Supreme Court in that context. Even Subba Rao, J. in his dissenting judgment equally placed reliance on the American precedents on the 14th Amendment ... which we have stated more than once during the course of the judgment, the discussions of the U. S. Supreme Court which turn peculiarly
Supreme Court in that context. Even Subba Rao, J. in his dissenting judgment equally placed reliance on the American precedents on the 14th Amendment ... which we have stated more than once during the course of the judgment, the discussions of the U. S. Supreme Court which turn peculiarly
Section 149 cannot be given the meaning 'served'. We dissent from the views expressed by the Gujarat and Andhra Pradesh High Courts ... obviously has, one must respectfully record a dissent therefrom.
31. Before parting with this judgment, reference must be made to the Division Bench judgment
both questions 1 and 2 discussed above. A perusal of the judgment would indicate that the issue was not adequately debated before the Bench ... supra) was brushed aside and dissented from without any indepth discussion. As has been shown earlier, later precedents in Ram Niwas v. Mithan
wake of this Division Bench judgment, a number of single Bench and Division Bench Judgments both reported and otherwise were rendered in line therewith without ... offences under Sections 41 and 44 of the Act. This Judgment has been expressly dissented from by my learned Brother S. S. Hasan
this connection, it may be mentioned that in the judgment of the Supreme Court, the dissenting single judge has observed that it was difficult ... discretion by the Income-tax Officer. However, in view of the judgment of the Supreme Court, it has to be presumed that the interest
both questions 1 and 2 discussed above. A perusal of the judgment would indicate that the issue was not adequately debated before the Bench ... entirely tenable. The contrary view in and (supra) was brushed aside and dissented from without any indepth discussion. As has been shown earlier, later precedents
then the same is not good law and the judgment is hereby overruled.
19. In fairness to Mr. Rameshwar Prasad, one must notice his pointed ... precedent within the country and they chose to dissent from as many as 9 judgments of the Madras, Mysore and Calcutta High Courts. The judgment
aspect, I feel compelled to take a contrary view and dissent from this judgment.
7. In order to fully appreciate the prescription of time
aspect, 1 feel compelled to take a contrary view and dissent from this judgment.
7. In order to fully appreciate the prescription of time
