Venture Professional Hospitality Pvt. ... vs The Union Of India Ministry Of Finance ... on 4 September, 2025
19. The decisions relied upon by the Respondents are not
applicable to the facts of the present case, since in the present case on
11 June 2019 the Petitioner in its statement has quantified and
admitted the liability. It is also important to note that by letter dated 1
March 2019 also the Petitioner had quantified and admitted certain
liability and requested the Respondents to give their working which till
Page 7 of 9
Sayyed 9-WP.3383.2022(J).docx
today has not been replied to by the Respondents. Therefore, the two
decisions relied upon by the respondent in the case of JSW Steel
Limited (supra) and Shri Siddhi Kumar (supra) are not applicable to the
facts of the present case. The FAQs issued by the Respondents dated 27
August 2019 (page 68 of the Writ Petition) and answer to question-45
(page 70 of the Writ Petition) also supports the case of the Petitioner
that the quantification was done before the cut-off date. In the light of
the above facts, we pass the following order:-