi- 110089
Aged about 40 Years
6. Sukhbeer
S/o Sh. Kamal Singh
R/o F- 2/330, Sultan Puri, North West Delhi,
Delhi - 110086
Aged about 45 years
7. Sunil Kumar
S/o Sh. Satan Ram
R/o EE 2515, Jahangir Puri, Delhi- 110033
Aged about 31 Years
8. Vijender Kumar
S/o Sh. Pale Ram
R/o D- 164, Gali No. 8, East Gokal Pur,
Amar Colony, Delhi- 110094
Aged about 24 years
9. Bijender Kumar
S/o Sh. Daya Chand
R/o 211, Balmiki Mohalla, Near Bus Stand, Pilla,
42
North West Delhi- 110036
Aged about 42 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and Sweepers-
Cum-Chowkidars)
.....Applicants
VERSUS
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
Through its Chief Secretary,
A- Wing, 5th Floor, Delhi Secretariat,
I.P Estate, New Delhi
2. Directorate General of Health Services
(GNCT of Delhi)
Through its Director General,
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F- 17, Karkardooma, Delhi- 110032
3. Chief Medical Officer (Care Taking Branch)
Directorate General of Health Services,
(GNCT of Delhi)
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F- 17, Karkardooma, Delhi- 110032
4. The Secretary
(Health & Family Welfare)
(GNCT of Delhi)
9th Level, A-Wing, IP Estate,
Delhi Secretariat, Delhi- 110002
.......Respondents
11. O.A. No. 3461/2018
1. Ravi Kumar
S/o Sh. Ajit Singh
R/o Village Chohan Joshi, Dist. Sonipat, Haryana
Aged about 30 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
2. Kalpana
W/o Late Sh. Rajkishor
R/o - 425, Inder Enclave, Phase - 2, Delhi - 110086
43
Aged about 36 years `
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
3. Deepak
S/o Sh. Kanhiya Lal
R/o A - 427, Sharda, J. J. Colony, Delhi - 110081
Aged about 27 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
4. Kamlesh
W/o Sh. Beerpal
R/o 90, Panna, Mangol Pur Kalan,
North West Delhi - 110085
Aged about 40 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
5. Sangeeta Devi
W/o Sh. Ranjeet Kumar Parsad
R/o B - 332, Gauri Shankar Enclave,
Gali No. , Prem Nagar, Delhi - 110086
Aged about 27years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
6. Karamveer
S/o Sh. Shri Chand
R/o W - 116 A/175-T, HGTS HMB,
Jwala Puri, Delhi - 110087
Aged about 50 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
7. Sandeep
S/o Sh. Jai Chand
R/o H. No. 187, Sat Grah Karala, Delhi - 110081
Aged about 44 years
44
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
8. Raj Kumari
W/o Late Sh. Radhey Shyam
R/o H. No. 1 - 99/10, Gali No. 01, Tajpur Road,
Mohan Baba Nagar, Badarpur,
Jaitpur, New Delhi
Aged about 40 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
9. Tara Chand
S/o Sh. Dalip Chand
R/o A-32, A Block Guri, Shankar Encl.
Part-I, Prem Nagar 3, Kirari, Suleman Nagar,
Delhi- 86
Aged About 28 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
10. Rinku
S/o Sh. Mahjeet Singh
R/o U-1/140, Prem Nagar-2
Kirari Suleman Nagar, Delhi- 86
Aged about 32 Years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
11. Ram Dawar yadav
S/o Sh. Dawarika Prasad yadav
R/o U-1-397, Prem Nagar- 2
Kirari Suleman Nagar, Delhi-86
Aged About 38 years
(Group „C‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
Sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
......Applicants
Versus
45
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
Through its Chief Secretary,
A-Wing, 5th Floor, Delhi Secretariat,
I.P. Estate, New Delhi
2. Directorate General of Health Services
(GNCT of Delhi)
Through its Director General,
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F-17, Karkardooma, Delhi - 110032
3. Chief Medical Officer (Care Taking Branch)
Directorate General of Health Services,
(GNCT of Delhi)
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F-17, Karkardooma, Delhi - 110032
4. The Secretary
(Health & Family Welfare),
(GNCT of Delhi),
9th Level, A-Wing, IP Estate,
Delhi Secretariat, Delhi - 110002
.........Respondents
12. O.A. No. 3508/2019
1. Manoj Kumar
S/o Sh. Om Prakash
R/o H.No. 344 Village Neelwal,
Post Office, Tikari Kalan, Delhi-41
Aged about 38 years
(Group „D‟)
(Sweepers-Cum-Chowkidar)
2. Mukesh
S/o Sh. Ashok Kumar
R/o A-3491, Sultan Puri,
