Moon Rock And Marble Company ... vs The State Of Tamil Nadu And Ors. on 13 January, 1995
9. Ultimately, learned Counsel for the petitioner places reliance on the judgment of this Court in the case of S. Palaniyandi and Anr. v. The District Collector and Anr., Salem 1994 Writ L.R. 719. On the facts of the case, the learned Judge found that the petitioners were entitled to quarry, remove and transport rough stones in big sizes or blocks also in accordance with law on the basis of the leases granted to them and they were entitled to quarry for the full actual duration of lease from the date of registration of the lease agreements, notwithstanding the period mentioned in the lease agreements. The decision turned entirely on the facts of the case and cannot govern this case. The facts are in dispute and the petitioner cannot claim any relief unless and until the facts in dispute are established in a manner known to law.