Karnataka High Court
Imtiyaz Ahmed Shiraj Ahamad Mulla vs State Of Karnataka By Mudalagi Ps on 6 March, 2009
Author: Huluvadi G.Ramesh
Bench: Huluvadi G.Ramesh
3»: r'§"E~§§§ E-§E€.§T%~§ {TEQEERT <3? E<:g%.R?~2£';'E';'X£{}'a
<::§§zc':.:::'.? B§%2§'€(7§;§§ 9:? {)E--§&E§%%?§§§}_. ' %' % %
§A%:@ %?.;£::$ 'rm: ésm §§;%;j~5g.§$ §s.»m:a;i:--§iijjj _ _: "
BEZEi'=5f§R§l'-.__
?%;~§§;: §%{}E'~§'B};;§: zss:§m:::§*;iE<i:-3§£';s:;a:%;';a§:s§=§;§§§;;:%s§§::§;:~§VA
CREMERAL m>m;:%%Azqg¢;%s1?z2§sg
8%:-?2§'EE3€: Z ' %
3: Ezzléijgaz Aifizxiaii-'§Ei1§§f;ii§Vx%Ej:::1;1{i_Egsiéééiigy
§.'i'.?.£§Ee:3.""§.f?3Z'>3;'?=_,
:.f§sEa9h$al§:§1§.:i:*: _§i:VA3§¢gba;§"£§;a§':z:sa%g Siéibargafizfi,
iii'? i'%§:'}_. E __
3i*;»3§a'1.§*:;'%{:§3a{i$a.%§ {i',h.a§:"z1a;pat'%{,a§15
s$..*i'.:>.:~4':e, {:75 39'?
% Sé;';::i=ag ?r:s¢§§; geigaum. APPE:,m:»é*:*s
K {Big {§r:;v'vE'§*§ag§l:11cg%§;;ia:_:s $3335}
;%'*§}T75;:Q .
:' ' ' = ::".é%g._:e 0%? éiaifiaataka,
Eééudaéagé RS' . ES§*J'N§§7§:§'§T
{E335 Srifinaizd Eiavaigizgiaiéé, E+§C€}?}
"§'§";§g C}"§fi}§'§":a} apgeaé; 33 uzzdfiy Sis-rciiazz 383 sf
C;'*:':?.{: pszayiszg 'Ea sat. aaida E116 impugaad jiifiigiiifiiii 0f
Ex.)
{:0:'1vicE§«:;E3 ;:~;:'1{i {)§"'€.'§;é3§' :1?' 3%-:z";€.%:::':<:€ éiaterzgi z%.?',V:2i)_{}3_ in
E'§.<'_"i..§'~E:>*f>'§/ 3%}??? 0:": 33.13 {fie sf' E ;'i<1c§§ti:311a}"_§§'@§:;i{;:1:--§
<}:,::ige,, 33: _§§<>,igam*z1,. arid €::'{.c:. " V
ffzis <_tr%3:1i{2ai appeai <:€)mé1j;g :33} 'fig .. é:_§'__fis 2
siafg', €123 {imzfi d::§3l_2:em{§ {ha f{)i§{N:i11g:
JE_}'i)GME3%:'€: AA :
'f?i':i$ E3 3. jaii aggaal :§fi§,'f3,?i§fi'--V1'I'f3§§..':7§§-"_ ' ihz-2? 3.C%$!.§S{ifj§
againgt @362' {:;"{§e1* r:}§'1._ €{f?'G_£"%§f§L€'§}:.{)fi' .§~;€::f3:2'1<:€ _§l'i8$S€€§
agaiéést ':%;1a;':': {$37 "€:%'1<:%.w-};5:a;{'*:1a5«:¥_ ;--%,£;§_:;§§}" ",§5€S$i{33ES duiégs,
Eifiiaigaazgzikg E ii? ;=2i§3_*:é{':" ff, Eéfiifiifi.
2.' 'z%§:c{:zz§"§:'3:g,_ .'?::%:;:_ 'fi*;.@ {'3&'S€'3 £2?' §:>:'<3s;<:<::,_:'%:§.:}§';, (ms:
"?a3'::;§§ " Ej';i'::ai;:§.a§§,V SS1": 3%' '§%;§z§é':&<;§€:xz Y€$.§f§'%«'E3E§i E"§i;::a:323,§::,
§?;.Eé{i :§<;3f;:'§;:aé&§::i 23gai:;';:§§i 'zifiéa aatzsusaii zafiifigifig fhm, he
§'$r?§:*';§'.'§..3:v§§§J§:;'}'§" 1;§¥:;'::"'.a:"n'i3a$sa:i9:' 21:23:' %-6.:-23"*§3f:ag $152.23 ;%;§.2f}-"$3
%}€§é§}gE.:ég'ib his .€'23é.i'":e:"i§* P'&f.2 '§¢Ea;'§':§.é&v, 3% :22. sax; ':53 ca;':'y
_::~é12<:§{::iger3 mi; §';§?€:, am} $13"; an 3}, §.€;E.§%é}§ z2r{3'm':d {is.-.i~3£3
2§,7?;'::i1'{A%%?§2€E§ 2531:: cam§:}ia§:A3.a'§:é. $22152 §:}a1'*E<&<% his <:a3'* E3683" Eaxi.
2 '"Sfaa1':<§, zieag' _?'eéé§;jg:2a:::§ 33:13 :~::a;':{§, %§é::*£»*;€ as{:':.z;$&:;'é »§:»€1"3::3f§$
a§s§§:*:}a<:;%s€i:i§ him aszzzi *;::}§{§ him that '§'}7,i%3}=' Ezaszi ':9 gig: is
iéizkzxk via ,;5:tE*;a3':i 'E.-G aiiemé 3. maryiagé: 33 %;':'~:~::}%
'ECG pick up Sfiiilfi §i}€E'S3-GE} at .A:h:§:":i "F323 fi2e"~<:__£§:1:jg2?;é;§zfia:§:. "
céemazidaaé Chargfis 9? R3. .}72i}%E*;'»»...4§';€*€>:f:'i '' $[é;«"i4:'_%;;:_s*:.é:1i. 2
p<:'::'s:;<.>n§s. (1131:: (:3? me 'three agcagsaci pe:~so%:s;' §:';1¢'*ii=i;;i'
tE"1€m. sag: by 'i'§'"§€ sidfi 0f i§1eV.<:.:}_:1'1pia1ir_:a7*;:: a¥h07§%-*a}7$ &1f'§a¥if:g_"' L.
{be czar mad £133 Qther {W8 égsfijiased §3@:'Sir;:::-S E11 {he
rear 563:3 Sf £115 car, gar 9,3£'} ';:{;§n}""%E1&3i 1"*e:«':c1':éd Athani
and "£:'i";€ car was s;fé2;:.>p<:<'i-- } fé*':3$1:7t, {:;f_ {ha hatsse «sf
§;c>u:1gar sister Gfifiv, §§1:i"i7;.';':;'ié':3 g§f;.i.§';e car. T236 sag'
waiiadfor 'abéiizfii »%:.;:3"";r;:"z§:'m'3{,&s ami thez:5a:§"'£€:' 3795i} 3%'
ihé': i§'::f:1a%,:3.g:;f 315%: 3313* i:§_5§'10 _h.a2:§ gcsrzit E0 '§}1*i2'z§, §'.§"3€§i" $§,:~:s*é;<:tr
z'€§é.;i§'£1€'<:3 S3fy"§ i"i§.§. f:£i"}a*£ she has aéready is~:.§.'% ii": a:1aif:"1::=:r gag'
z3:::;éi gsigé §§3'{.c~ ikzs <3 * 83$ wfien iha {:35 was §§:ivs€::'1
?;j0i'é*§ar€i§;:=§""'i:§r:}§{g%z:T, 792": {E33 way' at 5:1 §}§:'::E{3€ aésazzi 2 E333
aw-35-* fa-:;3::§;.i'.V'_?*§aga1"::§z' véfiags, {E36 imfiaies if {he ca?
askeii mmgiaézgani :0 SEQ? fishes star 5353 thagaf Waxzieii :5
~ af1$%.g§}"€:§ r:a?;"a:r€'$ {:33}. i§J§."i€i"1 {E13 Camgziaiizaifi E-§E{§'§Z)p+'5:{§
'iihé "#33:, "we if Eng imnaies get dam: frag': '£5335: 93}: grid
" = -~.{-EEES p€:'$e:1 whe was $§'£"§iE"E§ ii: {ha rear 333: fiiigtiraissgi 2336
W'
:'::e<::i<: 2)? E.i1::: <:*;GI:=;;p1ai;1a3'";€:'. wi'é?;: ffégze :1}~=iafi m;;3€ ;i¥;1§§;..f:;§*:%.;é<:i_ {£3
$'::'a5.":g:?1%a'E.§: the c{;fi:;3§a§T:1a1'fi;. {frat Q3' t.§1%:':5_ j .
