Delhi District Court
Civil Suit For Dj & Adj/177/2007 on 20 November, 2007
1
IN THE COURT OF SMT. SARITA BIRBAL: ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE: DELHI
! "
# $ &%'
'#(% ) +* ,
%
-
.
/-
01*2 '3 * 4 % 5 "
6 6 7+ 98(" : ;
< = >@?A*:) B*2" : 9 "
CD 8E +7+ 9" : 9 ?F8G H. I= = JK% "L M) 3 3 N>: +793 O)QPR B% 3S6 3T U : 9 3 * >.
*F"
6 6 Q BV13 Q F >A*23 8(3 $T3 * 3 W XY6 "
*Z .3
-
; & [ ! \ 2"T 23' ] :%T" D6 3 : : 9 3 * 8( V^6 "
QP!>.
*:V13 *U7 P_#( E`a ]"L < ?D E% #cbE3 P 79"
ed + " 8Q3!bI . f`g% ;8T%h% "L a) 3'3 iV13 *2, 3 g`a B%j B% 3R6 3 : U 9 3 * ) "
#k$ ; 3l *2 3 *1 " .3 m EnL Zo /- Tpq6 "L ( I3 r)QPts& Eu+) 793vsD 9, %wCD '*Z a > V^) " PL 9 ^ [ w \ ." .3 x :%T" y" 7+7z B% 3{"L ( I3 U |"
7[ 9"
) +7+ U 93L } >f?~ % #G"
bE3 P 7;"
Rd "
8(3!bI . i% " i) 3 3 ."
#G3 1 $T3 *)QPh + !" # n'
9 5 B% 3^8("L I3^ >L B% 3i6 3 : : 9 3 * B% " *23L E6 3 Q y`c"L f, *2"
Q .3 s *23! '*28T% "L 3y>." 8 [7+ Pg>. *L>: + T"
8E ,h"$T3 % 98E793RV1" # 3 " *U ( : ( HL) 3 " *U ,
esA X:J' X En \p HK ' e I J J o LHkC%' & . oEJ' (p $ 9 3 sD +*23 '*28T% "L I38 'V bE "
S" , *23 3 V13 Q j "T 23 - = = /- "
S 2 T 2"
7 'V > F
-
H/- = H= oE I X`c"L f [ ) L* 3' ^ . y :%T3N*23L E6 3 Q >.
*' B% 3M6 3 *U 9 h > B% *.3 3 P 3 " * E F 9 [ N>: '*Z B% 3 *" 7+7;3 ,'3 :%T" f*23L E6 3 Q A" , *23 3 . *23 6 " Pe B% 3O I" 9 7; "
S"
V1 ' Q g 3 T" .3 rV1 Q B% 7 P % *23w8T% "
*2, 3L _ > F &J oEJ I X 9 g [ >U L*Z B% 3 * \ ." .3 ] B% " " > .3 *" $T" [7+ ,K% *236 '*28T% "L I3R>." 8 +7+ PLH' B% 3K*23L E6 3 Q >2"
[793 . k6 " Pi3 T" .3 kV1 Q B% 7 P]% *23k6 L*28 %T"L 38T% "
