Karnataka High Court
The State Of Karnataka vs Andappa on 16 September, 2011
Author: Anand Byrareddy
Bench: Anand Byrareddy
V" xs_'md;-:.§7sg%?2: is 25;:
' i ' {}::L:A:T {EEEEEEE {'{§E E53? {$15 §~{:":§%i?'~£f': ikifé/'E 1: :2»: ii{)N'BE 3*, M14: 3: ssmcia; §'§S;;<Q§:1<étam"
Criminal Ap11921?-.No..534;'it}{}§ V ' C/W. _ V' ' C ri m i n :1 Er',/RV!) {ma £ ' E\"U'; 3.3 :i()?'2.(_}(}S f3;1...,§.f;:;L£xJf>i:.2;§_Z i;f%"éi§',s§'%§'iv§'§"§iE§E£E§£:§E}' :';3.!:;::;2}';:E§E. _ we 颫:..:§':a:::*::;». "
ii/~::a §~£.;:;*:::°:é 2: .3 %E*§,>§ l§'é,§iA'3'fé:§§')EiIf?:i%L 3?; }_'c;:.:js.-
ifijéi: V§{::;1z;';;:E« s =:j§§§ ;%§:_r% S%::\;.¥":1:i§*;%:zz§. :E{§'~;a%$;i£<:,} V i u ; >é__:i':'%:§:%:V:;1§ Z>z*:>é:axé:::*:: iféjy fin: fézziiag §}i.%§'§§§C §}:*<>s:::;L::<;:r $132' ééh: ii; §3§"2:j~;§:zg éhgzi *;,?3:T;~;; E3 V:~ea.:a%:::z::e: é;Ti;'iE<f'i§ fféiss ééiézfi f%§'%§3i:2i§ §§§ce.;§ :A::2:iz::' ?é::<.:%%:>:': 3177 :3? i 2::
L>:":"é:§c {f:;>:::'§ §"§22§}' Ex §}§i.§'i;£}~Ii:§§ s:z2§3;2:zc::
_.'EiFi§:'= §?:':>e,s;:::;§ in 232:: iii?" é"§i;'---1. §{z.>g>;:;£= §i"i { 33$ E §:;,{,'.?"~§éf},{(7%§?§!2§}{§3u 213:3': iijiiéflgi. Eh: :":::~;§§3:2s£:::2';/;:§a;:,2>;:::,§ $0? 3%: :2§§;*22i;s;~s ;'%{i§2§>«;§3,é;?i§'f'§§:.;' ::;3<%s::* f~%::a::§am;»; 4§%%;?<i£_f>;} ;::%:§ 362:? :;>£"§?::: §§2;a.§%;;2; §'<.:é'22:§ {'s§:.§,g:, 5 ..;'€§ §f'~é%}§}?'~£§}§{?\E'E' §E'1C§'§,,»"'\,.?\§a>.f3éi§ 331%???
;\m.§;2ppai S/<>.'»/'cc:':1pp;: Mamzssésiijx z\§.c:<%: zzbmlz 30 }'C§.1§'.\;_ {)::c: z\s:z:'§::L:E§:§z'a:. R/<>« E<a:'::mud§' Eg: ":':.:ibm(;:.: V E)is%.: Kogispui.
{B3 fshri §,§.>{>V§\:',£i{i1'Z%E'§"§i.rA\£.§'»'(,?éJ;i§C,§ }.:e::~:s;§><m>§«:é~;g' (Bf; S:'i,;*\:1z::}a;=3 '"aVi'£§.._é:'u;£%§§f;- .1 {£311 fif{%g::"::V< %<m:m:nc:1E P§s:azi<.::;'.} j§'F'i'i'$mi}°%:3§€,i':;1l ;s:;5p¢a%,£s EEEc_cE"Eii:ci<::' Szzclimi 3'?»3{fL} 0:" ihc:
(Jada: <31'- £'z<§52:?11:1?,§":"<>Cc:iim; the zzaiarawzzias fan' @113 mm 4 2:52:32' zajgatéim; :%*:c._iiz<.ig:mc:':1'<i;::c(i~3§'5 E...-f{}{}§7 gégsssscaé £3}; am» $50, iV§L€.'~§.
