Karnataka High Court
Smt H Jayamma D/O Late Hanumaiah vs The Karnataka Lokayuktha, on 5 August, 2011
Author: N.Kumar
Bench: N.Kumar
EN THE HIGEI CLOURT SF' K§F§'AfE'A}@ fig? BEEGAKLQRE ff)2:':s:?<i this that 5'-*1 £;§2a;;; of AL1g_;:2.;sE..1 f,3;€}_i_1f'i ' » E3§%IFOR§§ _ TEE HGNBLE MR. ,.1t;$?*3!§1c;fi 5% Wm. pm_x.:<;-:4: N<;.25€:5§:~:.z"%206?£322-€{.:§,L2$;::"' B '{€"7F'JE I}-I E-ZN :
W . V 3 811%.. H Jayamrna .
E)/'<3 E:1.¥;e HE3,T_1Lii'1'1&1i§.:'c§":- . _ Aged ab::_z::--_.A5é.}Ie2§;rs _, Vx701'k1?ng3_as §':§'{:E_b/R€tgi§:;f[IZi"21'£" _ = Krzis?::§1é:i:'éi§:1p'i;'::92; 13": ,, _ -- "
E%21:1g21.1.g;m2.._ ' .
2 Srii} E{ristf.:12§:fp §f}a " .
S ,1 :3 122.132" G C {Eaves "{T§<§_s;:v:i2:.
Vzxggsd aijqsgi E. 356233"
V, .3fi,F<}3*Es;.i:: 2:5; =E*i<m:*.ad Q :3z»1§'€,§:2.r::é " 'VSt;i}~%{€3gis1.re1:"V" """ " ' « , E~§T:":fsif2:7i;§':'*;-1_;'21;::z,2ra:J;:2.
'V 'E§2é;1':,§,{:s;Eé§;?§;% "
_ V32": 1% 'C3;v.CE7£.i.§£}§Ei§"}€f{§{§éi.§EIi"££§.
" E7: _;'=:} {§'z1ng;L:§a;i:pz2 Aggezi :»:b(:u:". 33 }«'€Ei.'{'E$} V n '§€r;§:f'i:iz2g as»: SE,§.7i}AR€f§.:§1§Si.ET2§1' "fiféih 2§.'::'fi<;2: 1' " Efiziiiggai fifffg? ' mi Sr: K M A<%E'1.2,:E:'E'":g~: Kzm"1az"
55/5) Iatfié K Knme1:'2t:$x%:e1z'.njg2' Ag<%ci a§:><}:_1i. E3'? jg¢::2:.rs;
W{>1'E<.i:'1g; as; §*'£:'s-9:1. §}§.'v"i§§E§(i}E'"I A:-;a:%s;§::ésE"21;":'£ Ce11E..ra3. §{e<::};"«:E E-T%<><:m'1 i8€s5hac:§:'ipazm3;:1 E3a:1g§aE.o1'e ~ 560 @120 S35: K 3 £32ir§ss}1 S /' (2: J' z»:.gz1d1's3.h Agemfi &1b€}?.j'E 30 3,-'e21:'s's W<>'rE«:ing 3.2+; 'E"y"§>i:e;¥:,,--g _ 1 .
®f§i::7€ <21' {I36 I':1ss;3€::_éf€';-** Gr~:'-:am€';:".:x::I' RegisE';'2m'e'n zmci S1,:-z.$r"s_i:ps'L._V.7 * "
K21Veri.Bh3;\»'a1'1 ' V ' Bazclgalweé _ Sr: Raga 51121 'I[_. _ S/0 N:2r1e.g{3g>wzf';: » ' "
Ag;€d'T';:.bg§s;1.£. 5' if: ; :*.ai'1°:'~ss KR-?0:"L£i:11,g§V 215:;S§%érz::1d.._{)é:3§::iGE': 1-Essis-Eiazrzi. O.ff3_lc:é {)I"'i,}1:{ SE:.b4TI'i§ég_;_;;'..§i4§.:ir Shi'9'V3:§i'1:é£1§§&1;<. V 4' V E3&iI1§_§&?;§€f;§'"$?v V ' '5;;;'5:ii_ E': N 21r;1j§*a':323_ £33.31»:
¢ S f'z:3E-a3i!r>{.§ ad(§a£.hi:1'::nz2§aEr:
, V .éF:'§.':V\f§'E:E{43§' a,«Ei><.i::_'§_, 3;"£3.az:s--:s '*2-"*;;'<:>v: jiE:E;_§fELS.>S{%&f{}§E£i }}£vis«-:;iz:»2": z'-'a:'«:~;$§si.;::2E: A "~<'3§'f'i{%:;{7{>«i' fS:w:%)~E?{@g§§s;§:.:'a2:° __ E§21$:~2:*!;1§i:22§z.2{£i Ei%g§'f2§§a:i<3:°€% L ~ Sri R21} <;:z'§<ir;»';
_ff:1 fa; S C E{a§':::z;1§2s.h fagesi 2i§3{}§.§i'. 55 :giEi§:§.§."S%§ ';'€<):'E~;i:':§§ as Ef}'§zrés%;§<:n fiSf5%§S?.EiE'}E..
