Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Keroo Waloo Bhalerao vs M/O Railways on 24 October, 2019
} OA No.l TU/207
MA No. 252/2007
cennected with
O.B.No.1091/1999
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
MUMBAT BENCH, MUMBAT
OA No.2 71/2007
MA No .252/2007
connected with
O.B.No.1091/1999
Dated this Thinsiey thedi day of ficinbesa, 2019
Coram: Dr. Bhagwan Sahai, Member (Administrative)
R.N.Singh, Member (Judicial).
{Applicant in O.A.No.171/2007)
} &
me
$4
es
sy
2
<
} a
rt
cy
Choy
fy
oe
font
st
ree)
acdhnana
PB
iy
o
my
we
bet
~
OO
fer sO 0 Bt
$3
a
Mo
th
oe
fote
a wm mm
"
Ry
wt
mo oF
an TS
&
co
mo
» Gh bee
r8
2)
fo ++ 2
ct <3
ib
cr ono -O.
Oo
tH
ee
4
fee
ret
a
ER fs gi fet bh
Go
eM ee Co
oo
i
¢
pe
Wa
{
Cy et
i
ft
$3
@
v3
. Applicant.
i By Advocate Shri R. PB. Saxena }
ro Versus.
Ze Divisional Railway Manager,
~ ae ee ca oe
Central Railway,
Bhusawal.
. Respondents.
iY
2
7
1/200
OA NoA?
MAR Ne. 3252/2007
connected with
O.A.No. LOSL/1999
. Applicants.
3
be ht .
cog 3 ,
wn 4d * Ad cited yok
wo OF Mt Ct oo SG te end
i ee OM 6D ip é MH
: mw SG tS BE 7 Oooo aw ny m4 B cy aoe
ws Oo a $4 SG et ' 8 mp cf Uw
Mi GI Dek ef B ebony & hk Gs 3 dO
a bg + OB ot by 4) o " a 5 cs i Oe ed
oy % Get ue we bs Samer: am & ih 3 hm ge
g PED OG Lt @ : rt ed 4 on Se
Gh + @ « £0 Gy GH -~. m wm oc > Word te ood D
mo ky a UW ©) Qe «w« 2 oO . rf Ta @ Ba ts
. mo a + MT oun A te a ema boa
a oor 8 a oeaan o 3B 2 ud Bs
" Os a ford we BM + oO « 5 ia | ,
> OG > wm OS Bt oy as for GE tA ad
4 vod w to bd WO in rf modi mt Bs im
Yy n WC ef a oo et O Bt oo» ort uy aft TOG inh sed
L Bs re @ Db Om Ueuy Ort oo» bb L oS * mt
3 $4 OS O G 24 OD ih GOP ed gt ot
w om Qoerised | Se hE ow Wa Beck he ro tg S dos
.. SB oO oS oo Ow mow et © Bo A rd
@ et td oe BORG oh OO 3 9 HA Ww iG et ra 43 6
Gb ab st @ 2 O CG 44 be td oO oo Deg [2
oF ha in ved Gok 19 : BD om wy fa Dern iw 5 tm 44 (0 wD wm
o poo ya we Gy Gs ay St go we "bh HO
0 OG = { c mt C coe ee RE 2 OO ek mt Bs
9 6 @© 88 S22 60 B2U@ m7 &@ 2 OO dea a ri Mord ret
w Pt Mord CI & Oo hod oe eed EO Yost a Bo 4G sa Dw
a : ym 43 Ee a) Ge Be Gs fa Mma Oo Om We DPE f4 03 fa
iG by,
Pt sae i
tt o » . a * '
~ 'ot cs oq ws ad ot on
tad
OA No.17 1/2007
MA No. 2252/2007
connected with
O.A.No.1091/1999
LWA ¥ ft , Chbat : BDat
... Respondents.
{ By Advocate Shri V. 8. Masurkar }.
Order reserved om: 12.07.2019
Order pronounced on: ty [O20 49
Per: R.N.Singh, Member (Judicial)
i. We have heard Shri R. PB. Saxena, learned
counsel for the applicant in OA No.271/2007 and Shri
3. M. Tanpure, learned counsel for the applicant in
eonsidereaed the Facts and circumstances, law paints
a. In the aforesaid original application
no. d7i/eoo7, filed under Sectian 19 of th
Reministrative Tribunal's Act, 1985 the applicant,
2 ' eee nt ten ~ 4
idew of one Shri Vitthal Digamber 4alifte nas
x
challenged the order dated 18.10.1999 {Annexure-A)
wide which the respondents have rejected her claim
for grant of family pension on the ground that her
husband wags not eligible for pension.
2
?
71/2007
f
OA No!
MA No. 252/2007
cennected with
O.A.No. 1091/1959
Oo
ay
id
&
eg
LY
43
a
ont
ried
Aut
Gy
e)
wy
fv
mo
oy
ust
cc
a
rs
&
wo
eon
oy
red
4
send
ef
a
orf
oy
%
4s
yt
of
ry
od
vert
i
ay
ot
ao
ood
Oo
Be
we HOS
Gg et gn
wed
; he
He 42 oD
pb BG
fe ib
a Met gy
BO
ey
a
nO 44
apf EG
Aut OY
oF TR
&
Jd wp
Cc a
G 43
oO @
tedined fy
ol YD
fa, fp 43
Oy Ge bea
mo, 03
wy
me om
rs Ot
oy
oS eed ed
Cy ed
eo
ved eed
+
Oo
kewl a
ye
tp)
BO «
oo 6
ved EDD ord
mp
(CMD xed
« Ky
dA od Ty
Drt G
wo» DO
4
Word ow
G os
mm Sa
yO ba
i 42 43
MW Go
3 OG
oi Ma
nh
on
43 ka i
Q
oeeny c/l =e
kp @
see oy Sh
ti
a
Gh
Kt
Red
4
3
4
ie
7 t Th tg % we = Ved rem ote G4 *
a 5 bs COG ow 3 5 Ot ms wD ted
aos m 5 ou a hy ke 4 es sed mee vd ~
agga 4 mF 4) yy a % a B & Bs
see EN + 2 a ° a c ao w «
ra RN ef Pm BD yO Da 4 TH oo
Ma ed ogy mo ¢ SO 's os 2 Oo 3
SU eG * Mo eh mo be . Rd 2
ie a EO " @ a rt $4 od HN eh 234
"i >. 43 <4 ae a a} wt e a td mS _ ce ie GS ..
f£ OO > "i cn + a * i : Se cs) % som
Beh 6 oe & B 5 Gf a & ae bi £3 1B ag 2°
OM ee oS ms mH 8 0 ow wh Ad Gow et O ae
oa 5 ro es ' bei « OEE eh A pL rd 4 8 a &
Oo 2 . gq) 5 ae bd an . 4 mop ot SN tae aa coe om 43 2
o : wd 83 ry et oo 1 a c o th bed 35] Ke x . en iG rae 3 3) rt ce
o ® C ut a . i «@ wo PEL mf wm) a i cs a EG
+ 4 , a | ra ,
wo Hog ms a4 G 3 Oo
© 6 4 @ + 0 " ci Bow
Ej ie a fon ant Y 4 4 es *y. eS
m4 a ort is 5 a uct i " CF a C te o
rth] i % cA pan 3 oO "@ weed & v4 & 4 O g
pd ~ Pa Ch o 2 tg & fa "e 4 a 4 a e a <# ra
t cs wet ; rs ' f3
wu rt 44 Q . os a 4 up pl Py geod mn Po Oi omg
a © fs 2 es wy 3) in 6B) ead a 47 OE ks
wy w@ y «i m aan 43 i 5 GL ay ct od ort OS TH
| i ie a %& iOBM leh OD wos
tac OH By cE : --_ ote
tee ty eh hog ui Oo os OG ane aie
£ 4 ed Ba ? 1). Sos ba a abe ey
*e @ a ~ ¥ "oe Hoo hog
42 bet ne we iss Q =~ OG
D ot te $4 ct 4 ee re a iw '0 oy on
w c = a a v a o oo Da. a %
x " vy @ 4 orf ate vor 3
ha ey rs hy Meet aos ar} ttt
wv a vf ad A 5 fs os : ~y © 43 8
al 3 ro wy be ° : % * ct 3 cy <p Qy A x ret
: a? 4 tea ® wi ved Fy TI iO aS) ca
mm i 2 3 3 a gt St Mea fo . ty a oF a QD a
% * pat eh O +4 o Gy oN ry ry CA &; CR Os hy 84 sed
at " t § tortor mid Ol rtrd ht BOW
ne el, @ 9 re ry Cy in : . 5 ' + yen w@ gs ps c
i o i a Ch, es "5 4.3 roe % wy fg os foe wt rf + ay Ms oD
iS 8 g i ce ret sed rl 2 et om & meted SO fF 4 GR,
* . ret so. . a aw
a» oF + ed oy ie fy n o Cy ed Pe mM ID ye CR pe
vu ef = 4. : s a RA on yo ae
¢ 5 & 8 a € € 8S Bim [sao [Sas lane
> 6 6 o Bo Bg O
. 8 Ff O "rd GM g Moats ' a
a 5.4 GO - Oy a 2 oS Bh et iN oy
2 Oy ui ca ut} Q oO ny :
applicant's
The
30
yg
i
OANO.171
MA No. 2252/2007
connected with
O.A.Ne. 1091/1995
i) wd tS G y ' a $4 s uw " re) @ ea } rf G4 tS
ny ng wy oO 3S 9 w Pe) ba AG oe @} £ 0D Se 6 o ie
4 3 red 42 oO 43 Xd io) 4 os Ad hed ved 40 3 i)
ns 44 ig 4d os as) ocd rs my ved 3) 43 ba
ae c ry w end ae ott w oo od oO ® Q a ct ca ©
e a % on =P " fa . . a Ra 0 a 3
co th 6 a oy t @ x ' 4 Gj re) $3 i
"AB gh gt
bf a + i ' be 5 ci ao CG fn
wot ~ B @ O or @ ty, isa) tc ce a 5 pa , a
mpg ek rh emp GS " ® 9 4 2
a A $3 Ch, Oo os mo Ae aly on 5 @ fy
. arf B w 4 jel me ge 4 m ua o sa ao wt Shad a
B yy ed oS ¢ oo & @ DB a Be O
4 a % ig gg i oe ie An e hd a 4
44 a4 wd a T oh a is & st " a o 4
: 3) O i au Gee Go Hey an moor Oo,
me ky TB i og HO Oh
2 i ond 3) 6, ed O mt e ' od a ved Q 5 ig
is "3 a Ch a os i be @ wed m4 i +3 a ha
. i . : "a a sect 5 Lad et '
fle ggt te Me Se , fe PO BR | "OU
ms a ard 3 a G 4 tt 4a PA 3 ce aa h yD
4 a . fee we a iM ) @ a bet a oa
fe we a iT 4 het o oO bey Bad iw 44 ut 4d
@ 3 '4 od i. aed a a en o 4 3 "4 gn
ot Y , : G ae cs te A ot mi Pa 4 rs Ce :
wa v o7 ed GS a3 a a ~~ ch hot oe Ba m3 = ; 4
u i rg ay q wv fea 'ed arg 4 fa a > i
ad os o itt as ig wv Gy : : rm Y
ns spe Shed -- o a 4 c w aon ia bo
we < 5 my ae a @ wa > a Ch "3
2 cA " a "5 : 5 gy @ mm ir 4 Ci ae « &
ba oO fe ed pik x a ' 4 ~~ ¢ ae
Hh is Mog ey eo
rt aM @ . 2 & sp re "4
«6 ay ~ 4 OQ ~ 3 ma a S o bo Q << . =
od M4 B hag © hi bet 4 ve a S ae ved ag ws
&
oe
2
at
wk
%
t
a
a
"
o
Bou
a
t
ae
ye
a
a
5
.
a % > : 5 og Sy Gps gg mgs
3 toes re " "je = "7 3 . ¢ 3 5 : } ind : : oF
egy ce 8 @ 8 8 Bw & 8B 9 fo x
% 2 iB cf @ et at sed w a AS FI "6
wD od i O Ch we 44 i ws . ved $4 44 4
.
4.
