Karnataka High Court
Chandrashekhar Junjappa Sooranagi vs The State Of Karnataka Reptd By Spp on 25 August, 2011
§fi§§fi§§%§€§§§?€%?%2E§&T&a£ €IR.€EJ'E'? ggrsggg £3' §§~§&;':QEW;%E :. > DA?§a2?a$iwfi:2§hBAy(fi?aUm5$§§§§5y Efi2?{§€§: ft ,E ' "
?HE:H<nu£n12§4RAn;$?g;fij3§5;%§fi€§f ::R;xxNL;23@?jg$Q§ V' W Cgma % M §RL¢xN(fi;:?8;§3: Q5 ;§"¥?%&§;:Ei_;i£2§2§§»_ in €rE.A,N{).236Z7 2095 E3€E1V€€}i: ;' ';_ "_ g**x "=A ~T*«HHf cMAxnRAsHyKHKR,{ BOURANKUE ' a<as3a\$;:xs_"
§wws@£sxam:_ éQ;muRxuA?H'_ snsauanxm ' ..':P§}£5§,E,;'a?\£¢§T /':.\€3 W %g§s$A?E<%?KARNg?AKA _f§E9RE§E&?E§E?{S?&?iE%E%j£ ?R@$§CUT®E fl}§§§€}§SQ?EfiHL§fi%3 "?§_aAgs2;gga . . ( E3443' EC i73'<".[§ 3'} 2?
E. W K' /1;)?'/:
2% :',§&%Ggg®%E'fh PM ?a agvmag f§£3§%%N£&£PPfi&L§S%H£§}ah" » ?§ FGR THE A{fl%AANT AaAm&n'"
\ E ' '§' 5 V , 7 ;2m5 PAas§> 3%! "x& 2@{2 VUNWC?&K;?H€ ( ,4',X , _. §5,5E3'Vr'i#§i%.E¢%(E, 325% E13 /'i?v" §t§§;ZC.?--$?7% {XV EEK', ; J 41 (3%? EPC zU\Ei } E%§E£§\%"§'§*lN(jiENéf E.1'\x§P§13Z§%(V)1'~EFx'3 EN" E*'<?}E~3 A P}€;RZ( §ZL} C)?' 2} EX. E5} E5 ([3 F £953; 2 {M} --
§ET'§{L «*A .n32x)w£¥2;
I} I 13 $09 THE nygawsaisi' in C1"l;f3x¢EVTQ. ?:7éE}%,52G{}€f> B€Z'?:f\7C€?I3I S?ATEEE§KARNATAKéW _ REPRESE%?§D§3¥?fi§$?A?i Pa8L%:§Ea:*ca?eR ¢ 5 L19 {N {E zfi@a@§aR?§¥ . E93 8 ?~'{[} F»! 5} SEE'?
, . , 3 :13 E?3;%E+;z&;Y§$';.;§:.§€zfi§z,}, "' §:}"%.»;:!Y~3»» E'¥'§f72 V zgwwaaw m§ER<xéu ';x:x%;Awuf n \z E,/W '5>\* <:;:s;:+::?x;:'; E--EUE4é3'§' ':1; 2:
°"'§ IE2 (5% €55' E}7'{f.
E V} 77 .
L3"~E§}§Z??:(VV§([} 311 W43 §w<}?\EE':fH'L §\£"{ 39%} 7 3@4~: Rjfif a3:1
% g» I s.2<::@;¥ :?+':>§e TE :2: am Ii': €3:'E_A.N<;:.23 E /Z2{)Cr€§ B€E\¥;"€€1'"; :» E . M 7} ME 'R< ;; a:>m ME 5; .§.\~I§ ;\<;%> ':'§i;\§§iE~%;
M; as ::<,::;\;,4i:< gs 'm,:%;~; eam4:mé'es ms'? :1};/*\:'>;x<;
3. MA:.mz>m ?\~"§§7£%i{éi'i .w:{ 3: 'fl{.»*\§<j_ * ms éia n _ 3 'M: A; :5: 5; am: j; ";"2=:...
Ekiféf' <m'i:»,z\;<T';" I
:85; Sré. _
SR§N§LiNfiRA§gfiEhm}§A?E§§
?§€§%§E"%?¥g§gg?axA
,. $ V__
RE?EE§EN?E;;8¥;
'*5TA?E?QS:x3&§&:?€u?@R
V;§eH€®§R§ggmST
--»B%§G%LG%€_*
5
....».
M
"J
3~;:;:u: ;--a3:>::>§;+:A§, ES E*';¥LE§%Z§} 3?; if,é¥ii.E3.{§' A $3; ,r:,:>§a%z§,:,»x:~;3/5; ;:a:;x::?xr~;@' mg: 2mg;:~:?:-*' § "
"%«;;:;
E3/»'*£<'.¢§' ~ ii E{7'J': _'%§:i" 24'? Of' E2? ;K7»§§> f*~§%5."a §§{}\€ ENE; E3} i 7\Ti;>%{§=3{%{} éMP§{§f€(}?\§7'aE§L7V'? §*ij%§~?iV 65> E§{"}.7\"i? E34 fV,\;é> ? §éIf, in {;i:'}.:':.N<;>.2€§(352{}€3?} i' V E.§;*\ i~;§?7,\*i:\%{ ;"€E:\'{j %;*s.§'?*.»*X H.x':§T¥.é 36 YE{,»'\I{.\', '1 ;,~\\":~",--x B.:s;,«x2'":',;2, Eifééé i E _\;@:\%< ;»292>,»x mi: jé , "
2* 9;:
,.~x<;;{:\ _R?~§ V {By ssm <1; :3 )3, ADEr'<i§CA'§E*j;E§} % 812:": PR{;'S.§C§'§'{}R :'f<>'R '.9; :..<>%' A §{;5\.
W} 1% <: 5: i%:'mé*:<%::\;
:§%:;:'§a: Fag;
8%' L. A 1 ;%..:;>.:: $1; iégjazzaszifg ' %;:v,«:§,<;m»:é': §§£7é:é}.,Z% <3 1;: ::~:;:; :*'%£>E>EAi 33> §1'§T§,§%Z§iL} U;'E+3 €;,i%€ié>.{; Ef§':" ";§m::; ~ '?§~§f .5'x;?>E3EZ%,,§,,J% ~ T 3;
, §3fa3§6%E%;§i§ ;i§":*' *m';f%: "
§':,,}{'.'}2:; <..:<M;:~a::;:<,:*:":figs: :<;>:;: ma 2 * * :
"%aB&N§%L@QE'{& . my,' if?" 2* 3,35/V}:
:35; 9; §'>.\,>'_/55> 4 £iLK5A§"L&§§£SS&¥XU:
Asnauwn gwn*xy§,:a §{A?SLRAX&U§ :
if if Sr:
53$;
?£EE§A?§Kfl?K%§?% ) §E?§E§mN?E€VfiY S?g?S£Hfifij€j~' §fiQfiC®U%?g Kw 3 w ~ , « V --;~ yr { M K, .. ' _' X :%:E:» ,. ,3 , V ' ._ xiii: fidijiilvéii, 1/~.,;~ * X K, _ ,1, I 9a3:gg ~ 30% }4?flR% Q/%?S§€f Vs':
'" 2 zsirrsré ;;2;::::«.,2:1V'£%.
/W '2' 3; 34:52 %i :5: RE
2 §l}.2'1":'° , *1' M iii <_j::s:
5 Ti 5"' L 5': Pi 3151/"':
I 1 £122? E'??? Eé%§:*\,§%3§§'xE{V} LEE' §f}%:;E.,EE~"E11 ' j §;§,é}':«~'t.:'i Ki}:
33 ff T315786': 2?:p;3&é2,*:Esa 2;u'i3€ {mi {>1 ()7; E 2.2005 ;:>asss<?<i ':>j« {he C'ri:i~3::'i<t: 2im.<::?; E3<3sé;i:3:*:%; .§L2'c:§_§3;:*:._I{l' in S;C§N0.23,!2{3Qf3 by wh*£:::h Ehizi:%§32é2:":n<€{i§ E'%.§«r:s:;:'<:;:::-5::.,E'L::%§:;@':
C(>r:<J§<?t€{§ -E":€ app€§E2:m:;s;; for {his <V;f""?<T:V.%.;:'A<i::**':f+i; 125% Ti'§?c{::E:;>:V';s'~; E4§3§ E432 E48, 326) and EL, '" ,:.,E_§<%:tA::é<>22 3/??? {PC 2;m.<'i A M E§:':?:?,€fHC€'{i sszzcéa of thcfim EC L:.:":.<;i. .,biV}..iii}j;}%"'§'f%{}'f2~;fIE'i§'ii (E2; 2;: §353:*2}:V::::E 02' six r:1<m'£hs far z:fsff€:7, fa: z,i_fl'fjC:':?_ Secéifari' ?4'3":'PC, :'c»;<> ;;a2:1V:'s; fit}? 4 50:" <[>'f§€:": <::€:: ma =:§a%:* offemge under E§e..<;ti-::*;*;V 144;?' '--I??'C,«.:xé*V<> S6:c*:1'<:»n E48. EPC-3 1:{x»~?:»_-faiéezrs'~f"{5r...§}:€.'offenatsé Lmder E§eC'{.:<>z": 346 iéz" §#§<~::z;:ié<m Eék zamd WC? ':¥v<> }'€éT%.Z'%3"~- 0:' <>§Vf:%:3"C.é:% 2,, fg/€Z:EZ?'S %3::2:.ftiéez§}f§€Eé'€£t_Lms:§::§:r* E?%§::%a:;t'ié::>a E3213": E2 'xi/Ewéécé aC::_L:s€~%:E.,?'£a>.3.E.. £1;§'=§ C{}E'"§¥3:C'ii€{§ {ins §;E:<i: '::>2::2;:E'«: 5;? '£333 {'§§'§'€;',Ci' 5%)?' ,, ,, ,1'; 2,%3,<fT{T :2 ii » a> 3 T W.) 5"'-.'.