'1'.§":.<i: V" 211:?-"L é;}£'f' JL1.dg3;t:? 5%: E73p<:is;*E;:?:..E z,,F*a.1<.§;g:é E933" Eg{)k.22;};:,2.E<;.E.§:é22: f:§:?;.:'1§;j2-fi<§:s;*{%' €i§'§'.j; {{i{,';E~§~;~Z3} :':3(} faif em :;.}:;:'£i1.i:>':':a-'r:'s:=, .2-11%? {_Tt{',>3'1{'E{'.§"1"1.f;'?:d. é "fhis '£«'s;"é'ii E3.-2E,it.§{)1'1 ("f€)E."£"Ei§'E§.-§ am €252? he3£s:'i:'1g'_§' 3%: e:§.é§_§:_:"E;':";€; C<i>u:*':'. magi»:-=? 'LEM': §'<}EE<.3w.i.z'3;g:
Q 1?. Q '1"E1<=, [email protected]:£{;2z'1€rs-i; £11 éfihiss \,x:»;:%i_. §::@i,v37;i,':-s:}§:'i*:»12*'<: §1::f*';{.ifa?r§%:,, L' {':z"{§.€z" or £ii:'€<.711§<)1:T: <gz1z1sE1i§'2g 7{";f _ '£9 €.E:<é ;:2:';é?;.§%.i0m-#2" 33:; £316 Acid!' {?§§,:'§'§'H$:?V' & Sp:%Ci21E Jiltigéi. Bzmgafare City {CC}-1-l--23}L'v'.'a'."}.S§>;:g:{ji:.:I '{1€§'_.N031. 300?. 2, "E"h<-3 '?;)t:1;i.t.E<>1f:é:*:%§'21%;? £:}'_H..V:§}'L1ff,'3v-.§.&Z.':~.'E5?i%Z"VE}.1T11ES wor§<.1?r"1g in D€:§)e1.:.'ii~:3.€.£1._'é .<>f"i;1i'eV<§s=:3::€:;<.Sij5§i'€ .<)f K3u"1'1z1.§.21ka' Pci?;i'£;i0m:rs»i and
3 v<,:=c;*:"e wo.:jk.iz:g ass ;'T~':.:§;>;§~%?;tig§'ét.:*a:'$ 21116. sseC:{31:1.d §>e:::i.i1:§m1<:~r was w£}:°k.E::";g§; E3€.z:.iQé°"SuE}?§?.€g;i:5§.r"z:.:". wZ3§{:§': is; .21 G:"«:)':,:p~§: pG:'~_sé in P:31;.ii.§{3':'1&::rs;--4 anti 5 25%-'é;%1.'é.=: w{)r§~:§1'1g as E' E:2<51':
A*if}i':?i$:im!::._}1§§§é§$f:::§:é~i': eimi '§'j«;§>i$E, in i.§'}€' =.<;-;e::?<:i {}§f§{:{:% :":;%5=;:3€€§.§.v€;%£§;.
"'i"E':€, §§22_§{§v.{:s§"'€§{.téi ':,E':é:: :"a%§%;.*§:';21:1E4 §'}<>i:'2§. <3'? %Q:§n":e,: §1'§:%;,§'é;:T§>§1s:3_z*5sr~§fair are: *é,a:m°Ea§z:;;_'_; age; S&é:t<>:2<i §}§'~J§5",-3§{Z31fi As5;s~s§.$E'.21:1:.s £22 1/ §
3. E¥?;@5§;_f)<>:3{3;e:':'E:s;~i zzmd 2; E'1zT:\.-'9 fiifigi <?Z:~;._:%'g.<;_¥"<.§§§?:A§%£?i. 5-15;§:«3;i:1:&sE. E:§:<t §:)eE..§t.3;<;>:.m§f:~3 f-:72? {trifle->z1<%<3s;a :_1§"*;{}i@':' E.-§:%é7.§.3i.:).;'T:V:§~;'vL. E3{E}{d} and 33(2) {)5 '$15? §):"%3'L-'€',E'1'H(}§'§ f3§'C!'f3§'E'E.E§§£§§fi ifflii: ' §;h«:>§°L §}i31'€f§§'1£1§'3;¢:?1" :*<;%§E:"'m::E M} 2.-is {.§'}€';', '7'z'5';f."::?""';' " (P1"éé*~.:*;2'.(§%;:.:»:; :.~;ar:£_jELi..<i{i.vi--bf the G{>v5:"1'1n':c:2'£T '<Ji.='£iS 113:. 0b§21:r1§%€E._:fms:§ §3>r§3fi21_{ée'%c.'; ;={§§_§'n;;;..x,v;*it'§1 3:3 V charge sh€e't., §"£{>vx:€\»f:t:: !1?1éf_..._E§%9;:f1'i':%§i S§)ii:<:é,aE fiflzdge E,G0k {?£}g.11i2:a:1Lt€ of the (22158 ziiiffi ::3L1§':i:'1:.0:;-5% is {E16 _§3{'3§..iEi{)I1€§":*-ii, caéiingg' upon then} to 21;:;2;'>T'€%'¢:;*.:¥c>r1'O.'?KO;3.iZQC5'?§ Agéggriexrcé by 'iihfi Said Qrder, i'.§fi.€':"..{)€fi£,i{}£1€*1;é$ am b::;%.i1':fI"€:% i:2':ié§WC<;zuri', athzxiiengézzg ihe ssaid etréer p;a:~;»és"ed:_;b),r §h.'€V1:€A&1E"3i1_€d pfizidge taking «;:4:}gm'.2:anC.e of tha <}§'fénce__ 5211153' '§E;S>>a.,fi1*1§;{ '5;«v2,;:':1.;*§1_<>1}is;.
