Gujarat High Court
??#?I??Xg??????7':?Q3]]|*?Nst???Z?U?R??(?^?(#?\???,!#? ... vs ?/'???Bc^ ????%?X 7Y ... on 19 February, 2010
Author: Rajesh H.Shukla
Bench: Rajesh H.Shukla
Gujarat High Court Case Information System Print PK �����?[S?????}Ig??(�hd?#????f??%?N?S????I .l? ???Ny}wa????S h)???!??:n=?
YB mF?L8J?!??.??�???mV??L Xx *? ?%?P??'?n? i2A?i? n??n?q?a??(???<.? d ? ?Gk?
?E9uT?I?0? ?
?= x E?#4n $jl??H@?Z?X,?? a??????Go?B? ?O ?x? -? q ??TFgKG?" 2u??Lr?v �&??G? @%?? g???? y???^@ ??y?"c/ ???? H??3/P ???_^!?3 v^?? ?HFCr? #;?! ??X??o ??z??a??G@a???S%J/|BeH%?Qr o?6Mrf?; ?rs?6f ? ?"EH? ??' ?TJ??? ??O F?w?]X? ?P??U?`H?y?IK? ? W?u?? ?? 4W ?????? ? 7~? b+???-U ?3 ?cM?c?d ??WF4Pl?Tv ???u? [ ??8>� ?P?? ??}?X?,Y??EX ?& xm??x??n??M rk3??P ? P?? ?g{??+?Goa{H?G?D?Pf? ?W?"Ip m?G ? ????'�?? ? ??Ak? ??? ?3?` 0O_ ?? ?Z??u??8??????{?V????*O?^??gM???q ?/?@_8??o2? ,;??????j??s.X???4?n??,?????t??G>xy^?5?c?l?G ? ??@#u?5?_3 g??G? ????j?y?: ?e?PzQ?:n??x??^???p?y???p?4? ?2?|?c ?o ?uot? ?k ?W?u?? ??&m ?[???�mP?[ ??C??F?I/?n? ?Ta=?1 6Nx?4? ??b?x???j?@N????q**??[o?2n[???? ?�?ze ??+??C?R `S d?A?????x ??????q?@???< ????5??F??y??_ ? p?- ??c??$??? f?o?8??!Xj???? z_?? ?6 ?m?????{?:????l? ?? y?>i????? ??4?O ??A?m u?????A?m9c? ?==???{? ?9??GN??<�'? ???v[??n???;_?7? ?Q?*VSb ?( ??0 ~??d?1M??, ??$? ?N>Wq@?5?&?A??8?�? 8?K?s/??? ? //? '?n?~??V???l{8?\?????\?~?&???? ??'???n?; ????????G?w\??? ?.??}??? /????m?;?}?'??!0 1"F?(?lQl?M? ?1?6W Z??????! ;_? ???[ ??>v? ?? ??1 dh??S???? ?*U?d ??U>z5?g* ? j)??'?? ?? xR?� ??V*9?o??N�?]?\_?u? ? ?w??nn?cq??H???A ?J?? q?? ?A??{? ( ??V ?c]iS^+l??:?6???????????>?S??j ?cG? R??v`AP?pa? )?%?? `lB?u??(3`???}??? ?S_7? Ux?? ZE??? ??;7_ ??+?????kr?<^??[hg} ??2 U?j ??a?t?f [J ?n= ?E ?-???x??%�n?C $S?? j g 2?? ? ?'C ?&,??? ?< ?|? c ? ?d?4?? ) H !?#??~G? J?&??g???0??�? ??dU&j?D{ ? ?D????Sfv????S ???V?@=~?d ??x2 D?8 {" y??U? q?Q??*?: Z''?F>i?O2?{??!? }? x??O?~ ?F ?N?cG?? ??? ??2$�3 ?Lf?u?? ?< ??D?S% 9V????? ? Z-??B??@5??????5 1 ? ? ? t ??6* Z ? MV? y ??t?#?�W?b$ ? N Q ?? .4?|s? ?$3A ??�o? _ l ??R?i ?? x?o?`?A (???)??C? ?z? Pu ?O?# ?F?}P?R?f?-???R???}u??J6??7,/0 ??)LC#}z??@h 2L?PLWX???h`)???#???M???? ]j$??;? ?8??`_????8??%|n??? =? ? Fs? ?b,J?b?FK,?? ?? ??0 ?3 ??m??9 b K} _?i??~ ?g ? ? ?i?(B?`(?}?)|?A&/?y ?k #]jBr?'??u ???UM?~? cn?? 7?I ?z????A???O???? PK ?! ?r ��?G��PK � � �?[S<������������ ���styles.xml?Z[?? ~?_a??>?,? ??? ??
