Document Fragment View
Fragment Information
Showing contexts for: highly improbable in Arun Kumar vs State Of Himachal Pradesh on 16 October, 2019Matching Fragments
the accused and the prosecutrix were seen together covering distance of about 30 kilometres from 'Balle to Rewalsar' in a car, having lunch in a hotel situated in a thick locality at Rewalsar, staying there and returning from there. No person has seen them together. Hence, alleged fact of prosecutrix going to Rewalsar with accused on 26.02.2014 and 28.10.2015, went completely runnoticed by anyone, which is highly improbable considering all the facts and circumstances of the case.
.
"It is correct that as per the complaint Ext.D1, on 11.3.2016, the accused was accompanied by his wife when he allegedly met me at 12.00 PM. It is incorrect that the wife of the accused gave me beating on that day. Self stated that both of them gave me beatings."
It is highly improbable that accused admittedly accompanied by his wife on 11.03.2016, in presence of his wife, would ask the prosecutrix to accompany him to the hotel in Rewalsar or else, would threaten her with uploading her obscene photographs on the internet.
FIR:
6(i). The events projected by the prosecutrix, be it of 26.02.2014 or 28.10.2015 or 11.03.2016, are highly improbable and unbelievable on the face of facts and circumstances of the case, statements of witnesses and the documentary evidence available on record.
6(ii). As per the prosecutrix, all the events, as they happened on aforesaid three dates, were described by her to her mother in March, 2016. This is also the version of mother of prosecutrix Smt. Usha Devi (PW-2):-
g). It is highly improbable that accused in presence of his wife on 11.03.2016, would ask the prosecutrix to accompany him to the hotel at Rewalsar or else would threaten her with uploading her obscene photographs on the internet;
h). Family of prosecutrix was apparently on good terms with family of accused.
However, it is established on record that relationship between the two families turned sour when wife of accused demanded the money deposited by accused in the bank account of prosecutrix, due to which, mother of prosecutrix (PW-2) .