'~»<>.€'é§*§/'3{'éi%f5.»- ;:.'=i'~;éa:%im: ii}: ;i§">;1t3§§;%§E§=':;i£:Ciif£z:€§ My 82;:
Kaégwpeii in S".-i.
£?§~§}é:11é:i3> §7i2!?§S'§'§:i§§§i;v?.V%§fE{§é:i", ?€§ai'é:ii<>:z>; ~E'v'§~i{;':) ;i§1<:,§ 3&5: 0? iéév E:2:%i;:::
§'a:::;i§ .§§i_7a:c%a:..
'§'%;;::xw; 213$ :;%.}E?E§E.':f;:?. or: {or éénzzi §V:s.:2:z'§2z§«t: Eéééfs iizijy. 333:: €j:>;::'%§ E if 1} {S 3%»: E '3' "?%":s:ea; ai:'>§:c;:§;»: ::<.>:*::s§:.%:::':::VLE Eesgiajééstz' £22 aé::2a :2? 83; 5:22:32 ',;.) 7 Eézas ;:p;*:a:;2§ £52 éfiéréigégai :'a,p;3::;:§ T\4<>f>3l 2€',%<}%?é»T is p:'::§L*m:<;% bjx Eisc S:2:§:: *::é1c:'c;:+e like Qkémézéasi x\;*:;°;;:::§ Elissa? b} Liza: ;ié.:tL§§»Cé§, J :. fEE';:: Ewiasi' iisesirs ;:2':.: as £é>%§:*>v§:3:
3 he ::<>2:V1;'::§;:im22: amt ':"::E}::ni§z3V;i'"2xas; E§2éi~=.";1:%;'1--§é:::' aééf Eigzszagwzs '~a;h:;> is said in Ezzm: aié<:{§"~.;§f'!.cz'_7 §'s:12'A12'2§_.: ::éé';.fa;2m§*:1<:d sszécéaéc. zizs bz:a:i~;gmun<;§ to w%*:§a:IL axels: Liz;:'i":%f:<: a: {>n'ipEerinai:':--3.:_'E:2;_:§:~ :hr;:«: <§2zz1g§2:::1's s and {:20 32:51: §iL%'§'é'L£,:3","'»,-§'3Z£S2:"i§a'1ii. 'f'i?E;:§E';:xid'"S.:.:x;--é%;;'é' f*§§:;::'2::2::;'2p;: aim:
EiL1c§1s:c:*;1pp;zf H127: [email protected]::ab2{:';£i o%":.'ijac Lvmpiiigixiéiizi hzzai bcgézz 12> Raillaigifi x is :"\r'E21§1z;:'2i:sE:£522'"é§f3_§1:gE0 c.:.::€";.._h§>» 3EVi\'V&E§i§,«E(<.$€_}£%a 22:; 0:2 {ht s;1z:1<.: of' :13; éizesédzsni gzfyié 9:: §2::=:§ é::a;%<i::::.:. E: ::':::é:;§;:2§:i:'reféezié 23%;'; zsscziscai amsa zasssidmzé of éézai ;~;:2sm:
é:§a::'zf§;:_;;é:-r':s;';;$V' *2-:,:":§:c:E axéiéz $22: c§>:23§3E:2%€::::z:¥; §'>§*<;>:§é:.::: xxézigsig 2222:»; :32}: !;':;r:_ ézssj" §§%;§;'3<::$ /332:: ::e:c::r»::.::} and §§;:s;:x'z;2 *s.a:::':.* :~:::%g§ is: 33:: oz'; . ézziimziéc 'is:-:'mts 225:3 ?.§'}i}iEf»:E§E {Ems ;:§:::ure:.:<§ K3218 §::;:r:"%2:<i ézsaéiég :3. :.:£é§§<i. . §§"é%'2:§}i§§3§:"'aZ5% {$32}: if (£2:
1» :2:€a::' 353: 323:: m;z§:*%;:§;e.: 3&5: ;:¢c2:é~;a:a§ 21225 ("M aa:::i§:-:a::%, amaé §§2:s;:;::'s:: ézzeé i':2;i::":"§a::,§ gmé §§':;':'é. Eézsséz' a:;::«; :2, :'e;:::%:~;§:::"¢éi a>:';;:$ Efées agagsmgééas§:'2;.::2E ;.%.§';ai EWSEPEEEI € {M2 S §':".éi,%§"§%§é.,\T ;i>:'§<>:' is: 331:: {$2153 :3?
