M/S.Engineering Projects (India) Ltd vs M/S.B.K.Constructions (Bkc) on 21 January, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 2]

Karnataka High Court

M/S.Engineering Projects (India) Ltd vs M/S.B.K.Constructions (Bkc) on 21 January, 2011

Equivalent citations: AIR 2012 KARNATAKA 35, 2012 AIR CC 44 (KAR), 2011 (4) AIR KANT HCR 584, (2012) 4 RECCIVR 77

Bench: N.Kumar, B.Sreenivase Gowda

3&3? TEE HEGH CQEJRT Q? i{ARNA.'E°°£s§'& A'? 

E-.}z'3§§.'§_*:}3 "E'§T-HS ":*:~-He: 2: 1  ziszw Q? 2,: AN Uz*~J-+1':-5, £33'    ~

E?}E%2Ei1ES§.':?§\J_'_§T.... 

$33 36%" Big MR' JUs3*r§<:i,E..§'§.:§?:rs§z%;R   '

>?*x?%i;>

$33 any gm MR. J:Is*r1§§:_ .B,s;1;%EEf:s::§x%;é;sE §:3+®wnA

    %k
g§;§C. 1N{g; 2,;"3:é" 998:« '

E3 E5;-'i."'W §;::::_1$g; _

EVE g' ssi. --Ei?§T1g§:;€%é7:'§'§'§g:; v;'37;'"<}j <-i<?£.5:f {.E:'1<.§§iaE Li. (Ea.
E53. E33,?-CN<}§£%§?, &"<:é'€:.v;5::2§::§:.:é«e:;'m:2':21g;21:1

.  -. E3:1"3:--§ié1i{3:%s:é 4" 56% 038;"
V_ . E%!e:§_3:°e3_:=.r'1.?,{:~:§ bf;
  Sm} fix'?  R'.§_«, E3:;€.11_c§[€-:., s%i.§,<3:°;3e}4-*' E0 §.:'§.{'.
' Ch'ai;?'m£:§t{_21;'; {$11. Wialzé a g;§.r1;_;_§ I§f}.i§re{?E 9:.' <2?

* _;'13.;T'a§"§'3T;

E%:'E,f;+3. E%3:'1§;:{.:°ﬁé::«§;:g*§?:"2;§ §3'I"(i§€¥(ff?§$ {F3 Lida  §3@.§,§.i':i{3z":.£:%:"
' V' V {E-353? Eézéa E/. "§11:'a}»;21:fa ;:'3:1 {Tf:.m:é.§;:::§ §::si*'
$2?' ., 9? :3. mi :11? Th 2?: 1': 2:2? ;7i:fiv.,:%

far?/:<;. E3 E1, {:«{'3§":.i€»=E"§"'i.'%{E'§'i{}HE:3 {§:§§'-'Z{T7-Ea

""§'§<'>,Ei~<%*{'§a ﬁa.:':jzi:é{t:j;:;3 '§'§:%:'2':§;§::: 

§.5s;21;&?3;vJ;2.:";-rsjg} 2.: :';;;m.'_:.,

E§a2§'2§;€22Eé:'s:'c--  Eﬁéitéif} %T}{}%«"§,

1%-i=g..:':'z%5az::'2ézjiié 'i.i:{:.-=' §%s~';- §73;'::§'3:':'<>?::>§*

f§;"i._ EM-~3__,{T.' :f*§§":2'=a:'§"§:;'.:., 



«so:

ﬁn

8/0. 8. R2::1':":a§':;':2-1.

zigéai z%.§:s<3u¥L'. 4% }f't%2z:":'=,~s;  E%:%:ig§;§3'§';:ié%'1':i}. '2

{B3-* Sri, K E%ia.g:{§::2-u-':é:r:£i:"a1 Ram, f&£iv :};

'E'%";i<s zi':I"§3i*;:1'at,£c33:: C2188 iziieci z.1.j'ﬁi é:?"<3»-:~={§:s;~ °V«EE_T}*€1_1§e E- <<:}§ 319 T

