Patna High Court
Satish Chandra Prasad & Ors vs The State Of Bihar & Ors on 19 February, 2016
Author: Shivaji Pandey
Bench: Shivaji Pandey
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.24719 of 2013
===========================================================
1. Satish Chandra Prasad S/o Sri Mahesh Mandal R/o Mohalla - Navtolia ( R.S.
Tank ), P.S. Bahadurpur, Darbhanga, Presently posted in Arya Kanya Primary
School, Balbhadrapur, Darbhanga
2. Pawan Kumar Yadav S/o Late Chhote Lal Yadav R/o village - Ufardaha, P.S.
Bahera, District - Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School Saramohanpur
Urdu, Darbhanga
3. Shushil Kumar Yadav S/o Upendra Nath Yadav R/o village - Kabirchak, P.S.
Sadar, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Upgraded Middle School, Dhoi, Darbhanga
4. Prabhat Kumar Pandey S/o Indu Bhushan Pandey R/o Mohalla - Belwaganj,
Post - Laheriyasarai, Darbhanga, Posted in in Primary School, Rehamganj ( Hindi ),
Darbhanga Nagar, Darbhanga
5. Mahesh Yadav S/o Chun Chun Yadav R/o village - Ram Nagar, P.S. Badurpur,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Iddle School, Andama, Bhadurpur, Darbhanga
6. Narayan Prasad Sinha S/o Late Jalim Sinha R/o village - Pawada, P.S. Baheri,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School Baheri, Darbhanga
7. Manoj Kumar S/o Late Hari Nandan Kanth R/o Mohalla - Shahganj, P.O.
D.M.C.H., Darbhanga Presently Posted in Primary School Govindpur, Bahadurpur,
Darbhanga
8. Sajjan Kumar Sah S/o Late Mahanth Sah R/o village - Massa, P.S. Jale,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School Basaha Mirjapur, Hayaghat,
Darbhanga
9. Anil Kumar Pandit S/o Rajendra Pandit S/o village - Ahiyari, P.S. Kamtaul,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School Kamtaul ( Balak ), Darbhanga
10. Arvind Kumar Choudhary S/o Late Ram Bahadur Choudhary R/o village -
Pokhram, P.S. Biraul, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle SchoolBalia, Biraul,
Darbhanga
11. Raghvendra Kumar S/o Sitaram THakur R/o Mohalla - Sunderpur, P.O.
Lalbagh, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Upgraded Middle School, Behatwara,
Keoti, Darbhanga
12. Vinay KUmar S/o Late Indrakant Thakur R/o Mohalla & P.O. Shubhankarpur,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Upgraded Middle School Ganauli, Bahadurpur,
Darbhanga
13. Chandan Mandal S/o Late Lakshmi Narayan Mandal Mohalla - Dilawarpur,
P.S. Milkichak, Darbhanga Presently Posted in Upgraded Middle School, Dhoi,
Darbhanga
14. Sanjiv Kumar S/o Tribhuwan Prasad Choudhari R/o Mohalla - Imlighat, P.O.
Lalbagh, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Kanya Middle School Darhar,
Bahadurpur, Darbhanga
15. Rajeshwar Yadav S/o Ram Binod Yadav R/o village - Kathara, P.S. Baheri,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School Beladullah Nagar, Darbhanga
16. Nawal Kishore Jha S/o Birendra Kumar Jha R/o village & P.S. Keoti,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School Koyalasthan, Kewati, Darbhanga
