Karnataka High Court
State Of Karnataka vs Sri J.P.Choudhary S/O J.Jakkareddy on 3 July, 2009
Author: V.G.Sabhahit
Bench: V.G.Sabhahit
,....._...,. Vem\dP|'U'l\?£ W mmmmm mww uuwm W mammw. HWH cmwm W mwmmm mm! ww » s671~?3,;667s, 5832 as 739412906) IN THE HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA at 5 V BANGAWRE % A % DATE nus THE 3" mix or n,r:.%s?%%2oo§j . _ T Z % THE HoN'aLE MR. an. zu:mc%n % ms HoN*aLEr.iR.msfr1u:}: 31.9, sasnmrr Dcmmmw4%Fm1y Welfim M%S..Bm1din& A % é Senrices, 51 & 2 coma; in A.Nas.33'll-'I5, ...I=m'1TIoNms (By srilfi Am) wwuna UH!" mmmwmimmm NEW" MWWWW ,9L¥jE"' WKWNHHMKM WEWW hfififiéfii WW flfiflwflififlfl waww "m3JUK§ WW wwwemumxm WEE?" uwwm WW mmfimmammm WEWW MWWWE 1.
SziJ.P.Chw%, Sic» Jjakkaruddy, Aafid 43 Y¢m._ prmfly wormg w ' Ofieeeft1wDistxictHeg_Ith AndFam1yWalfmeSenfiegs, "
Be11my583 191.
2. s:iL.s:ipadmq5m Sfo Lag ' '_ Aged sbm1142 yzam-,I"
pmmfi:r*%w'¢aMts as Sign H_.B _ " "
Aged abw%45%m:s, ; ' " prm1L'3a_wer1:iézg m &:f11& Tradman, " ofthsfiimict I-math mad *. , _ 'FamiiyWclfa-e Smrises, s:eL%sar:e;%a*vmkamm:hy,, eb*out48 yam.
~ prmatly worhhg 3 Shfied Trudi V of the Dimict Health mi ' Fmmly Welfme Sexviccs, up -.»....w awwm wwwmm awmmmumnmmww uuuwrawé Mwwmfi mmwmmzmmum Imww Mfliwfli Ki?' Wfiflmfififlfifl Niwfl LQw%"¥"' WW Sri 8.8 Axjun, S/ca &B.Ba1q73'xae, Aged sham 42 yams, prwenflyworwxgas Sh11edTradc& om ofthe fiimia I-Icakh am: T « Fmfly Wfilfflfi Sri s.L.sm~mnm s/9 Late NL ' L Agedabout {$7 'y§':'ai'='ai « If -- om £>f"t}:'x§.I3igg1:::°;'£' A T0%*Iifi'v311Cir¢i¢--%%J'%%~% & " ;.SJo.._R.V.K.' 3591:: 46 yams, "V '" T. w Tradnsmmi, T fifths " -Fmzily Welfam Servicfi, Gadq.
wnvwwmnu . H». wmmwmnmum mm-u uuuwmu __a..¢-;-- wmmmmamuw-as ¥"l|'£U7E"'fl MWMKI UH" mmmmnammm WEWW Lmuhm Uta" mmmmmmmm Wérémsw %.,.,€,,M+.$W: wv mmmmmm Wfififii %.'."U%.M$.%' Sxi Ashokliumaz Ska Lie AF Aged aboutsfi yams, 13%}? wnmtgm &il1ed Trademnm, Omafmnfiimfictfieahhmm Fmfily Welfmascrvlees, I 4 Hcms'mgBom'dCalony, Bmgabzara.
Sfi Sic LateDe'venht, Asedabomiiiiyams, prwcntlyworhnlzgas ' ' Grade-II, 1i. -, s%gx.$;zmm'
-E90 S.T.K1is1mmnunhy, Asfi sbw E years.
pmmfly wo&1g w 3% Tradesmm, Dim': Health ma Family Welwflice, a mum vamvvwwh Axvssehcamfuiet mmwgarwm» wag VW5 mwmmwmmzmmww swwm wwwww war" mmmwmzmmm imww fimwmma: wee' mmamwmwwum Wéwfi Luum W?" wxmmfiwmmm wmew %..UU!'H
12. Sri K.'I'.Gu:n1rg5, Sic S1'iB.'I'him1m: Gowda, Aged abmxt 45 yams, as Sm-vim ems.-. efthc Distant Hcahh *~ & Fmtity Welfme Oficgz, ' Hm; Dimer, .%..aEsréNaEms (By Sxi -»_ _ "
WRIT PI.2:1*1'r1<:>2:z%is; SECTION 225 AND 22': INDIA mama T0 BY ma KARNATAKA BANGALORE IN APPHCELTIONVVL 371 T0 savsmms cm % TO 5673, 5573, 5332, 73m AND 37.952993, ETC.
