Central Administrative Tribunal - Delhi
Arup Kumar Pathak vs Cabinet Secretariat on 20 August, 2024
1
Item No. 23 (C-5) O.A. No.3791/2022
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
PRINCIPAL BENCH: NEW DELHI
O.A. No.3791/2022
This the 20th day of August, 2024
Hon'ble Mr. Manish Garg, Member (J)
Hon'ble Dr. Anand S. Khati, Member (A)
1. EMPLOYEE N0.22862
ARUP KUMAR PATHAK
S/0 SHRI MRINAL KANT! PATHAK
AGED 41 YEARS
R/O 31 GIRNAR, ANUSHAKTINAGAR MUMBAI-
400094.
2. EMPLOYEE N0.22842
ABHISHEK MUKHERJEE
S/0 SHRI PRABIR KUMAR MUKHERJEE
AGED 42 YEARSRIO
1C GULMARG
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI-400094
3. EMPLOYEE N0.6191
SWARUP ACHARYA
S/0 SHRI MRINAL KANT! ACHARYA
AGED40YEARS
RIO VILLA N0.48, AMULYA HOMES
SY 191, BEHIND GR REDDY NAGAR
KAPRA, HYDERABAD-500103
4. EMPLOYEE NO.22850
GANGADHAR HUDDAR
S/O SHRI ANNAPPA BHUDDAR
AGED 42 YEARS
R/O A-07 SURABHI
ANUSHAKTINAGAR, MUMBAI
5. EMPLOYEE N0.22824
ALOKKUMAR
2
Item No. 23 (C-5) O.A. No.3791/2022
S/0 SHRI SUDAMA PRASAD
AGED 42YEARS R/O B02 AJANTA
ANUSHAK.TINAGAR
MUMBAI-94
6. EMPLOYEE N0.52500
TATAKUNTLA MOHANA KUMAR
S/0 SHRI SATYANARAYANA
AGED 41 YEARS R/O E-27, BRINDAVAN ·
GAUTAMI NAGAR POST
ASWAPURAM TELANGANA-507116
7. EMPLOYEE N0.22885
MALUSARE MANGESH M
S/0 SHRI MALUSARE MARUTI R
AGED44YEARS
R/O·E-31/6, BARC COLONY
TARAPUR, BOISAR
TALIDISTT. PALGHAR
MAHARASHTRA
8. EMPLOYEE N0.22829
MENKA TEWANI
W/0 SHRI RAMESH TEWANI
AGED 40 YEARS
R/O 16-C, ALMORA
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI-94
9. EMPLOYEEN0.22818
ALOK KUMAR SAXENA
S/0 SHRI MAHESH CHANDRA SAXENA
AGED42YEARS
R/O FLAT N0.3B, KEDARNATH BUILDING
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI-400094
10. EMPLOYEEN0.157
SINGH RITU SURYAPRAKASH
W/0 SHRI ITTENDRA VIR SINGH
AGED42YEARS
3
Item No. 23 (C-5) O.A. No.3791/2022
R/O 7B, GULMARG
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI
11. EMPLOYEE N0.22884
SOMALI PHANI
W/0 SHRI SANTANU DUTTA
AGED44YEARS
R/O C 13, KAPILAV ASTU
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI-400094
12. EMPLOYEE N0.22820
DIBAKAR GOSWAMI
S/0 SHRI PRADIP KUMAR GOSWAMI
AGED40YEARS
R/O 18, MOUNT ABU
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI-400094
13. EMPLOYEE N0.6447
S BALAKRISHNAN
S/0 SHRI P SUBRAMANIAN
AGED 41 YEARS
R/O 146, SADRAS EAST
DAE TOWNSHIP
KALPAKKAM, CHENGALPETDISTT.
TAMIL NADU-603102
14. EMPLOYEEN0.22828
ADITI CHAKRABARTY
W/0 SHRI ABlllJIT PATRA
AGED42YEARS
R/O 68, SATPURA
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI
MAHARASHTRA-400094
15. EMPLOYEE N0.24054
KANCHAN KUSHWAHA. .
