Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law

Nikesh Tarachand Shah vs Union Of India on 23 November, 2017 Equivalent citations: AIR 2017

leading opinion of three Judges held that the judgment in Cooper affirms the dissenting 24 Cooper (Supra note 4), at page 289 (para ... decision in Maneka, in fact, expressly recognized that it is the dissenting judgment of Justice Subba Rao in Kharak Singh which represents the exposition

last 70 years illuminated some of them. In a series of judgments commencing from E.P. Royappa v. State of Tamil Nadu & Another ... dealing with article 14 has been dynamic. Justice Mathew in his dissenting Judgment in Bennett Coleman & Co. and Others v. Union of India

alienation in favour of a third party. Even the dissenting judgment of S.B. Sinha, J. had on this point noted: 62. It is also

pages 142-143) B.C. Ray, J. dissented from this view and followed the view of the Allahabad High Court, which accords the view ... numerical strength of six learned Judges. If the dissenting judgment of B.C. Ray, J. is to be added to the Kothari Products (supra) line

City Civil Court by L.C. Suit No.2942 of 2011.   After   judgment   of   the   High   Court   dated 13.05.2013,   the   respondent   No.6   approached ... 20279 of 2013 was finally   heard,   in   which   separate   and   dissenting judgments   were   delivered   on   25.04.2014,   which mandated   the   SLP   to   be   referred

other cases. We shall refer to the judgment of the High Court dated 10.11.2014 as the impugned judgment while considering all these appeals ... which is the basis of the judgment of the High Court, had itself been dissented and not followed by the Andhra Pradesh High Court

Federal Commr. of Taxation [(1925) 35 CLR 422 (Aust)].” 51. This judgment was followed by a Constitution Bench of this Court in DTC v. Mazdoor ... dissenting on this aspect, decided that the regulation cannot be read down, and must, therefore, be held to be unconstitutional. In the lead 43 judgment

M/S. Innoventive Industries Ltd vs Icici Bank on 31 August, 2017 Equivalent citations: AIR

State Of Kerala And Others vs Fr.William Fernandez Etc Etc on 9 October, 2017