State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
Bank Of Baroda vs Jagrut Nagrik on 16 April, 2010
.,.........
'izse 2* ~.
\§"""x§-ac»
: *:%1«:1?§::: {.:a:T§§s:m§ER _imSP§$TES R:§:«;*;,r:m;m*;§s%.._..<;=%.;;:.--.
M _ §l{}:;§wI'Eséi£S;;E3';§i{§§§f'
$Te§?;E3;k.$~i%i»&§S§3&$$fi
:zsaf»s:§. $31 7:33;' :§m:.3j
_ ,
,§§£;:§.s:::_a$%,i V
iéizig _
$§a{§a§i ilmxzg' _ _
Vwsliéadara €§;'$ ~§§s;§§?fi1§i§1I§§§
kmixis. g~x;:,a: _.~mg?:, ..§=€;::a:;:::--
fiémgii Gsatass Raévci
Kfafiiafiara;
z--3
}E§£s._'sE: 'i:'i3:2§.iae}
' t _ . . .
wt '.
3..:%;_ 2:': '
2,. ' Q. _ T;
§E§&RE:
»a3'=*;::§;Ei:
a;:jge:€i¥s3:':§.
»§2=.§:g:m?& N;:g:"i.E-1: 'i:§:me~ .§§§¥&§§3fi§§t'L§§:Ei3f4$
iili-an §§3"§:.§§:'::'.é1':t£ip§i§§fl§£§;£?E'€:, p'1=&ae:;~;: ra$§3€§n«::ig'm7:: xmgfsi -fififiéii
-e{3;1i_§::3ia'§3':{t'_=1:§%:1%s:s1:g§E7:. r»:s.§m1::3«_6n§'_: '§'§3}:§f';§"§1l%;I7'f3-"'{\3-'?£>?f$ iiiiiégiltfla
E?-sxrmagixmer 'sZ3a.2?;s'::»:§iie3;$ina: 1.32% 'mi 'ESQ? aa.:§1=&frair3... ;;a:x~ g§.w.*§:§i.§§
gmssaé
§s§:?§:s.i§:&: as :;::3.':'»:'§&r:I:
""*§'3t:<-:----s:t"';1ipEiaa:sé:i§<>fc*i: '§.'2:i§%-. i<:z§:e§;:a::;tr;s:ax*-2i':i>:~>
ta v=..'~mp;:§§~<~ :7:a:s§:{y »a*;~:f iii:-as '£};fi,§§§§'na:'i
'!&>.','§&';hi§"s zm:sn'%;E€s'1m:°e:éf arxszi 'Sis .&i3*r:é§'i'§§s»ii 'Em:
m3i'7'.s.='u~:t1#:a ::.::_>;:s3; and ikzgaii -'iii? Eiifama Vths' .§>gxgm:r::§%r::«'$$«:
-.:;§-sjmzstgzi 'ta .§a§zf§Q«a$:* ;§§§§:s§::g1'1 _§;§;::gs~f:gs:gi3s:3;:;._g,rs§§' :;§mf; in
_;;f§-3_;:es»'i:ic31:a_*ix: 3:13?' ms_gs:3*::&:§%, w't;.a*:=seo22~:a-§lr'_-- ::'§g3a:a:a;1--:ss'*$}§ai§§
3::-s:*:..;§~" .§T:.'s.»>'«.:=:=VVir.Té*%.s';r:z*;.'~.4.::z-a~m'§ri:i otxaisgé is;:w$..t:r;§"sV '-
.a:n§im3;z'§t§1.»::r:.:;$mn§ {ifRa;§.;,{}§§{3§'i§§§--'{§'§,§§3Tt$s§=$.§§R8£"§} zmjE§='§
§§q;'2'§;«:§3?§;} Ems iiziesti aaxigirgagi. .s:}s§;§iZs§23.«&$:I.§:;. 'EM; haw;
'i31ii§3§3:e:£i_ tszi; wtféaiitiz .:!tt¢;;*§;m:u::sti~;eI=:?:$.'.E:sqeiw&i=
1+.~mm§:s::2§ mar': weiii zjm w.:t'iti%£:!§:% m*?g'*g:e';iz1'§2;%xt--*:s::'.,$§sr.~:?4:g.
