Skip to main content
Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law
Document Fragment View
Matching Fragments
a) Lorry hire expenses charges Rs.6,71,450/-(Page 7 to 16 of P.B)
b) Diesel expenses Rs.3,79,938/- (Page 17 to 26 of P.B)
c) Repairs & maint. charges against transport work Rs.1,74,096/-
(Page 27 to 31 of P.B)
d) Loading service charges Rs.4,01,766/- (Page 32 & 33 of P.B)
It is also evident from copies of accounts of respective parties
that major payments were made to them through banking channel
and supporting evidences along with copies of account of creditors
were also submitted before authorities below. In substance, gross
receipts of transportation charges of Rs.18.04 lacs has been taxed as
income but corresponding expenses to earn such income have been
disallowed in full.
10. Documentary evidence filed in the paper book clearly shows
that the regular books of accounts were maintained for M/s V.K.
Transport. Transportation services relating to transport work were
provided to various public Limited Company viz. M/s Crompton
Greaves Limited and M/s. Dawat Foods Limited, and other
concerns. Ledger accounts of various customers of M/s V.K.
Transport are placed on record. Assessee does not own any
transport vehicle and he carried out this transportation business by
hiring trucks/Loory from other concerns for which charges are
paid. Major expenses are towards brokerage, diesel expenses,
loading services charges, Lorry charges and repairs & maintenance
charges. In these given facts and circumstances, assessee having
carried out the business of transport cannot be disputed. Since the
Shri Vinod Kumar Jain
assessee is carrying out business of providing transport service
then certainly expenses incurred for carrying out business needs to
be allowed.