New Delhi - 86
Aged about 36 years
(Group „D‟)
(Nursing Orderly)
3. Geeta Devi
W/o Lt. Sh. Devender Kumar
R/o A-57, Gali No. 4, Laxmi Vihar,
46
Mohan Garden, West Delhi-59
Aged about 43 years
(Group „D‟)
(Sweepers-Cum-Chowkidar)
4. Sandeep Kumar
S/o Sh. Braham Prakash
R/o H.No. 1045, Dispensary Wali Gali,
Village Mundka, Delhi
Aged about 36 years
(Group „D‟)
(Nursing Orderly)
5. Rekha
W/o Sh. Dinesh Kumar
R/o R 3B-48, Mohan Garden,
Uttam Nagar, West Delhi
Aged about 48 years
(Group „D‟)
(Sweepers-Cum-Chowkidar)
6. Kamal Singh
S/o Lt. Sh. Lal Singh
R/o C-73B, Tilak Vihar, Tilak Nagar,
Delhi - 18
Aged about 39 years
(Group „D‟)
(Nursing Orderly)
7. Radha
W/o Lt. Sh. Partap
R/o H.No. 283, Block-H, JJ Colony,
Bakkarwala, West Delhi - 41
Aged about 36 years
(Group „D‟)
(Sweepers-Cum-Chowkidar)
8. Deepak
S/o Sh. Vinod
R/o B-509, Jwalapuri Camp No.4,
New Delhi - 87
Aged about 25 years
(Group „D‟)
(Sweepers-Cum-Chowkidar)
9. Sanjay Kumar
S/o Sh. Mukhram Prasad
R/o A-194, Chander Vihar,
Nilothi Ext., Delhi - 41
47
Aged about 27 years
(Group „D‟)
(Sweepers-Cum-Chowkidar)
10. Dharmender
S/o Shri Prem Singh
R/o H.No. 479, Village Mundka,
Shaheed Bhagat Singh Park,
Mundka West Delhi
Aged about 30 years
(Group „D‟)
(Nursing Orderly)
11. Mohd. Zakir
S/o Sh. Khairati Khan
R/o D-270, JJ Colony, Khyala,
New Delhi - 110018
Aged about 32 years
(Group „D‟)
(Sweepers-Cum-Chowkidar)
12. Pradeep Kumar
S/o Sh. Ram Naryan
R/o E-249, J.J. Colony, Raghubir Nagar,
Tagore Garden, West Delhi - 27
Aged about 39 years
(Group „D‟)
(Sweepers-Cum-Chowkidar)
13. Ravi Kumar
S/o Sh. Brahm Prakash Phalswal
R/o RZ 11, O Block, New Roshan Pura,
Najafgarh, South West Delhi-43
Aged about 36 years
(Group „D‟)
(Nursing Orderly) ...Applicants
Versus
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
Through its Chief Secretary,
A-Wing, 5th Floor, Delhi Secretariat,
I.P. Estate, New Delhi
2. Directorate General of Health Services
(GNCT of Delhi)
Through its Director General,
48
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F-17, Karkardooma, Delhi - 110032
3. Chief Medical Officer (Care Taking Branch)
Directorate General of Health Services,
(GNCT of Delhi)
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F-17, Karkardooma, Delhi - 110032
4. The Secretary
(Health & Family Welfare),
(GNCT of Delhi),
9th Level, A-Wing, IP Estate,
Delhi Secretariat, Delhi - 110002
5. Chief District-Medical Officer
(West District)
Directorate of Health Services,
GNCT of Delhi,
A-2 Block, Paschim Vihar,
New Delhi - 63
...Respondents
13. O.A. No.3792/2017
1. Jitendra
S/o Sh. Sanjay Kumar
R/o F- 1656, J J Colony,
Tigri, New Delhi- 110062
Aged about 27 years
2. Tabassum Parveen
W/o Sh. Nasiruddin
R/o D- 5/470, Street No. 5,
Sangam Vihar, Pushpa Bhawan,
South Delhi, New Delhi- 110062
Aged about 35 years
3. Shreemati Maya
W/o Sh. Bhagwan Mishra
R/o 286, Gali No. 6A, Block E,
Sangam Vihar, Delhi
Aged about 38 years
4. Parvati,
W/o Sh. Ram
R/o K-1-18/22, Sangam Vihar,
Nagiya Farm, Hamdard Nagar,
South Delhi, New Delhi- 110062
49
Aged about 38 Years
Group „C‟
....Applicants
VERSUS
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
Through its Chief Secretary,
B- Wing, 5th Floor, Delhi Secretariat,
I.P Estate, New Delhi
2. Directorate General of Health Services
(GNCT of Delhi)
Through its Director General,
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F- 17, Karkardooma, Delhi- 110032
3. Chief Medical Officer (Care Taking Branch)
Directorate General of Health Services,
(GNCT of Delhi)
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F- 17, Karkardooma, Delhi- 110032
4. The Secretary
(Health & Family Welfare)
(GNCT of Delhi)
9th Level, A-Wing, IP Estate,
Delhi Secretariat, Delhi- 110002
.......Respondents
14. O.A. No.3855/2018
1. Kavindra
S/o Sh. Kripal Singh
R/o Mohammad, Shahpur (Baghpat) Khakra (UP)
Aged about 25 years
(Temporary employees- Nursing Orderlies and Sweepers-
Cum-Chowkidars)
(Group „C‟)
2. Pinki
W/o Sh. Ajay Kumar
R/o A-271, Mangolpuri, Delhi-110083
Aged about 28 years
(Temporary employees- Nursing Orderlies and Sweepers-
Cum-Chowkidars)
(Group „C‟)
50
3. Kuldeep Kumar