v??-2?E_i???H?@Rc;??????)^L ?4 ?????? R???}??^0 ?? / ?? ?%?n ?????s??? ??zMb|????0???? ? L??? ????} ? S34f| L?0 ?o???g ?5??%??A? T`?:?[#,bG?x > ????AH??b 8? 2?N? iY??F?|Kb?Yp??L?@?V??^lQ?v>( X?? / G?<"4?z.?E???>?/? ?P } ? ????a?? ;X& ?>B?5 c?N?G?d ?& f?b>J?-?0?o ?
To8uH,?D ?j??%0=?\??Jh?? OT??d??Q*?? ??V(3?i1K i? \ ? _a?h?? ???n ??!L?�?8Tr??O q,???`N?Fa????#A?? ?x?W;????~oE?BVB u(?Y??xo w?VR??J? ??6 ??BeF7???V*?? 9?H{ `??!?b?$TM?EI ??< ;?hFq? 4??Q? 1?o0?n)O ?5?? ? ? ?7?l ?????g Y?}???{ ?Z? S??? ??mp? ?fL?? ? ? "?W??? (/6 ^? ? ?? -?_1?B_ U?z?4E?PA?K??zR? ?/? ?????:?\s ?O?( ????]) H??c/?w??F???b?Pu`4 ?00Z?????Q?8? `?\?????,?E+&??$??p>??;"?>???S?I?G?M? ??b??K?Q)???D0 ?[?w?s?????? ??k?? `????C??&? ? ??zC??.8:+!Z!?? ???n?Du2k?.???$?-?fL??? ?)??? ~??R?7?Y? ?+y??l ? ?? =D?>W5???o ?? A?y ??qx?./??7T ?%??*??d ?an?,?BH?>? ?uv?'?7{yV?0?l?$?X??B? l ?$�?????xm???8??t ,1&??o{??|1?k]s 9? ?T0 ???n? pe?E ??od'??w?Q ???! ? ?m4mX!?-?(m??? ?e?i ? (?"???A????KF?=o ?????.?}k??frUl?W????.???U???*6?b??*6Q?? 59? ??I,?6?5? \?`8xEe 4 ?/(-?n :j?Re? s??'??g?PW ??<&????Q{??j+;Q??;?6???t?D???q????\?? ????@k?? ?? ?Ib?
???????e?4|???e?P??~^y????5??fU? D}1??'??S? m??2???b? V; ? ?S?c ?;"??+g?:???.???";??M?2n???E8 x??|x0y V?W?5? ?g? "?m?J?m8???+C?_a0???a??? Ck???B??0??5?l?9?#%???? ?~??K??y?3??A?~ ? ?9+k4r?#? ????? ep;??F ??}rV???b??|Z]1\a??u?@ ??????a? ?? ? ?R`??