C3 .. J ""'\ W) ("N /"K W, x * a' §;T.{mV':s?: E3': fi? :3 v 4 , 4;
%zaf:.='€: €§£'T:€Ef'i, CV{>.%f;z»'::~:%:€;,: 2;:":z:£ V; zrvéééi --':EE{,: ::,2%' S§€?€§,§£1E§E 4: -3 «*%ii3{§¥ §3n:{::.? 239:; :.A:r;:m;7:V;§;i viiézzagzz? in §'£"{f}'£":§;, 53:' éfééé Zr*:<>::;~i+:<:% 8% :5 :3 m 23> mi 32 2": I E?' fa *7:
1 Pi' ' E3 is; {';;€%E§€f 53f ihié §::2*<3$€<tz;;iV§<>:41 éfE":;:2'L1 :52: 2?T'"3_:€§3€;}E €235) 223;: L2,:i%;I;*:'«».'a"i":.zE 35%: :*:'§%;§"s 2E":<;> <sEf2ja:ra:é of 4:322s;is"a:a:'£é§:;: ve.*2;i:E} sf? {Em E39353 <25 ;52§<;tL;:%;e:':c:% :'\?<;).2 ji*:éi:i§"2§;':2£§"}"25E,, %l2s;:rs;%::1§E<3:3..§:é:2E;ii§~Eig2§3;
Eefinai *w€:a§>(>z2:3 Ehééjv hzzséé C£:7:i':E'S{T".C§ %:":};:,mk'%s; 2:) §3{?I"S§~f§__E":ES' §3E,1S§i'i/'EiY:~Qi§ Ké'}7§§=:mz';i, ?\,='§; V ' Lani~:€g)pa §<;<.>Eie:":m} ?:3t§2::p;:::;éz_ §v<:i3'§E<?m;'"2é 2;*éz:j<;§" Z%%,§§§5é;'§'L%§;i{"*Cé:
wiih an §3":I::e:3'i;é(>n 35> égegmmiz 'z1_f:i:szj<'s<?-:1!' ":i>§ 3%:-£27:%;.;22;**:._:.mV:hgéppa * if if} :11 if séf. :3 E33? :3 :36 £{<;:3€:mé :1hercéf;},g 22:26.61" E3r:%C'a:k:>:3s; M3? zmcfi Li'P'«f;';fi}:; §';'iL:{ iV%:V:%:';:2E§e§g:3} &'i_§§6§§E2S§; the: appésfizmts t}"121'{_§>::.. :Vhej'Ae2,E3'<§v<: §sé.z*£.:<§.V_g>Ea:::;a::;V siazisé ;?a_m:E Eréfigefi Ejeing the men'1b<%'1* :¥:~._{:§i'=-v-;§'g":1é1'x?g§f;:3;:
3a'§<é}'%.§§>:2:r£§",'~€E*§»=:r§'e§:3v? €h<:%%»;
g;:*ic:'w/"om 2"; LE ii "iT:':"; . égéfg-:3 Egg i WC"
.1 /'V :0 have <::c:}m 15f1§§ 'i§?€f? e::_i"; 1%: is; '§Li1"?:§"3€f €;,E":2?::i._<>:€--. i%;~~::§ ésamaé d£::V::€:, §}§£:7s;C{f ;~f:£1'"E{.§ {$333, {EEG ezagiéfjzsgséi I Lzsaési E2 amij Ea E%2>tse:2:s*x72:i:::"z:*:j, EVE &iI'}fL{E:'é'§i, I 1 ~:
if'? 2~e,':"ez:% ;2:§§:;7;;:<;3<j 22:': §1:»m~'s:
i E - A.
"'--~aia§::m§:§<:_d {)§f.E3C€:§ azzzdsz Eéecéieia 1%,/'aw; Ei§:3a:z§::>:; E43 ~.«}.j::<is;'-§L2:":E*:€§*.é;?;;;:r§;€s:§ éha: 6523:: cészza, ;::E:2::t5: am':
the '£TI"E€E'?E§;3€§"S; <3? XL/:5/fiE'§EE£,K;§3'§~E//ég €323 Z572,CiCT'L,%i;'*,§{:'{E iha <:z}m;€%aé:2a'z2: 2::z2{:i §:3};ur"<:=<:§ pa:<:*s;:>:2:; fkéiézéfijy' :3? E4?) §?'€ji. E: §':;;:"':E1<.?t:" ziizéiaégstyzé ':%'1;.2'i <53: E3263 2;,i3}{}i"fif? sazzzzézé <:§22E€, :;f§£:1C€ 21:? {E 2'32 £17::"1:§*:€:*g:m<:€ <35 §§""::'? s:t{> m :31 i:;>a.;": "-:;4>':>:g;I:f:%<t%z {E3 :3?' saws <i<j2:::"::2":§iéV«:=?<% 'aha: '.fTi1.,§§"iC§€?E" <55 §"§?":é%1*2,E"32:E-':;_".' 2": é3:1\f<? £j{}§'E/2 m it i; <3 6% ' ' " 2%-7% .
Eh €:mi%':3}~'. Eh 234:1?' a22E%{?§:/;<%::'§ to Lmder Sections 3023 3/;'u;. 149 {PC ';§i%'€T. }3:"<i§':x.:;ir "':;:?TzV:;;> <,.eass;{L 225%;
«W Tim g::>2"<2se;<?i7u:ii<;>:2 in <i>:
examinsd in 21%} %<} xaéi;z33s;si:::.s; ;:;mé;:E :§"§Ev€:l7i7f'..§<:€{§ E2X§+;§?E 3;; PW p1'<t:du<:{3d F\/{€383 U) E4. The Eji{.'CL§:4;€:?{§ 839 0f 50'i333 C3€??§E33"-4"'?L??..{:~4v 'z;hs;2é 2a'§i;Vn»:%s:es;e%;«:
'i'h€1"E'ES€?§¥..'€'S had' £:{3:逧3 :5' =:i'<éé;.% :*o'}?"-ifhzfg i'*éo::@E FLETE ':3;> z:s.<:<:u:;:;é<:i N{:>.2 zmd £1': '§E'1{iE'{"§é?'§'3'£,, éaj.><:>i~:; ;:1;'a<*<:+ ;:a::":r:§ .g:a§'{;~{:<3s *:hs3§e§<>:"€, 1':h€~j;,j .;;<3%;f<: E E€;2::"nt~:§ E3 =£;,<~:*;<:;:3s :,z£:§g;{€% 2i>f:€:' 2?1§}§}E"{'f?{L?§2:EEL§Hg i%7<;% s7;%:»":i<§{;>:4"::;?:% {iii/Z :*<%€:';:r'<3. E3 ?;%Ezi§ 21?? 31% ':32 ;§;:;::';_9e3EEs*::3§s; ::3:"s;? ii :;t<>?2 22:: 53:
88$"; 3253?": 'E9? ' {V-3 ' 32%;? zhszéé §«i%22:ms~:% §:{'}%,Z1";$:';'?E i'<i;:* E:?§§.TZ?}7}%%:"§iE:1,E'"§E~E*§ :»m:::.%i /"H s" _ :3 T526 E:i'»:%}71,E"i'7{'i',§§ (fan: :1 :~3{-->i §'<:»:' 31%": <5 2~Vm;t3<i€E2:2':1*{Vs; E'>::':i"§1.s; tzézzai;
21% the <;::%;:;sL %;E'":<% §:~z*::>si;é;*%<:L:'£::':>:'2 \%"'§i',§'}<i?S§T,{i?f€; ':':::I22><=,:= :~4;:;g>pzV'oL 2/u:'%i";' {>5 the in <:i<ii<;é:'1% gm {#1 5:? 211:: <21: 2;: :'§%2:?2§'i:z3:3j -' L, .