4. __ '*2:§u';s .§i'01,1?*:_ é::i*'§é.<:e1' <:z":£'.<;é'fl.21ir1i:":g i:}1é:% Wm: ;">€i:i:';i0:1, ~._;g§"22;E;_§.é<{'§;»_i;1'L:3?<r;%.::z1 «:>%"&:E'e:-;:""<V}§' 5:-%i.a}j,r sf 5:33 f1sré,E'3&t§" pZ"0{?€t3diflgS befmre ' €::E*'::-3 ;':§§3é%'a:t;§e4iE.,';;§?,2Va"Eg<;s;€% in CC :'~J::}.3§ /TE?) wE":.§1{:E1 .?:.'{Ti§I€'f'f§E'.H :>'§'c:E€i' E55 ::C»n:§h::e{i f:=:%:*«;{ éime {<2 iégmg': sand is :5'; i"::s.:*»::7:L~': Etiié i.<s<i21;;. L5» " hv '.!'7%_1'3"§ii'f£' $£%:"a?§<i:e:% {if r'::}§':.£<':€; éiété r6s§3€}'z":s:i:--3:':t$ i':n:é3*;"€%{§ ;2§,»;3L¢>;1r;1§§T<:t<% zzzzd fiééstuzi :+;"£.2:%::%:m%n'E, {sf €'ft}jé?£'?'i.TEi')E'}§S:;_ '§'§":e3; {::';m<"::"2r:%e<i <57 'E3 €?'§;.i;€.'.i'::§: . ' %E':2.1.i. ii is; <>r1E§: am-:=.;.~ dllff £'rwe:~";§.ig§a£'.i<}:': a;:j1:.§ W1?;:;1iE.ca.E,i.e:3':':, 232:': au:.§1<)ri%4ir:%:%; Eaafzw $:3L:g§'1% §)€'§'i'E':§E.~}f€§3i(}I'E 0? {ha {1--<)'«.{'*<';*,';~:'"2;%%'1'5:-'22:.1*;, as §}i'<>S€*:€,Tu'§'.€3 éhejé ;.>e'£.3i§,§€}:'":<:>2'. §§<>v«:c%v:'%§2 ii': visgva: EIEFOEZGLIE'1€T€fIE'§EB?"S Si' Eh? ii-~E<m't3ic= ;'E-§:.':§):*:3.::1e {fig 200 mg; mg 4:327 g';}R;1;<;r:szjT1 sszwaigé-37' 3U£'JJ'z%B,3 and 2001??' 5} KL} S'f'ATf:T GE' EEIH/85%}, -s~;an<*%'.§cm :.1.i1:v:,§:é%1¥. Se<::.i':>2'_1V <';EV"""v}.f.§rV;V{;:JV:V Act. is' auE.cm'1a1.i{: and I'l';mm.21}. V2Vi..~'~';;}<':;3<:1;.s.¢;' éi'1'{=,,0? :§<r;_ 1'(>,§E?"."'<':ifi€3,€i': in View Of Efiisea 3e3§_2:z»z.E ;:=c>sa:i*;:ia'>:1' "fhté Cgifix-'e?Lm':"ric:rzi:.1,,'$253.3' 'baumi in aCC{}i'd SEiI1CfiOH. Z51 .vi««f;>j;a.r"-.<}f §£:h€_, f:~{>}S;i§,i€>:§LI' e11u':1c.:iz-m:=:«:"1 by Ehe I-iQr1'§::E€ SL1;}1"ém.Cf ..C€}¥.."i1"t7._ii"L_{.§1€_"21f"€)1"€3S21§Ci {§*€§€'.i$i(}I15:§§ :30 prioz' sa1;1<:i.i{3 (1: 'ii {ht-5: {}{}VE:'i"Ai"zf§1'€:.'£i}ii"$5 :"€:quz';"e{i €19 p;'<3s:s:;:=«:>u1e 2: g}ui:z»Ei<: 5-aé3:'va:7:'{; _ T%:€3:'-€~é§'<§i'€'€ ibkjéji s(}L.zg;?:§: 501" {fis-;miS§321§ Of E1h.€:=. vusm: "E?-';i{§:'2:. éhéi 21f<>reSaid §:g»1<::'i:s:;, £1; ::.};s.-éai" ftxazut. 33} E:§';s:r peé;§'%;'r§?L'35:'E£;%:"s:~: ';2i%:f::*..9: §:>Ls?3E17s:?. S€':'E";,-='8_§'E§§?>' Ch2'i.§."'§.{€. Sh€i'.€§E.'=3 ans: {E2613 1%}: a3f§"<;:*z°;{::':s.e :::'::::§::*:' £325? ;'a{?'%'. a:z;_§2:£.:'.25;«:':. €3.12: ps%E.ii.i<>z:m':%a G1': €:§:":{% {i2::,::é 2:E';:é:
-.'E§}T§€;'fv';%§;':€§ E.':§"E;'3 £3Z§s:%€.1? E3a%§%';r{;% t§'2<? C/<;}:..':_:*§ 2;m<:§ E315? C<:m"*:. '§,€}{}§'; ~ V. & p§.'{><f~:;:éi:{§i;3§;"'* :{;;g:'1%.;s:;1:'1<:r€: <35 mt"? 5&3-1§'1'I€. {he §?}€3I'§§'§£i)I"i€:?X"E-S w::--:z'é;-2 w<}2'1<.i:':{;4:..§§~:.;?}§é<.: S€ffl='§iIfi'S. ;7¥s:h'21:M.€':€<ii}-*, {:0 :-£éE;i.{'§.:..'.E.i€j)I'} is <'>'§:}f,.2'1§::.:§>:d'"§73'§..':é §~".€;_E:z':: {?€)I}'1p€€.€§'}§ au:i§:mré%.;; E0 p:'<,>s,~s:;?c:2,1{,a? £23.-2 $36.?E.ii1iei)E'1€i'fr§§...iirTE;l'€3 §'c';7a2:':_w.€7{'g Jucifigét "wiéjhmzi. nz'2ii{tE.:':§g {.§"i{' :sa1'e:.§ fag): Z'.-,:A>:>nE: €:5>g§'r1i;ii':1:':{:: =..