u wart mxmox CGMING UP FOR % A _ Pnsxmxmmv Hmmm cm '11-as DAY, SABHAHIT 1., kiwm nmrmowmez
-cu.-w. .. u-u-a.-..uwunw um nvnnnwmsmrws nlun ywunl-ur nflflfiflfiflhfl HIV" «wax! 3.3!?' Wflfiflfiiflflfi NH?" "OUR"? IO rains forms abomm orpm ifit is so max i with pmeam known to my 02.11.2095 mi ' Ak qggaeved' by an aid om u 97.95.2008 amwrsrpemmns"
5. We :i§.a%%%j% Mwxvw " Gfi vmGo%tAmw be memo abolishpoa wlimhhadbem Am cm & ' mum mdtheK.A.T. xw$%1§§i1jua5i'ndh1settingm5dethnorda. on the cam and, mm mm apmy far rulamthcstwuneeauldsxotbcnbofishadbyiimestoawva orders w1daAm':1el62 fim ofhfiawMdw \)"
ii Hotfbls Suzmzme Cam': in various deafiens the I<'..A.'I'. m also an: amisxon or this cm in 3302 (m mi. mxrr v. %3%'r}A?£: %m# KARNATAKA AND OTHERS) * ma by the K.A.T. is justified ig % war: pm' 'om andthe itcb¢%%§emide.%
8. We have fl_m; V' swntmom of
9. The elm show am this pm mgf med by flaming r-alas mam' 12mg" ruins, tho ma could not be . exacative ordm tmdu Axticle 162 of the r % 'cm of ma' 'm visit' of the decmon' ' af this Couzt in %%% kn..§ mu ICAR 3392 (am M.v. DBCIT AND omms V. % " STATE op KARNATAKA AN!) ommzs) wnm it is
-nu-In-n.n:~u Iv: rs:-|l\I'Ir'Ill1l\l'I l"ll\wl1 l'~'.;fl"'l"b.l'§.!§.i'Wal"fi'fl"l"\Wr-5"! 'I"'lI'fi9§"l"a'M¥l.ilCfi KI!" fl%.l"'lKi'€#'\l'l*-Qfl.f\' 3'11'??? MVJVKI wr fl.l'%K¥Wl'\Wl-Illflfi KTHJTS LKJWKE kg?!" fififlflfifififlfiifi I"'IIE"l'E VWJWMI aluatlyhc1dt11xoncaKiCivi1ScrvicwAct1978m:¢ \?
www wmwww my-Q "fiwfllm - .. __ _ "H" """"""""""'"""'°' I mwmwwmswma euwuwmm \-I'Iul'k*l\g% 'MW! W%:l"'|§'fl.¥V&""&fi4"'K|!\uP"A lfliflflll '|vmHfl'4fl'I\I 'LI! 1\I'1X\lWfi"&fié9"'fi%'§n#"'% fl'3K5J'fi"8 Vaflffiifli VJ'! I'\£"'8i'\§V£""IIl'¥E\P'I TIIMWIT MIVJIJIEI i2.
nnormcemestaeaemmoairyozmpheeazynaéfigsmzmz mum' to ' of cadres or flung' in cm of Section 3(2) rand s Kmlfiakfix '. Civil Sezvices Act me! not by ¢ ;mac1§ 162 ofthe
10. It is ha powmo abolish but the mm is to be Tribunal he resmrud to abolish the peas in mnenfig flu: provifiams of the % T: J %%%%% «MomwmwF _ W I " Xjggguaas in momma with law. Thnmfmc '3 is c1ea:ss1;wseoadamwaby:heIn1ama1is;ua;5ea' ' mddoes ' " fiommy marozmal1ty' was call forn:£erf:aw' efw£ ' ' ' arms couu:m1meny' when H&vwtot1wWzitpctn1on¢1t" szaaeowammmin Wfl}EW.
\..7* u..;&§§.iv_.a.§ x 33...»:
. , *- 'Scl;'=?. .15
'writmtizions an ciianaisucd. Index: Yuma 3: Wubflost :
Hnaylia T' if"
é . E 5 Fa} 5.3 .?..e§._§?,w_§. $.19 35?}; .;.m.y:§ .E3.§§§.._n?w§9$§ ..§§ .£_§aJls §§§§ _..,?«.§x§.s..¢§.£ £3 3:...§§ iaafiaa igiaiggvafi. .a..a.a_ .333) $33.» §ifi§?_£i§ 9} m§.3.},.J.