Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner vs Shri Dhiren Gandhi on 23 September, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
his»; SOEE. §=;a,::°:=em§@::"@€i <i=s;%m:m§ E}-;i{,'féS€: :°€:g;:is;%::°2z%i.is::§:
<7:<=::°%£.i§i{:a.i;e§ 3322?'. miiigaci 'ms: 2¥;s53€:i:§ $2' i;'.h_s::% bz2$ir:€:s%:=:~. azfgd £8 %:%21:'r}-*§::.§; :32": 'ahzsé w:~r:'3:' sama %3z:s§.:1£;':ss$ Lniéier iihe "€.:'é'3'i.'j£V namézg as its pr<2p:'"iet{>§'. '"§'E:€;'ef{>:*€% {}z:{':<3 ihg-3 .§"'€,':':gi,',%;'§§V"&":.%{1I§;::'=3;b'.T.§'*'-T * <:e:*f:i:§§.cz:E.e::*~ is s;':,:;:r<~:I:d€:*€:i Ezhs €:.::§§;t:z:{, {?§>'<1*§§.§i_ ;§v;,"{':E'£;:€§"w Sh<}':::£d E29: §"€i"%£%E'IZ'S§;£3C§ EHEQE: --.._,%:€:<.1::$a%;:§:é:;1'駧 "{i:::t};"
:°€pr€§€5§:M€§n§§ éhe Sazid {?€E}i7£lt g':':"'%r;*.;:'i§',_i:s;3:VE";"*;§$';:§é; E19 t.§?1§=: £:E€par§.rm3zmf; it is in causae 3;'.§{}§§{3€ 'SFJEES isszxsii 3151? 39§€5§a as mi 33 é:.1=ii€§ Viiiggbie to pay the duiy é.€:r:21:r:§fié{iV'211*;;:§. thezéi étha Tribuziaé is mat jag-:5%ifi§':i§; S162' 'e§-*€§ czézzssidéiifeéi <::':'de;° p&iSS€:§ by {E9 ;:1:éE'%::§ri"%:_ié>S:
«ifiyEV"1§3e§'~'§t::2mi§"a1_; 83:3 §{a:?iS'h2H1k21z: Eagzrm-izj C{}i§E:5E=3€i§ ;i§}§;é;€:§:*é3?.§--.§a§;' a$::%€ss;€<3, zéayétssizdsgii, zaaftiiiihézi' ii': Sean} 1 aé2:*"'§:"§ ;:'3;_;_'<':i,..1--§& Ehere 35% 39:23: §::d§:::a1'%;i<>:: ef f<>i3é§:::g§ agéy '::::é::E€:r §h€;'i fiifii 0:": '£326 §:":_;g2:.E E':€i§t'.:=3 af §}";=iZ' iimteassii _ -_%:'=:_:£{i%::* {Ef £2 :'§%g.§iS%;'"za:§:§<}§1 as-::°€?.i§i{é2:i:€%. 'E"'E':@§°%5§0':"£i '%fiJ§".z€'EE {};"§E{':€ ~ ' '*:%2a§;L:{f1a;":f{::: 291:",
2.;
Séaiizfisri E"T':{f}"€, pa}; I.i'.§:€~ a:3'1{3:2:'1i'. :s;'p<:<Eii"§<;>;{§ in £;hé3 :3<:a':i<::: "E"'hé:
p:a:wi:*-::<} €15} {he saié g3:"<}vi.5.~;1;{}:1 {}.'§"Ei§/' 6i::;::§js3.'€:ess i,E';::~ psrwai sf E§:m§§:a5£i{';:; if 7é.h€f. 2:22:56: faEE$ zmiier any one {:5 ».tj§-1_:}:;_e <:i'§°<:um-staricea Iilemio-ried thereinm 'E'hs2,refQr2: SE6;-§..%§2:.._j'%. {ram fiff §;z"1vs:>E§é:d :mEjy' £10 :'ezé01r<ér_..:jag:,}-Y f:i§:::"
érhargeaiésie W}'_f:,h éa:§:§z, S€<::'V.i»:«"[':--
se€::€i0:"L it p.mVi@@s-3 éfizggli "§:€:"v;';:3v;i:€€§ and ztéaileaziség in Such a 51:93-.'p:'<5${3.z?.i.bed§ :5:
duty af €::;e::is€:.:*:§:*=;La"_£E.T élfif pmduced er man;L1§'e:ct{ig:%{§:A'£'§:'3 .izgzflfig-.$5;,__§;:::%§:b'&:'£he rates, 36% forth if': the E'"i:*é:'." E.X{:§.$&:~ ',{'arif5f Act 3985. *§--"h:€:a:z;'€f0r%3£ makes ii; 'very ciearg a §}€§"SQj%f.?i_ {:if2g;:§?;;*Z:€»'5..':*\\%§:*r..%;6§%'« §§'§;€,i:'§ dui:y azziéar 31%? A522; 3:5; {he ;§'§*:'é%' ward 'ifiailiifaéillffifg héiiiw 538331 :§é§§:1:¥:3 65 Eims: £63 w';¥1§{th :°:::afi§~;: 3:3: méderz xv j;;:j§:;:%::;gf$';e:%§::r{3" irzséagéeg gmgg pmzregst -- {E} §::::€§§£%§zZ.aE gr §§'E,{.*i§EaE"'§g is §?"a::> <:=:3:?':p§§3z":'{>ra 553'" as A 'T 3':fé5%3.nHy;,?£:'2,{:§'2,§,re§ §:ma'.:zs::':
w%*g:i{:§2 :3 ;<-;g9€é{:*§}"E€ci $2, :°€§:2€"§en 5:52 {my §a6d:§ 5:: E326 Sgaciiazz gr €§%&, {er :':a§i'&§ $5" 31528 Ssfzeéiaie 53 J .,§3_ §}£E}r"§E':{"°?E1i'j 0? S':.E{,"f§1 S'?;.§Fi1§§ am} e:§:*r{§:.:{:%. ?::%1e;% zz::"a{}:.::n1t s;:=::s paiygzbie immzn gm}; :12£3r:{-33¢. awing; Eta éihéi ;;}i>.¥s<>z1 f:"{}::; *QVh;{}':T:T'1 $:,2_{:§"s. §:§U.fIiE§ may be réétm-'§éra%3Ee <31" e:§::e,..;r~;.:-Egéizh may ha in his; hezzzdsls 91" ':.a:1de:° the <E§Sp:>s§ai Q:3}{::<}:fi;?§3-§_ :;é:"._. 1:121}? rezzewzr aha am<:s:.:§fi by z1%_,*£,..2?:.{:_E*1mé:§-::i¥*€f'"<':«:%*j .s~:{;22.§<:é'.V :35 i3X€'iiS{:}.b§€ g;a<;£§:'~a 'fi{-,'.§{}§"§§§§§},f.(;§ §I{}'..$§E%~{f%1 §3é;:s~3<>::?:: "éhéi naiiurs {ii 2: §§&1iT"3.":§.S:?:€{3 {}§'C§.i'3L.E'";"' -.'Ef:§.9"-€:?:_:E: 21Ifi§:;:d.:§:eni. {.9 Sean: E by As: 1130.2 of 2§f}V€'%3§ i'%4I.E".'n§;'.,E'{j:£'E ggéinét. §;--2*i{;» <:§°fec'€. fmm E9? 9;' 2884; as }">§"*s:§1«?.F1${3 %;éV':{t§£};§f:::§_; *m}§.1.§ch zj<-:.éids as unaierz Pr0viaE€2:;i"':',f'}L':z,_€ per:»f'o?é g".?;e?'ei:2qf§;er raj iefred :9 as pre:a§e$:€ié;$;o:}'mf§'e;§§ ;'y%=§§%§i. duzgg or any aifier Suaézgsf ':;::?'a§,£ s*peC§f'§3d in {his S€C§'f92'"i'., is :'ec%§':?;3:%:_%,:E€ ;<>§"*é'as_é;*.:§;%i:;:f§€§,{}:3r$* ax" Q§'%2.e3r:;:§3<3 sifispcvges; agflfiis E2z,;$:.;?¢s$;<§ wfimie :3? in parfg G!' Q}f}f%3.c'f:;'=s gig} Cfzgzzige» ffé 'fie aime;'3f:z'p iftarezgfl in c<3:'zs'eqz.§§r2.s9 'i,%§i%:':7§?:.A.§1é: S 'fiiiiéééédfiflf in 4-223:7}: %}:.