17. Sushil Kumar Jha S/o Late Suryakant Jha R/o village - Bangarhatta, P.S.
Singhiya, Samastipur, Presently Posted in Middle School Balha, Kusheshwarsthan,
Darbnhanga
18. Arun Kumar S/o Late Sitaram Sahu R/o Mohalla - Hasanchak, P.S. Nagar,
Darbhanga Presently Posted in Primary School Chamarjan, Kewati, Darbhanga
19. Binod Kumar Mandal S/o Late Mahadev Mandal R/o village - Sundervan
Patna High Court CWJC No.24719 of 2013 dt.19-02-2016
2/7
Dhanauli, P.S. Baheri, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School Baheri,
Darbhanga
20. Rajesh Narayan Jha S/o Mahesh Narayan Jha R/o Village & P.O. Baheri,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Posted in Upgraded Middle School Aadavan,
Baheri, Darbhanga
21. Gautam Kumar Choudhary S/o Late Yogeshwar Choudhary R/o village -
Dumri, P.S. Biraul, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School Piproliya,
Hayaghat, Darbhanga
22. Md. Ali Ashraf S/o Abdul Jalil R/o village - Chakjohra, P.S. Lheriya Sarai,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School Chandanpatti, Hayaghat, Darbhanga
23. Ramswarath Sahu S/o Asharfi Sah R/o village - Mahisari, P.S. Singhwara,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Upgraded Middle School, Aghyaspur, Darbhanga
24. Dhanesh Choupal S/o Bhola Choupal R/o village - Lagha, P.S. Khirma,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Upgraded Middle School, Jurauna,
Kusheshwarsthan, Darbhanga
25. Lalit Kumar Thakur S/o Lakhan Thakur R/o village & P.S. Biraul, Darbhanga,
Presently Posted in Primary School Mohimbujurg, Kusheshwarsthan, Darbhanga
26. Iftekar Ahmed S/o Md. Yusuf R/o Mohalla - Maharajganj, P.S. Laheriyasarai,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School Urdu Garadi, Jale, Darbhanga
27. Ram Bilas Das S/o Rajendra Das R/o village - Baligaon, P.S. Baheri,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School Ujjaina, Darbhanga
28. Shyama Kant Jha S/o Late Umakant Jha R/o village - Hati, P.S. Biraul,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School Brahmpur, Kusheshwarsthan,
Darbhanga
29. Birbal Rai S/o Late Rudal Rai R/o vill. - Pakaria, P.S. Kusheshwarsthan,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Upgraded Middle School, Barhi, Kewati,
Darbhanga
30. Dr. Kishori Lal S/o Prabhu Lal R/o village - Pakaria, P.S. Kusheshwarasthan,
District - Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School, Biraul, Singhwara,
Darbhanga
31. Arwind Kumar S/o Kailash Prasad Yadav R/o village - Rajauradih, P.S.
Raiyam Factory, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School Megha, Keoti,
Darbhanga
32. Dinesh Thakur S/o Ramashish Thakur R/o village - Madhuban, P.S.
Kalyanpur, Samastipur, Presently Posted in Middle School Gorhiyari, Hanuman
Nagar, Darbhanga
33. Akhilesh Lal Dev S/o Mahendra Lal Dev R/o village - Manoratha, P.S.
Hayaghat, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Upgraded Middle School Hawasa,
Hayaghat, Darbhanga
34. Vidyanand Das S/o Mahadev Das R/o village - Rasalpur, P.S. Hayaghat,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School Arakshi Kendra, Laheriyasari,
Darbhanga
35. Md. Aziz Akhtar Sawari S/o Late Md. Ayub Ansari R/o Village - Basantpur,
P.O. Patori Basant, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Upgraded Middle School,
Narsara, Hanuman Nagar, Darbhanga
36. Manoj Kumar S/o Kameshwar Prasad Singh R/o Mohalla - Anandpuri, P.S.
Pupri, Sitamarhi, Presently Posted in Middle School Sahaspur Jale, Darbhanga
37. Awadhesh Kumar S/o Surya Narayan Yadav R/o village - Jurauna, P.S.
Kushewarsthan, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School Parv,
Kusheshwarsthan, Darbhanga
38. Ramesh Kumar S/o Srikant Bhagat R/o village - Gathuli, P.S. Kewati,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Upgraded Middle School Hazipur, Kewati,
Patna High Court CWJC No.24719 of 2013 dt.19-02-2016
3/7
Darbhanga
39. Kalim Ahmed S/o Md. Zamil R/o village - Bhawangama, P.S. Kewati,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School Banwari Patti, Keoti, Darbhanga
40. Shiv Narayan Yadav S/o Late Ramfal Yadav R/o village - Dhkaniyan, P.S.
Singhwara, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Upgraded Middle School Katasa,
Singhwara, Darbhanga
41. Jitendra Kumar S/o Suresh Prasad R/o Mohalla - Senapat, P.S. Nagar,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School Samsherganj, Darbhanga
42. Bhola Prasad S/o Rajendra Prasad Sah R/o Mohalla - Lalbagh, P.S. L.N.M.U.,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle SchoolAlafganj, Darbhanga
43. Binod Kumar S/o Shivnath Sahu R/o village - Balughat, P.S. L.N.M.U., Naka,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School Chamarjan, Kewati, Darbhanga