W/0 SHRI VIPIN SINGH KUSHWAHA
4
Item No. 23 (C-5) O.A. No.3791/2022
AGED 44 YEARS
R/O 13-C, KEDARNATH
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI-400094
MAHARASHTRA
16. EMPLOYEE N0.6273
ANSARAHMAD
S/0 SHRI NISAR AHMAD
AGED42YEARS
R/O 1-1-3/38, PLOT-38, GOUDAPURI COLONY
KAPRA, HYDERABAD
TELANGANA-500062
17. EMPLOYEE N0.22861
SOMNATH GHOSH
S/0 SHRI BISWANATH GHOSH
AGED 46 YEARS
R/O 2D, BADRINATH BUILDING
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI-400094
18. EMPLOYEE N0.22817
BALAJI PRASAD MANDAL
S/0 SHRI AJIT KUMAR MANDAL
AGED42YEARS
R/O C-1, ELLORA
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI-400094
19. EMPLOYEE N0.22865
ARNAB DASGUPTA
S/0 SHR.I SURAllT DASGUPTA
AGED 41 YEARS
R/O IRIS-1202, KESAR GARDEN
SECTOR-20, KHARGHAR
MAHARASHTRA-41 0210
20. EMPLOYEE N0.22876
SATINATH(}HOSH .
S/0 SHR.I PARESH NATH GHOSH
5
Item No. 23 (C-5) O.A. No.3791/2022
AGED 41 YEARS ·
R/O 16. MUSSOORIE
ANUSHAKINAGAR
MUMBAI-400094, MAHARASHTRA
21. EMPLOYEE N0.24430
SANDEEPBHAGWAT
S/0 SHR.I VINAY BHAGWAT
AGED 42 YEARS
R/O SABARIGIRI-21
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI-94
22. EMPLOYEE N0.22851
KARKHANIS PRASAD P.
S/0 SHR.I KARKHANIS PRADIP S.
AGED 41 YEARS
R/O 2A, BADRINA TH, NUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI-400094
23. EMPLOYEE N0.22854
TARIQ AHMAD MIR
S/0 LATE GH MOHAMMAD MIR
AGED43YEARS
R/O MOHALLA BUNPORA
VILL. BEHRAMPORA, TEHSIL WATERGRAM
DISTT. BARAMULLA
J &K-193303
24. EMPLOYEE N0.22934 .®K.ASI VISWESWARA RAO N
S/0 SHRI NARASIMHA MURTHY N
AGED 43 YEARS
·R/O 36/04, BARC COLONY
BOISAR, P ALGHAR DIST
MAHARASHTRA-401504
25. EMPLOYEE N0.22873
SUDHIR KUMAR
S/0 SHRI MANGEY RAM
AGED 47YEARS
R/O FLAT NO. OS, BillLDING GIRNAR
6
Item No. 23 (C-5) O.A. No.3791/2022
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI-400094
26. EMPLOYEE N0.22886
JOSHI HIREN MUKUNDRAY
S/0 SHRI MUKUNDRAY JOSHI
AGED42YEARS
R/O A-1403, PURVA SWAN LAKE
KELAMBAKK.AM-603103
27. EMPLOYEE N0.22816
BOMMISETTY SURENDRA
· S/0 SHRI B. RAJANNA
AGED 44 YEARS
R/O 32/16 BARC COLONY
TAP PO, PALGHAR
MAHARASHTRA-401504.
28. EMPLOYEE N0.6442
KALY ANA RAO KUCHIPUDI
S/0 SHRI NAGESWARA RAO KUCHIPUDI
AGED42YEARS
R/O N0.606, PODHIGAI
ANUPURAM, CHENGALPATTU (DIST)
TAMIL NADU-603127
29. EMPLOYEE N0.22924
CHENNA KESHAVULU GURRAM
S/0 SHRI JAGADEESWARAM
AGED 43 YEARS
R/O 7, 53RDAVENUE
DAETOWNSIDP KALPAKKAM
TAMILNADU-6031 02
30. EMPLOYEE N0.1486
PRANAB BHATTACHAR.YYA .