Q *M??e????p. gn?j]???, ???? ?no?I ? j?????UL= j p?c?9???\y?I^4t,??Z? iu9mNxe???>????10_?B5R?? ???O???g??N??4;??w ???-? PK g?!? ��?'��PK �����?[S OpenOffice.org/2.4$Linux OpenOffice.org_project/680m12$Build-9286 aasaiyed 2010-02-19T16:59:40 aasaiyed 2010-02-19T16:59:48 2 PT9S PK � � �?[S<������������ ���Thumbnails/thumbnail.png?{eP???% ??? ?? w??5hp?�? $4 ?qw'8 ??n n ???j??TM ? ?g???9{???&ZCM?5:): ?kE -??F88x8Td'+?w+pp?!?2?:>? Z ??]??????!?|?h?T?L?T?u ?5? s??8??2?r??sY?>??kk??~ ? ??#?I??Xg??????7':?q3]]|*?nST???z?U?r??(?^?(#?\???,!#? &?? %?VS?/'???BC^ ????%?x 7Y 5L??)???]f??t??.??E&P1 >? ?]??Q?x??.6???,? ??????M???�)L5Qzz?xf?gTS? {8Y????M?|;04??u??`???? '?2{#?(??c)?^?????c l?? S?GG??Y????N?o * u?'???aO ?N??Oc` ????z???w#? ~?O=HmM ???o'???:G?2?[ ? 'O/? 2?GLN/??"?\???9 ?]? ? ???? ???2 ?I O???Q*Eu?? zb;D??8?% 00 'X?;?)f ?????x?gw ??\'P????w?6n????&c, y???FO ???y?>!? ?? ?yxA??M?_??_d? @??r?C?? ?Qn?Z?aU F ?Zu ??z ?!c? ? ??????????(b??tw`?Q??q?\n"??f?,? J???;~????Ta}? 4;_?^??????j?? 3s? a'}???g? ???? ??l?q5?L?x&B6 ? ??}[b??^?~? ?$?? ???>???x>?=w?4 $2 A?:??L[?-|?C?f?H?X ?4??E?? ? ;?C ????3w?ON ???>?!?K0 I_? ?? - ??? ???,$?? ???? ! t?r?w\??u?HU?? Z ?[?tw??}u? #???=D?P??a$ ? ?g ?Y??BOy?B p? (?*-?R ???n=?? ?????0?^-N?\?f??J ?? ?????b ??FW?f?+'3?.??x!K??
??;5??h?? +?]7??k? ?fa I? ?$? cF?uE?{-Y?8>4 %1 ?????Y&~G??}t(?,?w9MCMJ6??a% 4 ??#??? v???c +?#T R?P??a}Y? ? ??S??m8*9-???k??A? ????%A? ?9??O0?? ??? f.? ~?? }????^r ?_o?&7 Zi?4)L?Q???E?+? .+?rK???}?\h{~zXX??I_ ?\ ??Xu?^j ??!??F?????}c& ? ??AF?B ?g0???f?]] ??f5?)??? ?+???n ???? ??JRt,&????,?? 4 ? ? 6~ ?LK?/ ??q? t??YG?m?
? GZ? w??'\?Oi$?? I??9w?8Z$L~?j? "fE m3.j??@Bt?S6???A ??1? ?A$? w??L ?[?? ? d? ?"Z??>? Zl D??L? ?????V??Z` ? 7k?/?t??? 9??9`??\??7? S? 0? ?C? ?J ?? `N ??|9 ? ?O???>?jv?? |#K?I??Y??A ?m{8?k ?? ?8U| ?3Q??g ?? ?Ql?\s?U.?6?A;??W??|?
oQ?`?+?? ????e=?=:_^Gg?
??W|??@ x }r ?^ ?e??1??
?P ??Q????,n @R????rM? ???zL-? ????>? ?:??M???}, ?`7?3* ??? 1x)jJ?* \ ?#?q?&MG???? ???z`? ? E??s? W?U?Y/??Cv?V?s N?{? b ? ? l?? ???F???(?[??` G?O? ?a ?kNocT?P?87 ? ? o rE,??7?t??pV?0!??MzrR??