__<)f?:%;.};é:;e <'}f"£'%:%i1{*€:%s:: g31.:.:3is;E1.;2:§3Ee'? mzifiéer '€'3%'1€?»'}"?%s§If[ a2:1"2d.is'e.é:st.:£%{1 :.SVE.i'.E'§;}";{f2'{}I"1SV§{.8 i.%'1_<§ 1 §;:eE,iE.§<):1€:3"3, K,-v'§11*(:}': ES ::}2'§:=, '»¥J§§l§"£()£.I §"."..}ié£'i§%§{§§«{*fE..ii£}f'}.' ' 'T11<§:;°<':i"{)r='3 it is Eéabis: to bi? zissicia 1' F 1?. ii»; in i.%:.iS JP32;a7k§g:{'é::c:;3nati; Er}. :1Lm:}be'1" GE {,'£iS€S pe1'1di:"2g; beE'<>z':3 jslhigs C:<'j'L:ri';'~E16'=_g1,g«ES-t,i<}3: \,vhi<?h .E1E'{)S€ Em' <E:):":$s;'.ci€f1faii<311 %i$ié1_~s _w}:g:i:i'1;;§.:"ra__ p.L.zE_:iiU SEE' 29311.2. s:i::;:..n bi'? p:'<3S.€<?:L:'¥I;{2<i wi':'.'E';.{2s_z¥. 5.~5a1'1':?£'.i<>z*; ._:.1';1i{{};éé;*"~ Sé'{é*.::'{>:"1 198} of £316 A<:3:. G1: Eéze :":é€,§:z&5§'£'. of '~:h€% k:~%::z;:*'§":s:*d'~~--"{?G:m$:;<3E aepp --%z:ri:1g;:; £111 'ililfi 5-said ., 'E'.E1.::< .'§3iT*:'f1.§§}fii'i1El§"}? §}{}?lE'1i'I iézaé é,1§"(}S<;'. §br {'::m:2.§{i:%.:"21%:ic>12 3323:; ,21§;s1%:::f:Et;:§%:>j,' mis Couré. %.>'§; <:::"c.':r;é:* {§é';i'Ef€-id 29*": 311%; 22$ 3. .31; 2.2': %i'1'%.<%"-§é:._£'<m';é': :,;»:{§:;§<:§?:"., i',E1€: p:.°e§é§1'::%z':e1r*}* ;:sz3:'.m;. §'a22°.::";'z.';§z:m3£§3 :%"@:::<f§;c§ ass :.1.:'1é:::'.;': T ' "'%»E-/'%'2,g§§'z;3:' (:2 51:31.32" ms: Eakg,-9 {R:}§1_"j?'E z':_«:a 2:353 63;"
"2 '*;:';;'j:f"e:':<?e? ;3:.:.:'s£.¢;§'2(z.i?3§g':> :sz':{§e,>:" S::7<*:€Lr.3:': '.72 E0. EE. 3;; arm' 2:3 aiieéggazzf 5.0 f"s{::::@ §;?€?€%?'E <:7<'m'm'2i:£caa' §3§.~j. "g-'.3 ;}§.z§3£'ig:% sez'::(§.;'2{. £.:'..,'-I'.F'1"2(;¥£.ii'_. E_'}7'E&.> pz'c,>z,>=€oi£5 s<z:'2r;:'*£Ea«r'3«;,.§;_"" 5 . z'.f'z.c e*f,Z'@z'2.:.z"af €§(}1>erm'r2»:%:'3 Z1,/' -f§f':f:Z'e;? {}(3z:éz'__nr2<z§%r¢?;.i,%' AuzZ'1<3r:'{;; <:0m_;)e>§.e:?E 310 ?'E?I'E'2€).§,}:1?'§?§?'"i'2'f}.;{}f'?'Ev(éZ?'3§?é??V"
"E336 ',f§§'<;?§.§',:ni:1.:::'E'}' §§c::»im"' §s%':%~:'1:é*.R'{%'{t*,{i [:1-'%_ "§.;.I'1K:vi':<z*:' " i 5. '7"_Z'éé:'3zjs;: {(122139 ~ {me T' :1;fE3«3j€:~';-£zVi£:7':
{}§);'§&?F'Z}C2£{'i(§7'"E. ergzf" file Agiaégzcb {f(2:.z.r§"'-316:3" {E}; be z.m::£ers£o<3d in .:f}u-,3 <?(;rz'£é:<é' Lésfg. Q)?'-z.'i.t?f1 it" 23.4: zféade. '.'§?2e;; wergi poz'.ri.%:m5:;' Z;>:g:;"j3'~ {:f1<3"«:§_2;_;j}T}2:*;>;1::?e> in {he Earzgazage..en1pZog;e:::Z . gr; S'€C2'.:f()I'1 '_f 7:;j" the Cfiédel' ':gme:'.§, T;S%7Vc'§'iz37_ré:_:.; "ii 9"oj.f"z.--§'2.e }1'é;":'t;" in Section 597 Qf Ems' "'-:.;§s:;,¥j{Zs._:2:::<ed "5222? "is acrcumad (gf 5:32;;
§gjf]{%;>%'2::e 'czViiégé3'a:' »_z'1::«.__Eé:;é;e;e §3€'6!"£ {:onzzm'Z,i:<sd by Fain? _ :.::f'n'§'<2 aQ::i;iz':§;-- (}r"v_;3:£?})<}?'£z'r'1g 3.5;: :;z.<:°z' in Zfzza «:§2'scFzczrge Jizis {§[.Ti{3Z'§£,€'__C§.£.ii.§; W?'2c>rc»a:~:, §'}"z.e3 :.z:z;r{fs_~: useci En .4;'3é3.<:£i02"z E 9 are '°'e:s,E£eg:;s>{§ :0 E'2_.5:;::-2. E;»e(5:*: ' ..{7a::n'::=2'2§figéif 53;; {z §}E.£f?Ef{? 5%-3z°z;¢z?'2€.. fr": (75:55: (ff S{%:}:.'§.:j>3%. §jE}§7e i3ej,f?<>;*'::,= a«::%{.'