7 §'x§ii'1':E§3EEE' e;;;:;~;i:: ;:;2s.§ 32:32': é:>:;:i§a :a;":?§;m*}'2 zaimazi flag wzzaézl-~--<>é M » H, V §§;:.~<2.;:a:L;: zmai 2%}; zzgtaéxsfi zmai 2'a:£':::;a:L:3 as zgagccgii §§;:r~;;a%;\.;2. '§.;;?§<'; ?;'§--';jc ::',¢ iéuéiéc, E1 is in ':.%3i;~s b:3<:E~;g::'<>u:2<i éimé :33/c a1a:;;u;~;<:<% :;::1<;§*'..E§2a>~;m.;faE: Eiwgi éaégcééici" Ea"; Em imszsc fir: Spitz: <>£f-'fiié:';24=:::zis;cgi_.;>§_§£."z%.gi§ é;';.é ' marrigrd. fkficz' 50212:: 'Lime. i§:a::'a: $5; <:Vidc:1§:§% 01} _:'<:z.:o:'d 'éai; £:'V*:»:.f'§e;:2L:i£;;_i§'2--::: " aha: dé.::::::iSa3L§ vvcnt to Iixc ii'; :3 ;~eEi::d;v.._:i"i2A%»cE: bc§<::22::::s;§ i:_;2 {E253 2:{:Vw:\c:% gmd axzzéx, r::s%dis22.: 1h::r::in. E? am E13£'2i:':'z*::i\'i<.>:€'121221 sin: im<L§":}icc§ uiéssr :.:<>n;~;umEn<:z ;mi_~;<>:z {fun this e:oi22.§>'§;':§:2:v=.m!h2%%'.iL;§:*<§:'w:Véq Sic sixcci v;§1c:':: aicééai ;::.z:a_%..';: <;.:si';3;'3j%~;aé::: %i;:;\: 3<>d}g_:,:<§ viii": the éhc aigzcczzscai mas: i}/.2 '£:.i>§~?_:§:i.§éi£;'i*3Ei}' I':a13'2::s:s§:'1g and luz':L:z'i;1g :i:EEc:_:;1ii<m abet? :h;:."::;C{:'s'=[:d» *4"
aha: aEc<:c;2Sc<§'21':'si.§fL&'his:§é5 593255 i:§§%m:':i::Ej{Zf':*VixVc;2 izzsr in sgmmnii szzigiaicfi «i. a_{};3 flzfzi §3'iir§;if% '"a--->§ ii2:: c<§a:;7§:zi:z§ $25; EEEC s;§"§%::1<;c;~e §'3&i%§"§§f~;§E;i'i§.'%1§z:--,{i§E€.§i:E" f~§_a:{::iz:;35; -é<}§~i:f;X} :'<.:;2z§ zzéiia; f*$::<;':§a>;z 3€;>{> as? 222:; 2' 1:3? iéiééé €§::::'::%32::§§.<::' :'a:1"<:m:-ii 3:) :25; "E131" E235 %.'%'::f &é:i:é;i:§é;{§ 'x%»;;:;~e :;§":2:i'g,:: >»;§a::a:§c;é ééiééf $12; ézzégi §§%z;§'a:i<é:'C r»;§:>:::_§ 3 '?§":c iréai £7<:::2'E gE2::a'iz';5: Etszsm ;2a:§::E 3:22: aim g7:ms;c<;z:§%<:;2 ' $233: %§§€é:§§%%%"%4'iE§§7 ::>;%.:i%?>£§s;§3::a§ gaéih :35 iii: :.:<;<:z:s~;::é ihg' a2f§::%:::v;:s; 2 ";*::2:éi2~;§M:;T:E?:::: amdesz' ;::?<V2:*<;r;.:L:§& .*;%.:i3§§{'}%'§i~; zmsi E2315 %§é.3;:aés::<i iha: ??é,§§'§§iw1§E§"i'32;'%"§§ ;»:::;::c:2::' E 'éw ;:a;:;'::&«;::a.§ 32:: am: 2:::.:§',~; %'a:::5:m!g;~a; K'?