;:3€':'s<."::':"1s E§='§"1{Z'$ gei: 011': 9%' ms car, {§3;,i1§_.'%":+i°:1{§_-'*;%i%:'--i5§a1é{i €335? iitzé' "
€{3::::s§3i3éz1a;1€;. and £216 iéiher Si":21§T3'§3é(§.A~'Tv'£3"§3r:._ c{}§;z;§.%é§i;:1é%:::§.
with kxaife an Efzig é§;§3§§O3fE1€}*i, _ {:1'é:;és':,, i'>:s.§::'§:. 3Ei§,g;'£'1.?=.V?«§:._§";%"§§i'§1'V L
i:ii"'E'i1S szraé ez:.<:. $<>r;16_§1z:;w, *§.§i<5i:.i?{}}fi1§§}.8§i18;"z'§i?,_Afififlagffi ta
<$;%i%:r:<:3;tTe h.;:;::;::§€ 15%"; <::%J.:;.§'s.€:s {:s;;..:.:3@ =:1¢<:us«s£i @€§:'S3:1$
éifid szsg-"1313: Ea} 4i,.i9::3._ {§é}§,?f.i@:;§S§;i{1€§:' Sizidappa whc
._,' séeie;-«'V"g;:::§ fefl in }f'3:{,>:'3;i: <23' 1;i*1z~?:
was Smyirg zg §Z.}"sf
{:afi:TE€:¥-SE3-sad.' i}1':'j'é.§f;V'6 »T.:1€a::g:7i*1a§?E:iE&, the Saki figzfsif: a::<::11$:5:d
wezfli éiii«'.§'?Lf%,fa %2~£%i:h .'_{h%€:_ Dégciegiizg tééeiz' _i<i€::";€.§§;-* 'zfhgit:
" < €,%i:€'«:a£:§€;$§:é £a?§::*i:%...%3.€a:'ifig geagizs pagfi, 'E{'-S§::ir:, am? were
' .%'9$§§'§:i:":g; me, '(he Camlpiaixzi camfi :0 be flied.
'1-s_IE:}7:. the m§Tdaigi1§: [P'%?. 32 S§{3e:§3;p§:>a caxzize agaé
Saw " :_%:f::: Cfiiiigjiéififiafif. 313$ 31} {ha §11e:amz:§':i3t:, fffiii
%§7_i§§}»'.€$S6S 5;-Eatigeuda, Ehémapgza am} Si{§€§E£§}§3&
'§'a(isa:1.av3r ¥§.§§{'} 'ilfi-='€i"€ r€$i<3'11":g 313. izhé: :':£=:igE':%3{:v:.1.§*§:'2g
Eeagzids csiésciiézii. P€Z%f,1.i3 ahivappa? Siiiaiaggpgs, améi
S
W
;§§:'§:ig(>:_:<"':a i:§::§s>:*:m»*::'i. i'.%:€*: f2€:T':£%;22E§% ';::<:Ei<i:::. E?%E§§4;_£ ~ 3
Ciiiiiéi '$9 {$13 sp=::§ii 5-zéeiig '£5;-$92": 392?»? $8 E--ifi,§'_*§{;:'§a§e§s:E:a_'§_;~ %?'€jTf T?:::_'§«'T _« '
%§=*?'m.{é3;3ag§. '"i"3':é: C:>3.13;3£:::é3":2*s3:;$ 3:33: '%}_'§'Z§:§%;}, €:;i§:§% §§E.{§':i{§iV§-§E'§.;
i\:€a.:"a':'.§"}i aéaté Ejififé PE§iE §raV:';s~3J;_:§$.{é{§"' ._iE:'= {.0 §§:é::'1;:;'f;é:a<:123;
d%€:[:12:%.{:<% ta E}'iK»' .3 PC zszhsfi 3:"; '%i§§:::' 2"_"E{T7{}1'§{"'§*:§VVA'%f."§'éi€ {fz;21}§;>§2:§:":i'.
in Eiarmada, Erie :§a11Té£:_?;%.?;1s; 7fsi':T:;,§;:>§. "i:fi:_':tVz;ffig: 'me: <:<2":'_z3§3éa§z:2::':%;
ané §i§£'1a?,'i}I'('"? £633' iéfzaé <:::s:':'s:§.:§3i:3a::;§. i:"a$"Eé;§;%::"1.
5%. "E'§firs:V 1: Eigaéé S¥__E$§ffi§.}j§_£E€§. :-si2;*:':: %§":§:.__;.:'§€:$
am. his é:§§~:_'§~. ':.?;:z: P4557: Sizéfzfzéi Ezézii 'bi: iiéézéaaizai
§~§<3:?;;g:%.%_.:a%:E u 'at: {.§7'V;}2§€«."§Lif%§.,"'~§5'§.§?.?i§"€f Efii}:i,£%§;:%"1{§§:, §'E§?f§5;%_, ::}:':
{:Xa3::§:':é::g aigsi' V<:{}§3"i;3§3i§:a:'1é;. .%'{:au.§:s:i 'E13153? i§':€::"€ 5:2}:
" %.§":é':%$e€§"}'::;i:i:m::§$ E§'§.:imé{§}§'f i,ET::'s':%*:%E;i«:t::$ :*$g.>;§;:3:'z, §4:r":€i${-3;:'§ :m*s.s::'1<§,
€;*«.ii=.:?.§'['a.:E'€;é:3.s§§';, fT~:.f:f;.é;;:E?£A%h§:Ee i:'1s:::%$z"--:{§ 'a%:a:,:§'::i am T§'}€ :'ig§'1'?§ s=:§":_":§<}%5;,
§"i"%€?T§$?,{_?_.- aaéfizzzkgifi {'}'i?€.§" sizzisé :31": isaskgiéfi, i:3c§$s3s:§ €5;a::'1.z§1€§.
msséi" ésaétk SEE §*ig'§";% Siiifi, &:t,::. sméé S€§§.?fi{'§ 33%;: Etwfi i;2:1§z13;*§;«€:3
g;:*é"=g*§:%'%:{}1;S in :":a?;":3;€{: a;:<:§ zaiixer ,§3"},§'§§§'i€$ aria Siifazpfizéé ii":
1§";am:'€:. §,,a*£e:"" '€E"3;£3 imgairaai Cfifiifjifiiiifiifil was %m;3§:,€::§ at
' iffiisifici H§3$;:§§ai_. '§3e§gam3":,
J»
'§'E'1<: PS3 :2?' ?v§:1:§a§gi_ Pzsfgca S%:.a%:ic;§:'"i"'i_'i':g§%,:%~:%§§»::*:;:{%§~ _
a sags: ii} _?a:§1_:{ia'iagé R3' C3;'iméé fig.§T§};fE"§1*§%18.»é;E1<% $:;:::ii."=
5:16 ' ii: {E36 <::<>m:§::"*;E:€:{§ §_%*§a§;§;<;'§;sj4ai,€_-.~ .. 3
'E'i"3€:1'%:a.§'%f:1; E~}'%Z2 L --.,,§?';§iE», =i:.<§é§{ 1.1;}?
i'§*i1?es:ige::{§<:.::, §}E'G€€€f§€§% §:§'fe€'i{e{i
'Q36 ;3a:1{:§":a:m:;::a as siaifiiznttzfi af
%%'i§l1{"3SS$S E:g§€%.5{} "«§§§:é215€'.~§.:fé:iLi3:;'%"zfi$ {sf '%;'1w%°:.:r€§.
::::§:22;%;§ai::1.:饧;§%;::'E'»{i:€:"}:€§§ sf Qifexaas. {E}:
§':::*it.h§3r: ' '*§z;9é $; §'¢fi'\5f3a:§€{§ '£'§'§8;§'. 'i§Ei"i
2:-1:13 7:}a$§,>:;::{ia:3;'V garage 3%; _E%::§§§a2_s::":3 3:25": 32%':
2z;a:":é;',- E33 EEK?':;%eg::%<iV.g;8§';'?::§e"'§:::i ssimsi SE15 iifii'.
" ~ "--§"_§*.za: '«..;§!<_;s::,;$a::§ 53953.' E. azgzi 2 Wfifé &{'E"f:?$'{€:{§ ear;
§.'?;'EE. §%:}'T{}§§ 9;;=:3{E éikéiz' z;0;%3.:::"§:a1'§' siaistfizazéis 33%: r<":£:s:2r%:§s=:g%
I 2::32{% .aif{f§2e %:"zS'i,:5s:3<:e 9%' '£335: acizizgezi :29' E E-mffs %:~.::3.$
ff :f5:i::~.:%;€:;"e{§ 2383:; t§.1<é fiiifififi af' <}§§'&:::<:€:, Rs 3135:: §'€C§'¥'€"3Z"€E%;§
{Exit Eagia §"'€"i{1'{}§'%Z§€3f', <':2i§_:;s{--:i:t€ ai fizéé ififiifiiiiififi {if ac€:.:;*~§€:1:i:i
gm, Ea ;%i'?,:::2'* :§;z1%:<2:~;%.égaETé5:':§ C§'}fifgi? fsimtzii wag ézzéfi §7§i?3f{}§'€f
'§'E'";:*i Eéaiziéfai e.§;';'*»é.§'Ci, {E-<>i»:;§§{, §:§§;'2a<i :}§%%:::r::.5 35 '§.;EI"§£§;§j}§{E §i>f;;'
W'.
