The Branch Manager vs Smt.Laxmavva W/O Laxmappa Naragund on 23 May, 2012

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

The Branch Manager vs Smt.Laxmavva W/O Laxmappa Naragund on 23 May, 2012

Bench: Subhash B.Adi

w.Wmm..mwwamwm

w_.-  _ m V 

3&5 mg §~€EG%é ggagm C2? ;<a§§§A?§§<A
:;§§;€w* aazagcza M" §%£éR%"x;'A§  
amgg '?§=§ES "mg 23% ﬁﬁff 9;; sazm' 2§E2f « "; . ""v.u
BEEQRE   AA A %
mg HGNIBLE §'«"%R3}éj§TECE $.a;.3Hg;<~;s=}:"   

M.F,A;Nog22241g2trgg{i~iv7     
gzw   "

;»1.F,.a.Nos.2223c;2oo9 zjziggzg20%ag,ggg§3.%'2'a3§
  ' V

w:.A,&ée,2224::2@§9:§«:§._ 

;§;§:§"%ﬂfEE?~§

 
   

'FEE ggégag §'»%.5g§'\§g$:£"§.E§<-,.  'V   
UNZTEQ ENBEA :ra;:%;gi:a>g::';::E.V{:%f.':.;fr§.;_ 4. ;,
§<G%?z.\:_ NQW R:-E'?1>°PiE_S'E-N'"5'.fE§'-53E"§7S__ I "
gzxgigzcmm. §VE.ﬁ}JAi?2_E§?,, "  ._ 
P}s?~.E§\§\iD §<:,.:sv:gR;'~._    
amvga ENQEA, :i:<:§%;RA.:x;%::E cgza§a2,§:? ::;"&,,
§2EVE§ISf"é;%7§, S§1%'?E{1iE,; 's §;"~>*-3%?<Eé?«§.E§'%é'§éiéRA ms gigzgazgasgf
'~5ELA§vm:\:§H',aL; «C:3?=és:'>?:§)§; .:$:';,.=:;?":;@:i: Raga
;~ea;§§;%2:. §ES"%"":--?E§i.§..,3::§L".r", ;  

 §%??Ei,i§:f\§'§'
{*»£G?%'§?~*'§$§'xE E5'? ;%?§Ei:§_$}

 ;:;g%".::§:;"; E   §§%;a¢§xs?a§@9@;:§'; gag. 

mg "  V

  ;;;;;'§§-\ffJ'§~::'.§.%:%{;§5:4V?"f:g';'jé?§':?$§§.f{:: %'%f;'€3C:.§}§?*é'§g%??§1 gxggaggégagmgg

-- g5'2§'§§4V'3f'5E;5%§3'L$; §C€:§'*§G§§§E%§Sé.S? ':!':?®;§L,§<i
 ?1;'§«8§f {?';£%R§ '?C_:: ?%i§.§f3§€€3L; $§§?:Eﬁ%.§£éé3~iQ?I

% /I .5;é{;;2:'%~:Aas%§z:; sg@,%z§:sgg&a:a:&;%?ga §Q§.£:i§é':s"§;
"._§z§3E:§§ yggéiggg :;::£;A§§:§::;:"§2;§E;
;"'~:g*§,3£;§,£§§, ?;gxL:?"5§§j§§""§§§..; $ES'§":§;3§;5a§.%€Z@'E'1

?v§§,§S;i§<L5§??£a Sg'f,}f":"§§"=*"§§i"-'*:§'*-§,r£2;§?ﬁ§ %éfs:é,§.E§
f%§?f:é%§ ?§£35§;§; QCC: §§??;?'s,fEi:?:
f?€;5§,C%%E§?§.§.,£%§{é{?TE; "§'"§.:§;3,§¥"§:'7}§,§§?E;

 



, , .,WW,.ﬂw 

E»)

SEQ': §E§.,,G£i,§?%"%,

 ?iESFQ§"§;?§E§'~§"§"S
€'»*'?E5a mag L§f§ :?3:;:; 3? My §::T,, égaggagr mg 3:.:i::3?s=:E§a;"?
aw A':?'€£R§ m':@s;e§;'2§§9 Ragga 23¢ :»2.\.::g5:2g@§ 3:g2.:::;s"'--m:
mg %'%LE :3? ?HE Cm: 351355 {ga'e§x:.; 3 AQSLE :»'s;aac::;VVv.;§_:>;%é:,:%.A::.§
.é$vV;f%R§E§\ié:§ A ¢':G§\%?E§\iS,%TEZ;'N SF RS,a2§fSQ§;~ EiiJi"§?'%."E?'~§3T;Ef?€-§S"§'_'€§:%  
3% PA FRSM THE 55:5 9? ?ETI°§'E§{a§ T2,: T%-%E _mTE:'}e:§ '§E?€3SIf}f} = 

?v'EEﬁ,£*iGg22Z38f23§9
AND:

PANEI?' S,/C.CHENNi1§'€?£\LLAP?V§eué!3.,%.,2'3:§'~r'§£¥f'"§7§
A§E: 49 YEARS; GCC': §§RECé,§E_.§?§.§?{E;.»_v -
R;"€3BID§RE; W2: f'«'§i§E'?5.:Q%.é, §'L{ST':§5_§$V§;:§§GT§

§.....Js.

If .