S/0 SHRI JlBON KUMAR BHATTACHARJEE
·AGED 42 YEARS
R/O 144, RAJA RAJENDRA LAL MITRA ROAD
KOLKATA-700010
31. EMPLOYEE N0.1487
7
Item No. 23 (C-5) O.A. No.3791/2022
TAP AN KUMAR RANA
S/0 SHRI SIDHESWAR RANA
AGED 42 YEARS
R/O FLAT N0.0502, HEIGHT 06
UNIWORLD CITY
NEWTOWN, ACTION AREA-Ill
KOLKATA-700156
32. EMPLOYEE N0.1485
SUDESHNA SETH
W/0 SHRI SUHRID KUMAR SETH
AGED 42 YEARSRIO
5B, MANI RESIDENCY
30/2A, C. N. ROY ROAD
KOLKATA-700039
33. EMPLOYEE N0.6444
SATISH KUMAR V
S/0 SHRI SUBBA RAO
AGED 43 YEARS
·R/O H.NO.C-1003, C-BLOCK
HAPPINESS TOWERS
PACICIFICA AURUM,PADUR
CHENNAI-603103
34. EMPLOYEE N0.22860 (!j)LORI RASTOGI
W/0 SHRI HEMANT KUMAR
AGED 42 YEARS
R/O FLAT N0.202
A G HEIGHTS APARTMENTS
STREET N0.5, M J COLONY
HYDERABAD-500040
35. EMPLOYEE N0.22813
RAM CHANDRAM.
S/0 SHRI RAM LAGAN KUMAR
AGED 41 YEARS
R/O 6B, EVEREST
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI-400094
8
Item No. 23 (C-5) O.A. No.3791/2022
36. EMPLOYEE N0.22822
GAURAV VARSHNEY
S/0 SHRI G K VARSHNEY
AGED 39 YEARS
R/O C-11, HASTINAPUR
BARCCOLONY
ANUSHAKTI NAGAR
MUMBAI-400094
37. EMPLOYEE N0.22836
TARUNKUMAR PRAFULBHAI PATEL
S/0 SHRI PRAFULBHAI PATEL
AGED 41 YEARS
R/O A-6, INDULEKHA CHS LTD.,
PLOT N0.47, SECTOR~9A
VASHI, NAVI MUMBAI
MAHARASHTRA-400703.
38. EMPLOYEE N0.22845
POULOMI MUKHERJEE
W/0 SHRI SUDIPTO R CHAKRABORTY
AGED43YEARS
R/O 8C, KAlLAS
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI 400094
39. EMPLOYEE N0.24308
S. GANGA KRISHNA .
S/0 SHRI S.NAGESWARA RAO
AGED41 YEARS
R/O FLAT N0.202 HINDUS THAN CASTLE
BEHIND LAW COLLEGE
PM PALEM, PO. MADURA W ADA
VISAKHAP A1NAM
ANDHRAPRADESH-530041 ·
40. EMPLOYEE N0.1484
VIKAS SINGHAL
S/0 SHRI SAMPAT RAJ SINGHAL
AGED41 YEARS .
9
Item No. 23 (C-5) O.A. No.3791/2022
R/O PS IXORA, 10-1F
GA.URANG NAGAR
NEW TOWN, KOLKATA-700159
41. EMPLOYEE N0.22839
MAITYPS
S/0 SHRI RANJIT KUMAR MAlTY
AGED 39 YEARS
R/O 15B,BADRINATH
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI-400094
42. EMPLOYEE N0.22880
ANITA GUPTA
S/0 SHRI B R GUPTA
AGED 42 YEARS
R/O 52, ZARINA PARK B,
MANKHURD, MUMBAI-400088
43. EMPLOYEE N0.22879
JAYASHREE BISWAL
S/0 SHRI SIBA CHARAN BISWAL
AGED 41 YEARS
R/O 22-VENKATAGIRI
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI-400094
44. EMPLOYEE N0.22826
ABHIJIT RAHA
S/0 SHRI NANDA LAL RAHA
AGED41 YEARS
R/O 11 A ALMORA
ANUSHAKTI NAGAR
MUMBAI-400094
45. EMPLOYEE N0.6443
SHIV PRAKASH RUHELA .