M3
{E16 {T':<:vz;:*%, 53?? S€:s$.%<>:";$, 333%: 1":1a§'§.:':::'° is {:0:3;::"i':%'%:.'m::i§ "ié?g 2';Ii'1a
{f<m:*%. <3?' ${"'i$S§€§L%f}S. ""i"?:e:'€é::§"f{.&:; thaé §§Ez~}§'§f1§{7§.f::§€:§§:Si{}f§"}S
<E'i.§{§.gff .€3:a:*:;1,&:{% {:§:a:'gz%:S :«::ga;*z:':.:§é: asatusétii I"1Q$ .'§~,§i§ §_~§'~§:>:' E"._é":%*:_ ' '
sfiifigfié =::s§¥€'{:z':€ iiiiiifiii' $€::'zis:>:'1$g'a--:1"'é; '§{Ai§;(V};}fi§i%V ::§f
and far ihfi affazzce ;3m3is§1;:.%:}ké z1;%52<:iéi"=-- s€e:t§g7:.:. :?{i§§ 5%'
agaizizgt {he aceusexi 119.4, a::C€;i$é{E' }}ié;a.<ied 1163?;
gui§?,;=; 3:32:31 cams: ta é3::: 'iri€d.;_V
6. '§'_h.:% pr0;jseCf{3%:§,::;3""; "~.',L'<3§§2:i1'1'f;;.";5e{§ in 8}} 23
wi.:11€S$e$_15§:;;.r};_a go: ' fi1§I"§{_€€§ 3: €§GC"iifl1{','§1tS- 2:351:23 16
13f.1a'{@:*§;::E ::§{2c:1>§':V35{é:":'i:s;;' '«f§_'§1»$:::aai"£er accaaséiéi ;§:<:':'e axmiziflcii
in 333 'atar":;:3 §«";.f1:It:::* havimg hearasi bait} SECEEEE, 'aha
ieagszisxgé. Sa$S;i_§:':S ;.J*:_;.{ig€ {:{33'£V§,Ci€{§ am? seiaéezzaceii
aiimagéééii £105.} :_:§::{i€1" fififiiififi 23;3{2} "E 811:1
3s::£§;iit*f£{:i={§"i}i'::,;f:;c€:23€d 139.4-. Efieémg agg:'i€'%<i by {he Said
{s:'?:;:§m' §'"§§C.vé€C1}S€{,§ 33:33, E E9 3 hgsare pmferrtézi ihis appea}.
: Haarcl Sriafiwi}. .?%~'§aQi_?;I', Efitarfisti C3{3iji§§S€§
aégafia is &pp{)i}1'E€fi as ar:1i<:us3 curiae £23? £326 a';3;3e}§a::is
£3313 the iearrlai G1E)"+J€fE"3I}'i€E"i?§ fieaéiez' _f£:r§' {ha 833:3.
3%
'§§1£rs'si§g}:;s{€*".i§:}zji;= was/_ : -
8; {E E5 tht: $:.1E3m§s$iC«n 63%' the i€aFf}_.%?.€?14'f..§{}EE:'§$€§§
far' {ha a;4;::p€E§a:1.ts§, that €:.§':t=: &}}}}€:§_§ai'1'f$ i1afs_.,-*f9e:""~.1:}€:'~E i:t?.';:~
§i'"§1§.}}§C§iifi(7§ in this Case. The <:¢¥1;Ifl;.. £719.23' 519$ ;:;V::fzj:5}?3§:fifg-'
appreciaifizi {ha :3135;.s:*iaE_._€vidéi2{:év. on Trficegfiéfi. " :'
t5'v'\
33365' x L
<:{>nt1':-1{iic'{.01"'y £2?' fhéz» ,_{:m11'p1ai11st "§:.**1<-',[ Ehgyi. 0%" $316:
vf - " '. '
. -- La; Ia-at
{:<;m§:3.1a2§1t &"J€I"'E:€1€E"1iS__ j45é1:e; statzizzzéirzt sf {ha
<:0'::1p1a:in:;~'1nt rficorciad §3%;;r._V:§5i§; §3<3.':i{,:.<==;';--.i'V_*v'}:_"'§,'"-im recevery at
{he i:13'7£aI:cei 1£>'i7;§i?<:<1'=a3;f::3ee:§ tits, .3 ES'---i:a§i:f:*a?§?' £5 tffie varsiozi
Gf the §:a_i1'1'§:%1;1_';:"1i;22r;"i;--.4V higizsfifi', shat 8.C€':u§§€{3 120.3 has
3;SS&Li:{€(f§«. flies ;:a:§'i113_§1:§_ :;1;3_";':.--~i"fl is;-=ii§'1 knéfé 3.: MO. E, "1"h<'::'6
waa no i:}.;¢§:?g.§ufiCati{;r:ngiaradfi had, in '$15 a*a'::$€:§1s5 sf
€GE1{i'i£C§.€{§ amai §.f§:a§: ;3.c<:u$@{_§.
3 ' ,2" I ' I . *3 E 1}
133$" bfiazg iaésely §EE}'}iC£1i{i{i if} fi"';l'~"3 case 'E'h:::"e 3 Pi
H "i:1¥§.s;§sf:%_,:s: Efagarsiiizg E'€CG"%z'€§'j€' Qf §%e'£{>$,} :0 E3 aii the
'A'-';i:'3':a§T1c€ {>5 3{':{:':;$€:{'2 1:52, Ha f1_z:':,%"z€:* Sub:3:.i%;S that. as
---53:1' §E{"$S€C?;E'{iQI1 'ii'€I'Si{31'"E aatcuseai pm. 3 :2s:%..1*e amund §'§i€
W'
:":<::<:§§ £31? tiisst <:{>:1":;":%z-3éz":3;:1{ gmci i;ri:%:{1 ts; S§'.:'a:':§;3;aV§};ai;r;§ 5}_:_%::1s
Tzfifi'. 'fifiii 'ft ia 1:9 §§}._§'E1}L'}" 01" £3. mézzaiiazi <3? :31": ..
1".a<:<::§«:, 1:; {ha %'{}E,1§'1{§; {E{i:"Y.i§i':§fL€. __ ;C§}ji"1i€?I'i£'i§1;i§ 3&3? $224:
€"3'%'i€§€'f3.C€f itxi "by fiiii p;f=:>Sf;C{1'€:E__§z1 i:§§i};E} 5%' ':.:i:f2'1'i2,v§t::"E,';.j£'i§<":§§.§::3:*:s:,VV'2
am: 1£arn€:{§ C{}'£_E}'3§:§€:§ _§'3§"§i}"€{'5; é3g:§;u§€.{ aE._ ¢f %:hfi} ac<:3;}.see:=:E.
gmtrflb
9. §'+3=':"« itcsfiiiafa, .V vj:C§ré;;€*JF31*r3z:1€'§T1ET E}i€aG£{i§'
SL1_b:1";§':'.%;&:€%. Eihézigv.'i[1fi%€z*§'iV$é<;-- 'Ea 3201:} 'i&&zm§=§':{:a§;%{}i1
AAAA
}_;)ara<i_i€ as :'n3':»;afi_}=* *3; '§:}:';{«: 3::{::uS€{'§ ,?L§éi"»£{f tz'ax='::§rr;{§
3.21 ihfif €332' (FfV_{7ii?i§'§3§{iL§§'1éi§'§'£1 Q?' w7§'::i{::: {:<}m}::-éaima;1:.
himsaif a>i:*':z::~: §#§E§€§{'§ii'§§'t§E'; §~3.,E1{§. as V.3i"i(}1'éS '§'}§§;35iZ'€:3S fizsra €31'
A uz-é1é~§* %':;g%%;::w£:§;A 311$ '§;%;'1s::':*{:f{;§§*%: i'fE€§"€ '§«'~£§»%$ {i§";<::1g}': 'izimé f<::"';h<:
' .<5{§;52§;f.§,%;1":a;::1fi§' ii} fgaik a;:':{§ gfié". §'3.§'};1iE:ia3c xiii": éhz": asazzigziifié.
