Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs Smt Vrinda P.Issac on 18 October, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
EN ?'%§E ?*%§{3%°€ CSURT S?' §{fieRE'\§§{?A§<§ QT S§s§"~§Gé3.§. §RE mam "M23 "?§~éE :8" gm" @;~'= <:>z:ma5@: 2:12;:
yagggw? % THE :-i.m;*'BL5 F\€R,Eé§S"§§{;E__§'é,§<_i;}'§%¥*¥s?§:§'_';: "
M2331' '_ *"§"2-§a Ha?-=§*§L§ MR.3L:§_?§j;E kayak: §'»*?§fl%E;j}F§5»%§*i?»g_i:':"«§~»:é. :3 :m,§*as€;,4s1:;%:i;é_%;::3_»:§ ..
EETWEEN:
2. "'§"s~:E £€3%v%§v3::~::.;§::3§xz§:R :j}z~*~...'::%'«:f'C::'::v:a.i€_'f§§,:;*< ?a§QgSS;"}._,"S§~§§'§;'P;1x:§é~é?;E:fi ._ "
VI§Y§§%,,&E'¢_3;';*'% V. VIS%f¥fE$'.!;W;';*:g§,A :Aé?;&;*z:;V§:;?_;-- 2: 1%: Eg§§'é€ZGf§~E.E "*;*«".,a;::<: ::~4?;F§§t:§5--R E§\é"§'ER£'éATE@§'<iA§; fE"siE}<§'«1TE'E@§'~§; §2:;@«$5;i'; §'s«%z§~,§%%--V§w«:;":~§§§;
'§;;f§E§'fiAR.%E'xé'2'§'5§_'€Qf'v'§§*§_E;'><? ..':$g§§;?<iki':Z.§§w§ifif;$x§{;i'*--*a§£§§5a§'; 'V " «_ §%~§:»'§a:":§g;~..._V Wfi??E§_j;;1§=$%'"$ 1g~5%'----$§;§V ;¢i';'3$.%*;é;J:::§v§§§§, ;:§:::«:zQ£a€g:: §§%§§*~~ 1' z .' '""f;i'§asz.f§";':%fi.£§a;:»;: Rifififiaii §a;§.:;§; Séfifééé ;:;w;a§~z"§v:§§\:?§;
'sf§'--£EE<£§\§;§;E'x§ 35% QQEEE;
xiaaavagzazf :'vw;§@9;E. K..REg§»>:3§x§§.E§as"€ {av SR: ;a,$:¢a§x§§<;:R & $93 zm.«,&;w:;, &§"s:'GC;'i"%"ES} H >€<>ifi>¥3%€>§< mg rm fé%e§ amfier geczmn 25%:'a:e.§_A':~;V?:.';§.¢':,'%1§§':;._ '= arégéreg gut 0? swag»? gated .:Z';3%€}6H12._4@§.Q"'-::5§séd. ";'~.rz E'€AJ'éa;21;'Barag,f2®1Q,, far" :he _é%SS§3§$'3m-€§1£.'~.,_ y:<»:~;a€.-* 2§§§»2Q§?, prayéng Ea fsrmagiate '*:E"':e':._S{.:bs1t§a»E":_t"2.;3E' qa:e§§.é er-:$ sf Eaw stated therein; aE§@V§£?'§i§_'¥E a§§::_e'aE an;§.v*}3z::t'afs:d:'$ the', arder gaggeé by the E""i'"fi."§", q$a2_:*:fg:,ai';":::<<::" én"
§TA;?x§§w2i/8ar:§f2@:G dateé "*;?A$;s35=2a"mA"&-' C@':j':f§rm the rsréar gasgefi by tha Q.§:a:§a:jV.r;;f_A:'s*:;ccw:{ae Ta><,;vv{.§%":1.t%'ernatéenaE Yaxatéenj, Baagaiare; ' "més ETA :@r'mffe_§ ' this @3321, KUMAQ JP; a'§eE§§,je12%@é {$25 f:§§VEg:zw_és*:.;;2f»:.§_ "