aaxaith :i.a:a:é=u::2.t:%zat:;;; w;x3,fi,:a$L E?»-'§'} "Q34 ' §;3'ifE€;i
.;:« ':§:9z.:;::.é:.s's'. mi fifiaéz «» 3:3; "
.a:.:3~:r:§:s§.a§:1'a:§t. §'€T;sj.~',l~E. .{§fi'.r\-3536:? sixawxfa mmgjziaixfiaxxi} iim-.~<s agymaskefi'
;=z§35§3*5*3~§ii¥3.'$ §3?m'1§c--i.-'i'.1:§" '*a_.§1zt%'3.§m1g;iaa3.*::. af §Ea,fi'_.-*:'s§3_;,%Gfifi 5» _£§_i?§§:r
.2-«ax
.ik:§it£:r vmsi §:4s::m:*2¥:i.? .";:§;*- -me' :_1u:i:i§%%;t*
'}_;3§%.?£:'..: «gm .3 it "i3i»"«§¥'-;°'$ £ii:ih?'z;£:r=$ée€i.'i£§
:33: 'mi'
mag-.
§§1<}z'a:£:§_; wa\$- éamri I§§¥§§;::31:3ra;::»;$s--.:;;11"sr»*§:&
gm .1'..'s*'--,i§'. 1.. 1.%13$'3*§;. '»&:"§':i;§»;e sammiifing 'itim ia::ga1 :«fi=m:u:me:m.£s_, féhfi.
--»:s:§¥m1;:jI;a§:3§£:i€:_ j§j;;w'§: ut§:i§rta¥:;§{%'g_ gm :§..;.E¢€~3€%=§ £53' vitim' a.;:t;m;fian':.
-.m§:§;3.fdis:s§ =:1m'ii§:::1i--:s:=:is:3:: €éE",i§§.*s?3;fi§ sham {~:§art§i'i§;§t'%s_:s a§:amra~%'z§+;;._
*§'>'i
3. 'éfiisfiflgh §18?Viflg'G%$Si£)£ij§" mi' {fem casxftiiiezatam. it
1.~;s§;:;::+;=:' £$.E'3§«£'i§ -§i§iti~E1&:¥£I ex:-r§:.;:'s.§:3;+ *-ta-::.~°it:h . Ehs:
fur-*:§;¢2r' zttim 1§iE'g§.i:£§1§§§§'i§§ $.=i.=;xf'§I%>*§'~.>;.t3.r€:1£é?sC§:'31§«".'£i*3.%3--§;§§?i§'§is3§'§'§;§i§£3£ as' .%.m:::s--m1i ;:;:é:ai:§. <§.ue.au1:a*«1m:t;, §::.»em:s._z1_t am-§.&::i§ia:r*1'§: $§3m--_§;2*s~:i»' :;*T':=**1:.1:::"':1a*§'*ssT;'.=$t§2§:v:'1 :i=:;?s~i&$$' %'~§_,;%_.;Zi§.'§i}§-- 'the; -«::::m;g3Erg;in2a1n:§: '§'§§'g$§.E§§§§1'g; ~;lm';.é:'m.+;é:1:}: <:s§'.§§1a~: resgxiisuzfifgu. Amssther sws~at.s*:.;<.§.;<%;:i£' m ':'%a-gzsgjgmsaait 33$ &.mii_::*.é.~>.: g1.juts:a:af;:§i:::g .,a3;rmt'e¥:x.::§_ 'axvhsarttisé it Iixms 'i:a.xe::1'_z::sx::3gx':A?:*i1s:js:i'i.E'3ei m::m:i:>:::2e;2=r;*é. iziziaféz. if rssgxixggiiaiitazixzfi ssla: sag :;.~::%:::=g::«e;2't3s"-- 1:; we-sV::?::a: '::2i1::;.:_i ta:---.a3.::,*:'::i:s.m-. vtimr 'fiér ra Ga1:~%§§3r§<_' :xf'E:a::i§:'?$e E~':j:.s?':$_=¥;E?'.e??s\35:;;%§ .:%~:>1§:_;. i3£'é§;'r:i£ 'was. fimeé ists .§ia§S&it3# 'wittmiiz £31} {§&§€':§'=, iiiéza. -§ia§'§€% ;§.=3f '%<.§'..2§¥ :.*'s.~:=.i='§jzL:'s:1§L. ?é§*.32§ l§.S$'3§.f£.§fi{3.