E§'s,1;§;€§'1s€_"_v»::§c'::;'::$:3{T'i %;a%<.i:'1g 132$ (}§}§'}QZ'€.'§,Ei§§f}g' §fE€i'%'€33 8;§£;%€§§."'i
§2'{;s:m. ?:C:i.§},}«-§'f'§7i§ the car, aligécs .§.§;:§iisc:'%:3:iz1,a2'_,::§;r 2-zg:e:;m}£;{::i
{ha fciéfizgjgiaiiaazii am} zzemsséi i;mju:'i&s aaviih §<:"':if:3. 'i"z:<":
" 7E{§V:é*:::i§:19:*':j§; 0%' PWWE s::'§;@1;?:. i{i::11:§.§§i§'2g 'iéxa a.c:::%,1:~*,{::§. ami
;z:'e<_S:}¥€::i§ 53? car in 3; gz2;'a%g<s:, ififlfiifiifg pfimg fflifiiii §}I"GE?f.:f the
ii}
gzziii £3?' Eéize a{:€::.13€{i. "?;"':':£:j Eeamsté {3--=c)¥a1*z1.m€2zt §?§%"::'a.s:'%t:?
fz1r't.?;€z' $u'ts;'::§:t=ed than in me guésti if §',a}{i;"1g~~3,f
égaazzssci §13'£?€': §'}€3§'S{1€«£{§é3{§ 'aha €:{>m;:}§a;Z:1a::::{_?{:{§"§=€::§<§§":§s ties: 2 '
er; fairs: am s:~:;§":ii6 {ha €'3Q}"iE}33a§f§é%._i"}'§ H:";4E§i,§§3g€§' in '{'§;3T§4§'§§:';§:§,'
E}: 33.6 ::::iai:*:igh=;; 3.: 'she Ifi3{§i_).€S'{ £3? ':,2.::£:13§~;é;:§. fiwl. 7%;
<:Q:':1pia;%na11'iA Stopyeai $316: a '§.'_§";.&
aifififiififid aftai' a.sSa:2é:§§§*_g in} :0 'éimiz
(:0:T::j;3§ai:'1a§":§ ifffi, E13112. ----§:1<£ e9.:':}:mi%,:§€:s:.i
ra%,>ha=::r}? af' if-E aogerfi: gr:-.z;§§
S:_:f§"i<::i$'1'3€--, V:'.%n»,;>:{T-'_:."v'V£'flfV::§:.'§%;v/'V':L.3"§.~'§:,8%'€{£ §}{}S.} "Ea .3 gmi7i'i;f,.-* (:2? gm
0f'§'t:'§2C€r$VV%1},3;V&g:»;ii{:i :;§:a.s3:§a§;;§§i €§<>:.1'i;i zfiraii {'25: s-*,:'"§*<';;"
<;~r~ '.§fii€g%:.Ei'{§; ES' ":?:€>::_:1;_§1:ifi€r;§ §::§; ?:h{«: §fi2'§.i'.§l%i{.i 'i;r§,aE judgge in
' ;:éf>:}v:€::i1:g' «.,a§;:;:§§ $€:z"§:§3;1ci§'1g the 8,C{§'LiS€{§. Aces-z«£ii:*2g1}-*,
é;i%3é=é€ar;::§é%§é {:§rG'¥f3§"'I}fl}€f§il E3E5z3;e:§€:' :*&$i:sts:d the agpsai
* 3%.. E2"; iii:-: iighi 3%' fix: abs?-sa argu::'1€:zf;§s afivazacaééi
'$33? '_«i}@?;?3 sides, the §;3<>imiS that :a:*<}:,1§<} arise far
{i:{>:1s逧emii0§'f: a§'§=:: ~
gr»-M
iii.
EV:
M
W}1€:§*i*1e2" ma triaé (ram? is righi Er: 3"1.01::'§:__i:'ig"
an $13 micirzighé <31' 31__,i~ii i§398_--"'f[%3é%:_¢ '2s::'f:::1:g:::~d3
§1a*vi.:":g c:oi':$pi:'<:<.§, wok 3:"-I16;"t;=::%fi1§ia§§3.éni;V' §{3 E'fr.:6
guiaéz 0:' Eakixzg his :i;::;;f <>3'§"-}%1i1*:%,_ Efiffifiséfiiifiiéfigi mad.'
5::-'a,us3€<;1. g1*i€vm.__:s §r:}u;f}§ €::} V?§"l€: ¢@:::,§§iaj:§;a12E. am
mbbaéi {ha cz-3r'?"- T - '
§«¥§'f:e°{;%1erA'£.1f;a i:§?Z:TiaY}":':%§L:fE...}a"v§.,a5; 'cc:§3é::':§tt.&& £1513? €"ii"f'{?>I"
mi __i_':§é:g;a;§§?;E:§;g'. §;'IG;.:f:§1<i'; a<:z:u:3f:ii g'ui3'ij;»' 0%'
33ff&°E'_§&"it":.S agzsgw. agéziizgz i3:?:%::':::'?
7fj%%'.Ei:a?; acazusegi §"}a'V€;': aaismiiititei?
'i£%"§i;é£Z%j:€:' '%.§i€:~ a::»_<5§.::§%é3é1 am €3.":%.;1"'{.'1i:{i §€;;" 3.<:qzs.ifi=2;aE.'?
- -V:\:?E'13;ii
'V " Qfifiézhai 0'i.1.t$e'£, €336 evédanaté af PEEK} a,s$':1.:21@3
:'§:,;.2{:h §%:§.}§2§::"%,a;:2c{% in '£326 £2338 an hazié Es: E{n:::ais: Whaihar
$16 aézztzsfid SE6 imiaiveii in °§§'}€i' <:{;;':z1m§saiz3§: af €3.26:
-r2?'f¢:":€'é:'. ?'%§2.E :23'; ififi éiviéézizza, E133 dspgseii E.E'm'{ ha
' 'iikxzsivs €§E'§¥"iI};§ gmé ix: was; {i1'iv§;;:1g 322$ ?'%.Efi?;"3&SS&{§f."}I' €32-2.1"
V__?;§i~:a1'i:':g ?§=::2».E'§A~'23j?i§ X342 3% a taxi, '$35: ;<-?~23;,§.zf1; :*::5;:*
.
figifiéky .
E2 r-9;' 7:3€§9.§1$dg Ea} E33 fa3T;.§;'3;€§'. £33: 33;. E53' 1998 z§:..*~:~~...'*:.3_.jVu%5i__"}_1L"§'i:g:§":":§ :s:§'1%::"1 he had ;3a§%<:§~:d E133 sag' at 'ihfi _5t£z§;ui' =.:s'{'.a;f1{§4_ u §'§§§}T;:3a1'1i ?i>1i:<§-Sia::':{é, a€:":':,:i;ed r'1i::£$. 1 f3'-.g3'p.;:::f{};2;v:E1€<i'V«'Eiiifii is': him his $213' is a'tt.ea2d 23. Ifiaiiéiagé z::_V%A{§r:3i<..a%§.:"aft§::f iaisiing fiéfiii' raiaiéve f'r:3::.2.. Athani, féfir A §%g;%2.i;:}*: §.}::~3"
Camgiaiixajit. siemalzcieté {:hz3_f'g§S Q3" .§"~<1'5;*;;--?¥;,Vf'2€;Ié{E/4; ta 2s.:hic1":
