Secretary of the
Uttarakhand Subordinate Service
Selection Commission by which entire
selection process in question has been
cancelled.
iii) Issue a writ, order or direction ... right, when entire
selection is cancelled, to approach the Court and point
out that the decision to cancel the selection is
arbitrary. Arbitrariness is tabooed
selection process
and mere inclusion in the selection list does not vest any right for
insisting to be appointed, but whenever selection process is
undertaken ... Further, in the same selection process, selections were
conducted to the post of Stenographers, but their selection was not
cancelled. Therefore, cancellation is arbitrary
selection process
and mere inclusion in the selection list does not vest any right for
insisting to be appointed, but whenever selection process is
undertaken ... Further, in the same selection process, selections were
conducted to the post of Stenographers, but their selection was not
cancelled. Therefore, cancellation is arbitrary
alleged violation of Rule 15 regarding the quorum of Selection Committee, the selection cannot be cancelled.
16. On being confronted on the aforesaid submission ... short comings or anomalies in the selection in question, the said selection could have been cancelled but this Court is unable to comprehend
cancel the entire selection so as to ensure the correctness in the process of selection. In a large scale selection process, where more than ... respondents while cancelling the entire written examination. However, such reasonings are required for the purpose of cancelling the selection process en masse.
29. The party
going into details of the selection proceedings found that the selection proceedings suffer from the following irregularities and cancelled the said proceedings with a direction ... empowered to cancel the proceedings, there is no illegality in the action of the General Manager in cancelling the selection proceedings and that there
after
five years does not have any reference to the notice cancelling
selection process issued in 2009 which had required that all
candidates found ... Chief Security Commissioner, RPF,
Northern Railway took a decision bonafide to cancel the
selection process as a whole and in his opinion there were
large
arguments:
(1) That the selection having been held and the petitioners declared successful, the selection could not have been cancelled and the respondents acted arbitrarily ... selection is held separately and the impugned selection pertained to district Siddharth Nagar. As such there is no direct concern or relevance with the selection
selection process. Before the selection list
could be issued the respondents issued a notice dated 15 th April, 2020, cancelling
the whole selection process. Subsequent ... where the selection process was abandoned; one would be before the selection
process concludes; the second is when the process culminates, selection list is
issued
without cancelling the entire selection process.
8. Nextly, it is submitted that for the small
irregularities in the selection, the selection of the
petitioners ... unlawfully benefitted
or wrongfully deprived of their selection and therefore,
the selection process is liable to be cancelled.
17. In all the cases relied