?[?8 ?3A???=???~ ` ????$0 o3l?v?Z ?nFb_?}P?Oo ? ??o??Y??? ?| ? }? _?? ?tl?n ?? ?? m.???#^?|%G? ? 4?4?D!? ?w?w h??T ? -b[xn?4?M? ?a?? U?B? Q �3{?_ &�g"GS*u?H^EX o`O Z?X ?!? ??8L@?(?l I)? 6???Oj?? GRxe?=8??8??'?"?x??\??Y??6|?x?Vk?g?? ?%7??Z???? ??Q&M?_? & ?? ) ??? ?b???N?? ???_???.u? ? l? ?????.q? ?a?j? ?D?z]??N b?g^h? ?F"BjM &?w E4?/?0?i??1?@c?? ???S? ?0?U?`????L1rv=?nQ???Ke??m?E ?~?D_A6"?u??(*?:
?Jr ?_[v?c ??#U|C? &?j h{?B? n?? J*1 0?F7?? p?? ,???g?) 3N/??n? v ??~????(d?? ????&)#??M?8 ????@4??? i?v??O??????y?J??? ? ?? ?723]???R!_??5? ;?;?Vq??F e ? F?v n? I?to? (I??P |????? Cx W? ??? ???]?? =OCP??Vf?nA?[/??4?J? ?R?kpG1?6 ?k?�?0\UXk Qh?j?e?i?? ??? ??m??#?d????^i?f,???_??e,O?e???kFh?O Y ?????.?Nn?9s?6?? ]x?`??? auA?8?yHl~?;t???PHdY?x*w?,?-S???v??<+v ????A?{ ?`??/?;?LVN(r? {I D?U?% ?&?HT%? ,?? ?? XQ?T^)5 q?xVz??\*l;?yT ?dy ??P??#?a?,?/0k;?2<;}??? auc< ^?? q(Qo???pa>?? ?5S???&H[| ?}eI??D???*Kow? y???|?F??4J???U??2|????zSk?4?'???? G?$??f? ~?`?_n u?kf-cp-=?A?%N???^?]? W N ???^? ? 'd-Y?,????+?i ?{?]X4?xu? 7;???]?o?7?? 67????b7????_? [??-? ?g??L?U??r?4??Z| 3G u?z???T? '?;??e ` X?9 >??'???? ?G?w?? 2??V?.???%?q???? ?K '??|(^R(|?K?*%, E??a y?+??3n? I� ?f??F??C???>F- i?8? ??k"KX P?`" ?#;c:? ? ?d????< @?8A??G ??????
??? ?? ???A?{8???p?? LH ?? ?/??Ii?JMN?rm?z? ? -??????d? ?|>???g2?? ?G??K???h ?S 73???@pw?K????;??:??-Zn 1Q? ?:???9? o?n?tK?S?[N)?}l ?~?aD?2 ??W??p???%Fn ?p?W?N??^?g ? ?a??'??_kD�K? y?? ????N??O???6? ??0??x??b6?\$? f3???~??Y?b? {W3?Z?o +? R?V"*??[ f&m?? ??X 5??+?J ?9 Bm.UA?h? ? ???? > 2 a; /5????P ? 5??:y?m??X? q?QZ?? ?r??]?N? ??L ? ?? _?B?^n? e _ ?Ld ??M1v2????~[M ) Tt$d????(\Z??_P?Ys ?Y`?Xt q?? ?%?? ? WJv? ? ???T_??[?~?N?X?s, ?+ $? ? S??A/?0;y?v?5?1fx|dajx=^C? I?-?|?)?I r?/|*?? c??Mz ?8?%t? * 6?????#i?) ????T??? ??0 _HQp J? .bN?? ?? ?F? ???hA IB4|4????A?? ??e? }???u??ML??3?.?? ?????T??? ?m2 ??H????c??P?Mf*a |kM???
[??h??.????g*m?+!??%???4\E8 ????lQ#?T?4?+>j> j??T ??Ru!?{L?7gx???WvH*?D?6#? ??XH?nt??a ??3e?l?=?q G?7A'??? ??m?j ?Kv??H MM]^{?l?? B 5.?dB???P???!? "X ?Z? .1?=l?(? ?w?`?6?J?%?J?a????c??@$ ??(??A??O A F?!?Y?? ?
?v W?\?PG??ix]n??N?D?\???0c??n?- 5mxq?%? s?x ?}? +9?%?VY??? Ge?S D?w? ? ??VI?????? o & ? Ga%?d??m?? ?? N?@/g^ "T1??Q?T}n ?u? R ??n?F?^??????? ? ?fj(?:4?Jan d(z????FA ?IOQ?6?bU:???e ?~?`?j?,?????m? R??N?? ? ?YM~? ?t?$?9!?1 ?????? ?j?R?o? :?.T*T?>?L?L??%?uB?? ?�3~???5b???e?L??`?I??0,?&??o?? ?^??k?i7?y~g?????gDV ?"? ? *?T?%?hc?c???T3z???? X??Y ?d 4?L??= OU ?o ?? � O?Bt?
h$B???`???)L???1!???i? ?
X??v?l??+U 2J?T6??y2HW)??'z?V????