the. 8;(:CE.,1S€(§ ag1"i2<:<.:i '_ 'f~:3.»,.'3G $11116}: left igspazai is Aihaizi am} 'rc3;:v::3§:6:I{i ;5;5;Q7i::_;<5::'1:i. agmzmd 9 "gm. £6; fathazié, ":}14%:"*:i§:{t:1e3é<§';";:§>s~';."iA..§2=11{iV'.;?;. g¢:;9§é: {imam} {man '£116 £393' afgoi €§2'@;Ei_ '?i.@: ";-;1.E:.=§"{,3T:~;_é"§{{} .E::'i.§':g mafia" mlafivézfi 'W§'1{"3F€3§iS '$33 aatatifiseii :';<3;I?; %¢;~fav3,'é§_}L$;€i;1g in {ha star. fiffiiéig" 011$ h.E':="i3i£", acégugziafi 14:33. "8!:1§{§ 3c®'£;:.1rz1€{§ Stating {hat thajg iteziid «1":i:«-i;{' b.'I'*§%;zg ALE 'ms ihffifi acrzcusfid and the "{d:§:::'i1*g:%§é.t;§j{'15eL%Q":*%i. iészaia: 1113318 Athani. Tfwreaftfzr, may" were '§j.:',ff5(':6§v§i.i'.i§t»i'§g_ iawarcis Cwkak {ram §§£.ha11.%.' E13 éiha mea:'{;::.i::;m tame}: E136 gar was going E1633? Efiagaaxzzr 4:12:33; iaiciatxaseci n{>s--:.1 13:} 3 askafi the coxzigiaimani ":9 stop 'aha ' ::21r statizag "£i*;a€ {Easy W311? ti; ansxzaxer 3":a"az1:*e'S {:33}. §:i:{:us€<:i I168. 3 W83 s§i:I;i;ng :31: '$15 Eefi seat. =33' the: . S ~4W'"
<:<m1§3§a1§1"3.': amii A-2 éiifiéi 23:3 sat ii": this back. $i3E§§'_§';.'._V AS 3011 as '($36 <:c:m;3iai1'1a11t s't;a*§>;Qed €316: €381', 8.€:§§;:.s<,%{i----.r2f;£a;§:s;_w"i_ and 2 pm: 3 Iljfkéil mpis: aracgzumé tfze ne(:.}<;' 't':;'f'--=§{§;';3xt'a;i';::1:::¢;iV3";3_.::*::' . arid {Tried {T8 stranguéaiii him :'{:<:c:'1s€€i '~3":{:~.3" §;"~f";f3;£"é,e_:<§ assa2_1ii;.i3;;.g tha C{}lTI1{§13iI1€i§}'§"*~Efififh }=;3:1ifr{: _ {)§f;'é'1is .3b@{t1f;,-gf abiieinafl, chest, ferfiarm, efip. 'H".E'§'z§f%_§;:§fi1;:}iai:"aa:1t is gaid is have frszn his right hand 'is says Z{:%,;;1se}_E;' 5:*{..E*:€ zzyisrz §°£}§"3€§, his i:§:A33?3:1rg%§;*':: %:fe1§I.f%'fi;::'a":1§'e<i. Acaugfid 2,3,3 §}':1s§i¥:_§1 '7i:;i1:;'3V_ and Simtte, he, feéi iizjivfs he r<>?.%e{iE 5;%r;f§;?:: Vics' " .:g}%%_.:"s'£;3;12:::i: in ms adjeirzséfig 133:3. '§"::;§:%1*'r:~:23i'£.€§g "';é:{:_§f:fi$€:E 3393.1 is 3 task aaxzafg its car A A %.7c;az;5a:=*.éiia S:gOi~{8;%:. "" The Casnagiaigzazzt E'8iS!C:':{i a cry fer 371631;} '";»3_i"ié. 'j§'«;§§%?s,2€"*F£s:§fi--.,£a.:z}<=: fffifii gaaarby Eand and gazfs Waiar iii} 'd;'*i§1}<: a§i5.__:;-ibaui. 3 :5; 4 persans gathemd thaw. {E2136 GE.' §:I§A§:_.":"::5f§'§V""{-:31Ve"*5._i'".3.':E'%'E:4 Ea 3:316 paiéce. gtaéian arid broughé: the ;:»0i§{:&. * '$391335, {fame paiiits i1::c;uér€:{i axié ha :1a:*3:aE:~:{1 2:336 Efssgifiigpzit, in Esziarathi 3ang'a:;:;g:: azié E223 {$03206 %s:m':£-'; 'f§'i€i' ceizlpiaiitt in E{a:1na.<ia. '§'}'1€::*€a§'iaI* ht} wag E';::§<:{~:f: ';:::; E5;
{}03{;;a}<:' Hc+$p.§"ia§ ami g_§;V€::': §"i§S{ fiizii "i:'.§'éézi'i:3(:1<"f:E*:";»j aiizai i;h$1'{:af§§:' hit was sE":§§t;@<i £5; E}ie:3:§"i<:'é:. 5'-Es::§;;)§?<a},...a2..§) E3§i§§§i;a%.:;:'2":
fa"? f:::1f§h6:§" ?.z'<:a.'i,:."z1€:I'i'a W§':€*§1"€f é'-Eff was ;11'3~;'";ée;-ii:1fé:'3;9aA_*;i'~ €631' 3 _§,~'«§ "
nm§.1':;§'1$g E2. 'The i}:23'1;:§'{:<_i fifliiivyifliiiavili,'§.§iV€Ei7{§f'§,€§V{§ €315: §"E§7§€3I:§ 13:32:": wE":ic:E': was 2;2:e;:é<3._fG§';A%éi':;'A§'%;§"é1?2.§%.:1a{i:§1": ":i'sf; ;3_::":::z3S{:{% ::"::::.?: miai daiszs me kxzife '*a%;*'i3:i.£:E";.Q.<;§sT§}€,;e {;;s§€s:1 5 3:8Sfi.E;i§€. "i"E'16 gkcsiizétt Ehé: €:;;,:'..$£ETT:%;£:§'§ '.f«.é,%;;; 3 -*2" gaé. rééifiaszzd '£3?' {:e::1§3§ai3;:a3::t's' §%:';£_§§£::*4VATfzif;%:':':' 7§v'%agi4si1".*;z%;e {T:es':.:.r§, {}§'L'£:it2::i'Se'._§:';,v »'::§s:?€*;aEf sf ma accxzgeé ihilg %s:ifa":€3$s giifésezg fixaiiiéiv-,<<i:f3 £1': 71§::1g*E.i'":. £3€r%.23§3': s:1gg€::%;ti{}i':$ W{'":}f6§ fi3'a:.s,'ia.._ é:.:.i>"'~ $1311: in '$316 cr:3$$~&xa.:11i.§;'1z1ii033 §:§gé§;§"{%i§":g "%§§{%::fi_i§'§;{i:5£%.is§:": £33" file {$23.22* 331$ aim ':53 {E16 t:ffx%::{:i; zhat %}'3@ja; dié '~:'";§*é. abméiz pa31'm.%s3§€§§: $9 211:: {E15 a:':e?:T1i::%§:: 2-23 3 iz3.;<:§. .$§§%;}":a:1gE: it is« a{hni":€.e(i that his fafaixér hag ET;-{'~§'t' €::%3ta§;'1&<i g;}@1*z:<2i'; ta $131': "336 car' aa 2: iaxgi, 32$ {%@§"1i€{i ihaé 3%: is fiat Mr"
,........
Wk :_2:<~;a:(§ as *?£a:>s:.'% aiad aim mg $":1g;;gz*:::;i§a::'1 mzszié": "'f:':-=:_..f»15« :?~§'§_lS'{E§;i§1f§{i §_:':§§.1?:€:S in 'i:,7i":$ gaiaia. iiiéifi ':;r<:€::'£i:::{:e::§¥;;'~V.V §3*i§§ i'a%;E}:::' sf §~'W . §»T.$'p€a}{'Va§§§_{:i ?}T1€.§ _'§,3{£};£* ':::€§;:":g aged as a taxi' {>11 itzéifiiiiagg Ei) i<.:'1§m:- rjéif' 'Tabs: §fiCiE§€3E1'L V an 3.11.98 233:<m1"1:'i §:,:_;'m.;_ti";;é._§2Iii113e{§iai£%A1j:"r::a$%1€{i ta ihs: ifiivii Haspiiai, B€;':g_3;;'m3}1, ¢zIf:{1 E§£¥$%'~».§§1§f$.V.~SOI1 '?'21m:s.j'1 Wiiifi was £1§i€§Ei3" ifim;;1wj;.$;;;"::s>::£%;1 :;~i_:1'e;i €§§;;r3;t2"iiisI1..fax.?2as <:a'§1r:§u<:1T:aci Si":
'E'zmaji..