:'f§""%2§s;- éis-} '-'la--«~..§fé'x:g:*:v:.::é'v:%_ 'agfieaé <:ha£§emgmg the aréer QESSES é:ay 'i"§"2§ '??:§'i%E.;§":'é"§'..V';é*s;*;§'E§{Z§"E hag S9'? a$%§e Sm szrégs"
pa;s;:_:§eZ<é.'a3z iEz.e_ §E:'é-:mr :3'? Eamme "§"a><, Ergiematésrzaé '§*ag$a€t§$:9;§ . E"z:;~:f;§a%§r°e amdar Seszéan 2&3 af Ehe §§'%£Z'{3?"§'E§ Yfax 'v"':"§"§*°;:e-3* §S§§SS§8 gm §§"':é§x!§fi?;3§§ EE§E%~;?"@S%§@§"'é§, Eiésg ééiéé Em? reézamz 3:? E;"%£?;';{€"E§ éeaéaréfig a isiaé Eféfifimfi ('sf "'.j§§§;A%}'« an §1kE§:2£%{}5% Efifia a:ag& zziga iaken zzg fa: gamiény 3$S8SSf?'§&E'Ei sage? §@C§".Eé3§"§ E43=;3E Q? aha fiat. The §%S$€$E§i§":§ Sfficer §"z£'s§;§{."€fi ma? the asgesgee hag %§"§€§§§'E'§fi ?F§}E"§'§ cagiiai ggém and §"?§§ aéaémefi e>:@;':*'s;%t%as**: *"';;[:":é@':' ;Se£:i$:'2 S4? 3? she 1%" Ag: $0? Em énzsegimeni :':':§.:£_é;' assatg Tm fiaggegging f3f?§€§f aacagteé me a*é:i3i::.,:rs}'_"~féV§'e:{iT' V' 328 35393399 551$ mmputed' "'€%éé'A.%éi2C:3::":':é'«a$"'Né'éL Eséégeguentéyg Em §%:"&C§$s'_<*;f Zniarééa "EEK;_" Z§;é*:'a:":':a%:ééréééa. Taxatierg, gm gemzgai sf i§"°t€"£'3.§:.S'<'3SS§"?'E8Vf':§i_ ;3A:%r_%'=;:eé.:5j;;r"§3gs fiflfi remrés; §bserx..zed 2%-:Aa«:k_ i:he*V'駧é4$s'Vé';5_A €233 Vvéaipfétaé gains Enmme gm Seing a§§a{ai@;§"§:'§é':'¥{ Tags: arsfi ihe 8S'S€SS€€ %:a5"s§ §*f;'<32eaEr:::A_ ' Cagitaé gas 3% F?2.:s.2§}.33T,,._@--3:V9}V,2"»'--*',,.V:;rs;»E}:%::§é"vE<zé'§--__%.}{%é:§"2 ascegiafl $32 ihe sfkggeggéng §§fE£&s': A'=L4_§;sse§:;§%é'§h::': §j:.f"J§v%j§,§an§<;a§p Wag: was aésa c<3;7f:_;fiEéi';~5%@E a§*%::'.._ %:§*:@ iémg {arm cagéiaé gain figs éesr:
€§<%i:§:*r3ff§"§;5zg:§'A3iiV R3,é»%,;%§,,§%§,.-I-"~, ;'i£{;'§€'§§§'%§ ta §?:e Reazigémzaé 5%§"§§.§E{)§;E"E;};g"_v.§§§i€%§"%; was g mésifike is: $8 &§S€§$§"{'§SF'é§; GE"§€'§" E5:
agéegfcévaéigé 'éféé sagiégé ggérgs ifiacaégge 2% fégazrg 3% ma Sham {:--%'.-€33? §S§5S§§€ 5% a b$§"E§§§€§aE"*g' in Em Eamkaig Tszggi has '::7.:e53?e§§ iiéafiged §§"E<:§ égiarrméneafi $3; 2% sfizfififififiéfig Qfféie? Q? ~%,, §~¥E,f§,§§:"§%<a§g Yragtg 8% furihér %§§§§"'~.:'&§ 'zfhai {fig aggéggee E353 céasmaé §@a:::§E:;:': méer §%CE§§%"% 5%? ag fiér giswmani Q?' magma arm that 3% aéaim as?