 
   

CFC; rfw S::*<::E.§{>z1 (E4 GE' '(E16 E&:'b§§:;*:?;:::<}:'1 -;*'~Li:%i; ::'e:';i3s%i:i§._,§ éj.{::'£§;"a:~,._j up
22 cieczrzse in ii-3:"m.s <2? 'E',i":.:~:» gmrareﬁ da_%;'e<:H__§ Eaéii 199$'; 21:}. i.§1<~:t --i:€é:';e;~e.3i

:3? jL1:'%E1§€:€%.

in AC, .I\§<}.?;g' 2.996:
B ETWEZEZN

~Sz"i. B. R. C. Sharmag
Sfa Ei Rar1'1a'r11ﬁ_;:;  & _
Agsd 21b02,1€. 4Cfj: }F)§§§  =i   A ' 
P1"€}}1>:'i<:t*£'.o:'€.>'§"~  4' L *

  

M/:2. B. K. 3:301":-sé' :1c::1;a.:«;s;';--{.".'i~L%  M-

 

.v

  

Q
M
ma
e"\

N0. 5¢£6,_3x.:f{§  V  Tf'_€g11;;3_'l§;: V'
Subs: 63¢, ' "V'isw€£:~fw;1rpé';;rz: m;~ ._ '

Be1:":,g_§,21E§>1*€._ + €};£.%." .  _» < .e.P:%tiiim1e1"

{%{3Z-3; fir? Q  KL' ~'I{2%.gh21x?e'1'1.c§ fa Rag. Adxa}

        

 V  3 "vI?v'§€',:5s3Q?%:i1g§i:'1.é3::f:°im,g§ ?:'<)§€C'E'.S {lndézl} Edtﬁug

& §:i';::?!§':':7V3€f§§»3%':§.%3{§ E33' $31.8 pmg' em; .E%«'Ze::1a.g;€;",
E3135 'F~E_':>,&f%§7. Je€*~xa:*: Bima E'»Ez3Tgga:".
§3§_;:%.1':gg:2:;'§{>m~. W .568 SS8:

 "Z5, '%I'E;.:::">S{5E.s3 z'%;'bit4;°21€.<2':'.;

 Sri' V1 53" E."}:i;?5~;i";p::nd::
= §?<m'21a:%:" Chéﬁf" e_}'U;s€~:<Eic;:€;
Ef}%3§§%.§T High C{}{Ei°L
:3» EEE. °{}i.¥;:.:-mw}?2?aE§'

N<;%aar~§j}<?:EE'1§ ~ .2 £8: {E} ii .'.§"{*i'.:*L¥:g?}s'f3E"z*C.§%EE:";¥;',S:'~;

{E:3§g 5271.: 'sf. 'E'a;2.:"2?;.§£.a>1I"2':1'é':.  {'i{§ur'2sv3eE €01'
33:1 {.1 1,;{:ii4:E:%£M{§-E'}E?LE-(gigf ;%{§"a:.§



'§.'%":£s.~}; §§:"b'£1?.mi.§{tm <:*2:';55€ fi§€{§ :.1:s:<i<:'z' :S{-3.-{1':ii{;;;': 3{};.~.__§";§ {Em
sT'?s.:"bii::°zI7sE.i€f):'"1. fuii §,'ﬁE'E.'£}_.»"§f1§_§ gm .<5;&€k§'z§g ;1sa;i.{.Eé:: 'ma? 22m~*2az.:*§§ >e;'}::ie;:{§
}:ii if; §§§{} g)2':$::~3<?(i Fay :'€ssp{3:':dr;%m. ?\I2:;3.:2;= *   "

'E'he;=.-as ztzzsesjs ::<)::'2§:';;,§ 9:': fat}: §'"§€El§"§'E'"i'_--_'9 §.hi.:<a .{ié;:;. .:.§i':i<:"<ZT{§'u.--:'£j;~.