"'AZ_?'»97§.,_3'i§'§§"§'§5<:1i}Ts 8<a1:*ag&vi,, 2%-°§":{: S};}€:f:}§§ absmi P'%"?£_.§ Wiée. was '2'g:sj_g:a:1§ E"::.1S-fiimid 993:3': his car §"*":§:§. a£i__€§%;3 ;_s;_§;3€aE: 333502:-§----«a€<:L13€d 1103.} {E3 3 s::*aI;1€ t}':€:§'<:t< 313:3 V "$33.1 for hifizzg iffiii 2133:. E-Ea iisriieii 'E315 '3;a:gg;es;ii07;_:AiE:at he $3 {3&§;$S§.::1g f§«§3S.€1'j;. Eissias fiiiif' ha iifigjcsgésd $333.? 3'25 hasé 30%, 336:1 Ehé acaugsizi PR3. % $§'1§;'€J8;i"'Ei;iE1 Qfiagémnaiih §3*§€'{I§.i, {}W}"'i€§' Gf Ba}: am} E€<:stau:"a:";%. at §§'{}"1€!.I3i3 ijiepeaed fhaii at €3.39 33.31:. E16 Eiias-3 {$661} aacusaé :":(2:~;Q% :9 I3 3%: fathani aiié 'é;.3::€ aficugeé 3:3 airsxng viii: ?.'i}%'. 1 '§'a3":aj§ '£633. is his 3322;' aziiii' f";i7§f$?i:€:?j;f£.1§"_:f35Q;"§fZ 'fa? rfigfzt E15338. He has sf,3.t<"::iM§f.§}:~1t a,cC':A::<-;§:*£i' §:o3._1 :3: and '1'a:'1aji mak <:i§"%.:";k3 3:165, 13::g:i:§--3 R~.:-?~;._2~i:§'2,1'%" €.<}w;&;*:i$ ' zraeaks and Rs. 3&6/~ §Z%3R?s?i/£_1f€Z§§ V cap}; 0:" biiis. as pe::f__fEZ§<hi1'§i_*§§:Ai7§+'2». E-"£_V::i?3":=:-*§:'%.,rv<-33;, 'am szzggesiiaiz has 'Ef3éé;'; <_:;'o8s*¢Xa.::1i;3a?,i:3:§ that he has 4:f'3;<33;_ $6331' ;. in igh-6: %':<3f.e;} and 'aha; E16 i5 {'3;€jg6$i11':g P§;¥.,§'M3i}a;:s;§a.@.{Ehaia{ir:: Efiaiiéage, 2%-*E':r: is {:a.:*z*j<;i3";g *m:S §'::a:-::.:.="~r.S< <3"; mgyairg 9?' had}; a?' V6:E1i<':ie$ at V = &§§%¢%:ig2;_::'::1; hag darzapgseci 1:115 aélageati Car was braught ¥;i_s"tfg;é;:'s%.g$ ';3j~; SG1'i"}fK§§Z§G{};f.f aa 'wit: ':3 E'i§fi"1 by ES §{i'T;£3}f1§§18., ,:%f're2* "aha a«*€i":i{7:i& was §I'G'tlghi, aftssr 4 <;ia§;:s: ' figtiziiiizg was is; be efiécted K} the <:;3;s; at éifiai. time Efii zvaizii iiaam afié mid magi} Ehai {ha car "£2:-11$ 5::§:::§€s§ "$29 a i:h€f't C336 ami Sfiifififi 'S16 car. §~£0we*J€r he f'il§'i'}€§ hagtiis is mg: §3<3:'t§{:1"1 9%' E113 gtafiexzgezzi §3€f<3:é€ {3{3'&'if°"E. W. «ma _%7'¥€,{'é §%Tfaja:*a::.1. .?'ae'Ic;§'1a::':s;%.13gi1 1.3 §'1.2::r":"i31'1€:§ s'€'.a":f.%:%e:'i §'.f;z.:€ 'r::=: wag "~fi5{}§k§§"?zg 91$ ¥~§a:%i{:E;maI: in "£315: §£:1;'5"zgai§'{;?§7 j';¥?'?:i{.;E,, ?§%'=;'i£f3"%Z€E', E36 '§i1i§*:"16d }"1§S'i;ii€ as; {G ii':-é: 's:{i2':§i{§i:v %;>t§' §3i"'()S€{2U."'{i03'} E§'::a%; Whfiafg E123 was; i1_E"1€:z"'€ 1:32') 2 3.11. }9€'%8, 3%} £16 fiéli? a€::z_:s5:::;%. $55232? i,%:;:: §";.i$"--.g3;:4ag{:~.:.g::§€E ' thai. acszttugééii 123.5% €033; _%:1§:.::; ta (3%; "ige i'j??é:'V«V.€§§Eesi:;:":'3{>€"%};T$.€: Amba.$s2:{'iG:* car {$13111 g£"&€'z.1 u'i:»:.> Whéiéi. 5§;:;;<iV€h:::.: :33? fig} A3 are :'€S§<§€:r;%:3 ggzf §}§1z;W;§:i;. ';§"}f}€§ Sé:i:i~S2;é.2;i?f.;5é3:':1€:1fi{. $523.5 '_f:>€:t:1': zjiiiizitéd in '{1.§"};€ *:.T,_}"5i3?SS----{iX€3.3T§ii1'T§?i.'{§{2E1. §'§{)¥%?€iV€3§' ha": E":::::<; a<.§.1?;':§-;ii.£:--v:i $1133' 5% Esffiizfifiiii 733:? éiéit ?s§'i.1};':{§a3""§,;§ pgéiéfza 3:': §§1{:'i:' g§a§.'a;:.g_»;§:i .:;1:'}A.i§" ii:r§E"1€22' <i{2{:u;"§.3::'§:%;.3 iEl"£ii"{.'. aim s;@é2€:</E. S::l.§'a'j:'§f§'":': fi.Z%:§+ {9:*e2'f:ci.;::1?:s:::: Q? ;~:a_m'i sin», 22%. E3 <'3§f::':'§§' 22%": %L'E':é:s ' ,.é,:;x1.%3:21fSé;s;§;5i.{§:" .._caa;' was 13%, iié fizz: §:;ar§a.gé: 9:5 §3E§J'.;3 ibr " ?::3;*;{i: Ciéiaé' of SE15: (:22: §<:"::z:::: g§'e:é<:;»':;*: £10 wh.%'%;$ aracé ;3{3%;{:éA;%;€:':i. 553352 §~f§§3i§4i€.3(.i i.}%"1{:: §z<~:h.%{:E§:. '§3'E%§',? §-{:'§.$ii::i22 'E.'§§;3;f:am:a EE§§:'23$£i, E3328 %{§{':;:'::¥i;§§"27{ia:'i iéiifi 21§z:§:;aS$as_E<:=i' {:2-gr 335$} :'i§:;g38$<i:;§ '{§:":z»1£ 3%; %.s:22$ '£2.:'z;:;gh%;. €19 '§'E'}a=: gg3;:'*:§.g€ i§?}.';ii:'i: E15: 'a-%2*a:rw; :iEs:3%:'3g 'E13356 jab 5:2? '§;;=z:ii:'{;%:§1gg {E16 W, E3 a?€%':?:€:%€::-9. fie E'1z~:$ ggiifieicifiai ig§'3;:}m};3.<?:{-: §'ir';2§'§i '§i"i€iS{: §2.CC'L2${fi{§ had %>mLi:gE":: €331': <':2z.:.' ami E3535? in 315: g_§:'z3,g'1:~:«, ' u§%E§'§' j1?:a2¥€¥€::', 33%: has; cisttriiaii ihai: E16: has €:'v€:1*«.§é§e<:p...%§é*{:'::.§§e{%' 319$, 3 is 4 :9 hava b;:~0i3.gi1% :h£:'%.M{é3::".« '_ PV€'.8 }§ar:afi':ania§,zp_3--.gfarhcé ':5 '§;:>;§i<:?:?:f <}.:§:?:8;."€;:1'¥;§§s stamd mai 11%: W<211%__: a}a3'ig_3;§9i":fn '§3f._£€ §.3 S"E«<)g;f: $11.. EEEQS in the rzighi gem' $226 éagfgé; :2?' é§m: "&§§§ig'i'a-_p'§3§: Yazizmié. wézfiré Eihsy saéa? :§z2z:."';}::;'sawi'§éfyifig 'é;+:'§jé'L..f_,.%:fV:'. gj:f:'%é::";{i zm::i ?%":i%; fiéifllfi was; 'I'£«_3.:'15L'5E'iL'..'a3::;§:V§:'«.§h'af{."'«f??Sl?_ §:"::1:":sia§e::§ fififi :::>:1:;;}§e:%r;€:. §§'<:arm E':;Eza_§;*£i%.;'f;i ia:':guatg;é: i:9:"«--.i:駻' '§£{231'::T:a<.%.z% iézifaguagz: sézizéi £*'§E"§€ z§:%'::: ::;§}::{:;:3§ai2':t.,"» _ V' " "
'?'$€ .'<§, __ 53:'. ;%$§'1§E»<: Pamiumzgg afiérgiégzj, Mfifiiifiéii * A "i;3§"§{*§€r1;_'j-- .. %i&i7§é{} had €XfiE}"§i§E€{§ {ha ;':§1ju:'@€§ 3% {7é~€,:ka}:
'i}<\"':..,"{"i§;iv"'8.§4'.VE"§{}E'¢'§T;'§*§8_§ 0:': 1. E1838 hag iiagizasazé ifrzafi. "'§"a§:a§% A 'T i;.:;s'£,a};1$<i ifiifiififi '%?«.?£)é1§}{§S Sfifilfi §§'=5;§;i{:i"3 weave: gifiveus 32:":
£:a%;:,3r£: arid 3:39 7% 288.3 issazfiaé "J'if§u;':<ii §"1e:*téf§<:a%.e 33 36:' 'E§'§<;.R@ aiifi aim idfiiliifififi {.316 iériifté $63133; far <é§:a:§3iI1a'§;ie:": 3%"
£~1z':{€ {};.:>i:'1{*:r:i fi"}§3E', tiimt ii§_}§,11'§€E§ $:,3:.%f:'.a3i:1i:€§ §.;2§; {Em %:;;j'é;%:'"§€§ Cesuiii biri: €§£i'L18{:€.§ E3}? *i;§1a'mvi»:a;3<}11 {§i1T:;?f::-E). E32?' 1%}, E,§§i'i€$§E E3i2"a§i §}f'§1a;:1'g1I2€~:,, 2%.:'§:{sv~ V. {3i?S.{1f;"{E' =1??? 'she g agé has ezriapmsizai {hat ha .%f;ac.%gg;§:%»}'€:z§--.f{.§25:"ga':*é};g§: 'icezg Eeasf: :5: ififisifé Exéaiiagma ab'-':%§;'§ PW. 3?': K. Sigééafi 'Eggs fi§§'2a?; Evizi, M3331 is }":i,:~3 $i}§T'{}§}1iE?I'#:§"If3;=:;:§'%"J " ':E3V:i':1'§*§_VI§I{'}§ su§3;'3i::*:e{i figgé: verséessi 53:?' $16 '}t«%<:§,::n1${*;{%;«Z2 has pE"'{}C§ii§3,€('§' *E'a§;3€' §3;§4-;9l<::~::::%:T*i{i.-r,%_E;*" é}? C3335, "i333:-xii: img, am'? 3 {':E,*:§,~3$'3Z7?;€S z%;<~;:_£"¥€:.$€:§2::=:{%._f§:':>:--:: §"1§:§ 'éissxzzgé: E33; 'iha §'}G§.§{'?i§ as ;:"2§:r ~ . «_ Esé§'i%.5'? §;§> § _z::'1:ié§*«II1%£2.§f:azar.