2* $.¥%%?.?%}%,ASA'€:?§a zgzzga,?;i§s;§:T-«:'é;é§;a§%4::;:'f%:.:.;V' 
ms: 43 YEARS,'©CC:;:%.§.R:£*.u:;"m§E;  
Rm s:§.aR;, féig mi:HQ1533s?:..a«:_g§L:§<<3"§i

3, BALACHAN-:';2,g s--%';z:}§s.»2g_§¥r%«;.é,E3:s-A §_@R!~1GéEfL
$53: 59 ';'EA{§S_, @C:::A_GTR.V:{:'u':;::'1: REL,
Rm 5:_§gR:,5_*?c;;--;»;,;\z;;;;*>;s:2;f §}'£~:'¥3'.:_5AG.€§.,KQ?,

4, ?«€i}£§;5%%<A_?§>£X S;;.Gv;.:s';::v;;::§*~sé';3--::,a; $-a:;*m.:,,
mg:  "fEA%{S; 'a:3C:::':3§L:::E:.;'--;,,
§;;C:.§:r«:;;V.:;3?;2e:,;<,§?°§;?';' ﬁg :é;:;*v: wag,
§E5"§':S§;{3'.é'%i§'f*:?g   

 }    §?;ES§G§'€S§§"%§"?$

-  A ;:§aag4':<,§%':A,§2§;a;<:A$%»~§ :; a:;<m ,&§'%;1 gag  & gag:
  ::;%;§' ;T;::§;§--:a__$, §§A:w;aYA:<;1:x€,é£"%e; gm: gfargg R.-$3 & 3-4;

 ;'{:§i!E'{§.:':§§;}::§ .:?3{:; G? W ;xC:: ;'%Q§E?*»§ST mi 3z;§§%v:§?e?

 ma £2§ﬁ%5;&%£'s.__"§§"§:€}8,!§5;'2£%::'2§ aagggs E523 ?\i?§\f;C8§'==§§;?; sggggga 
 $2.5 :2? mg €251: 3:39:33 {§?,§s§a;,; 5: 293:' ?»as;£?; §<a?::'%:.
' ;"§;§f;5é§;'»;f},E.§_'.'§§ §;"'iG?v??§?%3,&.'§"EQ§'2§ $5: &:;a4,2§;§aa:M aészws ENTEREST 
 $@;g«.§,;:;;_ ?;§.c:§v: mg azégg £3? §E':':**:"E@§x: T352; ms amg G? SEPSSEE".

  

<x»y.<g:»'\~L',Ke"< '»~z~.\r'z~'~.. 



§"§_g_Eg.&§.?€$.222'5jr2i2%§g
;%§"2.%3'

IL §§*'?"§;§,E§"~$§j§<£'% ZﬁJ;'€';;;§;£%?§{3,§g??A C%*§Ai"€BA?;éGE;
AGE: 2% ':'E;i§S, QCQ: %"§$%..}SE?r§QL§ §f'J{3R§<;
REGBZDARE; TQ;:?v'§i.E§§*§Q:; §2ST:E§%$AE,§<$?',

2: .%<.i}M.RADHA S/CLRANGAPPA fC%"§ANDRA{§L _ .__ .
$55: $4 '1*'EARS;§CC: SEFQCE f¥'!If'%i§R"'§.*EF, E?'  T
%'§ER MGTHER $MT2RENéj§<§&  _   '
¥'%£Xé3'tR;é;P€$§aP?§a CHANSARAGE; &  " _ » _ ,
REQBEDARI; '?Q:MiJDHQL; {Z?E§T:EAG;%L%<Q"€.  u

3" sM?,?ARAwm;,aW70,m:v§AN,a'§sv§é;":ts~;A§\s5;z;R§;::;:;
ASE: 6:; YEARS; @<:{;::-:@:52s5E:~a;_Q:;r;.:>,_::x;'u{::_R§<, '-
ggaggzmaz, "%"Q:F'v'E:E§%i£°§L, 5:33; E§,€;>'-1L"§<CT,

AGE: 55} VEARS5 GCC: ;§..f'§R_;£':;LfLTURE;"'. 
??\g"@.8§§ﬁ:Ri§ T€2i?4L}§§§QL{ 

42 BALACHANGRA sf/Q, :»;A'§€;%=&§§'P?§: 23$;-§;1éa;»::_;;.:E§,;__

5, MuBAKAP.Pﬁ"Sf®.._Y§.Fv§;1..:',%?§A s%;z::s;§,_;;, H »
AGE:46 ¥EAR$",;3c:::----:aRi*=£ER g '
&;s.C§:%;VPP;ag,4;;<sE;?§fi",.L '?A;;..; R;1.'bz§::s.L;,;R«'3;
mS:f:'5§;§;;;3::.:s:v3,   _

 _ --   '  RE§?Gf'22EE§'--§"E'"S

as 3% ?::z.:é_§' i'»§f!!g :::?3'2:: ;;  £5": aaamss'? mg 3%,3QGME§'=é?
mags gwgaga §3"f:~58;'S.§;'£%§'3 i::;é§§E§ EN :»w,¢.ek:::sé BEEEGSS Ga:
E}£E E:;;E_;ja';~ui:§~iE C;g.a;i..:;. 3%..§§j§E ::§§;;§%a:,;: & ma; ma: é<:Q?P§:

;_f;!3:?§%;E§-,%R§?:.?&§iL§ é..}g:{;vs»z:PE§:£SA'€':'@§x: @ R§.éi;;{}é,S{EGg'=» E:2z'ET%=§ EI§'2§'%E;§;:%ST {$12

$'3f'22  SF ?§"§'i§"?iSf"a§ °§§i.L THE §§C§"E 8? §E%'5GSE'§I

3% , M. gigg gggg

 £53:

" "  : .§53§'%":S§!5é;'§;.i wzagzigaaﬁﬁga €%:'z'3€%§§£§:£1GZ;

 §'§%:§E~«fi 25 '":'EARS, @i:£:%-¥<'3Li§E§'=*%SL§1* i?t.!Q?a%<§
= §§i:\'SE§£?;§§, "f'{.§:§'=é'?ié@§~§{§i_; 333?? $§_G,%%_.§<$"°E",

'72Ej;   .%%:;§«s:A§;e:R:$H S;'Q.S§§§&??:£'% C§%£2%'*«§§A?\£z$E,

£535: 5}? ':"E%RS, QC€:§}E%\§€E %\'?§§"x§C=?; RE? 8'?
£33 §v'%{T§?§*°fER S§?V'%"3'. 5&3? 25¢/C?.§E§Q,§:§P§§ €3*§é§'>é§é?§u§,{§E;
§§E:2:§ "5Eﬁ:§'§f:1 @%IZ{::§*§f3%;§§E%*%5§L§ Efv'€:%R§<§.

