Binod Kumar vs The State Of Jharkhand & 222 Others on 28 July, 2022
43.The petitioners have also relied upon the judgement passed by
Hon'ble Rajasthan High Court in writ petition no. 1211/2014
(Banwari Lal versus State of Rajasthan and another) to submit that
the instant case is fully covered by the said judgement. This court
finds that the said judgement passed by Hon'ble Rajasthan High
Court is clearly distinguishable on facts as in the said case the
scaling method was adopted not only for the optional subjects but
also for the compulsory subjects and the formula adopted for
scaling was itself found to be faulty as it had the effect of excluding
meritorious candidates as demonstrated by the writ petitioners of
the said case. In the instant case there is no such corresponding
8 LPA 198 of 2019
and analogo us cases
facts. Scaling method has been adopted only for optional subjects,
the formula has been found to be scientifically/ statistically sound
by the experts as indicated above and the petitioners have not been
able to demonstrate that the meritorious candidate have been
excluded on account of applying the method of scaling in the
optional subjects.