<}n'}§z'z§; $am:éz°.:)zfz. {he °;:r;;,z{?2.{;r:'E.gg §"E{£§'§ E.<;:_;'%'z'2c,i om' z.:J§':.s;>!iI'2€:' £325? (zfieggeai a<r§. V'§za:e~: aim; :Tzw:z.g.:-; E.zE§E':?E 53255 :f2i5;::E':.::2;rga> Q? (izfieas. €ff<>r':.z.?m"$e§;;, z.:.2f"z.:°.£;:s §}'E"£T§?E§'i.§2g $ar'2c§.§oz': :4§.:'2.§§ez* Sg:*<:rz"'§.{:s:'z ES? 5;?' §.§'z.{.2 /%.<.'z'.? :'2:.::2 $z:.{:°§'": <>E)E§§;a:.£0;': £3 {.'€"L'§E3 on éfze? czzz'.§'.f'ze:}:"z"51"z£?;~: §z.<1?:,':0:'cZ§n§; S€{f'E.€j?fIi{}?'E. f:'2_ E.?'V2i.€,.:'.i_ = <'r()z'zI:;?}<z'f' 2'3 zgsag saiici §?z.a.§. zz.m:i<:?z' See:?:€c3r': . A' _»='T§{:?:; 5::z:'2c?z':'i0z'2 {:3} o::z:<>m{::.:':;: s'z.c2z::.:re. .i'f_z:1z, zTz,:{.:zm'S. §§'2.c.> ggzzesf-{i(,>:'z qf azT.zZ'fjI.:m'.§g,;< £.'c',)?.'2'."*.'>;E;.é:;}vV::"f¥""i'.2"V':{2V§,j' r'z.exzss z.£:z':?t £3529' d.z's<fi2.:zr§;c3 {1'a'-z;§':'§%s A' 5;" :5: ;}z.g.!r3Ez'<:* E§'€?I"ifi€/EIEE' :15;_:':EEeg;e:*{%1---{<:§5'§'zc1:z.:e j(*c§.r?'fi}vé12§i{'9cf: . €;:n.;; Q]f'j§%nc:z: z.mdz:?r :"f'z.¢>.VL4'L:}i::§". if. itgilf sazi3i"ie(f a:i3():s£ {E19 CE§i£?%Q]§Z£:fiE§I'§.S;'.,{.£.?§if'E:(§E:fI,{.{i§§f?i§¢ izuo Zhif qz:e$£i.{;z':V A--.._._i§:?T2c>{--?:zeri-- . "S'Z:-{€_."§'} ",QZ_}'E£"%"E£'£? was <i'{}r7m'zz'.:.!e:i zmzile 51::-;.'.z'.A;'t§,IL'V<';ririb _,";;E.LI?f;.?_<'T§*i!":%Ti>'.fV7;5_rf;""{1} as: in 5:328 dis<.*!'2qIig{é pf _$:'};:'z::!fE2r'z grouici) E29 aCc:).fEied.§ f:j: <;.{i'f2eri 'Ei'_:?()!'C.l:£:>T.::"f*§s'!'."+:§ is au{,0rr1aI.iC, .2: is_£;!'2i$Vpf'zré£;;s;?_'E;1rf1:'rz{;zfio;"2 {S10} mz.:oz'naii.c zfzazmzre' is; S0z.;§}_}'i£ 122;' ?j){3*«..¢*or1szrz,:z3d as no scmca':1'zm is 'r;'<2€;u€r¢:dV'z,:}:i.(Je:T~Ss: :i'z'é}:_'_2 .59 Qf' {he Act ffsucrfl cm; iriIé"s-;%:p2'e££§E.£0131Ais ;:.i?:;c?ep:'€{£, £5' s':m:--3 <:0z.:nE.er 5:0 Size ' v g3rc>:>?s§{:»2'z;<;'{%<)z'zz:;":inezf§ £2": rSe.>cz'z'0z'?; I Q Qf 2.318 z§<:E.. {ii z::c£E 5:e§:'€:'2€:i":7h,cz: ca =:;:'.g>c7isz'.{::rz is an; a::5_?20rz'iyfij'e:>r
-- _:.::%§2%:;:.::.':5__ agfiuaiigg <ffé'e:Zfi{i.€E,i. §€s;jj"er'enCe 5.5;: :2: "";;i5a:?Ez7<:':.;'£a.:}' E:%'E3'I'?§€I'2{?€ in €§'E(3 {7{'3?"EZ'€.X§' Q)" _ f1?i{?E.2..i{2§ _:s4::s;%f'§'42f:'<} {::2,:'m{:»Z" Eye 235/2_1c,;' <}z..s.z'. agg" :7(mi.::>:~z£,k ff {E29 ~~ <fg;;'E)z'esmT::"§ :.::r:sz*(i.s {emf in {.528 ti".'{}i'3§i-';"'}€§' is: z,U?2z'g'3E2 3'3" is z.:.5;e(f., if. :19 53553535' aim; sn;r,"z2"2m'.i.»:3s'2 £5; §§'"§E;}{}5S£:T£§ on :"'§'2.e {'ff<.>:.:r§. zzzigéngrg :i*i};;g:2z';:<<z:2.{7e? Qf" z"-2'29 :i§}ff§?3r2a?§: {f7(}??'E.F?'Z§§E€?{§ zzr'2der* Em? A.::'z. 52;; az ;;;z%2E§.<': :3f.<;=m5::z€; if R} z'fi:§'2€;% :1; ,fE::r'{-?sa.i(,2' z.:7ar{§ '£z2z£<'2:?'2.gizfi<.?' is :"é'(2.eC§ €32.53" .Of;'7, ::>a:'zz;:.>::a(. if w::.>:,.:i<Z c2'ejf'E:=::z:: {.326 <>§§jE%(:f :.:,:z'{f'2, Z,i;?,:?';!.Z'{'T}'{2'.".v S{?(7f,2'{}?'i. IE} ezgf 5.5% Aazrf." is r€.'I'E{Z{.'€8{C§g €TZ.?'E(i F£'I1€F§g2??'E§"'f'f1§;?.. -3"
s~,:e<7°{.f'<>:':. OE"E'.{)S€.