44. Dinesh Prasad S/o Late Lakshmi Sah R/o Mohalla - Gullowara, P.S.
L.N.M.U., Darbhanga, Presently posted in Primary School, Megha, Kewati,
Darbhanga
45. Ramadhar Yadav S/o Late Sudan Yadav R/o vill. - Paghari, P.S. Baheri,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School Pradhari, Baheri, Darbhanga
46. Abdul Kaiyum S/o Abdul Hafiz R/o village & P.O. Baheri, Darbhanga,
Presently Posted in Upgraded Middle School, Nawdega, Baheri, Darbhanga
47. Ganga Prasad Mandar S/o Teji Mandar R/o village - Baghauni, P.S. Baheri,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School Baheri, Darbhanga
48. Binod Kumar Gupta S/o Late Rameshwar Prasad Gupta R/o village - Rajnagar,
P.S. Rajnagar, Madhubani, Presently Posted in Kanya Middle School, Kewati,
Darbhanga
49. Dev Narayan Yadav S/o Late Mahendra Yadav R/o Village - Mohammad Pur,
P.S. Kamtaul, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School Gehunmi Kothiya,
Darbhanga
50. Md. Nazim S/o Md. Sadiq R/o Village - Mahinam, P.S. Bahera, Darbhanga,
Presently Posted in Middle School Pohaddi, Benipur, Darbhanga
51. Pawan Kumar Jha S/o Yogendra Jha R/o Rambaghkila, P.S. L.N.M.U.,
Darbhanga, Presently posted in Upgraded Middle School, Karhathiya, Darbhanga
52. Jyoti Raman Jha S/o Late Jaikant Jha R/o Mohalla - Laxmi Sagar, P.S. Nagar,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School Gausaghat, Darbhanga
53. Ajay Kumar S/o Shambhunath Thakur R/o village & P.S. Baidarabad,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School Dhoi, Darbhanga
54. Sanjay Kumar Rai S/o Late Baidyanath Rai R/o village & P.S. Sonaki,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School Dhoi, Darbhanga
55. Binod Kumar S/o Satyanarayan Prasad R/o Mohalla - Laxmisagar, P.S. Sadar,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School, Bhagwanpur, Darbhanga
56. Chaturanan Mishra S/o Late Jitendra Narayan Mishra R/o Village, P.S. Baheri,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Upgraded Middle School Basaili, Darbhanga
57. Gopi Raut S/o Late Mangal Raut R/o village - Sirhulli, P.S. Kamtaul,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Upgraded Middle School Nikasi, Singhwara,
Darbhanga
58. Kailash Prasad S/o Shyam Bahadur Sah R/o Mohalla - Balughat, P.S.
Kadirabad, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School Kant, Darbhanga
59. Navin Kumar Jha S/o Ramanand Jha R/o village & P.O. Amaithi Bahera,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School Chakjamal, Darbhanga
60. Kamlesh Sah S/o Tulsi Sah R/o village - Aawapur, P.S. Pupri, Sitamarhi,
Presently Posted in Primary School Chakjamal, Darbhanga
61. Chandravir Yadav S/o Sri Rajendra Yadav R/o Village - Dilawarpur, P.S.
Bahadurpur, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School Mathurapur,
Patna High Court CWJC No.24719 of 2013 dt.19-02-2016
4/7
Darbhanga
62. Vijay Kumar S/o Late Jagdish Prasad Karn R/o Mohalla - Sunderpur, P.S.
L.N.M.U., Darbhanga, Presently posted in Kanya Middle School, Chandanpatti,
Darbhanga
63. Manoj Kumar Mishra S/o Bhawanath Mishra R/o Laxmisagar, P.S. L.N.M.U.,
Darbhanga, Presently posted in Kanya Middle School, Chandanpatti, Darbhanga
64. Bhawan Mishra S/o Surendra Mishra R/o village - Baghat, P.S. Manigachhi,
Darbhanga, Presently in Middle Madhuban, Baheri, Darbhanga
65. Radhe Shyam Poddar S/o Suryanarayan Poddar R/o village & P.O. Kabirchak,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Upgraded Middle School Mayapur, Benipur,
Darbhanga
66. Santosh Kumar Jha S/o Late Suresh Jha R/o village & P.O. Kushouthar,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School, Dihlahi Hanumanagar, Darbhanga
67. Md. Abbas S/o Md. Siddiqu R/o Village & P.O. Gujrauili, Darbhanga,
Presently Posted in Upgraded Middle School Sidhauli, Hayaghat, Darbhanga
68. Chandeshwar Prasad Gupta S/o Late Innar Sah R/o Mohalla - Shastrinagar,
Laherisarai, P.S. Bahadurpur, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School