Y
en
oS
nt
hu
e oged Peer ody 3 baa oO ot ,
3g ~ © pp 8 on
6 ea . wn & es ws a
the
oy
.
he
reek one,
PPLE
ei t~ ay 43 sed ay eo AS fe o~ ~ ve
on e ma TE eg 3 wy Oy ee BI "4
ES oy ad w ea a ~ oo oct oy 4 % ct a '
g i oa To th N 8 O 8 Poe
we . mo . i 3 ' DB 6 8
5 ed mi > 3 44 re g me ee) a ved h vend
; caer od 6, snd oi B Shy oD coe ved ae red vA ©
Gh * 3 wo a5 . ey % rea) "3 ' wo eed ou Or c
co yd 5) ad} Be ut hy QB An . ne od (3 iy res a
© ry w ha fet m2 rR a) i Feed ~ a uy ms ce ne Ch,
OA No.7 1/2007
MA No.252/2007
connected with
O.A.No. 1091/1999
&
ub
vse
et
2
f
5
44
Lip
ons of Rule-
3
3
we
»
provis
bm
43
He
o
Task
rant
g
wd
orf
@
co
vend
eg
per
ard
6S
=
mnala
of
B
a
¥
nd
ar
rate
Che apy
¥
x
or
x
,
TA
&
+
wt
DO
SAL 4.
y
her
our
a Fe
as
athe
a
ioe
4
ed
and
nye
'
e
urpos
p
+
e
t
LOR
as
L,12.2980 as Cas
tL art
wee
4
pen
YAS
a
a
Be eat Re
owt
be
TO
5
¢
wes ye
FACS
ys
75
the
13
he
e
he
account
Wa
19.05.
ar
er
wa
URO)Y
:
+
OA No.1?
MA No. 252/2007
connected with
O.B.No.1091/1999
Met a 43 2 $3
Qa 33 ne Set Ma
of "3 Be
a 3 B
wy aw) a C
id tt 3 A é '
3 0 "i 3 6 EG ct mt Gaon Oo GOO @ x om
Ss £2 tn 4 ao i 4) SE i MoM OG Dor mY Ly
. m "ec Sa, to Pf. 2 Ls OO Be 4 A hs i a a 43 an is
wt wD txt be ved G pS " ib iy ky
OD ms : a 2 ke TY ce oa
" "4 , ao ' 5 iv a i a & ha 03 "4 ay gy He BD
wt BS wo Rg SO a ng hae wy DO A
o a4 eo od 4 Om eo Og;
Y} we 3 o j Bee 6 Boon ao 8G
fe o ' C2 n wm Ho PHS
" cas ' "4 eH waa Ay ,
3 bd i 'i vy oo "a 2 a Bed
® QO a 4 ed "5 EH at 7 OG
b vg byt a I gs i ro Nag
ng 7 ne 0 gt o ae
oO ia " " i Bo 4. Go
ka ca "rt he ra % *~ 4 St
ws ded f ae Ae gl fact ( 4
ee Gia a & OP ey &
a ah Ch me ™ Bost ag eb. io
as my , 1b OD Neg pep OK wt
eX os , ifs ea te 4 poy oe HW ify
us fo Lr '4 ct fy Cy ef @ ond
5.--(C® 2 ce #0 S ® gD s
_ | . 4 ga a on
ot Ol e Day Gay a my A o
WG me, al iy f} 3 54
o a 4 rt tt £3, % Sf %% © Q,
ED = oO G3 aon ig
a od ved ng OM u a i 43 ,
: 2S " a 8, hag : on
y ord " As ry Moe a Sil fi 8 G ga
Ho Gg " Hw Oh "GO OB ie fs 5
nn wm : 46 9 y a o HF
bed go te ua A bo Ok an 2 vq
® , & mm B OM POO , Gone . 2 gg "o
rr oy Gt RO SO ty ESE 4
: aS e ME Wore Qo Boot 43 Gk wo oR @ Es
3 Be 4 a a4 i oy g in 4 < Ou fy 4 i rat yt " M4 ©
ie 3 } " Q m w mo En am ot oe ot rd i) sO t
be ct c rd ay a Cds set s OO FS 8 HO COS Boo We g
"<i 43 a oe é OM ODM wm OO OM FM me ou me eo Ge Oy
4 -
ft y oot
o oy wy
Mo Go oS
th G £4 Ch, a
swf hey gS 1 +
> i e G sed a
cn as oa a a a)
OA No. 7/2007
MA No. 252/2007
connected with
O.A.No. 1091/1999
on
ea
Be te
Mm AY OD
a a 6
Cr AQ
3
ORDER
set weet aia M3 fey ha oy a Cg AF ce ba Es AZ du oy of no bg wv at 43 on B LELO + @ at mS wG Ee ES 2 4 com Q £3 ian gw is ro TY ty @ ay ty OD wh UF ort $3 4 ay BY mG my ted AY UG "rf G3 $a % Ey tS O yA B+ ay oon, TY mo @ rf SH
-s pm) 3 ved o ig, bated vp ent & ya = ve Howe Les.
4h seed " wf ved 42 gs fy ct Ch od.
» @ i "GO @ $4 ta w rd OA No.171/2007 MA No.252/2007 connected with OLA.Ne. 1081/1599 1D wn oD hs = wn * 6 3 a © " a wed ° as C3 "4 @ 2g " " vy rc : oy ro} cee] % Ls) ist Ma meef a "4 2 3 et c a a Wy g 8 px ea "eg re) oy cant ' " © po 2 ; ool WM uy 43 1 oe TH tH $s @ 4a » oT * & @ x me © Be od Kio CF OF tae OG ao o oO 4S oge o ved co bt it ad 44 "
vs Moc gf os mt ord Bey SS 5 Boo. 1B 5 2 Boe Os + "4 ee wry she ' - My & * , 43 tS 03 red IS 2 1s, ei! 3 is x wd Q ns iS @ OOM oy Ge mi a ne Coed $ 3 3. 3 it / & ey no. epee wed g 'eh ry £5; ts oe op @ ~ © a e oe @ fom gp 8 8 3 , UO mq od 'bef vd in te 43 a Bo ry 8 i FW 45 Py Dm " Om oe " 8 & " . uy "ef 4 > nr ded an] Ya 4 wed M a i c th i : a Ab 6k a & - '3 44 Pte f. fy AE ¢ . . ~ tn ne eee os CO 6G 4 | gf om og wet we M @ =o SSR Ht 5 Bo ors we 4 Oo Oy ms gy ay FR ty rt Gy 3 ay i ft fh. ra nf ~ C nt wd ' so yy AS ae a a o & 8 oo 8 co & vot 7 5 mage ON. TE <a $ . be 44 a m | Oo is . es 28 oH . wy OD oc ¢ ® es a 3 ao BH OB © ky C3 WB O44 Bou} me ao. & --§ » FC & B ow a ¢ G 4 Ty oD G La Y en 3 . s chad 6 a , ey ce tg Se fod toad £ 4 shed wed g % oy Mes a BO NO Ts Go 4 fo @ th ne by sed 9 w 4 om Te me Dy? oy ha too o Q % @ gv ri & ao Oot "OES, a2 og 8 @ SG % o3 veh ay res : 43 fs = Ct te, 43 Tey et Ee ford -O ion ee fey dae ES ref at DB cs te try a et 43 Sg $5 uO es th Sg 'J i a babs e ved " rea ne fo 5.3 43 re ane xf . ae ty Se pny Ty ty OS Oy jae peo o oss C + ~ hb at Re . a) . ag bed BOR eed ty _ voor el o wc Gy a tr st Ge SB go. GC oe ea BD & Bow na 3 O 2 ne Gh sry Q Cr ory 1 by GG . e t set Oy at .
gM votre Ok "te 1 omy @ Bm a a Gog ot; OS © ae bg.) mM ey Cb Bp UO o 4 8 OR woe Boe wae Ge se ab uh & & "a foe .
S ~Giease Ee soag Dedgduc Voges Haat he Oe lg 4 BO ah 4d ong " yO fy Oi Ge OG See TE Oo bok a A a; c y j © , ' @ a4 os a @ «ed ei a4 wt ie ee) © a) $4 oS + : s ' i ord » wD wt i iN a) xe i fog . wi bs ri © ee a "
DOA No.d 72007 MA No.252/2007 connected with O.A.No.1091/1985 Li io @ WD is) wm wy ti as i) yoy ord Q c * ~~ + mG % ai . iat hy Q aS KS gS 2 55 or og tt Be a an "et o w O @ & a o 9 43 $2 rs o +e nm ci is g 19 os o rf £4 ae 43 2 Bet ved 3 Gang at hosel 4d a) a " ; 8 so Dy - Ha . on o ea wD 43 tpt "2 44 ¢ ; "3 4: 4 " cm WS * O A % orf ay 43 a 3 : oo 3 - by ss Bi, of ' i ' : is 4 if u vf Gg o et CF - MK rt wi oO @ a D Ab 44 Gt a ant tod © @ 28] ao -- 8 «7 @ es dood BD ¢ me BO gy « mom UUM ORD i. BOE ee ee ee > ao is 4 w mt Sel mn OB a "rt fe Ann oO ns! i we a _ . 42 @ & a S Feed yo nm rot oO as in Pie B oo Shs ) fy a Ch 5 . L et a . rd a ; i be Q a a oy mS eg A w fe Pe ie ; g rd @ = ; 43 fm » * ¥ tobe raed abe cst ; hb. ~ * 4 v '- 7% Gy 2 "i S & 4 | G80 8 G . 6© # Co ge GF 8 & 8 7 og os G6 @ & , 2 | rh , 5g ca r OQ i 43 us 2B 44 Bg M4 o 4 "5 oy a 4 4 © Ww c et es i . ved ww o a , C ws ey fe my 6 44 1.3 oe g ond et a) wt +h hy C4 m4 Ps 2 So 8 G@ » F & by mn BR mG OB wi ® o 86 "" Bs: GO yy 0 rn So O tm o , 0 LH yy G Q n G ib " oi ay to rt hy Pe "| 3 m3 @ a ret ay 9 " a fe pO Che Dy vd a BS y -- et bd ee a 5 a G oe oon Dy, be * a a go 4 ® ¢ th '4 <j Dy oy yd 4 "4 hg i$ wm 5 ot "3 cg wo G ky os ct ay ae wy i ed Q eS s o oo & 1 " 44 ny, oD a B i Ei re 3 My ip yh ct 0 os eG red "4 G mt « ° rt o a 65 a D ft} " by in i mf , a os 43 4 oD a ' ze ot i c a 44 R 4 i 43 @ sod -- a wt y isa i Me . uy iG et 3 om see] :
"cl L m + <3 x te wy a @ ~ £4 oy me an m4 a 3 Pa € % ® ¥ ot iy ot 6 red en i ni us a o o Mt * a ie as & G O a ~ ryt von : . @ : a seat Q . «3 a @ wed oa mo OO «a be ri o 4 o- ad th a ras + one Be Se ord ce oy ree °C "3 rl wy ' x w ee G 4 "4 ct Ld ey at we = as "m4 he ra ' wh 8 A 4 % met CO mg 4 ny q . ' G 4 ay 2 rd 4 oe tts ae $e © Dp cB 4 reg sha oe 4 uy > "rg . O aye t : cl 3 ' os * BS. t i ee J ~ : rd Lp rd ab o my $4 om 4 od ~~ se #8 3 ) GM rh g my OC ~ B * a : aye t 2 ~ ' 3 Hog Y 8 . Bm 1. 8g 4. & & "= «= a2 *% w 8 ww 8G "1 } 9 4 2 » ~ ~ Ke DAS Ne ¥ S re GS oo O <I ot Shs a aad fs oo 5 % a a ! ie Pa i eS : ct ! ® wy S te oo ~ = a ih fy tk cme o bee a4 Sh ; -- c md o if cp CG cm : 6G J ved 44 et bd © a be o cy : G ed nm 44 tn we 44 fe OS oj G a 5a s hay ths =H op Ls wd pot mn S ae m a, et in 4 od a v $3 ad fa ye ea roi su ha 43 ie ry "| so O 43 os Be mF hm et aaa awa at > mo Be a ot gt id hg gc 8 Tg cS & ~ Ee GK, Gort wi Goo os 0 @ 2 oo , g ba os ns eh G 9 aq a s wn a C ; be ch t St ref " Per ceed cc Go 4 be ae The 7 yy aed @ eae ® rd "
4 - od 8 G@ OG PP G&G Ff £ ® GS & «© "+ 3g «@ 2. my a oO © he} ha os YD ae a o cs my x Go Ky a @ ws te $y 48 ee iv cP n on Dy 2G be see oO 13 4d 2 ef 4 ire Ss sf a 3 m a 2007 ?
?