S/o Sh. Prem Chand
R/o V.P.O. Farmana, Distt. Sonipat
Haryana-131408
Aged about 40 years
(Temporary employees- Nursing Orderlies and Sweepers-
Cum-Chowkidars)
(Group „C‟)
4. Ram Niwas
S/o Sh. Shobha Ram
R/o Q-223, J J Colony Sauda
Ghevra, North West Delhi-110081
Aged about 45 years
(Temporary employees- Nursing Orderlies and Sweepers-
Cum-Chowkidars)
(Group „C‟)
5. Vijay
S/o Sh. Munsi Ram
R/o 29/565 MCD Flats, Ambedkar
Yojan, Rohini, Sector-20, Sultanpuri,
C Block, Delhi-86
(Temporary employees- Nursing Orderlies and Sweepers-
Cum-Chowkidars)
(Group „C‟)
....Applicants
(By advocate- Mr Ajesh Luthra)
Versus
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
Through its Chief Secretary,
A-Wing, 5th Floor, Delhi Secretariat,
I.P. Estate, New Delhi
2. Directorate General of Health Services
(GNCTD of Delhi)
Through its Director General,
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F-17, Karkardooma, Delhi-110032
51
3. Chief Medical Officer (Care Taking Branch)
Directorate General of Health Services,
(GNCTD of Delhi)
Swasthya Sewa Mahanideshalaya Bhawan,
F-17, Karkardooma, Delhi-110032
4. The Secretary
(Health & Family Welfare),
(GNCT of Delhi),
9th Level, A-Wing, IP Estate,
Delhi Secretariat , Delhi-110002
.........Respondents
15. O.A. No.4134/2017
1. Renu Chauhan, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
D/o Shri Banarasi Das Bagga,
R/o G-12, Arya Samaj Wali Gali,
Chander Nagar, Krishna Nagar,
East Delhi, Delhi-110051
Aged 42 years
2. Kuljeet Kaur, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
W/o Shri Gurbachan Singh,
R/o House No. 726, First Floor,
West Guru Anand Nagar,
Laxmi Nagar, Shakarpur,
East Delhi-110092
Aged about 46 years.
3. Rupesh Kumar, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
S/o Shri Gyanchand,
R/o H.No. 29/1/a, Street No. 12,
Vishwas Nagar, Shahdara,
East Delhi, Delhi-110032
4. Vikas Bhandari, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
S/o Shri Narender Mohan,
R/o T.3 Shalar Bazar, Uttam Nagar,
New Delhi-110059
Aged 42 years
52
5. Babita, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
W/o Shri Mohan Pradhan,
R/o C-60, X-1, Ground Floor,
Dilshad Garden, New Seemapuri,
Vivek Vihar, East Delhi-110095
Aged about 51 years
6. Ravi Kumar, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
S/o Shri Gian Chand
R/o 29/4-A, Gali No. 12,
Vishwas Nagar, Shahdara,
East Delhi-110032
Aged about 32 years.
7. Hari Krishan, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
W/o Shri Pappu Ram
R/o A-53, Gali No. 7,
Som Bazar Road, Mukundpur Part-2,
Samaipur, New Delhi-110042
Aged about 25 years.
8. Mukhytar Ali Abbasi
Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
W/o Mohd. Shamsuddin
R/o 71A, Pocket-C, Mayur Vihar,
Phase-2, Patparganj,
East Delhi-110091
Aged about 40 years.
9. Mahesh, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
S/o Shri Ram Prasad,
R/o T-Huts No. 81/86,
Balmiki Basti, Jhilmil Colony,
Shahdra, East Delhi-110095
Aged about 40 years.
10. Seema, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
W/o Shri Inderjit,
R/o T-Huts No. 81/86,
Balmiki Basti, Jhilmil Colony,
Shahdra, East Delhi-110095
Aged about 41 years.
53
11. VIjeta, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
W/o Shri Satish Kumar,
R/o House No. 435, Sunaro Wali Gali,
Alipur, North West Delhi-110036
Aged about 30 years.
12.Hitender Kumar, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
S/o Shri Amar Singh,
R/o House No. 129/1, Mohalla Gurihai,
Shahdra, East Delhi-110032
Aged about 37 years.
13.Manju Kumari, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
D/o Shri Puran Chand Pal,
r/o House No. 383, Gali No. 1,
Sankar Marg, Mandawali,
Shakarpur, Baramad,
Shaakrpur, East Delhi-110092
Aged about 32 years.
14.Aman Kapoor, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
S/o Shri Ashok Kapoor,
R/o FF-39, Guru Nanakpura,
Laxmi Nagar, East Delhi-110092
Aged about 35 years
15. Rita, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
W/o Shri Hari Om,
R/o A-37A Block Joshi Colony,
Pankaj Palaza Market, Mandawali,
Fazalpur, Laxmi Nagar,
East Delhi-110092
Aged about 31 years.