mt én 3C€Q§°§§§'EC€ 1"\i§§} §:,:I::~Ser.:i%@:"a {£3 3? we assggsee has maée Em §;"z'<=.,re§g%':'?:e:=;r"sAt" by gaging R332 §5§<?°§$ <:;s:"*:V Gé.@32Qé36 :5 };§.f_'31,ZS€_'}?V'a3:§rE{é;if~..:hé 3:a§§--..éf3$Q:; 4é%é§': a%§§ :~3Qi3t§;'e§ in faves? vaffihe_.3's;:;%$s:€é€L._f:2n'56'.'1:~;éGG? is"; Wei? Seymd ifie flue a,;a:ff;:.*§;§é:f.'_ga;fisesiéarz {1} sf gectém E-'3;v;§.::£a.g'_'§'3 ivfigpaséi the 33% praaeeds 53$' fififlfé} 3%' the m'1,&ci:, fie %3s}:§ed__ 3 Eric;-':.§€e=:; 'u§j2{:£'::3E'v$&€%:'§@n 253 G5 the Ac? am aftar' imaréng 'E§2@*§$Sé?S§"éAé»-§'%i.S§@§ as mder taking away '€928 begfgggféi L.2::h£c%:"' gfiafiiefi by $519 Asgeggmg éu%h:0,:=ét*;.»: :Afiagg§'%%:%?eAga? _b§';»<._%:%:e gaéfif mderf {ha §$§€'SS@:€ fiffiffifféfi as": "';§_§f';:%_gaE"'§:4%"'_i%:§.'§'§'§§::z:a§g, "§"E':§ Trgféagrzai ééd ma}: §§'"%'€€§'§€§"& with %:?3é""§%r§:é:s".a3§"'E?%e §e%z'§$§®na% Autmréiy 3:': 3:2 €a:' ag ?.:%"2e gagétaé ,:Q3.§E'f%S fégaigeg whéa': is %:$ éa aésgiaé far %%2& gsgwage 9? _' '§_$§%&;§'amen: E°--%§:}§§{%§§€%§:§?"?r ézéée "§':"§§ég§{:a% 3&2 a$§é@ ihe :3mee* 2? $28 §3€"v'§S§G{'§3§ zlzgiézfiréty 23:': the §%:§3v3;* aamfié 22%;, 3S§§§§§i§§¥"% sf fissiiém £4? 9? 2% £5? fiy h@%fi§n§j'~§_§é;%2:'-V:V§2e §E'§¥€§f¥'§§$§'§E raaéé éy Em aggessae §e%§'E§ §g3e£§f§e§ mam?" $:§§»3e:i:§@:*: e;4)_,§f__§S&€iiE'é:*g. 3i';3§"':<:%f %§*s:1e' ' miézcét, ihe §SS€$S@& fig eiigébég $e£iE9r: S5,? :3? the §,':£".;ic:t 'E" %§?@__fa;$$V¥¢'ss'é:& .h1a:{:. :"é::;:i§'g;*:.:f§3%rre::i' :L' am: agapeai 0?': térsfirsfi: '2ss;_v?2e:".é'a'*:=; :?:§f§ rgzzenase sreferrea an agjgaafi GV::"4--%fzE*;'eAs'é;{;:n§% % _
3. T§z¥:",T:§é-barisaé gaéfi €$E'ECEE.§S§®f"& the: {E23 §n'{€2é§9§:.fné?é§'*~:T§af*déf;,§-ély'-.€:§fs--e «2:2$§éSgee being within the time 3;3'é'€f駧e§{iii,:,s:'2u5é:' §iL:»E;:?*SecfT:_'§"<:v¥":*':'§ Sf gecticn 339 sf Em act :*"§%§"a§" zen' <3? Eizég Casasra in Ehsg €:aS€ af F8L€f?§f?"E§ 8&3' .§;?ve:§?s?§""§é,z" Qffisrger regzzarfgg' fr: 529%}; 32 §é3, "'a~'E*asz'§e:rz; E? ':1-am véewg are §{'}SS§;§§§€, the _éié'a:i%;?:':3.%[::'.%:':v:,§;&E'V.."';i:.s:.é%:'E/*;:3ré*i2; ésaé as jagrigéécizégge is §E"§§§§§E€ §%g%;:9駧?%§3.§'§'3.g:A%§§&: fiacééen 2&3 Q? '€§"éE fig: E? wag §%%§§ aha:
._%E*e@ ::>r~:'§;&é: gaggaé $3; we E~€§:§*: $35222": $3 é:':=:;@::r*€§%; w€':§£§"; '= ':§§:%é§gr;:": aaémmif fie gaaegééeé. 333$ fréfiagzéaé hag §{:%§sy2='e§ iiééa §U§§§§'5E§"2§ €35 éhés Qatari ag éghe «fieséaém 9:? iha iéégéx Q ,,,,,,,,, Cami: fig fiénfiéng $5'; i§"§€ sziémréinaie Cfiiiéfifi. E? §:E'§E gmfigmeaé: gagseé by thég Saar: £51; e€r§n&::m§, :%1e.,§'?«:~:.a;&~..%é:§& gémsgéé ?%§'-s'€ shaééangeé aha gaié @:"§€r.
Céféfifii '$5 a §§'Gi£%"E§ far émsoiqéng Sficfiigéé .% f'2'e :%.::tL.§;€"
the §ac:$ as' Ehég cage, in iha: 'a;*»§.,;@w;'{2=f.=%:?:é._:2*:a%E;éé,: '=m;Aé"'?§Q mi}? age any magi? Era %:§2T§$i'-.._Va§pe?a§.-- V;ij':;:'c%:f:E«%vz2§E3é,. E'E£3- 3a:§§%;az":%:sa§ Qiiéfifififé sf éaa_2;s_V"'-zéééggg ?§s*«_§ar:s.3é§?§ra§§as':fi Heme; '£§'§& agpeaé ég V§':'::.2§;'1é.sS:t~3fi;.;.»':v fl §%'$'*