«:7§s:§§'2;&rec§ the, .i'<}§§<.>W3'.ngg:

gkif, E\§<:=.I£A/' E'§39€3 is; E'"§§{f:s§_ by 1';-i;'».<i~:."~ §ing;:f:i:--£f:<:,r§ n;§ E'5*i§'{§;re:'{%'£jssL
{ixzciizi} Limi§e::<;i L1:";€i::*3' S€<':£i<}:é* £25' '1;.§3_€ V"!'{r*b'ii.;:'a£i0z: Aim
;'equs%s;E.i':'1g this Cmm.  §.'{5;_ m_:é§,§~;c/ i"§,7.gc_ :»1.vv'2a,:"°{§ §A2r::%é.s§ee:§ ':33-* ¥;.E';e::

A:'E3ii.mi0;" 21:5 Eizziﬁ of ihifi €;f:§ufri: VV b

  H ':*':,{'j';.  ES _§'"i'Efé:§:"E by 'i'E1<3 :"e.sp{snc:§<:>::1E. in %;.E":e
23,£'<>rs%s;g1é=ﬁ.. ;.";«r<>a::::--:(i'i':1"§;.,.;€g'T':a;ea;f:':«;3§;: Mia»; BK, {?0§'::~st..1':2€:%,i0§1s5 {EKG}

m3di¢:.2;_' §z~:c?::'.§€;=.:': i3{}.:' _:'.21.Ar:§_ V..%.i-%'iE"; S{"f(3iii}:} '?{3: <3? the ;'-\.'3:'b£.E.:"21é§.£>1":. A<:'s;

   {§::£;iAZ"{f.i'j§"£€§,f§.é315"' ':'e--£.7:--?;'§'{é{?: 2:}  'am: ;'%€:%2:'E §3r23;3,-*i:":g_;T Egg; set: assicis

V E;i?<§ 21w:';n-35.1;   
"    ,§a;:s:;V":1'%7:§: s;a=u'z>j€:<?:. ":z':ai.t<t§' 9%" %><>§'.'%": §.E1&%s:~sé;-t <.:2':::3<~3s=s 512%: (me

1.

i'}¢:r:_V zzmi €:h2% §3a.:"€..§s:-rfe»; awe? $~'.§3;E_:'EE€:. E;.§"':s:'sss=:=, ap§3m§.éa are ';.:«z§«:_:>::T:. €59 €51" <'=<;:'1ss:::i€:m'§.§.»:.>1: i',.{}§_;:€3ihé'fE' 2.i;':{,§ {Ei.s:;§.>§:;55;:%{.£ af ivy '€332?:';--:i'3<'>':": <:2::'::E»::'.

4%. '§'*7'<:22' %'"E':€ §E{.§.E°§';€§f§€'.E.% 5121"' (.'E2'§§'.§§.}"°., §'a»'?',f" Béi. {fIa";:'::«;§:*:as"*§'%{.:n:~«: ::?a:2..:.I§<;.§ %":a:"= :":.;:*§'<%::":'<%s,:'E £0 "§"§{':'i§"iff§§'a;-.i§"'§.{E:°' ':.E'2i"~§' '$4 E M'__...

?:}i:*:£ N93 i5¢ Es": <;:°d:==,~:"' Ea: ap;§:*é%<*2'221é.aé i.§2§.~:~s p<}m1. 2'.i ~ n{€:::€$ss2f22u'§;'T 21:3 ::%xi..:'a{:¥§, Em-*e:'} <":§2m§::e;=§ Q? %1':E":€: :':{>1.':E§"2;1<:.€" ::}::i'V\%,%i/U (.',§':'. ,;f"€'.§_:i:3 :'1'{':2*:_ is '§f;§V.2:_a:§%:i§, "E3. "§)g§:2§j g3ei'z{2E§'g;" ----§,'§z'n_";_r:2z*}'««:' A:g:} i:e <:<;a.rV':'":¥i9;éF,Vr:>;?':§?_r::i 51%; 38 ;':'::}:'zi?'zs zirng frarn :s:e»::1:;.--z,a> Qf' :':;s;.:..$cw~.<;}*'T: Ea;§.1:§3} égf"