"Q vcl???w?a$ ??B5? N??K'|?? ?? ??-?w?????'p?o?=Dp??@_?�???*? N?9 7]f?f?7 ???q0TU???} dy??p*? r???^(V?|& ?K???cdZ??n\?M5?]?nf ??Pa?+^??8?t??Zz?bF,? ???!e??e?U??|??X?? ???k?2b u?B?J?D??Jo???????1i???U?MrSH* ??? ?L[????d J ?[?%=????s?U?+?V/?s ??q? g k??`z?? ]?h??k8 l??? fo(?_?X?hx?G2d#72{t??d?%?'"? ^?W??? ?? ;?w?P 6??h lr<.???$!??L?J?? ?is??!??? :|xq??~?It"m?a^??}????0 ?z>??????r 6??Y 4??? ??:?%?7???ZD!??9` -??l5z 3? |?wG? "j?? ? ??h�C??E?w??i 6 ?`?L?Nx???d?p?|6h 1*H???? x??i?(??8v?>? ? ?.?z?[?\?{ @w ??j?+??
pW)I? i6??:?q_$?L?7t?8 Q??! f?
??3???? ;Bv??7 ?W ?A Q)9+? ???SC?? 9?j|??C???# ?&??I????? e?l ??s MM??w??[??}3r ??3?V???=_8bx??e ?MX?-*K?$vw==pd+??$_E?=? ?z???? ???????G ?_? ?sJ??LI H n E???e: ??N?v?+ ? ?) ? 0& ?? =M????4??:%eG??D ??2#??Aq? _j kIZ?????a 0 w??? &????$?>?u ?S]I? )Y1 e?yKCU??A??[s~4 ?,_ ?\ 1 @}cV*[?2??B'?Frw? ???C??7?
:???27O????}q? ?l? )? ?K? 2?W ?:??? ? d?lD+|?B ?9;?.?0?2c?a.\|ih ???t??q G? KL?)/K?b? r?b??WgQ? >/???? ??=G6? y??=k??N??)K 5 Q_[kg???)??? ?3?? 9?'?^?d,$:? X ?A??O-???e???f?~Y???? 8 ?@?v\p 3UJ? #k"?A??8? dC?x\?>?Qo? Tk???FK` 3? Ijd )=??~? V ??T?]% ?T? ?Tt:??~???2 Tx ???y=?u i}?B?? {? #0??d ??}*???H o????Hq?q?) ??s[& ??q x ???vr?? * ??g?? ? ? E=???QwnT?w??e]?J? CPO b?> .?H ?`?cy ?87???r` $7|(?? ? ?#?hq??I ??? ??F&?? k?0?1j2)^?H2)1???"??? ?K"?N8?? #?7T?P ?AX????+ 59Vr?? Q? =?? j?????h?? )? W??'? i8 ??*? N?A? n?!r V/� 2w?7uIS? V??? ?( K )~??~??@^1?? 1???'?J??@DG$???? $??\?J?m_ ?P?7? ?V zX?.?8??" ?x{?7|w?r7? 4?~3?] ?? ??.???5?????}??.???????K?F? ?????????l??z?`? ??z?| ????"?? ?P?????? ?? ??{? ???y@?QZ??? ???;D)?:4%?v?jv?]?!??I1[? ??&?? o_F??Z????.?? :??qYB ?k??cu ?F? ? Y?S ??M?????h y ??'R???? q?qh~ mx/Yz ?YPP??]?? ?f|?o? ????
?)s?)(??b ??zx _??
?m YH?D?w K2??N;}???i? ? ?tu?9?? ??? ???E \?v/p?q??4??? ? ? O2V? ao????v???g?}; | @gEt ,�?,&??? ??k?_ ?5:? ?d?M F3JZ~?AS?A?s^ ??(R?'(#??? ?^ [$qq??B? ?i]?? *????C?I????? ??? `d?% b?gB c D<(x?V??[d?Xdy?[?{2HX?Mn@? ???y?\# L???QfF??????S?.~hm W6 ?m?s????G?"? Ss m ?|?- v? ??U ' ???$?D?C? ??-??cC?F????u?? v=?:Z?x?????? -? ?q?x8>? &NEK?l6 ???? ??u?-yI ?E?k!y ??? Tq!? ? R??:???H=???H? ?m??iv??X ?[???_ ?? E?sI? ?? ??%o\?; D ?h?:9A E3*??T??3?J???y.^?:?{KY?jAE?
