governing verification of caste
status, particularly the requirement of conducting an affinity test. It
is well settled that determination of caste status cannot be based ... contrary view. The deliberate
suppression of the favourable findings of the affinity test renders
the impugned order wholly arbitrary and unsustainable
Committee that the petitioner has failed to satisfy the affinity
test, the fact remains that the satisfaction of the affinity test
can be considered ... matter of grant of validity certificate based
on the affinity test."
Judgment 11 J-W.P. No.1889 OF 2024+1
18. Similar view
Committee that the petitioner has failed to satisfy the affinity
test, the fact remains that the satisfaction of the affinity test
can be considered ... matter of grant of validity certificate based
on the affinity test."
Judgment 11 J-W.P. No.1889 OF 2024+1
18. Similar view
Scrutiny Committee also committed an error by giving emphasis on
the affinity test to invalidate the tribe claim of the petitioner and
therefore, urged ... Learned AGP would further submit that the petitioner also failed in
affinity test as he could not satisfy the aspect with regard to
Anthropological traits
order dated 29th January 2011 on the grounds of
Affinity Test and area restriction.
7. Being aggrieved by the aforesaid decision of the Scrutiny Committee ... affinity test cannot be applied as a litmus test. We may again note here that
question of conduct of the affinity test arises only
order dated 29th January 2011 on the grounds of
Affinity Test and area restriction.
7. Being aggrieved by the aforesaid decision of the Scrutiny Committee ... affinity test cannot be applied as a litmus test. We may again note here that
question of conduct of the affinity test arises only
that the sole respondent is a member of
Mogia Tribe. The affinity test conducted in the matter establishes
that the sole respondent Dule Singh Solanki ... supposed to be conducted by the
Vigilance Officer, would include the affinity test of the applicant
to a particular tribe to which he claims
order dated 29th January 2011 on the grounds of
Affinity Test and area restriction.
7. Being aggrieved by the aforesaid decision of the Scrutiny Committee ... affinity test cannot be applied as a litmus test. We may again note here that
question of conduct of the affinity test arises only
area restrictions as well as failure of petitioner to satisfy the
affinity test. He, therefore urge that Respondent No.1-Scrutiny
Committee has committed ... documents having probative value as well as harping on the affinity test.
In support of his submission, the learned Counsel for the petitioner relied
Scrutiny Committee also committed an
error by giving emphasis on the affinity test to invalidate the tribe
claim of the petitioner and therefore, urged ... Learned AGP would submit that the petitioner also failed in
affinity test as he could not satisfy the aspect with regard to
Anthropological traits, Ethnic