16.Mithlesh, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
D/o Shri Ganga Sharma
W/o Shri Lalit Sharma
R/o H.No. 233, Nehru Gali No. 8
Babar pur North East, Delhi-110032
Aged about 23 years
17. Babita Sharma, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
W/o Shri Vikash Sharma,
54
R/o H.No. 1061/E, Lahiya Gali No. 5,
Babrpur, Shahdara,
East Delhi-32
Aged about 23 years
18. Sushila, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
W/o Shri Vinod Kumar,
R/o V-5-188, Khojoor Gali,
No. 2A, Arvind Nagar,
Ghonda Bhajanpura
North East Delhi-110053
Aged about 49 years
19.Manish, SCC, Group „D‟
S/o Shri Pappu Ram,
R/o 27-G-7, Mukund Pur Extn.,
Part-II, Delhi
Aged about 21 years
20. Ajay Kumar, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
S/o Sh. Phool Chand,
R/o E-421, MCD Colony, Azadpur,
Shanjar Pur, N.S. Mandi, Delhi
Aged about 48 years
21.Ajab Singh, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
S/o Sh. Girvar Singh,
R/o H.No. 145, Dagarpur,
Khekra, Baghpat, U.P.
Aged about 49 years,
22. Dimple Sharma, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
W/o Sh. Bhudev Sharma,
R/o H.No. 1/5349/B, Street No. 14,
Balbir Nagar Extn., Shahdara East,
Delhi
Aged about 42 years
23. Manju, Nursing Ordrly, Group „D‟
W/o Sh. Kailash Singh
R/o C-332, Pandav Gali No. 1,
Arjun Mohalla, Maujpur,
55
Bhajanpura, Delhi
Aged about 37 years
24. Aman Kumar, SCC, Group „D‟
S/o Sh. Mahesh Chand,
R/o 124B, Rani Garden,
Shastri Nagar, Delhi
Aged about 32 years
25. Deepak Nagar, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
S/o Sh. Ramesh Chand,
R/o 31A, Sarojini Park, Gali No. 13
Shastri Nagar, Delhi
Aged about 26 years
26. Prince Mohan, Nursing Orderly, Group „D‟
S/o Sh. Madan Lal,
R/o 135/A, Jhil Khurnja,
Krishna Nagar, Delhi
Aged about 29 years ....Applicants
Versus
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
Through its Chief Secretary,
New Secretariat,
I.P. Estate, New Delhi
2. The Principal Secretary,
Department of Health,
Govt. of NCT Of Delhi
New Secretariat,
I.P. Estate, New Delhi
3. Directorate of Health Services
Through its Director,
Govt. of NCT of Delhi ,
DGB Building, Karkardooma,
Delhi-110092
...Respondents
56
16. O.A. No.4317/2018
1. Rahul Kumar
S/o Shri Gaindalal Sharma
R/o E-13/375, Amar Colony,
East Gokalpur, Delhi-110094
Aged about 25 years
(Group „D‟)
2. Kajal
D/o Shri Sabu Singh
R/o N-17/ A-210, Patharwala Bagh,
Wazrpur JJ Colony, Delhi-110052
Aged about 25 years
(Group „C‟)
3. Rohan Kumar
S/o Shri Shiv Prashad
R/o N/17B-121,
Ashok Vihar, Wazirpur J.J. Colony
Delhi- 110052
Aged about 29 years
(Group „C‟)
4. Ajay Kumar
S/o Shri Jagannath
R/o House No. 160, Village- Ghondly Krishna Nagar
Delhi- 110051
Aged about 43 years
(Group „C‟)
5. Nurudin
D/o Shri Shumshuddin
R/o F-2-75, Sunder Nagari, Delhi-110093
Aged about 52 years
(Group „D‟)
6. Sangeeta Sharma
D/o Shri Gaindalal Sharma
R/o E/13/375, Amar Colony,
East Gokalpur, Delhi- 110094
Aged about 32 years
(Group „D‟)
57
7. Suman
D/o Shri Munesh Kumar
R/o D-175, Gali No. 11,
Bhagirathi Vihar, Delhi- 110094
Aged about 27 years
(Group „D‟)
8. Kiran
D/o Shri Ram Babu
R/o D-167, Bhagirathi Vihar,
Delhi- 110094
Aged about 43 years
(Group „D‟)
9. Neeraj Kumar Sharma
S/o Gaindalal Sharma
R/o E-13/375, Amar Colony,
East Gokalpur, Delhi-110094
Aged about 32 years
(Group „D‟)
10. Mamta
D/o Shri Laxmi Narayan
R/o H.No.A/1/354, Nand Nagri
Delhi- 110093
Aged about 34 years
(Group „D‟)
11. Monu
S/o Shri Prem Chand
R/o B-31, Vikram Enclave,
Shalimar Garden, Ghaziabad, U.P.