*2, 3L ^"L ^6 3 * I8T% 3 793 2 LE .¡I ¢T £2¤ ¥ £2 ¦y § £c¤ § R£2 ¨ ©TL\ UEª«9 [j¬:©'£Z B £ \ .¤ . B ¤ ¤¡ ©'¦ ® ¬ ¯F ª.° ±² ³'±² °\´ ªµ ¶a·c¤L1 ©T¡¤L ® §^¸E´ ª² ª/¸ ¹ ¹ ¶y¤ º ¤ §\ B R£2LE ® § §Q ª «9 5t¬:©'£Z B £_» .¤ . ¼ :T¤ k¥ ® ¤ §½¤ º £2 ¦1 §Q N·¤Lq ¾T ¿ ©( . À Z·c §m B ¤ £Z :9L¤ zÁ& ¥ ¤ § y :TR¥ ® ¤ §¤ ¦ ® ©'§Q '·c¤L1 5EÀ ©'£I ® B M£2LE ® § §Q ¬:£ ® ¦m B Á& ¥+ ® ¬ ¬:;¿( ® ¬ B K : : ® § £ À ¤ § Â(ªx«9 &[¬:©'£ : £¤ ¢T £:£. ] :T¤ ¥ ® ¤ §K¤ º £2 ¦1 §Q ¿ ® §Q .¤ §¤¿ ¥;¤ © I¬ ® ££.L ® ¥+©( : ® § ® ¬ [ © 2LN B £ ® ©Tº ¤ £:À B£2¤ : ® §LªÃ i£. ¥; ¢T¤ §Q ¿ ¥9¤ © I ® ¬ B ¡I¤ 9^¤ º £2 ¦1 §Q R[c¤LA¬ ® +¥ ¥ ® ·TÄ Å Å;Æ ÇÉÈIÊIËÌ ÍÉÎzÏ;Ð ÈEÑTÒËEËEÓNÔIËQÎ/ÕË Ë ÖÎ.×IËRØQÈTÒÙÎ2ÏÉËTÐÎ×IÈIÎÏ[Ö^ÚGÈ Ð»ËhÛQÜÝÈÖ Þ ÓTÏ9ÐØEß\ÎàË ÈÒ2Ï9ÐGÏ5ÖQÑ ßEÖIÓ Ë ÒTÎ×(Ï9ÐDáÑTÒËEË âËÖ Î Î.×IËÐ\ÈTâË1Ð×QÈTÇ9Ç(ÔË^ÒËQÜË Ò.ÒË Ó ÎÛ1ÈÖjá Ò.Ô(Ï Î.ÒàÈIÎÛ Ò ÈÎÎ×Ë1Û Ø Î2ÏÉÛÖfÛQÜÎ.×IË ã ÕÖIËÒäaå×IËaá Ò.Ô Ï Î.ÒàÈIÎÛ Ò Ð×QÈTÇ9Ç ÔË1ÖIÛ âcÏ5ÖQÈIÎËEÓ1Ô\ÞAÎ.×IËfã ÕAÖIË ÒÈÖIÓÎ×ËfÈÕDÈTÒÓÛQÜEÎ.×IËjázÒ.Ô Ï Î.ÒàÈIÎÛ Ò Ð×QÈ Ç5Ç ÔËgÜ.Ï5ÖQÈTÇ ÈÖÓ!Ô Ï[ÖÓÏ[ÖQÑ^Û ÖgÈTÇ9ÇÎ.×IË¡ØQÈTÒÙÎ.Ï ËTÐfÚ Û ÖIÚ ËÒ.ÖIËEÓ æ Ï5ÖIÚIÇ[ßIÓTÏ[ÖQÑyÎ.×IË ÑTßQÈÒàÈTÖ ÎÛ Òä[Å Å ç ä è ËQÜË ÒË ÖÚ ËcÚGÈÖfÔIË âjÈ ÓEËjÎÛÎ.×IË ® £2 £' ¤ . h¸°Tªé ª/¸ ¹ ¹L¸¡ ¤ QI +§ëê ì í îíaïðñ ® /ª ¸ µ'¸ò ¸ ¹ ¹'¸½óhôAò<ëõ ® .¤ Ârôg¤ § £2¤ ê § ¤ § ¿(÷öI .q¢ ª ìF ® Âõ©'¦1¤ £ øOí £\ù ± ® £. £ ¤ . !¸ ¹úª ² ª/¸ ¹ ¹úûh ¤L(I §!ê ìFím¸ é ³\ò ¸ ¹ ¹ û óü :;¿ ® £ê +§ ¤ § ¿(lî « § 9¤ ðhö ¦y . |¢ ªñ& £2¤þýfÿE¤ §Sø½ìA§ £ù ® ¬ ® § À ¥; Á ¥ D9º ü ® ©'£ D¤ §T ÿQà ¸ ¹ ¹ µ|î¸ ðfïzü¼³Q´ ´l+§_¿(¤LIó à wôg¤ § ¤ º § º Á& £2 ¿G ® £B±í £U ¾ì~©( ® ê § ¤ § ¿(lî « § 9¤ ðhöI .|¢|ï £UÝÿ ¤ º ¦1¤ § £fï Ù§ º Sø ìD§ £Bª5ù ª à O£2 ¬. £2 § ¿(¿(¤ §_¤ ¥[ ® À ¦1¤ e ® B ® £2 £D ¤ . O³'ª5´ ª/¸ ¹ ¹'¸ ª ° ° ¶ ò ¹'¸ló üA : ¤ § ÂSñì D ª LElõ©'¦1¤ £ù ± ¤L( l §xê ìFí î.ígïðhñ ® ® £2 £j ¤ . v° ° ª/é ª/¸ ¹ ¹ µl+§lê ìí °I²'éò ¹ µ ó ü : ¤ §  ñì D ª ©' § £ ï+§ º ù¤ §T ® £2 £M¶Lªû ª/¸ ¹ ¹ ´ +§ëüA¯ ¸ ¸ ³\ò ¹ ´ §½ó ï .