S/0 SHRI BHANWAR SINGH RUHELA
AGED 44YEARS
R/O A-1 002, PURVA SWANLAKE APTS
KELAMBAKKAM
10
Item No. 23 (C-5) O.A. No.3791/2022
TAMIL NADU-603103
46. EMPLOYEE N0.6187
NAVIMAR SURESHCHANDRA DUBEY
S/0 SHRI SURESHCHANDRA J DUBEY
AGED40YEARS
R/O B 402, CONCRETE PALAZZO
NACHARAM
HYDERABAD-500076
47. EMPLOYEE N0.6185
SANJOYSAHA
S/0 SHRI SADHAN CHANDRA SAHA
AGED43YEARS
R/O FLAT NO. A-210, CONCRETE PALAZZO
RAGHAVENDRA NAGAR
NACHARAM,HYDERABAD
TELANGANA-500076
48. EMPLOYEE N0.1 58
SOUMEN SINHA
S/0 SHRI SUSHIL SINHA
AGED43YEARS
R/O 26, ANAND BHAVAN
DAE QUARTERS
BHULABHAI DESAI ROAD
MUMBAI-400026
49. EMPLOYEE N0.22819
RAJESH BARNWAL
S/0 SHRI SITARAM BARNWAL
AGED 44 YEARS
R/O FLAT 402, SWASTIKPARK
SECTOR-21, KAMOTHE
NAVIMUMBAI
50. EMPLOYEE N0.6186
AMBARISH D DESHMUKH .
S/0 SHRI DEEPAK DESHMUKH
AGED 41 YEARS
R/O S-204, SAKET SRIYAM TOWERS
11
Item No. 23 (C-5) O.A. No.3791/2022
KAPRA, HYDERABAD-500062
51. EMPLOYEE N0.6189
G PRADEEP KUMAR
S/0 SHRI G SANGAMAYYA
AGED 40 YEARS
R/O FLAT NO. 101, AMITY PRIME
STREET NO. 3, MJ COLONY
MOULA ALI, HYDERABAD-500040.
52. EMPLOYEE N0.6448
SUDDHASATTWA GHOSH
S/0 SHRI SILAJIT GHOSH
AGED42YEARS
R/O 108, 5TH A VENUE
D.A.E. TOWNSHIP
KALPAKKAM, TAMIL NADU
53. EMPLOYEE N0.52414
KOTESWARA RAO CHUNDURI
S/0 SHRI VENKATESWARLU
AGED 42 YEARS
R/O E-16, HWP COLONY, ASWAPURAM
BHADRADRl KOTHAGUDEM
TELANGANA-507116
54. EMPLOYEE N0.22843
AMIT PRAKASH SRIVASTAVA
S/0 SHRI C P SRIVASTAVA
AGED 40 YEARS R/O 55, VENKATAGIRI
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI-400094
55. EMPLOYEE N0.22838
HEMANT KUMAR PATNI
S/0 SHRI BHAWANI DUTT PATNI. .
AGED 43 YEARS
R/O 24, SABARIGIRI
ANUSHAKTI NAGARMUMBAI-400094
56. EMPLOYEE N0.6190
VINA YAK BHALCHANDRA DESHMUKH
12
Item No. 23 (C-5) O.A. No.3791/2022
S/0 SHRI BHALCHANDRA B. DESHMUKH
AGED 41 YEARS R/O F BLOCK-307, GULMOHAR
GARDENS SHAKTI SAl NAGAR
MALLAPUR HYDERABAD-500076
57. EMPLOYEE N0.22849
YOGESH KUMAR GUPTA
S/0 SHRI RAMESHWAR PRASAD GUPTA
AGED 42 YEARS
R/O 3A, KEDARNATH
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI-400094
58. EMPLOYEEN0.22881
KRISHAN KUMAR PANDEY
S/0 SHR.I MATA PRASAD PANDEY
AGED 44 YEARS .R/O 2A- KAILASH
ANUSHAKTI NAGAR MUMBAI-400094
59. EMPLOYEE N0.22847
DHEERAJ JAIN
S/0 SHRI SURESH CHANDRA JAIN
AGED43YEARS
R/O 9-A, ALMORA
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI-400094
60. EMPLOYEE N0.22840
RACHNAAGARWAL.