"+%'§.73L€3;'(E:§§§ 'ps.24=:~,<;s«::3:s;ai.=:>.:x3....»::s:1" 1:3-':3 3:::r::gm;:'4:;j3: in questim has 'Ema: a:Ié>*::;s;:g;::'s:Erz~«:i., §'§1.$r§:3xf§fi§' t:§:.e §_'?s:,z?">:~;"'sg-.?§::::.:*'i;:«a»" :§x;::i:$§;i{>:: hag iimfiaia 'szsn .;2=E§é;'=~Ei 'h.mi3E:,. Thsmaitézr? E*'a§dLm:iamta.
is::§§1é»:.:§ ~m'('li5§i§"' fiatéfii 3.5.;§§§.._§{3{}? §:ii:t§»': ?.€§a::3.§..miar jgfzxys-;§:+s22a::1:~:f¢i»z§»rz;":§3'T 'afiizae grmgmmr in 'quxé_§fi§m" amgri .-msvg§r- fixer' sszxiaasw 'E&s§i$;:is»1a::c1ar $3' é;_1;;e:i;_ .;:j:gfig~g§ _.:ia§ag§, 3:3,} j:{,:£¢;}{§§.,;§_ ts: xatgmgiia ;:i;:i$a::2.t: in .§.:a5a';r;2_{i asm a:i§~:;e';:mmaE'.1§n.s;se-ssivzzaz.(ix? suit: sm '2'3}--1f4!;§;%€¥i}3, "Hm :<:a::m§E;a§z?;.ant. V%:§r;r._e fiank "{3:_:é:'j3. '2§11_1:§3;*f3§3:£§3w zamri. :*€scgz%»::V=:§--t:§=:i azai' ::<::-mz.ni=--a:m;:32 the- _':av:;;2;;m:::r'-- at*?R3§1.i},*?§_éfi£3*¥3f-+- ami §.é*--2 fissit a:::3:1tm;§:t;§2;éix. 3é§;;é;3:§s1l:é:i:£..-- --d3ta<i; 112:2 \:i§:u=:-- --mm;;3i&in:a.nrt W1*):is;°-£3. im- ;.:I3{1Ci;S¥ mung >:s?i:11&r;i=s--si§:t3.2ms::fts.; Tim 5i?€;s:3:$:»i=ai;iI1;§n?;a::--gg;§a§.\»:. i,:Ei£:%__._§}E343 §>§.=' ms... '$3;:%§;.?r'3..:i._ d£é.tr§'eer;'j£ 'I..§:v;:E%§G:E§=Lvzimwssama mi: .'m::ngj Txvitii. jczxxzxgsrgémisssé §eé;:§*;§;:z* '§;e:a_ .$g§i$i1€N3;E?E£3 ._a:m§.sL::::s;':t. saf iiifa.-3.£};,?Ei§;}jEi§{3§« :2a:is;i.. _§:v:~'::s::;i:2e:éA:if T§a:s~'* L$i.{3=;{§§3£1,§'« j-mi. arzfl {:3 my mg 'i:'sae;¥e>:::::r;:
ta: 23333; inasainaantffi ;t:+:a.':.?§i°~*%'-- 1:35' east}:
xrxnmfiifs. ziiiam isgumzii :F;EZ§.€: fan-*s::u;a+ .'§§:.:e; -:§£§§§§§§§§}&fi¥§I. '_'?1;'::-e$m';;'2'£1i§:ar, §j}Ii~*3'§£%m§§§2&§§E§§EiI1t_s;32i§Im.i§B?sé§fS'€i ;m=:-mag. :Xi:E33T{)2-E muggy cs? :§i.*fi;:e;r:§g'¢_. '°_E'm§"'h§ax:}}: .¥:1s:::a' ;gizs§;::;_m. 4&1': :::?~§:}zsa'nt:s-.':i =:§«:,s?i$s.¥."$*.&&§ xa.-iJ;a;m;;{%.i :;m~s~ Eflfiigiifiiflfiflt wifii iim §::a's;:3;§»: ; gm *a=.=§f:i«;::E1 _§:z§:i am' 1, '-3- 1~.'.£%:€§§3. .,::§ 3;' "§~"ad:;s»:i:aa.r.2z. m;j:.ri;mm.s:e§§F. m~.{d»~e=:' hag. Eistflii ;;3»assaz>::§ fly' 2';ftx~:':"?z".§ii7;:z?:*;§;m'¢'5§'; W §*'m"£3.~m- «:22: 'iii ,--.ta- w§.mz~a§:: 'aiiia §}iT1§2§£?i'§'§;Jfi§'$§33;§§?§I§.§. -wimm. :§ir<:%:te'§. ta $x::;;:;§i;.§' t3::a.--:;*; _3;h.g'z%§': :i:t'$1?*¥C§§i.<::§3.¥?;'z:': uiifiiiifi rima mtmtfti fmtthgasi ;:;*13_;%:11-+e:;,_~::¢:e;<;-i fiiéfii 'éxgzsgksiiarxt ';;:;:a;;;;«>- wgssgax-£333' mentai .§1g:>:1:g',. ,:§;r;;:>é:sz:m:;r3i::.:3,¢sa%' anti l'C§:§:,-.fl§~3${;'e'3{'s:*i':.?_3-"'«~ tmifiafiifi 1§&g>:a§_ 'svhisfz ::~.':*§::=:§*'Tz*.:..2a& <:';?ia;az:¥2§:z*;§_§,:£:i----§.2§;4 'i§3s:I~&:;r1g:::§§xi- ::§}:§g:::i::1:I:;2§:::L'i$s:§ w;>;:g3:.* Si '§'.;é'§is..s:.:2'. 33 im 'im ;3r~:w§;' § 'hf; mm;§i2§i;m=an:€» t§:atAh.*e:: iiiama» hfiflfifié 1a»;».=é*.::.°' e7;§'i:§§i?4K'%e§l ?s;§1s;tz§a- gztariifiii?-§1:=ite-.53' ta' as-5 §§§€§V§i3Z€E€3*§§f mm' gixmavs.