¤ § ¤ £2 ¤ §  ª Áz¢T § £Fôg¤ º ¤ £Zù À ® § +À ¥9KÁ& ¥ 9º ]ü ® ©'£Z ªÝ« §]¤ ¥+¥( B LIe¿Q¤LIL :T ® § À ¥9 9º hü ® ©'£Z ¤ !¤ ® §Q . ]£. ¿Q ¢T £ ¬ ® £ú B ¢T 9¿ ¥;! ¾ < ¤ £Z . ® § 3 ! "# $&%' ( ) *) +, -"/. $0 (12"43- 561 79801 : ;3<"0 1=>3 ?#+@ A3B "/7C3<$/7D(5E"F. "G3H:=$I$/7'1 7D ="
J 8K #: 5L. >3NM ( O3H. PQ R$0 8!J 8K " $Q S TU 8V"0W 8K5(X8Y >3 (8K (5Z$0 8[) \ 1=1= 8K5#7] J#% >?_^`. ) ab.@: @7] 5( 8c^d7] J . ? \ :="F. 847C3B(5fe` (8K>3B "0 "/7 g h $ "/.
"/7 "/7' 8i1= j >3k (80 5l7] "F. Z ( @%97D1= "/7' m7C3n ( #7] "0(5Z >3o"/. 8K(1=#7 g 8`"0 p"0 q2r1 :@3<"0 (5 s $ "F. R3B #7'5pg .@7D1 %'N ! q2R ! q2 tY 84:="/7vu@w(wX? M ( 847] Jyxz X) { e`T/| w(T~} X}< ? )>xz X)&}Bw(|(w(| * ?@ . )>xz X)0} * | uG} $F8K X "/.
8K>3 5( "43h 8Q O "F. 8; 83B O 5O"K q2( R"/. 3B !f: 5( 8.@73 1 . X8KJ(X)ez(1 #7 g 8 ! p"0 q2O #%97'1=h >3=3=7C3<"0 1= 7] p1= >3BZ $c ((5X)d. $I$47'1= 8 M "0 #79 @7] J "/. #3 3B>3=3H7' $ "F. g .@7D1 %' P-79%9%73=3H:
( (8K (847' "0 8K(1=#79 "#"0 "F. 83B $/80 PY. >31 :@3<"0 (5 g .@7'1 %'y7C3Q"0 q2 5PQ79%C% #%C3B s "0 5( PQ "F. 8K#7] "F. n1= 5#7 "47' $v"F. g .@7D1 %'n 5yP-79%9% 3H: 8K "F. "A"F. g .@7'1 %D 7C3 q =" 7] "F. 3 ! 1= 5#7 "/7' )Wd.
8K E: 8K "/7' 7 $_ "K "/. s8K(1=#7 g 8d3 . #%9% ""F. $/7]83<" 7] 3<"0 1=M s #7'5
M "F. "/7 "/7' 8F)
|X) d. ;g .@7'1 %Dy3 . #%9%"F. 8K( $I"0 8#PQ79%C%@M 65( #% " PQ7 "F.7] ; (1=1= 8K5( 1=
P-7 "F.l"/. $/: 8V"F. 8o 8K5( 8;PY.@7'1 . ! M >3=3B(5M W"F.@7C3W1= #: 8V" 7] "F.@7C3
"/7 "/7' )
) +3=3H: h "/7D1=h $z"F. R "/7 "/7D X "0 R8K>3 5( "43y j`Be
5
"/. 8K #: J .! #:="F. 847C3B(5 1= #: 847' 8# (J( 12 $0 8#w ) )@w(w>u ) ^ \ ¡e +' \ ad+Ve a \¡¢ £ \¡¤_¥ ¤ ¢ {¡+ @wX)0}(} )@w(w 4