QANoTTI MA No. 2523/2007 connected with GO.A.Noa. 1OS1L/1999 a wD $4 43 aD Ww & bad TL = ae cH ft 3) oO i) w oy , G oe a ea & tS AS Aa 4 yD CO s q a. Se AG iB i reed ss arf $4 te) yok 44 he ed B ft i G3 ch wef 3 shed ved @ $a 43 "Al Sa 3 SS oS x ae) e % hey 43 ng yt ce; G 4 4d 43 at on Ce aw a @ wy oo CO "ed md cee a 4 " S Mi ew x ay roe gen hd eed a Fea, " ne bed " , / od Goo Gm FO Bg pg ' " BM G&G ~ O wm Foe & it weed n hy vee oS Ps od a3 et bs 7G a "
o gp £& @ 8 Bg a & eo @o mm 28 Bo BO Bes 3 4 6 xa Dy m4 He bin vcd ad ves a ee i % * 2 4 4 Q re) O, ot 16 e bd a G3 o Oo a 2 $2 oD a, ® Ys 4 Hoo Ge + + thd B ro ees ¢ G ' a C a bog S B Gi % 7 es -- jet by x4 OF at se " +4 o o ay OG rag oi Ch , f SY - hy o rae oa a es a , wa ay a % a G "ge fa » i y & o 6 a ve 3 my 2 ; i o - * * 7 nr o a © 98 a vo g gg 8 D a ty : aed ares a ve oy 4 2 2 ke 7 vd ; "4 . fe 6 . 44 Gg ' ef, 6 ws ued 43 boy '4 w o io 'G oO ¢ , "4 < $4 * Ae w 0 " : 4 n "rt & uo ved of 4 . * o 5 o '2 ce rs at "a om ree 3} ; 4 ¥ 4 eo fo. ne ES eS re y wf ex a as eek tied eo be a @ . wt 3 ree} ce rt a 13 ok veer fn yee 2 "fk re 03 a ree art eg ae fs 3 Oo <3 sof oe O q 3 oy inf ds a3 the a ba @ ky GS re: eee 3 i - eo cw Tc & vA a Q G "ws a wu 4 ne! its ted o Ot) ord G3 od ' ted ei : ' 2 es iy 4 0} G 4 ved "4 of 4 , z . 3 © reef vst 3 g Oo vet % fi es a aed . £- .. $ ¢ , 30 * és F ~ we wo eS o a 0 wy mB y a Cs on ct w eg oe G3 bs 3 ha < o i Sas Es a er o * bs G6 8 @ © § BB HS yy BF 6B & u DB eH 1 ® fo G4 i SE gy 3 ¢ we o 8 bs 4 iG ' 4 G th a a @ 5 v @ ia ® att a on i a in : F 3 wed if ec a fs as iA od 3 of rod 3 re AS 4 6 KS bed + i} ; ot a A od ced 3 & ae ae a x ~r4 { By ; a wn + ts ' " M4 @ Ep i Wy gS G B i oO & i G i 4 OS Oo mh Be fa a, ba os ¢ i 3) as Aa od te he oO by a 6 , * SP aed "e 5 Gt es ies % a 3 <7 « 3 ky ; be nm a a u gy ca ol Fo cy BD 3 wn ° vf 3 * "3 on gt hd Con oe c ' ed Q isd et a on Oo vi wt aoa 1 wor a5 sod Ci 3 ed c ' od uw oN orf we or rae we 3 as a os me Ss 53 ks a of * uy 2 uo is 43 f mG i Cs wt . ' ' ° - S < wo os 3 orf 4 ee © 5 Z ; ot n @ ws or o = at ted ~~ oo E "A G C4, a wm oh 9] iB 4 ' % w i C ;
a u ee f ° i194 3 » G > bd oy . eo) ase4 tat wed wt 4G peo ee js i ort 8 Os o> TS ky a So ceed Ad fas wD a o Ou tS rt o res D a td wy oe Ma fe i ~.
Of ot OAN.ITL MA No.252/2007 connected with O.A.No.LOS1/1999 he c r ake ze * a hy $3 if :
Ad
a) "of Py i 4s SB my Oo ® (yp <4 @ %& hi my Q, ' hi} iy a ra be Tg cs o SoG D 43 oe fg Sy Oy ba rf Bh weg lg "rl uy rs U fry td b4 oy £3 pm +e} by 45 Bd vet C43 oO G uO © Sy we € Kd "r S, hb acd rd oD ae oe whe 4 ba Tey TS te Gy %3 Ae "a ie] mi RY i dy 4.3 qi 43 AZ cel % ae € the Md 3 @ ry @ on 4s a O ay vod ORS kyo Et oy @ a wo $d. see} oy iy 23 hs 7 @ o 4 i OO a i oy RY vend $3 Ee @ et 4} 5;
at ORDER gned LDU save 2 ce Bey Ate meng nes.
vr "mg By 0 rd ty As "rd ae is 4 * sf h, Spt "ry wrk "4 IeaLr a * £ f Ca Ss tested t ay Gy OY "rq Eg reg CS fg < KY RS et Ay f+ 4 @ G sg} Bs ae i aa On oy ed m4 i As "+4 bg Qo 73 7 é { a4 OA Nod MA No. 252/2007 eonnected with O.R.No. 1081/1999 14 ae) o a rl, aD i aw he Gh A fo % S fl, & a ow, 3 wed nao C3 hy wet 2 TG ed $4 ft ed 4 o 3 gh ai @ 44 4? ae C3 seed i © a) sod eg i u 4.5 a 4 he OTs WP eh 2 3 eed : % ' fe } = a at Gb, Pt} fe "ak ) ; 2 . vo Ee Be wa a ® Go 8 gq G @ * oy " cs 4 om r 5 wD a a cy en 6G B 7 rod 8 wa £ u to i £5 ef a won Aa rod rs +4 ved ue vet a 5 x mh AG ' Fe ' G as © a a oy g voi g iD i m4 + ct wey Cr * DF os 4 4 oH i it ey oe 7 ~ weed mW wt OD go ES Get Os a To, a = @ % @ fa , rf ~, G id 4 m , fe Nl 3 Geog yy 43 Ba $4 * ig 3 re ts ro oo " 2 ha wy q my 3 hd g 2 oh $4 ~ ; ae FL, o rz x oO © - ey. "e e oO ' ot wo 4 om R & Tek, G , ® ' i w a O . "3 - § @ & GC 8 m 8 wg & 4 3 a J 2 bas c4 ee _ . a a tye "a o 3 wa % 4 Oo & a ¢ 1 a : \ 42 Ba ar A ne wy bo @ jd w vet at aa tA . 4 7 oj fon co an . ei oe art hn a a ras) . mS wD ve syd oH os rf e i y As ved ra tj te . be eft wy m da Bo EB S a ng D x . rs Oo a ot Gi oD 40 noe & , 5) ° 4 * ; a m a ed 4 ° a ol a et ei : e 3 43 Rs a £2 ss rs a Oe S$ 2S & . » . v4 ce ~ th 4A . 4 " iy 5 6 @ oo & a Oh as n vet g 3 43 Oo y 5 wu a ns a . "4 = 4-4 i % od mf ard as) 5 me 3 oe OE mo Sg, ey BR G as 5 w= rh. ee % bey 4 oy N a Ad a SA % a S ity "
yy Sy ie a 3 er LOS es Q vy 4 kee & Q 3 a £ a wh oo ey . 1 OU m 2 6 > "6 ie a *t ' w CQ ; Gy red eo we werkt Pa aD a °
-
e y a n 3 ss sey , :4
~.
& Ch nh ae h cs > : teed wy 2 7) ¢ at 44 pay nt &, ae) we a & tr . bet 20 @ 0 % mys w bed Ra wd a 43 % Et co + rt 4 so td 43 w or 5 by Oo rm my OE a ed ce ved G id Chy a = «4 4 MN on yet g Oo a LD Be a) , C a3 Oo et @ . a ra na + ri on % ay "S ue and 44 Ag ie) O a Ad bt im co 4 4 . nt a Al ay a "rd in a @ rt . * es c het iG o . A ad wt Ch ty eo: > ° 13 et wv Y ui GQ wD M4 wo ued « a 3 o he r © ri oS EG Oy x bed Sb oO vt C3 Be ce 3 Oo $3 is wt we ~ oO is , Oo & OF w w ® tht Co Ah ref an AS o a z a iG r " .
KD 3 hh "4 "Ht im Ad MPO oy ow 57 a St 0 e be OU - & ) OE S s eR ; a o 2 es , eB o a GG md F "ie a? ran 3 Ed Rory mo q ne a uh mG a ey a ca Bom ff ; 2 ip i oO - Ae a ai hs cs oy 5 Ba o) ° * oo C3 S te nv cB uy 2 ct : "et é hd OC « ee , cL 4 ou 2 1p Or os os Oo ~ ba veh Bs woot a Ts aged art . "rs o 4} me GT % oO a : ; es Ro te ay OO Ss is +) a fo mo gy Bs a ; ie : art a ' % a a b> 4 4 "7 0 he a) 0 wy ce: seef wD Qi ane a4 a3 wi i £2 ; ary 5 Es 3 9) a # « ; xp "es te a) ¥ : 4.3 4.4 Seg by an OES ree ; 4 4 ¥ "4 wu 42 wp Q ry rt 6 oy ices 5 Gi pa ¥4 e " £ oy a "4 '4 rg os vy > i ms . fos gent Toe LP O a a A A o 3 sed fh
- 6 tS a eon at ort Ey 19 ta rh te 8 bes , = zn ra i me 6h 73 & cl ER @ ce 4 hg a a) "oe ga he 5 on ye 54 w «4 B rh sch ogy 4 fi cM o oe g ct Anes) "4 ra $3 wp 4 . on rd & ged W g} ri 3 2 ae 42 0 ba 5 ~ * 2 c Bo i Ae te ee Vo ' a " z 6 De Gh Ss nh we ved % : * vad " ' O €. Do a c 2 O xs . ERS BRR SE ot " 6 8 BO fe £8 :
@ . : age ed 2 23) Cty rs 8 sa os ag ay oy f th O,A.No.1091/1999 1/290 s oe OANa. I MA No. 252/2007 connected w:16
o mw Cc © oo 8 8 & 8 @ mm @ @ Oo 6 8a OQ rd i cs Q im 4s ard 43 of ey a id we w "t "3 ; - es me eed cs ( 4 dae oe Op tt 4 F ogg 3o , 8 & 8 B89 @ 2 of @ EGU Ga oC a ot a8 gq B&O FS on, ol! a os eh ord wt vr oh Ut mos id 5h ceed o re - a @ a - " hope at Wort SE et 4A 4 c c 4 e gy RO kee ( e ge Shs og 8 KR wy ° 8 " aa - 5A ny e a ® "Ta UO rs aan 4 ea @ bn : a fs sy 4 4 ; . . * a i . eee whee fe @ BE a oo v a ® org sed o a "i 2 ot ont ki "4 ch «5 43 me h, rt ge Ao i wi 7 weed a e rd 8 i BS DE ys Bi YP 3 phy (3, Bos os ; oo S$ 6 yw oO Be he EE ey 9s ome M my © hak «3 ty Ht Bet a @ a Road ved ag 1» BO bg o Ch o @ Ce rs m4 be "+ &e OB, © ® 03 ® Gg @ wom ao og 8 in 7 a Q . oe PO ed OD Des tt ved 3 aa os $4 o KG re is ed gy ot ph fis} tse cod re ae ty « BO spot O A 8 8 Se a w : : he fs we » : yO" gt ogy Ss : a a a i G 33 Choe cy te 0 at ae a 1G Q w os cc '2 i » nm ww @ i eg ht ya wi wes ' & 42 oo i as i . " mh 4d Se on BoM 4 a ot 4 4 "a ic 'cS 2 4 @ Y O @ Cy a ry v ie Ch pet i is bd iy Pe 13 a <i 3 or s i ba é ae Sd y Boe 03 Go Ess os me 3 we sed 5 cm 0 43 mn UP Uhm ® wy 4 dd ey : a My ' Mog GS om 4 gy PS a 4 4 ra % o re * 3 4 oie & Gk @ @ ty w is yh oe H - & ° QO ¢ os : Og Bee tie 2 Sos o 8 oes Ue! Se Boog Bo wg RG i 3 west Boy S ® wg & we ft om 5 oy He i) a . a " ° b "RB OP yt wn obey PO fF 36 Bg « a re & 0 wa 4 OF ' "4 fo ; x H Fy FQ of TP SS oe Ra & g ma my @ g wy SL Reel ~ es 4 @ @ : S - #4 a3 es a Zo Ot Gort ie Do % Q Ge Bt Oo cs e., .