inderzsz. ff {he u:o;fi< £5 req:..z?{§'rz':g$ie:3{eci {z1"g?;'3<2j2gé_,H..f,. if}. zeiii Ede Z£3Z)§.€€§ }f'?r£$ "j%;z;.;'.r:i§;5'::% ';'§v£1£Vi"§;?;;i"é?*':'fbb 5:0 ¥Ti::"U<'§.§";'EE£I'i? Z{)% 53;" "coz'z.U"::"acz mcziufe .3 6. i:i,%%)§"i«<;;1iT::.:'ii'_Vr ¢ czﬁci $c:<)5:f I 4 E f"::e;>'§3r<>g;"e$s 533;" {he wait t;*":.;;,-44!.Vfggfﬁvfflézneféé.éi;rfg:zf€ :;;z.riiEi§3. pmgrczmme E13'! :VV.:>i'ZE'VTE:'{)zzA:}:¢': :L:lé{}§"E€ e)<e>»:7z.iE63d f;im3z.:gE'2. zfiifzez" -r,::?.A 'aim! €c:}SEI' cgf Si.£I')--C?OE?,Zi'I°5Es:f§.OI"

a:2'{i3._ Lz4§;:'.ZE "'2':a'%":":.€:':r;:'x..zf€:*--ézffjée mark." E/Vggriir {ran be _ .¥.;.?f?ff'E€§%:5£E{,%?'E;_;5{.£Z§; E323' f§;::r:"Z;; 52:. {he de;<.stc:?r€[_2£{o:': Qf" EQFI "'3'«:.z{;§~..f?§';¢>.g_-'23'. ?§2Aé§";3:<::zg;:\'£3s's: atma' 5:z,.zE)--::?ez'2§.2'a{:z?::;z' {£2555 i':az:£3 A _V :?._{§ sax??? wi§1§'z»:im.:,£:-Q5 {if E.i§{}F"§€ fr"r::%m {.3553 s<.:<i%;";é;2 Vz,;g_f}i=§2;é 3z.:§2--<:s;:'z2':':"a:?:;:}z:

Eiii *'§ ':h:"% Eaameqi .ﬁ§rfb1?'£':"°e11'<i>:" ii': 3£':$i"Jf;?E'i1'i§§ %;h.e {:<>z:::%',§2:° {Ti§?'i.,"§..'€:/f':"£ :}f"'§'.hz=i :'"e$;;}<'::zz<§e,:':'é. 2;.::":.c:i€t:' §,'.fr2::' 13::-:z;2{'E "E,i<;;:.é.i{§2:§<;éci <§a2:2':a-éggiéésf E':.a.sé:;':';?§Z<:€%r2 ::<>:.<::~ <3? éfmiy ihis; ;3<:ri'.§<;:": :33' {1E.;.m$e E3 Egg :'r§e2.:r f§2:;n1 " €3>g%;:°29y;':%:. sf %;,E'1€: %¥;'W§iil'"<§ WE:i{%.%; 1"<?;.2{§5~: :.1n:§::':-2':