5:?
-- ,3.
§::2§2;*Ese>§2;na,*z2: asraé fish; g>§'§IjE%;>:'§} - fig' :23: :>%éc::c:: g>:::2§s%:;:%:§::_-:.:_;:<§u f*%:::;§§:a:2 -§r'}§%{_«',} :32' my EEK asaaé {:::'1E'2c:" am: :s'ifZi§"h:'\'".§'§§;i.%§"€.}:Ef~i.' §s21§}:'E.xe;'::2sz2c:1i avd ling <':E'?.:i€}€}£%é ii}? {hes asficilasa: 9L::'§.%_>éi3z:,§'2§e., :: :1<§e:éi ' f~%cc':i<>n §{}{> vi' 32:: EEK'. Efzc :s:.:m.e:n<;a: 0:" $52p1=§+;m:.2m:;.2.{ _€:';:.~; '§:a:E':§;:;:> 51:11 c:>s:cum:z:§I}. ii is ihaz aims?) is Lmcicé*._cii;:_§§cng_:.: E3; am; :.:cc=-._:§c<i " £22 aha: ;<.;:c<;>m% a>£"ah:::~;c apgsusgels.
6:. En:~;<>§é::' 21:: {Ex} -:.:p:;'*::;:i'_§EI<;V-JV b:'s '.§,_§:'ii,',' "_'%~::_:éc is <;:>;2u::"1:c:i. to seek a::1.hu;"::;z::'miH_i 11$" '!EF£v-v.Sifi'}fiiCs1i{t'4.,2£§§§"§§§S§' 1.E"Ei'C 2ia:2:i.Ex::£§. Efm: %e:a1'm:d (§<>\;cz':1;'13pz":1;3E3i;:;:¢iC':". €63' i§1af_S*':.::ti: x%;'5(:i{:§ci cogmczad ihzzi {Ens m2::\;i1"num §3Li£'E§'i:$V§1I'V1-';:$3VE'1' p1'c:€<;':?ii$é;..?:~-;fi{§c:' f>'<:a;E.im: ~$')R{_/X} of ihc EEK' is, a:Vi1%c§€ §}1;*}.5 s:5;:--i:Q1:l Ea'; é%:v2':ECv...§'ca2i5>; and line: zmd izzrsmfzzi' 2:: ms m:i2§r«;§'2:2'::;:V:E p;'cs*:::'§b{:si 532* ;::3.2~-:.§§<:a:e:c 3L;n§s§s;:§?§:: amaicz' f\};c:h>:': }'={}€é :\>§:§":::'§§'€Z' mzz} :c>%';'::.:z__3;.% 2:3: Egg} }'c;::*:\: as? §§'%1§'s§"§§€i'!E'1}':E'x:E"i§§ zzaizd éiac. in $22 "ééfh'$3323~§§ET£§E%Ef§?~;§i%iEi£i.3f£ am: fix: ;"éz:>;:~;%a':§%>; 5023:": 332:3 ibzéiézi £322: 333:' ::?:If*' 'mscxz ;.::":,>xca_§ ;:;;_;:§;§si iiéa: ;:<;a:;::;a::%' § \ . é:":1§f%:::§'§':é:j>2é--- z;;%°§§::§3%. .-;w:a::2:;<::~; is :§:c:'a:§%>;'c as:2;':z::::,*g*;%;:':3;a gmé izasnzx: " ;~s;:aE§;v;«~ggzz%':.z:%'1a:a::3":g§é a2§':%':z: 3&2 5:23;' ;:p§;2:'a>§;*§;2§:;*E}'. ?. '%f"~--;'%":%§:: {$223 Es;:m::=<§ asaamzsci £792' {£33 :::;a:z>;::<.§ 5% aai" "éhas ;:§'ts§5:a:;:§ €%::a.§ :m:;%<.§ C{}%'E§<:%E£.§ ziuii, :§2:::*:: ac m;:é<:s€;:£ 52:: :*:::::;>z'<§ ég: 2:
2:2§L§:c:.;:a: aim: we ;::;£;a;s:ea::i aazzr; :':é;:ma::si Eat: i§::'s.:::;é:~2'a3%;§, ii; ' '=:.T_>§":3:s':.f;f':E'{§§_)'§3: :.gs~.sz;s:;a%%: §é::;:'";:: Emmi. fizz: ::':é<§::iE:::: {>33 :'::cu:'a% is :1: 122:: zéflzfia iiéaé 33:5; :ac:x:_.-g;__x%z:;2 m;::.::%za:r zsmé sétzgc £39.: ;;::c:::~;:::% v;;2;~; ;:Zz"::;:a;i}' gzzzméccé am? E':;'a_:;§:-.3' {:2 as mm. ii}: :,g::::se':i:>:1 vi' {item §3éf%E'¥§ :1 Vzzéiaf :1V2:;s';'Ez:g;'.§; 'i'>::jm,j¢{:-:3'"1EsQ accaésesai ami zhe: aicgsgagscaé did am: ;::'is;c. iv-E's:é*1':;':; ihc *gs:2'}. é:i\~I?>;;1ii':>i%.V<35» Scczéam ~E3}é'\'i{;"'y} at' m; EPE7' is no: :c:':aii"2i<:'émcfiw_£'é:r'i§m*i.%1<:'~film? E,-_§ ' i§.2;E" mailer avg»; Shea: Em: aicccazsaxi '~3.':i>é Z.g>i.VZ':~.§§\ <>;:;m.~;aé:i._1j:%_;ihV<;; :1 ::é:';*§2ag:c p:'<*sfs<%::x'c:i wéiiz $1222' ::2;:§c:':V2;1%:"u§:::Ia: ;:.A:':'s§i 0:7:€?1::'":;L>1§2;::' imhéé éézis %n":i:*;2;1%c axéziz Eh: zicsguscai and 'aha zicczssargi Emzfi.vg'}s3i>*yi§:}<§nf;:,:i; :«a_§1<:§%a::" in 2 fax: :9" _}1mi7§'} by Ema' mgsiim" zmd ms fzm; mm xha: §}':§'i':'.;7C'a3§i <;i§:i\>a.:n {rial <4;§° N '(>2-';.;u'1s:.i "£7:jz::s3.--:"2.1'z§<>n than she mzzju hgizc ms: £331: pssiiiézrnasr mass é:':d::«;c§ c<m3:T:é:§<:'{i §<>:'iut*§i;§; ";:;1é;i4_E2:2:"2:ss'£:2ig.Vim:TE§::::;;;:s::<§ is; §1{'3§ ceéazbiisiecai $3} em}. »::'x"§£§C§}i:_i3 SEE :"{;~ca>:*:§,. V15-§Va:: ".;_>§2§'j; <:%.§e;f<::2<;:: ii:fiiiL'E'<:{§ am ':a:§2;:i§' are? 2%}: '%a:;;:2:;§az:2 :a;,2:~; <';§'§;"e='«J:x:§% :0 3? vies; <;§a2;~;c: %_'a:§::.§%_*~{s;;=:; <}§.::§2<:"§§s.:{:;;:sa::i. z22:;':2:*§2,, §':,::';* i'E"E£f3§EEi;'§'. <:a>:::~;%z:, g:Y;:2za;§§12§E':a.:z' auzaf Em' :?3;.:%.::'%'%E'§--*:§ :::1.z;§c. 's'»§"§23E'£.;';iL~é ii}: X%é§:'§c$§%:.)&~; .§}!'=§"'¢T: Ea) i"$/f? %m 2 », ;:i:l;'a:: <f3;x'22m§§"§a:<§ :2::%:~..E:'::a%z::1~; gmé $322} Ezzsci %i:a;a.::é 2:':;;;§:s.;a§ "§'é:s::;%_§§a:,%.xéi:2cs:s;»:3:~;a ii 2a§a:=e i§3s:%;' :;*2:isc:._;»;s:€s:;2§ :::és;%:.:m:s: aim: :§:»::x {Em ms: 3 , §;:_:_€>xa 0% aim: ;:c:;a:,~;u§ §":;:a.-éfigzj: m;m'§::g:% 1%: ::.§;'%.;':::;E$C<§ é;EE?{£ iiéa: 52:5: 1233}. 