NM.mwm 

 x



 ' LA)

R,f'C§:BE{f}£xRE, 'f"Q:§'v"§§3E}%*%§L.g QESTE 8é§§,&i.%<G"?,

3. S?'v'%T[?§%Rr5a':ﬂf%f=€.é "%€Ei;§E':i5J'v'E;!1'é?1§;ii?§§ CH:'?'£'a§§§:R§.§i3E,;
,5i§E: éi '§E;5,RS; CCC: ;5z§§£CifL?i§RE;
R;'G,B£§é%%E,, '?£}:§'~'§U{3;i'~%Q:,, SST: §§§G33<L§'<ST,

4g SALACHANSRA SfQgHA§'s£ﬁ2fv'EAPP;f: Samagva
;%GE: 38 YEARS; acc: ﬁaGP;ZCL¥L'?'URE;  
RXOBESARE, TQ:!v%L§DHQ'L, 9:31': 3.Asm.;<:§":f.....,__'=_ - '
3 MUDAKAP? 3,f§,YA§*«i,&NA??A ;~w_:;:,
;€%GE: 4-é YEARE, Q€C:$RI'x.!'ERg   
R/QCHEPPALAKATTE,"§"AL:RAMSUR§g 
§:s?:BELsA:m * _  

{gas $R1PRA§<,$.§H %.i§EE<ER§,i ;:2_.m£¢ §::2s?<" :::§.;s:2é';A.._

I'v'IF;1z {£53 :35 :73{ 1} {'>'1F_J_:v';~:;' :i%f:'E§; gisgéirafvigéf TEE EUEGMENT
%ND A\;":z'§\R§ S?":G8,/Q_Sg'ZQG§...%?_é%Sv§EE? saw' %*¥iv_;ijI'C,.."§iiC3, 3452098 SN
"mg mg SF 'mg ;<'.i7;'"--'vf_1i'.'-.."1L§Z}GE:, :_j§-2R!-§V:*;:;j:j1V~g;_,&:j;?s*;, MACT, §<GPP§i,
QWARDENG A CQ4§*{13f%?E§'»3;§'ék§f§":[si>?i§« @'::1VRs,_3,;$r;,::ez:a'£« :!a;:':"§--é ZNTEREST gt:
8% RA, grmrvz '¥"HE _::»;e»;$é"€;F, :;*é'Ef?j;:iff;:':,?:;x1-- °%"1';L"T£~§E QATE GE §EP©SIT,

MgFﬁxg§'€a.2224:?§}2GG§::§:'§V 

giivfﬂ: _ V
3, s§~«:T:s%--::'é»§§_§2*;':a;;é' ;%;;'é:,%v,?5;:*afé%;*:.?m @
{:.-::A;:*:§.¥g:%?;£a £.§réé5§\§&§aR£\§}.i
 §z€3.é;'f;f: 45 YEARS;'~'§£__§:_;§»§Q§SE§~§€§L§ WQRK;
 Aageiggmkz, TQ:§v1i.j§i~§QL, §§$§°;a;:£A;:<a?:

2;?  "'3é§':*»fé;;=9}é;~§;,;s:§;'gA§A9? €%%i3x§'»§§§:R§%§;.

" ._§;§_Z«:   GCC;.%§RECL£%.,Ti}§;E;
%%j.$,SE:§_é§4;'§--§ f§"§}:§'~'EE..§$E~§GE.,, i'L3E;§5?:§A$z§é%<G"§'°L

 §z5%i§%~C§%;§§§QRé §;§;%€§f'é§:§'*??;iP?é ﬁﬁggﬁfﬁﬁaifé,
 ' .Ai%3"E: 5% ?§§%?§S; QC§:i§iQE:§C§§i?§}§§;
 f§.;'€j3'.,§§§§s§E; TQ:F%*%{}DE*§$§..; §ES?:§!iE%53.%:K§?5

  ':;s§::m%§:;a;v§§ §;'Qf:'é'%?Vié?'€A??§ ﬁaaaz,

 .V ___r'é'%§E: 4% YEARS; §£€Z::§§?;§"e,:'E§.
§;f3£§i'"'§f??ﬁiéiK$[??§, ?}5s%..:?\;3%§'¥¥§i§§S;
BE§"?:§ELGK%i,%§\'R
 ?x§§?§§§'«.§§E§'sE"s§

u,.wWm&m 

   .%;;E_3":»%;@§éé§E§\;"{s





 

?J§F,ri FEES} ii/S §?3{1) §?'-3 §'v'§\f A€:"?f é§£'3i§§'>.iS'?' '$565 }é£§§§"v'%E§"é?
ﬁx?x§§ ﬁé:'*=f£§;ﬁ i'ZT§":G8/§S,!'2G{§§ ?ﬁSSEé? IE'; %'%f\;'LC§é'\.§Q: BSEZCESS ﬁfé
?"%"§§E FELE S? "§'HE C}f'\;'Ei.. 3%.$§GE ::S§.DF'sig} Si §$$L¢ ¥'€§;5a€'§°;V.?<§???!1':L
§fv"zi§R§E?\§G A CC3§'vi?E?\§SA'§"L§G?a§ G? RSﬁ,25g5§{};'- 'aﬁffﬁi Ef"a€.?fiET:?€E'ST§" £5