Aamanda, Darbhanga
69. Md. Afjal Ahmed S/o Md. Alam Ahmed R/o Village - Fakira Khan, P.S.
Laheriyasarai, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School Imambari, Darbhanga
70. Gita Kumari W/o Chandra Sah R/o Mohalla - Imambari, P.S. Laheriyasarai,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School Rahmatganj, Darbhanga
71. Md. Rizwan S/o Md. Rayuf Ansari R/o Mirza Hayat Baig, P.O. & District
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School, Chakrahmat Nagar, Darbhanga
72. Mahesh Prasad Yadav S/o Raghunath Yadav R/o village & P.O. Shivram, P.S.
Bahera, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School, Pindaruch Basic, Kewati,
Darbhanga
73. Lalit Kumar Narendra S/o Surendra Nath Das R/o village - Ballaure, P.S.
Manigachhi, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School Makranda,
Manigachhi, Darbhanga
74. Srinarayan Yadav S/o Yogendra Yadav R/o village - Chambapatti Rajwara,
P.S. Manigachhi, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Upgraded Middle School
Rajwara, Manigachhi, Darbhanga
75. Bhogendra Thakur S/o Ramsewak Thakur R/o village - Rajegotth, P.S.
Manigachhi, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School Sakhwad, Manigachhi,
Darbhanga
76. Madhurendra Kumar S/o Akhilesh Chandra Verma R/o Mohalla - Indra
Colony, P.S. Bahadurpur, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School
Ratanpura East, Hayatghat, Darbhanga
77. Ganga Kumar Rai S/o Ramsagar Rai R/o village - Zimraha, P.S.
Kusheshwarsthan, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School Raghopur
Teudhi, Manigachhi, Darbhanga
78. Mahashankar Jha S/o Shivkant Jha R/o village & P.O. Bangarhatta, Samastipur,
Presently posted in Primary School, Hazipur, Hayatghat, Darbhanga
79. Md. Asgar Hussain S/o Md. Farhat Hussain R/o Mohalla - Rasulpur, P.S.
Bahadurpur, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Upgreded Middle School Basuaha
Urdu, Hayaghat, Darbhanga
80. Vijay Kumar S/o Harishchandra Prasad Sah R/o village - Ganj Wahitpur, P.S.
Bahadurpur, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School Pindaruch Kanya,
Darbhanga
81. Sanjay Kumar S/o Ram Bilash Rai R/o village & P.O. Itahar, Darbhanga,
Presently Posted in Upgreded Middle School Pakariya, Kusheshwarsthan,
Patna High Court CWJC No.24719 of 2013 dt.19-02-2016
5/7
Darbhanga
82. Anil Kumar S/o Jagdeo Mandal R/o village & P.O. Aorai, Madhepura,
Presently Posted in Primary School Rambari, Kusheshwarsthan, Darbhanga
83. Kameshwar Mandal S/o Rameshwar Mandal R/o village - Kaisth Kawai, P.S.
Manigachhi, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School Gausahat, Darbhanga
84. Raja Ram Singh S/o Late Kameshwar Singh R/o village & P.O. Punhad, P.S.
Ghanshyampur, Darbhanga, Presently posted in Middle School Gangapatti,
Bahadurpur, Darbhanga
85. Dilip Kumar Choudhary S/o Late Gullu Chouidhary R/o village - Pandasarai,
P.S. Laheriasarai, Presently Posted in Upgreded Middle School Hayaghat,
Darbhanga
86. Ram Bilash Das S/o Rajendra Das R/o village - Baligaon, P.S. Baheri,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School Ujjaina, Darbhanga
87. Md. Saiuddin S/o Late Gonar R/o village - Benipur, P.S. Bahera, Darbhanga,
Presently Posted in Primary School Govindpur, Bahadurpur, Darbhanga
88. Md. Mustaq Ahmed S/o Md. Jainul Haque R/o village - Khadsand, P.S.
Kalyanpur, Samastipur, Presently Posted in Middle School Hayaghat ( Balak ),
Darbhanga
89. Padma Bhushan Prasad S/o Ram Lakhan Sah R/o village & P.O. Khajasarai,
P.S. Laheriasarai, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Upgrded Middle School