'aim :§%;CLi>%;::é§ uraa»; §:;2§;:%e:~»;iz2;:: éééc ::.i:.::;<:;:>;::a;i 39:} gsééiiéiéjé :'a:%E::°:::':::s: 1:: §i7»;.?,; :3; ifia *§2::}V Ema? :%:;z2%é::a% 232:2: 32¢} Eézzag :V:':;:z,i.: gm}: £1 éf >a§;:%:,=::';c:'::s 1:: the céfccz ééuzé Sm: 2§Ca:z:2§§S23§§ '=2;;::~; a>c::;:.x%::::;a%§}; =.€.~\~.;é:%:z5: ihgsgzz 3:363 ::x:gé:'ss:»;%;;;: EVE 222% 32:: mag: §"%C§E}<:3 §§;:z';:.~«:r~:c:;§ 3%, aka: E22i2é_:~§}:"a>"
3.cw;«:cai. fizz: E;:2,:mcd <£Oil§ESCi vmzséai' iE2s:1"<:§1;>:":: >ei:E">z1':it--'§Ei;:: AE.é_ik;-e{:;E_s§ ' inc <.%:mg.<:mus E0 p:'<><:::c:;i gm ms a:x%<;ic;2*c'C=" t'z;'§1§§Cl']§3{§ }7>jf%?j:c i'2'i:r}i;iEj{» mesmbws <>%)i.?1c <.%c<;<:21;s'<.:d in 233:: effect i§2a:i5E"aé----.3x';2s: 'm:i's:.5; §x2.:2*;':.sséa:§.
the :i<:cL:s::ci ()2: 332;: oihtsr hzznxsi. 1%1<:'--%.f;:§E'";.§iaV hé1L1'iiC§éC.§f';{f'~Z_;§ Em" iéiiai ii. is we ;2c2:::>;<:<§ xxéso 3322:? ;sI'§'<n*s:E'1c.gi s;§1cE'§;':'i*';::V3L_§§' v»/;§;_\-_ p:'<_>1ca:'§Vz':"2g;ééci'. in 331::
z:bsa:::cz: 1:121:31» a:;<: :2 i::V1css::s 3:; :Ai:é:*%.:":j'Ls'i'%<:e; Li'°:-->,{_:'fi.L% :31: ms ciesaaai ivmij; :2? me d<:::<:a:;xicd._,%:«'wizld nifl bx; _éV:':i:*é4i.7€Vi':{i_:;%.:4? {Ft EICCIISCQ, Eh: fag:
mat the dccca:i§::d 522:1 'é:'i+§:§__§:ni't£[¢:i §é':;£__<:'%;ic' E3j» 'iJ:?IE5E§i])§i}j.§ }T>t)§S§'>I1 xmufai zmi ziiso §£:%{&":'<:.A;%ii;"m;su:;é'i;"s1fin:Viémt iE*9:C":i:L:::Lzsc:E Ezzid E:"x:si§g::1c<i Em' M: g:c;>zmn§1' .s~;{i%cic§c, j§'§1a: §'l4CE.§}*z':v:«%_.§ 23a;§<:r ézirs ;'m>2::c:§<>:1, 23:21:
E %'>::§z';; sc1'é<';aV2.~;§§"~V:%§§§';:.;§¢;.i i3"é'v_i2§'":"'§{?:':»' EEK: §;:9i%§}V :2A:c:n§1:;.::":~; '.'ii3iE%é§ 322:1 £3232? '-1:2 a ";3..i'::f$é{2_%"23gT%§iééfi E3322: §'2{:"'a;2';:s. ::a:ss-, i:':<.3 %2;::*az;~;;~;s:*:u:;': aiiéii Ema? diiz cm 321:; :,i*%.;;_:$é::s;i V Em}?:;:é' (§s;;é:'§.: ;
%::;::*:2:::% :::>:::2s:::% m>z:§s;§ i::§«;<: é,§:%>~; <:m:§": Limazzgié 83:: .;'cz;se:fi§.3§::g{V{>i'332:: {k;>m'E %s::§=;>22* gzéai azazaaziai §}i'}§i'E'i am. éiszsi ;§§?;é%'§, %%':>:2.2 {Ens £i§;.%£ii 'c,§§§{.§§'Ef4s azzgiaic $73} 32%;: e;2;;>:23;,:§;:§;2;:m zmé %}2R/'E in --% is nu ».