8% wz. ERG??? mg §;'1;'§"E. 3? FE'm':@:2; Em. EH3 :%::.m"E v;Q§%'1;f;;E§%f3V$::

§¥'Ef.A.§\§Q%2224Sg'2GG§
gm:   -

2' S§V§?.CHE£\§NAWWA Wm,sx/:AL;,,a'§?A'$Hé<AL}E?p;:[:'::;%aV:?;:R.,, »
;-'11GE:39 YEARS, @£C:§-=éQUSE§~~E§®LS WQ_R§<; ,  ;  '
R:!Q,BIEARE,TQ:FviUQ%éOL; :;:$':?;.;;5:AGAL3§_@'?.%_VV  " "

2, gmaaﬁm $50. §'vEALLA?P/'% sH,"::f_:'}§';§.?;x%::_,exv;azé,"~  
sag: 2: YEﬁR$§ @CC,:€;s:;G:.:E;  U V 
Rg'Q,§£BARL. "§'Q:§\«iL§9§~'§«€.>§;,_Q§$T%f_'8}A§;%§;§{§f§T,

3g SHIVAPRA Sgt;:v:ALL;:x9p,a sHE:§APf:A:€§;;£;§§V_;" 

gag: zg ysgassjg':3Cc:;gT:;3'g.:\:":T,, :
Rza,5:aAR:;"T{;j;;:x213353;; _{,s:s':f:a§,<;:.cx:;~<'::::::

4% év?ALI'2'AP?,£x S565» MA;:;A'PP;:\A SHEVLEPPQQNAVAR,
AGE: 1}?_${E§;.R$,'*:7}§C:S_Ié'«§.f;'E maxggggz' R59, 3%'
HES :*2im::T:-:'E::%.,TV?;~:1:»4T,~'§:H:§5:x;«§w:!wA M,ALLAP?,%
SHEi;;é:PP:g§£%3;3}Vzﬁ%%E;-_»  _   ' -
R};'Qg§:.?§zi§??<'§i ':"Q:;5rz:;:>_3§'z::;.;"»»:3:§?;5AGAa:«<G';:

 5§ a;;:A£:aéées?§R;:: §;:3.§%;gfx:;aé§A§?ﬁ. sGag$iaxs';i,

$553": ':'EéR;§g QQS: ;%{3RECi§i.T§.}?;E;

 TQf%*"§viE--§?§~::'i3L; EST: §é'=a{Z%§...§=<®'§I

 » é2:--::,g§g..%<;a;::%;;>;s§'§,2§x§s»:am§§§ $3,225,

"  ;<2::2E:* é§.§5&,:§<§.'...~a$£:mgvgaé,
=R§§};C§"§E'§?§-i";'§ij$=}<§;TE'Eg 'mg: RA§'~£'?§L§§;§;
:2:".ST: §.:§:§;§:}?=zL L
   .,,RE$§%?%:'§E§'=iTS

   32:'; §R;:§<;:§i~% 3. :;m<E§a ?xQ'%:i $32 a»: '$9 ;?<«3}

"  "'.?'?*?Fﬁé'A'§EiE{% QEE f.?3{E} §? §¥'§1£ ERCE} §Gg§;§§iiST "?%%E 3§§§§§%'§;E?=é?

' --'iJ"%,aa.;'é;§ §T%ﬁz'.é%§ §'§":§8;'§S;'2€}§§;3 aagggg 3:2: §~»%:s;:CE§2:§, 3§;'2§§§ $2;

"?f*:%E "§':§i.E if??? K??? CEVEL §§.,?§$E {§§.§f%§,} 8: &§§L, §'*~*'§,ﬁxCE'} %iZ€ZE§3P;§£;_

 '§:'%£»;*'}é%R§E?*é%£ g €:Q§%*'%?§?é§»&?EG?\§ 3? %1§%3,5@;3:3@; ~« :z:;::?*a zégfgggs? 
 3% ;:aa %'5?§.€.?%~'§ 'E'"%§§ 352?; 2:2? §3E'E"E"?':i€}§%§ "gm. "mg azxﬁa 2:2? i'2E;5f;%§§§',

 m\ §. \



...w.,ww"Wux«wmwmx~  

"EEESE s"«*"é§7.5g5' CG§¥'EE§\§{§ G5': F83 §'\Siv'§I§S§§§"':E; TEES 9&1, TEE
CGEER"? BE§.§v'ER§§ '?§~fE F$Li,§'sﬁfE?2§§:'

3 {E 3 G M E £13 ?
éif these ameafs are 3:; the 325559;; aLs_€§}.éf:§?J'»:é.'%j::::::_j'.t%f';%3,

Eabiiity in :v:.v.r:;xses.32; 3:, 33; 34,, 3-."~';E"~:a :§§: '$€3;'2G§8" E

respe::i:%v'e§y dateé 85.2309 GS'? iifge ff.§éj 1 éf_iaéiﬁ-§.15::;g1A.;.£';?=f{;
Koppai V % V 2 V