"ff 33%,? :;a<;§'§s; E'E{}E £_'?{4}§'?'"i§3i?{"I?§'ef:?{,.§'. 5;": §':':'2':az E§:ig§.s.$}:'i.{;§.:55§ {T§€£?'I'E§E{;£'?.§:2 352.5255 326% :'e:a%:..%:'{..n::'. 525' 31%;: g.2:.9:ﬁj%>r"E"s':fgjgiéz. s.:§4§E:;_i;*:?§'. :2 z;2:i':s;"is::::.m 513;' f{f;¥%§.: =.<:::,>z:;':":':g"*:_-- §}§_,;§_§§4g{_={§ V' rz§::é;<5e:}:'§af}Zes V25:§%'é:;2{:r'2saziigm 1195 "E8 pez'§;c'm. f':<:a<€ {?{}?'?f.F€Z{?Z.£;'{f 31:} ~:2i5;a:7§'2.:z:;{gea 5:'? smsi 52:15:? }}?'{}§C€3I'? h is {T-'{}g'E.§,'fD€:z{:'{x §:<g';{an{;.z'i<m.-» In <;>3ILima§,ing {he Z053 at)?" £§52.:'§';a§g ;;> , A' ar£.:~3in§,2M_j'}"<)zn cf: bree:;cf1 z::_>f'e:?<f2nI.z"«:2;:"t'f', §:'f29 zns;>{z':':_5:'§' :..:,'=h.;f§}E': 'M 9;sc:':--::z'.e:3f, 02' r°<3n':e(ig;§.ng {E253 zf::.<f<;z?2.yz-?_r_1éemééz <:éﬁ2éa:2:%fse:f_V'§*,>::,_%AVV {fie noz'2.~_{)eyjﬁémzazzce <g;'"z,'f1<2 <:;:;:'z:m.{::A §<1r':a:s;{ be-:5'---f€z'E»::«'g:»:3 .« i{2.E.(} (z.c(7.::v:z.;': E, " 25?. Campensation fﬁf _:§?Y'€fCICi;l!. '- éor1 '§'rac£ where penalty V.:;tipuic:sté'cl w;.1€n 'Q-Mmﬁ {Tad has been broicerz, 'f§€E4';'?Z.'ifE'{L7'2.€ «::on::'rac:' as She a.m(32_,:r2Z: £70 5122*" ;:§gz'r:i Er: céczsé?;:;»f'°§:.;,:€§é bf€;'Cé{?§'i., 0:"

if £323 <?:3?ié2}s3§:f3j. :::&1:_nf.céz".r":';% ﬁxing} =i)§;$'.:t¢1f§ 3€,ig::z.ziaz;i<m by ?'i£.:30;§; &g{;'"'TI'_;}Qi'f£aZf.g,:,Effie f)C{i"f_§} c02'n;)Zaim'.rT2g <31" {he §'};<ea¢7E2. Es.a3z1€i'£;=3.eéig«_:£5§1¢::Ezer or nos: czci:z.zo:£ d.amag(3 0:' §<>:;S°.z§$ ;}rc2:,'»;zci'A.::'<} fiizaie bc3e:%2*': ::s:;::.:se{i £i'2;ereb;j. :0 ' ?"':3(.f(3E'E}€1"_f}"f}§:'?%:V 3.52:2 pczrig; mm} has broker'; €326 <::>m'2'+::z{:!. '?)CC,'£f€-X2.' E°I"£g ffif,' j :;:v..r}*:{;z.§':*:£ ":20 §'::m2{-xi 0:: {is 53:52 e:?€::5e:3 ;'?I:C£_gj E3529 5 £19 '"*:%;:§.

Egzimiieﬁ ﬁg Eiindieg gag Qmnymzg Limiieﬁ :°e3;::<:;'m:s% E;-2 ﬁiﬁ §§5§ SS 33$'? 51?' 4&5 S Egg} i'é'"§§%i'f§.'§.}§'§:"?§§..' iE"2:;=:'~s@ §.:.%;::; ;'}:*{.>::';?é»;§<}.:;.ss; ' ;j§€>?'2'{};§ gig; ~ pz.::.E(,: §:'e::§_ {(231 §}c§2§s::r'z,a;:.ia?t. A s£'§p:.iia.{.§<}:2 fa?" én.{7recz:§§%<"§ z':x'"2.§':er:3s;:. fz*€§r'?': 513%: €§.€,"£,{E-i' Q3" £§ejfQ,i.z§.€. mag; be (3 s§.:°pz.z.§a§,Ee:m 59;; :,:,,'s«:z§,=' 6:35' _i}€f'£{iiE'.§;.