ved Way ga Eta Govt os BY tee Cy Bee ra w wo Sto 4 e dogs "4 oo wt gerd te Ch eg 2 es Ks 4 ' rl he s 43 rs v w ga a ft 8 af oe " g@ 8 & 3. 0 ye 5 toy oi bj 5 & thd "ey 4 ny iw 3 ry ES a 43 Sa Hi *, re aon i = 5 5 oR os " Th Ps ard 1 Gg MS sy os me " 2 7 0 Oo cane % ao OU « Ave et a og) 6 6D Hoe O 8 a Borted do Ut oat Dae pb Of 4 Soh og Cy rl n oo rt ae Mort ® © ome n~hB&@e 8B YS Gj Ve Ds bey os i © DFS AL WM eed WG Cy eto et OC ep a ch a z oe 3 TD 43 Pt & oe OG et PD oO Be go OO ~ & wb 2 co a G D 4 m4 a I 6 « § a a , @ 5 " : of Q u rf sy we mg ian i oe | Sort Oo 3 oO 43 wy 44 pe ® Ds 3 + 4 44 ie Ch a fs En . ce @ og id o we tied w@ et ' wt aed a Heed {23 hea 4 QQ Mt Gh OA NU? V2007 MA No. 252/2007 comnectad with O.R.No.LOS1/19a9 ee ~~ wink St 4 : ~ . Ln oe os ot ee ee, regulations which already stood superseded by the a - « ap de ' sey oy wee 1 TEE contrary to relevant extant the Rules~-i993 and also x -- i ¥ * £ me eye tt cat 5 Va mee law settled on the suodjgect. He urther piaces reliance on the judgment of ths Hon'bie Andhra Pradesh High Court in case of General Manger, South Central Railway, A. P. v. Shaik Abdul Khader, 2004 ay (2) ain WR No.10897/2001 cated 23.05.2003, para-5 7 Se cone into to which a reference h as been made by the Tribunal. Para-20 of a Saas Face RTA A 2 ere J the Master Cirecnlar No. 54 lays down:
t "20. Counting of the period of service of casual. "3 ws pensionary benelits:
Half of the period of Service ' . ot bee of 3 abour (either than $3 hm 3 ?
poe ba ay fh pe.
5) aa UE amployed fter attainment status on complet e iy ' » o EO ip
a) rt iss} rt Rho fb by ti be emer! o 4 f + te hy «bg es . pode Oo oO fm fh pod a oy ts G. is) #8 Q ye combinucus service if it is followed by absorption = * Ke oes ok ct eS Py th hes o @ es Wo re S rfequiar £ ps 3 th ree ba i O @ het Ke ft ry ed A a DB ocr co ot OG be rh we be oO @ a es ros Fae Q oe O oo dat , mm oO m & ch rh hy (D ory (b be ot io} yD uy B ry , OF ae D po at oy o if c o wu ca a t 7 o f th mot mp 1 or eke
0) oy f 007 a £2 1 i oe OA Nol MA No, 252/2007 connected with G.A.No.1091/1999 18 Lo lar b 3 S RS , 2h 8 wees S = e Tus £ 2 r abRrey rs! Me Ot Pt OM MB Oe mm mim: oO BS Mert & GW Wy O Ga, ont BO S02 8 Sb MOD OO EO ord et ced a Be we 4 ME 1 yy G OM 4 DU PP Oo of 44 6 rd ort i th Lo oe 3 OH Bolom Wg gy Os Goong OD ww oI yerd "ry hy "3 a ea bes oO vs a +c ths det ict so * i tet Sgt M4 oO St mH hae tte, {RO g te * i} a poy 8S "4 rey ed as £ GO wo aw @ eh og im le : he 4 og a t . wt we lk ty is ri R gt ret gg ed oh et Boek gg G} i SU og Lg ha ry Ooms Piao & hi i Qs go BBB Het Bort O Od 43 Hue Soe Yo bf 4 DB OG tt g a8 wee my ag ee EO Boge tm Soo om oO bn ® 3 © ie o. % PEM am @ oO, i AE WO he, B® age 9 Bo F he tH Cy My, 4 wu o4 ay "ES 4d @ al me 7 US 52 ty Ea 4 "-} ee A SOE Bo © og 8 OF bi Se Ly gy eo eog A & re ty OG i ar "dF 6g O vet Q vst it i a] ' io . & So Bs & G6 poo 8S ow BG oe om Cae eu emer, ag a Yay wt ry Ch wm" Peat Ged OO yard ae raced 64 tt Sa bs oe i tpt dy ae wa SG Oe Om ys be Bgl & yy Pa eT oS ww ca , My ref weed a os ta ag (TB iG ord & 4 Oy Op Oey, 4 7 wv a8 has ge WE ta ey tt + Bo ordig Bei Gg Ny a * Qo oO bE a ed Fe ay bz Cs LL Bors «a Die 2 PG Los it et 42 ed 'f 1 Wo 4 @ G68 SS 8s Da On WO mb TAO O Oc rod O = OH ms © , ch BD) set cS Ed Ob ed ce BM a ap wom g 0 Med fe 12 Ms ey & Bs art Dogs Oh vey C3 Se pe O bm GD peek We Ls fo OF 0 O 4s rt WG af icrt ee 4G 6 Ov d oc OG Gm M gO 44 wR EHO @ 9 OM BM oS a :
Oe Owe Eo Ob O a4 CoD OG wm ceed cd ay Dos som OD Oy yo 5 fh @ U4 4 Oy GO Me 1 ty 22 Qed th Doty «2 a ms OY TH Os cpoepord Gop eh bE hy "
we EOL OG ef a ec m ed Ue bE kD ord od et 3 oe OA No.l71/206 MS. No. 252/2007 cennected with O.A.No. LOSI/1999 eo <2
9) 4 bef G AOPMU OH ~ gO Oo ti Hg trai md a ti be DO oe OH . 4 feo SOO GM Gg O 8 ic OF BG oO 6 oS a a SA SPA OG 4d OF ad Ee CE ard ho gy SM" SS ( Dow a a e bo mo MG bd gory KG ™ OR 4 Dy 44 he f 4 Hw ES nme te G 4 Bo go gq 3S . 3 , 4 ot ye - tet or i a nr ae 4G ay @ oo 90 24 G & Oo & BOM wT AA ek ee ay etre gO Sy uy ae a « Wap wi Geo 4d Zi QO M tz * "yy ~, a 4 ne @ at @ Gm OY bsco a % Wk pond e eu eta gee FS a goat GOT @ oy ay . - a Sok Gye" BS eS SRE Bu eo Mog fa Wm a 2 O ry D gp Xt yx & Oo § Bop 4 oO AD ae PR ge ey ie BI Boo fe my OO rt tM "
' 3 BEY om i © Oud SE gh OL gent o ' A Wok ¢ Cm a, > Te Boke § Sm "Me ug Oo Bo oy YB fl a 5 BS ot ow a oP? pm OD et et YG D qt a AO am fon Oe eg Og ns ¢ ct gy FRG e 3 5 te og 8 a ' Oe OO sy, no Sb et ag be tT oy & Dag ee da 43 Ao Bo o mf "gg em OO" Cw Og f @ - 13 2 a i Dy enb@eg mmb~ Boyt et ef Bo" Oo 9 | oO oH Oo joe BT ey OO in x 5 g ; @ Be . a » 4 BL fo ed we egy ork gt SO ag os ; med + 4d ' w werd bs OB" os au om Og B® Boom Ua s G rd cs oS 44 be gs Ad % 8 oy cc ra 3 51 oD "ny " Cs ud Hd Ow B Boo a ® ea Oh Gov sO ee gh as bs a o 43 wel ke tt gy fe be TH od $1 gy gy oi i, 4 . . mt 4
- Shy we oy ODD Gon @ ® r ent yoy res rot ie Begs tg 2? BO On ae eB gy Oo op @ O rors wom 3 a 2 © 2s rp ak ry pees » yt Be ba Ee rh ORG « Bo wa, 8 "8 eee Big or th 9 gar D gag a _ ed ee PS x S DAS ad tg THe cS 4 » ce) BO ogo @o Boe db ta G y oo 4S og o 8 ~« » o & wy Bg a « ay BE OOD a Gg OG mm OG i am ort a wy mot) tye » a Ye O fo 4 Ra . God od Gh bt tn OOo ae i Ge US us g Peed ed Boe a wt oO & Oe o OR Bet ns Ob mt BI hy yO bs MO mp Oo rae 40% 64 ma Be O Met mw Oe Ga O OB 4G OF om sm BOD HW HD H BoM & 4MoOW Gad OA Gert a eG OO Oo eo OSG @ fb MW OO OG Ord Ow a we ae 13 Hot be gt Oe MP Me es AY eR a wD YD NO we oe be O mg mo Par a a * ed ro) ee rhe OA No ATL 2007 MA No. 252/2007 connected with ©. A.No.1091/1999 « g zg zg z zg Z zt zg zg zg zg z t OM 4 i wd © ve tf hy OQ a wy "24 a 4 yoy ae = 3 Mei G sh yp ts - a ® SM 4s UE oe ed MR et DOO © a te 8 wo Me Bom w oe ba od eee Se FO OH we Oe tt Oo Mor 5 fo BD Mb Os <3 a oo SB ee Oo Oe GHA oe , iif Girt 43 0G 43 5. bo 3 5 5 st gy AS & = we A ¢ +4 5 bes QD Pa ol ee wee GG ort . G hat ; Pa oS wm. om k Baw MD x 3 a Ne 6 8 OO Gy SOG fa bes, % Sea fA 13 ct a Go 1 ma * cs 4B yes eas et a e ood 4, 6 Hart CARO OG iS wd Sr oS oy . Qo 4 tt a8 7 a " Oh | ny is Q Gs Wd . 5 . a ue A es GG oy Mw @ he: Ld 4g a e ra) yD i ved mf wg 3 wey Oo ao Y £3 a5 > "ed ve % wed op if) 4 Cy it wo Oy a ai @ oe !6 6B pa Se ao Boe wy + moe, & «tH gg Be 6 Oo ow {ek 688% a. 8 : ye POOH OH need * t " ¢ ' wy er " i oo¢ Se yy Bop mom 3 Oo Gey , BS @ wd ek gd gy be Oe wp OOO WS fe my wi us a cn ay a i a @ "ed "eA 'gs ft oj fe 4 mt ef rp nd fe ee mb Pid ee gy 8 Es e OO Auk n s 4d ih we * rol - rp 4 8 aed be C ae, "og . . A 4 * on ee "oo ty Ta oO ' ay @ Sg ge OSB "Os a pg gy B Oe ene oth os g Hog ae e , woo mh os Re " a @ ow bea % % GHB oe © & Baw 4 pe FO Bh aul nel oy gy EE oe a Bp Bag FP es a 4, 0 BRS Y BY Ged AG ti yw Rg eb AY L 44 as oa 3 @ 4 sf > 4g ta & M4 Sts ; re ha a my bd as $4 G be A ba . ney tp ny 8
- <4 af he Gra G ti er ey Sa Ct OM . a a3 ce i oO ov a a so $3 - fis a sot ' G 3 ed gr 4 bs _ " rth » i . ! Sa 3 a i aos GO gy & cM ay FR gg > Coe OG Ko Gta w te ord Ce 4 4 . ng 4 Ud Oi Ue & jo . vB bod v @ st Ud Ch tp a ye fe Cy Ub 49h G3 Oe G3 Gp A 3 QS eo Mop 4D not & OE GS i oo LD és OG dP ae et Me reed GO" OR" DB AR a & ef a ad mt te bt Oy i wu ® #) ce) @ © mtom cc he "rd OP OH, LY 4 o rt cet DP GS wed KG ou ot 39 GO On BG HO O48 of i ci oe bE mG ba A 43 dat $2 EY OL oer MR wm WO. Oh ip .
oe ba {3 ig go ord td i ts naref OA No.171/2007 MA No. 252/2007 x wacked w O.A.No. 1091/1999 + a orn (8 eed ahd £G i
20. a "C4 ao bed G sr rel @ a wy ad AAAS a Lo eferred a SO al an ed Pitchamani ¥s.
V. Ajias ¥.
Sy PATIL Pitehar = a.