mazteyieai (313 :'€:c§>:':i ii: is; E,3C?€}'§ tVE12:2 :,..M{§1<? g:§'L.é'*é E}? :i:3:+;*;::r"<[[>§; 33:7: £7? 's3h:5;;> s.§§§§i<;:;.® w:':ness<%:<; v;2,é:s '£52: <7<>mg>Ea;::<:2 Q4 3 <f:»v;n€':i s;m<:§ 31133 ?;}}~' :aé:'><::_:$c£i N{V>,2V. ft-..é:e; fizz ;fE€%Z~" 5 éyevvftnessses have SL.E§}§}I'€S,_S€?C§ =;zé:é:2v:"i%fl€$.v':s;::zfl€§@:::§ by 333:3 E.1CCéIS€'.C§, in z"z:%:'~;p€C;:i 5;! (:52? is §E§€:::i§ E13};
:i%1€;i1" C;
:E*1':.%;'a';--._':§';€ ";»21§c1VV:s;e€} N92 zimzfi the accused No.3. if his fathsr B:«1:s2:\;::i é?1j7._E' M S;VL.E-fiv7{é'1'<i'~i'f *:41F'1€'?._vE{E':Vj";EE'*§§?E; if: Ehs: i:'}<:%;'<i::%m;;
ainti the §:"<:~v:;::%'<::--;}:' :"<V%;;s:V:zV'x:Vi£23g_};' éém '$52 €,':££LES€d an ">:;h€_ .é::;>;:é::i%f§c<:§ ::'E3is;%E1 i:2:%.i:7;§'::V<%s E22533 {E7}?
p:"é>§;€*€:uEé<:=:1 2?-§é§"..:3 aisij <:is:i>:":A;--.{:% p aa':§EE"2 abs? {?§{?£I%,§'E E"; zim <35; :%m d E132'{€:'":é:§"<;2z°s:':i§1zi._g;{;:<:t_::i§<?<:E '§;éé<éz:ii §<:;r 2%: it §>e::a:%1<%?i':, <3? ';,{f}{,;, 3%:
§L1:*:§':<3:" ..T_iE*:*:/X {E25 ms;;2§5>§"é'i;%: €12? '(Eve 'f}§"{}§§€f{fLé'Z§{}E1 '=.2;:Ié'§z1€$$€€_5 aré. .§:':~--1::;3*:*<i%s;::3€:§ wi?;Vn€:§é~;<?s§ 2::§":::E :23m<>§:s;: 'daetm ,£>:§'.{}5§'S§s '§,E'1C{}E"iS?:5r§{{?§?C}/', 5:5: 322%' 228 §;3<":é{:%€5r:'::
""3 M "-.,..,.«/ "4 WW} ("I1 (".3 W:
swé 53> Q IMAAYWWZ WM.
'"3 «D f. W' M»
--ml 5; > M a (W +-
C!) (W 4*
-"wV'*' ;..J 1"'\ M
6....
<""""f"
(":5 z/'"''\ \v/ W;
("V M."
C "*3 ,/"''x mm' WW.) ("T2 ('MN \vw/ wwvé NJ W _ .r'""'» \ ¢ {Mr W .
."'°'x V2 wow! W} {'2} <5"
W» Wm ("Q V-wk ) £{:{iE'§'Eij£. E: f:;:"£é1€~:*; s;:fz>::2éiz:%<i} 31%;' Ezézzé ?;E3::»ifié1 égéw *--..3:f*:%';:::::é;s:?s:§ s'~¥:[3«.E zimzii :1: s<;<%%:':§ ?'3if}§"§; %;»::s :>»:;§3 3:22: f_ff{'Z>;s'";:if£:"{§3<':i*{1§ wzéffé as? i;E"E€IE5§ :23: aimszfi 2: »:f:E,<;ii{T?"%,i.f~':1;{?{f'§ {>5~;.2 3:11} 4% §"{:"' (W &....w ¢ §':?§:::%:c{;% 31:; «€fE:':':{?§"1 s:>*:§3z:1* 25: :1 Q 3%": <:%:*<:{<3:"s? :1 33 as §<*3:zm2<?<§ E;§€f?Sf§§{,}E'"i :1; ::*zj;;;:2%é:i%<E 5.'§£?{iE§{')2'3 E4??? :10 z*s>§3<;:: 9%.. ::?:§E»[~.?;EVm {ézzcizgaé E22523 'm"<V- \ \ a<:C:::;é3«:i 1:"; {hrs 'Th<*% §'fiéE'{}E'~3{5{?L,3T;i'§<'}':'E Er/33234; 13031 63%,. fink ':3€:Iiw:%m3 the 2>2<:<:L::;<2><E l\k':3S.2 {<3 31:1 i§":«:'tt~'"s:é:"é:3.f§":2:72:26',;im:i Ehati 2;:<:::>:::$ed N<):':;.E 3::/25% 33 H} 9" _¢ii"'Z;ij é?:2iéi:':<;%{E. _?E[>::f.v €¥{'E'} "'{E:TC§{?E" 4:12?' acquiétai am this g:'<::um"i itsagéf. i*;__1'..<:s :fi'12.;r_*:':a_Ve:" :'~:¥,,1E3'j:31.i:E'.'[V€;'.§i by 'mm that th<:>ugh 1": is; 270: 3: r;'as'~:.«:% "%;a5:'fTc::r£~= V E ~%'f§{i}*:E_:"':;3 :;§3::': :::z:{:u.;<;€I::§ arr': emitied 'L0 t&l<;<? ';'.E'3€:.__$te2V2ViiA.4§ {§§~:§.Cif '£§::--f_é:i"1s;?&:,r;>'f §:w;'°c);>c>:* 5;, $8158 ' .V_3iE"E£':':if, *zE2<:% i;;<;:>2a>_ s'§"1<2g:> <25 ffififfl the: sari (ism:-.:'c iifan ,- t{:eré;--... .1 a<:<:L1:<;<--:d L? é:r;;z';1p1:3€€':vEVj;-":§<2s:is?<§j;é><§ :'mm€«:§§e:s.:;a€jg '::<-id {Em seatsiézié? 0? c>Ci:L,mi"2:":<t{3 aftsir C®V:';1:"§'€<}';3::!%:é.§%;:::§<é» 5; .%'\i{}'8?Efi;'I2{}{}E :i:§'2<::"<:% §?':cr (Siva? §3:2:*s;;V2:V12<:<é :1}? "--?:.}*se <}:*"a: 3 {'.~:':%'a:i:f%, %E€{:'S"'3.E§2fEiZf"2§.{;'£j stziisg-:;--«a;:;:<; GE'{§€:%:'" ii': €.:a:»':>:;§* <2»? 2&8 EECCLISGCE N{;:,;?. €§":;:2.t, {;'f"~,»'€"f3'7': if tlézc {*?E"E'{i:';'€;? §s":::::§:::§m3'i ii; '--...é>.e'§m:°E¥;<::f§ as §~:_z%;_p§:S:;%':*3<-:%::E; 3:13:63 22:13 {'t'E':§E;'{EE?{T§ 2&2 {§f3§?5E'EC{¥ ir2::{§,'1-5:c'::<:»s:§ to {§€§:'f3i"§{,'§ ':;%":€§:* ;_m$ F.:3'%2«:*;a?:é;_ 5: €:,::"'{?':s:>*~? $2/:%::3?3izi:::>s:§ M32": %;?":.23éV {Ear i'E"e,::'»:
"*§:é:3§;»"駧:f;;?:E <}:~'<%%:*€ é':EE'fi? 'CT{,}§";{TC?iI'Z';{"f{§§ 7{§"§{', §}§"{'}§§i?é7{.§:3§,{3¥§MZ E3": 6' 2:w;%g::*:§{§:E": 21:21:'; :3 '£?':%f:' 1é3§1;::"ie:?:4;
p<%rss<>z':s;. i?'22<:f§<ir:" E'§'}ii,*. %iT'?§"€IT2,Ei'3'1f~§§,é:iE1 Eézzzé 34;i.%}f}§'"§":?:§.,-5% 333:2: {E1 if' azc£:z:i«;sw:i 531%? :<::":.':':'3;E@=:i %'<::§:" gm <.>:'{:%s3:" 2}?' ::a<,:<';§::é'{€::«;:§ zmai psi; a,f5i~;.._§:E2::1?; {E526-5% 23;)/p<:%2?:E E';2ETi}' E:::::% aEE<::*;{%{§V if). The E<:?ai::':3e::E Hééfh C{l}L':f{ {E<2v;i§:'22:::'crj:::7,9 ;; "
oihez" hamd suiozmts that 'aE":<;é e:<;>r?:._;3};¢1.V_:°:";1:V ::;;:*i"é:s::--x,' E §T1d3:'v"§{1LZ£?i.E c>v<:*r:: aciiss 2;ma:% {hat "{§';,€ "";?'.u{§'E'f3§}§§E1§I';i'§L3_E:E!§"E-E18 ":3éz;1V:c%<% in the Csmpiaérzt :*e§;z1rdi:3g ssgisécgféat_?{>v<§:'E .42:';,€: f'A':"x:..'{:*§' 2;::::tta:s€::% E\5'c>$.i2 and H63 submits '(E223 a(i:<:u5;€:i_<::i .N<V:»:E .'E'2.;23':4;--[;aa;§;zmE§:<;%€:§ 0:: zimz':
E: *aC§, {if PWZ wiifn V ' ='e2n'":"d ;éL<::tV:i;-é€:~:%....F~E<222' ;::::"ss3;m'%iV§%:§ on 'she PW E m't:h C111 u':3--j_ E30 Efifif}' E3:C?7':L§'S'Cd "§\J<:>«§ {1,m,§'2<:r 2;2s;s;2212,,,:E?;:a:><;§ ?V\/'3 emd PW4. rf%C,'»;: L»§S'€?{:,'§VNif}v.2g}'E27'3S ':'?:Es;a::> 2*:s;s2&:L2'Ei1é;%<::i P\/'*fE":. T§":<:?'i":% 221:6 é:A:{%§2r§r:% Lia? 52$/':"€3,§'"§, 'E-,:%;*§'.T_E' 'E§"<.{"}"§§ ;§é::gté§;':é<:%d N 5-i2,33<§ 4% in '§"€;f?f%;§}%?€QT3, cs?