'§.§:a:i:Vh:=.=.§1j£:.s 'gararfiufgéfigi; 'tiéi§g *45.'i§§1_'!3.1?€',li "i3'i;1t;_§?&3*3. '§§§ii£§t§i"§§.'«§¥g§§15§ ta 2t§E':é:.:»§f§ w;'1iz:1°2s::%1€ '$§:s ?xm*:?§ t;§:T:sr;£ sit; ma tam: t?»?£§'é¢iEi*§§1§{€3§i:»'§¥3T*§%3¢<iii5--€*32fia1 'Ems nstsi '31amde:d.. =:;2»'.e'a:$.s>' tlizss axifginal §:aé::'i"3:i:'*z5ej::s:;3;asL §$i:»s3_ 'Tizarxssfsxra, 'w:>m..-::":i3\=:*.*. flf *:§f:=t?>@i;.¥i§._§j§ia;i?:,§é,$¥?:3?:L~ta:s §éI.'5xis'«*~:3~ mat samiw Vhfifi .m=:e;2:* viz: bm'23~z--. "'1.'i1»: §:ammia:si~;an.;mt:. :§ure:&:*.fi=:x;::s '§§?f':.£i*' .'£_<*i_.. iiegr the: xmigifiai. mmgfiaiéfiani. -amen wtisafagtfiawy an$x>;s$r"i121s- .E3_:«;°' itiizu; iim _ _ [I .. .} ' 'gn:fm§1;.a::e:§.:s¢1'recs3:\ei with £3133: -"§£xi':¢€3 Lafi ?F~';i§§$ $'-i¢:.€;e*:;v$« ms $a::m.a has §.';¥§§f§'i« .:¥--'"Q€3§°:3i§§$?¥3fi§i £33 the' ~<_<i::>%.2:2:§:1zi::s'iis:is.&'?-az=rt'i'= t'~»z:x='*:s;¥_:2 §§£E::'i-£2-£'§§ éziiigr o'::=tsai1ri$::'g_t§1:é.§::j>m_._ 'f'§'i1'a§ timt '::'é¥a;.é,*. ._._::ia§'s:€:(§. is; m.»~i:;g i:.h.2§=l hagsriiisz ma'-cams: vi»-"'é's:13.3t.2'.=fa.-E sgmcific ::;=.:--s=:-; Xiwi: 5§f§ai*ei:1:g_ 'fix-ass; zsim anti. at":-$'§£:§£§3§§$h§!ii iifééaxcri: {in 1§:'i'T£.';E'=2! I§'1.azz€:te~.x*--'--1::s:;::m:z. xaefizzimh. r<=,-.1-i.am:e=. has §:3€i'£-fit': ;::i&.s::ed by "time .1:s.*s:.'§-"-W'-E.~"$~e:if:i'?2i1:§*.*»-'.§ (sf ma :¥"t3fi§Ri}:I1'£i$2'Ifl'Ei as at 'lg '1§+:§:.§::§':: is *z'.i1;~:§§=*_.a-m "§§1=w:' flit: :;rx::tr:;i.fi2;s:2.*;::> '1:%m:xsé&:*:3ia mg; 'h§m;i_«:.. §f1:&:;.<1:-:_.sham: -i3é:i'ti:fiz'3--駧T:~E isa :i5£§}£..&¥sf1::t?"Ii-- 'iiifi qgagsiisisxi. §>'§1'i1a§::Lt3ii:1;1g§---gum": fixzésas aarimr aw': ra-'33. '§é:§E»'b"i5R?:§i§:g --s:I§b:,=,.v:§1'--f%'z':2§='-ii.::'.¥j:2"?s. msf .§m«m:2=s.-,1ra%§&. --§'§a§_ia':::;:a:'.i in: §mmt1g,s::e'3:: ass', f§?:>za;§>'°a*;§%$' §.'.§:=f£.>;