£.:<3'§:z£ss 53:' €::*€z,§e E-sgg agfigg gergam {iii excigabie £0043; FE'E€:Z«§;€»)?'ifi»£$?g '}§Q:'§.f'.'.:§ r:':ac?2€:ze2'€s-35;' zsegsgis, ;.:.{i'a:2:'~;i.§$; '---€::2_g:?§v;<:J;';Eé'3%é:':é--;' anéf a;*'§:2"cEe$ fr: $2255 {izzsfzéfigg or _;;a>ss-msgésm. {;f"5:§f;.é; _;}ers<2?2 $9 :<;2,;e::6e&.:":%.g mag; 52.533 be {'§é§.§j€.E{f§"a{3£§ A 'T £3265 ;;<:JE{§. Errgg 32.35332 <g§}":T{:e?" em;_:z3§.;:g'3:'e{§ 5;; {E29 CGEEEYQE V "'§3'€>a;rz§ :g;'L?F;1'x{%z'§e and <'32.zs£.c;:':'2.s;, aj°€.§»,>;?° {"}§:}§f€iiE3§?1;j :,:.sr§.§§.§3,r: ::a;3;2:'<}::ai j'%°am 3%? {:{}??§?¥'"£§SS§.{}?'22'3F° <3?" {?{9:2.§::"zz§ §§J€{?':E%'z':', w'_.M >§§I\\m < ms-~'>=»:;
M39, 23%; ms: ha:;£§s:g £3? félé? Eiégzzé £35.:-.*§.:*s9s w{:'z,:§£% :'1{3é &?aE"§f5%':<3. :'5'a--:+; 3": £5 {f§€'?%£.E" f§'~:>:1": Sec. E It Em §3z2rE::'<21.:E2?a;:* éhiir g3r<>v2'$§:s w.§:_E::%£":_ g_:s:'::é:%§:%~:i Ema} Sfi'£'2?§.{f€, Ezhks is méé: 3: tra:":$'fa-=.:° 9:' {%_§$p.e:::sa..E_ e:t:_§' 2: 1::1ii e:£z;::"*§ng the §§§%:'€.i:11_e QE Ehés, 0§'igiz12:§_.-3§1s§é;'€é§'$«é3é§;'.._. '§'§r:er€f:>m iheiy asarzxzcéf, bi: 'i::'€ai;e{i 2:$....s:»::<é<:é:_é;é%;{}i":=::.? _v,:'¥;i:} V{::<a_:1»L.v E363 gnaiifii ax-raiizibie fer the: €i:€3.€2y':;'_AA§§&§yEi§}§€3 _ 'E3j3f §}:"e%dec:§?s3s<}:' hf: Eitzie and §,_'i1("~3>;E'§fi1é};'€% p:'a:,::ri$.e:;_ 111:} 3. E' is Té'§:Z}?, afirzizttéséi :0 E,§'1€ faétifs af thiéa-9 <::j';1s--3é;.._. ES. 2:: §§"3<§S {',{}§E;E.€f;Y;£:',_§h§§' ":.i':g*: revenue Qzzeinted gut: :5: §;"f:.§i%§§f1".€<):.:rt in the case cf €Qi,,:}i,vE*":'i,f"¥Z4'_jQ§éV:€'i*:VE*"'€";»_%:.'__%31§'.% 12$. Xxmmnm fiE'3®R§;E_3.g 3111 hag "beer: §'1€E.€§§ éihs p{:;r$$:§ " s§,:_{%h §3m<:€§:C§.::1g$ airs §§'i§€i3;?ll€:':§.; iS:='V: €.§E'iEfv §~§:3£7fE%€','A:~'-;."_3_,:{f7§T}~é1Z'§€'3«E3:b§€ "mZ%;:§': éiuiy. 'E'ha§: is 23: "'~.§faS€:"§%:§' :S§"i€%_§"'§§. §é3'§L-*§g..._§_é'§'f«'{§¥.3'§1§f. 'E'§_':@: §}§'€}{T°.:E?€{§§I}§§S €:?é;¥;§": 'H: '{:§"2e;% §::§::i'L:§22<:%;:u}:"e:: .3? hi': hag? F{i'§iE{}E-"Q5 's.,:,:':::E€:r §%.<1*:é;" {}§:2v:i.:}u.s;E}; Eiés 'hz:'a§s €18 pziy '§'E"§€ bzzigxaxzie éhgé V§:%§*:}i:§1_:§::%:i;é__}§;2§'i::g§ '§hé"» €§'%.,§§',}f §<>:$$ Ezéaggn Whéifiil :5; Eigbies *4,