" 3 ;« éirsaih <>f;'i:§'}:3 d€::':%;é§:§ %é::§" R3 Lfzzréizmr E9'Lé§;}?§2iEE§ Z;
fa-::>a;./§}EVz7:,:";:»:;:v:é(I:::'"a 5:? V ;
W Wm M ) *'\ M ».
«x N-> W Rm/I hm;
, M ..._ M) ("N :~m<:§ §??"W ' §":a\;é: acééifi 17¢-§%:h'v:%C<>mm{3:": <>bj€a::i <2? iiggzzssééztgg 353} on ?E?v"2 ;é';2<€ .,<3::E*;.:>:* w:%::V";<2:+::s;%::; §.'?i3"§{§ ?;Ez€:"<?fE>:i":*;% E':"::=? ifiifisifff" :3? {T{f}E?'=»/'E'CJf,,i»{l3'f3 'w}3§:_.i~;sa:,€:s:E« , * % 2?€::i::E;e3<:§ is El": ixéii": E11 * é;:2§j>m';'e:i<2s:§ E33? 'iéézza *::%é.:2: fli? E 22222:; <:§£:?23:"Efa :%§§i£§i,':if;"f§§ as ar:e::m:--: :(«'~;* :6: $352223 '<2 f2{;§3E :E:':<-, :><*<:": :'i:{§%';,{'E"*: (1 E: 1 :E:< fhig: €<>m1"<:*{:::é--<§é: "$6? E/22&:<% E3:"<i>::g>;§2§ 23: f§$§§:§§,L! «:,i,:~';%"s:Em" §'é'<:=:'1:; .3367 E3235.-sis; {>5 ?,§"E{fi' <V:<:«mLg>TE::sa':':z 01?' 2e;<:<i::s;<><E :V>)3 2,':1§2i~§;f:'z12: aha: <>§%':V1%:7:<:<V;*:~;
azmisiz" Sa%<:§é{m$ \>;5\>% 584% %v:>2r:<:§ z.%;i':E"2 :'§{f?<,itE,"§:--'5,?vZQ_"'-33$-._{éf {E353 sand ;><éi1<Eé:§;g; %.:"zi2s§ 22:2 s.;L:'i>méz;s.; tlnaé, am gi;2:'a>s3<:<7Luf§(>33 T of the iE7C';d€i?}'3§, as 23$ % :':<;>i ijsafiiz":<?1'_%i}z~:':: 't;}f1f_::,7:i_§%' 5%;
an 1"'f5'C{[}}"<'f§ am (3 :3"; sz*<3i:'[2:r<>, E10
7. Ti":<é §3§a{)$€?{f§r'E{»i{§E/E in E';-*':i_s; .§ji :3 2&2; 5s:;::7:'{i%<:E in ':E'::% fiimg {sf '£3163 <:<;mp;§:1ié':--
Complaint: Ifhaii :v:§";<:«:i'ci_é:1 "' <A:ar:*:;i:::: {>33 Eh Q?"ifégréc::2€L--:.r::£%. :ai<1>1'"E«:. Th (2 E?i{f(Zf'Z,.1i~%(7?{,3, 0,2 C£§1"E€j,.='§§'2g on '§§:.;3 :é2: §:Vi"«._f%:>%V:: 0? his; §"::>:;:~';€ 3-mi? he '%}~,':€Ti,,S§ § h€%7z'f{i§'7{',£'§ vgzgziésg < gfiézamézz ':3; 'C:{}3f3§~3FE"L.EC75§_ §":'z'L :¢:§, ;<»'{é§3,,1§§£§§ bf; r<?';3§s§<:2,£":
E"s§:~is him ii, ':3 E2 §3§"€fK»'£?E'E§f:?{T§ §'i.2_3<;:€' ~i;ajE<f§ 'L in?
MM] '9 A, 5 ii l'§r'r W i''\ \,~. (3 4- A /'x' M 1"/r--,4,. 3 f , ;";;L,§{% as ;_;i1:E~.» {:33 lg§{'i{1,§{.}§{;, 3% 219::
3, ' _<i'zi;.;*%E;:g:=§":"% *:€:::_i ijiiié €.Z{:é:"'::. E: f::1"§ff": cg" :~:§3[?f:ii"ifC'3; §":§z*£ 'iihzszz, E3'? 9 (V ;;:::€_. e:jé§7 £2": i:é{E%3i":% §{}V:,?" E£Z*i'zi,"\;'€?§"5S i:>"<';%m éfiéirié €<1>§z *a.x*E";<[; v;<--t:
. ;E£§Z3§T}{}§.E:"E§[{?{§ =:7s.V>:;:"%1 <:<::m:':3§ss;§<V2§': 322%? {T'f,}§EE{l? :13: <::- Ef}'§\.'g3"L§:'}{\.::F;$r;i/ if}? §;:m::t% gm ail ;;g\,§?f?
?E:2;:Vt;_ 0?"
E?€E€E:2SLI1'€§§ Eh ii' ism (E; 312:5. zéazi :1? §:3;;::<;%E< 233:: ;i2Zi:s<>:.M;1 {§.{}§f} ;:E.:r21 E¥'§"'iZ?3":€;?C§:§&2'£Zé'f§¥' E§'1€?:<"€;?E1i«';'rii?Z". 'iézaé 2:3.{,',{,Ti,E,f§iZ,',{"i a::E::>2V':V:2; vs:éiE'"-. >T eight p€3§'S(,}§2E§ Czzmsé :":<%25::* I315? 'gm: 542152;} 2:f1e:§ :E1:';:?;'.--§ " ' :::';3uSéng, PW? aim 6% his; §3:'<;:w%;}": $3? as 12 5% {}EE">1v€?1'8 :%.<:%'i*é:%%"
ti': ms an {E Eh mfg? Vx'é?1ES C><::h2m (>5 <§x~.'m'<§ «Sn, "'f7§'?$§j§">{'7£f'{iVV @ A5 .0 ";>1'i:i:${':~;'1 " » §.*'zCCU§3€fj N32 gczmg {<3 ihe C{}§§i';'E~._2?i§'1C;; '-§{<i?1iiiE3§%._E;"{f§':; "'{j;:ie',§m" <93?' sEatus~C;L:<:>, E: fUE'§:'1€E" _S{é3,,'i,T€C§V_i17: '?i§":'i?.._v <:<>::1;;%3§--2%.§mV:LV.'3LE222: {he ' 2'?
acczgsezd :§E2.:1'E€CE a§;$2;L:%iét1<>é*h<i:--<65;::1E§%:t+s£zVé2:.f:A:; :e*;~::a:é {}i}"if;?§"S grand 21?;
that time {hes dascascd :}:§%i?"3i§:§"2"}.Q?7i!.§:é'i}}§"}'&,",':3?
more a:":<:iZ :>vi2:'1&% P7 23<7CL:sed n4<:>S.3_.