2SS $} ras zy 0} Union h of India and Aner.
ae tee wnde:
S as .2
;
os tA re as Ae pa g4 i ris) qt rod iB be ved 4 Bs ed ft Ha 4 a ved g3 aed 3 «yt ip pot fed z e aed ip wi Ay O 44 oe re) 42 us> a LE 48 dt rs oO {3 wo a <i) Gh bed tot Go en OF 1 @ a bd
i) red seed v Gh, Re} Oo « ' g3 4d S 4 eC if mA om ted UY Mo Cy ba ae Cut cee me ty a ic Serv gu 3 @ ey I> 4} at at OF neg mo DP a Ot apd a £5 a ered wt oy A i e os ot Ph a Wy a Oo iF} ae 5 xf oO oO, 43 by oy mr feted on fe nm v SG o 7 o:
med BO $4 44 ot 1 a4 Sef w w ui ved 4 M4 wee .1
eo 8 @ a ng of vet & ae in oS nt vn Bi u @ 3
3) aq $3 iy 4 bf ® o D4 a ny gd O,AS.
ma esar % tad itt' @ 2 Son AS aan ce) my Q & 3 5 yb i w iy te4 Oy 4a ch co + fneiy Frog Rg 58 wh "ry ee "Py te ey oy ony No. 63 G tnt Seog ® a sf z ey ro oS Oy red Se 2 SS OA No.171/2007 MA No. 252/2007 connected with O.A.Na,. L031 /1955 wy ys 4 8 cm fe ¢ ¥ eng hy Toy oy ye > Taf "anf ey
18) in Fong Sg 44 a 43 ME OX ET 3, 42 8a 5 tah hd 43 Q com CS A ged bee Ky ® ® wm ted As a a, 3B toy wy SLO @ pen ~ 2 gE eg Ae od $3 ct hg 4a By iF
a) a ay s ed Ad a temf ty) chee 4d Qa 3 4 ™ om oy us, toned ha wy ae "hd ¢ og ox 4 x AG ts AG Hs i ted 4b v4 é o wed
9) "4 OA No. L/2007 MA No.252/2007 connected with O.B.No. LO9L/1995 tibtdnaiieedeededeeeee, fy cr Gay EP ae 4 YD oh fF oy Mw Oo Y& @ % oa ted OH OSHC BH G€SO9N GOBEr Ew oH
- 4 Th ge ay AD "4 be OS h sed om cro og Ya 44 @ 43 OO Gow a BATES BS eB BE t) ha Oy To 43 uy Q'S S A Bh @ fee oo ® OO By CoN G& ™ 0 ge" Cc . ct MO oy of a : tO My coord % qe a my Ty ES Hh a & he iw a :
S pe A os pa he fe 3 Doce Oo 43 07 4 Py 8 ry ay "te eS : ° ms. : 3 e hy $y Bo Oro hey | TT Ge sy sore, GOS mos, 4 wy O a y ba _ © i, BE e m5 re 2 co & ee mH tM Dy % ae AQ 3 GG al oo oo @ ef Bot My, tg 2 "ed pea A mS ty % 1% ty 54 nt wm ty OM $3 bry & 5 i 4. @ 4d oe wy OM C3 ci Gh wry it Sj 3 = me hy % QO 2 ® ea an e & i ie co x ct G a a 3 Ss, %G © my G 3 ' oy % %. oy WM 43 iG bea Oo gy oY 6 "rj uy % a Ch re . a © 3 3 = SS 6 tm $4 a a ton oo 83 E 8 G& 6 PRS Om Sey eg O8 Bo i ~ & "4 a 2 a ve my SB s os bt yo Tio a a8 Soon 8, & egpohOsadeo 2g SES eo BSES cy uy & rey * 4 %H GD by ee red Ee k ms Bg mo on mod i Teng tr 3 hy OQ Rot a Ye & {3, &e Ss me Gg ag CG % o cy oy my OG ie B.S 8 6 sot SON Gases ga SO Re gw. a a as 5 BB iG @ apg Gh Leg ving "4d Gry gy © My ky a a by mi yd & % 4 e mG Bod na ey @ a a es og go % © os ss, * Bg a Sag Be! GR Aas ae tod wi wo SB 2 Q 13 .Q aa re wh he . ry we 2 & a4 wy @ 4 x , ta td of Ba ogy fy A et! fo wu ha oF ew ms ve ie m4 a a m ti, O Fa 4a 3 ae o Ei eg ey Q , de MO i Phy 6&2 oR O&O Sf uy es By 43 td My a Bong tne gs ® yu, Uo ® the fy UI & "hr, ay Bey y wm @ = - a2 ae <M w, th ty hy c "hee oe a ne a a 433 a 3 9 4 & ma 29 $ s oe a 8 8 fg 8, a ay a a ay cS tay om w - ny Q 8 3S aq Ze 3 , 5 et Be ss sae on Gm Roa "8 we BOP 8 By Be Bea ee 45 Co 5 a -- 2 $3 © oy & 3 m 4305 z= pg 6 a a 3M a Sy iv " i i" os a owe ' x ns eh np. t » Gy) Ad fe . Soe - me Mog my 4 p OV OES AG ep OBae" Sus BAD eRP GEE eos ut 4 3 tt i a & % tA Oy oh Beek ee pay Wore oN oy BS om Og m te ty Tt Oy, 2 4 wr pe Cy ny m6 SS Tg eo 42 oh Ry OO Boa MS Bo ng wD 1 gy 4 Dm gg Oo o ey 8 3 Py O, ® ane @ yon | 43 98 Be Ry % Cody tp Re ost 1 MA @ «By ag te LOGAN & BOG OS we 2 Ow & Oh ® agg os o " gg eSeusesan ss 3 Pp ms ig 4 5: LD ogy oF : 3 Py ke ta ~ Wom 4 wh Bey TG « My ta ky 4 yO Ms O24 O Pr oO DE wy 93 5 0 490 sr GY yg ed HY Oy RS Ck ee EY BL me} He ey am 4 OA No.l 71/2007 MA No. 2252/2007 connected with O.A.No. 1091/1999 M6) % 3 PS Hwee BO O42 & Som g OS B etry GG Ma Ay a
3) Om omom Go PO , 2 An he 2 so OY by UE OT fy Dog ea @ bag ey 63 * : w ny
- t Cy is ® "ry SAG & GY.
oO 2s eh ee Tee hy Be OEE Oe Gy yh Og i wt Es gs bea, n wy had 6 ras) ort we n My Nee : OB a ' t.. ViE XY rh ty By AQ feo ee ct oy td OO. $4 GD my OU oy oH Bb oe a zm G > iy Cp ovmfocey ry iD Wome OF Wy Oo 4 tyme TR ED OO wy COLL LL LUT UUTTLOL LLU OTOOOOUUU TLL LOTOLULLTTLTUOLEEEEL, bh a 2293
2) by ¢ ms Uy ba @ 4 woe GY ct > ray FY rt QD by GG Ma A "3 we s g a TH bay Mm Gb SG & te ay a 1¢33 Ry Uy mo 4 tr G ex < % P @ 439 2 tnd r~ Bo CH 4b 4S red bed m4 4 1 Gh et ord =O 6 ga Oo oom ff mS " oS ot By oO pe ia aon Sets or GO aD ing 5 HS "4 4. ca " a oe mamnte! a Lm Gg a fea at ® ny 8 HS dad D3 q i 2 a4 SA we © we 5 iy md tk , a he rds g R cop te oo OM & D s 7 oie & e < zea ou a 43 HE DN ey @ oe Som woe. # Ew oa 5 OC Gem OS wy a 6 8 * oo # 43 Oy a Be
- r oF gy oy et ted ae @ he ae SONS ME my ff Ree S F Pe 8 my beg sy ot 9 _ io "4 "i AX had 43 a io we "ed 8 " i} ® oh , oe) nel "ty Bly bY tts 43, ve a EO gy © ry aan Bg nok BOR os 4 aay e ho sued 3 a 4 : ". f 4 as . Pe ry wh ri tay ; eG q O4 be TR "ef 3 e H 3 ee - fey en 3 Re 8 3 J + 4 M pra ; 5 %y ore + oe ree t "i e . € WD fa By o re on as oS oy 4 "ey % > 5 é Lt 4 g) a % on oH my hy MR St ty vod ra hy OF » A GS wy Tl ow 8 he ~ ww St & a ob, cette ga oH i 29 be A wep PM ¢ ' al Oe ae. sen t o Lf og ob 7 a : % 3 C3 4 op 83 4 oo te by m4 te & act MY SY I } ts i % , ey a ty & %3 ge Dy ky 4b hy mf v® 4 at 3 43 St oA Oo Zo OHO etl g s ° b "ae 8 8S 5 . ven eo AE wa ES On Ye trap By ned ats epg OSS 2 My Pooky Qa O & cS ' oD a 4 Ey it ted Ep a ay we rn 3 Se ma eed 43 cd pw ioe GO ci 5 CS ef 2 @ Shag eg UY - a': mR ay OS 43 My By Ty tgs See Teg 6 6 & o 3 & © Ro og Oa TB Hg 0 | ot ve ALY Ka te "yt tt a = one a } apa * * 4 G o> ih B Be i <A 'og ® Sg. v8 Ss St on 43 th ope, Ey OP gy ty > Be gh re eh gg my Bo ci Ch & 5 4,3 " not Medd is 7} fs raed Beg i" oy hy sey . oS oy . 4 hg *33 ny bog QO. ay 43 By ' ro : 2 OM G&G Q t B43 me oO te n oo Aw aa eu. oa
- i 4 . ae we, Y Yang Nee ey eg SY m S Bm % 8 i wy sp 9 gq BOs On ig Rp > oy Oe no Ho ke ty OO Dy Dy 42 sk go 6" ™ "tS , be © GW OG Cpt Ore By hy , in » tr 9) Sas at a ce @ OB we Qa oa o mR A td ve : so a o TS Oo & " 8 GE ee oD i Oy ey i oe gu ia ty oy ' a S S 3 oteg C5 ep mp ved RED 4 tel Yong TE Met aa ~ ND, ay , i ta Wood oed O,4 Of % 3 2 O % go a op = Bm a 4 Ad sep my My Sy Ad EE ty A hy a OG 4 5 ny ogy 2 omy wi ap ap iG wes ort My OA O 4 O O 4) OO OD | B ok, £3 cr ty a £3 4 83 % 3 Bo 2 HY oy OO a oy ddode Uw md OF my $y i py Eb ky 4 on oS Oped ty oe Peat O 4) tn ty th, 0g 6 eorf 4 bag LE OUP By ' me 2 Bg Gy mao Of Roa os a it by C4 im i BU Pde GD GD wg 4d * OA Nod? 1/2607 MA No. 252/2007 th O.A.No. 1091/1998 connected w Gs nage oy oy wy th ard 43 oN 23 i 42 > Ong iy rod iy {fF od ay .s wy A aod 4d at rd a mS A oe} fag «rd a 4 42 OO Boy 4 LY © AS Br ory Th gy > a iy $d hy hy + We OW ted Mg dD rs ned oe ri of oy 43 ke g Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z OA No d7 1/2007 MA No. 252/2007 connected with O.A.No. LOSL/1988 by wy Ry OD & UW 1 YH Sa 2 pw SS Mom sy NM me O Or @ ee ag Gy H Of By ow Bm Gem Np Sy 1 oy OF Gerd ORE mE ORG KE & Oe thoy ° ° Ba re o ae a 3 i ap rt Rd 43 a Ad pep Uy or ted cet dd Of Dove ddd Wy o43 iB a 4% tg fi, Chore da 4 mo a Gh OG tes ao ie a . O & Bag n NOG WH eos ug Bath og ae 43 uw boy BE tg 6 MO o A ey ts TG mon GO % i oe Gt aoe oa O& & 7 Oo mH MO mE mt Ow M BU Pp Mid Be we o Ou Be Ss, ry tg 8 wD uy 2 ey ha bs i a a EY gy + a 2 SG Ath & Oo 4 36 8A go Deg ae 4 » Org mE BOD ey Gg, 2 ay wD SO ag a WZ wd org BY de Hoge 2 OG co a = TY - Sf ay A BE eg «@ we req be ree Eg wey ES yO OSS ay obs GG MoE seg ak fA Soe a My hi eeg 4) yy ER mm wy Py tek TF £t by ~ 4 By ag Q, 5 ca % :
. go 8 eh "BOS th ee SG gs 7 a8 % 2 dbo i QebB es a Sm Pag eS 9RR BUre a gS, ge if By ah . ma req ed WM WM. ad s. 5 . mi Q a at 3 4. me % Ay La 6 8 my Hop ee Me a PE gg my og OD Dee 2M be a wy oe DA Gow og og ee @ 3 8 a Gow a o} ba "E oO SS ay os "eh ° : sie we * _ * - 3 i pee on pe on A C8goR7TE ES "HH BASS ae US ® m4 1 hs ao BRO a Oo BS ae ag Bwa BS @ og iy 3 OT x A x Be Ly om eee The 5 a th 2 Doe OF tb mf % aoe by Hy @ ©, Q a 3 se Ae a wl ay ® 4 @ a 483 5 th Ww ' uy ee ee Tt ya fe Mt am A Mao 3 bs ; 3 mh ge qo ee Pee a a ved hE SSO Aa hy SS By 8 Mou © oh oe My » Ei RR gy anced Som ayy we tS 4.4 73 Uo Bee Tee red gy, ES o % ay 5 B ong rd th Bo DO xb be Ee ms we Bi eg ag mh. co me 8 ge 2 mt OO. og 2 bw a 8 top el 4 ey 8 GB a oo OR G Dy by, YY mm Bi a mG fo BO ee pM ge op BM tye "ha, ay mos mM ip cy i Gog MCS im os Q 5 4 ee Sa, aa Hh Ba sp GH Be Oy PP BO Ap oes a a @ » oe gem gebn ep OG 6 @ BM Set ol 9, @ 2 982 Bg lh % aa ER ay S89 Gy fe OS op SS BB oy e | % G WO 4 Sey wg F eh ooy Fat ts, ee AP OB O Get Ba BG © Be Gu 4 o 2 by OC Rye ee eG Bg Bice Bat Bh bs Se 8 Ou 3 oa By oy ep eh YR Ay es OQ @q = O a te 4g @ 5 C 'al i th hy org QB OG 6 G4 G@ A Rm MG 4 se oO 3 me gf Bono Oo @ Gon ky Sh iy TS AER conf BS ~ age A 42H C1, 73 (ira by GO, Sass as & TM ONS em 6,0 GS .
