Karnataka High Court
G Ravindra Reddy vs State Of Karnataka on 13 July, 2009
Author: Manjula Chellur
Bench: Manjula Chellur
:3 was HEGH 3932? GE Kagxgwaxaf 5AN§§E§§£ Iu ngmgn THIS THE 13§*a@y a? JvLyg"2a¢§iT=:*:* BEFQR$~m_ wag HG§'BLE mas. JUSTICE fiA§§6E& c$gLi§£,'k'
cr1.9}3g?5/gees V ER fig % .M 2 3, Ravimdxa Reddy W Sfa Qavinda Raddy "T Agad,abaut 31 year$H yroprieter Qf'_ ; "v ._, fifs. $riniva$a ?erti£i§e£w 'U fiaax B§2,Sta§dwq Hiafinpar 293$" ' ?avagada* "*7 mugkgz Eist;i;£_ . ¥ _ _; ,¢¥ FETI$EQ¥ER {By gr; *$$ K; §a§k§§a'§edfiy; gay'; sag; % §§ét¢ge§ Kazna%akg .'3y fiéeégéiasgeatcr Qum . *§£$iéfiahth§ixectar af u'.£§zicnlt§r§;"§avaga§& '?umkar fiisfixict 3." §E$§fi§§E§§ {s§,$r;§ 5, R. S. Bkat, §ce§} fihia firi,P is filaé andar fieatian 432 '> €z;§.£; fig tke fifivocata fax tha pet£ti§n%r ;pra§iag thai this K0n'bi@ Qaart may ha yiaaaaa ts .Jq&ash the jgxsaeedings ig Ca£.§e,22f2$G§ an tha ! bx.) a fiie $5 gfififig Eavagaa far the effenca §§fi§$§ébia under Séetimn 1§(a}€&} 9% the Seed ~§$t .vith re§§&ct ta this §at:tiQnexw ." "' '* ~ Ehis €rlb§¢ caming an Ear fieaxéég t@£$ §a§§'. the caurt mafig tha f¢iiewing;m_ a R E EVE T"
fieard tag ieaxaed ¢$€m$ei f§:=§§$a§e£iti§nef anfi aifia the Gove§fimgn§ §§v§¢§ta. 2, Ehe admitte$ fa¢i$;i§"é§g§ ¢&se 33%:
§e€i%iéfigx héxain is tfie §€@§Eiafi®E QE §§s; $riaiva§§ {§§§ti£;§§g¢"»§;n£§§§r Raafi, §&v&gafia§ §umk§:_fi:s::3at; '§é gag garrygag $3 fihfi business 1% gégfifi 'xa§§"_ §§f%:liz$r$ aftax fibtainimg z'::%€.;%::$$ar§V Zi.::'¢éér:¢é' ir; aha zzazra axzfi gigjia sf zéfs "*.'§§:§:§as&_ yegééigzez, an E$sE§»E$%% at a%@§: ";§;§§Ki§;m{ ;t%e re3§aada§iw¢sm§iaiaafit 333$ ta hafie _vi$ifiéfi, his shggs gremises fiar i§$§aati@a, A: %§é;tim af in5§e§t:o§; he féfiflfi stfick §§ é,§$ *V§§:§taig $5 fifififlafiéf saaég wéiah fififiifi ha A i§é§€i§i$& £5 %§§zié'$mmfi§%§r éfifimlfifi witfi iét zm.Ef?$22 yaaiqéé in giasfiémc acntaiizsxs af 2 'kgS$ eagh, 2% is alas gm: 1:; éispfite téaat fifiirfila seeés meta iaken. §"'2';3;.§ was fr¢?!E?7{§" fim: af §.G$ qfiaintais sf seecm avéiisgblséu x3'2.,'f:;'@f§i'£ gaafis wera '§'i1";QEf§'fi§'§:l§»" m.:£.2:&§'. 'T $q"éJi&3. fimrtgg mm §a§<:f§é'%:: %s2*$.';:.~.* »§?_33.'::*¢;azi'~.__ ' yetaltianar, a:m'€:%;_;@x* *a«za:$i"v.._3i:?<:fc;ai.g:m5'é.--.V_ méfik: tize z::*;o§z$.'§,a3f.:';ant 333$ tfiéa *;£:E:;".i..zf:.?}§g ; xéégss semi £15: 3233 fififistm §.%.1"fiG"£3*;'?§" @;'?""'v;%r§x'i£'5f§i*}.;.'§?%.T§E:t¢%§'~.' L gae$..s fasting Lah ,3 %av°;'.rii:;a;,§'§.%':-':';n=;=,s,.V 'féi: V?;e;:sé%3;2?:{j '°:;E§1e peraentage éf §§ez%2m"v:':é;'5C':;€.raz:~3;j;,V ::m&° *E;1:i:'*E<§$§ af thé saafig; '§;aé:>3:§;:;$g "?:._$"~fi§:':a petitiaaerg tize zcegaxt 3% the %§i.:33;l3,?:s;Vi.--_ :§::X'§'£ii: §3;.'E§3sEE§%E% affice gave flag §éT:'§§&gz_i'%;agf_$ $£ §'€,?%3?§§;3§,R3ii$E§ at §2%a.$ agaiagt '?§% W V./W. ' gezzzaizzatisziz greaaribad. As it xag bg.;»a?"9§?*':I:;1%:$;§ §;:?.:%e:.~rsazf:e;%e& parzzzentage Gf gamrginatianf :55 gfiggéfit amgiaifit game ta be laégad fig tke Assgggiéizzant not azziy aagaizzst £3133 getitiézxez but 'zgigaé agagast $339 nmaafastézzar sf gaifi ggéfig Exam ./.