'§'?z€* gigyfsx {:{}E.i.I'i £2": E,E.'2.:> a.?z::e;.e {:3 Sﬁiﬁa zfiiiﬁ ﬁaiing 92.2%. is? 2.-2E"§'}§'%.§";.1§'§{§"§E :::%;;1.:»>:«;{-3 ?3.:I;.2:3}; E":»:i~§{é 21:-2 N 2.3 p¥'i§EC€§§ES, seaiiarz :5::doubi'edEg sayg ma: ifjge aggrieved party :19 enizitied :23 receive c3rr:pe*r2,sax:z§"a:2;":*._ fmm {he party wha has bmken ::f':s:> ~ wheiher or moi' aczftzai éamage or 3.933 is géfgvaéé' :5 . have been caused ﬁg {E26 Eagjfeagh. i':'_ rrzereigg dispenses wiih pr:*}:é;' '"aé'E:§,aa'i 'EVs§«:3s §;:;f°"V damzizge"; ii does net j:,as:&§f7g;:~--_ {he e:i£E_1.J€3,?T",I:iU. if zsernpensaiiorz when én'>¢cﬁ';=r§eq:Lé'm:Ve Qf f§7;€§"bI78f2C?€ ma iegai injury at aii reéiaiiétcé' beéfsgmge carrwensaiian 1:91-..'_ breaC??'1" é:;:;_n€r0;c£ 'Ccf£n be awarded {*0 maiéé 'V'ga::'>Q§_v ﬁamage which naimaiiy amse girzw uTs¥.;;zi_ thingg or which :?:é3§%:1r::és ::E<:néz,:j" §é:fé.én._..§'3€ey macig the u €9'z?;:;'z';::;:*:f," i:3';€:s.é3'£i¥{é£ {0"~:f"eS':?.:Ei' .fé'oVm {he breach "}£,><' &§><::?£7 xx {E E}. Lﬁwéfgré iumirig E0 {he qz;£€si'ion abaui {he <:€dL::r:pé£::sa;i£0:é""ié}?1ic§1 may be awaircied. :9 piainigff. _iZ't2"v..4fKS".":?t';"'~-*£'"A.fé;';~?:3a?"wl5.£ is corzszﬁer whether S34 appiieﬁ :53 " - §§:;:%;:§r:::i§>?é3 fig? jagjjfeiiure {if azrzsunis dep0sz'.{"ea or pgziéi-ﬁnder" £513 seniraxsé, E: was urged iimé {he ';§,:e<'*1~£:'@?2. aieais in sierrng wiih size right :6 receive fmm x 'T ééze party hag ﬁréfiéén {ﬁe a:a:?;§a¢i' reagerzaéée €C§3?§p€?'£S$_é§é;_€§?"i_ grzé §':e::%i_:'-fie rizgiii 51$ jégjfeiz ::;:h::a:" Eéag airéaég ébiéef: recéeizééé ﬁg zfze §§;*f,y aggrieved iﬁzere 23 hawever :10 :.:;Q;z"m:=<ai' fez" 332$ sssgazmpaﬁan wzaeﬁe ﬁg £32m': <33' éfzs Eéigfz Sguris 5?': Eizdiag £52.91 3,??? agypiéeg Qmig is cageg wieem €'§'§,€ aggréeéjed gsazigg E5 5»2ae§{§:':g Ea regaigse gang azmazzzzé: an §3re::;::?:

{gf ::°&:";§:;'<*,a{::: ami :23: 52:'; {.'€éS€:§ zzéfzgsré ;:,_g:za;2 Egzreaigh Q5' ii-

ifé §.n3u» {E} The award 9f the ﬁrbiirator Starzﬁs ..:m:§'c§if'igd $9 the extent we have indicaieﬁ abave. Boihﬁgzé cmenter ciaims are rejected;

{ii} §'§?.e award af tFtT:_e'.£5rbit§'<2tf'a2" £3 vj"

Court rejeating bath the clair_1_§"%;2V§;¢£.V§,-ozsféierf:¢Za£§%na {iii} Parties to beair€_vt§1..'5c37i:§01iIvz:"£:é)j§;':§-~ a.:w'«+;:a:§X'w A

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court