Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs M/S Indo Nissin Foods Ltd on 24 February, 2010
Bench: K.L.Manjunath, B.V.Nagarathna
'A ~ V."I::\N<:;A1_,o.1_{xs
IN T} II-33 HICEII COUf'{"l' OI? K:'\I'{.NA"l"A}{A AT I::?>1\.i\l C;iXI,O R15?
DA"I'I%3E') T1--{ES Ti--II": 24"' {DAY 01? I%'I€BI{U1\RY. 2010
PR1?-SEEN T
'm12: I~IO§\£'1'3I.§.~1 MR.JUS'1'ICE3 I{.I..MANJUNA'I'I 1g Q
AN 1.)
TI--II-:2 I---1ON'1---sue: MRS.JUS'E'ICI:', 133 M.NAG[x.f{Z\"ff;I'.ifi.Z§"V
1TA.NOS.80/200-'§ C/W 75/2OO4.7--,74;j' if
78/2004. 77/2004 & 79/2004
1'rA.N0.8og2oog 1' "
BETWEEN:
1."1'1~- c0Miw1ss1<':)N1aRVoF CRI'3UII,I')i%"\ECx r QL: 'I:13NS' 'E?;5<Vj}:\E):V€.' ' 1--sA;x;C;AL0.1eI;» -» ' $4 TI-{£21 JQ1N"Ii<:O.MM1SSI'oN1:1z 01%' INC; OM 1:2" ~*m;><.. ' L2.I-€.i3UI1.I)E'§*(;%
- 1<«.;»,.-=\1_')'v* ----- M "
. .. APPI*jLLAN'l'S (£352. Si-2; M V ""s;_1«:..ii;r--1A<' a --x.«\1_..A._ A_1)v.) UAND: 2 ..
' ..M/SE'I.,?xII')c3 NISSi§'\I P'()()i)S I','1'I1) _ NO 285 111 1e'1.<>c>;»:
~ - A A = cI~:NT1«:NA.R_Y 143 L? i LDI N (4; ROAD " ~ , 133fi\NG1\I,.OI{I.£w 2 . . . RES POND PZNT (By Sm?" : S ix' J\j":E.fI-{z'\i.'}i }A,_ AIDE-".] tr"
'lI'l"1.is l.'l'.A. l"ilc'(§ ii/S. 260A of ihe l1'}(?(')1'11c "l':':x Act. 1961 211'isiI1g rim: of' (}l'Cl(",'.l' (.la11ed 30.9.2003 passsecl in l'l'A N0. 240/l3211'1g/2002 1'01" {lie a1ss€ss1I1e1'1t yezu' 1992433 1"}1"a_yi;1g 1.11211 £1115 I--l01"'1'§3l<' ('()Ll1'l. mzly be 1:)lease{l £0:
E) l'0r1'111.1l251le £110 .:;:1bs1e.ml.1'al ques£'.i0;T1s 01' law sta.1t.(:d iilallow tl1e.appc;;1l aml scé. asicle the 01'cEe1's 1')a1S':;__edvby 0'i.l"ie' l;1c01ne' '1':-ax /\ppelle:l.c=' 'f'1'ibu.1'1z1l, {3a1"1V1g21l<)1':;4Wixlt No. 240/I'32.111g/2002 clam.-cl 30.9.2003 zzrlcl a:{.5i'1'i'i1'i11 t;i'1c.__.i,)'l'_cl<:%f"€51' 0 the Appclla-lie C3c):111a1i::si(311e1' (7()1j1l"i1":11'i:ng llle.'0V01"d&%1""p§i:g.géc'l'bjl7.A ihe Jcaini COl'l'lll'll.*€Sl(')§l§'>l' of l1'1(T:()1'>13c 'l'a1x,'?g'£)S, l3e'x1j1gE1lol"e'elf; 0 I'I'A.NO.75 [2004 BETWEEN:
1. Tllii COM M ESSICDNER Q:'1_-'V..1N€::cf;1\/1' §i:~*1:'l\:?;
c.R.:3u11.1'mafG V QUIEI-C'N{~} _.1j'e"a;.)A.I'.5*§i.:
2. T1---11~: ;}:)_1£'-efll' 192R 01? 1NC101VElC--..fl'z='-\X.'l*|_.):5._ ' C5. R. U ll.l'") ll-NAAG ' ' ' 0 l}3l{13N S R{")A'lf) . ._ _____ .. ;
- A 0'E::3z\l\l»GA:\lL{3'13£Ii . . . /«\.l5'l3[€Ll,AN'l"S (By Syi: M}.».?S'i:--;j;:a§é mitl-»n:-\1,A, /\l'.')\/.} _ T.M';4.s"1mi'1';>o NISSIN mcl:>:>s I.II'EJ "No; 28. ill I~"1-(')C,3R ' "{Z§i'l\l'l'lsZNAl€3" £3L.flLl)lN('} *.M.G.1-{GAD " £3AN<i3 A1.c)z<1;:,- :
... l--{l£Sl"ON[)EE\l'l' (lfiy Sim : S R z7\?\é.Il-\'r"-\l'}llA. l/\I)V.} _ rs/\N'*'(:;.~\..I§<~)1<.1..~;
This I.'§'.A Med Ll/S. 260A of the Incolnc 'I"z1x A01. 1961. arissi1'1g 01.11 01' e.)1'('1('l" <'i'.=1t&d 30.9.2003 passed in ETA N0. 242/Bz='u1g/2002 for the asSessn1eni. v\_/€211' 199495 p1'a:y_ir1g that this I---{c)n'bEc': COEZYI zmly be pleased 1:0: 7 1'. fm'1'1'11.:]ai.(-> thy :a'a:bsi;-11'"1iiaI ques1,ior1s of law si.:11.£--7c_E_§';i.b<;*.z'e--;..__ " » ii. afiow the e-1;:);:>c--.-(1% zzmk set asidz-3 the o1'dm*s ;:)a1sé::»jé.ci.'byV0'Ehe In(r<)m(* Ta-1x 1-\1':p('§E;m~ 'I'1'ibL11'121i. I13;}ng21l()1'{::""in_f£'.I'}\» N_o_ 242/lT32:1:zg/2O{)i2 d2ti.c.'('1 30.9.2003 atriti C{')iT;!'j1'i<3'1 E:}:c::"m:'dcff"OI' the Appellau-'3. C{.)l'I'"1I11i.'~3Si0l1€I' Con{'i1'111i:1g 1jiE'1c the Joint Commjssioricrr ()fII'1C()l"¥:¢t'. '1"'ax.r.'1'E3--S, I3z;k11E§.41.1§>'1'e0' etc. I'I'A.NO. 76g 200% BETWEEN:
I. 'Fl---IE COMM 1ss:'c)i\s:;«:"r1'a' ore . CR. E3UII..If)lN(3 ' V V ..
QU :+;'1+:'N:-.2 ..l:€:f:..}AOT~i
2. '1':-----11='~: .j<)1NiI' <'toM'M'1s0S';Q'é\:1s:R or?
1NcoM::«:--<i.m~<.V ' (F5.R.I-3UII,I..)§-NAG" ' 1;:;_«:N:~3 I-{{.>:'\'if3. .. ..... .. « . .. A1:'>m:r..LAN':'s (By .s.«.+; M0V0-"55--§-::Ea=:V--1:.A<"II/x1,A. .r\I.)\.«'.; 'AND: z .0 _ rs.r1/smjbfii' f.\:'ISS>§N mops 1'.;1'1.:> NQv.28."..'i11 }*'LOOE€i _V .ff.--CE-N"I"§5;I\£r\§'€Y' 1%L.?§I.I")I.%\.£(_'; ' _M.C;.1-z<>A1"'>.
