changed criteria cannot be
countenanced. The learned counsel contended that when the petitioner
joined the service and even thereafter the existing criteria for promotion ... from the date of such promotion because they get
promotion through a process of equal opportunity. Similarly, if
the promotion from the basic level
petitioner was recommended for promotion, the respondents who were fully aware of the pre-determined promotion criteria were bound to give him a grading which ... which deals with promotion from the post of Havildar to Naib-Subedar and for which a specific pre-determined promotion criteria has been laid down
followed
for promotion to E-5 or above level posts. It is once again denied that the
changes in the promotion criteria in the 237th ... meet minimum eligibility
criteria. It is stated that this modified criteria was applied to consider the
Petitioner for promotion in the years
followed
for promotion to E-5 or above level posts. It is once again denied that the
changes in the promotion criteria in the 237th ... meet minimum eligibility
criteria. It is stated that this modified criteria was applied to consider the
Petitioner for promotion in the years
followed
for promotion to E-5 or above level posts. It is once again denied that the
changes in the promotion criteria in the 237th ... meet minimum eligibility
criteria. It is stated that this modified criteria was applied to consider the
Petitioner for promotion in the years
followed
for promotion to E-5 or above level posts. It is once again denied that the
changes in the promotion criteria in the 237th ... meet minimum eligibility
criteria. It is stated that this modified criteria was applied to consider the
Petitioner for promotion in the years
wholly illegal inasmuch as, she was denied reasonable consideration for promotion. The criteria for promotion to the post of Manager was seniority subject to suitability ... unfit which was similar to the criteria of seniority-cum-merit. Wherever therefore criteria of promotion is seniority-cum-suitability, promotion is not automatic
orders.
Rule 4 of the Rules 1986 provides that where the criteria for promotion is merit, the appointing authority shall prepare a list of senior ... Rule 4. Preparation of eligibility list where the criteria is merit.- Where the criteria for promotion is merit, the appointing authority shall prepare a list
accordance with law. That the criteria for considering the promotion was over all assessment of seniority, date of entering into the service, age, efficiency, confidential ... merit and seniority. It is for the employer to stipulate the criteria for promotion and it is permissible for the employer to have their
further submitted that it was for the employer to provide the criteria for promotion and as the same belonged to the area of policy making ... promotion policy cannot be read dehors the other provisions of the promotion policy which deal with the criteria for promotion and weightage. As seen above