"ta" the-' 2 »LI.>..3
whmfi yefiitianer ailegaé ta have §mr$§a$eég i.e& 3:1 aama sagas Serymratgan af Kri§hfiéff;;§3$& guznacl, gnéfiza §xaé¢sh, $ggxiave&~£§t t§e_3a§§b a regigtratiém Qf the aase, fi§9:p$§Sé$%,§@%ifi§§nri5 filed: ' . V é. Accmrding tg £§§ §§ti%$§§e%,'Eth$ vary aamplaifit againsttfiim:§%l§§;Dénsta:fi§$§e aa the fimgles werg c$$;¢fi§%§fia£r§§ f$hapened seaiad amntainers $%§§liéd fifi hi$ By fifié 2"§ aceuseé Sr: Rama Seé§$J£%f§§$&E$%fi*§$§ §£é no: befaxé afi. Ea aisé yzgééé §é£ia3@§ am the gurahage bill $f the §ee§s*u¢a:e&. 1é,:§;é$$é. £5 §@r ihis ggzg an 1:¢l§§2§§é iWé--Var£é:ies af saaflswer see@$ wfize w_A $$§§;ie@nkfi"S:i" Rama Séééfi fifirgarafiiag ta the ' =§£$$eg% *§étitiQfi§§; af wfiich age 25 Eybzié *§ag§:¢gazxg§§ ~ Efifi unéaz 1&2 ma :?§22 af § fiig §§§téiné%$ aantaimimg éfi §afik§t3 and aaeh gA'§a$t§$fia: havifig 8 paakats.
u E?-
gaadaatafi. igeg fiavb 2§$§. gs gar the 7§&§e§5 fiuznishefi, thé date Gf vaiiéity 13 fi§i§ L§fi§@, Efiflfi. fiherefara, there :3 fl@ dfia§én¢fi é§ §ar ' as date GE galidity Qf thej£as§ a$Vzaqu§ie& fi@fiér zgie ? sf t%a Aat, V V . V ?5 S3 5:' as tamygéiggxuaf t&é' céntainers, Qtfig acacréing ta "thg gpetaiiénerg the antire saeés wage, fsuné,fa:n., fifi$§@fi$fi. acntainezs. Eherefarag 3?" ali"én§.Qfié~i$ xasganaibla, 3% wafiid ha fléhe R2¥§V acéa§e§V'm Srx Rama Seefis $sr§axat£$$_ gf ,'i$§na. aagarg fifigaasif éfiééza §3ad§sh; §§"$fi%§ §e;ng tha ail&gat1mn mafia by %ha_ §@%i§:$aé:;_ £% was igaambefit ugem tfig §a%itian&§ 'is ---- ~§ke ika Qmfi &£fifi$@é 33 2"
* fiégpafiagfifiga E9 is %rying* ta say" ax ih§cw° Egg 'AE£ame Qgaiagt tha §ez3a§ wéa ig fiat befaxa fiefixtfi §¥§n ,¢tE%r%i$a; w§&th$zT fihexe wag tmperifig af A;t§e Nsgaigg ¥%@th&z' :3 was :3 hha arigimai afigiaimer gr ac? as ffimmfi at tka :§¥aiaa méfi by S3; Eam Saafis Csrpstaiian is & guestian §f;fa¢t wkisk san $59 $32 aniy at the time $§_%¥§ééfi§%:_ 33 Eheiafareg far thé abave $a;&,:%%$¢ai§g,""
ihgre ara me gaafi :§ugds'a':ai'--§uash"' tha gxcaeefiings p&m§ifig agaia§%2 the figtitionafia in ¢,s.:~za2. 22;'2a§5 mt: t%:é"v..:§i--.ié ;"'--. §}a%;+;é§.g'a&a§.'§' §§we§@z; geiitimaag i$,"a% *§ib§rt§ 'ta v%a:s§ all t%a fifibfififiifififi éi fihé §§ fig fispasal af tka safie $3 znyiig. W§ifi:V§§§aJ§$n§§§%i¢ns axe iaft cyafi ta be mégsiéérefi at the tim Qf digpagal sf the vcase. ::§§:+;:::~:s.., §§& Vétfifiiéfirsfigfifig fiismifiaeé acsagéig 1 , ' .§ V .. _, 861/ 1,...
Fudge .§ai;3:;,.?,:§'?;§*;;{%§. _ V