W/0 SHRI VIPIN AGARWAL
AGED44YEARS
R/O 07 MT. ABU
ANUAHAKTINAGAR
BARCMUMBAI
61. EMPLOYEE N0.22841
CHlTRASEETHARAM
W/0 SHRI AMRESH MISRA
AGED 42 YEARS
R/O 13-C, KAMET
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
13
Item No. 23 (C-5) O.A. No.3791/2022
MUMBAI-400094
62. EMPLOYEE N0.6192
JAGDISH RAM JAT
S/0 SHRI POONA RAM JAT
AGED 44 YEARS
R/O 102, SAT KRISHNA APARTMENT
OPPOSITE TO NEEL KAL YAN APARTMENT
KAMALA NAGAR, POST. ECIL
HYDERABAD-500062
63. EMPLOYEE N0.22855
RAJA KISHORA LENKA
S/0 SHRI ANTARJYAM1 LENKA
AGED 41 YEARS
R/O 48, MUSSOORIE .
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAI-400094
64. EMPLOYEE N0.22882
ANIL JAIN
S/0 SHRI LAL CHAND JAIN
AGED 42 YEARS
R/O ALMORA l5A
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAl-400094
65. EMPLOYEE N0.1 56
SONAL GANDlll .
W/0 SHRI GAURAV GANDlll
AGED 40 YEARS
R/O 51 MUSSOORIE
ANUSHAKTINAGAR
MUMBAl-400094
66. EMPLOYEE N0.22824
SUNDAR RAJAN SANKARAN
S/0 SHR.I SANKARAN SUNDARAM
AGED 40 YEARS .
R/O FLAT N0.33, MUSSOORIE
ANUSAKTHI NAGAR
14
Item No. 23 (C-5) O.A. No.3791/2022
MUMBAl-400094
67. EMPLOYEE N0.22869
PRAVEEN JOSHI
S/0 SHRI H. D. JOSHI
AGED 41 YEARS
R/O FLATD301, MANASA CASTLES APPTS.
ASHRAM ROAD
HINKAL, MYSORE
KARNATAKA-570017
68. EMPLOYEE N0.22867
KUMAR RAJA MACHA
S/0 SHRI NAGESWARA RAO M
AGED 40 YEARS
R/O FLATN0.211, C BLOCK
SOWPARNIKA BLUEBELLS APARTMENTS
VIJAYNAGAR 3RD STAGE
MYSORE, KARNATAKA-570030
69. EMPLOYEEN0.20017
BIBHAS PRASAD
S/0 SHRI B. N. PRASADAGED 43 YEARS
R/O B04, ELLORA
ANUSHAKTlNAGAR
MUMBAI-400094
70. EMPLOYEE N0.1602
SANYASI RAO BOBBILI ,
S/0 SHRI APPALA NAIDU BOBBILI
AGED 45 YEARS R/O D-44/2 SECTOR-IV
RRCAT COLONY INDORE-452013
71. EMPLOYEE N0.1624
PRAVEEN KUMAR YADAV
S/0 SHRI UMRAO SINGH
AGED 44 YEARS
R/O D-49/2, SECTOR-OS
RRCAT COLONY INDORE-452013
72. EMPLOYEE NO.l613
ANUJUPADHYAY
15
Item No. 23 (C-5) O.A. No.3791/2022
S/0 SHRI RAM GOPAL UPADHYA
AGED 44 YEARS
R/O D-45/6, RRCAT COLONY
PO. CAT, INDORE- 452013
73. EMPLOYEE N0.1609
HIMANSHU SRIVASTAVA
S/0 SHRI KESHARI NANDAN SRIVASTAVA
AGED 41 YEARS
R/O 69, PRAGATI NAGAR
PO. RAJENDRA NAGAR
INDORE, MP-452012
74. EMPLOYEE N0.40824
CHANDRAGUPT POTDAR
S/0 SHRI RAVINDRA KUMAR POTDAR
AGED 41 YEARS
R/O K-8 HEAVY WATER PLANT COLONY,
POST BHABHA NAGAR
VIA KOTA, RAJASTHAN 323307
75. EMPLOYEE N0.1603
RAVI SHANKER VERMA
S/0 SHRI CHHOTE LAL VERMA
AGED 41 YEARS
R/O D 45/4, RRCAT COLONY
RRCAT, RAJENDRA NAGAR
INDORE, MP-452013
76. EMPLOYEE N0.1605
C KAMAL S/0
SHRI N. CHINNATHAMBI
AGED 43 YEARS