Kusheshwarsthan East, Darbhanga
90. Braj Nandan Rai S/o Late Maheshwar Rai R/o Mohalla - Janki Nagar, P.S.
L.N.M.U., Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Utkramit Middle School Raghopur,
Bahadur, Darbhanga
91. Shanker Kumar S/o Rajendra Prasad R/o Mohalla - Kilaghat, P.S. L.N.M.U.,
Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Kanya Primary School Jurawan Singh, Darbhanga
Nagar
92. Arun Kumar S/o Late Yadunandan Lal R/o village & Post - Ghosrama, P.S.
Hayaghat, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Middle School Khutwara, Darbhanga
93. Satya Narayan Himanshu S/o Bidyanath Mandal R/o Mohalla - Gandhinagar,
P.S. Sadar, Presently Posted in Middle School, Sinuargopal, Bahadurpur Darbhanga
94. Shivnath Mandal S/o Late Balgovind Mandal R/o village - Dagarsam, P.O.
Kapchahi, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Utkramit Middle School Khojkipur,
Darbhanga
95. Sanjay Narayan Mandal S/o Sri Shovi Mandal R/o village - Dhrampur, P.S.
Shakatpur, Darbhanga, Presently Posted in Primary School, Jhapara, Darbhanga
.... .... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State of Bihar through the Principal Secretary, Department of Education,
New Secretariat, Patna
2. The Director ( Primary Education ), New Secretariat, Patna
3. The Regional Director of Education, Darbhanga Division, Darbhanga
4. The District Education officer - Cum - Chairman District Education Promotion
Committee, Darbhanga
5. The Disttrict Programme officer ( Establishment ) Darbhanga
6. The Block Education officer, Town, Darbhanga
7. The Block Education officer, Darbhanga Gramin, Darbhanga
8. The Block Education officer, Keoti, Darbhanga
9. The Block Education officer, Jale, Darbhanga
10. The Block Education officer, Singhwara, Darbhanga
11. The Block Education officer, Manigachhi, Darbhanga
Patna High Court CWJC No.24719 of 2013 dt.19-02-2016
6/7
12. The Block Education officer, Tardih, Darbhanga
13. The Block Education officer, Benipur, Darbhanga
14. The Block Education officer, Alinagar, Darbhanga
15. The Block Education officer, Ghanshyampur, Darbhanga
16. The Block Education officer, Gouraboram, Darbhanga
17. The Block Education officer, Biraul, Darbhanga
18. The Block Education officer, Kusheshwarsthan, Darbhanga
19. The Block Education officer, Kusheshwar Sthan, Darbhanga
20. The Block Education officer, Baheri, Darbhanga
21. The Block Education officer, Hayaghat, Darbhanga
22. The Block Education officer, Bahadurpur, Darbhanga
23. The Block Education officer, Hanuman Nagar, Darbhanga
24. The Block Education officer, Kirathpur, Darbhanga
.... .... Respondent/s
===========================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s : Mr. AMARENDRA KUMAR
For the Respondent/s : Mr. PARTH SHARTHI
===========================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SHIVAJI PANDEY
ORAL JUDGMENT
Date: 19-02-2016 Heard learned counsel for the petitioners and learned counsel for the State.
In this case, petitioners are seeking relief of granting B.A./B.Sc. Trained Scale.
As per the claim of the petitioners, they are eligible for the B.A./B.Sc. Trained Scale, as they do have requisite qualification. He has further submitted that in terms of the Rule, by 31st December of the year, a seniority list is to be prepared and the teachers who having requisite qualification, will be promoted to the B.A./B.Sc. Graduate Scale, subject to the availability of the vacancy.
The counsel for the petitioners submits that in terms of Rule 11 in the year 2011 the respondent has prepared a seniority list, Patna High Court CWJC No.24719 of 2013 dt.19-02-2016 7/7 but the names of the petitioners are not there which has been challenged by them, but the prayer has been modified that as 4-5 years have already lapsed, certain posts must have been fallen vacant and if the authority concerned has not prepared the merit list of the year 2015 by 31/12/2015, they should prepare a merit list. If in fresh seniority list they are found to be qualified for the promotion, they should be given the benefit.
In view of such prayer, the respondent would prepare a merit list if already not prepared and whoever is found to be entitled for the promotion, they should be given the benefit of promotion within a reasonable period preferably within a period of six months from the date of receipt/production of a copy of this order With the above observation/direction, this petition is disposed of.
(Shivaji Pandey, J) Mahesh/-
U