inconclusive. It is further submitted that the appellant has
failed the affinity test. The appellant has not been in a
position to depose before ... documents submitted in
support of the claim but also on the affinity test,
which would include the anthropological and
ethnological traits, etc., of the applicant
Vigilance Cell for making
enquiry, an occasion for the conduct of affinity test will arise.
(b) For the reasons which we have recorded, affinity test ... cannot be conclusive either way. When an affinity test is
conducted by the Vigilance Cell, the result of the test along
with all other material
Vigilance Cell for making
enquiry, an occasion for the conduct of affinity test will arise.
(b) For the reasons which we have recorded, affinity test ... cannot be conclusive either way. When an affinity test is
conducted by the Vigilance Cell, the result of the test along
with all other material
Vigilance Cell for making
enquiry, an occasion for the conduct of affinity test will arise.
(b) For the reasons which we have recorded, affinity test ... cannot be conclusive either way. When an affinity test is
conducted by the Vigilance Cell, the result of the test along
with all other material
further submits that in respect of area restriction and affinity
test, there are so many Judgments of this Court and this issue is
no more ... submitted that the Caste Scrutiny Committee
considered only the affinity test and rejected the documentary
evidence. There is no scientific material available with regard
further submits that in respect of area restriction and affinity
test, there are so many Judgments of this Court and this issue is
no more ... submitted that the Caste Scrutiny Committee
considered only the affinity test and rejected the documentary
evidence. There is no scientific material available with regard
Committee that the petitioner has failed to
satisfy the affinity test, the fact remains that the
satisfaction of the affinity test can be considered ... matter of grant of validity certificate
based on the affinity test."
18. Similar view is already taken by this Court in the
judgment
that
respondent No.1-Scrutiny Committee lacks power to hold the affinity
test and embark upon the anthropological inquiries in the matter of
Article ... pertain to his forefathers
and other grounds like failed to prove affinity test, native place of
ancestors within the restricted area of scheduled tribe prescribed
documents of pre-constitutional era, the committee
then invoked the affinity test and relied upon the observations of the
Apex Court in case of State ... Tribe, as by raising a spurious
claims. Therefore by applying the affinity tests, the committee
refused the validity to the petitioners.
The impugned order record
Petitioners on the ground that they have failed to establish the
affinity test. It is submitted that when the documents produced
by the Petitioners established ... permissible for the Respondent -
Scrutiny Committee to go into the affinity test and to reject the
tribe claims of the Petitioners. Hence, the impugned orders