$1.: 9 "<23 ': V _ E"; i'?
accuséd Ne,-'"--?~<~= * :§':%i_LE§E€53'€:§~ =::>s":'--.P':z'1»"E .2§%\":'":v:EV--v<VE%z4/2 <;»::hs>i' E: is 4.4 «.7. m >., §":z:'w€ g2ss;z2m%§ec§ (E33 E313 aiéegeati '£E":é:~'i;_ €0m§::x%a23;:aI:2:s; gézazijy smszfi z::<t<::zs~;::?<i £:'é§"%{§ ;
2:s;ss.2f::1E:: is": tbs £T£f}f'i'E'§3§2;駧'"E :1; §%,<:::::::?;€::;'i ';"€:;>s--»8; =e:"}<;% _9>£<:<:s £%,S§§E§,L,E§ff3{§ bf; §?32:::":::i:+3 aim {:2 ?:}:"<;"%;;:<5:*° 5;}?
2:: '?é}2E3E,~f; <1}?
w;>§.; 22ss;.:_--:uE*:%:<:': 3}}! éTi€{"'/L2S:'i'd :<T§§,§'}i'§ ?Z'3§% 2 =2::§é:w:§, i§§_.EC§T3VEE;zbé"'fi'§3: is; 2,3353 "$3253 §E'ICiC§€72'§f, $53525 "._ %:'s:3.§:s:;>cs3:/2%:':§ at a':':3<}z;é; 63?} pm. 3: s;%iz:a':+:i:~{§ :33 §E";::> ::%{V;::<*:*;::§2'--:';m: §'3"£ZiTiE Vé'{T%§ '%'§}{'? :';§:*:<% 33 f"f,~2{[3"Z"; j é 5% 2 5 ' V Mm;
232V:ies;a>g;2§z:Vz%:E_ EE"sii'i" <:s>m§::E2s%:':2;znV3; %>2"<>'m::(%:/" zmsfi E}3'»z;25<i;<>::9 {>22 s;2=zi<:tE, C<,)E2§§3§E¥E%E'EE, I112 <5? P<3'1i<i<7 'h2:~s».»'s% N{3¢§§C};'2O{}E Ch21rg€ Shem 'sgzms ts'; be 'f?:§f:','Ci, s P15} is '£319 ::a:3mp%.;:§i3<:.gzn:1? H<?L----:s:[a2{<?<E Eh 3;h<:% €:(>%..é':"é {hat the: acCL:s;«:>cE No.2 S2::ng;;:::§V'*V*V tea Shep and iheif%$ i;Sé'iL:"' shay; is; ais<; 'L35? _:h>€j"'icié"+i:;§_ fa-2:s':Vd 'f;x:E*§ich E»:'~%2:2<Es to E3€EE2?:mL 'E'h<2 shop its <:©vé:'§é',é:§ f-M331-.};E':~i3s<:}:<:c£ :r'at:i<?s; am? 'iiheif aC<:::sm:§ :'¥<}.2 :gZ%§£%%§'23Vf1'§'§E§;{ ::€,;v.._g3€;--:..€--'%iE":é?.__S€;§%a E1', zéazxsfisg £22 3333 :<s:éf:§<i 382%: S§§'3{l}'§i2, PW? béififif271E113}?E"{}E§i,{i§i7_fSVCIi' "aha <tiw;E £62 21:": 23m (3 E*":2:sf~; <;>E>:Va%:V2 SEE éiii, :E":<:= C<f}i!E"{i §§'5:&1<?§, Cagmi ;2sséé":'{}:§:;é:r' %::>i{% *;e:; if": 325755521: :2? {E€.j?fji:,i,'i"E"€f'3"é iii? an %2.:::2s:E _ %z:s:%'12:j§;:::#t:::_f§> éiééé: E2212 5% an {E vc<%:2';:V 'z.:s:-;~1::E<:. TE": <=%Vz*<%za2Vf3:;&:>:" é?':C{.Tt 1:539/{E M13'?
"v'%j,i:.fgié§:./:féi:1::* £:T%_§'}L.EE%€€§ his §';3:%;E":es: E"€_:2:Ei1'"(§3:E"Z§Q§ E326': :'::iV:22":2;%:;:':V:a:2§<2nV <3? . _ %_é:--s;% %;:%$:i%£Es; 39 3%: £2 ';A<*%27:ss'z':::t;:ep. 'fie f'2'::%%;<?r {:25 Piéfé §g:,:<;:%:f;§é::::m':§§ 3:
E") ;[::§:>L:s;é:a§;»;, :%§iE"'i€_,?é:? 2? :3: 7' aim? £3 SE22? aj/:sas:"?;; Sézaiir 2E,{7Ct':.,Ei*,;f:?(§ Eh::%2"::%2;:f:Va%:" 3sIV;:::V'I;:%::*§ §*:',T"£<'}i""'£§':'§,£{ :V'<[%§::>::'<ié:3;: %,E3<;> {i<i;:::*i <}re:§<:>/2' £:1§§{f§ E%3e:%:":%s,;:{§m" b:'<>u<>E§: em §E"<:f}Z3 x:*<;%z>a:><>12 féqza 3:ss;;:zL2E?;<?€§ cm ihéi hsraefzéé (:3? ?'::':NC PWE 'x:*£%:3':V 25> é:":%:.1:*% {hat iime {E26 El-.':CCL,E_f§(','€i §\Es:>.2 2»;s;aL:§E<%<é§%§:23 <1:-25""
33327513. AM 01:59:" 2€:C<;T:2_$€d <;<;m*s:? §.31":i'?.;"S€??;. ';"?"Q1131' ~§§§{"'f%(%i?i'§{? ' :féf {}CCL:£"1"i'fI1<?{?. His; §;>:'*<,>1:V.?"2s;>:* I3E3S9»é[:R*'2T2§ V ; "E? as 212:} {E 6""?
mm» Vvw) "w E v {ié'3E'fl{? zééégisz' scene 05 (>CCL2E"§'€3":CC?.:.E§.§Ti(§ aft 'ifié d gisseuzééecé him by %T:('3£1fl§; 53? CEL:-E355' 7F§€@:*::;2;1VVf;§s:V;:__PW3";E;:h;z':"21:si?:~;h {::;7:m€ E}€?E:f:,Z" 'SE15 sscsm :3' :1} 5" .{'}'Ci'{f'i~§1_"fg§f? :2 <: 1;; = --z:f::*:--.r;§ E E': ' 4 ' =::t<;7: L': 53:? :3 -- 'xféj 2é:};§< 2:: $2 2%;
2133;; uitéé <>:AéA_?'i:'\/4%' ;3f:'§2:E*':.:; Ezjéxi E<;:s{;§g::_ {>32 E13: :3 $3 séaésii 1'": {E £232 his ankle' ?W5¥E.sh:xf2.-:ap~;::a'~~--{:am<% i€"E€&';*i"b}~' szmzj 325* w<%::~; ::?:E:i»v:> . . 'iii. ii 57:3": an ii. 22:': {E <73 2.2 Sii§§'E--Ei%:';"%§:i'_£§'§.§ié"%;if§f?'$A._§}§Z. 32:3,; Ea<;>2;fa. .42: '?§%"%€ ::%s<:€as;:;«3s:§ E¥§2§2z": L.E§E2E%§'§€L£i§§}§}8;
3::.f'i;__a:£n .ii§;§.§,:iréé3s an iziée héézzaii eiéziré fziieiiazé 2:::z":{:§ E36 ?":;::f::i§ fz::f§E€:":
. ':3 ~ . M. a:r3::§_ Ziékz {:3~a.:::,:f§ 1 235%: gas: 22%;}. 923;' E, z:1i:2:a:;: E 0:":
5:235 zvzaéési, q§'f}'f{})iE€3E"~B5§,»,3é%i'E2§"£E§§ ;h;7.a:"§ 7:"?2:i:f:_:,: {:33 M5; I:':%~::1{§. §":?:;'4~{%s'i;:s.}225i:"2t:::j;f;;2a: 2:i:§s;<:> aésii E": 63' EREJ E {,3 « 39.332 :3. 2': 2:2 3 ' (ff :«._ £;?:*::'2' :5: 2"; 1% ' ' 53 ~ ma :3 2:": 53% d {E :5 W b am {E V§:E"E,.§fgi§E1§<E§:§3§}§}E[Ti, {',.2::':'fl"E{? ziiigiiz' iih i'§%:T€_'?3}{,T.' <3'?