2. Regs <:§a§m petitéamg W6:-§'e--.5§§:::§:"-»;%:fy the 'Cf%'a§'r'%zar:t$ and

the Qependaats 3% E325 ée'§ie'a_fseé%..%.§~%2;:;§e;{: 353% G? the

meter 'xfehicées A<::_{"£:_:t'  iemgensaﬁon 53:

the injufy andéi;:¥'r*.._:§%é--':£jé'a4t§§j:--..__§n~.ah 5E::§.£§'ent that QCCE,i§'"§'"€§ an
5,3286}? a §'.--§.3.3A§'~;f§'.;a"z:'::';I:;:532:3 ﬁfe---.:§3§é'%:'-;2«e'§§§§s:§g,, EE: is aéieggé 325:;
as': 5,3,2G§.? 52%  zémsie ihg éeseaseé gm? the

§?'§ji,§z"'%d hag? i;*eé::.,io§ ._B::e§7z;'§._é:'m§a asiﬁgge is bring ?:%3{%'?§QSE'

;?;§n:,are..  u}3':'r5£i@ :* ";.%r:§__:ra%§<':? ﬁaaréng N3. %<,€a~28;':': 2§2- :3 253;

£§§§§'*:'?§E'$'§-»?5§v &:::§.+§ei'eaT_3§6 wsésée t;r5::$§§§s:g as iaaéersg %:'*é§"2§¥"% she

33%  %frIa§§::3§' Wﬁi §§'§€:€€é§§"i§ near ¥a§'E5§<§§'"§ zzéiéagg

 amss $s:?'§'x§,§¥§.,§3 {XE $23 éafé séﬁa, angiﬁer iracigr 52$ iraééﬁ?

-._§'%3§'§§§"}ng§'("'.§?§G§§'::§r*5§8f§:7§3 am '$34; €§§'°%'"§€ in a §'§§§'E éﬁé
 *.*.._Vs":e§--§%§:;'§:":€Amama? fram Em wgzégéie §§;'&§i§a:z ans éashaé

 §}g§%%'%;§% 2&3 égrgcia: gné iméfar Er: :r:s§:§<:%% iése {:§§§3"?%§§'E§S 5%?

§
aw 


 





 ii:§*:a€  zﬁé 3%

§EC€§S§§ vvegé ':r§v§%f§s%§; $3 a £'€§£J¥i'. Q? imgactg 353$ iﬁmaies sf

ﬁne saéé irggiar 5% irsiter wére tézrawiz 32;: ané aaseﬁggt $52

beiwaere the Eraaiar am iziaéisg as a resuii %:§'se»3%,i..'$;.;:S ":;a'i"§:§d

éajasrieg 333$ game sf them S:.f€Ci.i§'§"1b€§ is $28 %ﬁj:1;.:'§'.%$,f 

3" 'me siaém petitiang were  'épp'o1s'e.§j"r_b§;*  ':%_9§ei*.VV§~:f; s°:;iV:je_:*};,

,.",MM m%

denying ihe imzafvemeﬁi of me EraCi:Q§'V..ar;§ ::.;*2:.%§or A' bé3ar1i';":g ~ 

faia3aKA-48f'?1~?S3 & ':54 am a§%ége:?G'.:ha§,"':%§é'A:;éid §;*aCtor $3

faéseéy émgfésaied enév €£?,::~..V_get."V%i'%€é~-<:.a;*f§é;3§r:sat§éAr2VAfgﬁm {he
issagrer as ihe said ::a§':c2,r wa:s fjr:'fs':3re{§. %;zs:--§.i;§: %:§':e apzpeﬁané: ~

§ﬁS§,ii"€E".         

5% ?"%'%8 3"f%§3;:}'F2a;3,_b;: §fi>;<:;é*;9v'§n.gvVV:_hé': if': the Si,%§3§§€?%?€é'E§§E'}f
siaiemsréi ins <?;jC:%.z;~.§;:§;*asé':i[:"'%:~a§ ::*aieg:::§*§:a%§y émgiiaaie-é the
%:;'a{::o:' Ti3§aér§:§g%~ §\35-'%<;£x.§z%»8;f:""§1~?53 & $4; $3 3&3'; f:%*:§

<:§:2ie;':t§;;§;*:" ins §'2°:~$_:.éV:""£:* Saga mi merit aw acgarﬁéﬁgégg §'2€§€:f

'£A%§%§'2':._Va£c:;m§§ 3%,; mg i@ rash am ﬁegiégeai

 Q? ihg E35253: §€§?'§?:§ §K§&%<§f%«4Sf?«?§3 &

 ?°S¢:3 a%**:=.t% ..g:§"':}:~:2- ;"§";"§§:§§"%§§ aka gasssardgs §:{::%%::§%nsg%;§§r: €55
V&%&*%i%%§;sg;:s,g:ée;;', %.$ﬁa;2E;§§:3;-; R§ﬁ»;{3&:;§ﬁ§f~; %a3;%G;G§C:;t;
  5523 §.;§53;,S5,,§§&;'~ aagézh §§'¥:€?'ES?.j, £5: gif §'"%§§§'§§,£
 §a§<:§*':$5 ﬁgaéasi $23 gaéé §:§§"Eﬁ§§'E§, 2525535 agggaég

""«.%V§*:75%;'% E383}? §°'§§%:§ by §?'é§ §§'°%§;i,,§:%'§§1

 



W,'..W,mw//////z4 

. ,,,.,,..m».MW»mm¢ 

$5 S§":',fv'§a:'m@§§a?, Eeameé Ccamsgf far 3% §§,="$%§§&f'%*£ -~
§f'%S£§§':E*§" gagbmizieé 93233, we ::%a§ma§é%:§ Er: CQ§§£éS§Q?E_.._"g§§'"€§'% ﬁne