.:'$g::=:::m*;e:§ in 3Li)§1§_-iZ_E'é'*.§%*.:f2'«§i ':§"ik¥1$§" s1;ua;ra§§*' 1e::«;:;wm's,= 'ésim gar-a:sem:.is:s1w:,--
' aw am}. -V E.~§;2J§m:§ii§::s»?' -~; fi<;'3§:eE§ant ax s;:;§::s1§:i&iI:t' fimaai iris: §§§.§§isii{*¥?€i* s3mr-- m".§'§7s.,°: a:'1§¢:t::i;s._';;2«;§r§ai::i:1:§:-- his _;3§*a2:g;3e::r§i#::s. Eitii ::%s°:$:jgzfm1i:i§2at1.$;,. '§'ra--w:E:.' fiagem. was ii "i.-as '«---.&§:§§$1'Iatx§-ea§§ai'§1i:$ Samiigs ;gi~.g==a::j2. ~fv:a:> 2: .~:.<;:=%ga_:° ta. --i2ax%.'m,:§;2: I:m_c§ mi _ __ --£:$:m-- s::;:3;::.s:asé.a, _R§'§,;ip=e1%an=€*;--
:srs~:g:--'a1.§§:te;::c;i rxstggsisyaefiént' figs 't;§::t.§.as £_i£:%2~+:15_s"
zfasiéjizecfi it: mxmsfi Ahamraigxg fig '§§1«_:*;f Em mi1%"f§:%:*<:§:i'*:1é.%?tEr:§: mm; -afR$,'§2{3,{}i3V,_3Z§fiG--§~ as has its-*zza;$ mart ta =;>:'s§{;§§r:r=:i.s:~;s >;:§um§t§sn:i§ "i§Titi¢--' _g§x-mi in 1€3':.:»tr:2mis§ §iig§'s '«?.l5mx1mi=*sa&§:3:1' a3ré;§§'-- ti} _g§': Vi$.~2§$; »e:?v_is:§§:m::e§ ass -witzgi} hsafi "E'.i.'§f§s%' in :§:»:«. ism:-mssa m'§mm§$:3§§m9' 3% exris:iie;m:ua titm. §"§§.§3_§%L Qiam-m:i§.ssiia§;t'1-. si<';3zc§1,a:::::a'm:2s ix: £1123 .;rs':s§é<m:1$m_ i°=£%?§.'3fg;;\=:1iETi!1;'£:".'L3's'¢'f1; azsaatfiigfi ~'§:§:'§ti ms m=.é.ts;;:::s::\.. 'am ~ "'I§f'E1éE:*: .»:i§§z:%:;::mg*:sr1§tsl.
wew3:_.:fa§3-'ff. in. its '§*Q§'2'»..$§'t'{~2-'$ii§%:"1i':£'.$f'3"'. £3 fin --via:.°~:.zx aéf ;2e;t2-:w%.s.--, :'srs:1la:*'§3ass&:i my ma {:{1t'.i§$'§Ifl:§fi§' E-3:i:s§13;a'§s:e$ $36 quaahmti. maxi set a;§i<ie.,.
:§a:i§m:§&}n.,g__§§r<ia:r, 5'; :2 R 3'Z¥.'3::«e .:a§m<e:a;.I. is afl'§z:s~<s_m«.:iii.. i'§£m§:'.u§:$:3z° ;£'§isguf:>$$:
Rx~:<;irs.=:=:s;asa§. Fixax-zzarzia, "'@;§*'i:§:i_a:r§s. fls:a=:3:.:.;:.E§s:§§-Hi :i-5'?
1.fi...%E~;..§iZ%=f;?é,® ii: ~;§u~a.s§1a=:§ wt; sz=s_ss;+::§s.. e:s::ie:* as ts: wsta.
'§*3f::z::vm::::;=e;:::s:§_. szm. mm {fizzy axf &§1=:>i;E:, §' 'E3; K?
$1?' €19