€.[>€;TCEEE'E"i:'iE{Y€;' a:2?:<,i Ezafiez/" eitm s;E2§fé;<;%»:E 1:E"m:'%m {<12 ':.§'i§€:;i= h{[>:~gg::i1i:2 C§'{}SS--E3}{é'zI'§Eii':5E{§{T}E"1 ii xx':'2z::: E%§3<>C§§'§C231E'§}" 3:37; §}":',r"*;;«'§'E"----
J accusssd E\«'Ea:21p21::hé hgiié $L:ssi2:éa<>c§ éné2,:_:*§a%s:;,_-'"§j':A:":. _"§?i,?E5E"fmias«V :'6E?*§ie<;i {E2 21 1:: E: G iiézfi 1301 C{)E"§1i'7' E0 E<:'z§t>.<,'x* ?'i:'E.s;;:*éf21%}i'533-E'53' sustiained iE3jL.EE"§E*S, E{§}ama><*tz"§ i;m:~ V§:::<.:E2%::_%*"~.n{4E{:>s$--"
' :;:V--a:t<i'a;;s;:'%::§ E'l<;;T:,':A 'iévzéfacé _iE€=<E 2::
€2<:5:::':énaié:>:"g PW} bags s:«zdm_.i€;€<'ez§; zhzez E {i€{}_E'E3§3§£113E'i'E §3€:nd§°.;3g:;
<:::>?r:pEa£r"::i é%i§};£ii§"1SE theém 2s::é"<E' {via} befare the sam$'£ZC:L:1ji, Etégs fa PW2 iihat the d':*.g:»:§ <_a:%'d him in tbs 5?':/"§{,31€E"£i$€ imjidemi has 112:}: E3:%pVg:3'<3*;iIcdV ga, Cr0$s--5Xa_mif:;":§:s13' 13};1326'*;z§i:.:gé;;%{%3 ii fi.EE"{h€§" {séiatééisii Eha':1
Ehi? 'a*\VV*2::§;"'..{%f»<:és;f€;V:'iv";;;;;gérétaé" 2:5: EEK? é:A1<::§<%<?:2:, 211214; 3332722 ziféssr J} 9 /~-'--
.~--...:
J2 /"N V..../ cw .'''"5'' 0» § M» «"3 r Q1"
\...z W 2336 ~é:_1a3<%_%_::~;:;_3;2s:._'Lara s;%3:,;;,= ax Em: %§""::;sa:;., £2 P§*f'1é1:§*::3f:"§3é"'=:£§€:E 4i":.T<>f'€%:s:%:4": ihéséixi :%:a%; :'E*:«:> '§,E'2C§{'E€'§"¥€; W{}L,§§{§ *:2:{§/6 £2": S_3EjC ": :3 :*:":s.2:u9::3€:* €51 3:339 <::<}m §3§£1%§§'§ :4 .TE?iiz':2V4"L22V:2i:ep:3a_ %§a:':a:":32m:%2asgjgsa %{s::;§§:;>2rmé éestsség aE§;<.> 4'v,_<:§,*f*?i_}:"{:Ts:55:€f;-C333": i§":€ $213353 nzzmszsiz 'i§'12%3?I 53% §3WE, E3"; 31%;:
W.__s:X3,:fi€%fiai§€,2:2 if @§ée::7i:><t;
§::§€{E 3%"; S'.~:{i'i%;";%":'? {T25 {f}{§fiZ§LE§"Z"{:7E'"%iii?K ii is; 2?
511 siééjéiéécf 'ziéaéf; 2}: ':ga22,::z':* éasaék j{;§2:1<::<i in §'§f?§>'§}£7f'{Ti§;' 4;; §°§3<1% €€=e:?::;'m>§;= azié '$133532 §::s<>'i1h {E26 :s§2:Ea%s; ';22*:a:<;é <;:22::;*§'<EE<><€ Gthef. Hawevczézp {E is :~;pé3<ti1'EC2:§£Ej;~' 5/§§<::'ae<:§ fzxism 2:335? izé<§:,J:..T '7' PW2 E§'1E?CL' €:7i,{iCLESCC§ hé7%i»'éT% 2":{va:';%:' s;22s.<s::V2;:,§;igQ{% 2::::">--j§' "::;.§.i;:fié:%'2; E3 I"
fnlrther SL,}§.>;§3;(?S'E,{i'.£': an Ejyééimzlé" <2:
,..+ is C.' 2if:,<t"<¥:.1VV2:;:§?L: ~ ';'V\¥:[>IE_ f'I'1_;;é 1 ;
no C<)11m:C%;i(;}n §'}€ff'W€?C?E'E 'ah-€ s3§1<1>;§_ }i::::;f:{E :'}3'{: Vai;:<;jLés:;cC%. '§"$<;::, 2:3:":é::§' 'ihai a(:cus;r:><:i Ne:-'E *«;a'as; S€L_.é{§,}"iE'§§§E31?_:Q}:E3,}'%3.'2:i,§§ "é;;:3HiE?:;i% ii%2;::£> 4}?
éncédezza E0, PW3»B;:S'* -.f21j"Le:§i<:ipffi::2_ §<--'{31E:'->.:ién§ $2228 5:Ess<:» :s%;a{€<:§ 'a:"c§in§§ 'aha? 52s;:f~;2m§i '::>j\;' bef<:>r*<3 the (:€:.}!L1E~:V: :/}LE\§: pr 2*" V '*~._a:"::Z €379 ci<:*<:<>;:as;<?<i, in Ehi'. <:z":>:~:§~ 'zhe a<:<::u:s€<Ji on é €Xan2éna.€Véa:>:"g'§ ;'£i€§;"§"":f*J *:%*z22:i §§'I"2E":1f:?C§:i2EE{?§§' 2:z§"t:::%:* 3322;?
E27 23:: _§§,"1€ ::;f'j:?:*: 51% Q? {f}iT:€§ 1:: :';"<%:": <:<3, :V§%<? 'w"~JE:'{E"2i1?f§f%§{'?ft£» ":£€Ti">--f{i' §§'%.._:EEé':;§. V:r?{;:a--*:é' :§:'€r._.:{~:222s;E1<;:;3 é,%,E"'}§"% ;;a:,s;51-:;a2:,2E:z:€% ';3m;% 2:'s;V<_:::';:,z::;:%<:¢*§ zmcé f\ , ' K v.. 3" ; .' _, ;/ 2.3"', \ A' fig. A , ;__ agié/iezsg. «E%'@*2.. '>3 ?%%3 nggzs sésmcié ma? s~);:::/ms ::»u;.§;ag3.:;i;<>:;, E: as §':é:'_'{E°;€:r i'"2":f3:':r*; PEME $232: {$26 '%_>€E<>:/zgggsg 'ts 2ac<%a1:~;€::E %:Z%4;*i3_: {aria}? %4:<} {Ewe '§E"2C'E{!,%i?:f"§i? 1325323 '~fi:'E%,fi ~§é;E": :%;:::g3;:22;% wéé; :13": <1:«E;§: $2" :a':1<L:: 3* " 3 22:; qua:":"§1 ?E«'x:'3; kv'E2:{%":a:':i€s%2 2:::2<;a:'§";<;?:* :13";
' xx , 1» ~ , ' »- 4 ¢ 3?: 9 Csvi iii? * w 0,?" PW ?"sf::'%;'té 22, s;: :;>;t:2:VVL::V<>2V"fa {<5 éhé?
;::::m€E":2:me:?zm2:1 Ei><:.§?'21 £2: <?l§s:;téts:><% in 2312 {,',E"{}iéfr3~<?Xéj*iEE'i§f'E§.§'€:§.§}'?3. ii)?
PW?) {hat {E26 C2386 aa*a§; <;=i2<> in z'€5;p<=?c*L <3? {E€?ZTE{if3§§E§ii}-ii €[i}{"Ei?:;EiS§,[ ' of ;s:_c:{:::s{?<:§ N<:}»2I P\7\!'7~§{E"§f§§'3E'EéTi,§Lf3j)£33 "ES;%LE...i'{§§.,2'3€f'§§f*§'§O"£; :;' Céiémes 95 {he zinjgzzmcé 3:; pm" E252 f~'3E7 i§;* ';'?3'\3:1?%Qésegz/':1;3_§§v_ ' 2z:2<3I:h:.:%r 'J{}'U"}€3SE§, he Ems H{)'-.E7€3'~.r'f3l", h 6 E12115; S':2':1E::<::%d :+;aE ;<>ué, 1%2r;-->----- is/-é4a2eé":::fz, by ' E,-"2.{;',~{'.,'L,E.§% I :"*~§<:3~ :L.:m1<;€p;;>a, SO aéssa 1:313 e:;%,é:<§: K 81:41 hi: E12223 not specificeflly st;;:L§éa%_ 2?x:_*zj;--* "£53 Vr/a>sp<*%c§ of {the 'i1'1C%:'véCiL:22E E1SE§E}1,1.;':§;i'£T'VL"§1,.'"-"pix/lg"=_{';_2%§':.€F2§'TE52,3?',E7'?%E{E<.§f2%\"E'£i E--§i:"c3n: aéh . _. ,» .,_ Q , x «M H(}'-Q'J{":':7{T7 by ':2 :§<>€;;
1:': as ezEs<> SfE:?.,'JL'5f3'{,§' zi:;~>Vig;;a:v:; ., ":7 S}3€CifiC£1fi}r' ":<;_*{23;§.:§?€:éV .2§%:}<>'€;:.1"€§é%é,_é;;?:{i§ivéciL:;3§ %:';':z*s>:':V 2E*2?<f€[E§ <25 €;%3<*s H6 a§ :;§> f:,E.:"T;2§-f:«©i"--._ss,%2?{ie{§ :a1<:<;:u:;é:<E :.§:miE 5:
31$'/CU SCG L. ~.%h@ dé 5:5; ed. §'3"a/§r"'?;? hgtfgsi; :"2<::%: i'<E:3z3:L%%":'{t<3 €315} :%:€3.";:_<:r1""a$_é;;%:éti-,%;{>»7§€;;2 2:::3€:3 :.:3;€::i by -ah £3: :;:<i:;t::.s;€<% 21:3 za2:eéa2;?:ui?;V 23167 "'-.z§»=€:C»35:5;é:§_ :3? 336%:
: .';«: 25¢ E' u §*7=__ ?'€i?s:§¢E{E 2:335? 312. r2.m¢':<7:::fE §'";{§E§':7'§'§€:? 31:1} E73353? <3?