~ .. _ E3}XNGz\}..(}RIi-- 1 . . . I"{.E£SPC)NI')EN'I' {I':?3y 81111 I R :"\i'\i€jl-{I-'xI}I L/TX. .r'\.I..)V.) Q'E1i..$. I.'!'..»'\ filed 1:/55. 260A (;>f11'1e !1'1C011'1c"l"ax Act. 1981 £11'is%1'1g <..mI of :::1'<lc2' alatecl 30.9.2003 1:)a1ssed in E"I}'\__._N0. 243/[.32--1.115;/2002 for the asssess11'1:31'1i. yce"11" 199586 ;:)1'2:.yi'I1g t.l'1a1't this H(')1'1'blt:* CO1é1'{ may be pleased to:
i. f0m11.11e.11.c* {hr +e:.1§.3s1a111i211 (§{I('S{i()I'}S of law s1.z"ai'.e€i_ é1bL3~«.r§.0' __ ii. allow I.§":(t z1}';1';-«A211 cmcl sci asjsicie 12116 ()1'cier.<;_-;_)2=x:3é:¢'dbby i--'.h<:
I1'1c.*0z'1"1c;* Tax z\;.)1)<:11;;m::' 'I':'ibL1nz1I, I?$ié§{iV1§{a';Er_)_1"(>A L1': _ »'l"E7AV VNV0. 0. 243/I3a:'1g/2002 (.ie'1t.<'rci 30.9.2003 211"};1 C:()'1'1.ffVI'I1"1'»Ihfi*"()I'd0i*~._§)Tif'A the Ap1.)el1a£e. Co111missi()ne1" c()1j3fi1'miI1g_ ting. 0rclexfjgp'§IsSed';by. V the Joint C()111:[11iesr~;i()11e1' of !I1(é0'b'1e"---'I:;1X. 'I"fDS. E321f1g21iQ'I"e.V€.1/:5. I'I'A.NO.78 12004;
BETWEEN:
CRI3LJ:1,1.2iN6;«." 2: _ _ QU1a1'::\1$.--:'2--:qA:':q__--;. W £3ANGA:%.<3:<;e:V_'.
1 . 'I'I-Ii?) COMM §ss::,<):\JE.1'2' t)£~51'1?5CO§*x/lit 1'
2. '1'1----: JC--T:i'N'I' <:v«;'3'1\.z1:v;:S:3.1Ov:\;Ia;I1z OF INCOME). '2';\:<, "1*.:.j_3:+'._ C.R.I'3U"§Li1)%§\!C3' "
Q1} I-'CEN ~E-{{'JA. D j. _ :3's;ANa:3.Ai_,(>:'é.1%::
. . . APl?'E:?L-L-AN'1'S (By ;3';fi:f.;~.2\(__:; IALA. ADV.) ANl):"-._ ' '*'-iv:/ST rNif>c;>. Nasssrai m<:._>:>s 1,'2*1"') .320 232....' III I<'LO{.)%'«i T C: I:'.'N".I"£%:.1\:/\RY 13 L.' g §.£)1E'\J(".; RC)z'\D .,V§3A:\1c;A1.om«:~ 1 .. . RI§f3PO§\3 E3 ENT {By Sam : 55 R :"\§'£i,?IZ:'\i'_)!'II3x. AIM-"'.] "I'[.1i.>: I.'i'.A 1'i[c?c:l 11/5. 260!\ of"1'.I'1e lncoxne Tax Act. 1961 a11'isi1'1g (mi 01' urder {'l21I0('l 30.9.2003 p;.1sse(i in 1'I'A__._No.
244/I.3z11"1g'/2(fJ(fi)2 f{')1* the z1ss(*:as:11<-:1'11 yew' }99(:$--'£}7 ].)I"¢Vl§,---"'i"I'1._§.§ 1112-11 ihir; 1"--I<)11'h1t-3 €.'.<.)11x'l nmy bv 123102':-Sfid 10:
1'. f01'n1uIa1Itr Il'1<) »;a1l:)ss1;:1'11'i2-11 qxmséiolls <,)i'Ez=1\--v six-1{.c"d Z-113<'n«.-icVV.0' 'M ii. 2iH(..)W £310 a-11);'.><-1.11 amd set :;1s3icl<'r §'ht?WLv)I'C1t?I'S_'{3E'{S£~5_§'d» by 'the, income Tax Apfzmilz-zit '{':'i13Lmz.1§. ;}?3z111f_'._{a1r)1'{?& i.;13.¢IT.1:'«.V Ni). 0. 244/I32.1ng/2002 daivcl 30.9.2003 .2-md c::01'.A!'i'1'11'1'».f:.}'1~r3_'(;1'Ciei<..QVi'?(_' the 1\;)}.)e11z11<' ("X2111:"11is;si01'1m' ('()1'_3.1.ir'1'111'I1k;_-5; 1.320 o1'dC1.'".j ;.)A€i$sc:,d'3"by'0 the Joint C<>11'11"1'1é>sssi<)1sm' ofI1'1(:(')'1:1c""fax. 'I'i')S, B_z1i;.5_2;z01'i«V:_)V1"cVV315. I'I'A.NO.77[200é§ BETWEEN:
I . *1': HQ COM M 5:33 1_("');\!'EZ}1'? O {'f1:\§CQE\/1 1:: CR.£3LI11,131E'eg__'- ' » " ' Q1} 1.21-§3NS.~I<:' ';A;1;j), mN(::Ai,c)I<.»:¥;V_ ' '
2. TM 1:; JC31-,'\rfiV :'?:.o:y1Iv11s<:s.1C>N1:31--2 01"
C.1<.i§3U11.1;)INC} ' Q01-SIEIN ..1'<s-;';:s.x\1_.)' . 1'§;A:\' £31-\1,(.) 1-;»::: _ "V . .. A11'PI:£I,LJ--\N'1'S 0%0[;a;; 9.4%' jvivsi-éfis-é-V-lizxcr1 1.A.1,A. 1-\.I)V.) 'AND:
M / 0}§§J3"'}0' N ;< )N m<>I)s 1_.;1"1 3 £11 2=L<;><.>1a._ _V ..Q'.-CE£;\I'1'i::::\Ex\RY :31: i1.1.31N<:; M163. ROAI") ~ 1i3AN(m1.£)R1'«:-- 1 ... RICSI"O§\1I) EN'?