V' Shiaidappa ifiaiéapgya '%i"aC':;{~a:zi is ag;::§.{:u}_f:.'1:;i€§i S§;3@a§§s abaéjzi, the é;;*:§m"rs:"-rgi %;é:i":s:: %;a:~_=; i§2}u:':€§ H 33.22:': §§_ii%.";' 2.3:} $332} iz;1§:.::i%:$ 93 n1i:i:§;%g,t':': E1€3I'§§}};' .'m?S 2325:} ' Siateii '$33125. ha hag Caiiésfi ggiztsa p€I'SC*?{£ ziaarbjg ' " ~--;;«;i:i€: anzi :§":e§;" zxgerzé; azzé i§1f:3:'fi':e::.3; $316 @0133: 331$; $1.33 ;;3$.§_§£,:§: Cami: ihstzféz 311$ tack rim €':€Zi1I§§33a§.Z"£'i. M 2%} E36133 S1'2§v:§p;>a_ §j}:.2;1c§ap§}::3 Y§3{i:'%§¥§., ;;:é::~;s§- géfiézéqsg a%}{:'s;i{i 'E.hr:=: ii"ij"§,"éf€d "fa.§:2'«3;_§§ :§z.2s'§:»3i:'1i:':g i:::§:~u"ié:S«.__§yi::g. ' " "£1119; ianzi amt? T§:<:j: z>v5:§:t araai :';'¥s:Ei:[:'3;'*<:€§ l§f:"1é:« '-émééi'. §}{}}§{§€§ m0E»<: his c:0z11§::§ai§1s:é am}; §'1é'.€2izé:s,:§ $%}éf*§:;:{'§'f;i>'~ (§'a?.:Z$<':;;.i}éz' 2 }m$p:iTai.
PW' , E4 i3;§f§a3:i1{:aJ::"~~..é' §%§"?_%§f1"i7i§};}§§?;i. " '$a§::r%;'~:;;3'§:3.2*é§g0i, 3:": 2:3 ziepasfici a_'§i3e2.ri :"eco':r€T1'f%i_V (:3? f_z1§s*i<3f::%§:¥--pe aim aisz: S1z;>ps:*§".a:§ €h_::;'* *§'E}3f.%§3'i<'s§i?_{3:€" ii} 1% ;:)7:"9;$:§%::zt.%.z§::, 33?; $1133 1'*ega3:<}.. V'*;?§'."§:'} '§'~;.ii'z3};&, ;:5:»:§:*§;.:,' 'V:"f:i<:s:;§':,:§*, 'taxi :i§;*ia?€:* 9: _§§§;':c§'1 :%:é"i:1fiSs3 .%';Qc$ €i=s':§3<.;:s<::'i é2'.~3:§;>ui: '§'{i{3€}'~;'€E"f%f G?' Eiséaaii :;"é;:s}.n€:<§ " '~ .;Qzi..fii§";€i §§é&:;§f;----:"'1'a:1aj§ i,i":. %«.f§C1*$.-ff: is 4. ~£é:~;;i":3}g: Fv'£'s%;:.a.1:. ifiavafi is; gxisa 2?} ;3a.:'2::§": '%'z£'§:1E}€SSv-:7i35§-- ':%€p<3$e§ z'6:ga';3:%§§"sg :":%2":<:%;s:}:j§-* Q?' Ejwz} <.i'%_a3"i_{i:%; V"-:¢m{:i §a.**.'tE"%Lf§i" 8:(i{§§'€'E:3Sfi€§ Egg} §§§i§E§{§€'§ ifiéiszé, Eisaégazzfizi, .§'€:gza__%é;"§.i:":g géhezia €:g?:§:<§, 5:32, 3??"
E"%§J. E? E§%.,mi§ .§§«'§a§.},€E.€,§{iV E'*«E'%.:':?J;a.};éi ¥§-'izvzt: Es; 'éiié §);':;';«;§;T§":e:»;*i" Q? 'E'é:::1é3.}':i "E3233. E, 3330 Egifiakfi a'§;}{}L:%;= E12"<:;£}'1¥eIj..iz'é.'§:ié*rg§fiéiis. <_:z::3;* <12": §"1i:":2 akxzg %.A;i%i?: SGEEEE §3€f'S{}.E"}.S gmii Tz3é.'{3 'f.§:<%' :":&':»_:1i 7 ('E335 31$ .fz:2v.:"1<iE Eimi; his ':3I'a:>:§;3€:r %;::3fé r_3 in Efiaigaufli }£<:}sp.%{.aE $233' '{3:r:;ai:I1c::1:4t;..A A. . " n PWI18 E§h;i*9a§pa Bhiiizfi E~3[}€8}{S t3;1aEi he §f1€31"1é:¥;§*§_€:§.. 'Ea 'me FSL. afizi $1'-<:3:,1g§jJ: i3aCi§VV'E,E3L§:z;:1 .'i'fi}30I'{. P-'§3J§'E €§ »§*§'§:;g§gj:r:p.a L{3aga§A:a{§i, a:';{3€.he:" }i}()iiC€f {:ar3$§;a.E;§é§ é«3;E;§<§st,2§"~~1"{h_s3»t# an 1.12498, ' ggaye Ehég " = E~T'ii%':{ wii.'§:' «c.<:.m;pia§;t1*:T and E16 reafizazi tfze same ' ;:3..%"'{:t:;;;:-:%., };% an 1. E 138 '$33 the %:iag.i.3trat6. " .E=€a<:§":a.},2§;a ¥€ufira3=f$;a }:~§i1'<:%:maE,7§1, a.:f2c3i,§:1<=:r pa;3{:§':JSp€aE{$ sf I'€CG".?fiffiF Gf tbs kiliffi at {ha S§}{}'i 3135} "' _9i;s<é"_9fte:~ cmaductmg pazzcilxaama regardirag the &{:{:11S€i(§. K t3E<;;'.ng away 'Q16 acar {$0312 {ha Spat. fiat he has met;
sizppartmi vsrsiflfz £3? 'E233 g:>i"<}$€s:::..1i,i<>:":. W '(xi R} P'§.§%',i21 'iiizajyjva Ra{:}T1a;};j;a E{iz"t3§:é3.at3":a, wixfgi 'L SHE") {sf %e'im::<;§a.:'gi Pc>1ji(::3 S?;3;?;i0;;'3; <"§€p0s%.:__j {ziémiactaii amt} admit'£€:.<3' {ha ' t.0.g Hespitai.