Cy Ch 1 AP a sk os + oh Ss 2 8S a it vet DL By he s, WoO OT 44 O By more O GO Pw Gh a GG O 4 My .
eq i a OF te Dy { 20 7A é OA Nod MA No. 2352/2007, connected with O.A.No.1081/1999
5) $3 co) o a * 3 @ wy & td asi es KS od 4 @ $3 if % es SS A ea) wi g ha o & So 4 . co Mpc A oe m 5 33 oD at th 0} oD 3 pay 4 » c is) mg Mea ke nt ey . hi ox, oe mo o del > iL A DP »« 8 SB we 1 Gs "¢% a oa '4 +4 44 a te @ ' oC oat bs g 5 3 _ 3 Oo th ## g a OM pan co ng £ BD ty B S ved g3 @ hed 4 ma aed we CS ~ oD a vet ts $4 + <y oh A oA ey hope @ ie ms a) : $ 9 Bo 3 ° og oy 2 y Yo a 7 aa 4 @ at bef Ee 0 4 is na ry oS , . a ms od o G BG La i) < o a o a | eed > be a) ' fa oy os om ved re) Oy © , en qi A og ty md wd c 3 =o 2 : he 3 * :
cs a 7 6 8 2 og gard ort a " S » 43 » U 5 at wood he v te od a OH yy 5 ee 43 med aol i y Bf sod oe! q yaa a fo ¢ * a $4 C3 a i cs 'y 2 cy a a be a % 2 4 ed cg ty ra @ q oe wm OG ", a x ts, o @ 6 £& £ by ® 5 © ye £8 & WB mA w ei BE a4 vay " os $ ts 4 aod : pee ae ea wy 3 43 my OG a ee wed BG § o © es fe . "4 G se my ett ae , 4 a SS Re B Opes Bd bed hy ce) va od tx iD -- @ a $2. Ad . . 3 a 3 Th ree) % ES Oss Eo a Me sep ul 5) G & : 4} : coo) oF fy .
Q ip ey ¢ Y 44 ~ 44 a in} io a "1 ry c Eps S fF g¢ > = ® Gn & « 8 os § 6 or J s $4 A cA 42 4 * ch tt bet : al we in £2, a el as fm es a dons rs i ord oO ~ oA a ie f £3 £. 4 ae ae me $7 '2 4 $4 ok nf yd g re oO ; at . 4 5 _ i c ba Q Go a, 6 DOG aq wh UE o 8 wv wi & ny i" m9 e ' Wy & n4 wv ro) od et i vr ; ag G 4 ee be vA uw "S oO a4 ia mt B " Ba eed m * 4 43 ays Ls) tt ih ' fy ved ime af . Boot ha 4 co a 4 ea "C5 a * 4] ne % gy th o f eo Be F Fa 0 G6 @ & 0 9 ma KS pm OA ow aw we & hi : ns it : 3 ot us a My : se ' Ep 4 AG a) gy ae : 4 " eo } at z oh u3 My g $4 v4 0, og eet a gO r4 fw Bee os i 3S oes > po '4 4 . m4 of « Ay ag ¥ ? " \ 8 a 2 §@€ #2 "7" 2 YR 6 © 5 § € ? B&B g@ os
- oa 8 fi co 9 6S i Ot @ isa mn a o $ rH B43 oe a rif gS Q oe OOK WY CG 44 a a i aoe "4 7 mg Mt kk OO Bo oo 1 8 3 Bo <s © & oo o Ow Gt mG 3 bd, HM co a * ui '4 ory tT G3 ws. et > ie on =f } oe c bag he "4 be a @ 3 o Si ost 3 4g re By @ ' ned i a ™~ * es oo " m $4 ri bei Met om fos hy & w Mt Q ha o 4 a fab od E-4 © od 44 Q ny a) wy rd o se a © OS No 1712007 MA No. 252/2007 connected with O.AR.No.1091/1999 Boe MO Bog @ fo Woof WT Da- Th Go «© Ga Oy xP OD ee hed : % 4 g x 2 x > am mw ref Oat EL i eho Met OO et PAHO GO Bem ob oY | hi $4 0 ved mm 44 4d ref 4d OY @ ost We bb we ee a i CP ON Or rd Towed 42 4d BP 4d i x?
ct $f h 1 TS fh a i chet te Th by i of et aU yy, 8 % gy @ "yt GC tee COP Ud Ty ss $4 4 a, O a Oo eG ob @ & Bi, ee, nm. Uo fe oe go Sie @ ta tt HG 4 © 33 ort GoM ah Si mow Ob ge Be ort o 0 rf Oa 31 ag ky sory O oe 8 6 i Gb ay > m 8G wed US c we O oa ogy " Sy n & 2 4 Ue Lom S MORE nel py 3 a 8 os wom o Og & 4 oe Dg on get ord fey be I a et me dd BS te a S & hal 2 1e 4.3 ay es ey Ge de Q Mod ag 2) SS BEB py gd EN clog M , as Hoy A of 8 | f oD Be a es tA wo 2 @ Dt ; ~ ww G oss ot peck GG Be ny, Ga & Bb ag EP Es wy ed ra et GE Hy 34 4a @ < mocked 4) ¥y wd weed get as 4s @ 4 $4 @ OO oy 4! o wo, Og \ Oy ee ey eo Oe i PG hee ook 4 Hs ww fe ME eg of ot ta KA ~ wh UO et 44 a4 wo 44 Ae Fe oe 3 1 oO 8 poo ¢ ogy G mY sg 8 mo Ma ty gy gs A " vat Mm gs: ws on MoO he 6 OO C3 % Gea wa rp a es a a Oo, A @ a OL og wd bi Dg yon ob o AW ag Og 2 @ B soa & OP hed tn + Mas fy Cy 8 wey an oe Gk Hee & o i OD rho O 4, Om Bort GO 8 gg Bt GE oe oreg g ted Ad Oh Me ° ried ' ct Mae oy Ch ot ms bet aa we HO oh "oe 4 ed ~ $s tony ' @ 43 43 > Gh oet cyt Hon i OM + te O % Sr ef SOU UE By > Gy 28 Oo a a (ah pt 3b cg Fe ot gt a Oo, at Moby Ub ed Th @ th ved } in Pa 40 CF ob eet bob xed et yee GY fs sep oS Ch at wd Ye OG ao 3 Op MO OO Oo Ep 3) ed WD we Wort i Pp MT Of a be AO diet et Td TG OMA WoO Mt uD "oa eg OOP mA Ho Bom Mo Os BED OG ort GO GO be Gy by Gheeford @ ba me mG O al m win OO © ft Mo 4 Med MO Oh U SG 2 tH wo Om oO TR re ah Boga Op oH {Ad ct rm Sn "ogo pope t . 3 rominh- oH Oo hyo Om Ot WO aM 8 og ee gt S 3 et OD O ths WG BE oH & oy ENPO Se hoa Baws ee" Be ee eG BBB aes #00 aogat a |™ Gee" So RAS ae AGA ES CGR 0062 eee omna eon tS en e c cg a yt - oe cc C 3 OG x " . cy i. c ; be m aan fo} pet Oy, : et OF 8o Saas te ge, SE see gee ern e. wee ae ae Boe BS g mo Ro oSt hy ga a oe ot AeA 2 wort BU be od tb ee wed gi 2 oot Ga pd a + St 4 BP OE mn nC: by HO pe qa 9 Mo ee S o G Os yp" 63 fe eee Goa Ew g o PRE Ga ower Agee LG 3 OC » 68 Os Os ha Oe 4 ae: 5 Ow fee Ba, y Ode & it wf tD . u "ES Sayed G my . . Dy Lf '8 rs Lo J a aa * aH > "4 aan Sol mewn ob AB oe & a ay ow m fae Og "1 S 2 i a ess i # a oy my x Pe ey 4 ? mY "wf UW @ Gof 2 rey & be _ BA S72 4} te sed red . * aed ort 8 oe Wo oo aod my red 4d 43 acd mgd w re , Ow a4 a a Q are A mp ee de 3 a ee we yy mt O GT cy ap Boh ce & a ca 4 . i F = "4 as 2 {Oe Cg BG gue LEY & ; oa ER fant a4 @ pd ta we cet HQ 2 ox Q vf TS Bed og MA ey a OS o : 5 . ad A LS mM 42 ' % Oy mo" ay bh oe Bt ve i ao ® us a + ' 3 eB te OH @ 7 & th ge SE EE 44 Be oe gpg SHO. BSE OAR ® At eg MS Saga RY aaa ga er @ > Bp 8 6 Bes a Gey Oo he ay Bt 4a Oo. w 14 @ tts 4 ; oy BM oO Oy eA UBa nk meek enom Rg WO Oa 8 Oe oA Ba %) is ~ Oy i me ed eg @ Se Bas ts 4 G a Oo 2 oF ey RN ol Bk DS eo U : ms 4 oe eo &@& 4 2 w mh os eS we i MG 3 ct eg od OM oa Gimp P a VR nod gy foo! c ew O Todt oS nf ; ko he ah Gb at Ee AE ad 4 CG tej G % ria dg OS . B wy 44 G TE be @ a3 ve . 4) ry a vg toy wl . e x5 4 aa MOS OO ~ © 6 Boh x Nabe by OP ST yg, Bo pe wm Gg Ae Sh Oba OB 6 a i 4M a O48 mt 6 oe #3 i et ES DS aed at 6G oy hd 45 @ R a $3 Oa iG i 6 > Gem mm Bs "So GR kaw BSE S Bag bw ao Hoo Ga oy an ua 6m Lo bab he 63 EQ O00 ee Om 8. OG 3 O af Or b 66-4 GO Med ow Dt Sa Be Oe m0 a8 8 Cee yp eRe ow 8S CO g c 7 em 0 Dae oe Hone d ou Go au fod U (0 SON BEST OE OHO OS i Sg 0 as ' a rt pod 3 Hi 4 fo HM TO Hue th oO om & OA No.7 1/2007 MA No.252/2007 connected with O.A.No.1091/1999 n om £2 0 rf 0D Thy, t4 wm os £6 0 Oh mm UE Gm Ot .w Gwe Det DO « O HH HH Th G) om qi @ Oo fc ~« BD OD 44 Board aerd ad Soe i bead SG SE 6 Ort Ho Oo eG cine ny ay © 4D OE $4 ba T> EG fi ¢s That My EB a od a Ye AR m a > Sew :
y t } & 3 ., ed be SOA My 4 RM OD u a & a 4 Hed ' EG ia ont ow ys 7 a a "aw.
