Sonnegowda vs The State Of Karnataka on 25 June, 2009

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Sonnegowda vs The State Of Karnataka on 25 June, 2009

Bench: V.G.Sabhahit

%%%»W% 3

i
ER WE i-iiﬁﬁ Cﬁiiiﬁ" ﬁr-" §€§ﬁi'Viii"i"Ai{A arr 3.§§~¢§gj;'&ﬁE
mam 'rags "mg 25*" QAY as guzsgia zsﬁé  

ﬁKE§£ﬁY*.Aﬂ

T3? émrsgsptm win. 93. ﬁfifiﬁiiéinﬁﬁﬁ,€:§:§':.ﬁF.§i;§;STfi$.E

THE §*i§i\i'Bfi,¥;z¥~§R..;i%fS;ifIé'E§i.G.t saagaiaﬁrr

 

Eetweere: _ Q '

iéged ab~:>u:.;.s%;}.3;2V yeé=;'r3,  ._

?1f*Jf§* s.;'":';~E:«.'zss.E C'é:;ﬁ:.ra'ctr"or,  

'fat.;a'a:a%a_, "§{arz}a$eh--a;h"a§t§ (?ast),

§<e§:~'s.:f '§*"a;iu'£< 8}; .€;ii.st;.;--~'5€s"3 _1§1, .. PETIYESEQER

§enneg:c:'\ivéia,:E'§r*"%;»'§~§~;:_éia§::ia;* _: 

{By S5;-.F§i%a§a:V§*a§!aQF3£'; %§~§I:.=mu -« ﬁav. far Petr.)

' 1'. --*E'?1a'Sf5a~:.e af Karnatakag

' E%. eipr?esj:;~:,::§:ad by Eta ﬁacretary,

 Da'g'2'7a'rtzf'7:-'tent sf Camrrserce am industries,

£*3?_%v;:"33, ;§?s2:§id§:%§£, Bgngaﬁcw-S63 $81.

  2..'"E'v';i*.*:tTe Executive Engineer;

 Department sf P'.W.D.,
 Kwar Qivisiora, Kc-Ear.

3. The Executive Engineer,
ﬁepartment of ?an:hayat Ra},
Enginaering Qivigion,
Kciar, §<eEar District. 



4. The Ca-mmissiener,
City Mzsnéatipai Csrpsratésn,
Keiar,
Koiar §§st;*t€*.:.

S, The Chief Secretary,
Seaartmerzt sf A.P.§'e%.C.,
Kaiar, Kata: District.

6, The Cgmmissienegg  
Qepartment cf Karnata£<a.L.£§§um
Ciearance Board,  -
Sheshaéri Roaé,  ;    
Bangaiere.   _     RES?Oi"~§ii)EF\E'¥'S

(By Sri. B~asa%;.ara§a:A?Za:;ej§idy--.5;.?r'i.I"gGV§§1t';'Adv. for R3.)

__%_The$eé'*%ﬁ§;rEt F'e;titié:2s.a_ra f}i§eci under Articies 226 and
22?' crf "t3.'1;.'-::. Cé'%jn7$€Et'u:i':2n a§f'"'1Tnéia praying to éiirect the
res';,§sn.;dents;.::'~z:»t"$1:'d_éd.z,:a:t any myaity frcm the petitioner
running .wor.§< i.:x§§:i<:s.°  

T§'%'é%é W:-§tAA§?iet%i:'§Vens are taming 23;: Far preéiménary

"%.':_;}é3:$§Ang en"'t.¥:__:s éay, tha Cesar": éeiiveraé the feE£ew§ng:-

 3 ~.

 

 vA'.:'v«i_"3De§E\1er&d hy R3. Dénakaran, C3.)

  Qetéitmrzer in these patiticms is a registereﬁ Civii

 .. ,_:a:'§tv%":actcs¥ carrying an cévii werks cf the §{}\ié!"¥%¥'¥'§€!"¥t

V' "ﬁéparimentl ana Locai Eoéms. It is ccntended that far the

purpose 0? execuiéerm of civit warks; the petitioner is

requireé to purchase izauﬁding rnateréais from the prévatze

 



3

warms. it 33 fzjrtmr czcmtenaed that the pet§ti§n._é:r.._éees

ms: awn any quarry and that ha is net E2a.%%:i e"ié j $§~;:___é'ny

royaéty ta the respondents. Heaéqeyer, t%é'e"re§$v;":6r2.de.nL3 'am

aeaizactémg rayaiiy fmm the b§§»§.vs eff'Ttﬁeé'=;§_é:.i§'Ec-»ﬁé:%~L..g,§:'%Ai§*;£>ut auihartty a? saw. §~§ersce;, _::'iz.gse '§ﬁ£r§£ §?et§f§%::;%3;s;.._g:fg§%§::ﬁ fm ﬁaﬁéassi: 'ma rayaity i*ra:f:%{"'t§v§'e1.§ss§s":3?ﬁﬁe Vpetitioner $21 £"'QS§€€t of the rgxiai-9};a;;s:'._ §2jj;>§:2':f;e;i.A:"i':j; mm fram grivate sa:.:rca$ $95' executigm sf :i§'3Q'--f;fE'»§§§EC§ii§¥;3%f,'§ warks.