ﬁaiiag ésava §§3'y'§{§ fraud éefsraz the ?r§§~:;,:s'25§ £3 §:+ﬂ§z::i%._§'5.:fj':**;a;3_4 'C336

faaﬂcaieé ﬁaczgmaat mxéiiéa seée %§°;i:<é::t§@m Q? fa.§$%;é§yL._§}%':?§%%§:5"':i§4_

the xzégbézséa ingureé wiih the §§{::e%%a§3f:..i:§ gétéfféé':i{;r';"%§;:-:§:sé%:§::>ré__j; A'

recavereé fmm the mgasresx He §iéé:i%y1?:G';"%te%':éé$.. :§é.;a5:,: '::%3V:s'::§h

the FER was registered 3: ?.:%2e"§T::éiancé::--f:?:~3xC<*::{Ti§é§é'§'::a'%2t§ wfée

wag a§3Q 5:': iisjgreg in {$38 3aid:AA_a_L§fi§§.;j_g3';@.:§ cség/.tf::%e mmséaéﬁi
was 30%: gméuceé '§afQV%§ i.:é::é  zgﬁeg" éhreé ﬁaigs Q'?
iéze acéiﬁgfzi, th§.v»..%%;;:hs;'f' :z%%é"'g§mp%a%na::: was
reeisréeé a§'2 <:i_.   the 3§3§3§§f§§'"?§ wag
§??"%§3§f€&i€§¢_§;f§:  ..€§u§m§::§:é that; §°%:€:'e is as
atﬁer  'ta graze E318 vehécée

§£"1§$L5%i"€§ w§é§2--,_u:%%:e 3 §3§té§§§§"§: '_f:-':5§S ﬁreéuieé, Tsﬁe §Q§§C$ ézsfrzg

?:§'%EE m:,;:é*$e:u.ef ihé' §.::é;€s:§§;ai§s3§% 'ta make 92;: 5 a::aSe £9: 53:59:}? 3:'

"§*:.:§v:--": gag: §"%E3CSf"C§€§ E315 giaismené Q?" gezzergé

§£%'?§<..2é%_::_.§é'  éfzgaggsbzig éaseé 3:": 2.ﬁ.:%";§£%:; iihe Cfégfge 531%:

V "£3523 %:=2»§:::éfi§'€:€§I §§E!..T§ g:;ém§:i:${§ $5232; $333 amsuzzé; iii: ée ;f}§§§ $32

§:':_$:;:"é'%" £3 mi:§°:§m§ 3:25: a paébééi §E'%®?"%€§f am? if ﬁbre:

'_:::§ré:.:%é'r;':s5é%§s§°: §§ ggié by faiseiy émgffcgiéﬁg i§"E§f §§":$i.i§'§§"%C§
[' . f:;':::*";':'§a;2;s'f i?'%é3§'E E: wsaséé 33% é§f?:§€::%.§§{ fax 329: E§"§S§,é%"§%"§iT€ ismgawg

 50 gazgtéin S§I%.§i§'§ §;a§;2§§§%:E;,.a

'iﬁégf/ ¢-ﬂfléxar///x/y.e.WVnM 



,.~w;w 

ék  mg @i?§$:* hanéf §€gmeé C§:z§':se% wggagéﬁg 2%? 3519

 

céaémaaig 5::Sm%i:t%:§ 35:35; éheagh 3%: the '%I§§?'%§ sf %'§§§:2g___ Qf the
camgfaégig Em: vehécie ézzsured 2.:s;§i's mg agpeéiané"':ea§§:«%s:"*:f;Q§
%"f%£2F3§§S§"§€£§ E5: the cemgfamii as %i wigs n%§?°%i 
C8§T%§3§§§§"%3§'2E himseﬁ has given a _f:,;.a*i:%:§r  
mgmber cf the xzehicée wﬁéch dashéj 
vxghéch ihe ca;:r2;:2%aEn3a:t wag '3§9;f3~g;;ex§§§:2§;  is;

mihéng §*1;'?'Q§§§ in ifhe fiaﬁkfzg of th.e_ ;§':*§_bi:§ja§. .'

:3', Am: ﬁaim far  ;%§.:f!%;§é~gf:;i as: Q? the
d:"'§\f€ér' Q? the  ::;z.f.:%'as§*2 am rzegﬁgerit
drivérzg by   is make the Qwner
an?' ighe  '§'V§'"§§ViV}§?i'3L§:".:vf'  §?é§i§%:§e ﬁasie is gay the
caz*::;§e::3at:§V:>;:;  §§  35% mm :2 gzezze

gaiéafzabfe ;'se§§L§'tg-;%"{:eV3-§§é:f2S%"%%:€ §r§v'e%'* Cc? éfhg :2'e§":§{;*§a

V'  :73 éégazsie iﬁﬁi iié c§§:3§§a%::a§:i is 352% 9;?' 
§a;,§:s:i:§:§-[%_::%A§§é£*:§"":»:a_§:,:*.[':;§éz:§{§e$33 C§3§'2":§%§§5:§§2: himgeff 323$ gézsaé g

 ?:<;:_:"r:p§§§s*':"*:: §%3..fé:;%:2:,*"éfh€ ?s§§§:& ﬁe cgzggs Q? 3328 %'--'E".§ §§S£§§S§§ éifzai:

.«'(J"! .'

i;;s:*§---- ;3",?};§Q?"'é;2;%:%§€ thee :;"{}%"§"§§§§§§'E§§T§i am ﬁiﬁgrs \z"§E%'€ :";*ave§§§€2§ 
T.;a%%%%é:agiey am' zzaéésr eegmg ?sa,%:A»2g;:2a32~:2§3 far
 éhg mgnare 5:': §%:§«i:3 fzam §<'lé§$§??iT3§§ i$ E§a§<a§; €125:

 "=§:'::ié:::::* Q? 5233?':  §°%éf§§%§€s"%?:Z :'§?§2:%r:§ gr 3% @3539? {sf 

 



444:///////« 

 

irgzzisr am? f:§'§é§s3;" bggréag §*é©,,§<éc~28;'E2§2~:é263; 5% axés 9?
23:8 'ézracmr §3:'a§<§§. a3 a reggfé rs? %€J§'E§C?§; Em i:r:.:£:s§_§g {urges
iasrtfa, we Ciaimaais and the égceaseé, azasm :.ﬁ:e:*e:j;<3§é?%§:f§'z:§'*_:;:§: a

a;

iroiéey, came amsjier" igﬁe 'zre§%€§«' arid gugtaiaéé géE2v§:;2§Q'§'s:'§€;'1:§ér:

ané ssme sf €f§"§§F%"% sgzccuméeﬁ is §§,?7i.€.°';,_.S'~;5§'§"1éL5,H"'V:E}:,;{z.g"Lf§:'E i:'h._§ ;,éfig:g%'§; 

aisa gustafneé injuries,

9; 3%': %§ aisg 52:3: 3:: :jés§:}'Ee "§§'2_a*2" %?§e %::>r§§p§$:§z:5r:': $3 3?'?

éngagisaﬁ Ha was {:§¥'3S{Z?':2'£3 §. _<%4éé'h*a:§ §":"vi;e:': CGi'2'?§§3§§"2E an igfzs
'sew; 33mg ﬁgy :fmmed%a:<é3éy '.,%§f%é§/w."':,ﬁ'€' :_:iﬁﬁigdgﬁt; 3?; 'am
camﬁiaiséi, he %§a¢:% .,;:%:-S eizen; ::<2~é:,%:*z'%:vé<;é%€é:,§~.%:ff:.é; imaévement :3? the

tractm' and ::;»fa}i;;x'. §%éa:;§n§-viT':§%::%;'§<§e4s,;*?~--253 & 7354* Wher: the
:§5§m::=?::i1:'"r:§':?:§':i::e .é§*:'€_g5 r:':a'g mat be in a §::2§§::i§r: E6
raataazer €522 é:,G§'%2;;*:§:*;:§i§%:§_£*:;>n__T§;=.<;%:*2 iéze swag: a? tag iracier am

wager seagégéag. §'%1§g:';a§<--sﬁ§«A;E8}':i"252~E2§3; :9 9,63%? is gait me

1.4-"':A:,:_:*:*;g:3.3j§%;%_;§;}%;.%§:3, ag a'§:i"""afﬁ':Ve.r ?Z?'%i)Lég§"%§" fzsrtézsr §i§§€??"E€¥'2%Z Q? 251%

Vi;}%.'3§""3":.;?§§:V§";;:?'7':%A§'V:"7§.i§i_'.'*s'.?43'::3_V§'€i'.{Z*;5§'§}§E§ $3 $53,263? $3.; after Ehfgé ﬁgys sf

  ihe &§'€i§'§:>:§§:; ':§.§_: :2/wish far iéea §§§'§§ E52726; 329 manééms ahg
V.~.. _ 4§.§;'3R;fT:f;'§\;'E%§?3,:*f%%:'I.O%%:!$5??? %,:;*§::::$r gag iyeifag %:%§?i:':g §%§s;%<£a~i%«8;"%"~?S3

L  4'__%:'f"?AA§% "ﬁyéarafsa ;'~f§';5'Z§§3§ 3%: the 33% :;e%s%£%a atamg %@:":'s
 §§£'€C§§C%§'% am ﬁasfzéé 335313': {@142 t?"§{ZJi§§" is: %"€?'§§£?'§ aha

_...,,,,,,»_55€f§a§:2v:&:':i;'<; zaxeré 'srazixaéfiféégg gg 5 wazgéig 25% §Z§"§C?"§§' aséé i:'.'§"§§§:'.;'3§"

,,,.......(.'o4sa*.W.,99.'?%1'1§'§

 



.

aw éégéiézgzgi gags': §"E€}i§:;§§"?§' fa: ¥i:'§'%§'§;" §§i§'"%£f§i§"§ tamasaf iasriée am they $:§:3§Ca§%%$;."§ mjejryv 'éihegé ?i:§*§€ csmgiaéaaséiz is an éajweé wéiness 352:5 $156 given § zzgmgiainé bafarg iiﬁe %§§<:e; having €232: even referred :9 :r:2«+'§'§x:.éLni::%esf::' 3? any sine? vehfcéé 9:313: téaﬁ ﬁe me is w§%:§*:f2L..[:%::éj%§ tsa2;e§§:'r3§g ét ég mt knsxazn as Ea h<:_.:a:...$::dds2'n§yV'4"%:";~%§:::=§x§?e::5ié%:;»e:%if& eff: A' §ﬁC>iZ§'1,fE?f' zzehgéie Es Siatea Tc:

evésence. E': Gnéy $f';®1"k§IEg that'§:§"---rgjaké'::%§:m_»§§f§:é':'§§§ﬁ'e'rixzeésééiét was faégebg émgﬁécaieﬁ %"€C$E7é.%i;V:£f§'g;}_"i;'§'3..§. f§z%£§é'e.;:...si%i§man: G?