E5. ':"f':£>z"s:j['%3ra?, £3': jitfi"/ii" ----_ffff§. f}z.zE3?ie::.,_. ::er:sczr'z.§:$ are {3{}I'E(3é'?'!'l§3/.'i_, £3259'c{)gj;:2i;:::m;féJ, ::}':r2gj:
Q;{}%>:'2:?e by (gray Crmri --v£:§€2:f:fe?c€ £by._S:?::.§z;<}§'z 'fig? {"2153 C€}::i§{;% 8?" Sec'fziz".<>r2 VQ;"=__;if'3:3 .Q»'ie:;€".__ 'E'i'[ee :'r2c:r'2daI.'(>rg,; Ch <1:'§§ii';«.«,z:' 2:-I33 §§':fr;::a;%:f'z;i:)_r2 e;,{]E>:"(Ze(i E0 g:mI2Ez'c sen:ar"zz'.s 1:3' tV3z.::3.._iLjZ)'_1,%AA.';'?1;§_'_.533<'pr°£2ss£{>n "ram €3{)vz.::"§.V';;.if:a£E:_'fEz%€ *§::5;3ggji1§:;§a:zz:_.cé<§ q;' 'v5-;°:a::f2 Qfléfiife ='X{:eg::z'?._1.1.3321, ._:'.2"2.€ ';;>r€;z:i<>1,£,<; ,ésj--:Vzm.rrTi.z"c':>7%"z.'1 '5~;e2 Qf Zhe Z,i}"€3Z"{$if§'::K;?'?E3'Vb *f»::;z--zd' -'f;;'i'mZZ"' i'7'z:"z§<:3e-> iii c1bz.mc:iar':i£g_; (T560?
":_zi'2a:; I:s;:zfV:,>'i'%.,Af'?'w§ é:2jgs'rc:.isg>'<;_f" power' (ff {he Court" {.9 zigafigé <:<>§}:=3§2ar?'cre%_ "(g["::i'z;,: Q}fjf£>:2'zc£> is aEUsoEa::.e> and _ _ cram ;Je3€;e+,. VV';?'§'2e'=_zsé:*§; {?€jJ§;?EfZ{lF2.{.'€ is; barre-,>d, "f?1c::z:', viii V§':'E'2e A:?<;mg2_E cf22ir§i (?a?'Ti%"E€.}&'.. be ?Ci§~:j€§"2 n.0E.z'£7e> Qf. "C':;§;zA'2'é--.:/,v::z:T:c:s;%' 5'52' 3.516? <':{1n§.5.*..*«:f' in m:§2:'<?§'2. {.5 25$; useeii ' v..§':'2:<;?£s3§;:T~.VV}~j,i:,.:;"isd§§:E.§{m' 0?' "§?':a' *;%<e>r<?i3€ (3,? j;z;9§;~;é'?§?1?9£":»:32'?,' 0:' *poz.:,:e>r" is :21; ami ::§.:3§£22"z'ri::*zfz£ ?::s:::.:§;e»_<§'. fr: <7a:>z'z':m::>:2. ;3{::"£5:n<::r'e £5: :?':;acz;':.s; 'iazkirzgg ':":.{}§.€{?::? Qf'. "§"f2e:.> éfozm' §§'Z{?E'E;f_{G?'é? ;'2:"s:%{r£z4:4s:,i.@c>i.fmm €;??'ZZé?F"f.{Zf§'E§FE§; (.2 <_"<)m;;':E{zz'i'z: as?' z'.52§<:';'2§g :'Tz:}£i<:e3 535;' if." <3)? 4-%;:e:»:rz;::i:;£.nggjz.:z'*z"$:i§:?:i<m. 57%: is; in §'{?$';'}€'{?§ Qj'5,:. _§3§iE3§§{? C(.}i£%'"E'. A fréai u..rz'.:.i':az.z? ca s.;a:;:z'Tz.:.7z'..z'Tz>:"z. re:'2£§a?;":; zihez ;Jr<1{,.*s3s;2{ifr'2g;.<; 5:5) z"3'::'!,'z'z.>. zfizifeini.
.2 ?''E:.@ E.m':':'1.i:'z.:a;<:: (1 zguzjr jE,}r_fi"'a;:5§€~i--:§_: » ${mC£io7'2. is 552.9 35:71:? z:2:i'1a>n. £528 {.7<}am'" {:£%E§¢%é§. 32pm': Er.) fake {i:)§;r'zi_7:(,::'2{re% .;"gf -{.§jEe ;g,{'f?cé:"z'<i'@V.' z'f2c*ra>jf%')re;, :.uf:.(;>n {he o_1}f2:>,z'2(?'.s3 if~§_"':5?.E.;if€%g€:f{i' =£.0" ?'2.ti:.§e.__ beer: coz'z"2.rn.z'ziIea:L i"h.e: _£2z:7<iuse;{:i was T A ,:;}:.gi'3£€c§} ;¢;er';.2{/z:'1Z" bag: by :.}'1.{2 ziz':'2¢:"<.§?'%;:*» C»:}1"m'.-. is 's,.:gz_§'3_:ee::3"1.{;§€éiT: so I,c:§€e {.2:>gr'1z;2:c;;zc9 cgf 'ai}l:7E'3'§€?6' {l'€)?'£"EI?.1_{Z§§?5i by mm as pubI'_:3¢}1f;--:azr1.;5. 3'5.-;«* }z'J:;;».vV{:"e£Lse<i {lo 3;: £3 a. pubrlic sen:a.ru'i'. no [E€C(:'SSCiI'_y i3<3r° E::ai<z'ri:.:i'<;:o r'2z'§:ér(1.ric"fe2fi::3". :.i-my; "c>r'1'{;{3a ainsz. him. J KHZ" i"?'z«:>.j53':mcrivicra' (f::§'::.!fi" is €J.5§5C€{f Z0 iaice c»:)g:'n'z(mcs;> ".;%(fi7§' {.':r'1.3§; 'iz,§I;%_~*. .()j~}",éVI'1c:1Li>" :_?'zu$E:' Elaine been =:?c}r?1m:"€'z'.ed :'f';?\E;;7*.'_C:i"_Ef']fZ.i£?"31i-£1?'V£§€???E§C:}.'3.Z Fgzifz the pa'>r".<::{)n 5z:7:7:.z.s{3a?. is ' v §;::fi§ (E. ;3>;.§.bE.'z'z:% Si-3F"i§(1F'?.Z r'{;?;':'1::a::€1}3Zc:%f%"r:}r'z'fz in':-; (gf;'%i(?e> by «:3, mr'r:g;»e§.z;:%':'21""::':£z{§':<>r"i£§;9 Escjfésm :}'u;>, ;}r<>z2z's:'.ons 53]"