2. IS;"S§?1=?:ii§;.r-';';fnét:VafSw?_t£3"§s: CQu»rt M (iv. Kimna mm ﬁ"§7§ijv-§Ei:?;§x§;%;_$i'ﬁ"f'E §_§ .§{ARﬁﬁT§.i(§. new mwaas Era :?*Js"i5t":??_e4t:§?is§*§:;.«'E*.i5~%§; i3":.£eé-3:265 G? 1994 éigposeé 9? an 351%" ;£)ct{§be:;_' ﬁg mid 6995;"; the princimeg mating to t:we1 ,?;ég2§g¥:':3é;;rgnE Q?' gsyaéiy hy We canirattorsw Tm same are '«-['_ga;;i€§*v:%1{'t:%.ff%v;:3.A}*s.::ef;%"e:1miar:

{$3 %%'§s&re §s""3§a*'i§7ff?§ Size mazergai ggubjeﬁieﬁ Ea; myaiéyj zg 5:133 respa=r2s:§§'i:i°y of She canrrscmr arm' aria ﬁeparémesﬁ prvvsaes éhe ceafraaﬁar witfz spec:f.£ea* srormw araas, for exfracéiars 0%' fire required £'€3!?§£7§"'t§:Cf§ai?

maferiai, me caséraczar wiii be iiabie is my S purcfsaeea frerr: privafe seurces ii!-ce qiigergé' iease heiders or private quarry owners,;"'ti2e.(fe no iiabiiify on me comrrazrtor to pay _e'Es;( rciyaity ' ' merges.

(e) In cases: cevereef ,e3_:;'as {;f3} enc¥ the Qeparément ca;én,§'&..V_recé'i«'e{ mi ariy royaify from fee biiis _e€f":f§e-eeetfaefef anéz' if so aFea"u<:£'ed, z'*rse4"'*i:ep_3§rz=g2§e;é,;je ﬁe Edema to refund any ameehﬁ se cofiected to fee Ceijfreefogf;

('€=.'.)'H _'£=?I:§zf"2jié__z:*.i:;' ~.gng=, ':._eb.;c:ve, coifection of " the-'§e,}aa§:f;??e:é§£? or refund thereof by ifre wifi be gevemed by the terms " 5:? ca:3't:'a€:é{ ' _ " "

" " (f) fsiethinﬁ stated above shaii be canstrued A' eszea ﬁikeefien for refzsnd in regard is any iv'-».:_;;3e?*t§C£.ffar centrect. The ﬁepartment er ' e§';;f§r§§?}'fy zseneerzzrea Sheff decieed in each case, '' 'wgfefetﬁer reyaiiy is ée he aeafucfeci er 5? any " «:'rcyeii:;r* is asreeciy éeduetea; whether it shoufd ﬁe refueéee', keegéeg is": View the above §ri'nc;p§es am terms cf the centres , "

3, We said ﬁecésier: has been ugheié by the Eivisier:

Bench cf this Cami in the case ca? 3¥FICE GF THE 'W % ﬁiﬁiﬁfﬁﬁ as? BEFAR"E'"ﬁEFi'"f" 3? :g;3;1i¥§':'Ef'§ij"3.'"A§4§ §§éi.ﬁGY V, ?s§. §~'iﬁi-iﬂﬁﬁﬁﬁ RAISE in 'aééjtit:§;;5:;§éa.s " m5;._ 833 9? .2965 aésmsed cf on 25?" S°epte;?::.;be:7,'jéjﬁrggQ} 6;. Feiiowmg the judgmaaﬁ sf t"iz_§§"CQuﬁ{.'vvfe§%§i4§.re§; éi.§i'.*;y.*::*;L{;

Agpeaz &\é$n83¥;% as}? 2305 :1I'%V'$9=§§..-*V;: §*:e2_c%;. G?"95:_i:5";fgSeQtembe¥, 23%' these Wrét ?€.;:§';§_'E'ji«-o;1s'_VjVa:jf9;vL'a:'§.$§»,,LAﬁisgsoséé Sf. ﬁfe erder 33 to casts. ' "'%:.3Qhi8f Iustice Sd/'L Judge 'I:1.tié>«;;_: 'ﬁes; fxis 1f*:e§ Host: Yes; iﬁia ?*~?§$E<""

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court