Karnataka High Court
Sri Kannan S/O Madure vs Sri G Giridhar on 19 January, 2011
Author: Subhash B.Adi
Bench: Subhash B.Adi
)9:
IN TH E I*iIC}I"I COUE-Z'§' OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORITI
I]3A'I"§3I.') TE---IIS THE E9?" EBAY OF JANUARY 201 1
F73 E*3F'C)R£%I
'1fm«: H()N'f:'3LI*Z :a4R.Jr;s*1*1c 14: -SUEEEHASE--£ yam); " V Q " u ~
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 12936,/¥§.>}.t§'0';'?'Vj'L:--. .
B 'EETVV E2 EN :
Sri.KemnaI1, S / 0 Madure
Age: 51 years. Occ:E\l'i1,_
R/o No.49. 5"' Main,
Bztpuji Block. Sweiihanfirzipalya.
Sri.'1'ampL1ra _ ' T'
Bangalore A21. _ ;;A3?p£','1,1,ANT
[By Smi. Sulfutha 8.11., Adi" Adv.)
AN D :
1.. sr1.G.Gi;-igmgj ~ 1'
S / 0 C§(")}52i5z11§:?jsh:§i21'V' «V
R/a1£4I;N0._52O,V V}:3?"'vM&'iI}';'»',' __ .
5m crass, .11z."vLc:o1A'1"e.ge vI?("s~,:,,t.'
Mufhurayanagara ,. '
R.V.Nikei'a~:.1, 1's'IysC)reA~Rc3;3.d.
B211jg'a1Qr€. W59,' V' V '
.fI'I*1"e M";1'112§<g<?;f
' V.VE'3'-ajelj ~A1fi~i+3;nz&:' G-E-'*.1"lt'.I'£-li h'ISE3.'l'E11'1C€ Co. Lt.d..
N1). "f3F3;"v.I2Eesi(iVe1§cy Rozld,
" 1. 05' A. C{é'g1:'s§ 1=I-']aIz£1
1 ¥<"I.c)_c3y, _I3f21:.'1g21}():'€ W25. .. RESPOND}'LN"E'S
" «Sri.I).\?1};3§'.akLrI11a.1'. Aciv. for R2;
:'\IQ L*.»i,c:€% t;0_R1 cE.is;pe11s€.€:i wi't,h.}
. P«.2"E.I4"A' is fiierzi 1,a1'1cié:1' S<:=Ci.ior1 1173(1) GE" Arsi aigairlsi.
_3'€1cigrrIe':r1t: aznd awa.r<:.i dateci 27/L.:200'F passsed in MVC
E\€v(§KZf¥O?5/2008 011 'me iiie? of the KEV Addl. Judge, Court". c')fSn'12111
;C;i12ses;._ M::2:11l>e:: R./.IAC'§1 Me%;1*0;:«c)Ii€.211'1 21:13:31, E§§:1r1g;a.i()1'e,
{SCC.E'-E.§'J{:. £0), pa'u'i.13I a.1.1:3w'i1'1g§ the <:}ai;'13 11)<3iié,ic}:': for <:<3n'1pex1s5z1i'iim
= zmgi saeeking €:'.t'1hE'£I'1(3€?{'}'1f;?I'1f of cz:3:r1p€*r1:~sai.ic):§ wi.t.§'; 12% i1'1tere$§,.
Em}
s
This Appeal} cc)1':'11'11g; on for h<32u'i1'1g £1135; (my, the C0111':
deiivereii '{ 11 e {0} lowi 11 gr
JUDGMENT
Thjss is cEa1'1z1a1'1f':'s appeal seekiiag anhantécémés-xii; :)f c:0n1pensaEim1 in ms'-;pec=%i. of judg;1'ne:<1"{ z»1r1c%1. " am»-<::2.1*c$ ai_'i':
M.v.c.No.4o75,/2006 ci2=z.t'.ed 2'?.4.2007.:(m.._t.h€."3'*»f.A._C.'f';--.& V I3a:1g2110re.
2. C3ai1nam. has $o'ug'.ht for c.:r._3VL:'1"'1~~_pellsziuoxl' <11" /~» V for E,h<: injury s1.1s1.a§ned .i.;1:1. the 3.:'--Ga.§i~.2i.é:s:Aide1'11."on 38.3.2006. Ififoxvever. the 'I.'ribur12;.1 on the '£)E_3{$i§"s._()Vi::';.i1(3'E:7§%id'f§i1(§t3 on record has granted CO11}f}€}'}SEi1.i0_§§' Q1' Rs'.'§9';€.OO/ '~A.«_?:.U11Sa€'.i.s$fied with the said award , the (.'iE11'.i"11?.":I'i1'_'ES5:A.:§fi~.'_&1p§_€'aI:' E}.f3i4.(3_i't'::1,.h.iE-:- Cou rt.
3. 'l'i'a.e an»¢zi1*'<i."Vo.i' "éhe'«.fl;i~i.bL;--n:»:I. not <:I;1a.11.e1"1 fed 1:) the i}.'1Sl11'€'I'. I,iabi.E..:1f_t:y aiso'r1Oib_3i'1--..§iiSpu1e.
4._({Z3au1Em21111. fiass_Vs:.:i'{'¢r'ed two inguries v'i2., (1) Abrasicm over f1".Qx1u1f.:1I'i {2} Svueiiillg and deformity 0\---"€I' righi. leg, X~ 1fayL'S;t1t}¥;s./55. 1.116"..c_0:air;ii.1'111t.ecE C()1'1d}-'1E':1' fr21(:i:ure of right tibia with '(*V3..?ffE',~f;',E}.E$l'€)"i*}. €0,._'i;z'13;.wA§.é':*A '1/3 of tibia displacezéd. Piss. was inpafielit from x "(:91 21.4.2005 ané has; spe1'1t. abom Rs.50.000;'~ "1:.t}'»}éw.1.'V§V£;~s--rgiediétai. €Xf}f3,I'1S€?E§. D()CE.()1' 13.215; the di.=3ab1'Ii':.y 21:. {.119 wfwle bod}; zmci 48% to flhii? right iowerr limb. I~i0W<:>x:<3;', 'i-hi.-é evici.<%r'1<'~c;'r 0:' %i..1':c:: £3<:>z:::1.:.>r r1.<>%. ac:<i'e}i>t<:é<i1. as he. had not i "j--.. :4;
I 9' V'?