§3._fi'€,a?i2_ 2:zg;g;*;E§,;¢ 'E"?'3z2: ?'€Z&?E.F{Z.I'1E. €f.€§§.8 :.é,%i?Lf2 :'Q,f%3;'<3§1:E:3 :'<>'~v::.?§az'§?F'E 5: zméigi s:<::;':e:%';".:'oz'2 S§7r""i{:' qgzzz 220;": j'<}r we-:5 §~£1£.5{fE;I":"};;_§{A <><)grTzf2:<2;'z.<7z:> egg" 5%}? {;,§_}'7er[i<?:? a::?z.:>_nm'2£.£:'§.;:?(§. fig; ~~ {}:gf2Z.§(7 §7£>?'Z:-EH23. :25; K-?<:gu.{r*'@{.€ by S, .,E.:§'% ES E.}3s;% {£5159 cm E,i.?§§§{I'§'E. Ehéif <':f€}Z,.£f"Z. £3 {i?{TE§§EI'{§ a,.z,;:2{}:'2 :0 §.::z§c{;? €5?iT?§§?'3f:»:r:::'2::e? 52?? 37525 é?,5?%i;z<:*e? éE?"w?'::"<.*E': 5%? Es; {:s<?<;'z:.se{§.s E ii 9 , £9. "f'}'2a,> i'2:)f5;Zaér' ('5? 532:? {g;f_}f%'a:r<:% sf;£'(}:'§::«%._ :..mz,.r,{5§ §'Z£'.J:E.?{;' <:)pg)<;r{z.z:'z.i:.g; :20 {i§')§_£;-SE? or ;'?'22's;;.E;é;??e: V' :_. <,§;f?'%'.{%e. 'E"E'z.<:$e.> :;~;»3<."z"i<:):2s :rc>:§§iE.; as z:§e;aEE--2*"§siar:;§;r::§§s1:>af2' {rz.:z'.srz'; I'§"ii1i gx>z.:,%¢?:' §'"i{IS ifzszis I'£Fi'£€E{?f'Z.{f§g {:?{_)r'r'z.zg:;3'. Vféf, is; 522.5% f'2:;Z5Z.i:T2g +::gf £.}'1.e: :g;f}":§.g'7a? z.:.>E':'i<:?ét,_gi:,:£§::
<:3;c:g,_wc;~rI"z:.m' 1;; :23 :.:.;~;s:.> V » r if _g' :23' * A .<:}:>:"r2 5;); . v 5mr>:3fz':.:5.:=;<;5; 'I'?"z.¢=rqfE:);re, If'i'1{'.> {:c)rr:.zg3§$._é;t<}z':a{z,.z<:.r_. V ':73 (2;i:f¢}§£:Eg,§ c;{:r'.z*ib:.z z"czb2'r,> arm'; fZti)i£,.?S . f.f'z'z:.%, _§'}()£.i¥'{3? -- <>g2:':.j'?;irr'e>€f gm E316 {§;{:fit:'£?_, :f "IE-i:~: '. "~-._zf;=:.z"ééi*r'g?Er:;::.{o?':. a:':€i in£z:rdep€z'3,d.en.c?e> !?je::'z.:,r.é;->291'? fr:-::;.iV2'":,>z7»;f1V€:;a.»:z E zrzzid' 1.31.8 q,{_'['i<re E'1<; !mi_€1s s§z:f;:;:'ar:'i~i:;--F.._(m.o€1«::::>Z semarable. £§ag:!'1.:}vf"iE'§é* 1fffzz~':'-is £?.£€;{i.Sé'fZS Q/' 3az.E;}{<;e:7£":{3z'2 1' Z! Q/' S. £9 :a.;se--;€; V1J1.£e é;z':;jés::s§'ir§I5i ""i},{'}'3§;:fé' and 1.31.9 pozuer to §:;2"€2z°2E'= .'V:::1'§:iI'iz:?:§l'(fiI'3_ <?<3r';,f'er:"e{1 0:': W29 az:4§.E1.r:}rf.Z'y 'v--.;:o§:r1pe'ie%ri:':'~$52.Qr€r?"i(;z:e":_?'2e? ;3z.zf;»lz'c: :=;<3:'vam;"_j'mn1 his <;}fhfEg:geVV::s2:i"f§, 'VEAE}~'z°;-§Qrz.:z';"g>s 5: $:3;r2,<?!z'<}r'2. E3sr;j;'2'Jre-'e {CI}€§H§Jj :;:<)5:;:?€é:5z:':e:i°(§ " Q?" <.§,f'}?%;az'2{>e,<; €L'€}?'?¥I'?'?.f?,f.c'€f E/3;; p:..:bE2'.<:
;_$.era::r:;r':i.. f§'f;£.€.""{§}f'f%':"E.£?€ s=,=§'2.oz;:i.:€ be ::0I'r":m.§.t§"53€;' £33; {fie »_§}E.£%}3§§?"S#Ef'2'"Z.}€f3.E"E5., 33;; r'?z.:'§::.;s2'3'15;; or afmsingg {he g3oz;.:;er >é2rT2{€ E5. is _,'f'fm;*ITz. Ehsrzf. {;_;f}"if.::;=§=. 552.5 (zz.g.:§'z0:"£.E:';; mi 5953 :;:f<35?2pé%§eI':?' E2") :'e>:'n.<}z.:{3 i'z:'.m 30 as {.0 be? e&%'_'r.:.€:'E.ed 3%,} §;z'ozs:: S€i§'E{j?§§C=?'Z, '§'§':.z9 E/4->t%1?E:?'{)-.;'..;:,fi:.-/;-vE§ID{'}?-E. ':3{}'%i<T%e>s;> if'? {.523 f'§'?.?£?&? s;i.z§3--»{.7i<Tizi5j.«:e3?s i;§{Sé?e:'7if(2:'1 E32? {5} Z.:i}€T}Z£E€'.'§ {.'§&?{lf"Z§j s *3 ....