Aged about 28 years
(Group „D‟)
12. Pawan Kumar
S/o Shri Sukhbir Singh
R/o 713, Chander Lok Colony,
Shahdra-32
Aged about 47 years
(Group „D‟)
58
13. Shivani
W/o Shri Sushil
R/o H.No. D-1/453, Street No. 3,
Ashok Nagar, Nand Nagari,
East Delhi-110093
Aged about 28 years
(Group „D‟)
14. Vinod Kumar
S/o Shri Summari
R/o E-81/ ½ Balmiki Basti, Jhilmil Colony,
Shahdara, East Delhi- 110095
Aged about 36 years
(Group „D‟)
15. Soni Sharma
W/o Shri Anil Kr
R/o A-105, St. No. 2/2, West Nathu Colony,
Shahdara, Delhi- 110093
Aged about 32 years
(Group „ ‟)
16. Vikas Sharma
S/o Late Mangal Sain
R/o H.No. A-105, Gali No. 2/2,
West Nathu Colony, Shahdara,
Delhi-110093
Aged about 25 years
(Group „ ‟)
17. Mamta
D/o Shri Madan Lal
R/o H.No. 86, Gali No.7, Block-C,
Karawal Nagar, Durga Mandir
Delhi- 110094
Aged about 43 years
(Group „D‟)
18. Kailash
S/o Late Mangal Sen
R/o A-105, Gali No. 2/2,
West Nathu Colony, Shahdara, Delhi- 110093
Aged about 26 years
59
(Group „D‟)
19. Mohit Chandea
S/o Shri Subhash Chand
R/o C-71, Defense Colony, Shahibabad
Ghaziabad, U.P.- 201005.
Aged about 29 years
(Group „D‟)
20. Manju W/o Shri Bhrampal Singh
R/o H.No. 280, Gali No. 9,
Village Mandoli, Delhi- 110093
Aged about 49 years
(Group „D‟)
21. Alok Kumar
S/o Shri Rakesh Kumar
R/o B-46, St. No. 2/2, West Nathu Colony,
Shahdara, Delhi- 110093.
Aged about 24 years
(Group „D‟)
22. Bharti Sharma
W/o Shri Mukesh Sharma
R/o B-43, Gali No. 2/2, West Nathu Colony,
Shahdara, Delhi- 110093.
Aged about 41 years
(Group „D‟)
23. Sunder
S/o Shri Atther Singh
R/o 16/45 T, Trilok Puri, Delhi- 110091
Aged about 36 years
(Group „D‟)
24. Raju
S/o Shri Naurang
R/o 4/1840, Gali No.2, Rama Block,
Bhola Nath Nagar, Shahdara, Delhi- 110032
Aged about 41 years
(Group „D‟)
60
25. Sunita
D/o Shri Raju
R/o 4/1840, Gali No.2, Rama Block,
Bhola Nath Nagar, Shahdara, Delhi- 110032
Aged about 40 years
(Group „D‟)
26. Pooja
S/o Shri Sandeep
R/o US-14, Uttari School Block,
Mandawali Fazal Pur, Delhi
Aged about 33 years
(Group „D‟)
27. Annu
W/o Shri Soni
R/o H.No. 156, CPJ-1, New Seelam Pur
Bhajan Pura, North East Delhi- 110053
Aged about 39 years
(Group „D‟)
28. Vikas
S/o Shri Bhoor Singh
R/o H.No. 258/A, Mukesh Nagar,
Gali No. 1, Shahdara, Delhi- 110032
Aged about 34 years
(Group „D‟)
29. Rachna
W/o Shri Prem
R/o 8/293, Trilok Puri, East Delhi- 110091
Aged about 28 years
(Group „D‟)
30. Anita Paswan
D/o Shri Ram Lakhan Paswan
R/o House No. 383, Asharam Gali
Mandawli, Shakar Pur, East Delhi
Aged about 35 years
(Group „D‟)
31. Rahul Kumar
S/o Late Madan Lal
61
R/o B/44/A, Gali No. 3/2 B-Block
West Nathu Colony, Delhi- 110093
Aged about 28 years
(Group „D‟)
32. Bala
W/o Ram Prashad
R/o H.No. 7/182, Street No. 2,
Near Saboli Tila Temple
Saboli Ext. North East Delhi- 110093
Aged about 37 years
(Group „D‟)
33. Sanjeev Kumar
S/o Shri Kanwar Pal
R/o 12/303, Kalyan Puri, East Delhi- 110092
Aged about 26 years
(Group „D‟)
34. Devendra
S/o Shri Krishan Lal
R/o H.No. 457, Near Bada School
Mata wali gali, Mandoli Village,
Delhi- 110093
Aged about 24 years
(Group „D‟)
35. Shri Kishan
S/o Shri Sat Pal Singh
R/o H.No. 92, Ratiram Colony,
Village Behta, Hazi Pur, Loni,
Ghaziabad (U.P.)- 201102
Aged about 39 years
(Group „D‟)
36. Sanjeev Kumar
S/o Shri Man Bal Singh
R/o A-1-224, D.L.F. Ghaziabad,
Dilshad Ext-II, Near Bhopura, U.P.
Aged about 47 years
(Group „D‟)
62
37. Sangeeta Pal
W/o Shri Mahender Pal
R/o H.No. 107, Ist Floor, Gali No.1,
Shalimar Village Shalimar Bagh,
North West Delhi- 110088.
Aged about 40 years
(Group „D‟)
38. Sumit
S/o Shri Deshraj
R/o 461/5, Daliayi Mohalla, Bhola Nath Nagar,
Shahdara, Delhi- 110032.