'y_:§2<*f? f.?i3;5<%Sé{iL:£312. @525} E, 33.3535; 21;": ?~§{}vz'€v<%:1 hésf + 32;*<:i<;:é.'n: :;:%3<i}2,:: fins: é:";a::éd€::3E g::::;%":<é:":;2E in 23::12:zs:'e:? :;;'2'%:f%é.£:>;:::
%;E"w:::° E'{Z";'€«§T}{fi?{7§,§'i/"ii? §n§:..:§ iifffi» :3 :9 v,*z?:22g3{>€;":s~:. :a'§§E": 1f"i?§€?§'si'fZ"E{i€,? iii} E E": :17 %:'13'm"i<i1%::;. §731fi:"Ef§ isms; ::~:§s;{i,: 22 ,2-2 §3;6;%:*:m"2i:E ;:::::<t:>:mE;i of éém :ez:~;:ez;m%z wééE1::>a;t SS'g3€?£7f§fg~'1I"i§,:E§,3?;€,-._'{§}f_{i?:'""E 22%/{V5 0? 22211;' {:4 :42<;:<?;:3%;€%{E, 8:1: ;::§s;<[[> E3"J\fE4§ <i?V§C§¢:?E§eCéZ? :3; <2? :32} ::7<:mse;<><m<%z'3<:<r ziizzécftéH":%;é;m<:%<>"E3 2 _; .
Specificziiiy 23zE3<f>:,2E i:E'*:<:? s;3:~3s§2:3.uEtV"'2i3:¢* Dr.J2?:Gz;:<:%is3h N? E12318 {',{f}§'E{§1,§{T§€?<Z§ £3';€?"~.;}<3s<;*:e7§21xzimiefizékg 5 (gm {$26 zisezii %3<::{fZ;> 2'25 331$ :f,1€<C {3.." °a..22<i 55% :[§3<:% :»::'w*'i§f%VCa:e«E:<:KP§%. AC<::::'C§i§":'g§%;~f> _hE»§;%:, <§€~_:ei2§}*:.Vfs: {ELK-7 ii} {E23 ?vm@~ fra<:*:ure 0? {he sZ.<};1E.E b;i$n@é'g<,;§ Dr,Sha:sE3:'dhe3:' ;%'1~s<>=.::17t_;%(fit-my '<;~%;'h¥;é_ §";._é1:;__':%:x:21mémeci .?3'W':s:.E {<2 53 am? has; 'f«.,ajff.
P1§&'.§ 17 ~_F€;';é :1 %f%2<;? E' 82 \'«;%m 2&5; <:2;iz?r§::r<.:% {E25 536%? .E;ai:1<£<; 20 '-.?;%:?;%"<:i%{}i'iH(}:" é:2E?{3 C'/'{',§E":":',,32'i_,E,£'7'i'E"%":}i7»' :"n§:Vu&%:%;€"
E <>xr:3z" {E13 <;E<?g;:<§ '::;%<V:e<:ig' 3:1; 2?"; :"é;*/Ea:/Vt~;¥géws+i; (35 'E:*":{?:' g§':_<§€ée€E if; gs;
5?
Eiazéi 5:2 "27f§_V{}¢2~'9£E?. aim zhcé E>2aE:é:§ {L}? {E32 {>5 téés _'€iz;;3":'§'; E"; 3 as; :*"&%;;>;%s;é::§;?r::?(E in {Zfém C Naiza , 5&1} ,5 283$ é'az: é§%é€m:si%:"§ %:":v<=%3;%:é;3}2>3a;{2r":. ifzzax: ;::Esa;<'; §::,:*:V;E3a:?:1" saéjziaéézzii éi§*':';s:: 'fé€: E'é,.:_2:;s i;'§i;§:<%a:E é§"::€ s;<::<:;>:2@ {V} 1 m' , ::::'z".i:§;£é: 1:: %.,:§'::~;!,,é::E;Eé:%2,§ <;:E1{, ~ S} » {3{ZC%ji"T€?§'3£',{? 2;/meci {in :'<%<:a%é;3i if :'E2zi;> 'és2?;:§:'1":2z:iV:f<2:3 tihzaziij C§<7e::<:%2:?::s<>{é %3;2?::~;
Su€«:tu,m§::v3cE $0 §E?,ji,If'E?{f,; ziaiidiiééé E§e*VC:.§«:m EPC iii} 'iEj:v~;<ia_T&.:;g2f§§{::"
FER zémd E'%é;:::>:' (1)33 %::2z:"s«:§::%«::i§ €;v::'%;" {E26 émrii:§ié§3;.2iéé<>z2 Eéfifiléé 53 'A Eh Q? C:"<>:;s--c3:s<27:rninsziéfiim €16 hsis; 535% :":2§i:tV<f;<§...éEf_: 321:: {$233 5?: V he has CGTUS £0 E<:3£>v: éihezti a<:::7u$::2c:§ %12:%;<a.&;::E::§§é "§:;}L.E,E3*i,'é1'iiV"§'}.<:f:'/{TE f 7 Eififi {hat 2;: cassejs in Crimxe Neizéél 331$ 'ajassise of the s:<>mpE::2jm ..<}f ::§":$V.-:;:r:A.:%u:§%3:s;A% whijs"vsmisé i:3j:.1:*5=<:§g PWEQ is; (Z191 2v':":{> haé:z;<sI'c{:«%i:f§§:;2é'<§ '=?;E"§":3 é:w@s:§;;;2a::i<>:3, ayrsstccl the accusexi, -.::€c§f}rs:§::>€:%" :t,}":;é"~.é;ta1:énf:«<:§":3 e::ef W£:Vne3ss:>:§, '§'_fi§s:e::.:*e__ _L:;!"t::i:":;.a*{c>£j--; E21853 Elm': cfazxrggge <;>b:2?:ir:€d thé 'xX~'{')3fCiVi'1,.€f:.éi"-T ssheci in ti%':is:« €€'i':}§~i'?_; _-
24. E': E §:<< >'m €132 <21 <35 'ah ass vséiz/1 <?5%:.:a€:ss {E3 2:': $3"; Esargrésci S S':::iv:>:as g§»:,:{:§ ' miss; {<21/s:2<E EEK? ;?1{?{'fL2S€i'?é:§ :::§€:<% s§s3.::iséé1<*.:j:éE i;E3'£~:i:: _2?::a:._E1«s3:u:%2§:"s 3&3? {:rs% ET} %;:.ii<';:1<:§E= {En :: :'§>;2?.5'n€%§L2E :::O§ES§€§€iE"3T§'§€}§": iii i§"i€ mzzésgiigfig "wax/: .*,§'C{}I"§'§§ ~ié:'gfis %%,;sL:és{E Zhzai: {he ééésicééciét: hsezss §*222;;:>;:;s::":<"»:<,E >4 ::%"~fi3s: {EEK/'EEQCE 3% 'zézssr ;ac:é;:;$2:%§E ;em<:§ 22,: V2225;
--f;:£::f:'ii:1;> 'x3i~'%1€:'€ :?:CCé.:,s;:<3::E ?€<;3,2 was; rzgmaésxgsgg (:2 §€fé[':,E;§"§{[}§§, T%*§:3 3:22 'SE': LEE"=.iTf£§ E2:
jéi:i?;z: if X, /Vuk 4,» g:3{3§§C§% ziazééé aw: {§s:_i::z:'é :3<>'i 3.212, § {i;'{:§ §.Emé;1 §§"ééi? £:%€ifTi,T1.,i§S{f?{§ E":
f,\,;
:mff€r:'<:%ci '£533' as {E 9:1; is": :33 :3 if;1<;tie:%<;;>m, E2 is G3"; *sz'<;::_;§_3;h @3135 E %Ei<;:r I:1zn:'%s£ige>J:é:V1g {f,>§§'§<:@:; ii @§*;cé':v<?z.E zhzzzz, 2&2 {Ti{[ELE%"2?;C?E' "zTj§:*§.:m?
