Central Administrative Tribunal/High Court judgment.
That the Review DPC for the year 1989-90 to 2001-02 considered the name of the applicant also ... award of penalty to the officer the recommendation of Review DPC for these years in respect of the applicant is in Sealed Cover.
That consequent
case for promotion as Deputy
Commissioner was re-considered by the Review DPC. His seniority ... DPC or if there have
been grave errors in the procedure followed by the
DPC. Thus, it may be necessary to convene Review
DPCs
junior,
and others were promoted. Directions for holding review DPC to
promote the petitioner to the post of JAG from due date with all
consequential ... been
awarded minor penalty of censure in May, 1992.
10. The review DPC/Selection Committee meeting was held in July,
1996 for promotion
reporting authority was not reviewed by the reviewing authority was available
for consideration by the DPC. Further, the review authority had graded the
applicant ... made by the DPC is as in Annexure - I."
Para 4 from the DPC minutes dated 28.05.2010 :
"4. The Review Committee were informed
finally upheld the decision of the Respondents to constitute a Review DPC to reconsider the said promotion.
8. The Applicant challenged the aforesaid Order ... enquiry. During the period of suspension, they have also held the Review DPC on 24.06.2002 to re-consider his case for promotion. According
Review DPC held on 01.07.2008, the Secretary (Commerce) attended the DPC meeting as he was Member of the DPC composition as per the amended ... Outstanding grading by the Reporting, Reviewing and Accepting Authorities. A question persist in our mind why the Review DPC did not follow the then extant
Scheme has been ordered to be considered in Review DPC by the competent authority vide order dated 31.3.2009 and his representations have been disposed ... respondents under RTI Act is at Annexure A/5. However, no Review DPC was held for about one year. The Review DPC was ultimately held
proper manner and then to hold review DPC by preparing year-wise accurate extended panels for the total number of vacancies each year. He also ... then to hold review DPC and award consequential benefits to him. The applicant also seeks quashing of the order dated 2.11.1995 and notification dated
applicant herein, through this OA is assailing the recommendation of the Review DPC held on 16.9.2009 declaring her as unfit for promotion to Senior Administrative ... reviewing officer. Resultantly, we are not considering the respondents contention that in any case a reviewing authority had also to review the matter to whom
competent authority, they submitted representation requesting to hold the review DPC for consideration of their cases on the ground of additional vacancies which arose ... following prayers :-
8.1 Direct respondent No.1 to get a review DPC held through respondent No.2 for the post of Deputy