Aged about 32 years
(Group „C‟)
39. Narendra Pal
S/o Shri Lakhmi Chand
R/o Near Animal Hospital, Sujra Baghpat
Uttar Pradesh- 250601
Aged about 42 years
(Group „D‟)
40. Ajay Kumar
S/o Shri Keval Shankar
R/o H.No. 935, D-Block, Gali No. 31
East Gokalpur, North East Delhi-110094
Aged about 26 years
(Group „C‟)
41. Sumit Kumar
S/o Shri Roop Chand
R/o House No.1/731, Gali No. 9
Village Khera G.T. Road, Shahdara,
Jhilmil East Delhi, Jhilmil, Delhi- 110095
Aged about 27 years
(Group „D‟)
42. Pradeep Kumar Sharma
S/o Shri Rakesh Kumar Sharma
R/o 1/2981-C, Ram Nagar, Loni Road,
Shahdara, Delhi- 110032
Aged about 35 years
(Group „D‟)
63
43. Shelly Sharma
W/o Shri Raj Kumar
R/o 6/79-78, 2nd Floor, Dhobiwara Maharam
Mohallya, Shahdara, North East Delhi- 110032
Aged about 37years
(Group „D‟)
44. Azad
S/o Sh. Vijay Kumar
R/o G-2, Block No. 1, Kalyan Vas, Delhi- 110091
Aged about 29 Years
(Group „D‟)
(Temporary employees - Nursing Orderlies and
sweepers- Cum-Chowkidars)
....Applicants
Versus
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
Through its Chief Secretary,
A-Wing, 5th Floor, Delhi Secretariat,
I.P. Estate, New Delhi
2. Directorate General of Health Services
(GNCT of Delhi)
Through its Director General,
SwasthyaSewaMahanideshalayaBhawan,
F-17, Karkardooma, Delhi - 110032
3. Chief Medical Officer (Care Taking Branch)
Directorate General of Health Services,
(GNCT of Delhi)
SwasthyaSewaMahanideshalayaBhawan,
F-17, Karkardooma, Delhi - 110032
4. The Secretary
(Health & Family Welfare),
(GNCT of Delhi),
9th Level, A-Wing, IP Estate,
Delhi Secretariat, Delhi - 110002
...Respondents
64
17. O.A. No.4408/2018
1. Naresh Kumar, Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 42 years,
S/o Sh. Lal Chand
R/O N-166, Sawada, JJ Colony,
New Delhi-110051
2. Pinki, Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 38 years,
D/o Sh. Ravinder Kumar,
R/o 199, Bamnoli Village,
Delhi-110077
3. Kari Sahni, Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 42 years,
S/o Sh. Bhagirath,
R/o H.No. 39, Sec-19, Dwarka,
Ambedkar Village, Delhi-110075
4. Mukesh Tiwari, Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 29 years,
S/o Sh. Lal Chand Tiwari,
R/o RZP-320, Gali No. 5,
Raj Nagar-2, Palam Colony,
Delhi-110077
5. Santosh Kumar Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 47 years,
S/o Sh. Shiv Lal,
R/o 33, Krishan Kunj Extn.,
Part-II, Laxmi Nagar,
Delhi-110092
6. Sunita Sethi, Nursing Orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 45 years,
65
W/o Sh. Jitender Kumar,
R/o 13/52, Geeta Colony, Gandhi Nagar,
Delhi-110031
7. Parmod Kumar, Nursing Orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 45 years,
S/o Sh. Gopi Chand
R/o 194, Santosh Pur, Ahera,
Baghpat, U.P.-250609
8. Chander Kumar, Nursing orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 40 years,
W/o Sh. Swami Deen,
R/o H.No. 146, Gali No. 6,
DCM Colony, Ibrahiumpur,
Delhi-110084
9. Anjali, Nursing Orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 40 years,
W/o SH. Shyam Sunder,
R/o H.No. H.No. A-455, New Seemapuri,
Delhi-110095
10. Sheenu, Sweeper-cum-Chowkidar
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 45 years,
W/o Sh. Mukesh Kumar,
R/o T-Huts No. E-81/16, Balmiki Basti,
Jhilmil Colony, Shahdara,
Delhi-110095
11. Neeraj Dhankar, Nursing Orderly,
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 40 years,
S/o Sh. Om Prakash,
R/o A-69, 270, Amar Puri,
Aram Nagar, Paharganj,
New Delhi-110055
66
12.Mamta, Nursing Orderly,
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 40 years,
W/o Sh. Sanjay,
R/o S-12/185, Indira Gandhi Camp,
Lodhi Colony, Lodhi Road
Delhi-110003
13.Azra Sultana, Nursing Orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 44 years,
R/o D/S 03, Kidwai Nagar,
Sarojini Nagar, New Delhi-110023
14.Madhu Ratnakar, Nursing Orderly
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 45 years,
W/o Sh. Kapil Kumar
R/o 18/A, Aram Bagh,
Paharganj, Delhi-110055
15. Aarti Rani, Nursing Orderly,
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 28 years,
D/o Sh. Rakesh Kumar,
R/o D-34, Bindapur, JJ Colony,
Pkt-A, New Delhi-110059
16.Roma, Nursing Orderly,
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 35 years,
W/o Sh Anil,
R/o F-74, Laxmi Park, Nangloi, Delhi-110041
17. Sunita Gupta, Nursing Orderly,
Group „D‟/D.W
Aged about 35 years,
W/o Sh. Akash Gupta,
R/o TA-279, Gali No. 5, Tuglakabad,
Kalkaji, Alaknanda, Delhi-110019
18. Vijay laxmi, Nursing Orderly,
Group „D‟/D.W
67
Aged about 30 years,
W/o Sh. Satya Prakash,
R/o Flat No. 1534/1,
G.F. Side Southern,
Wazi Nagar,
Kotla Mubarakpur,
Delhi
(All applicants working as Group-„D‟)
.......Applicants
Versus
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
Through its Chief Secretary,
New Secretariat,
I.P. Estate,
New Delhi
2. The Principal Secretary,
Department of Health,
Govt. of NCT of Delhi
New Secretariat,
I.P. Estate, New Delhi
3. Directorate of Health Services
Through its Director,
Govt. of NCT of Delhi ,
DGB Building,
Karkardooma,
Delhi-110092
...Respondents
(Mr. Ajesh Luthra, Mr. M K Bhardwaj and Mr. M K Jangra,
Advocates for applicants)
(Mr. Amit Anand, Mrs. Harvinder Oberoi and Mr. Anuj Kumar
Sharma, Advocates for respondents)
68
ORDER
Justice L. Narasimha Reddy:
In this batch of O.As., common question of facts and law arise. Hence, they are disposed of through this common judgment.