V 'if:§ié§c:°%;2§ zf% ii_'§s3EEi::: £13 Eésfix' 33:: c.§<:;2§%V2 ii} 5.2:; zitiéiazs :22: 333:: 92%;': 0? iiiif m' 6' 'k. V, r'3«~«r.~ » A3-r« . ,: ~5 3'1; 'r4 .» ~. «-w:
;%éJ;':.i.'xi3£§. 2%: E325 amt: Easmi. in:;::.: :3 aim: ;'a:asma.: $35: EEE2, .;::.:u:_x:::§ Z i*E3}§ "
xaéziciz 2232:} cx%.a:n<.§ Em Em }~c:;::">;. E325 i::§:'fia:21 xayzis hgzzxfs a>~z1_ Q29 ;?:'<3;=4£::ii'{§{>;'3 Ea: cséaéifzéisfz aim %§%a:§"c ax;:;<; éi ;e:'a>\%22z::i:: <;:a§<.c";-£§ "-.§% 2v;: Cs3Em':1§5'.5%:>%E £3? wiciziaz E35 the: aiarccgiscci 2:: iha: i:':..$éig;:§AT::}27:L' }i::':+_i azixsizucm 0133:: ;1<;::u;-;<:d: ./Ks Li}I"Cii<§}' _g'>:T;§3:"{Aé:<;E'*:'>.m '§E'<>:j,n. {AE"iL' jx.'\.§é§§'«;:i!'§<;'C"" am 1'e.:::<>:'<%. apzm iron": iha: 1n<>tE':<::' M {Hui <%c;;c;m:d";.;;1c'§ §'i:;£1{i&"$§;n {E12323 was no <>1h:,::* §1c:'>eas;:'§3;':%_2:;1:i émf%¢a1i.g<§_;£§'2;é'§ §:cW<>:* aha: Sud :Vé:m:s:~+z:<1 3:1; E'::::";:;\;;~;:z*.:c:;§ E7} &I;Z'1éE :::;_§§:';zsa{:'L3_ on :Eia:'<i'<:c'<3;:;~;cd. E as find. 1312:': she had Ewen {§c>;<:1'1.;§§ E3;-V.«:§3;3:* _$.f2 §%:-":,'§_Ef\.VSfirzsizi :x:nda;:" IE2: i.,'i1'C§I}"1'1Si{1§'1£:C 0§ Z.E'1C"§}i:§"11E:}}V Bf'iI;}:3.,§iCCC£i'f§i3'§i~,¢;%»'C!§i"x'x itnccssiazg amjy SLECEE E1::m:ssm::z3%, i'5{:§'I3(';§'C: '§'7x"x§.:":>§§*i:§';-zgzfi .1_ivé';%1*aE'-jm;-:'c Enj:i2'éc:»' §i:s:;1::i an ihc %>oa§j;r as? §'Ei:.i'E§<::;xc:;3,;sc<€.