2?nF?:^f ?T??F?t4 J? ?X W?0 ????G ??t? W? ? ? RB?? ?Y- ????.61j??s???? ?? ???' ?+ "?@?`?Q????
.,C&??o ??f??Kgo^??? ? g?b ???
?1?e?kA# ?\????\??} ?3it g=???
u>TMg?kpZcc???? ?V?2`??6????B? ~?)6? V?KN? ??M?-???7? ??V??LSr?R?"?H???+? ???"? ? ?? ??L:p??/h?;?Gkb?s?? ?D??)??? __??W X??m ?>}jF"??k??P? ??d? ~* O??l?~? ?? ??? f? . g?R?? ? f%??l?rVq? ?RWb?? * A!?r??+U??O? YJPh /^??IO???
F? ? ?w*?? T?QB!oj?} ??,W_L ,? j!? ????/?T??@???zd??6?_??? ~?'*eG m?,/???bf?????}?D??!^ H?????Q??);y?$? ? +j ??? \?? ?C?? ? }?o?fu????X ??_Ix? ??> ?}?V,???? ???+[?1?9n???Y?&x7? u? k-??? *???a????i;?S 3???? *?-qke4?= @?!???:??\?'T??|? N??? ?z?J?
CsT)? ]U?>?7N?d?????x[???e??? =)@ ??\?:?I7)?=?_ 9 ?G ?z?~? ~/,??f????6?H?|4?Hb?o? ? ??9??@e?#? ?^?C?li2 q?a? ?oC?Y??? uL?N?4GS~ ?I????_N%?J S?1?#???x?????"?;?????^\? ??$??]? ??9? ?\e? {lA]?U?? ?.h?:?.?(H?X?dvucM?? 8]p??T? \s XS4?? .???-NTP [7n, ?Q ???Z #????J?/d?8??????L??sfZG7?2F ?NQN?g?J??~v? < ??????t~??????r?t??C1 ??`W??? ?????I2?? _u +KW 6nS?? ?@Ch??~ ,$?? ??}???q?/Z?J`#??? ???I ?????j??m??0?y%????a?/??gy??g???a??B0?? ?z~uQ |8??�| *hX????`? ??e ??&9?G?a ?q?7|)dQ) >,???U~?%?Pz??~ ?? GUZR ;
?g?orW?U?W?jq? ?rY? GUX??dI?m$x < '????A?M? ??l?( ? ? ?*??1z�Fwa???q?G?^?
?wi ?_�?WOq8 ?1 ?R?9??U ??a??}fG?? %? ?4?
>?;??H?%e,? ?? eJ???B?! ??'?w:?�3? oK"5 #N?[?>?@?}???M-9?%?? ??& "
?J?0 k)??/Q eS<=?rs ??? &?Ny?#',h??A?(7E?X ??Xc ????c-x??A?? o1?7?F?
?YxU?t?t-??'?h+?]!P';????E? ??(?V? ? L ??? ? ; ["H ?%?f? ?3?R ?<6g:D lNu?Q? ??{?J??????0u7eN2 ???R?? b?"?bAq??o?HM?_?/??Ysy???? ? �PK ]??? ��J ��PK � � �?[S<������������ ���META-INF/manifest.xml???N 1 @?~???? 'cXM MLT8??c??.M?m?N??{?q?D4??6m??t?tt?l??K?KvQ X?Z?J?d??}~?n??F??x?2??Z?e???? ?-n ? ? ? ?? `2?dO}^d ?=???[EE ???X???e?VD? ?D???? ?I ??H?T??&??U???9u K?URp?]?ZW? ?????IB?v??Tn9?J ?r ????e ? ? ??%?s!Pa\ "8 ??F??? jex|?4pkl?-? ?L?'{?M???d?J ?-o????[??q$?1 d!? ??? ???u?5?w&P.?X? ?7??88 ?-?????\O?Brl??O6???.5?? ?aausj?i/ ????? ? ???;PK w _?y ��? ��PK � �����?[S Top