2. The applicants claim that they are working as daily wagers under the control of Director General of Health Services, Government of Delhi, since 02.05.2016. It is also stated that prior to that date, they were serving with the respondents, through a labour contractor from 2013-14 onwards. According to them, once they are deployed as daily wagers, they cannot be replaced by another set of daily wagers. It is also stated that their engagement was being extended, each for a period of 89 days.
3. The cause of action for the applicants to file these O.As. is an Advertisement issued on the website of M/s. Intelligent Communication System India Limited (ICSIL) in July, 2017, proposing to engage employees in place of the applicants. They submit that any action, proposing to replace them with another set of employees, is impressible in law. Reliance is placed upon the judgment rendered by the Full Bench of this Tribunal in O.A. Nos. 1184/2009 & 1461/2009 and various judgments of Hon‟ble High Courts and Hon‟ble Supreme Court. 69
The applicants seek the relief in the form of a direction to the respondents to continue them by paying monthly emoluments, at the minimum of regular pay scales.
4. On behalf of the respondents, respective counter affidavits are filed, opposing the O.As. It is stated that the house keeping services in various hospitals was being outsourced, and that in the year 2015, a labour contract was awarded in favour of M/s. Shivalik House Keeping Services (SHKS) for a period of one year up to 04.05.2016. The respondents state that the applicants were engaged by M/s. SHKS and there is no direct relationship between them and the applicants. It is also stated that M/s. SHKS started working, but it was not complying with the conditions, and accordingly, steps were taken to pay the salaries to all the employees directly and in the interregnum between the expiry of the term of M/s. SHKS, an arrangement was made to pay daily wages to the employees. It is also stated that the contract of outsourcing was awarded to M/s. ICSIL for the subsequent period and accordingly, they initiated steps for deployment of the manpower. The respondents state that when the work was outsourced, the applicant cannot be extended the benefit of continuing on daily wages.
5. The arguments on behalf of the applicants were advanced by Mr. Ajesh Luthra and Mr. M K Bhardwaj, learned counsel. They submit that the applicants were initially engaged for a 70 period of 89 days on daily wages and that thereafter it was being extended from time to time. They also submit that the respondents cannot entrust the work to a labour contractor in contravention of relevant provisions of law and the livelihood of the applicants cannot be taken away. Reliance is placed upon the following judgments:
i) Shri Bhoop singh & others v. Chairman-cum-
Managing Director North Eastern Electric Power Corporation Ltd. & another (W.P. (C) No.6483/2014 with connected petition) decided on 19.03.2015 by the Hon‟ble High Court of Delhi.
ii) Union of India & others v. Tulsi Ram Jod & another (CWP No.3389/2013 with connected petitions) decided on 19.03.2015 by the High Court of Rajasthan.
iii) AFR Kartik Chandra Panda v. State of Orissa & others (W.P. (C) No.18004/2012) decided on 27.07.2017 by the Hon‟ble Orissa High Court.
iv) Gujarat Mazdoor Sabha v. Valsad Nagar Palika (Special Civil Application No.3062/2015) decided on 02.11.2018 by the Hon‟ble Gujarat High Court.
v) Air India Statutory Corporation & others v.
United Labour Union & others (1997) 9 SCC 377 71
vi) Secretary, HSEB v. Suresh & others (1999) 3 SCC
601.
6. Mr. Amit Anand, learned counsel for respondents, on the other hand, submits that the work of housekeeping in hospitals was entrusted to outsourcing agencies as a matter of policy and M/s. SHKS was awarded the contract from 05.05.2015 for a period of one year. He submits that the applicants herein were deployed by the said agency and the occasion to pay daily wages directly to them arose on account of the default committed by the labour contractor. He contends that once the new contractor was assigned the work, deployment is required to be done by him and the applicants do not have any right to insist on being continued. He further submits that dispute, if any, in this regard needs to be raised before the competent Labour Court and not by approaching this Tribunal.