{By E5;":'1l: S R .»'"\:"\.?E ?I"{A{)I-l.»'\, AI)\»='.] This |.'}''.:'\ iflccl an/:5. 260A c)1'i1'1e I11('.(>mc '1'z;>..x A01, 1961 arisi;1;2; 011$ 01 :'n'(1L::" daicci 30.9.2003 ]}'dSSt,'C1 in 1'1'A"'N0. 245/I32-1113,:/2(){}2 for l1"';(l' e1ssess111e;1t year 199198 _p2'.2_,§1"y.._i'1'0Ig ihat. this 1-1011'1')1e= {'(.>m'i 111:1}? be §31t"c,1St.'C.1 1'0:
1. 1b1"11'11.1121.tc 111:? :~_»1.1b:'i--Ha'111t.i£11 qU(?S1i()I1S 01' Raw SL2)i€.€1"a§3Q1~;C.¢ ii. aliow 12116' £1g.');":c'-2111 z.u:<:1 SCI" asiside 11'2c""(>»;-'d«e.1*s;"_ ;.)a1;suS't:}I' 1)V_V\_-"v.fl:1f1E'.1@ 111c0mc Tzix A|'>|)ei1u1v 'I'1"ibur1a-11. :=IA3e11'1:g.z;1E{:1'é-10> 1:11.' '=I'1";'\.*.._V<;__ f 245/1*3211'1g,/2.(){f)2 {§a1E:*("1 30.9.2003 a11'1d. {*Ea_:'1.§'i1';11"1.11c~ the Appeilaie (,i?{>1m11i:a:si0ne1' <:cai1i11j111i111gT§'Hie 01*cEJei*' 'p;??$$ed_V§by1 t.§1eJ<)i1'1I C<'>n1missi{)1'1c?r GE' l11C()1i'ie!f1'-z:1x. '1'1)EI~, 11;3211j;5:,{a1i'é)1't%Etc. I'1'A.NO.79[20O{}5 BETWEEN:
I. THIS CC)1VE§\;%:--SS-!{..)N 231% QII~'..:1NC'OM 12 *'m><' C 1&1--31J11,1?__>i:\J(i;~' V . ' A ' .
QU ;é0;4.A_:A~z:>«':-_V ' 13AN(3Ai,.()i'?£*J;»'_ '1':«1--1;: LJ,G1z\';'11'1~'::<9§\'n':\/11ss'1'Q_1\a13:--{ Oi'? :1\%(;:o.!\/1:-9:
(?.l32.13'i1i1;E)§N:G " ' gU1<:i_«:.N':':; 1"<:';»;\1::_ 4;;ja.xX.N.{i;z\1.('>ii»:1-_; " ' Ex) ... APP1IC1,L£\1\1TS AE'F?3y«.S11i1: '11';/IT'5:S!:5j'E?:.1-:'iA(.i1----{AL/\, ADV.) ',_AN1):' ., ..j1'M/'3'-1.111130 NE.S-SEN 1-«'<":)c;1'>s 1.;r1) _ in 1=1_.c)<">1'< C'."$E\3'1'I£N1\I-RX" I3L..:i§.I)1N(} _,}M:'<.1- R<).m> " ~ V _ 1¢3AN(;.:\1.(i)R1'::-- 1 . . . R1€S}9'ON DI't1N"1' {I'3y S1211 : S R s?\:'\€i...31'~ii"xI')| IA. .-'-'\I)\i'.}