cE 9 my NS 8 @ oad t <3 XA et bE Fa RA me gh 4a G "sy he alsa by "e we , , Ch i _ Z werd % 6 ae Oo ay * tH a og met ped Da be§ ct pe Re a) 4 Coen Dk, 4 4 3 4 €8 oy rf "el kd :
a i ry ey FH Pac Bo 5 eo 4 a 6 ma D we D4 @ Bato BO @ Oo Ay ae oo D4, wo & % ED 4g 8 Be av wo 3 ana Pil & a Ho " p @ G i 1,0 3 O p OE OA aoe GA Oo BOO OM 6 Om Of BG a Mme Th U Domo PO Bm eM vy p uy iB % oe i inet j 4 i wy 13 mo cS co gs ie os eOeS ~ gH QO HOD Penge s F go' @ rf £Xa Pod ey a rhe ~ Sy 43 Os ao . Ae at <4 cS rf geet Wg. ord Pe at ce cs - & . Wm 2 me kG a ih 8 ba "rt gy aD RE eye get ES pd OPS y oF 4 al 4 i } "
Bos gy OP Mp ti Bo Og Be Soh a (6 9 & a 4 so 4 4G pea a vt a OD ty 4 or rh kd ge nt ah oN is gh Pat a 4 bs a i fg i wy . CY om 2 7 ; ff % o a ts C3 * , . , et y Gg Sa} ; 4 a wha 4d 2 rd a) "rd 2D ogy ot iS va 6 fre och £3 OES ny g 6) i ; mA vt ord Se ole pg aH SRE AON eB Ay wy oy Sy dB © Ag way 74 fy wt % "taf oo a Es ay ED A gy ow ee rt AS gy oa Qa DG oo ' Te OY ON UE Oe ye a BO Gyr} oa roy a re se] a, ay ed ee es, g ret 5 NM 6) Ye eo 44 os 4 if ow oe bay th wo be api PRU HS ra yy D oO" 1G 2 Sg rh a 4G ED rm gy o a co vd wy be a, * a Mee LE Stat gs " roe a bE GOS mm Gi Pa cers oo oe mo x mo po Es, a i, . 44 My Med Gy he of Oo ct om al te TS ay aos O44 @ cr HGRA mH aS ae es ea Eig ay £2 yp wt m Me ge eS ay , Oo @ £3 aw is g *, ; Oot i a Fs a ort oy * yy oe » qa 5 as tg 3 Bs fy BO 'a bs O's Sty at GO om Ogre aa Md wT U ci qt <th aon oe a4 ney (bo Ra eed & ba wm a ; Go wD 4 an GOs ® M4 ny bE Eg at Gy 8 St ed by SH ved HR a @ 44 o n iow ty we Bg Qe Gy Gea PhP aa o mg oO TH ot cA ord 3 Moe We OE GOR ed ori wh 4d 4) or} Sai Od HM Bet a Oo 303 a HE a OL Md Se a gt i 0 cle Bp or Ne WW Ss 3 Par Pant :
& AY as ry 3 oy PD oUDLre oS "
x
-
y MH O DO G Shy G DP Ch wt rs bo HO et Z , th O.A.No.1081/19939 * ™~ OANOL7IL/200 No. 252/2007 MA.
connected w ® Q "xt $e "h a) ef G et ri @ a re) oO ee +3 ig '4 G ont wv 4 es ' Ea hei 3 fs ped Uh oe a wet -- me ON » » So MUO so Oe Oe GO w cri we dT es ae a a "4 o f° cg OO ks G $3 Oy "Beate Oe BM OW GB et 5 Co. ow ao eed" Be Or SO cf ri @ by fo "rd 2 hs ce 5 OG Mh ord Bde A, ans @ Me fs 6) or 4 * a " in Bo-cbrd a Big get gO a OO 8 GB 3B | Mg s3 ied Ged On U Ge wo ~ Oo aM om BES & TO SM gg td 3 4 i hart SE eget OD 4 e ral rh ae o c O i) @ D4 wh mad jada Ay ia a wt 4d res re t "4 ht W $F rd Oa ow aa vd 3 BOD ee 8 a gh « * ou orw~ 9 Hao @ Yay BS a a ga vel ae ot & co Me MO DS Hob eg "4 fae . at cS od wt sed Ut t Ae Og: on ig fea typ 1B ve Wyo M fo hg a a be ord OS Mas CE Oy cy vos lg oS ad o . . 42 "th yb iy be et yg Ay EO 4d an 5 $9 TE ge 63 a i ng Het OT a we 2 O Me wo 5 ce oi ; he ke TSE Oey OF neg Ba $e be i H u m4 a Gwe the? & fe ny og SO 4 . 4 Q eo re , 4-4 ' Hdd GE os ga o i 6 ow Bh ba ort a '3 re HB os 3 - th o : ' a . ' tb $4 L? at ns ' At g ua B et @ y are A ay 1B * , 4 ' 4 fos 'vat ' ts ey he tis we g) ms He) tS @ 3 a 2 ug @ 8 a 5 Boog Box ® ri a Os See M4 ev "et LE ro wo wd Ct {bed im MM Ep tre 0 fe ee ba we ' "4 SS oO 8 3 ' 44 "3 gc 2 : 4 ; ve ; o oO 4 bs at ip < bg ; QO - ag eh "4 e ie we PE Bue © ¢ £ 3 * Gi "ey b. Sa re * at oe ° A8 Uh 3 a a 05 "s "3 eh a4 TE Y a : . } Bye wo 4 B ® & 4 Gost mh & a a Po % oar, nt " 4 a 4 os , sy ne :
o bE Ge ef ome 4 om 8 a8 a8 9 6 Pos 8 4 6 F 's gE 2S OF ce ha ee r Vi oe ; ¥ a are het ® whe om ay if] : £ Mt, ey v6) y con ry Me ee Md Cg Bo, Po ced aM OR & Q a WF, ted pt 43 on i ; ER 6 werd a @ Mgt veh gy , 4 | ci m4 a » Oe go M 1 ® Ys yy uo p66, of a sy + BB "
© @ Yd 4 an Ath O11 O @ min www be 4 2 (3) : ! a : r v cy ' Word OF OD oo WM Feet iv is £ op iG z res = " 5a 4 cS mm et, wd © ~ Ch eT 4 aot eG 4 a &£ oan 4 a C4 G -
Ci a boy AA Se "4 wf 6) veoh Oo R ord 6 SEs Q ~ a ch " uS uh «3 @ g Ce pee HH ie) is x is o GO aie 43 I~ OD fo. 2852/2007 Gonnected with O.A.No. 1091/1999 rd OA No.l! inal rey MA et av OI ae a a bed U4 geod wD if ita eed 44 etek
24. oO ay g ae i whee 4 $i ha G a 43 G & aq) XD i + ra A a} $b a ied Gt hed x moloyee wa "
fas Ex! bunate "
RUA after 4 & a
25. e ¥ nab me AX ants :
eee e800 ha Railway tne ban ak Oo sph oy ot wd rd om] ry be 3 oO G} $4 syed Lo a es;
oo @ ok nwt aod ie te 3 vet 0 © 3 as hon oh pensi 2 x h ayen that GS SUORL % is bs LLL TOOL UUUTOOOOOUUTTOOOOOUTTLTOOOLOLLLLLL OA Now 71/2007 MA No. 252/2007 connected with O.A.No. 1091/1999 =f TY had "vd wd oy 5 a Ad x SLONAaLS pen x 'tt d Seg bef G wag et ONT MD iat Siast 2 ew Te y
26. mn od L a fot ishnan 2 KG.
India £ * of Union o case Qn ' 4 kh.
Radha Kr Vs. &SC 227 if < reported 1998 (5) and. Ors.
YY RA Go plicant ap Bumar Bakesh Radha Brishna G. i S548 % 2 qt ee Gt co £4 ¢ = od st Gd iP og 4 BS Sa a "
Qa oa B > "a > a 8 wa oo9 aS < "5. at a soe fa ia - bf "s bef "i x + g 2 a 5 ml a % o * & re & ei o m3 re to ri wD Bo . . ca ; ' s ' a oO Fi O % ty + wo: ORS a a ; @ in at Ps ct oe ® bs 4 Ms *. ay sy, ' os rat a wo a >a og » ui 2 oa "4 1 a 2 @ 2 ao: § gig oa 9 ny cs cs 4 . w ~ $4 4 @ wy 4 > 4. fh ; 181 ' 4 cs te md . cs Sry wy vt ms OG 3 i : a Oo - ' ct a ss $ ~ MM f ou r tp as oO : $4 I 7h ~ mS O 8 cc m et Oo a ew 4 Oo & nn? 2 SS CoD 5 8 of ed a i a tn ry . om a a fb on et J og @ o o & » DB Fs & 2 8 = § 6 8 $4 ka red a) ng Q oe ect + 5 % fe a . : oO 6 B ooo a & 8 OR a wm GE int wy OE 4 Mt a apd gf @ dds a ; o re) 45 @ vet oh a Ans si on aaa cs Bg © m4 rt é 3 Oy mt B 5 ni me rk OR oo « god . RB 0 ay ke : a B® ee QO ct 4S q5 . cei '4 rd rt a vk o ted "th : oO 43 ~ iota ts $. un @ 4 aw - wD 4 : a 0 2 od 0] wy Li hi mn we) 4 & cS wB 5 o rt p Oo » fg «A 8 sa woo | wo OR ma ns o " a 8 so cB SS B fy od > & 4H O. 5 3 3 3 . § Be £ e@ % 3 Hoops oO - & "
A Go Gf Be a FOS o © & mn 2 @ 4 OE w ad 4 a th Q "rt "s rs 4 xD ¥ DG v a 3 ~rt @ iG j Shs 4d o "a t a oS me a i ot o a: + 4 fee a nh w ES sd oy +5 : & * o wd ond 3 oe 2 a Hb a 4% SS mG Poe om os @¢ Gi, OD hs M a 2 @ ® Sa td ea x G 7 4 D a c 3 - Gi rn ee GG « Hoe 2 ut g oa ba . "3 oa wt oo © od o w 2 & # a a ££ 2B oO } oc w s « be La 5 rt ag Bo @ 5 ved ci a Ss wo oO foot a
- By 43 ee OQ 3) Oo o os v s @ . o on "gy a m6 OS ' o ~~ i Ss gO @ 4 G&G hg Ci oO rt % . - ty * @ ond ' 7 a hd a i <3 et o™ Ss he - 3 H "ed is bed Ch 43 & wD tt @ vd co ~ & oF oe og wv 4G " : ; 6 Oo om © t % hd ps ch Es) 1 pees ord ' a hy a i Oy ay 6 ar: Ge Fo oe OO eo sw og 8 S$ bg Gow un ® me & a o «a eo 6 o Ss o ie te be 4 a * a : ot Het : a & wo fe os 4 be - g ' aE | , 6 a "4 I ip ny) am kg oO o ct 4 oot *y a a » te o ae Q 3 ; tp rt oO sy iG 8 oS 8 gO Bo :
3 OU Q Go B rh rd we 6 id 3 a eo 3 5 gy 8 Dp p -& ei ao ° 40 @ 4 arf on i. ad > hd e " a ae BY a: nn ' Gm 8 } o e ved os > o 43 i oe 44 v @ es i © ct MG PA ed on bf ' @ ; Be a m A 43 td 4 a is) ia $%s 7 ert QB i pag x 4 oe Ft . i ay tA aed i? 30 t Se a et vt sy mS ay " " re a ib ns a » tt Bm A eon a "oS oe 5 A eo tr % tS a od "3 i ry O Q. 2 he OF n 3 be a Por w ® g * nem Ch OQ be a et " ay oy % 4 thd oped.