7. The pleadings in the O.As. give an impression as though the applicants were inducted into the service of various hospitals, through orders dated 02.05.2016, and were entrusted the work of Sweeper-cum-Chowkidars (SCC). The fact, however, remains that in the very order dated 02.05.2016, it is mentioned that the SCC workers are engaged through M/s. SHKS. The order dated 02.05.2016 reads:
72
"With due approval of the competent authority, all CDMOs are, hereby, informed to engage Sweeper cum Chowkidars (SCC) workers on daily wage basis for a period of 89 days for Delhi Govt. Dispensaries w.e.f. 05- 05-2016.
He modalities for engaging the human resources will be as under:-
1. All those SCC contractual workers who are currently working through M/s Shivalik Housekeeping Pvt. Ltd. at various Delhi Govt.
Dispensaries will be deployed on daily wage basis.
2. The SCC workers who are willing to work on daily wages will be placed on duty subject to their satisfactory performance over past months/year. A written undertaking is to be taken from the existing workers that they are willing to work on daily wages basis and should be kept in records till the engagement is enforce.
3. To engage the human resource as per the daily wage rate of Rs.368/- as per Labour Department order F.No.12(142)/13/mw/ Lab/3998 dated 31-03-2016. The daily wage rate will be revised as and when the same are revised by Labour Department.
4. The payment to workers will be made on monthly basis and through ECS.
5. In-charge concerned should note that the engagement is for 89 days only and should be adhered to."
In paragraph (1) of the order itself, the factum of applicants having been engaged by M/s. SHKS was clearly stated.
8. Things would have been different altogether, had it been the case where the applicants were inducted into service in whatever capacity, by the Delhi Administration itself. Once 73 their induction is through an outsourcing agency, a totally different legal regime altogether, comes into existence. The respondents have clearly stated the circumstances under which order dated 02.05.2016 came to be issued. The contract with M/s. SHKS was for a period of one year up to 04.05.2016. When some problem arose as regards the working of the contractor, wages were paid directly. There was some delay in awarding the contract to another agency. In the interregnum, the order dated 02.05.2016 was issued to ensure the continuance of work. This is not a case in which a set of employees was already in existence and that very work is sought to be entrusted to a labour contractor.
9. The main emphasis in the pleadings as well as in the arguments is that the set of contractual or ad hoc employees cannot be replaced by another set of employees. There is absolutely no second opinion about the legal proposition. The fact, however, is that the applicants are neither contractual employees of the Delhi Administration, nor were they appointed on ad hoc basis. Their rights, if at all, are governed by the provisions of the Contract Labour (Regulation & Abolition) Act, 1970 (for short "the Act"). If they are of the view that their rights under that enactment are violated in any manner, they have to approach the competent Labour Court for enforcement thereof. The respondents have already entrusted the work to 74 M/s. ICSIL. In their letter dated 20.08.2016 to the said agency, the respondents state as under:-
"Subject : Placement of Sweeper cum Chowkidaar in various health units under DGHS through agency i.e. M/s. ICSIL Sir, Please refer to subject cited above and communication sent earlier vide letter dated 16-06-2016, 01-07-2016, 11.08.2016 & 19-08-2016. As a follow up measure telephonic reminders were made from time to time but nothing has been communicated to this office till date.
You are requested to expedite and inform this office immediately regarding the timeline worked out for placement of the SCC as requested for.
Further it is requested to please acknowledge the communication and inform accordingly latest by 2nd September 2016 failing which Secretary (Health and Family Welfare, Government of Delhi) will be informed accordingly."
It is on entrustment of the work to it, that the agency is taking steps to deploy its own workforce. Since the applicants are already experienced in the field, they can certainly approach the agency and there is no reason to believe that their services will not be availed. This Tribunal cannot bring about a new legal regime altogether, when it is already covered by the labour contract.
10. In almost all the judgments relied upon by the applicants, such as Air India Statutory Corporation and Secretary, HSEB (supra), the proceedings first commenced in the Labour 75 Courts for adjudication of the rights under the relevant provisions of the Act and thereafter they reached the Hon‟ble Supreme Court after passing through the concerned High Courts. In the absence of such adjudication by the forum under the Act, this Tribunal cannot address the issue. Serious question of jurisdiction also will arise. In fact, the applicants did not canvass their rights with reference to the Act, notwithstanding the fact that their very engagement was under the provisions thereof by the labour contractor.
11. In Gujarat Mazdoor Sabha (supra), the adjudication was mostly on the concept of „equal pay for equal work‟ and framing of a scheme for regularization. That was not a case in which the employees were engaged by the labour contractor.
12. We do not find any merit in these O.As. They are accordingly dismissed.
13. In view of the above order, C.P. Nos.645/2017 & 446/2018 in O.A. No.2808/2017 and C.P. No.445/2018 in O.A. No.3792/2017 are closed.
14. All the pending M.As. stand disposed of.
There shall be no order as to costs.
( Mohd. Jamshed ) ( Justice L. Narasimha Reddy ) Member (A) Chairman /sunil/