under which the disclosure
of "privileged document" is barred based upon which the information had
been denied to me by you vide letter ... letter dated 27.08.2019, they
have categorically informed the appellant that the privileged document as
sought by him through his earlier RTI application has been exempted
petitioner further contended that
even if the documents form a part of the preparation of the documents
leading to the formation of the advice tendered ... President, the
same are also „privileged‟. According to the petitioner since the
correspondences are privileged, therefore, it enjoys the immunity from
disclosure, even in proceedings
lawyer does not in any manner grant him any privilege for his petition to be treated differently. Even otherwise, there is nothing on record ... could not reply as to how he is in possession of the documents particularly Annexure nos.3 and 6 which have been annexed with
chargesheet, has submitted that the petitioner does not deserve
the privilege of anticipatory bail. Replying to the contentions made by the
learned counsel ... poor
quality of coal is concerned, Mr. Sinha submits that those documents are not
part of the police papers. He submits that the petitioner could
Trial Court. Forcing CBI to provide to the
appellant evidence, records and documents it otherwise would not provide to him
or provide to him only ... accused were allowed to
force it to give out information and documents through the RTI Act .
38. The central point of this line of argument
primacy over any
privilege or special rights of any class of people including elected legislators;
and that all claims to privilege are subject to judicial ... therefore, it is not clear as to how "breach of
privilege" can be claimed on these points.
At the end, he had prayed
Trial Court. Forcing CBI to provide to the appellant evidence,
records and documents it otherwise would not provide to him or provide to him only ... accused were allowed to force it to give out information and documents through the RTI
Act .
38. The central point of this line of argument
Trial Court. Forcing CBI to provide to the appellant evidence,
records and documents it otherwise would not provide to him or provide to him only ... accused were allowed to force it to give out information and documents through the
RTI Act .
38. The central point of this line of argument
Trial Court. Forcing CBI to provide to the
appellant evidence, records and documents it otherwise would not provide to him
or provide to him only ... accused were allowed to
force it to give out information and documents through the RTI Act .
38. The central point of this line of argument
Trial Court. Forcing CBI to provide to the
appellant evidence, records and documents it otherwise would not provide to him
or provide to him only ... accused were allowed to
force it to give out information and documents through the RTI Act .
Page 4 of 7
CIC/MORLY/C/2019/654966
