promoted,
a decision was taken to call for a Review DPC for filling up the two (2) posts of
DLR&SO through a note ... DPC at a subsequent stage upon the detection of an
anomaly or error committed by the earlier DPC. Therefore, the findings of the
Review DPC
vide which they were promoted was subjected
to many reviews and none of the review DPC's
altered their position. Even today respondents
have ... accorded approval for holding a Review-cum-Regular Departmental
Promotion Committee (Review DPC) for reviewing of the original
DPCs pertaining to the vacancy years
name was kept in circulation. In the
meeting of review DPC held on 10.02.2021 with reference to the DPC dated
29.09.2018, petitioner was found suitable ... Perusal of proceeding of review DPC convened on 10.02.2021 of the DPC
meeting dated 29.09.2018 would show that in review DPC petitioner was
found suitable
2006 as per the
recommendation of the Review DPC dtd.27.11.2020 and to the rank
of Deputy Secretary ... 2008 as per the 2nd Review DPC
held on 22.12.2021.
Page 1 of 5.
4.1. It is contended that in terms of the order passed
eyes of law.
(iii) Set aside/quash impugned Review DPC held on
25.04.2023 vide Notice F. No. II (34)/1/Estt/SL-
Insp/2020 ... case that the respondents were continuing the process
by convening a review DPC for promotion to the post of
Superintendent and had also issued
vide order NO.STA/9-19/LSG (NB)/Postal
Unit/Review DPC/2015 dated 19.05.2017.
(b) to HSG II(NB) cadre on merit ... vide
order No.STA/9-19/HSG II(NB)/Postal Unit/Review
DPC/2015 dated 19.05.2017.
(c)to HSG I (NB) cadre on merit
been extended to
various applicants, as on date stands reviewed in view of the Review
DPC held on 29.01.2018 conducted on the basis ... vide Review DPC held on 21.11.2011 has since been
reviewed in light of the Review DPC held on 29.01.2018, conducted
on the basis
DPC did not recommend his name for
promotion against the panels drawn by the original DPC.
4.1 The detailed assessment done by the Original DPC ... DPC proceedings is limited. Courts
and Tribunals cannot sit in appeal over the assessment
made by an expert body, such as DPC/Review DPC, unless
grant permission for:
A) Inspecting and scrutinizing documents related to the DPC, review of DPC,
higher responsibility charges, notional promotion, promotional orders, all related ... Govt. of India that
were followed for the DPC, review DPC, higher responsibilities charges,
promotion confirmations, notional promotions and pay fixation for the promotion
accordance with their
empanelment by the review DPC for the vacancy year 2012-13
with all consequential benefits.
c. As a consequence of grant ... Foxit PDF Reader Version: 2024.4.0
applying senior-junior clause. The Review DPC
empaneled the applicants for promotion to the post of
STA for the year