R/O D-43/4, RRCAT COLONY
PO. CAT, INDORE
MADHYA PRADESH-452013
77. EMPLOYEE N0.1611
Ms. AMITA CHATURVEDI
W/0 SHRI SATISH KUMAR CHAUBEY
AGED 42 YEARS
16
Item No. 23 (C-5) O.A. No.3791/2022
R/O N-1 0, SILVER OAKS COLONY
INDORE,MP
78. EMPLOYEE N022925
SOURABHMOITRA
S/0 SHRI CHANDAN MOITRA
AGED 41 YEARS
R/O FLAT NO 304, SHREEKANT CHSL
PLOT NO 32, SECTOR 44-A, SEAWOODS
NAVI MUMBAI 400706
79. EMPLOYEE NO.l610SAROJ
KUMAR JENA
S/0 SHRI RABINDRA NATH JENA
AGED 41 YEARS
R/O D-30, TREASURE FANTASY
RAU, INDORE .MADHYA PRADESH-453331
80. EMPLOYEE NO.l608
ABDURRAHlM
S/0 SHRI SHAFIULLAH
AGED 40 YEARS R/O
D-24/2, RRCAT COLONY
INDORE, MP-452013
81. EMPLOYEE N0.1607
SURENDRA YADAV
S/0 SHRI RAM CHANDRA YADAV
AGED 42 YEARS
R/O 49, ANUDESHAK NAGAR
INDORE, MP-452010
82. EMPLOYEE N0.22858
RAJ AN KUMAR SINGH
S/0 SHRI LALAN SINGHAGED 44 YEARS R/O 22,
CIRUS, PRPCOLONYKALPAKKAM
TAMILNADU-603102
...Applicants
(By Advocate: Mr. Anshuman Mehrotra)
17
Item No. 23 (C-5) O.A. No.3791/2022
Versus
1. UNION OF INDIA
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR
CABINET SECRETARIAT
RASHTRAPATI BHA WAN
NEW DELHI-11 0004.
2. DEPARTMENT OF ATOMIC ENERGY
THROUGHITSSECRETARY
ANUSHAKTI BHAWAN
CHHATRAPATI SHNAJI MAHARAJ MARG
MUMBAI-40000 1.
...Respondents
(By Advocate: Mr. P.K. Singh for Mr. Gyanendra Singh
18
Item No. 23 (C-5) O.A. No.3791/2022
ORDER (ORAL)
Hon'ble Mr. Manish Garg, Member (J) At the outset, the learned counsel for the applicants submits that the matter pertains to grant of benefits of Old Pension Scheme in terms of DoP&T OM dated 03.03.2023. He further submits that the respondents are taking steps in furtherance of the aforesaid OM as several other similarly situated employees have already been granted the said benefits.
2. Heard both the parties and perused the material available on record.
3. Considering the aforesaid submissions, we deem it appropriate to dispose of the present OA with a direction to the respondents to consider the case of the applicants and decide the same in terms of the guidelines issued by DoP&T vide OM dated 03.03.2023. This exercise shall be completed within a period of 45 days from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this Order. The applicants are 19 Item No. 23 (C-5) O.A. No.3791/2022 at liberty to agitate their grievances in accordance with law, if so desire.
4. Pending MA's, if any, shall also stand disposed of. No costs.
(Dr. Anand S. Khati) (Manish Garg)
Member (A) Member (J)
/yaksh/