?W.22 Efiiiérairi {}an_ej$ha_I'aQ E{'aie}<;aI*, § M€::{fi.<:ta3 Qéfficey E133 iieposefi a;§2r:i1t 1£1':&{.» ;seaé;;:1§u: given :0 'i"'2a1::a3'E ailé haviiitg issusstd i.§1§:;"'3§;g§:§.if}a-' Cs:f:*fEi:Eét'a?€f.". ' "§:§§,1fi3vfiE£3§~E1e§f8.}{}}}£3 Eianfisité, ?t';}§i€fi h1$§}s':rs':@'§' has t:ié:p'<3s{ad. 2:_'i}Qi:*E.'cifiiiigffiiafiizég '£15 §;I3V€S'i,igEi'£i{}§{}. §'%':*€%§_§":' i:}";5' abmfé €'Vi(1€E1C(': it is; C1631' {hag £15333'? "31:: $V;§€i€}fb3€ mi' E313, 1, {.1363 éiviiifincfi of P'\§v'.§3 v:1:1<?3s:.3 garage EEK: Vfihicia W35 $@iz€d (iéf;3ict.$"€§1a:"'§'ac§; 313% '(E16 vehicifi baiaiigeii 'E10 '(E15 §&§}'1€i' Q"? h i3"%;%£_ff 1 the zrefzicie was Eefi; far gaézitizig is a:;h32"3.g:% 'éim :i:é§v:'>'i' fmm gear; to whim, S0 alse Siifilifi {sf {E16 i¥i'{f1§?'SS€S ' V' Eiave $§G§{€I'1 mgarfiiixg the vehicia Egeeirzg braugkzt ta fhizir p§a«:':e: 35$ mar: E5'é§Z.? §~'iriS%a:i':a Gfiii af {ha garagsa xmfr 1"») KM nfi€€:,}"3.a:.:.f2<:: Ems: id€m.ifi£:<i. Em? {tar whiith %§g:'.8,S » £21755 pairjafitirzg. 81.14;: h<;:>w€v§::"°, hi"? pisadagi ig3*:;;:'a:"3{év';.-- "'3.-'{é aezzcusaii nos. 1 is 4 haxsing br€>:.:gE:¢; ikza ztajits:'§v'}:é3»g;;21fag@;' = 14-. Tha ézvidafice G3.' the §?;':"5'si{ asfgé; £?§'iIi€i€fi£.f€i"{i>'f_E3E§?f§ Hsgnamazatfgappa, {".3.'§SC§OS{?:?;3 as piegr lflfziz ;::1"<3_:~'»<;:1<:*::E*i§";"3.,"--~f§}¥q $013: §ai.na:1E. i,f1'1,:1'€f;i 1&;aS'f£}ii:i:<i ivhizz. 116337 ?t%_*:é" V';2:«:35"1s:1 <'sf ans: Siddappa. The Cgzzzgaiaigfiiiaf 1 \;~J;-$3 :"::f;§"5:o}"'{§€:d 1T5}; 'she ?SL The <it3<:t.é.:;.z* _"'f?:a*.;-%;:*1g.é:s:a;:::};i:?;<::;i thfi i:':ju2"'eci at C}:;zka_k {}a$%é;:'%--7:z1i;£5I1fTE<ifiSpi'§ai fozmci that i'31&I:% w€:"e two gE'i6'J{,3'§;:;S '*iE"§"j:?;i1fi:€f:EA§:'v_3i'Ef§i"'«?:iSG $€*¢&}:'ai insised a¥c:~'am«:§$ suf%r:t-zd 'ijijg T2::;agI;i. V z',E':& i€1€':1'iiffg '$13 .€.i{'.C11S€1{i, {he €¥i§fiI1C$ sf .Z?'%R?. 3. ' ;§'é<:;"s_;j;%g s~ A133 €>;:ar;3.i;':::<:% am} 213 pa: his»: €?.?'§{§€3;"iC€ téxege "?3.£.I§{3E1$€§{}'..V7§{3(V}'§%?iVV'5?Z<1'1%'€ <:£}fi:§3§aé:1a3:1'£: in $26 311355 :3? §;3S:}<Z§flg his véhiaig' hire '(LG Atharzi afiéi fmm thaw pmcafiiieii %.{:zx?é§32r;i?3 fiakak mid 115$-3.1" {E36 866116.': ef Qffézmcfi if} the ~ Agiiézgfi (:2? gazing '£0 8;.E}S'§-iffii.' iizaizures ca}; fimsé accugegi
--§é§s'9a1.iE'i.eii §',,§"}.{i iiljurrséd Eifiii §>us§':€z§ Esiézn (mi. sf the :33? W ix»:
...L'».
éiizii %)::::}3~§ §§;'§§"€»}},»-'" EEEEE itaz" amai iE::i:§::af§e:':§* fiifiij-£ _ the gassfage 31; §3€:§ganm. Tims, !:.§"1:a:*:"-: is _:;:':;;§;%.:'-51:31:» {:~'az§<i;e:1ai_:%::" = {a maid "£;hz:: :i{:{:'::a3<::§'i gm??? :3?' {3§'§,%1":{:£: ;§;2%_:éi?f:§.931ii§é9:'r:E€':V::mi:E;;:>:::* 8<~':::i.§<3:'1 3%? 3"'€a::i §%?i':i"1 gas. _E§}{1 '~ 3453. "§"%n_:$§ {:31 §$}€E"'%..'£S€:fi"-_ :1'? V' §§'}{': ' :::§C<}:'=<:§::é: zasiéci 23. Qiafaiiaé s;crm;§:":§r' sf "é%*;%1<_§{:;.:_:{:€:ii_,' . é"'§iTi;2::;§"~'{»:§*';;3;E. i;§'E€ iézawifiii '.-efi E1352. :""':g?£§'§;E3;--v. .<;f:::1':%,=*%_{:Vtfi{§"'lagééé " 'é.;€::s;":'5€n{:{~':<§ me ;3_€i3'1;${3{i §};f:z5=_ §i"?éjf'::" ._»_m7«::¥:*i:§z»:id _.«i}§?*Ef';§f',i{Té$§: Thé: 9:i"gm:1:€::'1%: 5:1{'§".?£§3;§{7@<1§ tfifti. ':i?::€EL::3_§;§.._' s::»§ -- a{:::1.2;.$<i{_¥. '§'"i-":ga3'*{ifi":g $16 iiiisseyfiéz-;i1'1;:j," i.'§':»::=: %Ei'.'J§{§'f?;:'é\§;T€i Q? Em: '%<§2"'§iE'}i3§§E§f:$ zméi 1:=3:';« ::{:§":::§ 116?, 9:55 .iii§i:§}€.%.§c:§§i§€}§1i' §}é3§'"é§.€i€3, {§{':S€E"'s:'€f~3 E0: ':35 fi-:}s3£:§:{:{i in »§.§i§'w.{:§' t.3i':15s:..,§';::'$E' §;E'§;<:%f, 3% 3.3%? film §:vi<E§:3;";s;t€ €>'3'..': §*§"::::z:3:"*:i éi E3 f;_¥'{}%;;?é{§ %}f:_'f;Q::{§ E'eE:a39§':a§'3i& <%a't1§:i 1{§"';a'§, §§}€$;E: ac:t:_is€::i .3V§VE;&?"€Vf'3" §f'a7:?;§?f§\é:f{;§: §;.:i<:a§'3g 3;;-'i{%: '?:.%"2€ {fC¥'{}Ef}§é3iI"iéZiI'fi1 ffiélék. §%4'i§;2'§.::2m§ fifa ;75§%,§":a§é};£VVL: E2163}; i;<§g€::*i:3*:e:3:" 313$ rfiéfiifi aé &ti*;::~:z;n§ ami ?{':*<:+::1~~€;£"ir:%§'°€ wiziifi pr<>c:":€{i§::g i{yE§a:f{£%: Czakak 'ifiéfi &C€'§,"§$§Ed §'é€}§;_«} 'ii: 3 Eéazé ::§s$a2_:i'?;€::i iézaié zizzjzzraai 3.90%: '?§'E€*: {sat ¥é'}Tii€§} was I£3i€::* 16%'? E} the gafazit €35? P'%3§.;3, TETEEES tE1£=:
3)! K} 'xii a::<;I11;3};3s§§'1£3z"1t has? étrzzmgh {IiE'fi€ ii; ;'€;{*:;:s3.§:": 3': §§"i§:
Of 33:: E§;C€'ElS€fi and §{i€:1'1t5:;f}; ihaz :;*:§:::z1$f::;i.. V' ..
é:2;pia;;1ai:§i::;:: is %;f§'1€r€: 3:»; ii: *2%;'§'1{:g_ iéifi. i§%.§[E '£r%_S iiviiiemisi :31' E332', E thfisa aczé:3:.'&s§€{'E. i':§:?2gé' '?.'3}{{Z:§;§"f:§1€5;v'{§8_§ 2¥§i"£§"_#; ; '?I§Ti€ $936: §m:§::T§'£iai': 5:3? 21:":§z:3%5:ii:i. _ 31:52.13"; &2§':1<éé:§E.:s{3 §:;~:<3z£g§':"{: {£3 (3§7E£~i}'1g€3 {E16 i:.f§€1"1E;§}:.}; §i;'§3j<5 ::22'§; V éziso S5363} %:T§:1ai '¥;E'1a3::1'€:
is {:<::':si:=;2;.@:'1'€. s:%sic:§€a":é:=r;,'--v.;3:a& "--1::a§;ai°§a}"' 5:': I':~:COI'~::i Wh_%c.i': §;32':>'%.'!:5::§ 'T{:E*T':€i1..;Z.¢:f:EiT§.;TsT"i§.T'Ef::._f;" "%;}'::i 2',2.<1;<:ug.:':e:j§.V ' F"::3Ei" ?}'1€i*-S{'3 :*€as<::'}.s, E335: i::':33:,'2§+;§:€:<§. j,%'3i%"<ié'i':fiA:<~:~%V' "'iEf*i:f:- {:g:i§:"{:g"'?::{::%:mr :i<:><~:$ 11:33:: 2:53.: ;§'<:a:* %3{i'{.'€:';}'ff:§.'{i!§;'1f{Z€EV. _ V I 4;' ";%<;::tc:r<*§'i;7;;g}5§;§=; figs: <::"§:22i§1a% az§:p€:a§ is {iii-"§}{};i§S;'5e§E{§,, '§;T;*§i{.'.§{ me §'§:.<:<>:*<_%$.
Sd/-5 ' K Iuddé :3-§:_1§_}*'