31% a:;.*@m§§5%s2a:":i'. fie 3:2 Emzgstiggie ihe Cage; but §;:v*;s,f;stég:a'::"o':§:1 ~%i§'§eé $5': iéze first mférmatéan. §;*24'%"':'§._:*%:j_;::'%2§§:§c*:s'r*;':E;_a:%_';';V€{%%Vfs are mgre yaevarsi 553$ 339%' anci 3536;? $9 :«*'*»;'§?§€?"% Eiéés éswggié magg. Sui gévmg 3 tea? g$= 533; is §'Z:"i€ téfmfaéét é::.:esi%2é;;~;'2is mgkéag wt enéireffg ééffsreat cages i:.j::g§s"<:-if 52:": nvési-.¢:§éz2:§V:a§ 332d €C%;?'§fI§'§f';r' 153 $343 {ZQ§"E§é§'?iS 3? §§"'§€ ﬁavé ﬂied Eng ahargé §?"'§€€? am 3% s§23:"§'%~37_ aé::'eé':~v..._a};;:'§;é§:2 :23 be ﬁﬁf Swggayieé %;;a; 3:22; £§§€§"Ei:

V "a:?£;§§€:"§::e ¢:";t:f:Q"é:'%z§$ égaagmem: ég é"€§§€:'i§ $3: 'aha Trféwsai if: 3 H * 7€;:.:~ag"':2§§,.:f::§§é%%§>:: "§'%2§ ?':§§L::":a§ %"~J§":§§€ r:@t§::§r:g mass mszwégé ﬁgs: §:;.i:;s§2é'<i'é§%§e 533% €;f§§§§f§{§t:}§'3 £3? ééze Eﬁsagref @523'; are the gmﬁsé my ggg-i--"T:¥':e f:,2s*:§*:§r giatgmeni 9;? §:f'::€ :*i'Z§§'§§§§§§§'§§§'?§ §< §'€%f.fé1>:"C§€§ ¢"""'E'"

gaéé ;'5§_"&?:5§§?";€?""'.z§ $3?

N.,,44z/////44 §'E--E{2§§"{§§»:i"§ 59:5 wééy €32? <;c:'§;§%a§::ar2:'§ siaiemeﬂi at the iiécggiém wag reiéed, "ﬁe férsééﬁg sf thé "%'?2?§:2n§_§.._§§r S53 :3 ;:sem;e§°se gm cafznirary tag the evéégnze 0:': recarde We T€"§bL§§'3&§ has gagseé ifna judgménig §§%'§§f'§?};§ :--§é€: :r3:é§;%:é§"::%.§':zi%§A::{' of gévéng 62' gram? fméing $3385 a__;"2....t2fa_s 2%: §':;.aé'-- f%:G§I_f§ C-imgiéfered the materiaé ;3r@ﬁ:1::ea"":§e%Ti§Er€:TV ii}. ';5;*i;:;3"';?'§C§e"=':h€3 'E":'E'$a,::25§ sfsguié haw §r:s%stedi,:§:':,:: t%2eé"-::§§*2§§a§;'23':éé:"'E:3 §.*:«s"3dL:'<':e fzhé FER; §'}SEi'--£€if€F, ma suvgh dQ:A;;mn§x;é'§2.: '1A;_;:%zs a.§§'G'-;}.m.d:§;ced §§5G%"'€ the "§'::i:mne:::§, in my is @3336 as zwsng fénémg thai:..:he tracthéiéfi N§x§*{A~48f?~ ??:33 8: 'E54 $3. the materéa sﬁsws thai the ,.

I~éé%'z::a2='; . %%*: ihe Efsiifﬁ jasdgmeat is mi sagstaiaabie if?-.§aé;a-2. 'V3: $2; §:'é':es§§§*g' :3 3%? égéée tﬁe jaégmem: 4-"ram i:§:>§%§;'i:B§j?iiV";\,}§%._'E?§EE *?€§'%3:§f:a§ am Sam Qaak iéze mgtigs' Ea Eéég §:s.§:§*:.;3.__§§;j.§<::§Qn :53 fxsfﬁf § §m§%§* %§":Qé:i§f"';3 gézzg 3 . f§:2d.§m§"§.§g§%;§":%;i'T"2:f?":e cgmpéaénz 3525 6:312: maigrégé gm' fwiéses; __;":i'v'._é§'."?%§s'*e 3. €:;:§%a:§§§§'2 b§§Z'aﬁJ€%%'E the s:§3§s*m3s;%:§ 5:25' i?i%€3 ?§§§£§: .3' L __':%'%é¥~7:f'é*§§;:r:§§ is 57: §§e:'i*g 33:: tam %'?%£%$$E§?"g asifam égagé 53:2 33:3 __'f:'*:'at§f%r§:£§ éaefwg ii; Ea wag Em: "§"r.%b:m5§ Esgfés $25: $39 érasisr i%""§§§§Y éﬁaréag §%§5,>x%<;5:~é§;'"%"«?SE & ZESQ ég mi; §?'§'»!%:}€'%f§§; .

/7 'V Iggqczxx////4 iéabéféiy ééasz E33 $3 féxeeﬁ' $253; ggaéﬁst thg GWEWE? G?' 62$ %,?"%§:f.?"é3f} 3? 3:23;; 9?: §i§"'%E %:r§<:%:<:>s" arm? §:"a§§Q:' égasirsg §\é&§<A~28;';25__2~:263, !5:§;'*'"€}?"§§§'E§§'§!, gié ihgse agagieaés ara a§%:::swed_,....'4'f';ff§'?1? §éja§;%5:32 sgaingt ihe appe§§§m': ~»= ¥i"éSi}f"€§"'" $3 %2er§bg5V__Sé€:_aLSf.%ée1; "'§"%.:_e'.._ sfaémantg am 3': .§%§e:"2:§; E3: pradace :édd§ﬁE<:;:::3=§_a:zf_2§éf':<i:;:;,.V__'§%"g:f:T_:fé§€, 'ﬁe amezmi is': @9332: Eé ":<gfunc§:Aevs§;V:3t::%. K§\§M,f~

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court