+ 5 @ ee os a OG - fi 1, 5 nw 2 Q 33 Mf oD * rh o De 3 & cy San 3 ~t tow §.
at Xv ae 8 Oo arg hed 3 G ve cs wo . '3 dy a rt aged w "
ad K 2 ar m of ex We 3 uh Cc a ir ed a tS rn ue w . a Y % i) 4d oS & 6 so oe So a a S 6 i wed be i hy Ge 2 mG OM Rh x ms mq orn Sa $3 % sd wD pee Hes x 43 +t g mn rd 44 n Fa ii Aan ENE od ort rt rt ee) @ send sod 1D 4t boy pO Os Om Raw " Hh wo ma Oey i x tM rt te " wd wD o O of spd $e al U4 n @ bed as S go a eS C = ms 9 ged GQ coh a Qe Ort eg rs eet DG ree. 1B G rod Bo g oO 3 Ee ag 43 i Q fas BY eed 4S ao wo © CO ep 8 Oo st ot es 9 eau « fm a be ae 64 ay hy sy 4 nf w it $4 4 A®o °° } es #6 « ts & fy re "< a 7 ed it) % od . 4 . 7 "ed ns: w za a a Y Ob bo Met "3 nt mn 6D wy oO 3 a god pe med it Oo c rot M4 . £& 2 Si gk e 8 ki '3 it aq 43 ~ wD - hd Cy ee) Wy ry ~ : a * " a4 co at ya x rn «oh r 4 Wy ! fea va ; a3 ia vA "A Gt ma te ne *A uy 43 be eC ad oan O O % veh Q gi a £3 gS ke 43 > nt i B
4 sy ug 43 vet whe rr apd acd 5 4 ; "ed oB a mS 4 " et $e 5 i. oft ~ oa . i vps 4 Ct ea neg os Oy OG ; . wm . re ' 5 7 oy gy G a > , & 8 a Y a a au t r4 . 2 4 3 4 - i ws 4 ; an ; . : wr " *t a ded vet on 4d t % 43 0 ib 3 @ re ct " Ss Cs ' - ia oO é ° mm 3 Ad ; tw 44 c ba G pa r5 ye C4 pA 4 6 . tea ao (c 3 rtf 6 sed ted 3 Som a7 x) ra cr ar A eas ny cH "sy ded cf rt od red oo Bt =) 434 i) 53 hp et & ify } ' Kee eee Os m 4 oe @ w@ MA sed "
oa te oo im @ a > e, a 43 a & in o BM £m fe od y a -* 7 o 4 s fe pa 5 48 $3 bed w G " @ fe w) 3 4 7 . '3 a ~ rh @ Of OG Tr 2 - fi a ep Reh Q & gp TR set 2 gf MH 5 be $3 Gd a G wi ~ i co ot "rd w ard # Ge Bo Ort i mks op 8 3 ff 8 SD ; bs Ww y pets on o Sk > Se a 3 eR} ™ any Mm RQ & L Ww rh
4 aD ord ord o is 3 i Yad q Kd ee a Oe] ver} MI ¥ we ¢ : . be Beat ' ae 'eg tq 0 A @ i cs " aS a ag ved un 3 ved i hes io & es Oo 43 i P o i rs rd = a arf wo ad uy "rd 4 a rod ered GQ bs oe ay dD ne = we wo rat ot OR} ) c ey ¥ Yn SF es n ry yi ord $.§ a s.4 rf rn ved i Q a oO ord O cr Sa ver} ver ae J Ch * Oy ees eo} et $4 eet het ref Dr "ed © QO. x ' 2 be i 9 gs a7 Che a hi in i wd fle 4 % sed Bg yo Bs) mo vet S35 ued w Sy C 5 3 Eat i K o td e 0 £2 wm eS rd 3 Cr as a aw 0 a MM
29. t- ft hy $d 4 4 é So eo O ey a ot Y @ bt gt :
e * oe be aie 1 @ } : Fr my, a 4 OF 6B & a Ae ches G ord i a , t iP e wt aD they a ' a 4 SEN ard ed ho AS 43 ot "4 pve os nged 4d $5 i _ ; an rt m4 ia 43 3 "4 x C a : o ane Fa) fe aot tr ~~ fs, a +s am 6 i c "3 Oo 2 As 3 he "3 " i ve! A bf 5 wed i 4 3 ws Q ° 3 rt re id o> os %3 na £3 ord ard i a3 . 40 ry c St . : Sa ie Mw O O in yy 4 * 3 wd i | ts 4 7 4 re | my, © 43 ot Go . i C ; w 3 aw o } 5 2 oo ' x is ef oS a ood tS c wt mo + uy at ch te a "4 : mo 4 $4 bed 4 o re r 4g of on, i . ~ = Q a oy o w@ a = aS C fd v3 Cy e g ma es ed 44 v 5 "Os Oh a rd 0 es Cs, oe af Cy
- : % . ba a os 43 4 a ho & Q ' ir th G " to "4 2 4 wha *. O si wm 63 Bd ea o be o pt ™ 4 3 o a Th an] Pani 4 ci . te) Q tO 4 fw a " ed 6 w" & a qa Eee a 0 Qa oS Bf sy , & oa og 8 oS a 8 6 e BS 2 8 a wb boys he my oa t w@ syed Lg hd o ; f ay ct o G m © ey FD HOR & & 5 eo 2 og og 2 oh} ty i os , "4 w se qs a , ~4 _ a bee o 43 ret H & 9 & é ol ® 9 8 2 o GD 8 D5 C, rt og 8 o Oo mM @ 8 @ & a, gc: 7 :
oa | ard re es u i cd mh £3 3 O ut 7) "4 cg as ch id . % es 4 o @ G ag o $3 SI ae Q ro a ~ U o uv 2 ' eG thea & a 9 "4 (3 G 4.3 ' as 2 w oe O a5 th bs oO @ ro ie ved cs a ef 6 Q © @ S ¥ cal eo 3 ty bed * ce) . bj hy ca a CG * a ty hat Gs rh "4 ty Pt ay ord wn a o wn a 3) ins £4 ng 5 " hed «6 a ae 4 @ 4 " a ty v ol ' a 2 Q wo 7 po 4 & 8 2 BF BB mH eB o 8 we m@ HB g Q & u rh 2 32 a " ip oS a 4b mH " @ rf " MM oB co Be 8 , 8 4 SO 8 ~ 2 & 6 = g@ g 8 @ 8 &4 ste) 4 wy oe ed % a ba i. da vine. io g o we od @ 4 a 0 fd i oe o st eo po . ~ wt 4 we - 4 Bn ed +, goo 1 fed ad A " " 2.6 & 8 @ fe Bg EF 6 S SG @ of GX 3 ~ 5 -e4 43 Get i. fe) . ms : 0 C aS "rd 3 w 44 ce 1B ms is i vod 3 S4 * sy ta c < , weit is at "ed hs ts td : wD 5 C
- ra] wh o at 3 ha hey rn 5) Fs pet be iy O @ wo 2 ty , % "3 "5 Retard mm BH sgh uv mG oo a a ne : po x is 4 hi L of wed 4 om . 0 ti D 8} } & Ea O ci wed ww w . eon eal 4 x uy of} ocd " 4 r~f ; tt a 3 4 KS zo) 43 8 ee av u - 8 4 he » 4 8 © Bog yo ® oo CO op» Bk 6 ref 3 a $2 a "a as " t3 ra i > , @ os : a a 44 2 oO . ' a co es Ch oa ea o A 3 a ct @ 43 im ¢ 3 ' ra "ny 1 3 oh ie re mM 4 a nt WA wt vd a "A n 43 we 3 oy ; # a ~ a ca iy Om, 8 © Se eo 0 TG gg fo Do # & i OY eS fe HS ob we a q o Ge 6 8 n Sa 6 wo r ® ' C i cy Fs we A is good o a u v @ $e of el x ts o Ch $4 pom Dy ad o a As a 8 a 5 a 4 2 3 tg ia bf : . By ' om we ard Q : mo . a i :
Q an) re o rh . ) wp s at ; yo OG ed 5 mo OM BO Ho eh OM eS ee > ey O + @D ay ca a pe Son a o o rs a '6 @ we M @ i QO My mG ad 8 # | } 1 * s ?
g 3 ft OO hh a ik 2 f h « 3 ats Cc kp Ty Gf Gt Hy Bp Dy fy oe Oy ad. with O.A.No, 1091/1999 ies Ot O OG % & HH Uw tT Ye w 44 44 Ab sed ved srg a Bd rh 43 bes da 43 x bg fag ord 43
3) OANA I MA No. 252/2007 @ and Ors Vs. G u C 4 + a i w 4 KS Thy he ws rs m ee a B i 5 id F93 bt rt a Bs :
j yo te gy e B % m cS Be OO se 3 a oe 2 a verd st '4 Set wb i} Oy o 4 04 9 ba UO wy % ry $y ee "i 5 oo CA BM Ss + oo & a 3 ot a w ty EES o3 aad 9 "ey & 3 sy & a od a YE 9 th ee ty oe "A . el On G4 ey uF (2 3 fs ie a AD oy "e] .
i ui c " , > fb om ha -O cop TDs. a at a . @ 3 . sty h ie wg wl re "4 My OR G4 ne yy a 5 raf go be x t cs naa) noe oy C3 at o a wh "A * 9 a a 53 Meg a Ch, g . an oo «eh nh 4 ry 1} c @ a B oe Say a 43 @ ae am, td % a ~-- aa m4 ov - soe co OSS & ws. cs Be ar 44 ¢ BE oy remnp Oy Thy gg RY a ep eG G 04 4 9 mw MO SS ty a os % ey hy %) a <2 ro OLS ot O we OM a %& 4 e a $ 3 A my | Oe $ ay ed Mace YY fy £33 hs Lt b yy 3 2, s G hy & y 40h ' } te QO 2 Cy tn, a a 3 4) Ch Gyorgy Y yy ot & i oe a ee wo Coo By LE ey . M 4 mrd O ty he de ogy He % @ * os - eon GE O&O OR Ay os > 4 0 o aa ~ & diced 4) 6) O Vor 43 og Bw OM Ih © ay i @ OB Bret Goat % Me oO a Cp ceg Mord ad 48 3 teed fe db rey fy, $4 43 ts, $i Soy te IS iS ye Ad 4 aocep fF DG hi fo m4 ) my 3 fF . tg SY ae oe $a ke a ~ (5 8 O De gj SH OG he Se a Go G ns ae FD Ds by e Gia UO 8 Ge Oo O a + 3 ott oO « ois) oo rt a 8] so Cy * ig . hi jj 4 of iG n oe th ;
I oe it 2/2007 : ed as O.A.No,. 1691/1999 oa OA No d7 1288 MA No.2 a "eg @ oa a sing aed
3) pa vies fey oy iy Q} ef £ "yf hu vpet 4.5 uh 3, sg oy seq oy so w A A AS 4.3 o And "pf a x & £ tt 4 Fh vend AS oD cA whe od & Moe * pref we 3 "ed "mf AD ten} hy au Ay & a 4 AE ig tt ces Aion a.
G hed Ts weg t> tsi Q judgr "4 ta:
oresal:
ey ext rer 4 Yet id ne while ing ra © > eBASion M ~ oo ea we PLU/2007 Ra OGANGAT MA No. 2252/2007 connected with O.A.No. 1081/1998 Su Rumer io bea @ 44 iy is QB 4 $3 oh Wt es Roa ke wy vy 3 ef aah «3 os) t Anandrao Shankarrao (Supra) w! ¥ a a & aye xt {3 ng $3) £3 ip @ ti} © ce riot 43 wee gs cai abe ded "
Aas 4 ice io '% tie ee) ne da, 2 z FLiCe BEN oF iw iD 4 poet Aol the oiee iS> tat seed ed iced cs ee eh 43 ef a5.
4 Tobe, a @ on GANS. L2007 MA No. 252/2007 connected with O.A.No. 1O91/1999 @ ba 1G v4 Q hed ct yee Nae De Ne US ¥ b WWE "4 % £ cp oo ba «ed Law SFR
36. the ew that ~y4 v oy a '5 g bd Oi and eed ' Sigh nan eyes neixr
a) hee c of as Ce iS r Peery oy sianary pen .
s@Pit BONG aa te Net 7 G CS x eos 1A yonden the resp Ne worn wre} Sea Hed a hy 9 $3 m Ba i Ly oO ® La of pension purpose * Sar fying a &quall ay them x Cs and {in}.
;
i above at view the Th ng i eenk rod 6 fy seed See oO uy rd 0 COP + fe a a ealevant Em tne Lith + u t nee wi % OA No. t7 1/2007 MA No.252/2007 gomnected with GO.A. No. LO9L/1995 gr Ac beg h tere ve See oe Oo © od AS ay Mh iD M+ 43 tc ed ee.
hn Ry a may Nn a G oy 64 ved oy re B bel B vex ride imstar ard
37. t {A} Member (De. Bhagwan Sahai} angh} Mamber. (7) » a oe 5 wor ft ° x ee N {R.