N<1>.§§Z 2€§}€}1 'azaw; %:><><'>:z E'€?§3jS§§,f.?E'€j%{'i :22: ?2<:% ?;;>:;:é~;és; <2? i_?'";:iT' 5:;
of 21-E.CCLiS€d an {E %:3j%,2z'<*:<E. wiiinesssscés hEf7&/'61', S{.1§f}§f§Y'{';?SSC7{§ §'§1{'f 2~'<;?:j<;
azmd h2;2\«'<i? :3<>'{ 5;{:2;1i<:ei% mi? ':;"ut':2 E3{:._ 22 C856 undér E:3€cU1:>:": 30?' EPC .»£-2%-.f@g;§:s;{i{3:"ée::?-,.a§;:v;ééfm;*:; 2325 wi:n€Ss€s inr:Ei<ta:«:3s zhai :.}2§v "i':ff§'.F~.'§'§':€E£»5§'€fv§§" Efiéiifi? Came:
prepared for Same ;;1:£t;e.rc;?Jj§<>:23%,".xx;E':i<:.?e--._é::;zzéiézé; §E"E{T§.§€3E:{i*?C§ {mm the 2::ve1*m€ms :53' €§'é._'§1"€':,:$I{33ji3i2fz'§.{":{r~.§§§'§§i§f"bi}??? the ;::»:,~2r{Vi<~§e; S'{&fi£"§'E'<§ 2;2bu:§§r2 5239.5 2 "<i';:?f2_ V {:5 E2132; §}fJ {E78 E3?' ' :5 E~?$»'E<§lE"2f3S>"'i~,~ f '::3j; i:':1<:? ;3:<:z:LV:s;<?<[§\ % ;Z:iE"§3 05 §2%E'i}S»€;%C'LE"{3"' niim '":%?:>_ ;3«:?.<>:~;c':s:;:'%,,ifl;i<3:": 1»V:%':2i 2%:2iz:/6 :":e:;vi_ :;:a>:r:3 2? 231:3 'mL£AE":
:3 { E; <2 33% vi S é <2 :2 B <>§"*--t%"": iféé E': :32": iée 3 <:z?:51s<3 <3? E§:s2ELe;> 52$" ffl:,sV;%"2/2VasV:<zf<::;
954::/25;? {}:§?s:.>::' 3*:-::g:n:;t:"'{V:*:...¢;§ in 3?} fffifé? Q 1 § V 5,.
33:3? ._:%2:?"v.{;fi=:':1§:3:2 £Ei€;'€:LE$:':',{§ 2:*:.:"5> <?§'Ei§§'§i?{ii: §::,:':* gm {,:3£a§€,)f of E2: is; §:"é%3z:%r §§€;3i'?E"£ '$3': m:V's,:v*:'2;3é%<;:V*; <f2§ '£32 <5 4 ya :2"; a 5 ' =.::§:*€ irasééa é,E§'EG hzsxzar gm: é::2,E§T}{;% isizé ma ztésizzz §E'i,:2%,§::
\./ Fm» E22:2w§:;> ::.%E<;*2;sr3:' :+;iV2;':§<?<L:§ as»; 'é.,é,i2 vvifzézrh 5;? 232:1: ;¥:2;TaA::"<;%{§ fixes;
E%%.Eff€fi:'?'{§ 's~,*%€.'r2 i»E'f2'§{73': <2? i§'E€';? 'e;2':*>efs;3{>m; :az1a:'§ 22'§'2éa:;':%": <72?' :33 V.;:r:Er{:-{:\§;E.(§§l'§{V% :1' ii: 33 33 212 E"? {[52 E Cieafly, i'7u:"%:hs;*::", P'am'ss.13 ziméi 'E4? §hb{LEL,E§}::h' V{?l " 1' 3-'Vcwém@:s5:;<>s, E';2:z\:<;% <i>"z"~J<?;%:3 22 ;f§:jG}'3 cérgizl :iEi?3'{:§:7(>-fi'i,;i§;'E'V':{_' <5s'§7. é:E":_:?= 1"
\x.'E"1i{;th (21%; i:2{%:k:te;iai<>s §Z§'§2,%%,§, :':§>2":<=4 5)?
dear and CO1"1"f:'CE acceum Q? 1116 'E?-E',/S§"§r'\"}'€'A§£'{Q'?E'jV§E4"y" £2 §E~:«$2é::.é:i7G<:i in 2136 €x«'é::£€nC€ of 'she p:"{;s;€<:::;t§<tf,é:£ ,%.»'\"';"E?.7§Vi/;';~'"
:x;é";n £:"<:>_{é,'E'<:§» L;:f§1>s:? siifi ',2a::i 2229 aims {>5 i:1<:idx:>m 3Q»4{} ;>4€:§>';:»I<*: ";5i/,;7§i.Ah.€1f?T_£?{,?3&5 :;h«:% s;=:':@m§ <1?
{)CCLi§"E"€'3fEC€. 'i"§:;E% Q3 :2 2:es:m ES'%_:'rz.;:aEé£2?:zé% éiiiii'/Lisfiiii ?'i::>s;,E 2, \ W 33 5,113,} 'ft SE35? §§':{)';{§C";§'":§;
am d 33 to 9 *>.:='§':"<2 .21j:%"s% 2% "(';--§T f.§_'3i,". <%:><<:«i:§3: :5:
320?; 'aeeszz :T3p"'<_>§<;:c:1 "::3_ Eggs, €}ER1Efi3L§,S aCC{éE,if§§7 €':2z::':: V = {'3 :D?CES*:':3'Yéf at :"c?:z¥:i:*:';'**"?°hé:e <:%a2%::s:""§f;; é:,:::§i<7sé2E;:%s; 'i'§';=<','? §<Emi%{:%§'::::j\/ i.
" wé::V253:;ss:e:s ii; §:<5:;::'§é{*g,é§a% 223$ iéett ::sg%:«"s:::>::s; in a/§s'txa~' {L}? i'mp1i<t:%':?;é::'>n 2:1: £i:€:ijiE,2f5{';éf§ 56:25:? 15:": 55: 5* <,a'§§;m:: {ks <i>'%; s;;3s:z;:zE< L {)5 %;':35;= §:"::.%é<:§£%'m;p in i§{?E'§{}é.ii4§ E'§l:»i3.'{€iT'E" {sf ':8 :"2:<5sa1::::"<i; $3 §;<f;~;:3{}E sazaiéké :15) :*a:;;* <32"; 3e:::<;'E*: :4fe%";s::2§«:fx' .4'¥ £\/.?3, »;,, (a éiézaf; the €é',é',?i, s3%3e:}jg:3 €?§{iS§fi:":§{ <%:»'é;%n §3E"§{}I' %<> 'M1631 _P'a?~:'2 vvgaizss 2:::Hc;w:z<:>cii 2:2 ai":2Ti %}<';:?%3:'n<E §;3'1{f?
1?. E hem-w:*: g€)¥;E€i' {Z<>L1rt, gem d {E16 :'s3a:'1;('}m11g EEiSS§§§§i1£?{§ {Em §@:ai::'.é;3:7<?€ ya Jucigcé in camvicting ihsc a::€L1seci";";_"E gm": $125: s:::<;>:/*:ss:'::E<7§':;><€ op'ém'0n that the :*e:s::~;<>mn§,; ;::;sj:13:2'_imiii?" "§:>$;.f:E':.s-3 §é'té1,E'fl€'/{E $€SS§{[}§'3S Eh §€:?£:EI"'E"E aid Judge and She? gzpggréujiaI:§<'m" "V{\~/é';V{V':"1"'fTf;€i Sessions Judge naffj r':>as:édL €:2:':" §f}E'§'£"iC§§3§%3S <3? igzvai anci thg:-refers? E2:-_€ $__:«i§<:§ 3'i:<ig::f2~é%;"3:: '<3'f <t:_y V 86?'; 2::sid€r.
R:
38. '{A}i'?_2'i*s'«;;?':~§:>p*:%21% e2Ei<im'<::i§. Eiza? »:",}E"£"§{%§" {>5 Cs:>':3 afécii (#51:.'§3'€1é:::§:%é :1.:&3::n:E2€: 2zj§3;>:3§Ez;zm::1~s E3 <>¢;<>€:,>x,~' zzmfgii an ;i._%:;¥2::"':2>pp:3}§;~téi.9"aria a%:qLA2§°:%;€e:§ {>5 3:339 <>?f<:m:::% a§{a~m':sE éhem, 'Tééé 'bz:;,:'?§;j}:?5:':<:Es.~: s%3:<<c€a:::;s%=:% {§§:'%£ih§3E"§i:€*:i§a _ '~-f_%_:f:év,;::"§i;u:':%? c:§.:::§;:<i:::~_;z";€:::'E .:<;h2é2EE ':39 :":%:"'L::/:::t"§:i?<%_ 52> éizcm, §'\.»":2;:: ;' $9} a V:
<1 1'? ' u