£§e:"z.(;:z'e ::'E15a.§ -:.§{fz'.<fs3 wf'2.i{.tf2 §:f't»:::* pazbiiaf se2':.>(;:r_':%fv mz'.5~;z.::§ec;f, er a£;2za3a=écEhfl:.'2:' {,I'O?"i'I..£§}i i'?2£}?.§E,§€5~Z __}' %T'}?f'mE_,£.ff1E§'€Z'§'?.'W. V he 27:'; :0 53:3 '}F'{}5€i'(ff'£i.§.£;'d. and. in 3783 ;>s3<;7£ a,£"'i:.:i'2i§?Ei.xii H z 3 5, V S{£!ECZ.i{)Z'E. In g3r(,}5;«£-%c?z,.::€ §'n'::rz 5:3» F'?£1'{7€?5~fE:éi';Z.[:;§.::?§P§} "E£?2€fAV gromgjeierzi azgiizzgriigg E-"{'?2',E"Z'I'5€?1-If: £"f} _%'4<i*,"2?~'v?;{§1i.j+{;>5§}:f}'?% ;;'?f;;*IV:?(.2 ; 2',E'z.ai'. a:3{]Ec.:-s z,z;vf"z.z'<>h fig» i'2{2 §;_ i€;E,§i:z;;s:::%(i;" * . fr'2.Z"e2rr::>EczZ.foI'2 E363" L£,?€¢£'3¥'E' ' .Q[]"f::.'é::' ~ 5:353. if ss3:::e:*@d.§ :.a.>:>z.zZci. rg%:'zd.:,;f If} cféztrfid' Qj' } {Izzy meaning. ';"}'e:'.:§' *i;';5.a>rréZ§*i{:i¢é%§. :;Z&%s:;z"Z;; ;§i'{}:,rf{Zé%s a. {TEEIG Ir; {E26 zz:'z.c§.éfs"f:§:I:_rI {fieV;mi{5i;;:7si.(>zTz in 51 I 9 _pmz:ici.iz':(;fig?' sg::n«;:f.»z".<>f: 5;;-;_;:._ a.u.::'f2<)rii'g; Lcho Eve"-.a!0?.e"":€{J a(?i4i.an 62]" {he piziilicf "séfi!cii_1::"-b'e3g'E5're: _rém(2~z,aing the bar. by gr'af1'z;:'zfég s;e:zi%1c§:ii::>f[2'.«..¢i:; ii"E.(.>. ('M65129 :3!" Ihff c0gn§.?:c>:nce '- Q;" 4€§}fj?3f2:{V?€f;§i'-.'..?,3}§;.' z:§I;é' __C0u:rzf aga:'t'es3Z" Zfhf-3 pubiic sérgrczrzé, 'E'?z;ez"z:jJ§'E}:;9. £1: zm{g:.zes{.i0naE3Zg; _f0iEo;;::s §:f'2.:fz§' if':?:e3§é'<":;:"ic?i7j{§*'2. {.0 ;}z'(}5;2?a:':.:.§?e (Tan Z09 gzfverz by an :_--:::,:€;E2g:2:*:.zZ;; {§€}?s'a;Jé>§e:1.§. £0 :"e:'3':0::e3 §:'?2.e pzzbfiat se:'z;a:r'z§' ..V'j%c:rTz3,é'E"::»:_<gfi¥§::3 z?:.>§1z"c?':: mg ?'za5,: mf;<;z.:.5;e€£ or aicsz.:$a>cE. "E;ééE£fa:;;sj':;=' {$2.33 :zz.:.§'?2.<3s'i§.;; sf£§{}?"E£? :4::{}z.:E(£. be abizs :5) .,?-a;:'?<_3':fg.;..% A:.u?zg:'E':e*:" §:ha>re f'2(z.:s: §;":€€?'Z. {:5 :'z2:';;z[:.s;g>. 52:' 5:52.232: ~~ 5:31;!" 2f"Ez£.> <ggf__}":'_ce by {$1.5 _g3z:E,>E:'.{: seraaanzi 532.53 r233" S:'_>3'E'Z€ r«§mi%: §>z,.£§5§:'£§--3r.
E}. EH '{,:?1(? light" {sf w:%'1ai" 3'54; ssiE':213.a%<:3 iihfi'.
}}§'(}{'€;'f€i.§i"§'E§;"S '§3ef<>z*€ Eézér (fmsrt mirjf. £253 izzifio. EEEE;-g2i.1:2§':=1§5§---.E§é&;':?;1::=:, iii} be éguasshéxi. Er: £..ha'é vissw 65 '£ih::;-é :.1'1g::.1i:>.r, Ej'5éi$§':~3='j€§§:i.::%"§'r}'EE§§w-iglg ' {_3E"{i5(f£'i Writ petition is ailawedlv, The iinpzggzzeéi (;réé.z:i;~ Vf,>cz3;;eci'_ by" '$1319 .i;<;<:2f.me{"I. Sp::?:'ia.i Judge in CC I'J0,:3j_'g'0? {::.21...:_f2.s3335.53qf°:}1é'*1,/Tidcii. C:'!.§,; Civii 32, S&<;sf::ms?_" J1»/firsigvg; .§:;:;'zci?_ S;3ef?*i<2:Z ' Jz,2:'ige, .E3a:'zga;iore Cézy. {CC}; 13:3}-::_'{'3g1l{ir'2§; '::¢;;;:.¥;.;:2:a:';:::}e égfxzfzsi f;'§Sl.£.E' <31' g}r0ca:>ss are §z.;:ra>E'2y_ qVaI£:f£*;:E1.;_3€LA ' !\?(2 coszi"5;. "~ I»