31%;: :;':'s~:3;L'-- iiuci:1gEii::"%E72:1cd in 'tin; zzcczzscai slim was 220$ E<E:.3;:%>E_:;%. §§§.sV3a:L*.i'§x::" §1;a::éE'~E.§ 5-ms» mmgzc % §<:'x>-;:::'aEs fix: &e:ca.:22;<,:.::'i. EM: §%'éji;E"i<fS b£:':°,g: '2:.:;§g:{ ii}; ;%§%:z,:c é>E§"§i:i' a§§:~s:> z:;::':m>: its: mEs:<i eéiéi' E3: v...' '«--.2§';;s'a iix: E"§":;%§.§.:f£' ms :.:::.i:::;<i2:'éa:;:} §Ei'E{§§E§f; of' mg Scxsigéiax €.7a:a:€ L, "
£0 ma: 2.-
Véxr §%E,§§é§é'i%£?i.3§f:§" éégc m;:2':n:;:° £23 2:é':§:,:%: £33: §?:::z%:e§V::*;:a;::2: E2:/3.2+ Esagga %?;':§3;':,~;:>;;é "E3 ;2;§.$é': :§:':«;i§c::é§za: as? 222:: 1, :>:::€:~; :~<:§::::§;2;V'::::: in :;:§a:::§'3%i§3g: ;-;a:a;%2 §'%§'%£.zf§E?.:' , j»%;3£.::: 2%}: ;32mé:~;%*;:'::s.::2i :.::as§:::' ::a;:*%;2£z: f"4;s::;¥.%:>:%;~; 22:': 2233:. ;~+£z"i:'sé::c:s§. %§°%;%::, .§é}(:é £33'E§";Cv.§}}( 'f,s§C%'E c:~;22:%:3E%:~;§"2::a§ ?:2;:;'a:'::1:.§ ;:§% §'::2:5»<.<:s§3;2h§<: ai§a:::%.*2i c;;:;s';::%; ""'"\ V{7a:a:§§ mass <::;>m*%::a::::i zzimzgé Eézc ::é':§";EiE":§%é:'\i§<>E'; :2? €133: :>§E1::é:;:: :32 £3: %:;1;»;§:~; 2:? :;x%2;Es:é<.:e.% %:§%;E% §'éZ?i'»Z Swag: 2ia;'<;a:§3%:*:é bx $2": aégxa gs? E mzaéiasg' iiéa: ;:g;p::;:E §E§:::§ 13;' ma Féézgéc sccémég :.::2§2;:2::;c::2c:1: 82;:
2 '"2 ;"2:a:2%r;§2:m:;":% is ::<"::; 2:? 21?; §3"§£'a§§"; i!§§2éTi%'%§C zmaé me 52:93:: is, ;%§>§1E2%§::«:_::<:.¢ §;zs<>E1:::' 2:: tbs: zxppcgi Eziesd 53>}; {EEC a::::u:\:::<i is s<m<:;:§:'1<::fi;»_%E§2' ' :§L:g;' ' :"<.:;:;»eu;1:s" sizizicd alum ca 'zha: gugccpiznmc ejxfEEC'*c?:'i:i':::3<;§:
'D - .
the <>%2s:::c::s ziéfcgcaé '~:a;:_~t. no: <;mi:"cE}V szi§f§Ea:'§*e;m is} i'é;<.é:1g§:..§:<.>:27L--.;§ £3235' ::E2;:2V'§.;c>; azgaiiilsi zzcaszsscj bi:}(>§){i 2111 "1~+:::z;§hE<: ;i<>L:E:I_.T E5} i.E";;:%; 'ééasxx 0! {he mz:u:.::' {he :»'<:n!.<:m:a: i:i2'{>g>:s::xi ;:::*:":'hs;§'::<fC§:sc<i is #19; ";is'id:. The: ztmmmi 0%' iifzz: '£3222? ms: sj<:;ms.i_E'c(i Eévy'%::1c_.;;iit%:;is;{i is aiézrcicd to ix: r::i"umic<.£' W
2 2 .
1% "V itgsiécci.' 22%